These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Any skin on any ship - bug on SiSi - yes we could have skins on ships

First post First post First post
Author
deseana
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#181 - 2015-05-03 14:56:21 UTC
currently my favorite mixed skin... Sarum Anathema

Anathema being a T2 hull as no skins for it, but the Sarum prime Magnate skin fits it very nicely. Doesn't hurt that I love t he Sarum Prime colors for on most Amarr ship

side note for the CCP jockey making notes, I'd love to see a permanent skin that are "Sarum Prime for cruiser class hulls"
Charlie Firpol
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#182 - 2015-05-03 15:31:44 UTC
I really dont understand any lore reasons, too. As many people have already said, if I, as a semi-god capsuleer whatever-uber-being want to paint my ship in Guristas colours, I should be able to.
There are so many pirates around, that are being actively hunted by CONCORD, can barely enter highsec without getting shot at but they´re not allowed to change the appearance of their ship? Even though the NPC pirates do it?

So I would defiantely want to be able to paint every ship in every factions colours.

The amount of SKIN items that would have to be created would be absolutely crazy though. We´d need SKIN licenses like "Guristas colour scheme for frigate sized hulls"

And for your viewing pleasure, take this Guristas Orca: http://imgur.com/cPQi1c7

The Butcher of Black Rise - eve-radio.com

Mehashi 'Kho
New Eden Motion Pictures
#183 - 2015-05-03 15:41:44 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:

This thread is over 48 hours old now and still not even in double digits, so there certainly isn't a threadnought of demand from the entire playerbase asking for this change, it is just a couple of self entitled snow flakes repeatedly posting.

I would suggest most of us actually want CCP to quickly resolve this issue...

Far from it, there are others like me who have been having so much fun with this feature that we have been logged in playing and not reading forums for a change. Ive been fairly disaffected by eve the last couple of months, happens to all of us now and then, logging in less and less, yet since this feature I have been logging in every day, just enjoying flying my police myrmidon, or blood raiders cynabal just for the fun of flying it, even if there is nothing to do.

I wouldn't have engaged with skins and appreciated that work and content going by their old prices ever above the 50-100 mil pricepoint, so I am really glad even for a few days to experience some fun gameplay without the prohibitive cost.

I haven't felt so enthusiastic about playing eve in a long time. Absolutely gutted that this will be patched. You can't have player customisation but still try to cling to rigid ideas of racial themes in any way that will make that customisation meaningful. The focus seems to be on bringing isk in for ccp I get that, but as someone who is already a bit disengaged with the game atm, this kind of thing could have been a motivator to re-engage and extend my sub. The prices I see on market for the larger skins are ludicrous, so once patched this whole thing becomes totally irrelevant to any ongoing interest in the feature I may have had.

It has been a fun few days while it lasted anyway.
Corylus Avellana
Avaricious Crustaceans
#184 - 2015-05-03 16:04:52 UTC
Great job, CCP! Thanks for this super fun "bug". Got back to Eve recently after a long (year+) vacation and um.. tested.. this feature myself and it was really fun. Really liked black and white Gallente hulls and Sukuuvestaa Caldari battleships. Look forward to see all skins unlocked at least for faction and/or all classes in NES.

Don't understand all this whine about "Eve is going down" and "CCP lead us to ruin". There was some questionable things in EVE history but as for now Eve is much appealing to new pilots than ever before. Have some faith.
Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#185 - 2015-05-03 16:25:13 UTC
Mehashi 'Kho wrote:
Moac Tor wrote:

This thread is over 48 hours old now and still not even in double digits, so there certainly isn't a threadnought of demand from the entire playerbase asking for this change, it is just a couple of self entitled snow flakes repeatedly posting.

I would suggest most of us actually want CCP to quickly resolve this issue...

Far from it, there are others like me who have been having so much fun with this feature that we have been logged in playing and not reading forums for a change. Ive been fairly disaffected by eve the last couple of months, happens to all of us now and then, logging in less and less, yet since this feature I have been logging in every day, just enjoying flying my police myrmidon, or blood raiders cynabal just for the fun of flying it, even if there is nothing to do.

