These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

CSM The Mittani's Misconduct Calls for Resignation - We Did It!

First post First post
Author
MotherMoon
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#1801 - 2012-03-27 02:50:54 UTC  |  Edited by: MotherMoon
agreed kick that ******* out

Noted, i voted for him, but ti sets a bad president. I'm sure he knows it too. He also knows he would still have a powerful voice on the CSM, he just has to live up the power to be a public figure.

point is, pure and simple he deserves to lose his position, or else PR for the CSM turns the CSM into a joke that is pro-bully. not pro-fake bullying in eve online. But real cyber bullying.

http://dl.eve-files.com/media/1206/scimi.jpg

Shade Severii
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#1802 - 2012-03-27 02:50:58 UTC
Ranger 1 wrote:
Silas Kautsuo wrote:
Kyle Yanowski wrote:
Algia Knightstorm wrote:
There can't possibly be this many ***** ass faggots who play Eve online. The guy Mittens called out needs to harden the **** up, you butthurt faggots need to harden the **** up and go back to your asteroid mining, no one gives a ****.


Feller. You know nothing of being hard. Even hard men break.


I do hope none of those defending the incitement or who find it funny every have to deal with depression or anxiety, I wouldn't wish that on anyone, though maybe then they might get some perspective on why Mittani's actions weren't acceptable.


Wow.

Depression nor anxiety were the issue. Being pissed off at losing 20 odd Macks and wanting the Goons to feel bad about it was the cause of the original EVE Mail.

The Mittani has seen hundreds of similar EVE mails. Hell, I personally have seen dozens through out the years and I don't go out of my way to kill anyone I'm not at war or red to.

This was correctly identified, laughed about, and filed away... but was classic enough to be used as a bad (and admittedly inappropriate) joke long after the incident happened.

YouTube and EVE Files are filled with video's depicting similar events, and they are funny as hell in a mean sort of way.

No poor suicidal victim was cyber bullied here, in fact no bullying of any kind happened here, feel free to ask him yourself.

If The Wiz is fine with the apology and 10 bil, it's really time to shut the hell up about it.


Its because this is clearly NOT about the wis or wanting an apology. Welcome to the internet.
Shandir
EVE University
Ivy League
#1803 - 2012-03-27 02:55:32 UTC
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.
Kyle Yanowski
Malevelon Roe Industries
Convocation of Empyreans
#1804 - 2012-03-27 03:00:48 UTC
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.


I missed it as I dove head first in this thread. Mittani posted his apology. I won't say anything else other than, go read it.... And learn from it.

Host of the High Drag Eve Online Podcast ( http://highdrag.wordpress.com). Director of Aideron Robotics.

Cipher Jones
The Thomas Edwards Taco Tuesday All Stars
#1805 - 2012-03-27 03:02:54 UTC
School Nickname Worldmonkey wrote:
Cipher Jones wrote:
School Nickname Worldmonkey wrote:
The double standards of these pubbies who scream for Mittani to be lynched is abhorrent. Mittens has lain himself prostrate before you and you ask for him to be banned, while those in Raiden and literally driven another player to suicide receive your undying admiration.

You pubbies are a thundering disgrace.


You can talk all the **** you want but your alliance leader has publicly disgraced himself, as have many of your members. Diversion is a sad tactic.


At least he has manned up and taken responsibility for his actions, something that Raiden. and pubbies will never ever do. We take our losses and don't cry about it.


He has done no such thing. Thankfully, it will be forced upon him.

Also, you have been crying about it for about a hundred pages now. That's a matter of public record and all.

internet spaceships

are serious business sir.

and don't forget it

GeeShizzle MacCloud
#1806 - 2012-03-27 03:03:21 UTC
yahh tbh just to get the record straight it wasnt the public addressing of the wis' personal eve mail that is at fault, its the incitement by the mittani of... 'if you want to find the guy and make him kill himself his name is...' comment.

being bad at the game and getting trolled comes with the territory in eve, but inciting that course of action when you've been flown out at the expense of CCP to be the lead elected representative of their customers is seriously out of line.
Anya Klibor
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#1807 - 2012-03-27 03:03:28 UTC
Let me relate a story.

