These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev Blog: Reprocess all the things!

First post First post First post
Author
Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1781 - 2014-04-03 17:00:04 UTC
Inspiration wrote:
@Querns

You keep going back to situations where a lone wolf miner with large volumes of ore (for him) has fewer options and disadvantaged in other ways compared to people we organize.

Your replies assume, the situation is permanent and that miner has no option but to sit there doing the same thing he did before the changes and be forever disadvantaged.


So in order to encourage unaffiliated players to join a corporation, we should hang a huge, uncompressed-ore-shaped albatross around their necks? This is pretty dumb. Lead with a carrot, not with a stick.

Quote:

It seems you replied to statements you did not understand and you even made several false presentations. You dismiss my arguments about being part of a corporation as if that alone would bring magic access to compression without any effort.

* You misrepresent that due to 24h notification, the POS driven PvP risk in high sec is a absurd. I can see this as trolling or plain ignorance, but will reply with a few points:

1. It is not just the POS, which ** underideal circumstances ** you can remove and rebuild later. Your mining fleet is at risk just the same and jumping between corporations has its limits these days.

2. While removing the POS, other corporations can simply take the free spot..no way you get that back without a fight.

3. Corp standing is not static, you might been able to anchor a pos at one time, but a few new member in your corp that draw the average down will undo that.

You can work around all of this by making your standings alt be the first one to join the new corporation. When the old pos is being removed, the standings alt hangs out on grid in a blockade runner and instantly anchors a new pos for the new corp. With no more 24 hour timer for roles WRT quitting a corp, this is all incredibly trivial to do.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Inspiration
#1782 - 2014-04-03 17:11:54 UTC  |  Edited by: Inspiration
Querns wrote:
You can work around all of this by making your standings alt be the first one to join the new corporation. When the old pos is being removed, the standings alt hangs out on grid in a blockade runner and instantly anchors a new pos for the new corp. With no more 24 hour timer for roles WRT quitting a corp, this is all incredibly trivial to do.


* They can suicide your ass and you cannot go back to said corp for another 7 days.
* You have to create a new corp, how else be the first in it?
* You will be caught up with unless you have an unlimited supply of corporations with proper standings ready.

Your counter argument is a fairy tale at best, an excuse to get whatever YOU want!


Querns wrote:
So in order to encourage unaffiliated players to join a corporation, we should hang a huge, uncompressed-ore-shaped albatross around their necks? This is pretty dumb. Lead with a carrot, not with a stick.


CCP adds a compression facility that was not there before, and you call it a stick.

It is not like younger players have compression BPOs or even high enough skills to get the benefit of them, if they buy BPCs. Compression is a new lure for them, calling it a stick is disingenuous. You clearly have a hidden agenda as you are constantly misrepresenting everything to get your desired feature accepted. The straws you grasp at are getting thinner by the minute.

That said, i do not feel like spending more of my time playing your forum game...it is not particularly productive.

I am serious!

Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1783 - 2014-04-03 17:16:49 UTC
Inspiration wrote:
Querns wrote:
You can work around all of this by making your standings alt be the first one to join the new corporation. When the old pos is being removed, the standings alt hangs out on grid in a blockade runner and instantly anchors a new pos for the new corp. With no more 24 hour timer for roles WRT quitting a corp, this is all incredibly trivial to do.


And they can suicide your ass and you cannot go back to said corp for another 7 days. You will be caught up unless you have an unlimited supply of corporations with proper standings ready.

Your counter argument is a fairy tale at best, an excuse to get whatever YOU want!


Ah, yes, the vaunted barrier to entry for creating new corporations. Let us list the requirements:

* Corporation Management to 1
* 1,599,800 ISK

Truly, a backbreaking labor. Hercules wept.

Quote:
Querns wrote:
So in order to encourage unaffiliated players to join a corporation, we should hang a huge, uncompressed-ore-shaped albatross around their necks? This is pretty dumb. Lead with a carrot, not with a stick.


CCP add a compression facility that was not there before, and you call it a stick.

