These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev Blog: Exploring The Character Bazaar & Skill Trading

First post First post First post
Author
Dave stark
#2441 - 2015-10-17 10:38:49 UTC
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)


oh right when you said "massive income" i thought you were using it to make pure profit rather than offsetting the cost of the subscription.
Ima Wreckyou
The Conference Elite
Safety.
#2442 - 2015-10-17 10:42:34 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)


oh right when you said "massive income" i thought you were using it to make pure profit rather than offsetting the cost of the subscription.

The "massive income" was in the context of the pack consumer IIRC, since PLEX prices will skyrocket and a new player will not be able to get a pack or a PLEX for ISK.
General Lootit
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#2443 - 2015-10-17 10:44:20 UTC
Gully Alex Foyle wrote:
General Lootit wrote:
159Pinky wrote:
Kitagawa Mika wrote:
Really cool idea, would love to see this implemented sooner rather than later. This is a good way to help new players and to make eve a viable option for new players. As it stands now, someone coming in to EVE as a new player the skill system and required time must be really daunting. I understand that older players don't like change, but I see only upside... So I welcome this idea with open arms to insure the progress and success of EVE going forward.


So, where will new players get the isk to buy this? Not by playing cause it'll be expensive. So they'll have to buy plex with real money. If you feel like this "pay to play" is good, then yeah: this is good for new players.

I can afford that. In FW earning rate is about 75kk per hour on trial account. So if Packet will be cost around 1/4 of PLEX (assuming that farming rate is 2000k SP per month so 500k SP is 1/4 of month) I need 4 hour to buy Packet which worth 1 week of traning.
I believe it will cost less. If people sell SP from their alts, they don't necessarily need to get the 'farming' SP/PLEX rate, because they'd pay the PLEX (or sub) anyway to actually play with their alts.

Not saying 'SP you don't need is free' (like 'minerals you mine are free' LOL), but it's certainly worth less than a full PLEX per month.

Market will show.
Estevan Andrard
Doomheim
#2444 - 2015-10-17 11:00:11 UTC
Daniela Doran wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Laodell wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Maraner wrote:
Our CSM have come out so far universally against it, but you put up the thread anyway.


http://crossingzebras.com/skillpoint-trading/

afraid not, gorksi is in favour for example.



A single CSM a majority does not make.



i'm aware but even one supporting it means that the csm are not "universally against it" as you said.


Which means that CCP is longer functioning in unison and is becoming divided. Which is not good for other reasons. Hopefully the majority with eve best interest in mind would prevail and axe this cancerous idea before it manifest itself into the actually game. If it does then Eve would slowly but surely die.

Is there a time table when this is suppose to hit or is this still up for debate?


CSM is not part of CCP, it is a separate entity said to represent the players. Which anyone following their public presence may dubt they actually represent all kinds of players.

CCP themselves, for better or worse, usually take action in a certain way despite player whine or apocaliptic thinking. At least that gives hope that this idea if implemented, wont actually be so harmful as it could in the hands of a company like blizzard or Arena.

If con is the opposite of pro, then is Congress the opposite of progress?

Daniela Doran
Doomheim
#2445 - 2015-10-17 11:02:39 UTC  |  Edited by: Daniela Doran
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)


deleted!!
General Lootit
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#2446 - 2015-10-17 11:03:00 UTC  |  Edited by: General Lootit
Mag's wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
Until someone counters them with some reasonable explanation I will stand by the fact that this is easily the worst decision ever since it will change fundamentals of the game for unknown expectations without helping more than minor percent of the players.


this is one for when you get back then, Don.

let's start at the beginning.

What fundamentals are being changed?

buying/selling SP? no. we're already doing that with the character bazaar.
bypassing the skill training system? no. we're already doing that with the charcter bazaar.
"now we can get characters with 400m sp" - so what problem does that cause?
Dave I'm rather amazed at your posting on this regard. You are quite a level headed chap and clued on in many respects.
But I feel you're dismissing facts and inventing your own to fit your stance, in this instance.

We do not buy SP, we buy characters with all the baggage associated with them. This is why many of us are OK with the bazaar.
It does not bypass the training system, as those characters had to be trained over time with the normal mechanics. The speed at which they gain that SP has a ceiling.