In 2008 I was the acting company commander for our battalion's service and support company. We had a Marine I knew about who was suicidal because his girlfriend of six years had been sleeping around while he was deployed. He'd thoroughly loved her and was devastated when he found this out. This Marine was exemplary, and in great health - both mentally and physically - before all this happened. In classic Marine fashion, several of his NCOs said that he didn't have the balls to pull the trigger. They didn't care about him, and they openly mocked him for it.

He checked out his personal sidearm to "clean". It was a .45-caliber pistol. Instead of bringing it to the range, he brought it back to his barracks room and loaded it. We were lucky that the corporal on duty realized what he had and called both myself and the Provost Marshall's Office before he could do anything. I was the only one allowed through the cordon without a badge, because as his company's executive officer and acting company commander, I wanted to be there in case I could help. I considered this man one of my few friends in the Marines, and I didn't like the idea of him pulling the trigger and taking his own life.

He eventually calmed down enough that I was able to walk into his room, unarmed. I had PMO stay back. He was on the first deck of the barracks. He was relating everything, and he simply said, "I want to pull this trigger and just end it." One of the NCOs who had been ragging on him the entire time yelled, "Then do it you ******* *****!" I have never moved so fast in my life. As he brought the gun up, I bolted to him and wrestled for the gun.

He pulled the trigger. Luckily I was the one he shot. Blew out my shoulder when he did, but PMO was quick to rush in when he fired, and they got the gun away from him.

This Marine was exemplary, and I refused to have charges pressed on him. To my knowledge, he continues to serve in uniform, though he was very close to being medically discharged. He was a Lance Corporal, and he's a Staff Sergeant now. He regularly tells his story during suicide prevention classes, and i'd like to think he makes a difference.

But the point of this story is, something as simple as a little ragging can lead to someone going through with the action. Not everyone has someone who can stop them right then and there, and plenty of suicides happen annually.

We are a cruel group of people. We play EVE because it is cruel/ We do everything we can to hurt other people in this game, and many times it goes beyond the game's confines. We are callous to one another because the game allows it. But the problem is, many people don't seem to get that there are lines, and the line was crossed. It's clear those of you supporting Mittens have never witnessed someone take their own life, and most of you don't get that this isn't a laughing matter. Undoubtedly this post will not receive likes, and the only mention it will get is a quote from a Goon followed by "lol u suck". But as a Marine and a human being with empathy, I can tell you that you are scum if you think this is funny, for whatever the reason. If you consider this acceptable, then the problem isn't the people who get suicidal over internet pixel. The problem is you.

Leadership is something you learn. Maybe one day, you'll learn that.

Shandir
EVE University
Ivy League
#1808 - 2012-03-27 03:08:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Shandir
Kyle Yanowski wrote:
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.


I missed it as I dove head first in this thread. Mittani posted his apology. I won't say anything else other than, go read it.... And learn from it.


I've already read his apology, and as I said in reply - if it's honest, it's respectable, but the persona he has spent years building up makes it difficult to swallow. It is fitting with his persona, and the persona who did the thing we're all quite upset about, to apologize with a delicately worded post, quite convincingly, and mean not a word of it. For all the rest of us know, he could be posting on the goon forums about how funny it is that CCP made him apologize. This is not tinfoil hattery, it is simply The Mittani he has showed us through his words and actions.
I do not believe that his apology is sincere unless there is action to back it up. What is effectively pocket change to his character does not count, by the way.

This is the problem with convincing the entire game he's an *******. He's very good at using his words and actions convincing us of that. He's worked very hard, and now when he wants everyone to believe it's just a mask, words are not enough.
He might be a nice guy in RL, when the persona drops, but as far as most of us can tell - the words during the Alliance Panel ring truer than the ones he's posted now.
Kyle Yanowski
Malevelon Roe Industries
Convocation of Empyreans
#1809 - 2012-03-27 03:10:19 UTC
Anya Klibor wrote:
Let me relate a story.

