These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev blog: Skill trading in New Eden

First post First post First post
Author
pajedas
Doomheim
#1861 - 2016-02-05 23:26:51 UTC
Has anyone done the math on how long will a new pilot take to train his SP's to 5.5m?

Basically the new players will have to train for 5-6 months before they can start buying/injecting skills.

So, is it really for the new players? Not so much as CCP's pocket.

🐇

Tyberius Franklin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1862 - 2016-02-05 23:28:57 UTC
pajedas wrote:
Has anyone done the math on how long will a new pilot take to train his SP's to 5.5m?

Basically the new players will have to train for 5-6 months before they can start buying/injecting skills.

So, is it really for the new players? Not so much as CCP's pocket.
A character can inject skills at any time, there is no minimum. The only limit is extracting which is the 5.5mill stated.
pajedas
Doomheim
#1863 - 2016-02-05 23:33:38 UTC
Tyberius Franklin wrote:
pajedas wrote:
Has anyone done the math on how long will a new pilot take to train his SP's to 5.5m?

Basically the new players will have to train for 5-6 months before they can start buying/injecting skills.

So, is it really for the new players? Not so much as CCP's pocket.
A character can inject skills at any time, there is no minimum. The only limit is extracting which is the 5.5mill stated.

Oops I just read that part over again, I guess I need to train up my skimming skills.

I stand by my greedy CCP comment though.

🐇

Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#1864 - 2016-02-05 23:38:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Moac Tor
Tyberius Franklin wrote:
Moac Tor wrote:
Natsuko Kanami wrote:
Natsuko Kanami wrote:
It's gonna be 1000 AUR. That way you buy a PLEX, convert it to 3500 AUR, buy 3 extractors, and have 500 AUR left over. Then you think to yourself "well, I have these 500 AUR left over, if I just buy another PLEX I'll have 4000 AUR and can buy 4 more, so I get one 'extra'". Milking 101.


Called it :D Obvious tactics are obvious.

I wonder if now the people who were claiming that this will be great for newbies and all us bitter old vets were just complaining for nothing still think this is going to help newbies.

Malcanis's Law comes to mind.
This isn't a case of Malcanis' law. The pricing helps no one really. The cost for reallocating or consolidating, 2 vet centric applications, is beyond my willingness to entertain and I doubt I'm the only one. They could still be useful in alt creation, but that parallels the expected benefit to new players, just with a known and IMHO higher than healthy cost.

So unless Malc's law was recently revised to "Expensive for everybody" this doesn't fit.

For big alliances and entrenched vets this will be easily affordable, for everyone else this will be prohibitive. Malcanis's Law applies perfectly.

And to make this gift to the big alliances the cost has been to knock down a fundamental pillar of the game.
Maekchu
Doomheim
#1865 - 2016-02-05 23:47:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Maekchu
This was never meant to be great for newbies just entering the game. This is still good for "newbies" who are maybe 8-10 months old, who can boost themselves over some SP hurdle with the ISK they've farmed.

Will this be abusable? While most scenarios people are crying about is not really an abuse or even something the abuser would profit from, it is still possible that the feature could be abused. But I'm sure CCP will monitor for exploits like any other exploit out there.

The facts are, that it is still much MUCH cheaper to buy a character off the bazaar. As well as, the free market should, in theory, counteract attempts on buying out SP on the market. Hopefully, this change will make people realize how pointless a metric for "power" SP actually are. If someone have subbed their account for 6 months longer than someone else, does that make them automatically better than the lower subbed player? And let's assume this actually was the case, is it fair to make characters more powerful, just based on the time they've subscribed? Isn't that basically P2W too?

SP is just a means to an end, but it doesn't tell you how good someone is at the game. More SP on your character does not mean you've "won" EvE more than someone else. It just means you can do more stuff. I supported this change from the start and personally I think it's great to see a method of accelerating the SP training, so people can be out in space doing more stuff. Compared to sitting in station or being offline, waiting for those skills to finish.
Corraidhin Farsaidh
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1866 - 2016-02-05 23:52:21 UTC
pajedas wrote:
...How can CCP even consider charging real money for something that was introduced as a way of improving content?...