I wouldn't have engaged with skins and appreciated that work and content going by their old prices ever above the 50-100 mil pricepoint, so I am really glad even for a few days to experience some fun gameplay without the prohibitive cost.

I haven't felt so enthusiastic about playing eve in a long time. Absolutely gutted that this will be patched. You can't have player customisation but still try to cling to rigid ideas of racial themes in any way that will make that customisation meaningful. The focus seems to be on bringing isk in for ccp I get that, but as someone who is already a bit disengaged with the game atm, this kind of thing could have been a motivator to re-engage and extend my sub. The prices I see on market for the larger skins are ludicrous, so once patched this whole thing becomes totally irrelevant to any ongoing interest in the feature I may have had.

It has been a fun few days while it lasted anyway.

This is the kind of fun which is similar to the fun they had when they made every character in WOW level 80. Yes, it is fun for a few days, and the kids get to try out all the toys, but then once novelty has worn off your left with a poor game.
Cleanse Serce
Lonesome Capsuleer
#186 - 2015-05-03 16:25:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Cleanse Serce
For the whole SKIN thing, i thought it would be 1 SKIN Licence per Ship Class, not per Hulls.

I won't ever buy a SKIN (unless LP Store) for one single ship hull.

Although, if you make SKINs per Faction and Class, i would concider bying AUR for this, and at a higher price.

Make SKIN per Faction/Ship Class, so that one SKIN Licence could be applied to a whole Ship Class (Frigs / Cruisers / Dessies / etc... )

For instance : a "Frigate Khanid SKIN" applicable on every Amarr frigates.

Or another possibility would be like for instance the "Police SKIN" applicable on every ship concerned about this SKIN LOre-wise speakin : Incursus / Comet / Catalyst / Thorax / Megathron.

Raise the price. And go !

Who would buy a a Khanid SKIN applicable only on Inquisitor ? A Kador only on Crucifier ? A Krusual only for Vigil ? We barely see the difference for Matari SKINs anyway. :D
Charlie Firpol
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#187 - 2015-05-03 16:36:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Charlie Firpol
Moac Tor wrote:

This is the kind of fun which is similar to the fun they had when they made every character in WOW level 80. Yes, it is fun for a few days, and the kids get to try out all the toys, but then once novelty has worn off your left with a poor game.


I am afraid, your comparison is not working.

If you set everybody at maxlvl in a themepark game, you´re effectively removing all the content they could´ve enjoyed while leveling up.

This glitch however is ADDING a ton of content, in the form of hundrets or thousands of ship/skin pairings. Of course, not everybody is interested in this kind of content, but we did definately not lose anything. The only moment we will lose something is in the moment this glitch gets fixed.

Of course the glitch has to be fixed.

But we´ve now seen and enjoyed how the SKIN system should actually work. We saw all the possibilities and we want to have them!

Also, have some more Guristas awesomeness:

http://www.directupload.net/file/d/3976/xexmq9ou_png.htm
http://www.directupload.net/file/d/3976/zanttz2d_png.htm

The Butcher of Black Rise - eve-radio.com

Mehashi 'Kho
New Eden Motion Pictures
#188 - 2015-05-03 17:04:08 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:

This is the kind of fun which is similar to the fun they had when they made every character in WOW level 80. Yes, it is fun for a few days, and the kids get to try out all the toys, but then once novelty has worn off your left with a poor game.

I disagree.

I haven't magically been able to do any new things due to this feature.

I have however magically started to enjoy doing the same things over again since this feature.

I don't feel your comparison works.
Altirius Saldiaro
Doomheim
#189 - 2015-05-03 18:46:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Altirius Saldiaro
I want the Sukuuvestaa skin as an option for all ships. I put it on a Stratios and an Astero. I want to put it on a Providence too.

If we had the option to buy any skin, I'd buy the Sukuuvestaa for Stratios, Astero, most likely Providence, the new Caracal and Cerberus hull, as well as for Nemesis, Manticore and Purifier. Would look great on Tengu, Proteus, Legion and LokI.

Right there, I listed 12 ship hulls I would buy skins for. CCP, you want my money, there you go. Make it happen and I'll be willing to buy the skins I like for the Hulls I want.

