These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Announcement regarding rewards and prizes to fansites and third-party contributors

First post First post First post
Author
StabThigh
Amarrshmellow
#241 - 2013-10-11 01:35:53 UTC  |  Edited by: StabThigh
Gogela wrote:

If you are talking about the total "damage" to the eve economy, you haven't bothered to see what the isk traded per day in game is. Those IWSs are a drop in the bucket... and when that drop fell it didn't even cause a ripple.


That is not what I am talking about - but if you'd like to continue this discussion my inbox is open to you. I'd like to hear what Guard has to say about several very pertinent and unanswered questions in this thread without mucking it up with side-discussions where I am repeatedly (deliberately?)misunderstood.
Kirren D'marr
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#242 - 2013-10-11 01:36:20 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
Kirren D'marr wrote:
CCP Guard wrote:


You are misquoting me. My reply wasn't to that post as can be seen here.


There was a limit on quotes allowed in the post, and I did my best to distill it down while maintaining the essence. If I misunderstood, please take the opportunity to explain rather than dismissing it outright.

For that matter, there were several valid and salient points in that post, and you seem to casually ignore all of them. Care to try again?


Sure thing. Sorry if I came off as gruff.

You said you still weren't clear on what SOMER did to deserve our attention. I replied to a similar question in this post . If there's anything more you'd like to know about it I can try but I really don't know how much more I can add. It was a judgement call at the time.

I see you obviously don't agree with that call or with the fact that SOMER or any lottery site deserves any attention. Not everyone will agree on that subject naturally.


Specifics would be a good place to start, something measureable, quantifiable. Something that can be held as a standard of measure to other sites/organizations. Otherwise, this award was purely arbitrary.

Any explanation as to why it was deemed acceptable to shift player traffic to one player organization's business and away from others would also be appreciated.

As would an explanation as to how the use of SOMER Blink, with their control over player participation as a prerequisite to participating in the giveway, was considered to be in line with CCP's previously stated policy of not engaging in community events in which participants could be excluded based on other players' whims.

Why a switch on/off? Because the new animation doesn't add anything to gameplay and it's graphically annoying. In other words, it's worse than bad: it's useless. Simple as that.     _ - Kina Ayami_

Garandras
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#243 - 2013-10-11 01:50:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Garandras
I say give out in game prizes.
they are kewl and are mainly just a epeen at any rate.

Somer Blink does make profit.. but they do it in a manner that is fun for the partisipants.
I know I did enjoy a curier race that they hosted during their 1Q party.. there was no cost involed, you didnt actually needed to be registered on Somer Blink to participate, and everyone that finished got 25mil.. plus prizes for the winners..

People also keep throwing around this TRILLIONS!!! in prizes thing around when talking about the IWS' so they were valued at between 10-20bil a peice.. at 30 scorps that makes them valued as a group at around 600bil.. that is well short of the trillion mark.

I also wonder just how much Somer Blink actually does make per month..
I am guessing alot but I'm also thinking probally a fair deal less then most people are claiming.. Sure that make about 20% of each blink but when you fator in the Promo's and the rate that they pay their staff (which sits at about 30members) doing some quick rough math with the 20% figure.. you have their earnings sitting at about just over 24tril isk,

this figure in itself is inflated as it counts the value of promotinal prizes handed out aswell but keeping with that figure.. and the fact it has been running for 3 years.. thats 8Tril a year earnings before negating the cost of paying employees (say there is one person on 20hrs/day which makes it 657bil/yr plus adding in freight employee we will round to 1T) and promotional items (3.65T at roughly 10bil worth of promo giveaways a day)..

So at the end of that you have about 3.5T profit per year..

And while that is a larger number then most wallets it really isnt that big
Mr Kidd
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#244 - 2013-10-11 01:55:52 UTC
I still have issue with gifting anything to a RL business that is operating in game. Hell, I have issue with a RL business operating in game.

If SOMER's intent was to be a community fansite, they're no longer such. There should be a clear delineation between the two with strict rules of conduct. Frankly, I'm not excited that a for profit business is being 'gifted' anything, especially rare in game items.

Don't ban me, bro!

DNSBLACK
Dirt Nap Squad
#245 - 2013-10-11 02:01:05 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
It had to do with timing, our impression of their overall track record and capability, their niche, and habit of sponsoring events...to name a few.


1. Timing really the summer summit was in AUG. you chose not to include the CSM in any of this WHY?????????????????????? Please give me a real answer for this. here is the answer Trebor gave me on the phone when this broke back in Sept. " This was the first we heard of this and we are pissed"

2. The one thing the CSM is charge with after the T20 crap and yet it never hit the agenda.

3. What amazes me is you guys have yet to post a single solution. All I keep hearing is we will work on that for the future.

