These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Incoming titan adjustments

First post First post
Author
Vile rat
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#1501 - 2012-03-14 14:30:04 UTC
Tobruk wrote:


maybe you should grab one and calculate how many dreads it takes to kill our titans and how long that would take given your current tech income.


Are you really going to make me detail the many holes in this plan? Is this something you're seriously suggesting or are you just trolling me?

No way, you gotta just be trolling me.
Flores Negras
V0LTA
WE FORM V0LTA
#1502 - 2012-03-14 14:30:20 UTC
So I should start out by saying I'm not a titan pilot, though it has always been my wish to one day get into a super and then a titan. With that being said, it is called a "Super Carrier" and as CCP Grayscale mentioned earlier refuting another post, CARRIERS are supposed to be the ones that kill the battleships not the dreads, supers or titans. If you look at the name "Super Carrier" It has carrier in it, and means that they should be able to do both intended purposes for both a carrier and a super, which is kill battleships and destroy structures.

After the last Super Carrier Nerf, supers became no more than giant logistics and structure grinders that people had wasted millions of SP and months of training into Drone skills to fly properly, but it was an accepted change as now supers are used as the logistics for the Titans who can kill alpha fleets that would otherwise be to strong. Now Super carriers are one role either grind structures or kill battleships (ineffectively) and titans will have one role to grind structures. Super carriers need a larger drone bay if they are going to have to take on both roles, which previously the Titans could have played, but that was also done away with by the same CSMs because they were losing BCs to supers. Which is stupid and a waste of SP and isk for Titan and Super pilots as they trained Guns/Drones and wasted isk on those skill books.

With the last nerf all supers saw new roles as they could no longer be fielded alone and they still cant be. Without a support fleet a super/titan fleet alone can not live as a few well piloted dictors can keep them locked down for any length of time and have reinforcements brought in, so it is the fact people still need a support fleet and that's why the changes to Super Carriers were made.

If you are going to take an absolute bat to all Supers/Titans and continue in doing so, some sort of compensation should be given to those who fly them as of now, and in the future. In addition prices should be lowered and build time as well for both titans and supers to make them a more viable weapon for all alliances/corporations which will in turn result in more being fielded, more mixed fights (Capitals and Sub caps), and will result in more destruction of all types of ships. If a Dread is to kill structures and costs 2b, and a Super is to kill dreads and Capitals should be about 5b, and a Titan to kill Capitals and Structures is about a combination of the two, but we'll say 10-15b...
In terms of prices a frigate costs 200k > Cruiser 3m > BC 35m > BS 155m > Carrier 1.2b > Dread 2b > Super 20b > Titan 105b
For the prices Supers/Titans have the same roles as Carrier/Dread so they should be MUCH closer in price.

Lastly a point about this thread is Goons you keep crapping in it, and have yet to make a valid point besides posting a few killboards of you getting owned because you wouldn't field your capitals or supers. The ONLY CSMs that have posted in this thread have also been Goons and 90% of people in this thread FOR the changes are goons as well. The same CSMs that changed Supers to be useless against sup caps (when carriers should be useful according to CCP Grayscale) are also the same ones now changing titans, for the same reason, they lose.
Hannott Thanos
Squadron 15
#1503 - 2012-03-14 14:32:18 UTC
Andski wrote:
Hannott Thanos wrote:
This is bullsh!t and you all know it. A titan should be able to track all ships. It's biggest, therefore it has to be best.

--
Sincerely, Death Star.


nope

sincerely, me


Someone did not get the joke? :)

while (CurrentSelectedTarget.Status == ShipStatus.Alive) {

     _myShip.FireAllGuns(CurrentSelectedTarget);

}

Roime
Mea Culpa.
Shadow Cartel
#1504 - 2012-03-14 14:33:05 UTC
As a general note an adjustment that benefits a single entity over others isn't probably a "balancing" adjustment at all.

Why only Goonswarm members are gloating happy about this change, and everyone else in null seems to be butthurt as hell?

Maybe needs some more thinking, imo, just by looking at the reactions.

Quote:
If 1600 people show up to take someone's space, and they can only field 200 guys, then THEY DO NOT DESERVE THAT SPACE. This is how the world works. You should not magically be allowed to pick space and control it because you can stick 50 guys into a super ship, and stand it up to 1600 people.


Why should 1600 be the magic win button?

