These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Live Events Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Probably the WORST event I've wasted my time on in my 10 years of EVE ...

First post First post
Author
Anomaly One
Doomheim
#841 - 2013-11-10 03:39:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Anomaly One
Quote:
Manufacturing is not creating content, it is creating stuff for PvP'ers and a few brave high sec'ers to create content with. Do not confuse the two.



wow,

"miners and industrialists build weapons and ships
those weapons and ships are used to create content
therefore miners and industrialists do not create content"

tell you what, since everyone around here hates mining manufacturing and considers this game only pvp, how about CCP just make it an instanced game? I see no difference from your barking arguments

your mistake and all the null and low bloc is mistaking this game for all pvp (fighting), when it becomes that way then it is no longer a sandbox, a sandbox does not cater to one type of player alone it gives you the freedom to do anything you want, CCP limits that freedom when it makes the game revolve around one thing, if I want challenging pvp I don't play eve, I play cs, LoL and dota, remove the economic conflict and marketing for me and this game is nothing but a bad pvp (again combat side) game.

You disregard and forget that all kinds of players play eve, if someone doesn't want to join null sec he will not join null sec, get it through your thick head, when CCP says **** that then we leave, it's simple, there's no function no algorithms here, being a carebear is just a way to play the game, either because you want to or because you can't do to certain situations.

Also your myth is not busted at all, it was a blob that won the fight 500 people gatecamped vs a bunch of noobs, we were maybe 1500 in total numbers but the ones that actually got to the event in time and got through and the way we went in the gate was not a blob at all far from it, half the people didn't get there and in the end systems there were less <400 of us and the ones that did died going through the gate to guess what? a blob.
Maximus Aerelius
PROPHET OF ENIGMA
#842 - 2013-11-10 03:53:34 UTC
Alaric Faelen wrote:
[--Now I know you didn't actually read my post.

Did you not notice the same quotation marks to denote sarcasm that you yourself just friggin used? Seriously? Literally used quotes to mock something I just used quotes to mock.


Actually I did and while I only quoted part of it for sake of clarity I can only apologise if it wasn't read in the tone it was written.

My reply was well intention if abrupt and I wholeheartedly agree that PvP doesn't require billions of ISK but does require some financial backing to replace those ships you are most definitely going to lose but in the meanwhile learning and hopefully enjoying. I'm glad that we agree on some if not all of the points.

I'm not into forum sparring as it's very late here now (0352hrs)but my reply was well intentioned if not well phrased and apologies again if you thought I hadn't read all of your post.
CERA Elitist
The Prometheus Society
#843 - 2013-11-10 05:03:05 UTC  |  Edited by: ISD Dosnix
*snip*
Fixed off-topic post
ISD Dosnix
Countess Lamorei
Hedion University
Amarr Empire
#844 - 2013-11-10 05:52:03 UTC
One ironic point seems to be that the empire forces had two npc ships on there side, and the nulseccers in effect had twenty faction battleships on theirs...

Nulscreamers... CCP did actually have character NPC's lead some of the fleets, those FC's were simply put terrible, knew the camps were ahead, and still ordered there rag tag fleet that was spread out over many systems to and I quote "Jump through and burn out of the bubbles" No orders from them about targeting any of the dic's, you know to perhaps stop more bubbles or anything. They really were just there to push the mass through without thought.

Highbears... And I do mean the clueless bears. Yes CCP screwed you, from what I hear those who went to the combat training earlier were even scarily told by CCP that they thought 80-90% of attendants would live.. so yeah you got screwed. Take from this also that when it comes to capsuleer strength, highsec is weak, and not just a little weaker but more like, your the scrawny kid and nul is a grenade. In the sarum part, that blob that caused so much damage was at a serious guess only something like 10-15% of cfc(goonies) sub capital strength, and while being the largest nulsec bloc they are far from the only major entity out there.

CCP did take control of many participants as fleet FC's, thus taking responsibility for those pilots, in that they FAILED.
They also planned a route to the objective at least from the sarum end, right through a cfc staging system, another failure.
Tidi caused many to never even get anywhere near the event before it ended, let alone start. Just sad really.

