These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Prototype: Dojos

First post First post First post
Author
Mharius Skjem
Guardians of the Underworld
#1101 - 2014-10-27 16:57:36 UTC
TheExtruder wrote:
people who have bad opinions of dojos probably have some kind of greedy agenda to keep their businesses going or maybe they just want more flies to be caught in their pvp net somewhere in lowsec which nobody cares about Lol


Complete Bullshit.

I'm not a pvper and even I see this as against all of the founding principles of Eve Online.

An Instance in the Sandbox...

A recovering btter vet,  with a fresh toon and a determination to like everything that CCP does to Eve...

Don't take me too seriously though, I like to tease a bit on the forums, but that's only because I love you...

TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1102 - 2014-10-27 17:31:27 UTC
Mharius Skjem wrote:
TheExtruder wrote:
people who have bad opinions of dojos probably have some kind of greedy agenda to keep their businesses going or maybe they just want more flies to be caught in their pvp net somewhere in lowsec which nobody cares about Lol


Complete Bullshit.

I'm not a pvper and even I see this as against all of the founding principles of Eve Online.

An Instance in the Sandbox...


what is this sandbox exactly, is it not a playground for all the kids no matter what toys they choose to play with

i have flown with the big guys in null, and i have experienced/lived the blob mentality, its just not for me at the moment because i choose to live a different type of "social mentality" in highsec where i can create corporations and channels around anti-ganking for example or whatever else, its simply my career path.
I would like to have access to pvp in this type of social lifestyle in highsec, the closest that comes to fulfilling my pvp needs are NPSI fleets like spectre fleet channel, but even in NPSI there is a sense of blob mentality which i am not a big fan of currently because of my lack of understanding of ships and fits that i would consider fun to try out. Dojos would be a way to dive deeper into the ship fits and from there new pvp schemes can grow, these schemes might drive me back into more dangerous territory like lowsec/null where fear of loss is amplified
Evora Pirkibo
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#1103 - 2014-10-27 18:43:34 UTC
Eve's sandbox is where the kids can play with their toys, and other kids can come kick sand in your face, stomp all over your toys, and perhaps ransom the bits back to you. Or just laugh in your face.

There are much better means of driving conflict and content into low/null.

On a long enough timeline, the life expectancy of everyone drops to zero.

TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1104 - 2014-10-27 19:10:13 UTC
Evora Pirkibo wrote:
Eve's sandbox is where the kids can play with their toys, and other kids can come kick sand in your face, stomp all over your toys, and perhaps ransom the bits back to you. Or just laugh in your face.

There are much better means of driving conflict and content into low/null.


i guess a higher evolved sandbox would be more like what we have in real life society, where people cant necessarily have an easy time to "stomp all over other peoples toys" because then they would get into trouble and the whole thing wouldnt be worth it to begin with
Evora Pirkibo
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#1105 - 2014-10-27 19:37:18 UTC
What makes you think its easy? Your argument has been that its hard and requires a superfluous "middle ground" to make an easier transition to a harder playstyle. The trade of sapping content from low on the chance more people would venture there is a very bad deal. As if you dont need to go there, why not just play controlled instanced pvp instead? Especially considering plenty go out of their way to mitigate any kind of risk.

Eve is far removed from the real world, and rightly so. Our environment from conception has been one involving freedom of choice.

Honestly, why do people expect honest combat from those that live in highsec nigh exclusively? These players are demonstrating a pattern of risk aversion behavior before you even meet each other, then you expect them to not use any advantage they can? Simply counter intuitive.

Basicly, pvp matchmaking in eve is alien to its very nature.

On a long enough timeline, the life expectancy of everyone drops to zero.

Gaan Cathal
Angry Mustellid
#1106 - 2014-10-27 20:02:55 UTC
Sierra Payne wrote:

So here I am, going out for a roam in FW space. I do not have a link-alt available to get boosts so about 75% of the fights are badly in the opponent's favor. So I am sitting there with skills that need some work, fighting someone who has a massive advantage and you then tell me it's my fault I can't find fightable targets without just throwing ISK at it and pray?

It's a problem that puts a lot of new players off.


You're right, that's a big issue. However, it's probably best solved by actually fixing the problem (the fact that off-grid boosting happens, which is a plague and needs to be purged with fire) as opposed to turning the core principles of Eve's sandbox on it's head.

If this ever makes it to TQ you'll actually have a class of character that's more deserving of the 'carebear' appellation than afk miners.
Bastion Arzi
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#1107 - 2014-10-28 00:33:35 UTC
havent read the whole thread just the first few pages.

but i have to say this is the single most awesome idea i have heard of yet in eve and also that i cant understand the fear and skeptisim behind putting this on TQ.

I have played eve since Dec 2012 so im a relatively young character but i feel the addition of this feature will breath new life into the game.

Eve is an awesome game, and i love it. But man at times i just want to log on and pvp.

I've been in Hi, Lo, Null and wherever i go sometimes (most of the time) space is just dead. You can roam for ages and find nothing. Making the whole experience boring.

