These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Announcement regarding rewards and prizes to fansites and third-party contributors

First post First post First post
Author
Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#261 - 2013-10-11 04:07:28 UTC
Sai Talos wrote:
PS: When did we start looking to themittani.com as a source of credible space journalism? Jesus H Christ.


CCP and Somer both have confirmed the mittani story as accurate. So therefore in this regard it was credible...

In regards to "sponsorship" - it is called "advertising". Somer is not a "do gooder" group, they are in the game to MAKE ISK. They are no different than any other eve corporation that is MAKING ISK.

There is nothing WRONG with them (aside for the risks they create to the eve economy by concentrating large amounts of wealth should they ever release it all back into circulation) but they certainly do not do anything special for eve players.

CCP screwed up on this one, and they don't have the guts to really admit it and fix it.

People want a FIX, not lip service. Someone above Guard needs to handle this imo, as the devs who have handled it thus far seem to be in over their heads. If CCP goes through with the plan to use Somer to give away high value, out of game prizes, it will be proof they are clueless. The MMO market isn't that big, no MMO company can afford to ignore their player base. So even if not all players are upset - there are enough of us who are that CCP should take notice.

Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#262 - 2013-10-11 04:11:35 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
Doc Fury wrote:
Morphisat wrote:
This doesn't answer any questions at all. What ties does CCP have with Somer Blink ? First the weird community spotlight, then the lottery, followed by Billion isk ships.



This has been asked several times since page 1, but it conveniently remains unanswered.



I've answered this but I can clarify. It had to do with timing, our impression of their overall track record and capability, their niche, and habit of sponsoring events...to name a few. This mixed into a feeling that we should contact them and do stuff with them around EVE Vegas and upcoming tournaments. One thing we are doing more of and looking to do more of is E-sports and online tournaments and if you look at any team sport today you see a lot of betting sites doing sponsorship as that makes sense in sports...so it's just a relationship that we wanted to explore and which we will continue exploring. Doesn't take away from anything other people are doing that is totally different and brings a different kind of value to our universe.

Regarding the rewards specifically, we've said we'll reconsider our approach there.

p.s. What was weird about the Community Spotlight? :P



Let Somer sponsor whatever they want - doesn't mean that CCP should have a hand in hand relationship with them.

It's not about what Somer does, it's about whether or not CCP as the impartial entity that manages the game world should be basically in business with Somer.

Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#263 - 2013-10-11 04:17:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Argus Sorn
CCP Guard wrote:


In the same sense you could say that CCP didn't support SOMER, the players did :). Not trying to be a smartass, I promise, ...just a little late night philosophy.



Guard, the point is we don't ALL support Somer. We don't all believe in supporting Somer. Are you going to tell us all to f**k off?


Weaselior wrote:
Cameron Freerunner wrote:

4. A Dev endorsed a player run lottery and specified that it was totally legitimate. CCP endorsements of player run businesses must never be allowed to happen. Ever. By endorsing one group over another, he has potentially crippled all of the competitors. Who would risk their ISK with anyone else?


Yeah, this was a serious, serious problem as well. There should not have been a CCP endorsement that SOMER is not a scam and has operated completely honestly for its entire history. I don't actually believe the research to verify that was done, but it was wrong even if it was.



If goons get it, why can't you? It's this simple.

You gave them thousands of dollars in real cash value prizes to give away. What on earth are their qualifications for this? None! They run an in game betting corp. A corp that apparently, CCP devs love to the point of being irrational in defending them. Even if they were qualified in some way, CCP shouldn't be endorsing them this way. The bottom line is that CCP should stay out of the business of supporting ANY in game entity. How can we trust you to properly adjudicate/police an in game corp if you shower them with gifts and have them give away trips for you?

The answer: WE CAN'T. In fact, the responses are so over the top in favor of Somer, that I seriously question the impartiality here. In his own eve-mail, where he encourages his employees to keep quiet about the gifts (and no you might not have asked them to do this, but you endorse them as totally trustworthy, so own it) in that mail he says that he doesn't want to jeopardize the "relationship" between CCP and Somer.