It would be cool to play a game where the better pilots win, you know, a bit like it is in small gang combat.

.

Valearx
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#1505 - 2012-03-14 14:33:47 UTC
Tobruk wrote:


we should just get rid of all spaceship classes and have pods. whoever brings more wins.


Please continue, your high-pitched squeals of indignation are ******* musical.
Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1506 - 2012-03-14 14:34:07 UTC
Hannott Thanos wrote:
Andski wrote:
Hannott Thanos wrote:
This is bullsh!t and you all know it. A titan should be able to track all ships. It's biggest, therefore it has to be best.

--
Sincerely, Death Star.


nope

sincerely, me


Someone did not get the joke? :)


i have a hangover so yeah i kinda missed it

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

Reilly Duvolle
Hydra Squadron
#1507 - 2012-03-14 14:34:15 UTC
Vile rat wrote:


Realtalk:

Every single titan nerf has been to reduce their effectiveness towards subcaps. Titans on paper are actually not designed to hit subcaps for ****, it's only when you get a bunch that it's nearly impossible to maintain transversal from them all. **** they have dread guns on them and their drones were taken away, what about these things suggest they were designed as anti subcap platforms? I just don't understand this reasoning. Sure you've been taking advantage of their inability to balance these things vs subcaps properly but being an anti blob weapon clearly wasn't their intent by design and now we have them on record confirming this is the case.



They were originally designed as the ultimate anti-blob weapon. Dont even try that god damn Goon proaganda with me you god damn useless piece of sh*t.

Current Titan and supercarrier capabilities against subcaps have existed since Dominion. They werent important enough to nerf even when playing an instrumental role in toppling the Northern Coalition, a conglomerate of tens of thousands of players. But it became top priority once the Goons themselves were under threat. So in two passes, first back in december and now in April they get nerfed into oblivion. Wonder why? Oh scratch that. I dont really wonder why.
Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#1508 - 2012-03-14 14:34:45 UTC
Hannott Thanos wrote:
Someone did not get the joke? :)
Granted, it would be nice of capital ships had thermal exhaust vents, but they've talked about adding that for longer than they've talked about WiS, so good luck… P
CynoNet Two
GSF Logistics and Posting Reserves
Goonswarm Federation
#1509 - 2012-03-14 14:35:28 UTC
Roime wrote:


Why should 1600 be the magic win button?

It would be cool to play a game where the better pilots win, you know, a bit like it is in small gang combat.


Someone has never fought IRC
Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1510 - 2012-03-14 14:35:29 UTC
Roime wrote:
As a general note an adjustment that benefits a single entity over others isn't probably a "balancing" adjustment at all.

Why only Goonswarm members are gloating happy about this change, and everyone else in null seems to be butthurt as hell?

Maybe needs some more thinking, imo, just by looking at the reactions.

Quote:
If 1600 people show up to take someone's space, and they can only field 200 guys, then THEY DO NOT DESERVE THAT SPACE. This is how the world works. You should not magically be allowed to pick space and control it because you can stick 50 guys into a super ship, and stand it up to 1600 people.


Why should 1600 be the magic win button?

It would be cool to play a game where the better pilots win, you know, a bit like it is in small gang combat.



I'd say it's more indicative of the current state of nullsec - it's dominated by three powerblocs. Two of them, the CFC and Awagon, despise tracking titans. The other loves them.

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

Franklin D Roosevelt
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#1511 - 2012-03-14 14:35:45 UTC
Valearx wrote:
Tobruk wrote:


we should just get rid of all spaceship classes and have pods. whoever brings more wins.


Please continue, your high-pitched squeals of indignation are ******* musical.


Goons have no class. They are like kindergarteners that get a chance to be cruel to other nicer little kids just because the other kid peed himself by accident in front of the class.
Tobruk
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#1512 - 2012-03-14 14:36:27 UTC
Vile rat wrote:
Tobruk wrote:


maybe you should grab one and calculate how many dreads it takes to kill our titans and how long that would take given your current tech income.


Are you really going to make me detail the many holes in this plan? Is this something you're seriously suggesting or are you just trolling me?

No way, you gotta just be trolling me.


im not trolling Vile rat.

you made a choice to invest your income and time in a specific fleet doctrine, one that vee invented to counter armor hacs and abandons. It was the wrong choice.

