These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev Blog: Exploring The Character Bazaar & Skill Trading

First post First post First post
Author
General Lootit
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#4201 - 2015-10-21 10:38:20 UTC  |  Edited by: General Lootit
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Lordy, Mr Dave, I am beginning to suspect that you are a 24 hour a day typing bot :)

Keep up the good fight.


it's threads like this that remind me why i go to reddit rather than eve-o to discuss ideas, to be honest. (more dev replies, for a start)


That the devs respond more outside of their own ingame forum, is, bad, bad, bad.

When it comes to public relations, CCP remind me of the old John Cleese, 'how not to do it' management educational films.

Reddit is better because of design of comments which allow to popup most popular opinion. If devs implement something like this here then many people will blame them on wrapping votes.
Josef Djugashvilis
#4202 - 2015-10-21 10:46:44 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Lordy, Mr Dave, I am beginning to suspect that you are a 24 hour a day typing bot :)

Keep up the good fight.


it's threads like this that remind me why i go to reddit rather than eve-o to discuss ideas, to be honest. (more dev replies, for a start)


That the devs respond more outside of their own ingame forum, is, bad, bad, bad.

When it comes to public relations, CCP remind me of the old John Cleese, 'how not to do it' management educational films.



to be fair, reddit is a better source of eve info all around. all i have to do is check the top threads on reddit rather than checking F&I to figure out if there are any new stickies, devblogs to see if there are any of those that are new, eve news if there's anything in there, etc.

it's all in one place; the front page.


Does this not rather suggest that CCP need to revamp the ingame forum site?

This is not a signature.

Dave Stark
#4203 - 2015-10-21 10:50:19 UTC
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Lordy, Mr Dave, I am beginning to suspect that you are a 24 hour a day typing bot :)

Keep up the good fight.


it's threads like this that remind me why i go to reddit rather than eve-o to discuss ideas, to be honest. (more dev replies, for a start)


That the devs respond more outside of their own ingame forum, is, bad, bad, bad.

When it comes to public relations, CCP remind me of the old John Cleese, 'how not to do it' management educational films.



to be fair, reddit is a better source of eve info all around. all i have to do is check the top threads on reddit rather than checking F&I to figure out if there are any new stickies, devblogs to see if there are any of those that are new, eve news if there's anything in there, etc.

it's all in one place; the front page.


Does this not rather suggest that CCP need to revamp the ingame forum site?


not really, i still wouldn't use eve-o as much as reddit. even if the layout matched reddit it'd still be strangled by moderation. not that i'm saying the moderation is bad here (far from it). ccp are obligated to moderate it - which can be stifling to discussion. reddit will never suffer from that issue.
Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#4204 - 2015-10-21 10:54:45 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
not really, i still wouldn't use eve-o as much as reddit.

Is it possible to use reddit any more than your useing eve-o atm?
Dave Stark
#4205 - 2015-10-21 10:57:02 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
not really, i still wouldn't use eve-o as much as reddit.

Is it possible to use reddit any more than your useing eve-o atm?


oh, i'm sorry. did you run out of actual points to make?
Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#4206 - 2015-10-21 11:15:34 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Josef Djugashvilis wrote:


That the devs respond more outside of their own ingame forum, is, bad, bad, bad.

When it comes to public relations, CCP remind me of the old John Cleese, 'how not to do it' management educational films.



to be fair, reddit is a better source of eve info all around. all i have to do is check the top threads on reddit rather than checking F&I to figure out if there are any new stickies, devblogs to see if there are any of those that are new, eve news if there's anything in there, etc.

it's all in one place; the front page.


Does this not rather suggest that CCP need to revamp the ingame forum site?


not really, i still wouldn't use eve-o as much as reddit. even if the layout matched reddit it'd still be strangled by moderation. not that i'm saying the moderation is bad here (far from it). ccp are obligated to moderate it - which can be stifling to discussion. reddit will never suffer from that issue.


Actually it is one more sign which shows where EVE is going if CCP employees discuss more on reddit than here. They should fix this one then, either make same outlay as reddit or find some other solution...

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Dave Stark
#4207 - 2015-10-21 11:24:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Dave Stark
"eve is dying because people use other places to discuss the game"

probably doesn't help that unlike reddit, eve-o is blocked at work for a lot of people. no amount of "new layout" will help that. as evidenced by almost every first comment in a reddit thread that links back here says "can some one paste the text so i can read it at work please?"
Corraidhin Farsaidh
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#4208 - 2015-10-21 11:26:13 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
...stuff...


The problem I see with TSP being used in rental (and there's no way to stop that if it's a tradeable commodity) is the newer less capable and/or space rich players will be tempted to just harvest their own SP meaning they then get 'left behind' as they see it.

I notice from skipreading the thread now and then that no goons have denied they will attempt to control the market on SP ;) As I have said before they would be stupid not to.


and that's different to them just selling the SP to pay the rental bill if the landlords say "carry on paying your rent in isk"?


You can earn ISK in many ways, you can only gain SP personally with time.
Dave Stark
#4209 - 2015-10-21 11:31:34 UTC
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
...stuff...