They added a compression facility with high access requirements (standings, corporation, pos fuel, anchoring) and took away low-effort reprocessing. Yes, I call it a stick.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1784 - 2014-04-03 17:18:06 UTC
Also, hidden agenda? My agenda is quite clear -- I want compression to be as accessible as possible so there is more compressed ore available for me and mine to import to nullsec. My goals happen to dovetail nicely with other concerns as well.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Inspiration
#1785 - 2014-04-03 17:21:59 UTC
Querns wrote:
Also, hidden agenda? My agenda is quite clear -- I want compression to be as accessible as possible so there is more compressed ore available for me and mine to import to nullsec. My goals happen to dovetail nicely with other concerns as well.


These arguments I have already debunked in lengthy posts...go back and read again. Your feature will not do what you claim it does, it only creates loopholes to be exploited and even hurt the players you champion in your posts, the most.

It is sickening really, you should go into politics.



I am serious!

Weaselior
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#1786 - 2014-04-03 17:23:14 UTC  |  Edited by: Weaselior
Inspiration wrote:
I like that it can be taken out, the pvp element is certainly there. But there are ways around it botters will exploit. They can sit at a station undock of a quiet system and simply dock up as soon as anything is on grid.

a botting compression pos is 100% safe

Inspiration wrote:

These arguments I have already debunked in lengthy posts...go back and read again. Your feature will not do what you claim it does, it only creates loopholes to be exploited and even hurt the players you champion in your posts, the most.

It is sickening really, you should go into politics.

you haven't debunked anything, you've just repeated bad arguments over and over again and demonstrated fundamental misunderstandings of how the game works and good game design

Head of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal Pubbie Management and Exploitation Division.

Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1787 - 2014-04-03 17:28:16 UTC
Inspiration wrote:
Querns wrote:
Also, hidden agenda? My agenda is quite clear -- I want compression to be as accessible as possible so there is more compressed ore available for me and mine to import to nullsec. My goals happen to dovetail nicely with other concerns as well.


These arguments I have already debunked in lengthy posts...go back and read again. Your feature will not do what you claim it does, it only creates loopholes to be exploited and even hurt the players you champion in your posts, the most.

It is sickening really, you should go into politics.

Loopholes? What possible loopholes would allowing unlimited station compression cause?

If you consider strangling a competitive edge for the poshaver to be a loophole, then I'm afraid we can't come to terms. Compression is too important.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Weaselior
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#1788 - 2014-04-03 17:31:06 UTC
really, you have to have a completely fundamentally absurd idea of what risk in eve is to think that a highsec pos that never holds anything of value whatsoever is at risk to anyone, short of you pissing off someone so badly they'll waste hours of their time to cost you pennies

in no situation will your compression pos ever be at risk. in no situation will your freighter going to and from your compression pos ever be at risk. you have to imagine an insane sequence of incredibly stupid events to even have the slightest risk your 100m small pos is killed.

Head of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal Pubbie Management and Exploitation Division.

Weaselior
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#1789 - 2014-04-03 17:33:35 UTC
let me put it this way: i wouldn't even bother finding and killing your compression pos once this went up and we delight in making people suffer in-game for their terrible posting

i would not bother because it would be trivial to evade and you would not suffer any real loss even if I managed to kill it, i would merely be trolling myself by trying

Head of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal Pubbie Management and Exploitation Division.

Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1790 - 2014-04-03 17:33:46 UTC
And, even if someone DOES wardec your poshaving corporation, you can just abuse corporation standings and creation mechanics to safeguard your investment.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Jagoff Haverford
Royal Amarr Institute
Amarr Empire
#1791 - 2014-04-03 18:11:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Jagoff Haverford
Inspiration wrote:
As these [Jump Freighters] are already jumping back and forth and will have to continue doing that even for current levels of null industry, the fact they use fuel or can be destroyed is irrelevant. Compression or no compression in station is not a factor that will change this in any way, shape or form.

The null consumers of that ore are acquiring it one way or another from high sec, the hauling costs are a given.
Sorry,, mate. I misunderstood what you were saying. When you were talking about null sec being able to outbid other pilots, I though you were talking about bringing minerals back to sell in high sec (that's a huge hassle and I'm thinking we won't see too much of it). But now that I've re-read things I see that you are talking about out-bidding on buy orders for ore, since (once compressed) the ore is more valuable to them than it will be to high sec refiners.