What relationship? They are an in game corp. Some in game corps now get special relationships with CCP?

For crying out loud - how can you not see the problem here.

I really wish someone from your legal, internal affairs, etc.. who understands business ethics would respond on this issue. No offense Guard - but the dev responses on this make it seem like you guys are in over your head.

And you know what sucks, we as players don't have any recourse but to stop playing.

Maybe I'll go play Star Citizen, at least I already know those game developers are greedy bastards, lol.
Montmazar
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#264 - 2013-10-11 04:56:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Montmazar
Sai Talos wrote:
Those of you calling SOMER's contributions to the Eve community into question, lets make one thing clear:

They have time and time again sponsored people and organizations who create content for our community so they can continue creating content without the need to make ISK. If you're wondering, just ask a SOMER employee what all they have sponsored.

Needed to clear the air there.

And no, I'm not a SOMER employee, and I'm out tens of billions thanks to them ;)

Edit: And you know what, CCP hasn't gifted me anything for the hundreds of hours I've spent editing videos, but that doesn't give me the right to throw rocks at them for trying to give back to content creators.



If Somer is paying X, Y and Z, and we think X Y and Z are great, then reward X, Y and Z directly. Paying Somer back makes no sense. And that's not even getting into the ludicrous concept of Somer sponsorships being something other than advertising.

In other news, we still don't know why CCP loves Somer so much. We did at least get to find out eventually why they loved BoB. Looking forward to future leaks, because the explanations given so far do not make sense.
Argus Sorn
Star Frontiers
Brotherhood of Spacers
#265 - 2013-10-11 05:03:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Argus Sorn
"This is a really unique thing CCP is doing that doesn't directly map to anything they have done in the past, and we don't want to mess up that future relationship."

That quote from Somer, combined with the overwhelmingly pro-Somer stance of the devs in this thread have me seriously questioning what the "relationship" is. And that's not rhetoric.
Kate stark
#266 - 2013-10-11 05:30:46 UTC
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Kate stark wrote:
KIller Wabbit wrote:
Is this review going to include the lack of opportunity for some time zones to participate in in-game events where items worth billions are "dropped"? I'm including both Dev roams and RP events.


do they not have alarm clocks in your timezone?

with all due respect, if you wanted them you'd log in and try and get them. if you chose not to participate; that's on you really. just like if you never turned up to whatever event it was they were giving away the noobships then you didn't have a right to moan about that one either.


They don't allow alarm clock responses at my WORK.


how are hours you choose to work, any of CCP's problem?

Yay, this account hasn't had its signature banned. or its account, if you're reading this.

Molica Iwaira
Perkone
Caldari State
#267 - 2013-10-11 05:37:59 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
Doc Fury wrote:
Morphisat wrote:
This doesn't answer any questions at all. What ties does CCP have with Somer Blink ? First the weird community spotlight, then the lottery, followed by Billion isk ships.



This has been asked several times since page 1, but it conveniently remains unanswered.



I've answered this but I can clarify. It had to do with timing, our impression of their overall track record and capability, their niche, and habit of sponsoring events...to name a few. This mixed into a feeling that we should contact them and do stuff with them around EVE Vegas and upcoming tournaments. One thing we are doing more of and looking to do more of is E-sports and online tournaments and if you look at any team sport today you see a lot of betting sites doing sponsorship as that makes sense in sports...so it's just a relationship that we wanted to explore and which we will continue exploring. Doesn't take away from anything other people are doing that is totally different and brings a different kind of value to our universe.

Regarding the rewards specifically, we've said we'll reconsider our approach there.

p.s. What was weird about the Community Spotlight? :P



You are a great guy being here, listening and being involved. Thanks Guard! I think most every one is wondering how an "out of game" website can generate enormous amount of isk with "minimal to zero" in-game involvement when most everyone have to sweat their asses "in game" to make tiny bits of isk. Is this legitimate? Are you rewarding this? CCP who constantly nerfs, monitors, micro-manages the tiny bits in game so that people should not be making excessive isk and exploit anything...is actually rewarding this sort of money making?