4. Hell I had a friend who got hired by CCP and when he did he told me he could not be apart of DNS any longer. He then joined another group with some other memebers of DNS and I warned him this was a dangerous road to travel. I warned his friends who he was trying to remain with and play eve with this was a dangerous road to travel. This plus a number of other issues ended my friendship with him. He is still working at CCP and to this day doesn't speak with me. I am thankful for this cause of the reasons your somer blink issue of favortisum brings up.

5. I thank the eve gods everyday after I watched CCP presents from this year that Hilmar gets it. He mined trit during his childs first birth to replace a thorax of his corp mates he got blown up. If any one deserved to spawn a ship and benefit from their hard work for eve it was him but he didnt. this example should set the stage to how special this game is and no third party, corp or GOD himself should get any inside the sand box favors ever. If I have to earn it in game then so should those who I have to fight and that includes the fing ceo of CCP.
Gamer4liff
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#246 - 2013-10-11 02:04:25 UTC
knobber Jobbler wrote:
CCP Guard wrote:
l0rd carlos wrote:
Kate stark wrote:
also, generally, the people in the poker tournament put some extra effort in (you know, turning up to the poker tournament, and winning it) vs somer doing nothing that isn't day-to-day business for them.


You make it sound like as if creating and maintaining a well know eve online fansite + infrastructure and handling with employees is effortless.


This is a good point actually. While we totally understand that everyone has different opinions on different projects, there's no denying that it's not an everyday task to build something that a lot of our players like and use regularly. That goes for a lot of our fansites and other contributors. I'm constantly amazed at the sheer number of high level stuff we see coming from our community members.



How is it any different to running an alliance with forums, mumble, support services, politics, metagaming etc? It's creating content, takes work, gets in the news. I fail to see how you think it's at all defensible to give 1 person items which they can then sell and potentially do something like buy a small fleet of supercaps with. What would have CCP done if somer put those ships up for gambling, made a trillion profit off them at no loss to himself, then given it to say PL to go and evict an alliance from it's sov? 1 trillion would have covered all the losses from the fountain war on both sides.

I'm gonna have to go ahead and quote this, as this is probably the hugest issue with this mess. I don't care how "neutral" parties look at times, there's no guarantee of anything. Isk is power here, and CCP has given gave Blink considerable power.

People need to re-read the above until it sinks in. This is the real problem with playing kingmaker.

A comprehensive proposal for balancing T2 Production: here

KIller Wabbit
MEME Thoughts
#247 - 2013-10-11 02:12:01 UTC
Kate stark wrote:
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Is this review going to include the lack of opportunity for some time zones to participate in in-game events where items worth billions are "dropped"? I'm including both Dev roams and RP events.


do they not have alarm clocks in your timezone?

with all due respect, if you wanted them you'd log in and try and get them. if you chose not to participate; that's on you really. just like if you never turned up to whatever event it was they were giving away the noobships then you didn't have a right to moan about that one either.


They don't allow alarm clock responses at my WORK.
DNSBLACK
Dirt Nap Squad
#248 - 2013-10-11 02:15:30 UTC
At some point you are going to wake up and realize what you have done and the damage you guys are causing. here is a good answer

1. We were wrong

2. We are sorry

3. We will be collecting all the scorps back or making them be bound to that charcter that got them so they cant enter the market place, so you dont have to fight CCP isk. We are sorry but we have to honor the free trips and bling from vegas and it wont happen again and we failed at truly supporting the sand box by favoring a single website that is trying to earn the same eve isk u are.

4. Any and all future give aways will be brought to the CSM first for review if we feel they are going to effect the integrity of the sandox.

5. If there is any eve player who has a gambling addiction we are sorry for endorsing a gambling site and compromising our integrity. We know some of you play online games to take the focus off of real life and our actions of being a service provider to that community was wreckless. In the past we have shown that we do not support in game and out of game actions and behavior by our players that can lead to real life problems. We as a company will hold ourselves to that same standard from now on.

Thank you

P.S. I could have gone on but will leave it at that



Frostys Virpio
State War Academy
Caldari State
#249 - 2013-10-11 02:16:03 UTC
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Kate stark wrote:
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Is this review going to include the lack of opportunity for some time zones to participate in in-game events where items worth billions are "dropped"? I'm including both Dev roams and RP events.


do they not have alarm clocks in your timezone?

with all due respect, if you wanted them you'd log in and try and get them. if you chose not to participate; that's on you really. just like if you never turned up to whatever event it was they were giving away the noobships then you didn't have a right to moan about that one either.