I can't argue that point at all, but I do know that the Eve market shakes these comparative advantages out pretty quickly, and that an equilibrium will quickly be found. I'm really curious to see just how much the selling of raw ore becomes a "thing", since it's hardly happening at all right now.

It will be interesting.
stoicfaux
#1792 - 2014-04-03 18:28:48 UTC
Inspiration wrote:
You clearly have a hidden agenda as you are constantly misrepresenting everything to get your desired feature accepted.

Of course he has a hidden agenda. He's probably sitting on a huge pile of ore in a high-sec station in preparation for the summer expansion and realizes that, come summer, he will have to transport it from a station to a POS to get the ore compressed, for which he will need many, many, many freighter trips of soul crushing tedium to do.

Pon Farr Memorial: once every 7 years, all the carebears in high-sec must PvP or they will be temp-banned.

Dersen Lowery
The Scope
#1793 - 2014-04-03 18:40:54 UTC
I don't understand what the fascination is with instant compression, or instant refining for that matter. Why remove a variable that could make compression in stations doable, but not preferable to a POS?

Proud founder and member of the Belligerent Desirables.

I voted in CSM X!

Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1794 - 2014-04-03 19:18:52 UTC
Dersen Lowery wrote:
I don't understand what the fascination is with instant compression, or instant refining for that matter. Why remove a variable that could make compression in stations doable, but not preferable to a POS?

If I was implying that station compression had to be instant, I didn't mean to. Having a small cost in isk or time (or both) for station compression is perfectly acceptable to me.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Beaver Retriever
Reality Sequence
#1795 - 2014-04-03 19:55:52 UTC
Klarion Sythis wrote:
Any chance of gas compression?

Can this PLEASE be a thing?

I've barely even sat foot in wormholes, I just want this to be a thing in Eve. I want to run a gas compression plant. Make the pos mods for it look really cool with moving piston compressors and everything.

I've never realized how much I wanted this thing before now.
Inspiration
#1796 - 2014-04-03 20:16:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Inspiration
Weaselior wrote:
Inspiration wrote:
I like that it can be taken out, the pvp element is certainly there. But there are ways around it botters will exploit. They can sit at a station undock of a quiet system and simply dock up as soon as anything is on grid.

a botting compression pos is 100% safe


You are not reading, just a mere few posts ago i demonstrated using current game mechanics it is not safe. It can be taken out, you cannot simply retract it and get away with it if the enemy party is prepared for that. Disputing that is just a hollow claim, repeating lies does not make it truth.

Weaselior wrote:
Inspiration wrote:
These arguments I have already debunked in lengthy posts...go back and read again. Your feature will not do what you claim it does, it only creates loopholes to be exploited and even hurt the players you champion in your posts, the most.

It is sickening really, you should go into politics.


you haven't debunked anything, you've just repeated bad arguments over and over again and demonstrated fundamental misunderstandings of how the game works and good game design


That is a broad claim, backup up by nothing, and which quite frankly you cannot back up. You can have different opinions about what is good game design, but you cannot dispute market and logistic dynamics. That is how people react to their environment, it involves distances, time, organisation. Measurable and predictable quantities that lead to certain outcome possibilities.

The game is more complex then you know or let on to. It is more complex then "null needs compressed ore and with compression in stations even new players on their own can supply said ore". But it is the way you and "Weaselior" try to present it.

Introducing NPC ORE compression gives null more pricing power versus other sources of this form or ore. With it, the refining benefit suddenly expands beyond null localized industry. It is doubtful this is CCPs desire. It gives null the more pricing power versus local producers and puts the squeeze on the high sec miners who would otherwise be the sole source for both high sec producers and null alike.

Enabling NPC station ORE compression would accomplish exactly what industrial opponents to these changes fear.

The thing is, your simple version of the game does not take other parties into account that are connected. You just present it as null need/buys, and newbie can get a good price. This simplification presents a non existing scenario, designed to lure others into thinking it is a good idea.

I am serious!

Vhelnik Cojoin
Pandemic Horde High Sec Division
#1797 - 2014-04-03 20:32:52 UTC
Querns wrote:
Also, hidden agenda? My agenda is quite clear -- I want compression to be as accessible as possible so there is more compressed ore available for me and mine to import to nullsec. My goals happen to dovetail nicely with other concerns as well.