Of course, this goes to other gambling sites as well. So people are naturally questioning CCP's sincerity in this. I know that CCP was complaining that there was too much isk in game. So is Somer Blink a back-handed operation to vacuum out the excessive isk from the game? You will hear all kind of such questions. Because you are spotlighting and rewarding "this way" of out of game isk making and people are rightly suspicious.
Shai 'Hulud
#268 - 2013-10-11 05:40:20 UTC
I don't think any of us have a problem with you rewarding contributions to the community, but these rewards should be limited. I thought Chribba's ideas on this were more the types of rewards that would be appropriate for these types of gestures (or out of game rewards, or course).

But I don't like that you are acting like PLEX would be ok... that makes me think you still don't get it, CCP. Rewards of this type should be about recognition, NOT compensation. Replacing the gold magnate reward with a new unique ship only solved the threatened encroachment on EVE's history. It did nothing to prevent effective favoritism of a seemingly random gift. It scares me that you guys are just throwing around game wealth so whimsically.

The most useful slaves are those that believe themselves to be free

Bi-Mi Lansatha
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#269 - 2013-10-11 06:36:13 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
...Should we stick to out-of-game things only? Create non-transferrable in-game items as rewards? Give no personal rewards and only prizes? Only items below a certain expected ISK value? Always give out tons of stuff at once so early recipients can’t cash out? List all rewards publicly?....
Awards/Rewards given by CCP... out of game items only. Prizes won by players... in game items.
Morphisat
Millard Innovation Inc
#270 - 2013-10-11 06:46:11 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
Doc Fury wrote:
Morphisat wrote:
This doesn't answer any questions at all. What ties does CCP have with Somer Blink ? First the weird community spotlight, then the lottery, followed by Billion isk ships.



This has been asked several times since page 1, but it conveniently remains unanswered.



I've answered this but I can clarify. It had to do with timing, our impression of their overall track record and capability, their niche, and habit of sponsoring events...to name a few. This mixed into a feeling that we should contact them and do stuff with them around EVE Vegas and upcoming tournaments. One thing we are doing more of and looking to do more of is E-sports and online tournaments and if you look at any team sport today you see a lot of betting sites doing sponsorship as that makes sense in sports...so it's just a relationship that we wanted to explore and which we will continue exploring. Doesn't take away from anything other people are doing that is totally different and brings a different kind of value to our universe.

Regarding the rewards specifically, we've said we'll reconsider our approach there.

p.s. What was weird about the Community Spotlight? :P


I was talking about the Markee Dragon spotlight that came out of nowhere. In hindsight it was a setup for this blatent Somer Blink favouratism. Accuse me of tin foil hattery if you will, but I and a lot of other people have a feeling there is more to this than meets the eye.

I am very sorry to hear that you will keep exploring these 'relationships'. Knowing that CCP is heading in this direction has already caused me to log in less the past few weeks.
Prince Kobol
#271 - 2013-10-11 06:50:27 UTC
Kirren D'marr wrote:
Sai Talos wrote:
Those of you calling SOMER's contributions to the Eve community into question, lets make one thing clear:

They have time and time again sponsored people and organizations who create content for our community so they can continue creating content without the need to make ISK. If you're wondering, just ask a SOMER employee what all they have sponsored.

Needed to clear the air there.

And no, I'm not a SOMER employee, and I'm out tens of billions thanks to them ;)

Edit: And you know what, CCP hasn't gifted me anything for the hundreds of hours I've spent editing videos, but that doesn't give me the right to throw rocks at them for trying to give back to content creators.


And in doing so, they raise visibility of their site, bringing in more customers and making themselves more ISK.

Sponsorship is not altruism; it is advertising.