The fundamental difference is now we will be able to buy raw SP and inject directly. How you cannot see the difference, is rather puzzling to me.
Buying raw SP is bypassing the training system for characters being injected. If I train for the first year 2 characters, then move the SP from one to the other, that's almost doubling the speed of one character. Not possible right now, so a fundamental change.

As far as 400m characters is concerned. I personally don't think this game will benefit in the long run, from the 'I want it now' crowd. If you don't see an issue with that, OK fine. But I do. For instance, FOTM is a thing and will not improve with this change.

I'm not going to argue the point with you, I've had enough of the topic. I dislike the idea and the blog just seems off to me somehow. I'm not sure why and maybe it was my initial thoughts when I first read it, that still lingers. It is an emotional topic for sure.

You ask what is wrong with it, I ask what does it fix. So far, not one person has answered that. As the onus is upon the ones wanting change, I will wait to see if anyone can justify it. I'm personally don't enjoy seeing a change like this, seemingly on a whim.

Dev: Oh let's do up the bazaar.
other Dev: Tell you what, let's sell SP.

It's such a mad escalation and tangent from the first thought. It just doesn't sit well with many of us.

Anyway that's me done. I still like ya Dave, I just don't agree with your stance.


I give you my personal reason why it must be implemented. I need a better way than bazaar to exchange my isks for SP. Now I waiting while skill traning happens to change my in-game activity. I rather play more to earn isks for Packet than waiting until ends of time but bazaar not an option for me. It fix nothing but giving an opportunity.
Levi Belvar
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#2447 - 2015-10-17 11:08:29 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Levi Belvar wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Levi Belvar wrote:
The sticking two fingers up part refers to : 80 million skillpoints = 50,000 unallocated skillpoints added /// So ive played the game for 9 years had upto 3/4 accounts running so someone comes along maybe stays for a month or 2 but gets 500,000 for the same $£$ and i get shafted ...... Thats not unfair ???


at 80m SP he gets the same 50k from a packet too.

that restriction is on the character's SP not the age of the account.

if you create a new character on the account you'd get the same 500,000 sp.


So what is the whole exercise for then ????

Is it for the benefit of new character creation or to add yet another game straining microtransaction that has nothing todo with the bazaar in itself but to afford old characters the potential to max their toons by using RMT


according to the devblog it's to make things more granular and give you more control.


When your were seeking an answer i gave it you now you quote a line, i meant your take on it. I always took it in eve that certain area's were sacrosanct and now it seems not.

How will this effect a new player in anyway shape or form, except for him to spend real money to advance instantly. I agree with you that having a 400m sp toon has no bearing on anyones ability to pilot a ship no different than someone with 150m sp but to what end its not been earned, The size of the wallet should not dictate the class of the pilot.

In what way is this helping to boost the flagging sub base, its just taking money away from an already jaded one.

“Stupidity and wisdom meet in the same centre of sentiment and resolution, in the suffering of human accidents.”

Black Pedro
Mine.
#2448 - 2015-10-17 11:10:20 UTC
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)

Ima is right. Medium-term, skill packet prices worth a month's worth of SP will stabilize just below those of a PLEX. There is after all, only one source of new SP and that is paying for a month's worth of game time. This is massive buff to multi-boxers who multiplex characters that do not require continued training. Ganking alts, mining alts, PI alts, industry/research alts, etc. will all be essentially free-to-play, or certainly only cost a fraction of a PLEX to keep running for a month.

This is perhaps the most worrisome aspect of this change. This will have profound effects on the economy and a massive proliferation in extra accounts.

On the plus side, this change coupled with the recent buff in skill points is a huge boon to the New Order and other highsec gankers. Using the trial period and the free PLEX for a buddy account, you can almost have a near max DPS 5M SP Catalyst ganking alt for free which you can then run indefinitely, also for near free, by harvesting the SP each month. Free gank alts for everyone, and as many as your machine can run at one time, should make our job of bringing highsec into compliance that much easier.
Don ZOLA
Omniscient Order
#2449 - 2015-10-17 11:20:02 UTC
Gully Alex Foyle wrote:
Don ZOLA wrote:
No worries, I am not referring to that "history" post but to posts with numerous arguments and expectations like 50 and 70 pages ago. Until someone counters them with some reasonable explanation I will stand by the fact that this is easily the worst decision ever since it will change fundamentals of the game for unknown expectations without helping more than minor percent of the players.
Did you consider the fact that every single subscribed account will be able to get ISK for any and all not needed SP? And that SP accumulates constantly?

