These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Jester Trek Latest Blog

First post First post
Author
olan2005
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#3901 - 2014-03-26 22:27:38 UTC
Navi Annages wrote:
Abla Tive wrote:
Hours of humiliation is clearly abuse.

Abuse is clearly against the terms of service.

Violation of terms of service is legitimate grounds for banning.

Where is the confusion?


The Eula for the millionth time states "in the game" not outside the game in ts3 mumble vent face chat ect ect ect. Which part are you unsure of?



Correct put there is a grey area. The origin point for this was in-game . The at stake (already scammed assets were in-game items that belong to ccp proprietary intellectual property . So due to the fact this originated in-game with a legit scam then went out of game to humiliate someone < the issue is the out of game interaction > i believe CCP should intervene
DJentropy Ovaert
The Conference Elite
Safety.
#3902 - 2014-03-26 22:28:08 UTC
Danalee wrote:


You could be allmost right if it was only after "everything that led up to it" (= being asked to read stuff and sing songs).
Only, it's not. The anti-gay stuff, racial slurs and stupid rants are there from start to finish, he is reminded plenty of times this is against the rules but soldiers on like the derp he is.

D.

Bear


Yup. Having your greed played on by the most well known scammer in Eve online - our victim should have learned from this experience. Having your greed played on to the point where you read boring walls of text and sing silly songs? Silly, our victim should now know how easy it is to take advantage of people by playing on their greed.

Responding to all of this with homophobic rants and racial slurs? No excuse. A sign of a truly sick mind and an awful human being. Sometimes only when under stress will the true colors of a human being come to the surface, and I feel this may be one of the most dramatic examples of this I have ever personally witnessed.
Upde
Upde Harris Industries
#3903 - 2014-03-26 22:28:56 UTC
Sentamon wrote:
Jenn aSide wrote:

What we see is you defending a racist who threatened another players life and his mother's life rather than disconnect from TS.


Let take this to its logical conclusion.

I get ganked, gankers post the kill mail, I feel humiliated and cry to Rippard the CSM, gankers get banned, I get to go on a free racist rant and threaten gankers IRL life.

Wheeeee .... EVE will be more fun then ever.


that is not even in the same ballpark. Posting a kill mail publicly v posting a recording of someone going through a humiliation aren't even in the same town sport.
Drone 16
Holy Horde
#3904 - 2014-03-26 22:29:04 UTC
Navi Annages wrote:
Mr Epeen wrote:
I'm curious. Why is everyone (well a good percentage, anyway) using a guys racial slurs and death threats made after the fact to negate everything that led up to it?

Strange way to justify what a freakin' sick douche does for jollies.

Mr Epeen Cool


Because we live in a beautiful country that allows people to act however they feel like.


then why care about the threats and slurs to begin with, the guy is just trying to live in the land of beauty in the nest in the tree of trust, no?

It puts the peanutbutter on itself or it leaves the bonus round... - E1's greatest Hits

Chopper Rollins
hahahlolspycorp
#3905 - 2014-03-26 22:29:41 UTC
dexington wrote:
...

If CCP decides to get involved everyone playing eve is going to lose a little of the freedom we currently have in eve, and i don't really think anyone wants that.



The internet in general is losing freedom because of exactly this, in fact any environment where people are allowed to use common sense is ruined by the tiny toxic minority who have the need to be transgressive to realize themselves.
So we end up with rules and mods and cops and secret police and undercover agents and detectives, all because of the growing pains (or the refusal to grow up) of a few tools.
I don't even hate Ero1 and Co. ...I've seen how high school boys act when there's no teachers around.
In this case the regulating adult influence was meant to be Ero1, so yeah.



Goggles. Making me look good. Making you look good.

Josef Djugashvilis
#3906 - 2014-03-26 22:31:01 UTC
Jenn aSide wrote:
James Amril-Kesh wrote:
Tarojan wrote:
James Amril-Kesh wrote:
Hi, my name is Joe.
I have a reputation for kicking small children in the face.
A week ago this boy of age 7 stood in front of me in the grocery store line so I kicked him in the face.
Kid should have known better than to stand in front of me, after all I do have a reputation.
To punish his stupidity I kicked him in the face and stomach several more times.



real life...game....real life...game....

You having troubles telling the difference between the two bud?

You seem to be having trouble telling where they separate.
If you torment someone for hours on a voice chat to the point where you're systematically attacking things like speech impediments, then it certainly has gone too far and crossed into the point of torment.