The problem I see with TSP being used in rental (and there's no way to stop that if it's a tradeable commodity) is the newer less capable and/or space rich players will be tempted to just harvest their own SP meaning they then get 'left behind' as they see it.

I notice from skipreading the thread now and then that no goons have denied they will attempt to control the market on SP ;) As I have said before they would be stupid not to.


and that's different to them just selling the SP to pay the rental bill if the landlords say "carry on paying your rent in isk"?


You can earn ISK in many ways, you can only gain SP personally with time.


or by purchasing it from the market.
afkalt
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#4210 - 2015-10-21 11:33:48 UTC  |  Edited by: afkalt
Rawthorm wrote:
Levi Belvar wrote:
Dave,

Game as it is now , No skillpoint trading in it.

rent 3 bill

because we protected you against xyz you pay us 3 bill tribute this month also as you losses would of been far greater
There is no skillpoints in this senario so you bank the extra cash, distribute it, buy minerals - There is no instant character progression it doesnt exist.


Game with skillpoint trading

because we protected you against xyz you pay us 5 mill TSP tribute this month also as you losses would of been far greater.

Now times this on how ever many they could use this concept on
Right we have 80 mill is TSP this month in the kittty, we can use this to create a new logi wing in flashjacks crew.


You realize that even now in the scenario you talk about, they could have just gone to the character bazaar and bought a bunch of new logi pilots just the same right? .


Only if they are there. This is a key facet you're all (probably deliberately) missing. There is a finite supply. Furthermore the bazaar cannot react to a balance or meta shift instantly. Toons take time to grow, overall SP gain is tempered by the existing stats limiting how fast it can be grown because the core skills are off map from the ship and weapon skills, for example. If tomorrow suddenly maels were the go-to line ship, there wouldn't be a flood of those perfect pilots on the market overnight, it would take time.

These packs though, allow focused min/maxing to harvest the most SP possible on a single map and dump it elsewhere, they also mean that large blocs could react instantly to a new meta, if they so they choose.

Today, there's absolutely no way possible for me or anyone else to roll up to the bazaar and walk out with 50 sabre pilots tomorrow. Once this goes live, I can spit them out this afternoon, never mind tomorrow.

And don't give me cost, large blocs reimburse caps and supers, if you think they can't and won't spring a couple of hundred billion to hit the ground running on a new meta, well then you must be new here. Further undermining the cost argument is the "newbie tool" fallacy - and if it's not affordable for newbies, what's the goddamned point of all this.

If a newbie can afford it, people like me and others can afford to burn them for funsies.


edit: Oh and Dave, reddit is just an echo chamber for this, there's a serious and dedicated downvote campaign if any dares speak against it.
Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#4211 - 2015-10-21 11:43:56 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
"eve is dying because people use other places to discuss the game"

probably doesn't help that unlike reddit, eve-o is blocked at work for a lot of people. no amount of "new layout" will help that. as evidenced by almost every first comment in a reddit thread that links back here says "can some one paste the text so i can read it at work please?"


Please stop twisting out what I have said. Oh wait you are doing it for last 150 pages no matter it was already pointed out.

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#4212 - 2015-10-21 11:44:47 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
...stuff...


The problem I see with TSP being used in rental (and there's no way to stop that if it's a tradeable commodity) is the newer less capable and/or space rich players will be tempted to just harvest their own SP meaning they then get 'left behind' as they see it.

I notice from skipreading the thread now and then that no goons have denied they will attempt to control the market on SP ;) As I have said before they would be stupid not to.


and that's different to them just selling the SP to pay the rental bill if the landlords say "carry on paying your rent in isk"?


You can earn ISK in many ways, you can only gain SP personally with time.


or by purchasing it from the market.


You mean purchase char from the bazaar? As you cannot buy sp at the moment silly :)

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Dave Stark
#4213 - 2015-10-21 11:45:10 UTC
Don ZOLA wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
"eve is dying because people use other places to discuss the game"

probably doesn't help that unlike reddit, eve-o is blocked at work for a lot of people. no amount of "new layout" will help that. as evidenced by almost every first comment in a reddit thread that links back here says "can some one paste the text so i can read it at work please?"


Please stop twisting out what I have said. Oh wait you are doing it for last 150 pages no matter it was already pointed out.



i haven't twisted anything.

reddit will still be more popular than eve-o due to the very fact that most people simply cannot access it as easily as reddit regardless of layout.
Pinkylein
No Vacancies
No Vacancies.
#4214 - 2015-10-21 11:45:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Pinkylein
First i do not support this idea at all, as probably most ppl already covered all parts of what it brings with it in negative effects towards other players.

"One guy beeing happy about Command Ship V" ... the other one "just bought it 5 min ago" ...

In case it will be placed, i would suggest an alternative ... something like "trying to extract SP from your toon results in a chance-based success". Best would be like the chance of getting an escalation out of one of the HS Combat sites into DED sites, or even better the chance to get a faction spawn, after grinding ore belts".