Had you been able to field 300 or more dreads there is no FC in his right mind who would have opposed you with titans. Those same dreads can work unsieged like titans and do the same volly damage at the same range as maelstroms.

but this discussion is an academic one as CCP is playing favorites, your CEO has said as much.
Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1513 - 2012-03-14 14:36:35 UTC
Reilly Duvolle wrote:
They were originally designed as the ultimate anti-blob weapon. Dont even try that god damn Goon proaganda with me you god damn useless piece of sh*t.

Current Titan and supercarrier capabilities against subcaps have existed since Dominion. They werent important enough to nerf even when playing an instrumental role in toppling the Northern Coalition, a conglomerate of tens of thousands of players. But it became top priority once the Goons themselves were under threat. So in two passes, first back in december and now in April they get nerfed into oblivion. Wonder why? Oh scratch that. I dont really wonder why.


don't talk down to your betters, please.

also why do you think the ability to doomsday through a cyno was removed? good god

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

John Maynard Keynes
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1514 - 2012-03-14 14:36:41 UTC
Andski wrote:
John Maynard Keynes wrote:
Dear very important space ship personality,

the main purpose of AE DD was obviously to kill subcaps in large numbers.
The main purpose of focused DD was clearly to be able to kill every ship with one shot (including subcaps).

So as you can see the idea that supercaps should be a pure anti-capital weapon is rather new.

However, I do like that this was changed and do think that supercaps still need balancing. Making them useless is not the solution though.


Yes they should revert titans to the way they were originally added, AoE doomsdays coming through a kestrel cyno

sad lil pubbie


You can read reight? Made it bold for you...

Andski wrote:
[quote=John Maynard Keynes]
However, I do like that this was changed and do think that supercaps still need balancing. Making them useless is not the solution though.
BrokenBC
no tax's are us
#1515 - 2012-03-14 14:36:48 UTC
Roime wrote:
As a general note an adjustment that benefits a single entity over others isn't probably a "balancing" adjustment at all.

Why only Goonswarm members are gloating happy about this change, and everyone else in null seems to be butthurt as hell?

Maybe needs some more thinking, imo, just by looking at the reactions.

Quote:
If 1600 people show up to take someone's space, and they can only field 200 guys, then THEY DO NOT DESERVE THAT SPACE. This is how the world works. You should not magically be allowed to pick space and control it because you can stick 50 guys into a super ship, and stand it up to 1600 people.


Why should 1600 be the magic win button?

It would be cool to play a game where the better pilots win, you know, a bit like it is in small gang combat.



If you want small gang combat go get it!! No one is stopping you, there is plenty of it out there.But dont go thinking you are going to go take and hold entire regions of space without building a coalition or having a large alliance,it.just isnt going to happen.Live with it.
Le Cardinal
ECP Rogues
#1516 - 2012-03-14 14:37:55 UTC
Andski wrote:
Le Cardinal wrote:
Cut the crap will you. This adjustment is a shortterm solution to stagger the whining of all the goons whom are unable to think outside the Alphadoctrine box. PL and RDN have given them easy solutions on how to kill titans. And yet they keep throwing drakes and maelstroms at the titans. So they go to devs and ask for help. And how surprising is it that CCP yet again does a half-assed hotifx that gimps the titans ability to work properly against anything. By the time you manage to clean your brown nose, goons will infact reach many of their objectives through sheer numbers. Nothing else will matter.

And again you prove that your "humble" attitude last year is worth nothing to those whom can actually fly supercaps as long as the voices from those who cant be arsed to get one is heard. RDN does not give out supercaps to its members. Losses are reimbursed however.

So basically you are shafting the people who has been working their arses off to achieve these ships. Yes im a bit pissed. Not because this patch affect us quite much, but because devs let goons control their game.


it's not like this change should come at a surprise

/maybe/ basing your entire alliance around the concept of dogpiling all the high-skillpoint bittervets you can hoover up and ushering them into titans wasn't the most optimal plan

also - your alliance doesn't get its members into titans? yet you criticize GSF for not doing the same, while we heavily subsidize members who buy them? tell me all about how it's our tech income that gets RMTed.


A change is needed indeed, but this is as i said, an half arsed attempt to stagger your whining until they manage to think out a new function for them. And we all know CCPs ability to fix things properly. My alliances members get themselves into titans by working for it. Your alliance dont encourage your members to be competitive in anything else than drakes and maelstroms. You have the funds, and ability to reimburse losses, if you just used them. Instead you turn to the devs and cry.

