These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Off Topic Discussions

Author
Valerie Valate
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#61 - 2017-05-05 14:05:54 UTC
So, there I was, somewhat rashly, having rented out a ground-car, and going for a spin in the desert, to get away from it all, and be able to think without distraction, when the car hit a rock and punctured the tyre.

I looked around, and there was nothing in sight except sand, and the occasional rock. So, I tied my dress to the car's radio mast, to act as a flag, and awaited rescue.

Lo, some time later, a ground car passed by, and came to a halt. The driver got out, and asked me if I was alright.

So, I said "Yes, fine. Say, do you know the way to Kaztropolis ?"

To which the other motorist said "Sorry, I'm a stranger here myself".

And with that, they departed.

Doctor V. Valate, Professor of Archaeology at Kaztropolis Imperial University.

Halcyon Ember
Repracor Industries
#62 - 2017-05-05 14:13:31 UTC
Valerie Valate wrote:
So, there I was, somewhat rashly, having rented out a ground-car, and going for a spin in the desert, to get away from it all, and be able to think without distraction, when the car hit a rock and punctured the tyre.

I looked around, and there was nothing in sight except sand, and the occasional rock. So, I tied my dress to the car's radio mast, to act as a flag, and awaited rescue.

Lo, some time later, a ground car passed by, and came to a halt. The driver got out, and asked me if I was alright.

So, I said "Yes, fine. Say, do you know the way to Kaztropolis ?"

To which the other motorist said "Sorry, I'm a stranger here myself".

And with that, they departed.


This story seems light hearted.

Queen of Chocolate

Arrendis
TK Corp
#63 - 2017-05-05 15:21:15 UTC
Halcyon Ember wrote:

I'm not excusing them, I'm suggesting that their experiences aren't as "worldly" as yours, that the information they're offered and the choices available to them aren't as easy or as informed as you'd like to believe. That when you have, for generations, been told that this is the way things are that a shift in view point isn't an easy thing. Especially when the same Dogma continues to be taught and expounded upon. Reserve your hate for those who truly deserve it by maintaining a poisonous system for their own gratification and glory, rather than those who might otherwise have lives you consider blameless but for the place of their birth. You'll find people far easier to persuade if you don't act like they all need to be shot on principle alone.


Are they human beings?

Are they capable of rational thought?

Are they capable of empathy?

Do they want to be enslaved? To see their children under the lash?

What other 'learning' do you need?

You talk of reserving my hate for those who maintain the system... the system is maintained by the apathy of the common men and women of Amarr. Speak all you want about the terrible monsters keeping the masses down... but those monsters make up less than 0.001% of the Empire. The masses are kept down because the masses let themselves be 'kept down'. Because for all you plead oppression, the masses of Amarr still get to hold themselves better than a slave. The most menial drudge of a free Amarr holds himself above the most skilled and cared-for slave.

You seek to excuse the masses' apathy with feeble whining about 'they don't know any better'. They are human beings. They can see other human beings. They can imagine whether or not they would want to be slaves themselves. In every other major culture of New Eden, that is enough to say 'slavery is wrong'. But not in Amarr. Because the dregs, the poor, and the vermin at the bottom of Amarr society still get to tell themselves 'hey, at least I'm not a slave'.

The idea that they should need more persuasion than 'would you want that to be you?' is insane.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#64 - 2017-05-05 15:22:39 UTC
Ayallah wrote:
Two pages into an off-topic discussion thread and it has turned into a debate about slavery. I am guessing within another 3 it will be about comparing who is the most Caldari.


As long as it keeps those arguments from detailing other threads, that's kind of it's purpose, yes. Congratulations on being able to grasp elementary concepts, Ayallah.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#65 - 2017-05-05 15:26:42 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
Are they human beings?

Are they capable of rational thought?

Are they capable of empathy?

Do they want to be enslaved? To see their children under the lash?

What other 'learning' do you need?

You talk of reserving my hate for those who maintain the system... the system is maintained by the apathy of the common men and women of Amarr. Speak all you want about the terrible monsters keeping the masses down... but those monsters make up less than 0.001% of the Empire. The masses are kept down because the masses let themselves be 'kept down'. Because for all you plead oppression, the masses of Amarr still get to hold themselves better than a slave. The most menial drudge of a free Amarr holds himself above the most skilled and cared-for slave.

You seek to excuse the masses' apathy with feeble whining about 'they don't know any better'. They are human beings. They can see other human beings. They can imagine whether or not they would want to be slaves themselves. In every other major culture of New Eden, that is enough to say 'slavery is wrong'. But not in Amarr. Because the dregs, the poor, and the vermin at the bottom of Amarr society still get to tell themselves 'hey, at least I'm not a slave'.

The idea that they should need more persuasion than 'would you want that to be you?' is insane.

Then the world is insane. Setting empathy aside is at least as human as experiencing it.

Do you suffer the same misery as Miz does, Arrendis? Endlessly expecting the world to be more than it is?