That means that potentially 100% of EVE players can grind less for ISK (and/or PLEX), provided obviously that on the other side there are ISK- (and/or cash-) rich players willing to buy SP.


I can see it happen in minor amounts among regular players ie non farms which are going to be used for this.

There are 2 rules in a successful life: 1. Don't tell people everything you know

Dave stark
#2450 - 2015-10-17 11:20:19 UTC
Daniela Doran wrote:
Plex cost 1.2 bill isk, this transneural package containing 2 mill SP is gonna sell for how much?


well the "cost" to produce one package containing 500,000sp will be 300m of game time at current plex prices - plus whatever the extractor costs which is currently unknown.

so for 2m SP you need 4 of those - and that's assuming you're not injecting it in a character that's going to suffer from diminishing returns.
Ima Wreckyou
The Conference Elite
Safety.
#2451 - 2015-10-17 11:23:41 UTC
Daniela Doran wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)


Plex cost 1.2 bill isk, this transneural package containing 2 mill SP is gonna sell for how much?

This is uncertain, because this will have a heavy impact on the PLEX price and we don't know what the extractors cost and what the demand for packs will be.

I just pointed out some consequences for both the scenarios, where the pack is cheaper than what it takes to produce or where it is more expensive.
Maximus Aerelius
PROPHET OF ENIGMA
#2452 - 2015-10-17 11:24:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Maximus Aerelius
Black Pedro wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.


The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)

Ima is right. Medium-term, skill packet prices worth a month's worth of SP will stabilize just below those of a PLEX..


I find your logic flawed as the proposed cost to the SP Package creator is a PLEX. Add that to the cost for the SP and this will come in above the price of a PLEX along with inflating the price of PLEX. Another reason it'll be more than a PLEX is that it's instant SP and not 30 days to train SP.

Sure you could just get a PLEX and train for 30 days cheaper but those that want to inject SP immediately will have to pay more. It's how the market works. It's how the trade hubs work, the further you are from Jita the more stuff costs. Want it in Rens, pay Rens prices but if you're willing to wait\travel then go to Jita.
Dave stark
#2453 - 2015-10-17 11:26:41 UTC
Levi Belvar wrote:
When your were seeking an answer i gave it you now you quote a line, i meant your take on it. I always took it in eve that certain area's were sacrosanct and now it seems not.

How will this effect a new player in anyway shape or form, except for him to spend real money to advance instantly. I agree with you that having a 400m sp toon has no bearing on anyones ability to pilot a ship no different than someone with 150m sp but to what end its not been earned, The size of the wallet should not dictate the class of the pilot.

In what way is this helping to boost the flagging sub base, its just taking money away from an already jaded one.


what do i think it achieves? it makes skipping the boring and pointless training of core skills significantly easier.
lets face it - everyone is going to train cpu/pg skills, basic nav skills etc. they are essentially mandatory. - it's just an irrelevant time sink to train them. you can skip it by buying a cheap character with them trained already this system just makes doing that significantly less hassle.

that's the same way it affects everyone; open your wallet (in game or out of game) and advance instantly. the size of the wallet has always dictated the class of the pilot - the bazaar has ensured that.

it helps boost the flagging sub base in the same way every single other QoL change does.
Lan Wang
Princess Aiko Hold My Hand
Safety. Net
#2454 - 2015-10-17 11:38:20 UTC
Black Pedro wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Ima Wreckyou wrote:
Anyway, in both cases the PLEX prices will skyrocket, since there will be a lot of players who are no longer interested in getting SP for a bunch of their alts and rather just farm packs for passive income. I will do it for sure if this hits TQ.


unless the margins are 100% or better (which i seriously doubt) if you're doing it purely to make isk rather than offset the cost of having the account... you're better off just straight up selling plex.

The point is not to make ISK. The point is if I have an account where I don't need anymore SP because it's perfectly focus trained for what it does I can just sell the accumulated SP as packs to lower the subscription costs.

