These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Crime & Punishment

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Blowing up AFK miners. What do you think?

First post
Author
Areen Sassel
Dirac Angestun Gesept
#121 - 2016-06-11 01:37:59 UTC
Robertina Palazzo wrote:
People suck at pvp, so they look for targets that cannot fight back or at least allow an advantage they can live with.


Looking for targets that can't fight back sounds like excellent tactics to me, not "sucking".

I explore; my killboard is entirely red. Do I complain that the people who shot my eggshell explorers suck? No; they won and I lost. They're not idiots for finding the eggshell to shoot at.
Crinnfika
Doomheim
#122 - 2016-06-11 21:08:10 UTC  |  Edited by: Crinnfika
Well you lot are so quick to judge miners, yet are so ignorant of the reality of highsec mining.

On the subject of "mining afk"
Most highsec miners aren't truly afk, miners are however usually doing other tasks (i.e tabbed out or buried in various Eve windows) For example I spend my time mining buried in various market tabs researching where the best places to sell the ore I'm mining. And multitasking like this is important for profit since the low value of highsec ores means that the only way to make decent isk is to maximize time efficiency, which means multitasking whenever possible.
Most miners don't "mine afk," most miners do however "mine distracted."


"miners should watch dscan and local."
I keep seeing people in this thread saying "miners deserve this for not taking precautions." Look guys, getting ganked while mining is enormously rare. I've never been ganked while mining ever, and the last time my corp lost a miner was 2 months ago. Expecting miners to maintain vigilance for months with no threats in sight is unrealistic.

Mining afk/distracted is like speeding on the interstate, sure you could get pulled over for it but the chance of that happening is so low that you do it anyways, and if you do get pulled over you will just go back to speeding anyways because getting a ticket is a freak occurrence and probably won't happen again.
Ralph King-Griffin
New Eden Tech Support
#123 - 2016-06-11 21:15:01 UTC
^^ how to talk your way onto the list.
Dom Arkaral
Bannheim
Cuttlefish Collective
#124 - 2016-06-11 23:51:48 UTC
Crinnfika wrote:

and the last time my corp lost a miner was 2 months ago.

Your corp (RMS) lost a ship to CODE. at 19:44
You're a lying miner.

Quote:
oh but I have a powerful main somewhere

Well post on it or gtfo Lol

Tear Gatherer. Quebecker. Has no Honer. Salt Harvester.

Broadcast 4 Reps -- YOU ARE NOT ALONE, EVER

Instigator of the First ISD Thunderdome

CCL Loyalist

Galaxy Pig
New Order Logistics
CODE.
#125 - 2016-06-11 23:52:45 UTC
Crinnfika wrote:
Most [Highsec]miners don't "mine afk," most [Highsec]miners do however "mine distracted."[/i]


Fixed that for you.

Crinnfika wrote:
Expecting miners to maintain vigilance for months with no threats in sight is unrealistic. [/i]


Expecting to mine AFK (or whatever you call it) and not occasionally die horribly is unrealistic.

Highsec is owned by players now. Systems 0.5-1.0 are New Order Territory. All miners and other residents of Highsec must obey The Code. Mining without a permit is dangerous and harmful to the EVE community. See www.MinerBumping.com

Areen Sassel
Dirac Angestun Gesept
#126 - 2016-06-12 15:01:22 UTC
Crinnfika wrote:
Well you lot are so quick to judge miners, yet are so ignorant of the reality of highsec mining.


I suppose that's an improvement on the OP calling us liars when we say we don't do it. Thank you for believing us. :-)

Quote:
"miners should watch dscan and local."
I keep seeing people in this thread saying "miners deserve this for not taking precautions." Look guys, getting ganked while mining is enormously rare. I've never been ganked while mining ever, and the last time my corp lost a miner was 2 months ago. Expecting miners to maintain vigilance for months with no threats in sight is unrealistic.


Like the guy upthread who genuinely enjoys mining, you don't share the OP's complaint. _If_ miners find ganking is a constant problem, _then_ they should watch Local. If it's not, then where's the beef?
Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#127 - 2016-06-12 18:27:19 UTC
Crinnfika wrote:

Most highsec miners aren't truly afk, miners are however usually doing other tasks (i.e tabbed out or buried in various Eve windows) For example I spend my time mining buried in various market tabs researching where the best places to sell the ore I'm mining. And multitasking like this is important for profit since the low value of highsec ores means that the only way to make decent isk is to maximize time efficiency, which means multitasking whenever possible.
Most miners don't "mine afk," most miners do however "mine distracted."
Mining distracted is as bad as not being at the keyboard, if you're tabbed out you're essentially AFK because you're not paying attention to the client.

AFK not only stands for Away From Keyboard, it also stands for A Free Kill.

