These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev Blog: Exploring The Character Bazaar & Skill Trading

First post First post First post
Author
Scott Dracov
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#861 - 2015-10-15 21:27:24 UTC
Vabanaz Arjar wrote:
Déjà vu!
I have seen this before and I know what happens next:

1.) the Maketing Guy who had this Genius Idea is right: it will raise the Revenue and a year later you'll see some solid numbers.
2.) however suddenly many customers will leave and the pretty numbers will be down to near zero just another year later.
3.) many People lose their Jobs but at this Stage the Marketing Guy already changed to another company - and continues spreading his wisdom elsewhere.


don't make me sad, ccp



Well said Vabanaz Arjar.

I vote NO to this skill point selling plan period!

For a long term game like eve being helmed by developers that can not even fathom this long term concept is a sign that they will likely implement this disastrous skill selling scheme.

EVE will end up with their great numbers for a year and then as you said when the proverbial $#!t hits the fan the "genius" who thought of this skill point selling scheme and got it shoved down CCP's customers throats will have already left for his next con job.

Lots of jobs will be lost when the customer base that was being retained by the threat of lost skill training time to skill points disappears when this incentive becomes irrelevant.
Moac Tor
Cyber Core
Immediate Destruction
#862 - 2015-10-15 21:27:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Moac Tor
Tyberius Franklin wrote:
Moac Tor wrote:
Mr Epeen wrote:
CCP will already sell you ISK. You can already buy SP in the character bazaar.

So, while I think it's a dumb idea, I don't think it will have the impact a lot of you think it will. I'll not be running to the closet to get out my army surplus helmet to protect my head from the falling sky on this one, I think.

Mr Epeen Cool

Whilst SP is not being created from nothing, you are freeing up massive amounts of SP on characters that don't need those particular skills they trained.

Like you say it is a dumb idea anyway so why take that risk, personally i'd much rather see changes to the character bazaar and attempting to integrate that into the game, and perhaps allow a history wipe at the cost of SP (perhaps 25% SP loss).

How does that idea actually bring any character bazaar functions into the game? Character sales exist primarily for acquiring training, not erasing history.

I don't use the character bazaar myself so I can't give you a conclusive answer to that. But going by CCP Rise's devblog the characters history and being stuck with a name he didn't want was a big drawback to using the bazaar. I can understand that point and so that is why I suggested a compromise could possibly be to erase history at the cost of SP loss.

If someone is willing to lose 25% of their SP to wipe their character then I'd say that is pretty reasonable. And after all it isn't unthinkable that in a high tec sci fi universe that there wouldn't be some way to erase ones identity at a cost.
Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#863 - 2015-10-15 21:28:33 UTC
PotatoOverdose wrote:
Querns wrote:
PotatoOverdose wrote:
Cash to CCP for 500k SP transfers.

This isn't the end, but you can see it from here.

CCP already takes its pound of flesh for character transfers. Thinking that they'd remove it in this case is idiotic.

You missed the point. And, as an aside, you've already done a good job of showing us why character transfers are not the same as SP transfers:

Querns wrote:


Also, you're significantly overestimating the number of times any one person would rush out to the character bazaar and snatch up a custom-made character just to stay ahead of the FOTM.

Mechanically, no, of course it's not the same. However, that's not the point -- the new mechanic doesn't actually add any new capability to the game, other than the ability to sap SP out of a pilot's head, if for whatever reason you needed to do that on its own merits irrespective of material benefit.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Cheapshot Calamity
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#864 - 2015-10-15 21:29:11 UTC
ITT: buttmad old people yelling that someone else is allowed to have the same type of pie as them without slaving for 10 bajillion years.

GET REKT.
Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#865 - 2015-10-15 21:29:57 UTC
adriaans wrote:
No. No. NO. NO

Very bad idea!

I do NOT like this.

Please do not do this.

Pay for character rename or re-model, that is perfectly fine. Skillpoints, not a chance in hell I will ever support that.

The existence of the Character Bazaar must really irk you.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Desert Ice78
Gryphons of the Western Wind
#866 - 2015-10-15 21:29:57 UTC
The notion that you should be able to simply purchase skills/ skill points, and the time invested in them, goes against everything I believed this game stood for.