They don't allow alarm clock responses at my WORK.


INB4 accusation of not being hardcore enough because you won't miss workdays for pixel spaceship.
Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#250 - 2013-10-11 02:27:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Argus Sorn
CCP Guard wrote:
Weaselior wrote:
I'd like a little more information on the SOMER lottery issue specifically as that was the really immense giveaway here and it's not really well addressed. Specifically, why an in-game business was given such immense prizes as "a fansite" that wound up making them almost certainly literally trillions of isk. It's not really addressed at all in your post: no indication of why SOMER, no indication of what process went on here and why the CSM was never consulted, no indication of what other "fansites" have gotten these sort of things.

It's not just that SOMER got the lottery gifts. It's that they were absolutely stupendously massive. There's also the seperate problem of Navigator officially declaring them Not A Scam.

The IWS issue would not have been nearly as big an issue without that: it's that both happened, and that the lottery gift to SOMER was already absurdly out of line. The IWS issue exacerbated the lottery issue, it wasn't the main problem.


I can probably shed a bit of light on that although Navigator touched on that in his announcement following what was going to be the Gold Magnate event.

Why SOMER? Well, they are really popular and they have supported a ton of events so we wanted to explore what we could do with them. Their influence in the community is significant for the same reason that they are space rich - because they're good at what they do.

In the statement we go into who else have gotten the ISWs and also what sort of giveways we usually extend to fansites.

As we said, we agree with you that we went too fast and that's why we need to re-think this whole thing. We need to keep the CSM more involved, their input is invaluable.


Are they still going to be giving away the prizes (SOE ships, Iceland Trips, etc) ? Shouldn't you rethink that entirely given the response?

What is so great about Somer other than they make a lot of isk in the game? How many devs have been Somer employees before working at CCP? I am just curious why they are so loved by CCP when a good portion of the player community views them with skepticism?

Frankly your response is inadequate, and raises a lot of questions about honesty and transparency.

I want to hear from Hilmar frankly, maybe he'll get it...
Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#251 - 2013-10-11 02:28:28 UTC
DNSBLACK wrote:
At some point you are going to wake up and realize what you have done and the damage you guys are causing. here is a good answer

1. We were wrong

2. We are sorry

3. We will be collecting all the scorps back or making them be bound to that charcter that got them so they cant enter the market place, so you dont have to fight CCP isk. We are sorry but we have to honor the free trips and bling from vegas and it wont happen again and we failed at truly supporting the sand box by favoring a single website that is trying to earn the same eve isk u are.

4. Any and all future give aways will be brought to the CSM first for review if we feel they are going to effect the integrity of the sandox.

5. If there is any eve player who has a gambling addiction we are sorry for endorsing a gambling site and compromising our integrity. We know some of you play online games to take the focus off of real life and our actions of being a service provider to that community was wreckless. In the past we have shown that we do not support in game and out of game actions and behavior by our players that can lead to real life problems. We as a company will hold ourselves to that same standard from now on.

Thank you

P.S. I could have gone on but will leave it at that





+1
KIller Wabbit
MEME Thoughts
#252 - 2013-10-11 02:28:32 UTC
Frostys Virpio wrote:
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Kate stark wrote:
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Is this review going to include the lack of opportunity for some time zones to participate in in-game events where items worth billions are "dropped"? I'm including both Dev roams and RP events.


do they not have alarm clocks in your timezone?

with all due respect, if you wanted them you'd log in and try and get them. if you chose not to participate; that's on you really. just like if you never turned up to whatever event it was they were giving away the noobships then you didn't have a right to moan about that one either.


They don't allow alarm clock responses at my WORK.


INB4 accusation of not being hardcore enough because you won't miss workdays for pixel spaceship.


lol +1 from me. Big smile
Molic Blackbird
Orion Faction Industries
Orion Consortium
#253 - 2013-10-11 02:51:51 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
iskflakes wrote:
When you reward somebody by giving them PLEX nobody else suffers any serious devaluation. When you give somebody an IWS all other IWS owners and collectors get completely screwed over because the price collapses.

Just give people PLEX in future, as much as you like, but no rare items ever.


That argument I would agree with in regards to certain rare items, but not the ISW as it was created for the express purpose of being a reward for all kinds of contributions and contests, making it inevitable that the price of the early ones will plummet. The problem more people would have with it is much rather that those who get it early gain more by selling it than those who get it late, which is a byproduct of slowly seeding rare items in this manner.