There are two possibilities here:

- If I can sell them higher that what it takes to create the pack (PLEX + extractors) I can create a free account with zero effort.

- If I have to sell lower that what it takes to create them all the people training while taking a break will make a better deal if they just cancel the subscription and buy some packs if they come back

(Yes, there may be some space between the two possibilities depending on how expensive the extractors are.)

Ima is right. Medium-term, skill packet prices worth a month's worth of SP will stabilize just below those of a PLEX. There is after all, only one source of new SP and that is paying for a month's worth of game time. This is massive buff to multi-boxers who multiplex characters that do not require continued training. Ganking alts, mining alts, PI alts, industry/research alts, etc. will all be essentially free-to-play, or certainly only cost a fraction of a PLEX to keep running for a month.

This is perhaps the most worrisome aspect of this change. This will have profound effects on the economy and a massive proliferation in extra accounts.

On the plus side, this change coupled with the recent buff in skill points is a huge boon to the New Order and other highsec gankers. Using the trial period and the free PLEX for a buddy account, you can almost have a near max DPS 5M SP Catalyst ganking alt for free which you can then run indefinitely, also for near free, by harvesting the SP each month. Free gank alts for everyone, and as many as your machine can run at one time, should make our job of bringing highsec into compliance that much easier.


it makes me wonder if this is the reason hyperdunking got nerfed, they nerf hyperdunking then release a way to easily make low sp alts

Domination Nephilim - Angel Cartel

Calm down miner. As you pointed out, people think they can get away with stuff they would not in rl... Like for example illegal mining... - Ima Wreckyou*

Black Pedro
Mine.
#2455 - 2015-10-17 11:40:15 UTC  |  Edited by: Black Pedro
Maximus Aerelius wrote:
I find your logic flawed as the proposed cost to the SP Package creator is a PLEX. Add that to the cost for the SP and this will come in above the price of a PLEX along with inflating the price of PLEX. Another reason it'll be more than a PLEX is that it's instant SP and not 30 days to train SP. Sure you could just get a PLEX and train for 30 days cheaper but those that want to inject SP immediately will have to pay more. It's how the market works. It's how the trade hubs work, the further you are from Jita the more stuff costs. Want it in Rens, pay Rens prices but if you're willing to wait\travel then go to Jita.
It's not flawed at all. SP can only come from game time. Therefore, these packets will cost the equivalent in PLEX + the cost of the extractor + some small profit. If the cost of the packets is capped at the cost of PLEX as if it rises much above the cost a PLEX, people will just extract a month's worth of game time from a character and buy a PLEX to activate dual-training to replace it for a quick, guaranteed profit.

So a months worth of SP will never cost much more than PLEX + extractor cost. If they ever do for some reason, then you will actually get paid to run a ganking (or mining/PI/whatever) alt. That situation won't last for long before players sell off some SP from an alt and buy a cheaper PLEX to replace that SP for a quick profit.

Unless the extractors cost so much that people decide the packets aren't worth it, they will be in high demand as you say because they are instantaneous progression. Therefore, this upward price pressure will keep them near the price of a PLEX. The only downward pressure will come from the alt farmers who will sell SP at a small loss because they are making easy PI/industry/ganking profit to offset their costs.

Therefore, SP packets prices will track the price of PLEX almost perfectly, but they will also push the demand for PLEX way up to satisfy the new demand for "free" alt accounts. There are a lot of unknowns as to how this shakes out, but definitely there will be massive changes to the economy if this mechanic is put in the game.
Maximus Aerelius
PROPHET OF ENIGMA
#2456 - 2015-10-17 11:44:23 UTC  |  Edited by: Maximus Aerelius
There was an issue with parsing this post's BBCode
General Lootit
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#2457 - 2015-10-17 11:45:16 UTC  |  Edited by: General Lootit
Black Pedro wrote:

On the plus side, this change coupled with the recent buff in skill points is a huge boon to the New Order and other highsec gankers. Using the trial period and the free PLEX for a buddy account, you can almost have a near max DPS 5M SP Catalyst ganking alt for free which you can then run indefinitely, also for near free, by harvesting the SP each month. Free gank alts for everyone, and as many as your machine can run at one time, should make our job of bringing highsec into compliance that much easier.