Fyi, you dont need to be so highskilled in order to fly a titan. Training for maelstroms and drakes goes pretty fast. How about training a second account for supercaps, or even use an alt on same account. After all you have "bittervets" in goons as well, and since your recruiting everyone and their mother you should be able to muster a decent supportfleet along with supercaps.
Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1517 - 2012-03-14 14:38:57 UTC
John Maynard Keynes wrote:
Andski wrote:
John Maynard Keynes wrote:
Dear very important space ship personality,

the main purpose of AE DD was obviously to kill subcaps in large numbers.
The main purpose of focused DD was clearly to be able to kill every ship with one shot (including subcaps).

So as you can see the idea that supercaps should be a pure anti-capital weapon is rather new.

However, I do like that this was changed and do think that supercaps still need balancing. Making them useless is not the solution though.


Yes they should revert titans to the way they were originally added, AoE doomsdays coming through a kestrel cyno

sad lil pubbie


You can read reight? Made it bold for you...

John Maynard Keynes wrote:

However, I do like that this was changed and do think that supercaps still need balancing. Making them useless is not the solution though.


You're insisting that the way to balance supers is to make sure they can blap subcaps with impunity because that was their original intent, in 2005, when it was assumed they'd be rare.

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#1518 - 2012-03-14 14:40:31 UTC
Le Cardinal wrote:
A change is needed indeed, but this is as i said, an half arsed attempt to stagger your whining until they manage to think out a new function for them. And we all know CCPs ability to fix things properly. My alliances members get themselves into titans by working for it. Your alliance dont encourage your members to be competitive in anything else than drakes and maelstroms. You have the funds, and ability to reimburse losses, if you just used them. Instead you turn to the devs and cry.

Fyi, you dont need to be so highskilled in order to fly a titan. Training for maelstroms and drakes goes pretty fast. How about training a second account for supercaps, or even use an alt on same account. After all you have "bittervets" in goons as well, and since your recruiting everyone and their mother you should be able to muster a decent supportfleet along with supercaps.


we actually do reimburse titans and supercarriers, oops

get better spies bro, should be easy since we recruit everyone and their mother right???

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

GeneralDisturbed
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#1519 - 2012-03-14 14:41:25 UTC
Roime wrote:
As a general note an adjustment that benefits a single entity over others isn't probably a "balancing" adjustment at all.

Why only Goonswarm members are gloating happy about this change, and everyone else in null seems to be butthurt as hell?

Maybe needs some more thinking, imo, just by looking at the reactions.

Quote:
If 1600 people show up to take someone's space, and they can only field 200 guys, then THEY DO NOT DESERVE THAT SPACE. This is how the world works. You should not magically be allowed to pick space and control it because you can stick 50 guys into a super ship, and stand it up to 1600 people.


Why should 1600 be the magic win button?

It would be cool to play a game where the better pilots win, you know, a bit like it is in small gang combat.



Better pilots already win. As it's already been stated -and ignored- by Pl/raiden in this topic again and again, numbers aren't the issue here they are desperately trying to make it out to be. Those 1600 people don't exist. The people fighting goons consistently bring the same number of pilots as us. The only difference is when that doesn't work, they drop invincible ships to win the battle. This is not world of warcraft. Paying a little more for a ship, or having a few more skillpoints than a guy, should not make you invincible. A small gang of well flown ships can wipe out larger battleship gangs. I've seen it happen in blackops. A small fleet of well flown battleships can wipe out a larger fleet. You know what wipes out a titan fleet? MORE TITANS. You know what a small alliance wanting to move into 0.0 space to hold a small area can bring to fight those titans? NOTHING. So you either join a titan heavy alliance, or you just don't live in 0.0.
Dez Affinity
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#1520 - 2012-03-14 14:41:27 UTC
Andski wrote:
Hannott Thanos wrote:
Andski wrote:
Hannott Thanos wrote:
This is bullsh!t and you all know it. A titan should be able to track all ships. It's biggest, therefore it has to be best.

--
Sincerely, Death Star.


nope

sincerely, me


Someone did not get the joke? :)


i have a hangover so yeah i kinda missed it


Sat on eve-o drinkin' beer, posting on forums

we got a badass over here