I do very much see the "lore" behind this event, the empires are starting to crumble and what not, and I think many empire players do start to see that, but a hell of a lot involved wont see the "empires" at fault but CCP, and rightfully so.

Everyone keeps asking the empire forces "What did you expect" nah thats the wrong people to be asking.

CCP should be the ones answering that question, what exactly did they expect to happen.

The answer either shows the live event team are either completely clueless on the game mechanics as well as anything about nulsec... or
They really did just organise an event for thousands of clueless highbears to be effortlessly slaughtered by nulsec players, and yes I do also live in nul more than FW, and seriously nulbuds, chestbeating about the turkey shoot is beneath the skills and accomplishments of being in null.
Octoven
Stellar Production
#845 - 2013-11-10 07:16:38 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Trii Seo wrote:
Confirming Asbjrn is a very bad person.

That said, the announcement from CCP even said that it was likely to be dangerous and that there will be a retaliation.

Plus, we're not a third party. We were there for our serpentis bros. CFC + Serpentis = best friends forever <3


Since you have utterly failed at reading comprehension let me enlighten you as to the actual thrust of most of the 'high sec' complaints.

CCP told us where to stage, no further information until after the event had started. We were staged 20-40 jumps from the end destination (Sarum Prime people had to move about 40 overall). Then gave only intermediate destinations along the way with limited options of routes.
Fleets moving along those routes were typically in 10% TiDi. Individuals could obviously break out faster but moving in a coherent fleet that wasn't going to get ganked 1 by 1 meant TiDi.
CCP then started the 'event' well before any of the fleets from high sec had a chance of getting to their destinations, had the Empire flee from the field mere minutes after, & declared the event ended entirely before most fleets were even into null sec.

In contrast, the 'pirates' got staged one system from the destination, and local sov holders already had large forces in the doril region due to existing fighting.

Meaning that the 2000+ (I'd say 3000+ initially from what I saw) High sec players who were attempting to attend the event got denied by CCP's decision on starting & finishing the event before they could even get near the target system due to TiDi warps along a massive convoy route.
That is what the rage is about. It's not tears over loosing ships, every fleet I know of was advised they would loose ships, anyone who asked in Live Events before hand was told they would almost certainly be going to Low or Null by older hands at Live Events. But we expected the opportunity to at least participate in the event, not be denied simply because CCP couldn't be bothered to give us the time to get there when they had to know how long it would take us.


I would just like to state for the record that the route from Sarum Prime to the destination system was NOT 40 ******* jumps. It was 23 to ihal and 5 more to the destination...if my math is correct hat is 28 bloody jumps NOT 40. Quit ******* exagerating, honestly that is a prime example of idiocy at its best. i arrived in Sarum Prime 20 minutes early, system filled and went into tidi. When I read the tweet I immediately moved out, didnt wait for conformation and as a result traveled 23 jumps where only 4 systems were TiDi rest were plain jane travel. I followed FC orders, I joined CCP's fleet, I brought an appropriate ship, and this amazing thing happened. I survived long enough to reach the facility and get some shots on it before i died.

Some people were bringing ******* battleships, shuttles, and noobs ships as if they were just going to innocently watch the event in hostile space. Common sense says if your destination is null sec that there WILL be bubbles. Sooo dont bring a ******* battleship that is slow and cant burn out of them, bring a cruiser with MWD. It doesnt take rocket science here. As for information available...live events arent supposed to be CCP guiding you 100% of the way. Live events is a situation where CCP introduces a catalyst situation, an event that kicks off some conflict (be it pve, pvp, or both) and then allows the players to mold the event and its outcome.

I think CCP did their job here, they got the fleets together, they had a goal...reach the research facility, they disclosed the fact that we WOULD be going into hostile space...null sec, they gave commands in each phase (like saying there is a massive bubbled camp on the other side of this gate, jump through and burn out of bubbles and warp.) You want CCP to bridge you from high sec to destination system bypassing any threats just so you can bash a facility in under 20 minutes? Seriously mate, you need to find another game.
Octoven
Stellar Production
#846 - 2013-11-10 07:18:31 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Raneru wrote:
Well I had a blast during the event, literally. Our lowsec system was on the shortest route to utopia, much camping fun was had Pirate. The entry gate was littered with wrecks. It was estimated that we had over 115 kills.