Yet it is still a good thing, unless you are saying that the 100 of billions isk they have used in sponsoring player driven events was worthless and that they should stop?
JohnnyRingo
Regiment Of Naga Association
OnlyFleets.
#272 - 2013-10-11 07:07:27 UTC
Honestly, in my opinion, i have no problem with you guys giving away ingame items as long as they give no ADVANTAGE over other items and or ships, i mean if someone wants to pay 15 billion isk for a reskinned scorpion that is worse than a normal scorpion then that is HIS CHOICE.
Pingu
Cosmos Butt Pirates
#273 - 2013-10-11 07:28:12 UTC
DNSBLACK wrote:
Running a penny lottery is not hard CCP so why don't you run it yourself?


Montmazar wrote:
In other news, we still don't know why CCP loves Somer so much. We did at least get to find out eventually why they loved BoB. Looking forward to future leaks, because the explanations given so far do not make sense.


*sigh*

CCP are not legally permitted to set up any form of lottery themselves due to Icelandic law.

Gambling attracts real life cash from morons who gamble away all their in game isk and need to spend more real life cash than they should.

Greed is good.

CCP want to have gambling in their game because it makes them money and since they cannot do it themselves Somer Blink are a godsend to them.
TheGunslinger42
All Web Investigations
#274 - 2013-10-11 07:32:38 UTC
So CCP directly, secretly, and personally spawn ships that are known to be worth around 20bn isk each for a bunch of their favourite people and then after the fuss says "well no one else is going to get the same handouts because we're putting that little policy on hold"

Unsubbing because this is even worse - and sadly, it was predicted. Somer got their massive cash influx, and no one else is going to get the same. Thanks CCP. Great.

Cierra Royce
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#275 - 2013-10-11 07:40:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Cierra Royce
Chribba wrote:
Synthetic Cultist wrote:
CCP Guard wrote:

Should we stick to out-of-game things only? Create non-transferrable in-game items as rewards? Give no personal rewards and only prizes? Only items below a certain expected ISK value? Always give out tons of stuff at once so early recipients can’t cash out? List all rewards publicly?

That’s it for now, let us know your thoughts.


Items such as the memorabilia things in the "time capsule", would reward people with a permanent reminder of their impact on the EVE world.

Those things like the "Piece of Steve", relating to the first Titan shot down, or the "Assassination Contract - Mirial", or the "Band of Brothers Director Key". Souvenir items that don't do anything much ingame, beside exist.

Those sorts of items would be perfectly fine, to reward people for contributing.

Or inspace monuments, such as was done in the past, e.g. the Jita Monument originally commemorated a competition between players, yes ?

Monuments and souvenir items, people would have far fewer issues with, than things that have a definable ISK value.

This pretty much exactly, the reward of being recognized and in a way immortalized with the items you have, or monuments, or even names of planets etc is one of the best ways to show appreciation.

Things like that would be worth so much more in terms of memories and feeling accomplishment than a regular item you sell for some ISK. I've been joking since years that my personal ultimate goal would be to have a planet named after me, and I'm sure that alot of people who dedicate themselves making things to try and improve and build the community (not for profit only) would feel very rewarded by things like that.

/c


I'm sorry Chribba, but you shouldn't have a planet named after you, planets are big boring, no one pays attention to them really.

Instead there should be one of those huge asteroid colony models spawned in Ammar with a globally warpable beacon, let's call it 'Old Chribba's Claim' and put a whole bunch of l1 & l2 agents there for the various mining corporations, with the immense help you have given to the community at large over all these years I think it's only fair you get a proper thank you.

One of the things I enjoyed most about eve, when starting out, was the monuments and the stories behind them. This is a persistent world and we are the content, if there is to be any in game reward for in game actions outside the tournament then it should be in the form of monuments to the events those players took part in or inspired.

You do raise the perfect point though, there are tens, possibly hundreds of thousands of planets, moons, stars in game, all with very boring names, these also are ripe for CCP to do a little renaming.

I won't add any comments on blink or the hidden and open giveaways, I've said more than enough and others are saying the right things here, and I think you guys are listening now.
TheGunslinger42
All Web Investigations
#276 - 2013-10-11 07:40:51 UTC  |  Edited by: TheGunslinger42
I also fail to see any kind of response to the fact that Somer ban people at their own discretion, which excluded paying subscribers who have done nothing wrong (by any of CCPs own rules or standards) from partaking in the contest.