More skin options available for sale per hull, the more money CCP will make. Price these skins cheaper than they are, but give us many more options to choose from.
Shinzhi Xadi
Doomheim
#190 - 2015-05-03 19:58:36 UTC
Considering what we have learned about how the skin system works due to this bug, I hope ccp decides to sell skins based only on their faction/livery.

Like, I buy a Sarum skin, it allows me to apply it to any ship I own, permanently. Or same for a Blood Raiders livery skin.

Now, done this way, I think the high prices of 20-30 dollars each is justified. Or, just price them in plex, 2 plex for a skin you can use on every ship you own. Would I buy that? Yes, I would be fine with that price, for that benefit.

Mac Pro dual 6-core Xeon 3.06ghz, 24gig ecc ram, EVGA GTX 680 Mac Edition, Intel SSD, OS X Yosemite and Windows 8.1 Pro.

Daemun Khanid
Corbeau de sang
#191 - 2015-05-03 21:43:17 UTC
Shinzhi Xadi wrote:
Considering what we have learned about how the skin system works due to this bug, I hope ccp decides to sell skins based only on their faction/livery.

Like, I buy a Sarum skin, it allows me to apply it to any ship I own, permanently. Or same for a Blood Raiders livery skin.

Now, done this way, I think the high prices of 20-30 dollars each is justified. Or, just price them in plex, 2 plex for a skin you can use on every ship you own. Would I buy that? Yes, I would be fine with that price, for that benefit.


+1
Pricing still has to be reasonable but thats exactly the way I was thinking it should be done.
Sell skins for individual ships and I will never buy one cause guess what... I fly a lot of different ships. I'm not going to spend $5-$20 to change the look of a single class of frigate that i "might" use this week if a need for it comes up. But let me buy a skin and then use it on whatever I want and I may just buy quite a few of them. 2-3 at a minimum.

Daemun of Khanid

Fabulous Visage
Bad-Dragon Industries
#192 - 2015-05-03 22:03:02 UTC
Winter is coming, ccp. Next week. http://puu.sh/hAojK/8d48a3fcd4.jpg
Rain6637
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#193 - 2015-05-03 22:12:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Rain6637
It boils down to denying content. Artificial scarcity for what, pricing?

Back during the clothing roundtable with the devs, that Corbexx organized, one of the CCP artists said that clothing items won't be made in versions for every faction, due to the principle of making certain things special. I understood that at the time, because clothing hadn't been codified by region, to be changed according to a set of color schemes.

That's the way the SKIN system works. Among the texture information is a color code, and you're seeing it in action.

What I think the NES -should- look like is a wide selection of every combination of color possible, for every ship, with better microtransaction pricing. It's a straightforward, honest offering of assets that have been created.

I had the same opinion as other people in this thread, that SKINs are not something that interest me, so -whatever-. But what I'm seeing is another example of the greed is good mentality, and content being held hostage for exorbitant prices.

Players are calm now, but wait until the plug is pulled.

CCP Darwin wrote:
Vimsy Vortis wrote:
Obviously you can't just keep a bug because people like it. But I think this whole deal has done a lot to illustrate how much people actually want legitimately customizable ship appearances and how not interested people are about paying a months worth of sub to get a skin that applies to a single T1 hull.

Sure, it absolutely has.

Take note that this is a brand new feature that's been rolled out in a very conservative way, using existing ship/faction combinations, to see how people react to it and to try to measure performance impact. New ship skins may have different limitations or possibly none at all, and the feedback and excitement from this thread will be part of the internal discussions that lead to that.

We discussed possible future directions for skins in the Fanfest Art and Graphics panel. I recommend taking a look.

The issue is the pricing. What does it say about what you do and don't plan to release?

The NES and the in-game economy are not the same thing, and I think the lay person's hope is that people will latch on to unique SKINs with real money the same way they do in-game with ISK. But you need to disconnect the two. It wasn't well-received by players when it was done with monocles, and it's causing resentment this time around too.

I'm not just making a negative opinion about this. The bolded part of my post is my suggestion to make things right. This bug has exposed the SKIN system and the pricing strategy in the most visible way possible. All over Twitter, Reddit... if you don't make it right, it will likely be the second time CCP has mismanaged vanity items in a spectacular way.