In 2008 I was the acting company commander for our battalion's service and support company. We had a Marine I knew about who was suicidal because his girlfriend of six years had been sleeping around while he was deployed. He'd thoroughly loved her and was devastated when he found this out. This Marine was exemplary, and in great health - both mentally and physically - before all this happened. In classic Marine fashion, several of his NCOs said that he didn't have the balls to pull the trigger. They didn't care about him, and they openly mocked him for it.

He checked out his personal sidearm to "clean". It was a .45-caliber pistol. Instead of bringing it to the range, he brought it back to his barracks room and loaded it. We were lucky that the corporal on duty realized what he had and called both myself and the Provost Marshall's Office before he could do anything. I was the only one allowed through the cordon without a badge, because as his company's executive officer and acting company commander, I wanted to be there in case I could help. I considered this man one of my few friends in the Marines, and I didn't like the idea of him pulling the trigger and taking his own life.

He eventually calmed down enough that I was able to walk into his room, unarmed. I had PMO stay back. He was on the first deck of the barracks. He was relating everything, and he simply said, "I want to pull this trigger and just end it." One of the NCOs who had been ragging on him the entire time yelled, "Then do it you ******* *****!" I have never moved so fast in my life. As he brought the gun up, I bolted to him and wrestled for the gun.

He pulled the trigger. Luckily I was the one he shot. Blew out my shoulder when he did, but PMO was quick to rush in when he fired, and they got the gun away from him.

This Marine was exemplary, and I refused to have charges pressed on him. To my knowledge, he continues to serve in uniform, though he was very close to being medically discharged. He was a Lance Corporal, and he's a Staff Sergeant now. He regularly tells his story during suicide prevention classes, and i'd like to think he makes a difference.

But the point of this story is, something as simple as a little ragging can lead to someone going through with the action. Not everyone has someone who can stop them right then and there, and plenty of suicides happen annually.

We are a cruel group of people. We play EVE because it is cruel/ We do everything we can to hurt other people in this game, and many times it goes beyond the game's confines. We are callous to one another because the game allows it. But the problem is, many people don't seem to get that there are lines, and the line was crossed. It's clear those of you supporting Mittens have never witnessed someone take their own life, and most of you don't get that this isn't a laughing matter. Undoubtedly this post will not receive likes, and the only mention it will get is a quote from a Goon followed by "lol u suck". But as a Marine and a human being with empathy, I can tell you that you are scum if you think this is funny, for whatever the reason. If you consider this acceptable, then the problem isn't the people who get suicidal over internet pixel. The problem is you.


Agreed. Thanks for posting this.

Host of the High Drag Eve Online Podcast ( http://highdrag.wordpress.com). Director of Aideron Robotics.

Borial Vokan
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#1810 - 2012-03-27 03:10:47 UTC
"For those who are unfamiliar with The Mittaniā€™s misconduct, please refer to the link where he knowingly encouraged thousands of potential Fanfest viewers to send mails to an EVE player who has exhibited a history of mental instability, to provoke him to commit suicide."

I think we have a new record for the CSM chairman to last the shortest ammount of time. Well done.
GeeShizzle MacCloud
#1811 - 2012-03-27 03:12:44 UTC
Anya Klibor wrote:
Let me relate a story.

In 2008 I was the acting company commander for our battalion's service and support company. We had a Marine I knew about who was suicidal because his girlfriend of six years had been sleeping around while he was deployed. He'd thoroughly loved her and was devastated when he found this out. This Marine was exemplary, and in great health - both mentally and physically - before all this happened. In classic Marine fashion, several of his NCOs said that he didn't have the balls to pull the trigger. They didn't care about him, and they openly mocked him for it.