Great event, would participate again :)

Congratulations, you had a gate camp. Still doesn't make it a Live Event.

From the PvP side, sure, PvP happened. From the Live Event side, it was a major screw up since the lore got made to look like a joke by CCP from this event. They should have written a chronicle & just run a massive PvP event.


It was indeed a live event, live events arent supposed to be like watching a film, you have to be involved. I think a lot of players are confused on what a live event actually is. It is lore happening live while players have a chance to participate OR ruin it. That choice is the fundamental concept for a sandbox game like eve. To deny that choice would make it NOT a live event.
Octoven
Stellar Production
#847 - 2013-11-10 07:22:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Octoven
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Raneru wrote:
Back in 2005 there was a nullsec event to stop serpentis stealing a titan. As a newb I went out there in an incursus with whatever crap was in my hanger thrown onto it to participate. First attempt, I was killed by a torp raven. Second attempt I got to it and fired a few shots off before being blown up and podded.

Bad time? I loved it! I found a nullsec corp to move to a few weeks later.

There will be scores of new players who will get into null as a result of this event. Not because it went successfully and they returned rich but because it was scary and challenging.


No, there won't. You know why there won't?
Because in 2005 you actually got to the event.
This time, the new players didn't get to the event, the event got declared finished before they even made it.
And half of them got killed in gate camps on the way that weren't exciting, were just instant death.

2005 null was entirely different environment to 2013 null sorry to say & the event was dramatically different as well.


Just to clarify on this fact 2005 did not have NEARLY as many players attending these events as there are now. This presents a problem when 4-5000 people want to run an event in 2 systems. You didnt get to the event before it was declared finished...I was in luminere before it started, server restarted and when i logged in i couldnt get in the system, as a result I couldnt do that event even though I was there on time. However, I will tell you what I didn't do, come ranting on the forums about how unfair and a disadvantage it was. I accepted the fact I could not run the event and moved on.

The amount of wailing and gnashing of teeth over this event is just a prime example of how a lot of player who play this game anymore expect CCP to solve their issues for them rather then empowering themselves to do it.
Cpt Tenguru37
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#848 - 2013-11-10 07:24:07 UTC
Quote:
When I read the tweet I immediately moved out

This is the point twitter was not stated as a requirement of the event... But like you I read it and moved out.
Octoven
Stellar Production
#849 - 2013-11-10 07:30:38 UTC
Cpt Tenguru37 wrote:
Quote:
When I read the tweet I immediately moved out

This is the point twitter was not stated as a requirement of the event... But like you I read it and moved out.


The eveonline website is not a requirement to participate in the event either, but if you want information and you want to stay on top of **** you browse there and read...just like twitter.
Killerjock
Von Neumann Industries
#850 - 2013-11-10 08:19:53 UTC
Trii Seo wrote:
To be honest, if you even burned towards the destination trying to avoid the pirates and stop the Serpentis you were there.


It's fun that you say so - you were not travelilng with us, were you?

So now since you can't actually find an argument to oppose our complaints, you now turn to saying "it's as it should be because the RP reasons are those" - well, in my opinion this is even worse.
Being incompetent can happen - everyone fucks up every once in a while.
DELIBERATELY setting up 2000+ players to act as NPC would be an insult. I do not play CCP to use me as entertainment for others. If that IS the case, CCP went far beyond a **** up.

Quote:
No ... quite a few people in my fleet logged out and went and got their null alts because they realised the whole exercise was idiotic and they would never get there in time with the highsec fleets.


Exactly my point.

Quote:
I'm almost sorry I missed it. But then I've died in enough nullsec gate-camps to 100man blobs that I would probably not have experienced anything new.


Another of our point of contention.

Quote:
Care bears, It may come at the end of a sharp tongue, but notice that our advice is....play more Eve, get better at Eve, make friends to fly with, come back and give us a good fight. That is hardly negative feedback, even if delivered in bittervet voice-over.


That's good advice. But it has nothing to do with a live event.