If it is a technical problem that will affect the game, you should have issued a cease and desist and banned people outright. Even if it isn't, you should have issued bans. It lets people know you mean business about the way you plan to manage things. Monument shooters should have been banned too, and I don't understand why that was allowed to happen.

Regardless of your reasons, people are doing the math of what they want, looking at what's possible, what's available, and then pricing. Even if you plan to release everything and are making an effort to do so, the pricing is... obnoxious.

If things go south and you have a summer of rage on your hands, I promise I won't say anything negative anywhere on the internet or in person that would contribute to the drama. For my conscience. But right now, this is the thing I can point back to and say I told you it was going to happen. It has all the same signs, and people didn't even care about clothing.

All this situation needs to go to 11 is a leaked memo. Got any of those around?
epicurus ataraxia
Illusion of Solitude.
Illusion of Solitude
#194 - 2015-05-03 23:46:25 UTC  |  Edited by: epicurus ataraxia
I do not envy you.

I am sure there were differing opinions, as to how the whole skins issues would be marketed, and we saw the view that won.

Many players felt his was a poor decision in a subscription game, to treat the issue as if it belonged in a free to play game, to max out the desire amongst the whales of the world, while behaving badly to the main player base.

Ok, we saw it, and it left a bad taste, but we could move on, a little annoyed. We were willing to wait it out until sanity and common sense prevailed.

But Pandoras box was opened, and was it fun! That will be long remembered as a great decision, but it was not, simply a bug, but seen as a great feature for the playerbase.

And no matter what happens now it will be seen as a feature that CCP management wish to see removed to make extra money.

Trying to turn back the clock, and trying to reopen that pandora's box and forcing everything back in, pretending nothing happened has never worked out in thousands of years of trying

However, the original idea now of trickling it out like individual grains of sugar to the foolish and wealthy, has been blown completely out of the window.

Being in denial, and continuing with the original farce, will simply hurt you. Badly.

Even the dimmest marketeer will admit that that opportunity is gone, and you need to offer something that the players will embrace, and maybe still earn a little extra money, because remember, this is not a free to play game and one does not put one's primary income stream at risk lightly.

We will see just how smart ccp's marketing are now, and how they adapt to change, as the inability to change with an altered enviroment usually results in a short lived career......

There is one EvE. Many people. Many lifestyles. WE are EvE

Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#195 - 2015-05-04 00:10:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Moac Tor
Does anyone realistically expect CCP to release all their skins, slash the prices they are asking, and then make them available on any ship? That is certainly what some of you sound like you are asking for; if so you are going to be disappointed as it is simply not going to happen.

What you need to remember, like a drug company that spends thousands on research and development, when they eventually discover the drug, they don't simply sell it off at production cost do they. No, they try to recoup all the time and resources invested into the discovery of the drug which was the difficult part.

This ships skins thing is no different, anyone who has been following will know that CCP have had this in the works for quite some time now. I am sure many of us had realised that once CCP had the mechanic in place, then the actual creation of the assets was not going to be the difficult part.

The business model is also perfectly reasonable, with many of the skins priced at under $10, and some for as little as $3.50 for a permanent skin. The comparisons being made between skins and the summer of rage are massively exaggerated and dramatic. With incarna CCP was taking the game in a completely different direction, this skin thing is simply a side project with the rest of the game staying on the rails travelling towards seagulls vision.

Give CCP a break and let them fix this bug.
Memphis Baas
#196 - 2015-05-04 00:51:15 UTC
Don't expect them to, but, to use your analogy, it's like a medical company releasing Viagra only in penile injection form, and then somehow leaking an email that pills are easily possible. I believe that if they sell the pills they'd make more money than if they only sell the syringes, and, actually, if you want, look up Cialis sales vs. Alprostadil sales.

I am FOR fixing this bug, because it's a bug, and because they need to get the system back under their control. Just hoping they change their minds and make the skins universal.