At which point you click on an X (or pull a plug out of the wall) and it's over.

This is one of the problems with modern society: no one expects grown folks to take care of themselves anymore.


Dear Jenn Awhine, as usual you miss the point, it is not the scamming which was the problem but the making fun of a person's speech impediment which was taking things too far.

Still, Jenn, you gotta sound tough all the time, or you would lose face with the hard-man trolls in the game.

This is not a signature.

Druthlen
The Carlisle Group
#3907 - 2014-03-26 22:31:17 UTC
Navi Annages wrote:
Druthlen wrote:
Ais Hellia wrote:
Iudicium Vastus wrote:
Leaving will be to turn your back on all that time and effort you've spent working for what you have.


Why would you work in a game in the first place?
Instead of having fun which is itself a reward for time spent.

In other words the outcome of your gaming activity is your satisfaction with the process or accomplishment not "space pixels"
if you consider your time spent in EVE as "work" you are doing something wrong and it's not even a matter of different tastes or interests



Talk about hypocrisy. Who are you to judge why or how someone plays inside the game. Outside the game we are now talking about morality. Some people cant recognize when they are outside the game. Ganking inside the game imo is really cool and I loved the New Order for it. I thought it was hilarious to see freighters explode. Outside the game torturing a human being just for the lulz. Sick.


Sick? Maybe. Immoral? Maybe. Legal most likely because the adult named sohkar consented to everything.


What I consider the worst is that minors who are very influencable have been taken in by this cult. We have minors who dont have a solid right and wrong participating in this sick torture of another human being. They need to be exposed and parents notified so they can get help if they think this is normal or fun.
David Kir
Hotbirds
#3908 - 2014-03-26 22:31:36 UTC  |  Edited by: David Kir
Well, that's it for me, it's late in the evening and there's work to be done tomorrow.
There's very little that I can discuss with the people defending Erotica 1, since they refuse to see how Sokhar was humiliated.



I find Erotica 1's actions to be disgusting, according to my own moral compass.
I would never associate with such a man, and I'm frightened by the perspective of meeting someon like him "IRL".


I find Sokhar's reaction to be extreme (and reprehensible), but less so than E1's actions, given that:
1) It was the result of two hours of provocation and humiliation
2) It was the specific goal that Erotica 1 aimed to reach


I find that this kind of episodes are detrimental to EVE's health and reputation, and that they are not comparable to episodes such as the GHSC heist, given that they do not rely on gameplay mechanics.



I've made my points; each of you is fully entitled to his own opinion.

See you all tomorrow.

Friends are like cows: if you eat them, they die.

Upde
Upde Harris Industries
#3909 - 2014-03-26 22:33:27 UTC
Chopper Rollins wrote:
dexington wrote:
...

If CCP decides to get involved everyone playing eve is going to lose a little of the freedom we currently have in eve, and i don't really think anyone wants that.



The internet in general is losing freedom because of exactly this, in fact any environment where people are allowed to use common sense is ruined by the tiny toxic minority who have the need to be transgressive to realize themselves.
So we end up with rules and mods and cops and secret police and undercover agents and detectives, all because of the growing pains (or the refusal to grow up) of a few tools.
I don't even hate Ero1 and Co. ...I've seen how high school boys act when there's no teachers around.
In this case the regulating adult influence was meant to be Ero1, so yeah.





with great freedom comes great responsibility. If the community cannot use the freedom bestowed upon us by CCP responsibility and in the "spirit" of the game as it was meant then restrictive measures are the next likely path. I hope for all that EVE is, that this does not happen.
DJentropy Ovaert
The Conference Elite
Safety.
#3910 - 2014-03-26 22:33:39 UTC
David Kir wrote:

2) It was the specific goal that Erotica 1 aimed to reach




Giving the section in question a second listen, it seemed to me like E1 was quite suprised when the death threats and nbombs started dropping. In fact, our "victim" surprised me with this - and lost any sympathy he could have gotten from me in the first place.
Sentamon
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#3911 - 2014-03-26 22:35:29 UTC
Upde wrote:

that is not even in the same ballpark. Posting a kill mail publicly v posting a recording of someone going through a humiliation aren't even in the same town sport.


Still trying to grasp how volunteering to sing songs is humiliation.

Posting kill mails is clearly meant to humiliate the victim, especially in a gank, and the perps don't even ask you if you're ok with them posting your loss.

