These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

So, where's our war?

Author
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#41 - 2017-03-21 16:38:09 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Nicely done, Ell. I especially like the frightened and confused younglings that don't know you well enough to read this in the right tone of voice, as it were.

I quite enjoy the preaching to the choir.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#42 - 2017-03-21 16:43:01 UTC
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:
Why, such wonderful, pro-peace, moderate, patient answers!

And how delighted I would have been reading them, ten years ago, when it was I and mine who advocated for that stance, when we were constantly called traitors, collaborators, appeasers for it.

I'm sorry, but it is laughable to claim that when Shakor got into power with his pro-war cabinet, what resulted is that suddenly every warmonger in the galaxy simply saw the light and decided peace was best after all, nevermind about our kin in Darkness.

It is especially laughable considering that our odds are probably better now than they used to be, what with the Empire having gone through their repeated succession problems, and with technological advances.


You need to step back and think, rather than just whine that the people you didn't like gave you what you wanted.

You've flat out said that while Midular was Prime Minister, you were advocating for peace. Now you decry that those who succeeded her are following the path you supported. Surely you're not merely upset that your people aren't on top, are you?

You say the change is laughable. You support the claim that the Sanmatar wields dictatorial power—a claim put forth by a member of the nation that tried to poison us our culture with their structures, their values. Parliament. Democracy. Faugh. The Tribes hold the power, through the wisdom of the Chiefs, not through some gaggle of sycophants currying favor from the masses.

Shakor was ushered into power under the Parliamentary system. Had we remained trapped in that insane, corrupt, foreign structure of governance, I have no doubt he would have gotten his war. We did not, though. We threw off the toxic yoke of anarchic mob rule and reinstituted a proper Tribal Council. It is they, not Shakor, who wield the true power. And it should be clear that the majority of the Tribes do not support the bloodshed you demand now in some paroxysm of righteous indignation... over the very concept that you got what you wanted.

So no, the Sanmatar is not a unilateral autocrat. And no matter how much he may have wanted to unleash total war when he came to power, the Tribal Chiefs have stopped him—at least for now. So stop whining that you won, and win gracefully.
KillJoy Tseng
SoE Roughriders
Electus Matari
#43 - 2017-03-21 16:57:37 UTC
Is this just something that comes with being around for a while - to actually remember the impassioned arguments and what was behind them? Because I'm trying to decide whether or not to find the predictable incomprehension amusing or not.
Bjorn Tyrson
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#44 - 2017-03-21 17:18:52 UTC
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Nicely done, Ell. I especially like the frightened and confused younglings that don't know you well enough to read this in the right tone of voice, as it were.

I quite enjoy the preaching to the choir.


So was this whole exercise an elaborate "I told you so" ?
Casserina Leshrac
Sanguine Illuminations
#45 - 2017-03-21 17:23:09 UTC
Louella Dougans wrote:
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:
It is especially laughable considering that our odds are probably better now than they used to be, what with the Empire having gone through their repeated succession problems, and with technological advances.


I don't think I agree with your assessment of your odds.

Especially now that Empress Catiz holds the throne. A lady who is known for her proficiency in industry and economics. I expect a substantial naval modernisation program will be one of Empress Catiz's policies in the coming years.


While many of the Houses suffered during advance of the Elder Fleet. And Empress Jamyl was able to rally and defeat those who dared to cross in Imperial Space it was hardly the Reclaiming that was spoken of.

I have noted with Empress Catiz on the throne that her commitment to the Reclaiming will not just be on the Military Front. The Empire is by far the largest and oldest of our great nations as a result will use economics to not only to improve Imperial way of Life, but the means to market it elsewhere.

The really war will not be between the Empire and the Republic, but Amarr Consortiums against Republic Consortiums.

We stand at the Abyss, drawing the Patterns of Fate - Casserina Leshrac, Savant, Sani Sabik.

Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#46 - 2017-03-21 19:49:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
Bjorn Tyrson wrote:
So was this whole exercise an elaborate "I told you so" ?

Well, partly, I confess, yes. It is sort of rewarding to hear Shakor's supporters now carefully explain the reasoning we always had for not fighting the war, and I am sort of glad they now understand. "I am sorry I called you a traitor and a coward" would be nicer if spoken more directly, but you work with what you got.