No, that was not the express purpose for why the IWS was created. As was stated in the first post, the IWS was created to be sold on the NeX store. I've seen several statements from CCP saying that community giveaways was the reason for the ship to exist all along. Is almost as if CCP is hoping that lie being told enough will make it become true.

When was the purpose of the IWS changed? If CCP had announced the change in purpose for the IWS ship ahead of being released in larger quantities, the price for the ship would never have been as high as it was nor do I think the outrage would have been as big. People were paying 30b from the start under the false assumption few additional ships would be added . If people knew CCP was planning on releasing 100's of the ship, the price would never have gotten over 10b.
Infinity Ziona
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#254 - 2013-10-11 02:57:04 UTC
Mr Kidd wrote:
I still have issue with gifting anything to a RL business that is operating in game. Hell, I have issue with a RL business operating in game.

If SOMER's intent was to be a community fansite, they're no longer such. There should be a clear delineation between the two with strict rules of conduct. Frankly, I'm not excited that a for profit business is being 'gifted' anything, especially rare in game items.


Yeah this. Wtf? Can I start a RL business in game and offer isk as a reward if people use my services out of game?

CCP Fozzie “We can see how much money people are making in nullsec and it is, a gigantic amount, a shit-ton… in null sec anomalies. “*

Kaalrus pwned..... :)

Nobani
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#255 - 2013-10-11 02:59:22 UTC
In my opinion any fansite giveaway program has to include at a minimum:

1) Published guidelines used for selecting recipients, and
2) Most importantly, a published list of all in-game items given away.

Giving away plexes and swag is less problematic for me, if only because it's basically similar to the commissions for GTCs.

And you can't really use "we've been doing this for ages and no one's complained about it so far" as an excuse, since these giveaways haven't been very widely publicized. Other than, of course, events at cons and the Alliance Tournament.
Sai Talos
Gallente Federation
#256 - 2013-10-11 03:24:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Sai Talos
Those of you calling SOMER's contributions to the Eve community into question, lets make one thing clear:

They have time and time again sponsored people and organizations who create content for our community so they can continue creating content without the need to make ISK. If you're wondering, just ask a SOMER employee what all they have sponsored.

Needed to clear the air there.

And no, I'm not a SOMER employee, and I'm out tens of billions thanks to them ;)

Edit: And you know what, CCP hasn't gifted me anything for the hundreds of hours I've spent editing videos, but that doesn't give me the right to throw rocks at them for trying to give back to content creators.

The guy that does all the videos

Sai Talos
Gallente Federation
#257 - 2013-10-11 03:26:34 UTC
PS: When did we start looking to themittani.com as a source of credible space journalism? Jesus H Christ.

The guy that does all the videos

Callduron
Dreddit
Test Alliance Please Ignore
#258 - 2013-10-11 03:37:23 UTC
Total storm in a teacup.

CCP has done nothing wrong and I feel no respect at all for thin-skinned narcissists who get furious any time someone else gets something nice that they don't get.

I'd like to see CCP carry on supporting people who put exceptional effort into the community and if people feel bitter maybe they should consider putting in an outstanding contribution.


Full disclosure: CCP Guard gave me a 30 day new account code at the Feb London meet. Think I got a Quafe bag once too. Encouraging fans is just business sense and helps us fall in love with the game.

I write http://stabbedup.blogspot.co.uk/

I post on reddit as /u/callduron.

Kirren D'marr
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#259 - 2013-10-11 03:53:33 UTC  |  Edited by: Kirren D'marr
Sai Talos wrote:
Those of you calling SOMER's contributions to the Eve community into question, lets make one thing clear:

They have time and time again sponsored people and organizations who create content for our community so they can continue creating content without the need to make ISK. If you're wondering, just ask a SOMER employee what all they have sponsored.

Needed to clear the air there.

And no, I'm not a SOMER employee, and I'm out tens of billions thanks to them ;)

Edit: And you know what, CCP hasn't gifted me anything for the hundreds of hours I've spent editing videos, but that doesn't give me the right to throw rocks at them for trying to give back to content creators.


And in doing so, they raise visibility of their site, bringing in more customers and making themselves more ISK.

Sponsorship is not altruism; it is advertising.

Why a switch on/off? Because the new animation doesn't add anything to gameplay and it's graphically annoying. In other words, it's worse than bad: it's useless. Simple as that.     _ - Kina Ayami_

Daenna Chrysi
Omega Foundry Unit
Southern Legion Alliance
#260 - 2013-10-11 04:00:56 UTC
I think the rewards should be non-transferable, and the list of them should be public.