These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Odyssey] Faction Navy Frigates

First post
Author
Kethry Avenger
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#341 - 2013-04-09 03:41:05 UTC
So if the Slicer won't go to a 2/3/5 or 3/3/4 fitting layout, when you get a chance think you could add some new navy frigates with the Imperial Navy one having 3 mids? Thanks!
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#342 - 2013-04-10 21:03:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Fredfredbug4
Please give the Federation Navy Comet it's blinking light and old "police car" skin back.

Do that and the ship will be perfect.

http://eve.aeonoftime.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/Federation-Navy-Comet-Side.jpg

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Maegor Stark
State War Academy
Caldari State
#343 - 2013-04-15 11:25:56 UTC
Imho Firetail should, instead of recieving a HP bonus recieve a bigger buff to CPU.

It has 4 Mid-slots so very much use for it.

Just compare it to other frigates:
(new) Firetail: 150tf CPU

FN Comet : 3 mids but 160tf CPU.
Condor: 4 mid but 185tf (!) CPU.
Merlin: 4 mid but 180tf CPU.


Imho the Minmatar Faction frig could use more flexibility (in fitting) instead of being buffed in the tank department. Right now I could imagine a whole bunch of interesting fittings that would be nice to fly but simply arent possible (unless maybe with Deadspace modules).

Try fitting a 200mm AC + TD Slasher for example ...
Naomi Anthar
#344 - 2013-04-16 11:35:18 UTC
Well Fozzie you said you cannot give Slicer 3rd MID ... and i understand why - it could be overpowered. But what about then give it 6th low, because with all honesty i can tell you that nobody wants that utility high on slicer !
Nyancat Audeles
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#345 - 2013-04-16 22:05:38 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Please give the Federation Navy Comet it's blinking light and old "police car" skin back.

Do that and the ship will be perfect.

http://eve.aeonoftime.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/Federation-Navy-Comet-Side.jpg


That's Amarr design language. Get a Slicer instead.
Nyancat Audeles
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#346 - 2013-04-16 22:18:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Nyancat Audeles
Naomi Anthar wrote:
Well Fozzie you said you cannot give Slicer 3rd MID ... and i understand why - it could be overpowered. But what about then give it 6th low, because with all honesty i can tell you that nobody wants that utility high on slicer !

This... that utility high is absolutely useless, no one ever uses it. It's pointless on a kiting frig. And a 6th low would maintain the role of the Slicer as a kiter.
Madbuster73
State War Academy
Caldari State
#347 - 2013-04-18 23:41:31 UTC
Nyancat Audeles wrote:
Naomi Anthar wrote:
Well Fozzie you said you cannot give Slicer 3rd MID ... and i understand why - it could be overpowered. But what about then give it 6th low, because with all honesty i can tell you that nobody wants that utility high on slicer !

This... that utility high is absolutely useless, no one ever uses it. It's pointless on a kiting frig. And a 6th low would maintain the role of the Slicer as a kiter.



especially if you consider that they are nerfing Tracking Enhancers so kiting will not work on a slicer anyway....
Naomi Anthar
#348 - 2013-04-21 22:49:40 UTC
I'm saying it again and i expect answer CCP. Give Slicer 6th low if you cannot give it 3rd mid. And if not tell me why. Because i tell you why we don't need utility high.
Taoist Dragon
Okata Syndicate
#349 - 2013-04-21 23:15:10 UTC
Bah slicer is fine.

It is powerful in its role. The TE adjustment won't hurt it a great deal. The 'utility' high allows the few of use who dare to try alternitive fits. Leave it there Fozzie and don't pander to the uninformed masses trying to force it into one role and one role only.

Good to see the firetail get some love and it should be a good boat with the new stats, not OP be able to compete nicely.

That is the Way, the Tao.

Balance is everything.

Zelarrs Elkoth
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#350 - 2013-04-26 01:47:33 UTC
Taoist Dragon wrote:
Bah slicer is fine.

It is powerful in its role. The TE adjustment won't hurt it a great deal. The 'utility' high allows the few of use who dare to try alternitive fits. Leave it there Fozzie and don't pander to the uninformed masses trying to force it into one role and one role only.

Good to see the firetail get some love and it should be a good boat with the new stats, not OP be able to compete nicely.


You know your comment would make more sense if you actually flew the slicer:

http://eve-kill.net/?a=pilot_detail&plt_id=926260&view=ships_weapons&m=04&y=2013

I fly the slicer (less often these days) and a neut or vamp in the utility high is a poor substitute for having a decent ewar/tackle compliment in mids.

A little more fitting room is nice, but I don't think the proposed "buff" will make this slicer superior to most t1 frigates, let alone the other Navy's. Particularly this heavily buffed firetail.

I think post count on this thread is another indication that these Navy Frigates are mediocre at best.

Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Captain, Head of Diplomacy, Recruiting Officer Contact on channel: "PIE Public" "I walk the razor's edge of embracing the future while protecting what we value of the past."

Rita Jita
Caldari Provisions
#351 - 2013-04-29 11:16:29 UTC
if only the firetail had a falloff bonus instead of tracking, it might actually be useful ship to fly.

need more ships able to mwd kite outside of scram range, minmatar is all about kiting

Founder of the "Haulers Channel"

Come Check It Out

Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#352 - 2013-04-29 12:58:10 UTC
Taoist Dragon wrote:
Bah slicer is fine.

It is powerful in its role. The TE adjustment won't hurt it a great deal. The 'utility' high allows the few of use who dare to try alternitive fits. Leave it there Fozzie and don't pander to the uninformed masses trying to force it into one role and one role only.

Good to see the firetail get some love and it should be a good boat with the new stats, not OP be able to compete nicely.

Ever tried using that utility high for something constructive on a brawler fit?
Neut is ineffective as the ships against which it might have value all have 3+ midslots and thus either superior range control or an injector.
Nos is ineffective as the few cycles you get out of it over the duration of the average frigate brawl adds a woefully small amount of cap. In fact, by the time your oversized capacitor (look at it, its HUGE!) is even ready to gain from a nos the fight is close to finished anyway.

If the utility was moved to the mid rack on the other hand you suddenly get eWar for kiting, injector/web for brawling or all the other goodies that one can get from that glorious rack.
If the utility was moved to the low rack the effect would be similar albeit not as focused or effective, but more speed/damage/tracking/cap/tank are all options.
In short: The utility on the Slicer is a wasted slot. Even if used as sink for laser heat one still has to repair after each fight.
Rita Jita wrote:
...need more ships able to mwd kite outside of scram range, minmatar was all about kiting

Fixed it for you Smile


Jonas Sukarala
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#353 - 2013-04-29 18:32:34 UTC
CCP
I hope when you get to pirate frigs you will give them the extra slot... they would benefit from having the extra slot for the myriad of bonuses they get for e-war

'Tech3 ships need to be put down, like a rabid dog drooling everywhere in the house, they are out of line' CCP Ytterbium Nerf missile range into place where is the TD missile change?  ..projectiles should use capacitor. ABC's should be T2 HABC and nerf web strength its still too high

Akirei Scytale
Okami Syndicate
#354 - 2013-04-30 04:58:47 UTC
Rita Jita wrote:
if only the firetail had a falloff bonus instead of tracking, it might actually be useful ship to fly.

need more ships able to mwd kite outside of scram range, minmatar is all about kiting


Just dual prop kite inside scram range. The firetail is exceedingly good at maintaining range and controlling the pace of a fight, even when webbed and scrammed.

Hell, I don't even fit a web on mine and have kept range when fighting ships with webs + scrams.
Colt Blackhawk
Doomheim
#355 - 2013-04-30 06:48:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Colt Blackhawk
Okay...
after playing with eft and with my own experience I have only to say: Total c...p.
Point.


Slicer is still too weak. There isnt even 1 possible slicer fit that could kill a 150mm rail buffer comet.
Hook will be castrated to brawler because it is too slow and unmaneuverable for kiting (yep I am VERY experienced with the hook).
Of course booster fags have the possibility to kite even with a noobship^^
Still don´t get any hook/slicer brawler/kiter fit that would survive a 10.5 ehp 165dps 150rail-comet...
Firetail... no clue...

But the comet is overoveroverpowered.
After overpowered algos + overpowered tristan... oh yeah I forgot we are going towards gallente online.

edit: only hook I can imagine that is able to survive a 150mm rail armor buffer comet is maybe a double td brawler. Maybe. It would be extremely tight.

[09:04:53] Ashira Twilight > Plant the f****** amarr flag and s*** on their smoking wrecks.

Andrea Griffin
#356 - 2013-04-30 12:18:50 UTC
The Firetail has always been the worst of the faction frigates. It really needs some extra oomph to make it competitive with the others. I think that a little extra damage, or the ability to fit a third turret, or some extra speed / agility, or an extra low slot would go a long, long way to giving this ship enough to be competitive.
Taoist Dragon
Okata Syndicate
#357 - 2013-04-30 21:40:51 UTC
Zelarrs Elkoth wrote:
Taoist Dragon wrote:
Bah slicer is fine.

It is powerful in its role. The TE adjustment won't hurt it a great deal. The 'utility' high allows the few of use who dare to try alternitive fits. Leave it there Fozzie and don't pander to the uninformed masses trying to force it into one role and one role only.

Good to see the firetail get some love and it should be a good boat with the new stats, not OP be able to compete nicely.