Neither have I seen any kind of response to the fact that Navigator made claims about them being 100% legitimate and honouring everything perfectly. Do CCP have access to somers code and services, have CCP performed a thorough investigation and audit into the services and every single transaction? If not then Navigator needs to publicly apologise and correct his statements.
l0rd carlos
the king asked me to guard the mountain
#277 - 2013-10-11 08:03:40 UTC
Please never stop the Community Spotlights!

Many people are not that active in the forum and just read the dev blogs. With out those spotlights they would miss many community events and organisation that make eve a better place!

Youtube Channel about Micro and Small scale PvP with commentary: Fleet Commentary by l0rd carlos

Mra Rednu
Oyonata Gate Defence Force.
#278 - 2013-10-11 08:07:20 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
I've answered this but I can clarify. It had to do with timing, our impression of their overall track record and capability, their niche, and habit of sponsoring events...to name a few. This mixed into a feeling that we should contact them and do stuff with them around EVE Vegas and upcoming tournaments. One thing we are doing more of and looking to do more of is E-sports and online tournaments and if you look at any team sport today you see a lot of betting sites doing sponsorship as that makes sense in sports...so it's just a relationship that we wanted to explore and which we will continue exploring. Doesn't take away from anything other people are doing that is totally different and brings a different kind of value to our universe. Regarding the rewards specifically, we've said we'll reconsider our approach there. p.s. What was weird about the Community Spotlight? :P


Yes betting sites, drinks companies, clothing companies and many other types sponsor teams, but the organisers of these events not also go and hand them money back, also why do you think they sponsor these teams and events ? To get more revenue in by advertising.

What Somer brings to the eve universe is dubious as to what I can see they actually encourage people to not play eve but gamble on a website only needing to log in to transfer isk over, the website does nothing else apart from give links where people can buy a plex so they can transfer more isk over.

Dotlan, eve-mon, e-fit and a huge amount of other sites actually benefit players.

Is it a case that CCP wanted to say thanks to Somer for getting people to buy plex's and make them RL money, then again what a strange gift, you make me RL money and i will hand you something which costs me literally nothing to give you, no effort on my part or anything indeed special about it as others have them, least making a medal and handing them to whoever was deemed to of deserved it would be special to them, but instead you give something which will add billions out of thin air and effect others ingame as well.
If you really thought the players would like Somer to get all this for what they do for content then why did you tell them to keep it quiet ?
Don't take this as a knock on Somer, they work hard and run a great buisness, but so do a whole host of other ingame entities but don't get mixed up with giving sponsorship and creating content, one is advertising and the other is organising a event, the Syndicate racing league or whatever it's called adds content, whoever sponsor's it doesn't.

Is very simple, CCP should not favour one ingame group over another, it is unfair to anyone else who has really added content, also though I am not a supporter of them but one word to the CSM about it would of made the concerns known and adverted all of this why weren't they consulted ? The CSM came about so you had a group of plyers you could get the opinion of.
Items given free by CCP to say thanks should be personal to those people and non-transferable items not items which effect other players ingame by gifting people multiple billions in assets.

Mra Rednu, Proud holder of a Kourmonen medal given for adding content in FW which is non transferable and worth jack-**** ( which is how it should be :P )
Ra Jackson
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#279 - 2013-10-11 08:17:57 UTC
CCP Guard wrote:
Why SOMER? Well, they are really popular and they have supported a ton of events so we wanted to explore what we could do with them. Their influence in the community is significant for the same reason that they are space rich - because they're good at what they do.


They are good at relocating ISK. That's about it. In this spirit you could give every relevant scammer a rare ingame ship.
Nolak Ataru
Hedion University
Amarr Empire
#280 - 2013-10-11 08:23:03 UTC
I'd like to register my corporation as an entity that adds valuable content and provides an entertaining experience for the general Incursion community. I'll take free accounts for me and my corporation, a Revenant BPO, an Etana BPO, or a Basilisk BPO, whichever is more convenient for you.

/troll