Be extra sure that if I'm ever part of a "retaliation" force, you'll have to know that we're coming through your intel - and not on twitter; you won't know 24hrs before where we're staging or what route we'll take... and sure as hell we won't slowboat 23 jumps with the entire fleet through hostile territory! :P

Quote:
It should encourage people to PvP, not discourage them.


If all of them were experienced enough to know what happened, yes. This has no impact on my perception of PVP, because I've done it before at different levels.
But consider half of those 2000 got there and did not realize what happened. Might be hard to go so far back, but if you think about your first fleet fights, how much of what happened did you really perceive?
These guys went there for an event and found themselves slaughtered by a superior force in terms of ships (most of us were flying lolfitted cheapships), of numbers (since we got there "trickling"), and of organization (that was quite obvious).

There was no event for most of us. We can have that kind of **** any day - and have a better time: we'll organize with friends or come soloing, without advertising the time and place 2 hours in advance.
ScoRpS
Moist Wanted.
OnlyFleets.
#851 - 2013-11-10 08:25:31 UTC
We all knew it was going to be in or near Utopia in Curse because of the announcement. We also knew when many hours in advance.

A simple inspection of the in game map would have revealed that Senday is only 2 jumps from ihal in hi sec and along with Doril, Utopia, Jorund, Litom and Hemin all sport NPC stations with a good local market. Hemin and Litom also have cloning facilities and as such there probably isn't another null sec area quite so user friendly in all of Eve and was probably chosen because of this. The final system R-MOC has no stations and this is potentially perfect for an all out brawl.

It is beyond me that with all this information at hand folks still chose to form up in hi sec and move in a completely inappropriate fleet size to a few different staging systems,suffering TDI all the way. And also monitoring Twitter for updates?? before trying to enter Curse in a such massive and attractive blob? Safety in numbers perhaps? in all honesty i am really surprised that we didn't see SC hot drops.

If you have cussed at CCP for a poor event here then shame on you for being a complete mindless lemming and expecting support for your insane expectations from anyone who actually knows what Eve is. CCP are not FC's or military genius's and if you've ever attended any of there other events or tests you would know this. They give us the toys to have a good time and how we use them is up to us.

Thanks CCP for trying and don't let the insane posts in this thread put you off doing it again. We need more of these.
Josef Djugashvilis
#852 - 2013-11-10 09:02:10 UTC
Hmm, forum ate my post.

This issue really should be fixed by CCP.

This is not a signature.

Goeben II
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#853 - 2013-11-10 10:51:01 UTC
I just want to thank CCP, with their recent live event, for helping me realize that this game no longer has anything left for me. My only complaint is that this "live event" was way to elaborate. You could have simply sent me an email telling me to " **** off " and I assure you I would have gotten the hint. Thanks again and have another shot on me.
Alice Ituin
Doomheim
#854 - 2013-11-10 11:02:10 UTC
Octoven wrote:
You want CCP to bridge you from high sec to destination system bypassing any threats just so you can bash a facility in under 20 minutes? Seriously mate, you need to find another game a nullbear alliance.


fixed
Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#855 - 2013-11-10 11:20:54 UTC
Lord Xander wrote:
The PitBoss wrote:
Subject says it all.

10% Tidi 5 j out to rally point (Sarum Prime)

10% Tidi the 16 j to the second rally point (Ihal)

Tidi the few jumps to the last destination ... by then i was numb and not paying attention




No real communication from gm/event host

Lots of secrecy on locations apparently to keep people from ruining the event

ONLY to include those people in the end.

I want that hour of my life refunded to me Shocked



Good Job CCP ...




NEXT time just open a wormhole and let people drop in


PS: Please point me in the direction of this post to remind me why I shouldnt bother in another live event ...



thats like evry day in 0.0, and you are welcom.
see you on the next one. <3


So, people should be as dumb as you are and pay for such shoddy quality game time every day?

Nope, people have better things to do than perma-TiDi, headless directions and F1 hotkey driven blobbing.
epicurus ataraxia
Illusion of Solitude.
Illusion of Solitude
#856 - 2013-11-10 11:25:01 UTC  |  Edited by: epicurus ataraxia
Hopefully CCP WILL answer the issues raised, but just trying to get through what really happened here without nullsqwark and leetspeak.