Yes, i understand that basically people have been doing this all the time via the existing character bazaar, but at least in that case you were buying the whole package - the name, the skills, the reputation et al. This "proposal" drives a stake through the very heart of your identity in Eve.

I look fondly on my many millions of skill points on my two toons, and in fact I was looking forward to the day when I could post in the 200 level V skills thread. Now all cheapened - once again CCP wants it all to be about your credit card, and not the central tenet of your investment of time in this game.

.......no.

I am a pod pilot: http://dl.eve-files.com/media/corp/DesertIce/POD.jpg

CCP Zulu: Came expecting a discussion about computer monitors, left confused.

Corin Lethander
Lone Wolves Mining
EZ. Street
#867 - 2015-10-15 21:32:28 UTC
Ok guys, yea. This is crap. Presented to the corp mates and friends, they literally stated their selling their accounts and are done. Any kind of idea that promotes that kind of response, is bad, m'kay?

If you have to do it... "MAYBE" leave it just between your accounts or perhaps, just between 1 character. I would love to respec my stupid mining points to something more productive, but trading them between toons and different accounts.... CCP please.. and CSM guys, please, shut this down.
PotatoOverdose
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#868 - 2015-10-15 21:33:57 UTC  |  Edited by: PotatoOverdose
Querns wrote:
PotatoOverdose wrote:
Querns wrote:
PotatoOverdose wrote:
Cash to CCP for 500k SP transfers.

This isn't the end, but you can see it from here.

CCP already takes its pound of flesh for character transfers. Thinking that they'd remove it in this case is idiotic.

You missed the point. And, as an aside, you've already done a good job of showing us why character transfers are not the same as SP transfers:

Querns wrote:


Also, you're significantly overestimating the number of times any one person would rush out to the character bazaar and snatch up a custom-made character just to stay ahead of the FOTM.

Mechanically, no, of course it's not the same. However, that's not the point -- the new mechanic doesn't actually add any new capability to the game, other than the ability to sap SP out of a pilot's head, if for whatever reason you needed to do that on its own merits irrespective of material benefit.

If, some years ago, you told me that by paying a small fee to CCP + some in-game mechanism I could directly add as much SP as I desired, to any character that I desired? I would've laughed. Eve was about meaningful choices, long term planning.

But now? Well....like the man said: "It's not the end of the world, but you can see it from here."
Arec Bardwin
#869 - 2015-10-15 21:34:54 UTC
Personally I think this is a REALLY bad idea for a number of reasons.

It will hugely favor older, richer players that can afford to purchase sp for their mains, nevermind diminishing returns. They will also be able to instantly create any perfectly focused alt whenever they want to.

For newer players it will create a HORRIBLE sp grind pressure. Since the new sp transfer feature will have a VASTLY lower barrier of use, compared to the existing character transfer. You can now buy sp in small increments whenever needed, instead of buying a new character that you have no emotional bond to (Yes, most players have an emotional bond to their first main).

"You cannot fly that doctrine ship good enough, just buy 1.5m sp and put then into the following skills......."

This fundamentally changes how people relate to sp gain, and EVE Online will now be catering to the instant gratification crowd. This is not a slippery slope, it's a ****ing vertical drop.
Tyberius Franklin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#870 - 2015-10-15 21:38:26 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:
I don't use the character bazaar myself so I can't give you a conclusive answer to that. But going by CCP Rise's devblog the characters history and being stuck with a name he didn't want was a big drawback to using the bazaar. I can understand that point and so that is why I suggested a compromise could possibly be to erase history at the cost of SP loss.

If someone is willing to lose 25% of their SP to wipe their character then I'd say that is pretty reasonable. And after all it isn't unthinkable that in a high tec sci fi universe that there wouldn't be some way to erase ones identity at a cost.
That still effectively leaves the same issue intact. You're stuck with a character that a) can't do what you want due to needing to wipe significant training or b) stuck with a character that does do what you want but has an identity you don't want.