If you don't, then maybe channeling her isn't a good idea.
Halcyon Ember
Repracor Industries
#66 - 2017-05-05 15:29:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Halcyon Ember
Arrendis wrote:
Halcyon Ember wrote:

I'm not excusing them, I'm suggesting that their experiences aren't as "worldly" as yours, that the information they're offered and the choices available to them aren't as easy or as informed as you'd like to believe. That when you have, for generations, been told that this is the way things are that a shift in view point isn't an easy thing. Especially when the same Dogma continues to be taught and expounded upon. Reserve your hate for those who truly deserve it by maintaining a poisonous system for their own gratification and glory, rather than those who might otherwise have lives you consider blameless but for the place of their birth. You'll find people far easier to persuade if you don't act like they all need to be shot on principle alone.


Are they human beings?

Are they capable of rational thought?

Are they capable of empathy?

Do they want to be enslaved? To see their children under the lash?

What other 'learning' do you need?

You talk of reserving my hate for those who maintain the system... the system is maintained by the apathy of the common men and women of Amarr. Speak all you want about the terrible monsters keeping the masses down... but those monsters make up less than 0.001% of the Empire. The masses are kept down because the masses let themselves be 'kept down'. Because for all you plead oppression, the masses of Amarr still get to hold themselves better than a slave. The most menial drudge of a free Amarr holds himself above the most skilled and cared-for slave.

You seek to excuse the masses' apathy with feeble whining about 'they don't know any better'. They are human beings. They can see other human beings. They can imagine whether or not they would want to be slaves themselves. In every other major culture of New Eden, that is enough to say 'slavery is wrong'. But not in Amarr. Because the dregs, the poor, and the vermin at the bottom of Amarr society still get to tell themselves 'hey, at least I'm not a slave'.

The idea that they should need more persuasion than 'would you want that to be you?' is insane.


I'm sure it's very comforting to cast judgement on people from so lofty a perch, in possession of riches and freedom most can't even comprehend. What Amarr needs is a change of doctrine and incentive for that change. If you're going to start executing people simply because they're guilty of being human, things are going to get very lonely.

You do not understand their position, because you have not been raised to believe that you are better than everyone else. It is a comforting lie, of course people wish to believe it. They live in a society which reinforces that belief for them on a daily basis. Educate them first, give them an opportunity to see that what they have been told is wrong. And no, simply seeing slaves is not enough. Not when your entire culture is built to persuade you that slavery is the natural order for those "beneath you" and that this model of society is God's will. Especially when dissenting voices are silenced.

You do not understand your enemy and thus you judge them unfairly. I understand why, your experiences do not allow you insight. Your culture promotes a different awareness.

I'd rather not be at odds with you, I don't argue with your end goal, I simply disagree that genocide is required to achieve it.

Queen of Chocolate

Arrendis
TK Corp
#67 - 2017-05-05 17:13:31 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Do you suffer the same misery as Miz does, Arrendis? Endlessly expecting the world to be more than it is?

If you don't, then maybe channeling her isn't a good idea.


I don't expect it, Aria... but that doesn't mean I can't hold it accountable for failing.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#68 - 2017-05-05 17:23:02 UTC
I expect very little from anyone but me. I just don't quite so happily condone failure of even the most basic standards of humanity, or excuse crimes against it as if they're unavoidable or acceptable prices to pay, Aria. It is odd how you fail to understand me still, when I haven't hidden any part of what I am for so long.

It is strange how you can not see the clear as day difference between me and Arrendis in this regard. Are you perhaps so blinded by now that all you see is antipathy towards what you have embraced, with none of the nuance or differences clear to you?

If you wish to refute her, simply equivocating her words with mine are not going to work. That's a weapon for an entirely different kind of target.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#69 - 2017-05-05 17:26:51 UTC
Halcyon Ember wrote:

I'm sure it's very comforting to cast judgement on people from so lofty a perch, in possession of riches and freedom most can't even comprehend.


I'm pretty sure that as a muck-covered eight-year-old, crawling through ventilation shafts on a space station to work for hours a day, every day, on machinery that had to function or we died... I still understood 'you own your crap' and 'treat people the way you'd want to be treated'.

So don't go trying to pull that 'suuuuure, you're rich and a capsuleer' nonsense. It's just another line of crap you're selling to deflect from the idea that children know better than the adults you're trying to absolve.

Quote:
What Amarr needs is a change of doctrine and incentive for that change. If you're going to start executing people simply because they're guilty of being human, things are going to get very lonely.


'Don't get shot' doesn't sound like incentive?

Quote:

You do not understand their position, because you have not been raised to believe that you are better than everyone else. It is a comforting lie, of course people wish to believe it.


And that is the crux of the problem, isn't it? You claim 'oh, it's not their fault, they're being lied to, the poor babies', and I say that's fedo droppings. They got their heads handed to them by the Jove, and they make common cause with the Caldari because they're afraid of being outgunned by the Federation. (And if you think they're only worried about 'the Federation + the Republic', then you're claiming the Republic is at least as strong as the State, something I'm pretty sure most State loyalists and just about every clear-eyed strategist in the cluster would find laughable).

