These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Aegis] More balance! - Ishtars, DDAs and the Tempest

First post First post First post
Author
Mario Putzo
#501 - 2015-06-25 17:46:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Mario Putzo
Terra Chrall wrote:

I think Sentries are only part of the problem. The problem is there is no other ranged drone and that is why I am against limiting their use on cruisers. I have not seen a lot of Vexors using sentries due to limited bandwidth and bay, they are very limiting there. VNI seem to use both mobile and sentries but in most of my encounters it is mobile drones.

Mobile drones are viable and contribute a lot to the damage charts, but are better suited for gang, low sec, and FW where smart bombing firewall ships are less common. And being slow, destructible, and having to travel are significant limitations. Sentries are needed to round out drone boat attack profiles. Removing them from cruisers might be the long term solution but there has to be a replacement option that makes sense first.


Which is why I don't understand nerfing DDA's to fix a symptom that is result of Sentries themselves. Nerfing all drones because 1 set of drones is very strong on certain ships seems stupid to me, and is an ill placed change. That would be like nerfing all Heavy Missiles because 1 ship became super popular using them...oh wait.

If the issue is sentries, and you know it is sentries, all the data tells you it is sentries...fix sentries.

Personally id rather just see sentries scrapped and drones be given a "mode" option, one that allows them to be "mobile" with more rof and better tracking, and a "sentry" option that leaves them immobile with higher Optimal, and better Alpha.

Leaves folks with Midslot option, do I fit for more drone speed so my drones can get on targets faster and apply their DPS quicker in mobile mode...or do I fit Omni so my drones have better tracking/optimal in sentry mode.

then tier them

lights for frigs/dessie (hull bonused for lights)
mediums for Cruiser/BC (hull bonused for meds)
heavies for BS (hull bonused for heavies)

ships can use drones to their bandwidth still, but will not recive bonuses outside their size range similar to how other weapon systems work on different ship sizes

if I ran the zoo..
Rat Scout
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#502 - 2015-06-25 19:04:58 UTC
Hey CCP, why not remove a midslot from Dominix as well and give it a low slot?! Eh EH EEEEHHHH?!
shananigans
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#503 - 2015-06-25 19:07:21 UTC
Why is my carrier being hurt with this!? Capital drone boats need a hug.
Shuckstar
Blue Dreams Plus
#504 - 2015-06-25 19:32:04 UTC
CCP Rise wrote:
Dez Affinity wrote:
You guys don't have a clue what you're doing. You're just playing whack a mole until you get the desired results.


Whack an Ishtar.


To whack the Ishtar as you say, all you needed to do is remove the ability to have sentry drones.

CCP Greyscale wrote:"OK, I've read every post up to page 200, and we're getting to a point in this thread where there's not a lot of new concerns or suggestions being brought up. There will be future threads (and future blogs) as we tune details, but for now I want to thank you for all of your constructive input, and wish you a good weekend :)"

Ellendras Silver
CrashCat Corporation
#505 - 2015-06-25 20:23:49 UTC
afkalt wrote:
Mario Putzo wrote:
Ellendras Silver wrote:

give me some examples because the only droneboats used in PVP are ishtars and sometimes domis in large battles i dont think domi`s are OP in this way but if you think so plz enlighten me. but dont just ramble something use arguments and some form of evidence that these ships are OP in any way


Perhaps the fact droneboats are by and far the largest sources of damage and destruction at (nearly) every ship hull size sub capital (Source CCP Fozzie made a statement regarding this https://embed.gyazo.com/45277828e1b46c214fe892021888099a.png)

(and im sure if you ignored Catalyst ganking in HS they would be up there for Destroyers as well)



Vexors are popular gankboats too.

What would be more interesting is removing structure bashes from these numbers. They skew it hardcore to lasers and drones for obvious reasons.


they are but not because they are OP but because they are fast to get into

[u]Carpe noctem[/u]

Ellendras Silver
CrashCat Corporation
#506 - 2015-06-25 20:24:38 UTC
shananigans wrote:
Why is my carrier being hurt with this!? Capital drone boats need a hug.


yes, this is also why i am against this change

[u]Carpe noctem[/u]

Schluffi Schluffelsen
State War Academy
Caldari State
#507 - 2015-06-25 21:37:00 UTC
Shuckstar wrote:
CCP Rise wrote:
Dez Affinity wrote:
You guys don't have a clue what you're doing. You're just playing whack a mole until you get the desired results.