It's not to improve content, it's to improve cashflow.
Tyberius Franklin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1867 - 2016-02-05 23:53:22 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:
Tyberius Franklin wrote:
Moac Tor wrote:
I wonder if now the people who were claiming that this will be great for newbies and all us bitter old vets were just complaining for nothing still think this is going to help newbies.

Malcanis's Law comes to mind.
This isn't a case of Malcanis' law. The pricing helps no one really. The cost for reallocating or consolidating, 2 vet centric applications, is beyond my willingness to entertain and I doubt I'm the only one. They could still be useful in alt creation, but that parallels the expected benefit to new players, just with a known and IMHO higher than healthy cost.

So unless Malc's law was recently revised to "Expensive for everybody" this doesn't fit.

For big alliances and entrenched vets this will be easily affordable, for everyone else this will be prohibitive. Malcanis's Law applies perfectly.

And to make this gift to the big alliances the cost has been to knock down a fundamental pillar of the game.
In terms of raw isk it's "affordable," in terms of estimated cost for effect it's not. Estimates are looking towards 1B isk for 1 mill SP. At alliance levels the costs are unable to be reconciled with the alliance level gains. At personal levels, between diminishing returns and cost, there is no actual point of triviality since prices for use approach 1B isk for 300k SP.

If you count it as a benefit that the entrenched can afford them as a commodity while having a further penalty on the already abysmal return then there's no avoiding Malcani's law with or without this since anything for isk will be able to be leveraged more by them.

But that distinction is pretty meaningless don't you think?
pajedas
Doomheim
#1868 - 2016-02-05 23:57:15 UTC  |  Edited by: pajedas
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
pajedas wrote:
...How can CCP even consider charging real money for something that was introduced as a way of improving content?...


It's not to improve content, it's to improve cashflow.

+1 for calling it like ya see it.

Just tired of people telling me they're doing me a favor and charging me for it.

*Why should I lose SP's if I pay $ for the extractor and then inject them into another area?

Should be 1:1 regardless. Say there are 100 trillion SP's total in Eve Online. Those were bought and paid for in way of subscriptions. Now they're saying those will simply be flushed down the toilet if a higher SP player uses them?

Does that make sense to anyone?

🐇

Leonardo Adami
Doomheim
#1869 - 2016-02-06 01:39:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Leonardo Adami
I was such a huge supporter for these. Now prices are out and I was completely wrong. Seriously F**k you CCP for lying to us saying these are for newbros which by the pricing it's clearly all to line your pockets. Seriously considering unsubbing my four accounts for you re-tarded marketing schemes and blatant bs.
Edwin Wyatt
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#1870 - 2016-02-06 01:58:37 UTC
If i cannot remove the skill book after reducing the SP to 0, than I see no point in wasting my money on this.
CCP has missed the mark from the players perspective.
all I see is another reason for a CC to be used to gain an advantage in the game.

Shame on you CCP, you can only milk the cow for so long.

Shova'k
The Bank Of Jita
#1871 - 2016-02-06 02:23:14 UTC
Mintoko wrote:
Shova'k wrote:
Mintoko wrote:
Shova'k wrote:
the people who whine this is pay to win are like terrorist they are stuck in their one sided belief no matter what any one tells them they will not change their belief. i made multiple posts point out that pay to win does not exist in even and pretty much cant. UNLESS CCP finds a way to directly copy experience and knowledge from players who have been around a while then upload that into new players for a FEE that would be the only way you could pay to win at eve and since that isnt possible yet lol. .



If the "whiners" are like terrorists in their one-sided belief, then what are you? Your belief that it's not pay to win is also one-sided and nothing anyone says will change your mind. So what are you?


your wrong cause it's not a belief its a proven fact by what happens in game all the time nice troll attempt tho.

also when do we get to see this skill trading thing in action on sisi so we can make sure its nice and balanced?


You're on one side and others are on the other side. It's one position or the other. It either is or it isn't. You can't dispute the logic, so you call me a troll?

In any issue, you as a supporter will call the opponent a whiner. If by some chance a change goes against you, you complain about the whiners always getting their way. It's always going to be about you and what you want. Everyone else is wrong.