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

Black Pedro
Mine.
#128 - 2016-06-12 18:55:59 UTC
Jonah Gravenstein wrote:
Crinnfika wrote:

Most highsec miners aren't truly afk, miners are however usually doing other tasks (i.e tabbed out or buried in various Eve windows) For example I spend my time mining buried in various market tabs researching where the best places to sell the ore I'm mining. And multitasking like this is important for profit since the low value of highsec ores means that the only way to make decent isk is to maximize time efficiency, which means multitasking whenever possible.
Most miners don't "mine afk," most miners do however "mine distracted."
Mining distracted is as bad as not being at the keyboard, if you're tabbed out you're essentially AFK because you're not paying attention to the client.

AFK not only stands for Away From Keyboard, it also stands for A Free Kill.
I know right? Can you imagine if a goal tender got bored and wandered off during a match? "Sorry coach, the ball hadn't been near my net in a while, so I decided to multitask and go send an email to my agent."

By all means, make the calculation that mining AFK is more advantageous for you than staying alert and at your keyboard. But don't complain that the game is broken or unfair if you find yourself exploded and in a fresh clone when you come back. You made a choice, took a risk and now you have to live with the consequences. That's the game.
Crinnfika
Doomheim
#129 - 2016-06-12 20:13:32 UTC
Black Pedro wrote:

By all means, make the calculation that mining AFK is more advantageous for you than staying alert and at your keyboard. But don't complain that the game is broken or unfair if you find yourself exploded and in a fresh clone when you come back. You made a choice, took a risk and now you have to live with the consequences. That's the game.

I complained about nothing. I merely posted because I am peeved by the amount of willful ignorance and strawman rhetoric being displayed in this thread.


Also being alert is meaningless. Whether you get ganked as a highsec miner is determined by where you choose to fly and what barge you are using. I fly a skiff in backwater systems out in the middle of nowhere and I never see anything more threatening than a astero. But I know miners who never under any circumstance afk or tab out who got/get ganked almost weekly simply because they choose to mine on a pipe or even worse near jita.
Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#130 - 2016-06-12 21:27:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Jonah Gravenstein
Crinnfika wrote:
I complained about nothing. I merely posted because I am peeved by the amount of willful ignorance and strawman rhetoric being displayed in this thread.
Wilful ignorance means ignoring any input that contradict one’s inner model of reality. The, all too, common belief that hisec is a safe area to do stuff afk or without paying attention to your surroundings, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary, is a prime example of it, some people call it premeditated stupidity.

Quote:
Also being alert is meaningless. Whether you get ganked as a highsec miner is determined by where you choose to fly and what barge you are using. I fly a skiff in backwater systems out in the middle of nowhere and I never see anything more threatening than a astero. But I know miners who never under any circumstance afk or tab out who got/get ganked almost weekly simply because they choose to mine on a pipe or even worse near jita.
While you're correct about the ship you fly affecting the chances of getting ganked, the location is not so important unless you're mining in a system where gankers ply their trade. I mine one jump from a major hisec trade pipe chokepoint, not once has anybody attempted to gank me, probably because there's far more lucrative pickings next door in the form of freighters; I start D-scanning when local shows gankers in system and dock up if a gaggle of Catalysts comes within 10AU of me, they ain't after me but better safe than sorry.

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

Crinnfika
Doomheim
#131 - 2016-06-12 22:09:48 UTC
Jonah Gravenstein wrote:
Crinnfika wrote:
I complained about nothing. I merely posted because I am peeved by the amount of willful ignorance and strawman rhetoric being displayed in this thread.
Willful ignorance means ignoring any input that contradict one’s inner model of reality. The, all too, common belief that hisec is a safe area to do stuff afk or without paying attention to your surroundings, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary, is a prime example of it, some people call it premeditated stupidity.

The willful ignorance comment was directed at the people that like to invent ridiculous caricatures of miners just so that they can claim some (non-existent) moral high ground.

Quote:
While you're correct about the ship you fly affecting the chances of getting ganked, the location is not so important unless you're mining in a system where gankers ply their trade. I mine one jump from a major hisec trade pipe chokepoint, not once has anybody attempted to gank me, probably because there's far more lucrative pickings next door in the form of freighters; I start D-scanning when local shows gankers in system and dock up if a gaggle of Catalysts comes within 10AU of me, they ain't after me but better safe than sorry.

You say that location is not so important and then proceed to give a example of location being important.
Dom Arkaral
Bannheim
Cuttlefish Collective
#132 - 2016-06-12 22:40:15 UTC
Crinnfika wrote:
Jonah Gravenstein wrote:
Crinnfika wrote:
I complained about nothing. I merely posted because I am peeved by the amount of willful ignorance and strawman rhetoric being displayed in this thread.
Willful ignorance means ignoring any input that contradict one’s inner model of reality. The, all too, common belief that hisec is a safe area to do stuff afk or without paying attention to your surroundings, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary, is a prime example of it, some people call it premeditated stupidity.