Whack an Ishtar.


To whack the Ishtar as you say, all you needed to do is remove the ability to have sentry drones.


Not even need to do that, just limit their total drone bay so that they need to make a choice and that they can only take one flight of sentries.
Portmanteau
Iron Krosz
#508 - 2015-06-25 22:02:41 UTC
Jackie Fisher wrote:
Problem: Ishtar
Solution: Nerf everything!

Just as well you guys didn't chose medicine as a career:
Patient: I've got an ingrowing toenail
Dr CCP : No problem, we'll just amputate both legs, hmm, better take the arms as well just to be safe. Not sure you really need two eyes either


you clearly have'nt seen the amount of tristans flying about FW space
Demerius Xenocratus
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#509 - 2015-06-25 22:34:20 UTC
As a year and a half old player who spent a significant portion of that time training drones, Gallente cruisers and associated skills...

CCP please stop. I understand that the sentry Ishtar blobs were a problem, but please stop hurting my drone boats. Removing a mid slot will kill the shield kite Ishtar which is a great option for solo and small gang PvP.

If you must continue this droneboat genocide please be so kind as to inform me of which race/ship class you plan to bestow your favor upon next, so that I can arrange my skill queue accordingly. Shall I start playing TenguQuest, or is that getting nerfed too?
Demerius Xenocratus
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#510 - 2015-06-25 22:44:00 UTC
Soldarius wrote:
I'm going to repost my suggestion from the last 2 iterations of Ishtar "balancing".

Increase the bandwidth requirement of Sentries. Whatever ship you want to be able to field sentries, give it enough bandwidth to field 5. This does not include the Ishtar.

A kiting heavy drone Ishtar might actually be interesting. Maybe.


It is quite good, 3 DDA, nano/overdrive, DCU, warp disruptor MWD and 3 slots for shield tank.

Losing a mid will kill that fit though, you'll have to do an armor fit.
Nergal Hurrian
Orange Lazarus Petroleum Inc.
#511 - 2015-06-25 23:34:14 UTC
Ishtar sentry bonuses ARE the problem, not the DDAs.
Loss of a mid slot also makes it nigh impossible to have a workable shield fit Ishtar for PvP.

Rise, this is one of the most senseless and uninnovative changes to game proposed that I've ever seen.

Hundreds of people are pointing out the problem, yet you manage to miss the point. Does CCP HR have a general comprehension test that a candidate is expected to fail before they get considered as hires?
Gyges Skyeye
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#512 - 2015-06-26 02:00:44 UTC
CCP Rise wrote:
Alexander McKeon wrote:
Rise, I believe at this point that you're deliberately missing the root cause of the problem: the Ishtar breaks the rule regarding size-appropriate weapons on hulls. Sentry drones are fundamentally a battleship-sized weapon system, and aren't game-breaking when used on such; perhaps in need of tuning like the DDA effectiveness reduction, but that's all. The combination of cruiser-class signature and speed, T2 resists (remember that no T2 battleships are viable for fleet combat) and the long-range projection of sentries are what push the Ishtar over the top in combat situations.

For whatever it might be worth, making the Ishtar into an improved version of the VNI, with fast enough drone travel times to be useful, seems a more practical situation, and allows for fleets deploying heavy smartbomb contingents to be an effective counter.


This is suggested so often but it just isn't the case. Drones not being locked to the size of their owner ship is one of the most consistent and distinct things about them. Vexors, VNIs, Myrmidons, Eos's, and Ishtars (at least) all use 'battleship sized' drones, and everything bigger than a destroyer can use 'frigate sized' drones. This flexibility is part of what makes drones really interesting and while sentries have become a big part of what makes certain hulls so strong, we don't want to lock drone ships into drones that match their ship size.


Ok, if we aren't going to address the fact that the of all the HAC's in the game, the Ishtar gets access to battleship class weapons with all the HAC defensive bonuses intact, can we at least de facto balance or item lock the ishtar around this capability so we can carve away at some of the toxic gameplay elements it is creating?

I can understand that you want drones to be their own snowflake of a weapon system, not limited by ship class. Fine.

Lets call a pig a pig. No one uses the high slots of the ishtar for weapons systems in a meaningful capacity. Supporting the ability of people to fit the ishtar in this way is leaving superfluous fitting power that is inflating the power level of the ishtar's other use cases. Take the hardpoints of the Ishtar behind the barn and shoot them. Do the same with the fitting power allocated for weapons over utility high's.