Skill trading is already active on Sisi. Extractors are available in the exchange in packs of 1, 5, and 10.



i never once supported this or opposed it have said so many times nice try tho, and its not a side or belief when its simple logic backed by solid evidence of the game itself. this game has proven time and time again that SP dont matter when you dont know what your doing. the only time it really mattered was when the game first came out and no one had experience or skill at the game yet. no matter how you look at it this isnt any more pay to win then buying a character on the bazaar which also is not pay to win. you save time nothing more specially since you cant win eve like some one mentioned before the closest you can come to winning at eve is figureing out how to make so much isk chribba gets jealous, and all you really won is the ability to afford to try everything in eve and get bored faster. i mean there are people who posted videos of low sp mining alt's in a hulk taking out cruisers who can flip them.

as mentioned many times i do not support or oppose this system i just enjoy educated people on the facts they cant seem to comprehend. tbh they should allow the skill extractors at the cost of 1 bill isk worth of aurm let u remove 1 entire skill with it (fully remove as in not in your head at 0 even) but lose that sp for ever be nice for those of us who regret a few skills in the past lol.
Memphis Baas
#1872 - 2016-02-06 02:31:53 UTC
Edwin Wyatt wrote:
If i cannot remove the skill book after reducing the SP to 0, than I see no point in wasting my money on this.


The Patch Notes say that, as an added feature, they're letting us inject any skill book, regardless of prerequisites, so anyone could go to a school station, buy all the skills they need (they're probably thinking of introducing skill packs soon), and just inject away, basically ending up with "all skills at 0". Then all they have to do is set up their training queue to train prerequisites then skills then more prerequisites and more skills.

So there will be other people with a bunch of skills at 0, no worries. Extractor people won't be the only ones.

It frees newbies to let them go to school, inject a whole bunch of skill books, then head out to live in nullsec or wormhole space, and no longer be restricted by the need to visit high-sec schools periodically.
Shova'k
The Bank Of Jita
#1873 - 2016-02-06 02:53:35 UTC
one question since some one always finds a way to abuse stuff in this game.

Will the injectors account for allocated SP when doing the calculation for how much to add to their pool?
if not then people can just inject tons of injectors at 500 k then apply the sp later hope this wont be the case.
Tyberius Franklin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1874 - 2016-02-06 02:56:41 UTC
Shova'k wrote:
one question since some one always finds a way to abuse stuff in this game.

Will the injectors account for allocated SP when doing the calculation for how much to add to their pool?
if not then people can just inject tons of injectors at 500 k then apply the sp later hope this wont be the case.
They weren't on the test server, but this was confirmed by a dev to be a bug and should be counting unallocated SP.
beakerax
Pator Tech School
#1875 - 2016-02-06 03:01:19 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:
For big alliances and entrenched vets this will be easily affordable, for everyone else this will be prohibitive. Malcanis's Law applies perfectly.

they are more affordable (and more useful) for vets no matter what price they are
OldWolf69
EVE-RO
Goonswarm Federation
#1876 - 2016-02-06 03:04:38 UTC
Just Lol.
"Working as intended".
Grats CCp for a new troll on the playerbase.
galtest12345
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1877 - 2016-02-06 03:45:51 UTC  |  Edited by: galtest12345
People saying this "isn't for new people" because it's prohibitively expensive .. seriously, you think people can't afford 10-20 bucks to spend on a game in a month? Have you guys even seen any of the other online games out there and the amount of money people in general are quite happy to spend on a game they enjoy?

This system isn't intended for a "new person" to instantly buy themselves to 20 million skillpoints, 40million, etc., that would be very expensive, yes. It's intended for someone to have paid their sub and then think "I could buy a skill injector or two to help myself out this month with my spare cash" and they go and buy a plex, and get a couple injectors for it. It's not that expensive. If you guys think only rich people can spend ten bucks on a bit of 'get ahead' in an online game and are calling CCP names or bitching at them over it then you need to look out at the world a little.

I get it, no matter what price CCP chose you'd whine about it, I know, because "hur dur the EVE is falling, the EVE is falling!" but out here in the real world CCP have priced this very affordably.
Leonardo Adami
Doomheim
#1878 - 2016-02-06 03:59:06 UTC
galtest12345 wrote:
People saying this "isn't for new people" because it's prohibitively expensive .. seriously, you think people can't afford 10-20 bucks to spend on a game in a month? Have you guys even seen any of the other online games out there and the amount of money people in general are quite happy to spend on a game they enjoy?