However, I also feel that time is now running out. I do not say so merely to call attention to a failed campaign promise. Those who remember me will remember that I am quite capable of swallowing my pride, if I feel it is necessary for the continued safety of our people. But now I sincerely fear we are losing ground rather than gaining it; have since the Ray's death and the events in Colelie.

We are pouring resources into a toy war, yet neglecting to push further when we can.

We have lost a lot of established institutions in a governmental change that has resulted in exactly nothing - not in our voices being heard better, not in any swifter resolution of issues. (It's proponents speak of it being 'traditional' but in doing so they have cast aside the whole of the Republic's history, forgetting that tradition is not book-learning about ancient ways, but the living, organically changing sum of all the previous generations. Doing it the same way we did thousands of years ago and ignoring all the generations between is not tradition - it's Scripture.)

We have lost a lot of our loyalists - those of Midular's and those of Shakor's.

I do not want peace. I never wanted peace.

I want victory.

And that is what Shakor promised to us; that is the one redeeming quality he might have had: the willingness to push forward on an opportune moment.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#47 - 2017-03-21 20:06:19 UTC
It's frankly depressing to see someone who once stood on the opposite side of the spectrum on these matters now state so matter-of-factly that time is running out.

I suppose somewhere deep down, I always wanted to be wrong about that. That I was snarling and raging in the bit and leash over nothing. Surely I had got it wrong, when no one else said the same words. Surely they'd gotten it right, since there were so many denying or condemning my words and conviction.

Yet, it does very much appear to be true. We might quite seriously run out of something good to fight for, and end up with nothing but hatred, anger and revenge propelling us to war.

... I could still do it, certainly. It just wouldn't make New Eden a better place, by any stretch.
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#48 - 2017-03-21 20:08:46 UTC
It is, of course, entirely possible that I am wrong.
Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#49 - 2017-03-21 21:44:10 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
Yuwei Sung wrote:
I should imagine that Sanmatar Shakor took an earnest look at his peers, Executor Heth and Empress Sarum, and came to understand the fate of populist autocrats who fail to perceive when to step back from their ambitions.
Yes, the Drifter assassinated Empress Jamyl I because she was unpopular. Ignorant to a fault, the purpose of the Sanmatar has always traditionally been as mediator for the Tribal Chiefs and he stepped back into that position. Of course you people assume he did it to keep power and remain popular or remain a dictator but there is no evidence of him exercising this power so he must be the most patient dictator of all time.


And Elsebeth, maybe you should disappear for another year if you are so bitter that the Republic is doing well and you mistook what he said.

Quote:
"Sons and daughters of Matar, make no mistake about it. Now is a moment that tomorrow's people will look back on for inspiration. Now is a moment where we do what should have been done long ago. The tone of the future will be set by our actions today. We will submit no more, to neither despot nor nation. Let it be known from this day forth that we are a race of warriors, not slaves, and that we will fight to the last drop of blood for what we hold dear."

Shakor also stressed the importance of clan unity. Flanked by the Chiefs of the Minmatar tribes as he spoke, he made repeated mention of the tribes' diverse cultures and capabilities coming together under the umbrella of a unified Minmatar nation. He finished his speech to thunderous applause and a standing ovation from the thousands in attendance.
Where does he say we are going to war?

No but he says he will unite the Minmatar and he did. He created a new Tribal Order and kept his word. Most would think of the Republic as a nation of warriors and not freed slaves, just as he said.

Admit you mistook the rhetoric of the bloodthirst and ignorant as representative of the policy of the Sanmatar to yourself. Embrace a Minmatar economy that grows stronger every day, less reliant of foreign aid every day. Take pride in the military that did not exist 150 years ago and has grown to be strong. Take pride that more Matari migrate from the Federation to the Republic than from Republic to Federation. Take pride that the crime rate is falling at an insane rate. Take pride that 150 years ago there was no Minmatar Republic and now the Tribes are united again, rule themselves again and are growing stronger every day.

People like you who do nothing but spit on your own nation are the reason why others like Avalykaa are no longer around. You are so angry and unwilling to see the good you point fingers and blame the very people who have made all of it happen for everything bad. Bad that no one seems to ever have a shred of evidence to support, just old rhetoric and stories Empyreans share trying to paint a darker picture of their pasts than the last worthless pirate Minmatar. Stop trying to justify your pathetic behavior and take responsibility. You will not lead other pilots to good but you will complain and spew vitrol to all of the same.