~ Professional Forum Alt  ~

Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#3912 - 2014-03-26 22:35:31 UTC
tiberiusric wrote:
I have been playing this game for many many years now, and have never really been comfortable with the whole scamming thing. I think it spoils the game and actually drives people away. Scamming as become so prevalent in Eve its over taken the good aspects of it. Look at jita every single post in chat is a scam.

I dont like the fact that goonswarm do this constantly to a point its part of their culture, and sometimes the way they do it is a little creepy and weird and wrong.



eh ?

Quote:


But this is a whole new level, and its just not about a scam, its cyber bullying, torture at is very worse. I am sure this is certainly not the first case of this and its happening to others by other eve players.



No - its mild hazing linked to a fake virtual identify, an identity that the owner can leave if he is sufficiently embarrassed about (by selling character and buying a new one), without even leaving the game, and which the victim could have ended more than an hour before he did.

Serious cyber bullying involves the real name of the target, and can reach as far as publishing identified naked pictures or sex ideos and whatnot and allows bullying to chase a victim into a new city, new career, post school life etc, none of which will ever be a consequence of this.

Navi Annages
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#3913 - 2014-03-26 22:35:52 UTC
Druthlen wrote:
Navi Annages wrote:
Druthlen wrote:
Ais Hellia wrote:
Iudicium Vastus wrote:
Leaving will be to turn your back on all that time and effort you've spent working for what you have.


Why would you work in a game in the first place?
Instead of having fun which is itself a reward for time spent.

In other words the outcome of your gaming activity is your satisfaction with the process or accomplishment not "space pixels"
if you consider your time spent in EVE as "work" you are doing something wrong and it's not even a matter of different tastes or interests



Talk about hypocrisy. Who are you to judge why or how someone plays inside the game. Outside the game we are now talking about morality. Some people cant recognize when they are outside the game. Ganking inside the game imo is really cool and I loved the New Order for it. I thought it was hilarious to see freighters explode. Outside the game torturing a human being just for the lulz. Sick.


Sick? Maybe. Immoral? Maybe. Legal most likely because the adult named sohkar consented to everything.


What I consider the worst is that minors who are very influencable have been taken in by this cult. We have minors who dont have a solid right and wrong participating in this sick torture of another human being. They need to be exposed and parents notified so they can get help if they think this is normal or fun.


Again Anonymity and privacy laws buddy. No laws broken then the Anonymity blanket is warm and soft. Good luck trying to get a foreign country to hand over any private data on players. Especially after the Snowden ordeal.

Now in a real sense maybe you have lost touch with truly how gutless, vulgar, and dark the world really is. Lucky for us the constitution allows people to be as conceited as they want. If you don't like it I urge you to take it up with your congressmen. Btw you'll just get some auto response email. Happens all the time. :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8-JfK-wwFU

Muestereate
Minions LLC
#3914 - 2014-03-26 22:35:58 UTC
Danalee wrote:
Mr Epeen wrote:
I'm curious. Why is everyone (well a good percentage, anyway) using a guys racial slurs and death threats made after the fact to negate everything that led up to it?

Strange way to justify what a freakin' sick douche does for jollies.

Mr Epeen Cool


You could be allmost right if it was only after "everything that led up to it" (= being asked to read stuff and sing songs).
Only, it's not. The anti-gay stuff, racial slurs and stupid rants are there from start to finish, he is reminded plenty of times this is against the rules but soldiers on like the derp he is.

D.

Bear


Erotica sends many female signals in a male processed voice. Every man, gay or straight is socialized to react to gender confusion. gays get excited I guess and straight men get angry. Victim didn't act any different that 96% of world male population does.
LUMINOUS SPIRIT
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#3915 - 2014-03-26 22:36:26 UTC
Just ban E1 + all the alts / friends

EVE community will not miss such a low-life.

Torturing a poor guy for 2 hours... Sickening. No different to real-life **** or pedophiles luring victims over the internet.
Katkon Darnok
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#3916 - 2014-03-26 22:37:56 UTC
Navi Annages wrote:
Abla Tive wrote:
Hours of humiliation is clearly abuse.

Abuse is clearly against the terms of service.

Violation of terms of service is legitimate grounds for banning.

Where is the confusion?


The Eula for the millionth time states "in the game" not outside the game in ts3 mumble vent facechat ect ect ect. Which part are you unsure of?


Technically, the EULA gives CCP the freedom to ban pretty much whomever they please for "inappropriate conduct". If you read it carefully it DOES state the following....