This system isn't intended for a "new person" to instantly buy themselves to 20 million skillpoints, 40million, etc., that would be very expensive, yes. It's intended for someone to have paid their sub and then think "I could buy a skill injector or two to help myself out this month with my spare cash" and they go and buy a plex, and get a couple injectors for it. It's not that expensive. If you guys think only rich people can spend ten bucks on a bit of 'get ahead' in an online game and are calling CCP names or bitching at them over it then you need to look out at the world a little.

I get it, no matter what price CCP chose you'd whine about it, I know, because "hur dur the EVE is falling, the EVE is falling!" but out here in the real world CCP have priced this very affordably.



Ya this works in a free to play game not subscription based model. This is point blank a money grab from CCP no if's, an's, or but's. There isn't a right, wrong, left, or right, it's very clear cut. CCP is being greedy and lied to us period.
galtest12345
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#1879 - 2016-02-06 04:07:16 UTC
Leonardo Adami wrote:
galtest12345 wrote:
People saying this "isn't for new people" because it's prohibitively expensive .. seriously, you think people can't afford 10-20 bucks to spend on a game in a month? Have you guys even seen any of the other online games out there and the amount of money people in general are quite happy to spend on a game they enjoy?

This system isn't intended for a "new person" to instantly buy themselves to 20 million skillpoints, 40million, etc., that would be very expensive, yes. It's intended for someone to have paid their sub and then think "I could buy a skill injector or two to help myself out this month with my spare cash" and they go and buy a plex, and get a couple injectors for it. It's not that expensive. If you guys think only rich people can spend ten bucks on a bit of 'get ahead' in an online game and are calling CCP names or bitching at them over it then you need to look out at the world a little.

I get it, no matter what price CCP chose you'd whine about it, I know, because "hur dur the EVE is falling, the EVE is falling!" but out here in the real world CCP have priced this very affordably.



Ya this works in a free to play game not subscription based model. This is point blank a money grab from CCP no if's, an's, or but's. There isn't a right, wrong, left, or right, it's very clear cut. CCP is being greedy and lied to us period.



No, they didn't "lie to us" - it's priced cheap enough regardless of the subscription model or not. Subscription+plex is more than affordable and something many people already do for isk. There's nothing about a 999aurum extractor that's beyond some newbies budget. Face it, you wanted to hate this no matter what price they used.
Leonardo Adami
Doomheim
#1880 - 2016-02-06 04:22:01 UTC
galtest12345 wrote:
Leonardo Adami wrote:
galtest12345 wrote:
People saying this "isn't for new people" because it's prohibitively expensive .. seriously, you think people can't afford 10-20 bucks to spend on a game in a month? Have you guys even seen any of the other online games out there and the amount of money people in general are quite happy to spend on a game they enjoy?

This system isn't intended for a "new person" to instantly buy themselves to 20 million skillpoints, 40million, etc., that would be very expensive, yes. It's intended for someone to have paid their sub and then think "I could buy a skill injector or two to help myself out this month with my spare cash" and they go and buy a plex, and get a couple injectors for it. It's not that expensive. If you guys think only rich people can spend ten bucks on a bit of 'get ahead' in an online game and are calling CCP names or bitching at them over it then you need to look out at the world a little.

I get it, no matter what price CCP chose you'd whine about it, I know, because "hur dur the EVE is falling, the EVE is falling!" but out here in the real world CCP have priced this very affordably.



Ya this works in a free to play game not subscription based model. This is point blank a money grab from CCP no if's, an's, or but's. There isn't a right, wrong, left, or right, it's very clear cut. CCP is being greedy and lied to us period.



No, they didn't "lie to us" - it's priced cheap enough regardless of the subscription model or not. Subscription+plex is more than affordable and something many people already do for isk. There's nothing about a 999aurum extractor that's beyond some newbies budget. Face it, you wanted to hate this no matter what price they used.


lol, you should check my post history regarding this topic. I was one of the strongest supporters for it from the get go. The way they priced these extractors is a clear indicator that they're only after money and not really supporting newbros which is how they spun this originally. Due to the fact they priced it the way have + the spin for helping newbros = a flat lie to the player base.