He checked out his personal sidearm to "clean". It was a .45-caliber pistol. Instead of bringing it to the range, he brought it back to his barracks room and loaded it. We were lucky that the corporal on duty realized what he had and called both myself and the Provost Marshall's Office before he could do anything. I was the only one allowed through the cordon without a badge, because as his company's executive officer and acting company commander, I wanted to be there in case I could help. I considered this man one of my few friends in the Marines, and I didn't like the idea of him pulling the trigger and taking his own life.

He eventually calmed down enough that I was able to walk into his room, unarmed. I had PMO stay back. He was on the first deck of the barracks. He was relating everything, and he simply said, "I want to pull this trigger and just end it." One of the NCOs who had been ragging on him the entire time yelled, "Then do it you ******* *****!" I have never moved so fast in my life. As he brought the gun up, I bolted to him and wrestled for the gun.

He pulled the trigger. Luckily I was the one he shot. Blew out my shoulder when he did, but PMO was quick to rush in when he fired, and they got the gun away from him.

This Marine was exemplary, and I refused to have charges pressed on him. To my knowledge, he continues to serve in uniform, though he was very close to being medically discharged. He was a Lance Corporal, and he's a Staff Sergeant now. He regularly tells his story during suicide prevention classes, and i'd like to think he makes a difference.

But the point of this story is, something as simple as a little ragging can lead to someone going through with the action. Not everyone has someone who can stop them right then and there, and plenty of suicides happen annually.

We are a cruel group of people. We play EVE because it is cruel/ We do everything we can to hurt other people in this game, and many times it goes beyond the game's confines. We are callous to one another because the game allows it. But the problem is, many people don't seem to get that there are lines, and the line was crossed. It's clear those of you supporting Mittens have never witnessed someone take their own life, and most of you don't get that this isn't a laughing matter. Undoubtedly this post will not receive likes, and the only mention it will get is a quote from a Goon followed by "lol u suck". But as a Marine and a human being with empathy, I can tell you that you are scum if you think this is funny, for whatever the reason. If you consider this acceptable, then the problem isn't the people who get suicidal over internet pixel. The problem is you.


well f**king said! +1
Eian
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#1812 - 2012-03-27 03:13:48 UTC
Kyle Yanowski wrote:
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.


I missed it as I dove head first in this thread. Mittani posted his apology. I won't say anything else other than, go read it.... And learn from it.


I read it twice. What would you, rather should we take away from that post? Please enlighten us.
Princess Nana
Doomheim
#1813 - 2012-03-27 03:16:03 UTC
EULA was broken. CSM Chairman called out of game for a player in game to be openly harassed. The one who is meant to represent the community has disgraced the community. Time to go.
GeeShizzle MacCloud
#1814 - 2012-03-27 03:21:27 UTC
Eian wrote:
Kyle Yanowski wrote:
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.


I missed it as I dove head first in this thread. Mittani posted his apology. I won't say anything else other than, go read it.... And learn from it.


I read it twice. What would you, rather should we take away from that post? Please enlighten us.


its very simple, cyber bullying is bad, it does have consequences, consequences that may not be easily verified but consequences that are extremely severe. The Mittani has expressed that he understands this concept, in his apology, and notes that his actions were wrong.

learn from his example that cyber bullying is bad and that you shouldnt do it, or enourage it.

if you couldnt get that from his apology then you definitely need more schooling.

Aker Krane
OMEGADYNE LABS
Rising Darkness
#1815 - 2012-03-27 03:25:12 UTC
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.



This.

Our little game is about to learn a lesson about consequences over this.
When you are a public figure, what you say has consequences.

Thanks Mittens for making this game the poster child for internet bullying.
Intended or not. You get a well deserved "F" for this.

For those of you defending this: Smarten up.

CCP: Cut him loose. There is nothing positive that holding on to him will bring.

There are larger consequences here than what he said.

Good luck to you all on this one.
Anya Klibor
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#1816 - 2012-03-27 03:26:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Anya Klibor
HTML error. Removing.