You know your comment would make more sense if you actually flew the slicer:

http://eve-kill.net/?a=pilot_detail&plt_id=926260&view=ships_weapons&m=04&y=2013

I fly the slicer (less often these days) and a neut or vamp in the utility high is a poor substitute for having a decent ewar/tackle compliment in mids.

A little more fitting room is nice, but I don't think the proposed "buff" will make this slicer superior to most t1 frigates, let alone the other Navy's. Particularly this heavily buffed firetail.

I think post count on this thread is another indication that these Navy Frigates are mediocre at best.


Awe Boo f'king Hoo!

Someone brought up my stats on eve kill, Yeehaw that mean everything!

You do realise that that is the stats for last month only don't you?

For the record the slicer is my 16th most used ship. the details which I keep for MY records only on my own personal KB.

Now that aside.

I often flew the slicer in a brawling configuration in a similar manner to how I fly my punishers which is my 4th overall ship used. The slicer makes a passable brawler if you don't mind actually commiting to a fight. People just need to think outside the box and not be a sheep!

The firetail will ne a nice ship with these changes. Competant pilots may even make it seem OP as if you can fly them now they can kill a lot of **** handlily as they are. But the the general pilot they will be competative but not OP with is where I feel most of the frig world (T1 & navy) is at currently.
All the posts about 'oh no my XXX is getting owned by YYY' are pretty much people not fully uderstanding the weaknesses of their chosen ship and fitting/flying accordingly.

That is the Way, the Tao.

Balance is everything.

Colt Blackhawk
Doomheim
#358 - 2013-05-01 10:09:12 UTC  |  Edited by: Colt Blackhawk
Firetail:
[scram web ab armor td]
Damage Control II
Gyrostabilizer II
400mm Reinforced Rolled Tungsten Plates I
1MN Afterburner II
Balmer Series Tracking Disruptor I,Optimal Range Disruption Script
Faint Epsilon Warp Scrambler I
X5 Prototype Engine Enervator
150mm Light AutoCannon II,Barrage S
150mm Light AutoCannon II,Barrage S

Small Trimark Armor Pump I
Small Trimark Armor Pump I
Small Trimark Armor Pump I

Almost 150dps with repfl phased plasma, 8.7k ehp. TD, Scram, web.

There is no, really no slicer fit that can kill that thing.
Kiter slicer will get td on it and will get scrammed+webbed when getting in range--> Kiter slicer dead.
Brawler slicer (10.5 ehp, 172 dps imp navy multi) will have the following problem: No range control. Firetail will orbit with scramweb+ trackdis script at 500 and the slicer won´t hit sh...

I am not saying the RFF desn´t need a buff. The buff is okay and really needed.
Comet is completely okay as it is. Really doesn´t need a buff.
But the slicer needs a lot more buff. Liquidate the 3rd high and give it a 3rd med. Otherwise it will be worst navy frig.

[09:04:53] Ashira Twilight > Plant the f****** amarr flag and s*** on their smoking wrecks.

Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#359 - 2013-05-01 13:04:17 UTC
Yeah, few realise what power that 4th mid on the Tail gives them .. was an absolute thrill/horror to fight before (mainly because only good pilots flew it, the ones in the know) and will be the biggest damn pain in the arse with more more damage .. mainly because more are likely to try it out.

Much like the early Hooks that flew around, was the elite doing it to start and when the rabble saw what can be done with five mids on a frig the bandwagon needed several more carriages to hold all the people swarming it.

Comet could do with a little less grid though, the sacrifice for oversizing the plate (yes, 400 on a frig is oversized!) are way too light, should be a choice between downgrading guns or using a second fitting mod/rig.

Yes please to finding somewhere else to put that Slicer utility .. or rather what is the antonym of utility, because it is never actually used now that everything of value for a frig can be found with onboard scanner (used to online/offline a probe launcher as needed).
Colt Blackhawk
Doomheim
#360 - 2013-05-03 09:51:28 UTC  |  Edited by: Colt Blackhawk
Seems that thread is dead anyways :P
Even thinking about selling my remaining hooks before the big firetail/comet dominance comes.

edit:
[Rail]
Micro Auxiliary Power Core II
Damage Control II
400mm Reinforced Rolled Tungsten Plates I
Adaptive Nano Plating II
1MN Afterburner II
X5 Prototype Engine Enervator
Warp Scrambler II
150mm Railgun II,Caldari Navy Antimatter Charge S
150mm Railgun II,Caldari Navy Antimatter Charge S

Small Trimark Armor Pump I
Small Trimark Armor Pump I
Small Anti-Explosive Pump I
Drones_Active=Hobgoblin II,3

163dps, 10.3k ehp.... even harder than firetail.

[09:04:53] Ashira Twilight > Plant the f****** amarr flag and s*** on their smoking wrecks.