They can be temporary skins, too, as long as they apply to all ships; I know I'll change my mind about what colors I like, at least yearly if not more often. So, on one hand, building a permanent set of colors would increase attachment to my character(s), and on the other hand, if they're temporary I'll just buy the FOTM color and not have to spend on the others.

Anyway, wish list. CCP will do whatever they feel is best, as they always have, and should. Not like yammering on the forums does anything.
Koloblicin Rahl
Forgot to repair
#197 - 2015-05-04 01:03:37 UTC
Ok so I've played this game a little over 2 years, my first forum post! \o/ (I despise forums)

This is a topic I must weigh in and voice an opinion!

Please allow the 'bug' of all skins on all ships. Probably the only time I had a genuine 'nerdgasm' was when I saw an individual linking pix of said bug on ships (screenshots of machariels in assorted colors & a screenshot of a stratios sporting the quafe skin). This is AWESOME! Why in gods name would you consider this a no-no.

You preach that EVE is the pinnacle of a sandbox, that the individuals run the game and the dev's/employees truly serve them with minimal interference. I find it difficult to believe that the majority do not want skins as an option, well correction - limited skins dependent on NPC lore. Seriously?!

Unless all skins for all ships is a bug that detracts from gameplay (causes lag etc), I see NO reason to not allow this bug. Machariel & Stratios are 2 of my favorite ships in the game! I tried to repeat the 'bug' for the machariel, dropping a few hundred mil on skins & failing to get 1 skin to apply to my sadness.

Please, allow all skins for all ships! o7
CCP Darwin
C C P
C C P Alliance
#198 - 2015-05-04 01:18:39 UTC  |  Edited by: CCP Darwin
Zappity wrote:
Hilarious CCP logic. Enormously fun, clearly doesn't fit in our game.

That's not what I said. What I said was that we're thinking about how to make it fit in our game in a way that makes sense.

CCP Darwin  •  Senior Software Engineer, Art & Graphics, EVE Online  •  @mark_wilkins

CCP Darwin
C C P
C C P Alliance
#199 - 2015-05-04 01:22:49 UTC  |  Edited by: CCP Darwin
Rain6637 wrote:
Even if you plan to release everything and are making an effort to do so, the pricing is... obnoxious.

OK, so why don't you give specific feedback. What do you want to see, and what price is the most you'd be willing to pay? Imagine everything conceivable is on the table.

CCP Darwin  •  Senior Software Engineer, Art & Graphics, EVE Online  •  @mark_wilkins

Sniper Smith
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#200 - 2015-05-04 01:41:33 UTC
CCP Darwin wrote:
Rain6637 wrote:
Even if you plan to release everything and are making an effort to do so, the pricing is... obnoxious.

OK, so why don't you give specific feedback. What do you want to see, and what price is the most you'd be willing to pay? Imagine everything conceivable is on the table.

The Price tiers are not that bad imho.
The issue is what's in those Tiers.

Why should a Frigate Skin, not some super special unique skin, just a standard corp skin, cost as much or more than other BC's, and even BS's?

Combine that with Aurum that you buy/convert from PLEX doesn't go evenly into these is also very annoying.

My suggestion is make pricing Tiers..
Frig/Dessy
Cruiser
BC
BS
Cap
Super.

Take the high price for Supers, the current low for Frigs, and the other pricing tiers inbetween. When we get T2 and T3 add a little more on top, but keep a T2 Frig skin to be no more than a T1 Cruiser.. T2 BS no more than a Cap, etc.

As it stands now the pricing just seems all over the place.

Also, Add them to LP Stores. Add more to drops. and more Variation to drops. 30 days IMHO is rather lame, 90 days, now that's more like it. Add them to the Pirate LP stores. In addition, make them mission rewards, like for Storyline missions, one time rewards for reaching a Corp/Empire standings.


Above all else, we want to know what CCP's plan IS. No one has laid out what their goal is with Skins, all we keep getting told is it isn't done yet. How about you tell us what the endgame goal is, and we can tell you now what we think about it BEFORE you invest the time in something that people are gonna have issues with. We could have told you how bizzare the current pricing is. We could have told you that we'd love to not be limited with "lore" for skin-hull combo's. We can vote what skins we want so you know where to invest the time in now..