Spend another handful of months complaining how Shakor is a dictator and ruined the Republic despite all evidence and then go back to your hole for another year. Or, open your eyes to the troubles of a nation that has risen from nothing and all that it has accomplished and can accomplish. Accept the work, embrace it. See the beauty in the Republic as even someone who was taught from the time they were a child to hate it can.

For your own good and the good of every other young Matari pilot who has hope for their Republic only to see veterans like you return just to spit on the Republic and share your baseless, bitter rhetoric. Open your eyes and see Pator is rising over Matar still, the water is clean again and the birds have returned to places that were once barren.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#50 - 2017-03-21 21:52:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
No, sweetie; it was not me who mistook his rhetoric for actually meaning war. It was those people who supported him because of that.

Also, I am not angry. That's probably just your projection of your own frustrations on me. That theory is supported by the fact that you complain about me having simultaneously been away and caused some other people to disappear. Make up your mind and try to keep it logical.

Also, to keep this in the concrete: what work would you have me "embrace"? Piracy, as yourself?

Edited to add: please note that I am not bashing the Republic here, at all. I think it was great. I think the policies of the past decades have worked quite well. I in fact think we have been doing so great that we actually might have the chance to win the Big One - something that was absolutely impossible 15 years ago.
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#51 - 2017-03-21 22:15:34 UTC
Oh, and - if you doubt my relations with and my support to the Republic, maybe you need to double-check the alliance tag.
Challis Drant
Gradient
Electus Matari
#52 - 2017-03-21 22:30:33 UTC
Please note Elsebeth is not a Diplomat for EM. ( Once I can convince her to stand for that again - oh I shall - I shall)

She is however free to speak her mind as I am sure she speaks for a great many pilots in the Alliance.

Challis Drant
Gradient CEO
Electus Matari Executor
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#53 - 2017-03-21 22:30:35 UTC
Deitra Vess wrote:
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:

This argument holds water only as long as we are gaining.

I fully agree with this, only thing is in the last ten years have we not been improving steadily? As I said before, with time tactics and thoughts change. I hope we don't rest on our laurels if that trend changes for the worse.


There seems to be a common misunderstanding of Ms Rhiannon's point vis a vis economic and military infrastructure - namely that it is entirely possible to be both improving relative to your position last year and falling behind compared to your enemy. Ask yourself if the Republic is any closer to military parity with the Empire than it was five years ago.

The ascension of Empress Catiz represents a renewed focus on trade and industry. This will yield the usual technological benefits. I seem to remember that the Empire has been first to the table with both of the major technological developments in the last couple of years - Clone Troopers and the new Destroyers.

Now the worst kept secret in the Cluster for literally decades has been that whilst the Golden Fleet is the largest fleet in being that New Eden has ever fielded, once you get past the shiny elite formations, it's largely gilded garbage. Tired hulls, slave crews and the oldest technology of any fleet in the cluster.

I'm expecting a lot of refits, going forward.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Graelyn
Aeternus Command Academy
#54 - 2017-03-21 23:47:00 UTC
Where to even begin.

Cardinal Graelyn

Amarr Loyalist of the Year - YC113

Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#55 - 2017-03-21 23:52:01 UTC
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:
No, sweetie; it was not me who mistook his rhetoric for actually meaning war. It was those people who supported him because of that.

Also, I am not angry. That's probably just your projection of your own frustrations on me. That theory is supported by the fact that you complain about me having simultaneously been away and caused some other people to disappear. Make up your mind and try to keep it logical.

Also, to keep this in the concrete: what work would you have me "embrace"? Piracy, as yourself?

Edited to add: please note that I am not bashing the Republic here, at all. I think it was great. I think the policies of the past decades have worked quite well. I in fact think we have been doing so great that we actually might have the chance to win the Big One - something that was absolutely impossible 15 years ago.
Where are these people? Who are you arguing against in this thread? I am not frustrated at anything, I am only tired. Your tone reads as angry.