It will be cost much more than sec.tags. Price to washing sec.status by tags > 250kk. New toon(PLEX) already costs 1200kk
Black Pedro
Mine.
#2458 - 2015-10-17 11:47:19 UTC
General Lootit wrote:
Black Pedro wrote:

On the plus side, this change coupled with the recent buff in skill points is a huge boon to the New Order and other highsec gankers. Using the trial period and the free PLEX for a buddy account, you can almost have a near max DPS 5M SP Catalyst ganking alt for free which you can then run indefinitely, also for near free, by harvesting the SP each month. Free gank alts for everyone, and as many as your machine can run at one time, should make our job of bringing highsec into compliance that much easier.

You can't learn blasters on trial account.

I am pretty sure you can. But it won't be a trial account anymore as soon as you use your free buddy PLEX to activate it.
Asveron Durr
Vandanian Order
Greater Itamo Mafia
#2459 - 2015-10-17 11:58:40 UTC
Black Pedro wrote:
General Lootit wrote:
Black Pedro wrote:

On the plus side, this change coupled with the recent buff in skill points is a huge boon to the New Order and other highsec gankers. Using the trial period and the free PLEX for a buddy account, you can almost have a near max DPS 5M SP Catalyst ganking alt for free which you can then run indefinitely, also for near free, by harvesting the SP each month. Free gank alts for everyone, and as many as your machine can run at one time, should make our job of bringing highsec into compliance that much easier.

You can't learn blasters on trial account.

I am pretty sure you can. But it won't be a trial account anymore as soon as you use your free buddy PLEX to activate it.



Have to use this quote since your editing your last post almost by the minute General Lootit.....

Your wrong about the blasters, sure maybe not about t2 but you do not need t2 for a cheap effective gank alt
Maximus Aerelius
PROPHET OF ENIGMA
#2460 - 2015-10-17 12:05:54 UTC
Black Pedro wrote:
Maximus Aerelius wrote:
I find your logic flawed as the proposed cost to the SP Package creator is a PLEX. Add that to the cost for the SP and this will come in above the price of a PLEX along with inflating the price of PLEX. Another reason it'll be more than a PLEX is that it's instant SP and not 30 days to train SP. Sure you could just get a PLEX and train for 30 days cheaper but those that want to inject SP immediately will have to pay more. It's how the market works. It's how the trade hubs work, the further you are from Jita the more stuff costs. Want it in Rens, pay Rens prices but if you're willing to wait\travel then go to Jita.
It's not flawed at all. SP can only come from game time. Therefore, these packets will cost the equivalent in PLEX + the cost of the extractor + some small profit. If the cost of the packets is capped at the cost of PLEX as if it rises much above the cost a PLEX, people will just extract a month's worth of game time from a character and buy a PLEX to activate dual-training to replace it for a quick, guaranteed profit.

So a months worth of SP will never cost much more than PLEX + extractor cost. If they ever do for some reason, then you will actually get paid to run a ganking (or mining/PI/whatever) alt. That situation won't last for long before players sell off some SP from an alt and buy a cheaper PLEX to replace that SP for a quick profit.

Unless the extractors cost so much that people decide the packets aren't worth it, they will be in high demand as you say because they are instantaneous progression. Therefore, this upward price pressure will keep them near the price of a PLEX. The only downward pressure will come from the alt farmers who will sell SP at a small loss because they are making easy PI/industry/ganking profit to offset their costs.

Therefore, SP packets prices will track the price of PLEX almost perfectly, but they will also push the demand for PLEX way up to satisfy the new demand for "free" alt accounts. There are a lot of unknowns as to how this shakes out, but definitely there will be massive changes to the economy if this mechanic is put in the game.


I think you're wrong on them tracking the price of a PLEX and there isn't any profit in that for those extracting. It's proposed that the character extracting uses a PLEX+SP Extractor to create the packet. What's the point\where's the profit in it selling for under the price of a PLEX?

Further to that you say people won't pay above the price of a PLEX but will instead activate MCT. That's not addressing the injection of SP as I said, instant SP will cost more than training at standard rate.

As for people offsetting their costs elsewhere, I agree some will, but the market will dictate what may happen and you know most people will sell for as much as possible.

In all honesty I hope this never comes to pass.