Next lets kill two birds with one stone. We can add back in the ability of Ishtars to participate in high slot style F1 warfare by giving it a role (or gallente cruiser) bonus to Sentry Drone velocity allowing and forcing sentry drones to move with the Ishtar. Cut power from sentry damage, tracking, range, and hp bonuses as necessary. This would serve to give the ishtar ship hull access to a turret style of warfare while eliminating the edge case of Ishtars dropping sentry drones, scooting off in a distant direction applying damage all the while with everyone else unable to do a f-cking thing about it.

This would still leave the Ishtar as an immensely flexible ship. It would have in space selectable turret-analog and damage type capabilities similar to arty ships while still being able to participate in regular (heavy and down) drone warfare. It would at the same time eliminate the pants-on-head ******** damage projection situations the stationary sentry Ishtar is capable of producing.

Portmanteau
Iron Krosz
#513 - 2015-06-26 02:24:41 UTC
Demerius Xenocratus wrote:
As a year and a half old player who spent a significant portion of that time training drones, Gallente cruisers and associated skills...

CCP please stop. I understand that the sentry Ishtar blobs were a problem, but please stop hurting my drone boats. Removing a mid slot will kill the shield kite Ishtar which is a great option for solo and small gang PvP.

If you must continue this droneboat genocide please be so kind as to inform me of which race/ship class you plan to bestow your favor upon next, so that I can arrange my skill queue accordingly. Shall I start playing TenguQuest, or is that getting nerfed too?


ur drone boats are very strong. U will adapt or u will quit. Both options are ok.
Arthur Aihaken
CODE.d
#514 - 2015-06-26 02:35:07 UTC  |  Edited by: Arthur Aihaken
Nergal Hurrian wrote:
Rise, this is one of the most senseless and uninnovative changes to game proposed that I've ever seen.

5th time's the charm for the Ishtar, right? Roll

shananigans wrote:
Why is my carrier being hurt with this!? Capital drone boats need a hug.

Because carriers haven't been nerfed enough...?

I am currently away, traveling through time and will be returning last week.

The Sinister
Interbellum
#515 - 2015-06-26 06:30:53 UTC
To CCP Rise: This is my girl friends response on the ishtar subject and I quote:

" Is this guy dumb or something? Why not just take the what ever u call it bonus to sentry drones away from the damn thing and get it over with, I think he dosnt get laid very often! Men stop thinking straight when that happens!"

And of course I LOL!

And she DOSNT play the game...
afkalt
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#516 - 2015-06-26 06:37:11 UTC
Rise, maybe next time split the ship nerf thread away from the module nerf one, apparently people don't understand they're separate.
Jeremiah Saken
The Fall of Leviathan
#517 - 2015-06-26 06:41:18 UTC
Hey Rise, if 125mb bandwidth is not a problem on Ishtar can we have +25mb on Stratios?

"I am tormented with an everlasting itch for things remote. I love to sail forbidden seas..." - Herman Melville

HiddenPorpoise
Jarlhettur's Drop
United Federation of Conifers
#518 - 2015-06-26 06:59:25 UTC
afkalt wrote:
Rise, maybe next time split the ship nerf thread away from the module nerf one, apparently people don't understand they're separate.
Then it's a conspiracy.


I do think the easiest way to explain it is it is a more powerful nerf the more drone amps a ship fits. Tristans and algoses fit maybe one drone amp and so they get a 4% bonus dps loss. Most medium ships including armor ishtars fit one or two and they lose 7.5 bonus drone dps. Shield ishtars, gilas and rattlesnakes are losing the most (assuming CCP aren't as stupid as I think they are they meant that): three amp fits lose 10% and the few four amp fits lose 11.5%.

Keep in mind that's not dps lost, that's bonus dps lost. Actual dps change is small but significant.
afkalt
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#519 - 2015-06-26 07:08:34 UTC  |  Edited by: afkalt
It'll slow down my L4 domi alts a little, but really...for a 2-3 month train I'm not sure they should be bossing the L4s like they are Lol
Aplysia Vejun
Children of Agasul
#520 - 2015-06-26 08:07:59 UTC
Jeremiah Saken wrote:
Hey Rise, if 125mb bandwidth is not a problem on Ishtar can we have +25mb on Stratios?

Sure. Can i have the pwgen and the cpu of the stratios for my ishtar? Ah and the speed too please.