The willful ignorance comment was directed at the people that like to invent ridiculous caricatures of miners just so that they can claim some (non-existent) moral high ground.

Quote:
While you're correct about the ship you fly affecting the chances of getting ganked, the location is not so important unless you're mining in a system where gankers ply their trade. I mine one jump from a major hisec trade pipe chokepoint, not once has anybody attempted to gank me, probably because there's far more lucrative pickings next door in the form of freighters; I start D-scanning when local shows gankers in system and dock up if a gaggle of Catalysts comes within 10AU of me, they ain't after me but better safe than sorry.

You say that location is not so important and then proceed to give a example of location being important.

just pay attention (by not being afk) and you'll survive
You sound like a mole with all your complaining Lol

Tear Gatherer. Quebecker. Has no Honer. Salt Harvester.

Broadcast 4 Reps -- YOU ARE NOT ALONE, EVER

Instigator of the First ISD Thunderdome

CCL Loyalist

Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#133 - 2016-06-12 22:54:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Jonah Gravenstein
Crinnfika wrote:
The willful ignorance comment was directed at the people that like to invent ridiculous caricatures of miners just so that they can claim some (non-existent) moral high ground.
That swings both ways.

I directed my comment in the opposite direction, namely those who invent ridiculous caricatures of hisec PvPers so that they can claim a non-existent moral high ground.

Quote:
You say that location is not so important and then proceed to give a example of location being important.
I provided an example that directly contradicts your statement, which was:
Quote:
But I know miners who never under any circumstance afk or tab out who got/get ganked almost weekly simply because they choose to mine on a pipe or even worse near jita.
The minutiae of my example, i.e. there's better targets next door, is neither here nor there; my point remains, you can mine on a pipe without getting ganked.

As I said, I chose to mine on a pipe and have never been shot at by gankers; maintaining situational awareness or vigilance as you called it, despite your claims to the contrary, does help to prevent explosive pod removal accidents.

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

Laken Starr
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#134 - 2016-06-17 09:40:30 UTC
1. The moment you undock, imagine that you have a target on your back. You won't be wrong.

2. AFK miners generally turn into unsubbed miners. If you're not doing something you enjoy, what's the point? Being a newbie isn't an excuse - running career agents or doing exploration will net you far more than the feeble isk from high-sec mining.

3. If you do actually want to mine, make it an active process - there's quite a bit you can be doing while you're sitting there mining - updating skill queues, managing PI, station trading, Project Discovery (I think, I haven't actually tried this out yet). Better yet, mine in a fleet and BS with your mates on Teamspeak.
Glengrant
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#135 - 2016-06-17 12:56:05 UTC
You are *not* playing solo. You're in a virtual word with several hundred thousand, tens of thousands are online with you at the same time.

Not joining a corp or at ĺeast getting aquainted with some other pilots is - sorry - being stupid. Or to me more polite :-) - extremely unwise and ill-informed.
You don't first learn the game and then *join* a corp - you best learn the game by joining a half-way decent corp ASAP.
While there is no shortage of pilots who'll shoot you on sight - there's also plenty who will help you.

Also it doesn't matter that you know nobody in RL that plays EVE - it matters that you make friends in EVE.

CCP could easily have made it impossible to attack other pilots in high-sec. They didn't. They made it costly - but possible.
Most of the time you'll be almost safe in high-sec - sometimes you won't.
That's not a bug - it's a feature. It's exactly why EVE does not become boring,

Don't sit solo in a mining belt and go afk.

Also don't make the common mistake of waiting to get particular ships to feel safe. There is no safe ship. A cruiser or destroyer is not safer than a frigate. It all depends on what ships you encounter and what the numbers of pilots on your and their side are and how good everybody is.

Don't sit bored in a belt. Do missions instead. Again – get into a corp right away. If it doesn't work out - join another corp until you find an ok one.
Mining can be fun, if you have some corp buddies in voice chat and especially if you do it in low sec and a ganker might arrive at any second. Have a mining compeitton. Make it fun.

But you don't have to mine at all. Do missions, do faction warfare, become a trader, find something that doesn't make you want to be afk for hours.

Really, joining a good corp makes all the difference. You have people to chat with, who can give you advice and more likely that not have stuff in corp hangars for you to use freely (plenty of mods usually for the taking, even free frigs some times - but depends on corp policies). At the very least they'll provide you with all the information you need to become better *much* *much* faster than if you try to do it all on your own. We're talking hours and days instead of days and weeks.
You'll be in cruisers and BS much faster while in a corp.