The expectation was this would be more like an organised event like a school trip, where you expect the teachers to manage the risk while giving you the feeling of having an adventure.

What actually happened,was if it happened on Earth, the pupils were marched from Paris to vienna and spread out all in a line, when they reached there, they were then marched into Russia, and dumped into the siege of Stalingrad.

And then expecting them to appreciate Russian culture and cuisine.

Yeah, that worked out well.

The fault begins and ends with the organisers, I am disgusted with the attitude and culture of blaming the victim.

There is one EvE. Many people. Many lifestyles. WE are EvE

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#857 - 2013-11-10 11:38:21 UTC
There's a common thread here from a few people (I'm not going to single anyone out with a quote) that all the hisec players who joined the event needed to read, research, and play more so that they could make the event more entertaining for themselves.

If you're saying that to play EVE, you need to make sure it is your first and only hobby, so much so that you'll have to do forum and intel research just to make it to a live event before it's over, you've been in null too long. Plenty of us play EVE once or twice a week for a few hours because we have other things to do. When CCP makes an event and invites people in, they can't believe their luck that they'll get to do something. When they say they're leading them into nullsec, they're ecstatic that they're finally going to get to go into null and see what it's like.

When CCP has an ADD moment and just forgets about leading the fleet, and they essentially lose their ships in one shot to an orchestrated gate camp after hours of just trying to get from gate to gate, at best, they're going to be utterly disappointed and wonder what the point of nullsec play actually is. At worst, they're going to figure that is the endgame and be done with EVE altogether.

I mean, if you didn't want those people playing, then that's fine. But those people have a right to be absolutely disgusted with CCP's handling of the event and its aftermath, and I can't really blame them if they just write off nullsec as a boring, time-dilated mess rather than the barren desert that it usually is.

Either way, I can't imagine that pissing off a significant portion of their subscription holders was what CCP wanted to do with this event and the blame for it falls squarely on their shoulders. They were the ones who organized the fleet, they were the ones with the NPC FCs, they were the ones who are ultimately to blame when the fleet had a massive logistics deficiency. Really, the logistics are what everyone is complaining about. They understood that they were flying into a place they would almost certainly lose their ship in, they just didn't figure CCP would make sure they took hours to never reach the target, and then that they would mostly lose their ships in the kinds of gate camps they could just as easily have flown into themselves on a Thursday night if they'd really felt like it.

Can you really ask the people who were there to learn more about the game so that it's more fun next time? Why on Earth would anyone who just experienced nullsec for the first time that way ever bother? If anything, CCP just exacerbated the problem they have where people who aren't into nonstop FFA PVP are staying in hisec or finding more versatile games to play.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#858 - 2013-11-10 11:43:09 UTC  |  Edited by: Vaerah Vahrokha
epicurus ataraxia wrote:

The fault begins and ends with the organisers, I am disgusted with the attitude and culture of blaming the victim.


Well, blaming the victim is the most popular sport to find excuses to make violence to women, why do you think they'd think different in something as unimportant as a game?


I have not read most of this thread because it's easy to imagine what's written.

The truth? There's been some studies that proved that failure leaves a 2.8 times stronger memories than success. This is of course a genetic derived safeguard mechanism (pushing living beings at strongly avoiding the dangers).

So, if you take 3,000 guys with neutral expectations about EvE and subject them to a slaugther with no way to defend or retaliate, all you'll get is some hundreds who will want to try again but thousands that will hate the experience and become even more "uncurable and strenghtened" hi-seccers.

So, if CCP's plans were to make more players become true adventurers (RP and not), they F A I L E D big time.
Kappy Ukap
K For Kill
#859 - 2013-11-10 11:44:47 UTC
CCP still hasn't given an apology yet for all of this.

I know many newbies who started EVE recently quitted due to the result of this event.

What the solution might be is to all gather up and protest like people did when they were not happy with Incarna. Remember by slowing down the servers deliberately to protest about it?
Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#860 - 2013-11-10 11:46:11 UTC
Kappy Ukap wrote:
. Remember by slowing down the servers deliberately to protest about it?


These days that's not called a protest. These days it's simply playing the game. TiDi slows it for you. Pirate