If only every 20th SP extraction try with reduced outcome ofc, would be successful, you would probably rip a 100M SP char for getting like 1M SP out. They would probably worth like 20B ISK ... but i doubt ppl will invest alot to push their skills. I still don't support the idea ... but in worst case, if it gets implemented, it should be that ineffective, that only 5% of all players even consider doing it, and from those 5% maybe 2% are really going for it.

I know you can buy alts, and i know tons of ppl who bought chars to have something ready. But mostly those are ppl, that already know how painful skilling can be and how happy you are and thankful for many months of patience to finally fly a ship you wanted for so long. And mostly those alts that are bought, are actually JF-alts, Industrial alts, or things ... that only come online once a day for 5min.

But if you would implement a system, that undermines ppl's willingness and patience to invest days, weeks, months and years to get finally into a ship, so thatt would result in like having birthday and christmas at one day ... by giving other ppl the opportunity to push their toons in exactly those ships in minutes .... that would be such a punsh into everyones face, that many people will probably stop playing as the ONLY big value ... "TIME" became totally meaningless in this game.


Pinky
Dave Stark
#4215 - 2015-10-21 11:46:19 UTC
Don ZOLA wrote:
You mean purchase char from the bazaar? As you cannot buy sp at the moment silly :)


no, i mean from the market.

we're talking about a hypothetical where this is already in the game. you'd have known that if you'd have read the thread before posting.
Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#4216 - 2015-10-21 11:52:14 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
"eve is dying because people use other places to discuss the game"

probably doesn't help that unlike reddit, eve-o is blocked at work for a lot of people. no amount of "new layout" will help that. as evidenced by almost every first comment in a reddit thread that links back here says "can some one paste the text so i can read it at work please?"


Please stop twisting out what I have said. Oh wait you are doing it for last 150 pages no matter it was already pointed out.



i haven't twisted anything.

reddit will still be more popular than eve-o due to the very fact that most people simply cannot access it as easily as reddit regardless of layout.


Of course you did. I never said eve is dying because of people using other places to discuss the game. Read my post again. Beside that you twistied every comment possible to twist in previous 200+ pages...

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Dave Stark
#4217 - 2015-10-21 11:56:21 UTC
Don ZOLA wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
"eve is dying because people use other places to discuss the game"

probably doesn't help that unlike reddit, eve-o is blocked at work for a lot of people. no amount of "new layout" will help that. as evidenced by almost every first comment in a reddit thread that links back here says "can some one paste the text so i can read it at work please?"


Please stop twisting out what I have said. Oh wait you are doing it for last 150 pages no matter it was already pointed out.



i haven't twisted anything.

reddit will still be more popular than eve-o due to the very fact that most people simply cannot access it as easily as reddit regardless of layout.


Of course you did. I never said eve is dying because of people using other places to discuss the game. Read my post again. Beside that you twistied every comment possible to twist in previous 200+ pages...


once more - it doesn't matter if eve-o gets a facelift, people will still go to reddit to post and the devs will follow them there as it'll be the place with the most feedback.

this will happen because reddit is more accessible to people than eve-o is. as i pointed out, every time a devblog or thread like this is crossposted to eve the first comments are usually asking for the text body to be pasted in to a comment as they can't follow the link here due to filters and such like.

now, you can discuss the point or carry on crying that i paraphrased you.
Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#4218 - 2015-10-21 11:58:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Moac Tor
afkalt wrote:
[edit: Oh and Dave, reddit is just an echo chamber for this, there's a serious and dedicated downvote campaign if any dares speak against it.

I agree, redit falls into the trap of a lot of social media. You don't get any or much intelligent debate, but instead it turns into an echo chamber in which anyone who doesn't toe the line gets downvoted and shouted down.

Also I find redit to be comprised of mainly of what seems like entitled 12 year olds.

And the big thing of course is that they are not all active subscribers wheras in the eve forums they are.
Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#4219 - 2015-10-21 11:59:43 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
You mean purchase char from the bazaar? As you cannot buy sp at the moment silly :)


no, i mean from the market.

we're talking about a hypothetical where this is already in the game. you'd have known that if you'd have read the thread before posting.


Of course it has not been talked about a hypothetical since he obviously wrote the state which it is now. SP comes over time.

So pleas,e in order to prove what you said is correct please show me where i can go to buy 300mil sp straight away. I have both isk and cash ready.
Thanks in advance.

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Dave Stark
#4220 - 2015-10-21 12:02:14 UTC
Don ZOLA wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
You mean purchase char from the bazaar? As you cannot buy sp at the moment silly :)


no, i mean from the market.

we're talking about a hypothetical where this is already in the game. you'd have known that if you'd have read the thread before posting.


Of course it has not been talked about a hypothetical since he obviously wrote the state which it is now. SP comes over time.

So pleas,e in order to prove what you said is correct please show me where i can go to buy 300mil sp straight away. I have both isk and cash ready.
Thanks in advance.


he started his post with "The problem I see with TSP being used in rental", so clearly he was speaking about the hypothetical where this is already in the game.

as to where you can buy 300m SP; here