Hmm, this actually makes perfect sense... Shocked

Requiring a POS for mineral compression would only be a minor speedbump to the established miners, but I can see the argument for making it a station service instead (possibly at a cost in time or ISK).

Even today my merry little gang of miners (when we do wear that hat) use a freighter plus an Orca for our HiSec mining operations. The Orca collects ore from the mining ships, and the freighter picks the ore from the Orca. When the freighter is full, it will travel to a nearby system with a station, where one of us has perfect refine (6.67 standing). Unless the mining fleet is pretty large, then the freighter has ample time to travel several systems over and back before the Orca and the mining ship ore holds are full. Delivering the ore to a POS in a nearby system instead of a station would make nearly zero difference to us. The exception being setting up the POS and keeping it fueled.

So I'm not sure what benefit there is - to us in HiSec - of having compression available as a POS module instead of a station service. In a WH, yes, that is an entirely different matter.

Additionally, I don't buy the conspiracy theory here. Even if we assume for arguments sake that Querns sits on a huge mountain of ore somewhere in HiSec, then he would still have plenty of time before the expansion to refine it to minerals, fabricate smaller molehill worth of railguns, teleport them to NullSec and turn them back into minerals.

Have you Communicated with your fellow capsuleers today? It is good for the EvE-oconomy and o-kay for you.

Jagoff Haverford
Royal Amarr Institute
Amarr Empire
#1798 - 2014-04-03 20:35:10 UTC
Dersen Lowery wrote:
I don't understand what the fascination is with instant compression, or instant refining for that matter. Why remove a variable that could make compression in stations doable, but not preferable to a POS?

I hate to tack on anything additional when I think these changes are supremely great, but I have to admit that adding in a production delay for both compression and refining would be cool as hell.

In fact, the refining skill could increase the number of lines that you could run at one time. The refining efficiency skill could speed up how long those lines take to run. Instantaneous anything in the industry game is a mistake.
Inspiration
#1799 - 2014-04-03 20:35:57 UTC
Querns wrote:
Ah, yes, the vaunted barrier to entry for creating new corporations. Let us list the requirements:

* Corporation Management to 1
* 1,599,800 ISK

Truly, a backbreaking labor. Hercules wept.


Why i am even responding to tour continued misrepresentation is beyond even my imagination. You leave out all important details and justify that with a quote taken out of context.

Educate yourself by creating a new corporation using a new character and go straight for anchoring a POS. Anyone that ever anchored a POS can tell you it is NOT easy to get to that point and it involves quite some effort. Yet you say as if its a 30 minute training and 1.6m ISK

You must be the most naive player in EVE and we all would become more intelligent if they just gave you a forum ban...instantly!

Querns wrote:
They added a compression facility with high access requirements (standings, corporation, pos fuel, anchoring) and took away low-effort reprocessing. Yes, I call it a stick.


Oh, now it is suddenly an effort to get into compression. A minute ago it was..essentially instant and virtually cost-less. New players never had anything resembling compression. Then you bring up reprocessing nerf...reprocessing of what? The 5 modules they get from killing a belt rat? What does that have to do with POS based ORE compresson bing a lure or a stick?

Exactly nothing!

I am serious!

Vhelnik Cojoin
Pandemic Horde High Sec Division
#1800 - 2014-04-03 20:49:32 UTC
Also, wardecs due to our compression POS. Our group has discussed this already.

If someone is daft enough to dec us due to the POS, then we will use the 24 hour ramp up to build a Goonswarm Federation approved D!ckstar(TM): Large Caldari POS, 13(?) appropriate hardeners to achieve nearly even 70% shield resists across all damage types, plus even number of racial ECM modules, as many as will fit (4x4 = 16, I believe).

If anybody is insane enough to even try and take that down in HiSec without access to dreads, then they can have it. That would almost be a reverse grief if ever I saw one. Lol

(I assume d!ckstars still work, has been a while since I lived in Null...)

Have you Communicated with your fellow capsuleers today? It is good for the EvE-oconomy and o-kay for you.