Even in RvB its duifficult to find a fight all the time. Sure you get more fights but sometimes theres just nothing going on.

This is why for a short while i stopped playing eve and just logged in to update my skillqueue. Other games had more instant gratification so I went there.

I have now returned to eve to give nul another go in the hopes of finding gf''s.

sometimes there are. but most of the time space is dead.

but if eve had this feature, i would never be bored. imagine during fleet downtime you can instantly find pvp. practice ur game , actually get better...

I think it would certainly open up pvp to new players as well. which is fantastic because its so awesome in this game when **** actually goes down.

I really cant express enough how excited i am by this.

Someone else posted that what if people just stayed in station using the dojo all the time instead actually 'playing' eve.

Of course people will still play the game. Use the space, go on roams, find the kills. Theres also always going to be pos' and poco's to bash and fights to be had out of it. Hi sec war decs, low sec FW, Null SOV and of course bitter vets who dont like change.

Dont worry, I dont think this will break eve.

This will make it even more ******* awesome.

One problem tho if it does get really popular. is like when u have to form up quickly to save some 'assets' becuase someone is attacking something or other. Sometimes u need to form u fast and if poepl are stuck in the instance they wont be forming up fast. So there should be an option to quit the dojo at any time.

Flame all u want this dojo idea is aweome!

Evora Pirkibo
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#1108 - 2014-10-28 01:08:32 UTC
No. Think it through from a perspective wider than your own want for instant gratification. The opposition is more than just angry fire, there are plenty of well reasoned posts describing exactly how this is detrimental the overall gameplay environment.

The problem of dead space and stagnation would only be exacerbated by the implementation of dojos, explained repeatedly within this thread. An increase in conflict drivers and player matriculation is the cure.

Veritas pushed this out on his second to last day with CCP before moving to riot gaming, the company behind league of legends. This should indicate the kind of content he wishes to create, and how it not so coincidentally isn't with CCP.

On a long enough timeline, the life expectancy of everyone drops to zero.

Bastion Arzi
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#1109 - 2014-10-28 01:27:47 UTC  |  Edited by: Bastion Arzi
whatever.

anyway i tried to dl duality but the link is down. just thought u shud know.

Evora Pirkibo wrote:
there are plenty of well reasoned posts describing exactly how this is detrimental the overall gameplay.


Wel ive read some more of them and they seems to boil down to "but i wanna gank your ship in space and if ur preventing me from doing that ur removing content" without really addressing the fact that ccp are actually adding content into the game.

There seems to be a real fear that space will become dead becuase eveybody will be queing up to do thier 1v1s. I dont believe this will be the case

and anyway a lot of space is already dead

but still

The players will still need isk. and i believe isk comes from pos's, pocos and sov all of which need to be defended. There are of course also various other activites missioning, mining, exploration. none of which are instanced

are you lot really crying becuase theres some small amount of content in the game where people cant be **** all over?
TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1110 - 2014-10-28 22:06:54 UTC
Bastion Arzi wrote:
havent read the whole thread just the first few pages.

but i have to say this is the single most awesome idea i have heard of yet in eve and also that i cant understand the fear and skeptisim behind putting this on TQ.

I have played eve since Dec 2012 so im a relatively young character but i feel the addition of this feature will breath new life into the game.

Eve is an awesome game, and i love it. But man at times i just want to log on and pvp.

I've been in Hi, Lo, Null and wherever i go sometimes (most of the time) space is just dead. You can roam for ages and find nothing. Making the whole experience boring.

Even in RvB its duifficult to find a fight all the time. Sure you get more fights but sometimes theres just nothing going on.

This is why for a short while i stopped playing eve and just logged in to update my skillqueue. Other games had more instant gratification so I went there.

I have now returned to eve to give nul another go in the hopes of finding gf''s.

sometimes there are. but most of the time space is dead.

but if eve had this feature, i would never be bored. imagine during fleet downtime you can instantly find pvp. practice ur game , actually get better...

I think it would certainly open up pvp to new players as well. which is fantastic because its so awesome in this game when **** actually goes down.

I really cant express enough how excited i am by this.

Someone else posted that what if people just stayed in station using the dojo all the time instead actually 'playing' eve.

Of course people will still play the game. Use the space, go on roams, find the kills. Theres also always going to be pos' and poco's to bash and fights to be had out of it. Hi sec war decs, low sec FW, Null SOV and of course bitter vets who dont like change.

Dont worry, I dont think this will break eve.

This will make it even more ******* awesome.

One problem tho if it does get really popular. is like when u have to form up quickly to save some 'assets' becuase someone is attacking something or other. Sometimes u need to form u fast and if poepl are stuck in the instance they wont be forming up fast. So there should be an option to quit the dojo at any time.

Flame all u want this dojo idea is aweome!



well said.
Nathan Shavit
Shavit Risk Management
#1111 - 2014-11-07 14:58:41 UTC
It may be controversial, but I like this concept :)

There is no problem an air strike cannot solve.

TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1112 - 2014-11-07 17:37:21 UTC  |  Edited by: TheExtruder
i am sure i am not the only one who has been actively trying to organize 5v5 or 10v10 tournaments. eve mechanics sadly make it very hard for us because people always choose a safer and more "isk reliable path in the game" rather than wasting time on a gamble and tournaments where loss of money is possibility not to mention being griefed by gankers. So i think its a brilliant idea that the host/owner of the dojo pays for all the ships rather than having to communicate back and forth forever about what ships and fits to bring to peole that are not very motivated to participate (probably because they are uncertain about what the match will look like).

I havent tried the dojo yet on the test server. But I was thinking it would be great if it came with a "entry fee" for entering the tourney. Or even a "exit fee" incase you lose the ship and dont return it, maybe the FC sets the exit fee to 50% of what the ship is worth
TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1113 - 2014-11-10 15:27:02 UTC  |  Edited by: TheExtruder
i was trying to do some arranged 5v5 this weekend in RvB but people seem to prefer their own ships, fits and schemes. and they seem to prefer to have a fight the normal way, probably because they are uncertain of how it will look like to fight in other peoples ship setups (even if they were provided to them for free, which is what i was offering this weekend but i couldnt show the ships to them and i had no way of sharing my vision of how the fight might look like in all its glory)

Would it be possible to get a prefitted ship from the dojo and then be able to switch around certain midslot modules for example, maybe the host of the dojo can make it so that certain midslot items can be switched around for example.

I think the core of what a dojo will do is it will give people "an overview" of how all the ship fittings will clash with each other (its a way for the host of the dojo to share his vision of what he thinks would be an epic fight) and I think people should be able to represent their corp in terms of kill stats and success rate in dojos (statistics). Give pilots a "cause to fight for" by getting killmails and freedom to add to the amount of kills that has happened for that specific cause, it can be political, it can be a charity, it can be a commercial, it can be a recruitment campaign etc. random people can join in as independant mercenaries fighting for whatever cause they enjoy supporting and their way of backing it up is (not through the traditional way of joining a corp) but rather through joining an event as an independant individual. Like in real life people enjoy the "event platform" and they join events probably because they have some kind of motive or drive behind it, in eve that drive would translate to getting kills and money.
Titanito 777
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1114 - 2014-11-22 22:11:20 UTC
Is Dojo introduced in the game?
Or from the Dojo refused?
Mharius Skjem
Guardians of the Underworld
#1115 - 2014-11-22 23:35:26 UTC
With any luck Dojos will all die in a fire.

A recovering btter vet,  with a fresh toon and a determination to like everything that CCP does to Eve...

Don't take me too seriously though, I like to tease a bit on the forums, but that's only because I love you...

TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1116 - 2014-11-23 01:18:11 UTC
Mharius Skjem wrote:
With any luck Dojos will all die in a fire.


what it takes you to rally a fleet will take a dojo twice as fast to get the job done. nothing wrong with a little efficiency. we have enough corporations, world is not gonna end if those few people in power of those mega corporations/alliances get a few less fleets happening, let their territory burn to the ground for all i care
Hairpins Blueprint
The Northerners
Pandemic Horde
#1117 - 2014-11-23 01:25:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Hairpins Blueprint
i think this should should be rented from concord so corps and alliances can have theire small tournaments.


but the structure should be baned in hi sec space.

it would be super cool to have it, but it should not interfere with normal pvp in any way.

Make it like special tournamet only thing.

200 mil per 24h can not be used in Hi sec space
TheExtruder
TheExtruder Corporation
#1118 - 2014-11-23 09:51:34 UTC
Hairpins Blueprint wrote:
i think this should should be rented from concord so corps and alliances can have theire small tournaments.


but the structure should be baned in hi sec space.

it would be super cool to have it, but it should not interfere with normal pvp in any way.

Make it like special tournamet only thing.

200 mil per 24h can not be used in Hi sec space


dont think i have heard worse argument ever. and why is highsec of all places so precious to you in terms of banning pvp there?
Steve Ronuken
Fuzzwork Enterprises
Vote Steve Ronuken for CSM
#1119 - 2014-11-23 12:27:14 UTC
TheExtruder wrote:
Hairpins Blueprint wrote:
i think this should should be rented from concord so corps and alliances can have theire small tournaments.


but the structure should be baned in hi sec space.

it would be super cool to have it, but it should not interfere with normal pvp in any way.

Make it like special tournamet only thing.

200 mil per 24h can not be used in Hi sec space


dont think i have heard worse argument ever. and why is highsec of all places so precious to you in terms of banning pvp there?



tbh, highsec space is where it has the most use. Especially with the corp aggression changes being talked about.

Woo! CSM XI!

Fuzzwork Enterprises

Twitter: @fuzzysteve on Twitter

baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#1120 - 2014-11-23 12:36:22 UTC
Bastion Arzi wrote:


Wel ive read some more of them and they seems to boil down to "but i wanna gank your ship in space and if ur preventing me from doing that ur removing content" without really addressing the fact that ccp are actually adding content into the game.



What content are they adding here? You can already organise 1v1s and this thing will indeed remove content from people who want to pvp you.