"CCP may establish Rules of Conduct (discussed below) for players accessing the System and may, but is not obligated to, monitor and take action regarding inappropriate conduct."

... And while it DOES list specific behavior-related banable offences, it doesn't state that these are the ONLY banable offences. They absolutely have the right per EULA, and - quite frankly - as a business. And no court of law would revolt against a ban in this instance. While the offense in question didn't happen "in" EVE, it 100% revolved around EVE and even involved transfer/APIs "in-game" DURING the bonus around. Any "reasonable" person would suggest that E1 attempted to explicitly avoid EULA knowing that the bonus round, as managed here, was a violation of terms and conditions. I think he even stated this explicitly.

This is not a EULA issue, it's an ethics issue.
Navi Annages
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#3917 - 2014-03-26 22:38:16 UTC
Muestereate wrote:
Danalee wrote:
Mr Epeen wrote:
I'm curious. Why is everyone (well a good percentage, anyway) using a guys racial slurs and death threats made after the fact to negate everything that led up to it?

Strange way to justify what a freakin' sick douche does for jollies.

Mr Epeen Cool


You could be allmost right if it was only after "everything that led up to it" (= being asked to read stuff and sing songs).
Only, it's not. The anti-gay stuff, racial slurs and stupid rants are there from start to finish, he is reminded plenty of times this is against the rules but soldiers on like the derp he is.

D.

Bear


Erotica sends many female signals in a male processed voice. Every man, gay or straight is socialized to react to gender confusion. gays get excited I guess and straight men get angry. Victim didn't act any different that 96% of world male population does.


Are you truly trying to confuse the topic with such a lame fallacy as bringing straight and or homosexual preferences into an argument. Here this might help you with your debate skills.

http://i.imgur.com/aEhOy.jpg?1

Try a lil harder next time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8-JfK-wwFU

David Kir
Hotbirds
#3918 - 2014-03-26 22:38:26 UTC
DJentropy Ovaert wrote:



Giving the section in question a second listen, it seemed to me like E1 was quite suprised when the death threats and nbombs started dropping. In fact, our "victim" surprised me with this - and lost any sympathy he could have gotten from me in the first place.


Urgh.
The last post, I swear to myself.

He didn't expect that degree of aggressivity; that disgusted me, too.
Again, rage brings out the worst of us, and that's what we see, in this case.

But his ultimate goal was to provoke an emotional reaction ("harvest tears"?) , and that's what he obtained.

Friends are like cows: if you eat them, they die.

Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#3919 - 2014-03-26 22:38:51 UTC
David Kir wrote:
Well, that's it for me, it's late in the evening and there's work to be done tomorrow.
There's very little that I can discuss with the people defending Erotica 1, since they refuse to see how Sokhar was humiliated.


Sokhar is a fake identity. The owner of Sokhar is not really humiliated, because he can abandon the sohkar entity and never have it ever affect him again.

Quote:


I find Erotica 1's actions to be disgusting, according to my own moral compass.
I would never associate with such a man, and I'm frightened by the perspective of meeting someon like him "IRL".



To what point, you aren't going to give him anything, and therefore you aren't going to be lead around by your greed.

Quote:


I find Sokhar's reaction to be extreme (and reprehensible), but less so than E1's actions, given that:
1) It was the result of two hours of provocation and humiliation
2) It was the specific goal that Erotica 1 aimed to reach


I find that this kind of episodes are detrimental to EVE's health and reputations, and that they are not comparable to episodes such as the GHSC heist, given that they do not rely on gameplay mechanics.



The game mechanic that allows you to give someone something is required.

Quote:


I've made my points; each of you is fully entitled to his own opinion.

See you all tomorrow.


Mallak Azaria
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#3920 - 2014-03-26 22:39:05 UTC
You know sometimes I do a quick awox on a corp & they threaten to cut my throat while I'm asleep. Other times I do a quick 20 minute scam for all of their assets & isk & they want to box me when they realise what happened 4 days later. I tend to just let this go & think nothing of it because it's a heat of the moment thing & never produces any results. Here's the problem I have with Erotica1: He's a sadistic & really creepy person.

It's one thing to do a quick thing for profit & leave them wondering what the hell just happened, but it's quite another to do the kind of crap you do to people over the course of several hours.

Would you like to know more?

This post was lovingly crafted by a member of the Goonwaffe Posting Cabal, proud member of the popular gay hookup site somethingawful.com, Spelling Bee, Grammar Gestapo & #1 Official Gevlon Goblin Fanclub member.