Leadership is something you learn. Maybe one day, you'll learn that.

Anya Klibor
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#1817 - 2012-03-27 03:27:10 UTC
GeeShizzle MacCloud wrote:
Eian wrote:
Kyle Yanowski wrote:
Shandir wrote:
The real problem here is that it is blatantly obvious that a significant portion of people on the forums think this behavior is acceptable, and unless CCP makes it clear that this behavior is not acceptable - they are condoning it.

This is public, blatant and offensive - if there is a better picture case of why this isn't okay, it would require someone to be seriously hurt. Let's not wait until that example happens. Put a foot down firmly now.


I missed it as I dove head first in this thread. Mittani posted his apology. I won't say anything else other than, go read it.... And learn from it.


I read it twice. What would you, rather should we take away from that post? Please enlighten us.


its very simple, cyber bullying is bad, it does have consequences, consequences that may not be easily verified but consequences that are extremely severe. The Mittani has expressed that he understands this concept, in his apology, and notes that his actions were wrong.

learn from his example that cyber bullying is bad and that you shouldnt do it, or enourage it.

if you couldnt get that from his apology then you definitely need more schooling.



The issue is that his apology is not, in any way, heartfelt. Goons have one mission in this game: to ruin it for everyone else. To do that, they must take on the sociopath mentality and lose their "conscience". They are not here to make friends. They are not here to play nice with others. They will lie, cheat, and steal in order to get what they want. And if you're in their way, you're getting hurt.

I respect that Goons are probably exactly what CCP wanted for this game. They are the type of people who make EVE what it is. As such, they can be considered CCP's "favorites". In World of Warcraft, you have the guild Paragon. They cheat and exploit constantly, usually not getting caught but when they do, you will generally find that Blizzard supports them with a claim of "there was no cheating, just clever use of game mechanics". They will take chunks of scripted content and make it obsolete with these glitches. But if you're not Paragon and you do the same thing, expect a one-week ban (I think there was a guild called Exodus on Ysera server that can attest to this). There are very few instances of Paragon being held accountable (first one was on heroic Lich King, and the second was recently, when Looking For Raid came out). They, too, ofer "heartfelt" apologies that lapdogs support. But they go back to doing it all over again. They don't learn, they don't care.

Mittens and Goons will do the exact same thing. The apology is not heartfelt in the slightest.

Leadership is something you learn. Maybe one day, you'll learn that.

TruthState
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#1818 - 2012-03-27 03:29:11 UTC
The op raised very valid concerns and arguments. If you want to be a public representative of the Eve player base, a normal standard of behaviour is expected, instead of the juvenille nature that was shown. I support the op 100%, we expect better from the top echelon thats supposed to represent this community.

JTK Fotheringham
Ducks in Outer Space
#1819 - 2012-03-27 03:47:39 UTC
This is the sort of comments we're getting on page 1 over at Massively...

Quote:
He is basically the player representative of the EVE community, and as such probably the cream of the crop. And if the cream of the crop is an absolute scumbag, I think it's safe to safe that EVE is rife with them.


The Mittani crossed the line into unacceptable, and he has to go. If he doesn't man up, CCP has to remove him.
orphenshadow
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#1820 - 2012-03-27 03:47:53 UTC
Heimatar Auctioneer wrote:
Ladie Harlot wrote:
Heimatar Auctioneer wrote:
Endeavour Starfleet wrote:
-1

Stop whining. He acted fine


Are you kidding me? Encouraging other players to partake in a possible suicide of a mentally unstable person is "acting fine?"

Its a joke. I know. But it has gone too far.


Anybody who threatens to commit suicide over a video game deserves to be mocked.


it doesn't matter if I am an alt or CEO of Pendamic Legion. I am expressing my concern as a valid subscriber of this game. I pay plex for this game. You pay plex for this game. An alt or a nobody i may be, but i am entitled with same right as others.



The right to shut the **** up and stop being such a pussy.

God, go kill yourself. (in game)