EVE Information Portal

Here are my two cents to the various concerns that have been voiced:

1. This will diminish the attachment to my characters / devalue the sense of unique history and achievement that is embodied in the skill set: For me the big change there was the removal of the skill queue cap. When I started EVE, the daily, later weekly, skill queue management was instrumental in making me log in. At that time I thought the whole training scheme was super clever for that very reason. With hundreds of days in my queues this motivator is gone and I can see players let their new characters just sit there and accumulate sp without logging them in. People who want to roleplay their characters' development still will be able to do that.
2. This can be abused to create super powers: I have not seen ways to abuse the system that would not already be possible in one way or another with plex, alts and the bazaar.
3. We won't be able to tell the skill level by looking at character age: This is indeed a plus in my book. It'd be great news if you need to be a bit more careful when engaging a young character. You'd actually need to observe their behaviour instead of just clicking show-info.
4. The bazaar was a good market that would be destroyed: Can't say anything on that since I never tried to use it, let alone make isk off it.
5. Monetisation through peer pressure: This made me very uncomfortable at first. But once I realized that it is the extraction of skillpoints from a character that costs aurum and not the consumption of the skill package, these concerns were largely calmed.

So at the moment I am pretty positive about the change.

What I would like to see is some twist, rooted in the game world. Maybe there is a fun way how messing with ones' head could have some effects on your mental health. I am more thinking of perks than serious penalties. Maybe there is something that can be tied into the storyline and the changes to implants that have been hinted at in the past.
Simply adding something like "This character had her neural pathways significantly disrupted by repeated skill injections and is going to collapse soon." to the character description could also appease the people who fear the diminished intel.

Here is something to consider since this skill idea will not assist younger/newer players.......

First few days or coupleof weeks are fine maybe......

But then space rich guy and his few friends ensure they drop their PLEX hoard(some of it) into aurum.
Then purchase the skill extractors....
Then use them on characters they have not been using in a long time....

And only after they have begin snapping up the skill injectors off the market....

Calculations between aurum/plex differences/worth, and equivelancy of RL Money will:
Allow for market manipulation and control, effetively making it impossible for new players to purchase these injectors....

Eventually the plex is much higher than it is today
and the Injecotrs will be soon enough in the range of 500million to 1 billion ISK themselves also.....

This will make the idea into "Golden Ammo" as the only ones able to use it at that point would be those that spend REAL cash on plex or even aurum...because the ISK market is for all intents an purposes in the control of players....and mostly veterans at that.
I could do it....and I am sure the the other EvE moguls out there are thinking of it.....

In effect i predict in a few short months of being implemented as currently stated this "skill idea" becomes a point of RMT and enslavement for new players to established organizations that will setup a way to exploit the "i have to have it now" crowd.

It will fail as valuable change in the game......
an as one person said once already....when a newer player quits he will pass on the knowledge:
1.) you have to spend $15 to subscribe
2.) then buy a plex to cash in to purchase the skill injectors $20
2a.) or buy aurum to get as many skill extractors as possible $20
3.) you will also have to fork over $20 for a plex to train a 2nd character or $15 for a character on another account

Just to be effective......and that is how the "i want it now" crowd will think and behave....
Bad reviews and word of mouth that EvE will cost approx $30 - $60 every month or every other month or so to be competitive will destroy player retention more so than now. It will no longer be seen as the $15 per month subscription game by a greater number of people than many realize. It will be seen as a PAY TO WIN game on par with many others, but more expensive.

And this is not including the fact of those that may buy plex for ISk to get the ships they will be able to fly after injections only to lose them faster because they have no practical experience how to truly play this game.

CCP promised us no "Golden Ammo" ideas, they practically promised us they would not establish a money grab scheme like so many other games do or have done, and some of those have failed os miserably they are either stagnant as well in player numbers or do not exsist anymore.

IF Hilmar and compant really wish to kill off one of Icelands top income makers....then who are we to stop them. But if they are looking to truly see EvE last a full decade at full steam ahead they would be well advised to reconsider this idea.
Veteran Players will scheme and break everything you introduce into this game.....becaue that is what we do, this is no different except you will be literally handing over the keys to your finances and ability to grow this time in ways you simply do not unable fathom at this point.
Might as well go public and start letting veteran players buy actual CCP stock.

i feel that could be solved by doing dropping everything by a factor of 10.

a skill packet costing 30m vs 300m. that's a huge difference. for a new player 30m isn't a seemingly insurmountable amount of isk. 300 is.

i remember 100m was a milestone and frankly a bit of a struggle, so trying to reach 300? oh god.. 30m, not so much.

according to the devblog it's to make things more granular and give you more control.

I like this idea. Gives more freedom hence more fun to the game and remove some of the too rigid rules. It'll also remove this "vet" "noob" segregation and give the game a real sandbox feel. And not "skill queue online".

But I also understand that it upsets some vets. But for the new players (or most players) the "I'm older than you so I win" is artificial and frankly stupid.

I see what you mean, but you're making the same mistake 99% of the posters are making: looking at it only from the buyer's perspective.

What about all the ISK flow from buyers to sellers? Sellers being, as you say and I agree, a very large chunk of the EVE population.

It's funny, people seem so attached to SP accumulation they're overlooking the opportunites to sell unnecessary SP.

Some people seem to be afraid that this feature would allow rich players to get alts with like 400m sp, which is more than what you could buy on the character bazaar. I’d like to explain why that’s not a problem.

What people don’t seem to realise is that there is only a limited amount of combat skills. You need approximately 150m sp to get at least level 4 skills for every available combat ship and module. Once you have that many sp you can continue to train barely useful level 5 combat skills until you have approximately 290m sp. At that point you will have nothing left to train but completely useless skills.

We have long passed the time where characters with 150m combat sp began to be available on the character bazaar and in 1 or 2 years even characters with 290m combat sp will become more common on the character bazaar.

If you want to have a high sp combat character now you can get it on the character bazaar. If you want to have a high sp combat character after this feature is released you would still get it from the character bazaar because it will be much cheaper than using skill packets. The diminishing returns are not only a great sp sink but they also protect the value of high sp characters.

In the end it will cost a shitload of ISK to push your character to 400m sp and the only advantage you get is the possibility to use your combat pilot also for mining. Who cares?

I can afford that. In FW earning rate is about 75kk per hour on trial account. So if Packet will be cost around 1/4 of PLEX (assuming that farming rate is 2000k SP per month so 500k SP is 1/4 of month) I need 4 hours to buy Packet which worth 1 week of traning.

I can't understand why people are complaining about P2W. Buying PLEX to buy characters is something new players already do! This just makes it more granular and actually they will probably spend less on buying PLEX as they don't have to buy the whole character with lots of excess skills or pay a premium to buy a very focussed character.

I am concerned that newer players might be shoe-horned in to joining the bigger alliances if they are offering free skill packets as a recruitment incentive. Not a bad thing in itself but a bit of diversity and incentive to join smaller corps and alliances only adds to the game.

CCP might need to rethink T3 skill losses as they'll not really be a penality under this system - perhaps a delay of a day before you are able to apply unallocated SP to the skill that was lost?

Are you looking to deploy this in on 3 November 2015, or mid December, or is this a longer term thing?

I'm getting really close to 50mil SP, and if that's going to be the first major soft cap, i'd REALLY like this feature before i hit that mark. :)