If you need tips or have burnnig questions feel free to contact me. I like to help - but you won't get my sympathies for getting ganked while mining afk.

And - sure - CCP looses the occasional customer to high-sec gankers. But they have retained so many more players who enjoy a game that is different from the usual glorified LAN games that dare to call themselves MMOs.

The trolls won't care about you leaving. They use tears for fuel.

New Eden is openly marketed as a harsh environment. That was truthful advertisement. But you'll also meet plenty of nice people who help each other out all the time. All the more meaningful in a harsh environment.

Posts like yours have been posted for over a decade. High-sec ist still a police-after-the-fact - not prevent - area.
EVE is supposed to be dangerous. The losses hurt and that's what makes the game all that more exciting.

I'm not a big fan of high-sec gankers - but I do think that they are a valid part of EVE and at the end of the day provide the service or making EVE feel a little dangerous everywhere (though high-sec is not *that* dangerous - it's still mostly safe-ish most of the time).

Join a corp – learn how to fight - get into a gang with some friends (who might be RL countries away) - then shoot as many gankers as you like. It's fun. Guaranteed. :-)

Blood Retributor wrote:

Being new to Eve I admit that I do not know a lot of things about its concept. And maybe it is a game for masochists? My question to you veterans is: would you be willing to let the AFK (on and off) loner noobs alone in hi-sec to give them a chance to start having fun in Eve getting a fighting chance againt gankers that enjoy
Quote:
nothing quite like the feeling of blowing up a ship that's worth 10 times your entire wealth in EVE using a cheap low-skilled Catalyst.
? Just curious Lol.


The answer to this question is that most of the veteran players are not your problem. They are either out in null-sec or have otherwise better things to do than gank your afk mining ship.

But some pilots (both veteran and new-ish) will gank you anywhere under all circumstances. And no appeal to their genereous nature will help you. They'll double-gank you instead.

Welcome to EVE
(seriously - join a corp - TODAY!!!)
Nofear Alt
Forum Alts Anonymous
#136 - 2016-06-18 17:51:11 UTC
Blood Retributor wrote:


Thanks to players like you I gather pieces of valuable information that will help me enjoy Eve, not get frustrated with it.

Lots of the stuff you mentioned above I have no idea how to do, but your suggestions are a good starting point for me!

More reading to do Big smile!


As much as I hate CODEs play style, they have certainly brought something to hi sec that has greatly changed the dynamic - it makes you think about what you are doing, your fits, about not going afk (and afk mining and mining botting has been a major issue within Eve)

There are some other options for you to make ISK....try some different things. Mining is one of the least fun things in Eve to do and it's not particularly profittable. Also, as others have said, look for a corp - your fun will increase 10x just by doing that!

Alt and proud

Dsparil
SUNDERING
Goonswarm Federation
#137 - 2016-06-23 03:20:31 UTC
Blowing up AFK miners is boring. It's ganking the ones that are at the keyboard and griefing them afterwards and making them cry in local that's fun.
Morgan Agrivar
Doomheim
#138 - 2016-06-23 11:07:13 UTC
Just ganked a Venture in 0.6 with an Atron on a low sp alt.

It felt good.

And I think he cussed me out in Spanish...it has been 25 years since I took it in high school.
Elliniel Anat'al'Ardon
Hallowed Antiquity
#139 - 2016-08-19 11:49:17 UTC
Nofear Alt wrote:
Mining is one of the least fun things in Eve to do and it's not particularly profittable.


My wallet highly disagrees with your ass-esment of mining not being profittable and it's fun as well.

So please, just because you like to **** bears on the highway, doesn't mean everyone else does too.

Ofcourse, unlike the OP, I don't mine in High-sec, never have, never will.


Dom Arkaral
Bannheim
Cuttlefish Collective
#140 - 2016-08-19 12:06:26 UTC
Elliniel Anat'al'Ardon wrote:
Nofear Alt wrote:
Mining is one of the least fun things in Eve to do and it's not particularly profittable.


My wallet highly disagrees with your ass-esment of mining not being profittable and it's fun as well.

So please, just because you like to **** bears on the highway, doesn't mean everyone else does too.

Ofcourse, unlike the OP, I don't mine in High-sec, never have, never will.



Well not every miner is aware that null has better everything lmao.
And most miners are scared of other players, and/or don't care about joining an alliance somewhere where isk flows
30m an hour is enough in their eyes XD

Tear Gatherer. Quebecker. Has no Honer. Salt Harvester.

Broadcast 4 Reps -- YOU ARE NOT ALONE, EVER

Instigator of the First ISD Thunderdome

CCL Loyalist