That simple math says 'I guess you're not better than everyone else, huh?' Your 'god' is a joke. An all-powerful being who tells his people they're the chosen ones and then delivers them right into the teeth of not one, but two enemies they can't defeat, and doesn't lift a finger to stop them from losing fully two-thirds of the slaves they've taken because he told them to.

And if the Amarr aren't willing to acknowledge that because they're too lazy to bother to think? Because it's just 'easier' to not think about it? Then we're right back to tacit support for the atrocity, and an engraved 'Please, I want to be shot in the head'.

Quote:

I'd rather not be at odds with you, I don't argue with your end goal, I simply disagree that genocide is required to achieve it.


Well, you're the Amarr here, sister. Better get to fixing the problem from within, before we do have enough bullets.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#70 - 2017-05-05 17:31:23 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:

It is strange how you can not see the clear as day difference between me and Arrendis in this regard.


They see me saying they deserve to be shot, and hear it as saying we should start shooting now.

Note the difference, Halcyon, Aria. I'm saying you need to fix your crap before we decide indiscrimnate genocide is the only option.

Miz says it already is, and it should start today.

The longer you wait, the more people who agree with me... decide we agree with her.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#71 - 2017-05-05 17:42:24 UTC
... to clarify, I do not propose indiscriminate genocide. Do be careful of the hyperbole here. It's rarely recognized for what it is, which is why I am rather careful not to use it more than necessary. Implying genocide is the solution to aim for is not, and I'd be grateful if you didn't put those kinds of ridiculous words in my mouth Arrendis.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#72 - 2017-05-05 17:43:47 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Do you suffer the same misery as Miz does, Arrendis? Endlessly expecting the world to be more than it is?

If you don't, then maybe channeling her isn't a good idea.


I don't expect it, Aria... but that doesn't mean I can't hold it accountable for failing.


As you say, we've all got a bullet coming to us. Only, I don't think that's the way the world works. And I don't think that'll be changed, even if we all tried to make it.

Actually I think we'd make it way worse.
Halcyon Ember
Repracor Industries
#73 - 2017-05-05 17:44:17 UTC
Arrendis wrote:

Well, you're the Amarr here, sister. Better get to fixing the problem from within, before we do have enough bullets.

I feel they'd be no more likely to listen to a traitor and heretic than they would someone threatening to shoot them all. This change needs to come from those possessed of both faith and standing. If you have ideas to present beyond "shoot everyone" I'm all ears.

Queen of Chocolate

Che Biko
Alexylva Paradox
#74 - 2017-05-05 18:13:36 UTC
You know what's funny? I remember making, or someone making, a thread like this quite some time ago, yet to the best of my abilities, I couldn't find it. Maybe I just remember talking about such a thread on another thread.
Oh well.
Nauplius wrote:
[..] do not reach out into the Void.
give up and go away INTO THE VOID
be silent and do not speak INTO THE VOID
be blind and do not gaze INTO THE VOID
be numb and do not reach INTO THE VOID
Arrendis
TK Corp
#75 - 2017-05-05 18:34:47 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
... to clarify, I do not propose indiscriminate genocide. Do be careful of the hyperbole here. It's rarely recognized for what it is, which is why I am rather careful not to use it more than necessary. Implying genocide is the solution to aim for is not, and I'd be grateful if you didn't put those kinds of ridiculous words in my mouth Arrendis.


You've called for all-out war just in the last two weeks, Miz. And as we saw in that discussion from the replies other people had... that would mean people targeting civilian populations, and indiscriminate genocide. It may not be what you intend... but it's what you'll get.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#76 - 2017-05-05 18:38:35 UTC
That is absolute nonsense and you know it. Keep rewriting other people's posts if you wish, but don't start inventing that crap wholecloth with me.
Tsao Aubbes
Tidal Lock
Vapor-Lock
#77 - 2017-05-05 18:39:48 UTC
Considering this is the "off topic" thread:

I somehow rolled out of bed while sleeping and hit my face on the floor. Quite a strange way to start off the (early) morning..

Tressith Sefira > You don't understand. She IS the awkward.

Arrendis
TK Corp
#78 - 2017-05-05 18:51:42 UTC
That sounds painful, Aubbes. You ok?
Tsao Aubbes
Tidal Lock
Vapor-Lock
#79 - 2017-05-05 19:02:05 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
That sounds painful, Aubbes. You ok?

Of course. My bed doesn't sit too high, so it didn't hurt very bad.

Tressith Sefira > You don't understand. She IS the awkward.

Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#80 - 2017-05-05 19:03:02 UTC
Halcyon Ember wrote:
Arrendis wrote:
Well, you're the Amarr here, sister. Better get to fixing the problem from within, before we do have enough bullets.

I feel they'd be no more likely to listen to a traitor and heretic than they would someone threatening to shoot them all. This change needs to come from those possessed of both faith and standing. If you have ideas to present beyond "shoot everyone" I'm all ears.


The Empire could always, just, you know, stock up on laser crystals while they're stocking up on bullets. (Pretty sure this is what's actually happening, in the wake of the Elder Fleet and all that.) That way the war's way less likely to come and some progress can be made in the meantime.