And I did not say it was you who made Avalykaa leave, I worded in a way that may have made it seem but I meant that people who share your attitude and spit this same exact rhetoric of a hopeless Republic under a dictator. This picture being shouted at her from all angles got to her over time and it has been a poison in the community of Matari for the four years I have observed it.

Embrace that the Republic needs work. Do not condemn it for the same.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Yuwei Sung
Federal Defense Union
Gallente Federation
#56 - 2017-03-22 03:24:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Yuwei Sung
Ayallah wrote:
Yes, the Drifter assassinated Empress Jamyl I because she was unpopular. Ignorant to a fault, the purpose of the Sanmatar has always traditionally been as mediator for the Tribal Chiefs and he stepped back into that position. Of course you people assume he did it to keep power and remain popular or remain a dictator but there is no evidence of him exercising this power so he must be the most patient dictator of all time.


My, you are passionate, Ayallah. I've a certain fondness for you in that, if nothing else.

But, I will say this: I never stated that the cause of her late highness's demise was that she was unpopular, merely that she was ambitious, and noisily so. Perhaps you are right, and that her death had nothing to do with that, either. But it is my experience that things do not happen for no reason, and it seems to me that she was singled out by the Drifters, while every other leading figure in the cluster remains unscathed. It makes it hard to believe it was merely because they wished to destabilize our civilization in general, and not something more... Particular?

As for the Sanmatar, I never commented on his character or his method as a leader - My use of the term "Dictator" was technical. All that I know is that he has been more restrained (relatively speaking) than the other rulers swept to power during that time, despite him certainly having the option to do the opposite, and now that he is more alive than them.

But all I can do is point out these little patterns, and patterns, though pretty, are often empty. I suppose time will tell if I am foolish?
Elmund Egivand
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#57 - 2017-03-22 03:36:10 UTC
Ayallah wrote:
.

Embrace that the Republic needs work. Do not condemn it for the same.


This much I agree. Yes, the Republic has improved by leaps and bounds in the recent years, but she isn't out of the woods yet. There are still plenty of Republic worlds, even the ones in the high sec regions, that hasn't yet reaped the benefits of economic growth. Not to mention the Republic hasn't yet reached the point where instead of simply producing enough, she's also producing surpluses. This makes her vulnerable still to the changing interstellar economic climate. Not to mention she still has to worry about the possibility of a mass influx of immigrants at any given moment.

The Republic can't afford to pat herself in the back for her achievements ever since the Tribal Council got into power. Her troubles are far from over.

A Minmatar warship is like a rusting Beetle with 500 horsepower Cardillac engines in the rear, armour plating bolted to chassis and a M2 Browning stuck on top.

Mebrithiel Ju'wien
Anshar Incorporated
#58 - 2017-03-22 04:32:59 UTC
I, for one, welcome my Elsebeth overlord!

For too long have we all lived sheckeled to the current world order!

May we now look to the light and BURN ALL AMARR TO DUST and see ourselves and our compatriots free!

Let OUR BLOOD be true AND HOLY and bring our enemies to bear against our holy ultraviolent lasors.

Yada yada yada burn the empire down et cetera and onwards....
Arrendis
TK Corp
#59 - 2017-03-22 04:46:49 UTC
Yuwei Sung wrote:
My use of the term "Dictator" was technical.


And it was technically wrong. A Dictator is a singular executive who wields unrestrained power. The Sanmatar can wield no power without the approval of the Tribal Council. He is the Council's representative to the cluster, and the moderator of their internal discussions. He is not a Dictator.
Yuwei Sung
Federal Defense Union
Gallente Federation
#60 - 2017-03-22 05:16:47 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
And it was technically wrong. A Dictator is a singular executive who wields unrestrained power. The Sanmatar can wield no power without the approval of the Tribal Council. He is the Council's representative to the cluster, and the moderator of their internal discussions. He is not a Dictator.


Well, if we're being particular, I never actually used the word "Dictator" in my original post. I said "Autocrat". I was indulging Ayallah's phrasing so I could continue the conversation without me being too pedantic.

While Sanmatar Shakor may not be a dictator, I suppose I will die on the hill that he was, at least originally, an autocrat. When he was raised into power, he didn't have to reconvene the tribal council, and he was certainly not beholden to the parliament in any meaningful fashion. He could have done as he wished.

He didn't, though - Hence what I was saying.