The alternative is to buy characters worth significantly more than what you are looking for, but that doesn't resolve the issue of wanting to associate the skills with your character. The idea in the blog solves that, your's does not.
Querns
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#871 - 2015-10-15 21:41:55 UTC
PotatoOverdose wrote:

If, some years ago, you told me that by paying a small fee to CCP + some in-game mechanism I could directly add as much SP as I desired, to any character that I desired? I would've laughed. Eve was about meaningful choices, long term planning.

But now? Well....like the man said: "It's not the end of the world, but you can see it from here."

"Some small in-game mechanism" is literally liquidating the SP of others, and applying it imperfectly towards your character.

I suppose if you were deliberately obtuse and boiling down the whole thing into that disingenuous quip then it'd be different.

This post was crafted by the wormhole expert of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal, the foremost authority on Eve: Online economics and gameplay.

Krispy Dingo
The Gold Angels
Sixth Empire
#872 - 2015-10-15 21:42:13 UTC
The problem I see here is that it does give you the ability to actually buy SP. That is terribad. SP should never be able to be purchased. A lot of people claiming this as Pay2Win? no, of course it's not. It's not different than buying a bunch of PLEX, selling it on the market, then using that ISK to buy a character off the bazaar. Just because you have the skills doesn't mean you necessarily know how to use them, and anyone who already knows how to use the skills has put the time into the game where it doesn't make a difference.

Here is where, in my opinion, it would work better.

As opposed to giving you unallocated SP, it actually does a rewrite of current SP.

Player 1 buys a skill extractor, pulls out 500,000SP of the skills he wants to remove, which are now unallocated, and can now reallocate those skills to something else.

Player 1 then uses those extracted skills to create the packet for the specific skills that he has extracted.

Player 2 can now buy the packet on the market, for those skills only.

Player 2 can now inject those skills, but in order to do so, he must give up 500,000SP of skills he has already trained to learn those new skills. In addition, he is learning the skills starting from 0SP for the skills he is injecting. Or, if he already has some level of training, they add on to what he already has in those skills.

This means that Player 2 doesn't need to buy skill books to train the skills, but gives him the chance to respec as well, and the market will drive the price of what skill packets are the most valuable at any given time.

Of course, if you don't have the necessary prereqs for the packet of skills you just purchased, then you cannot inject that packet of skills.
Aristash
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#873 - 2015-10-15 21:42:43 UTC
If CCP adds Skills for Aurum(plex)

Aristash and 3 other alt's will stop paying for Eve online.

Stop doing stfu thing with my Eve!

Kick producers of Eve right now, You must playing in Eve then do something with game.

CCP you are not playing anymore. Shame on you...
VaL Iscariot
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#874 - 2015-10-15 21:42:48 UTC
Stop trying to make buying skill points happen. Its not going to happen. Now, I wouldnt mind something that let me shuffle my ownn skill points around for aurm. Never the market though. No no no.
Opner Dresden
H A V O C
Fraternity.
#875 - 2015-10-15 21:43:06 UTC
Tyberius Franklin wrote:
Moac Tor wrote:
I don't use the character bazaar myself so I can't give you a conclusive answer to that. But going by CCP Rise's devblog the characters history and being stuck with a name he didn't want was a big drawback to using the bazaar. I can understand that point and so that is why I suggested a compromise could possibly be to erase history at the cost of SP loss.

If someone is willing to lose 25% of their SP to wipe their character then I'd say that is pretty reasonable. And after all it isn't unthinkable that in a high tec sci fi universe that there wouldn't be some way to erase ones identity at a cost.
That still effectively leaves the same issue intact. You're stuck with a character that a) can't do what you want due to needing to wipe significant training or b) stuck with a character that does do what you want but has an identity you don't want.

The alternative is to buy characters worth significantly more than what you are looking for, but that doesn't resolve the issue of wanting to associate the skills with your character. The idea in the blog solves that, your's does not.


You want a particular skill on a particular character? Train it.
Mr Epeen
It's All About Me
#876 - 2015-10-15 21:43:12 UTC
Moac Tor wrote:

I don't use the character bazaar myself so I can't give you a conclusive answer to that..


I spend more time in the Character Bazaar than I do in General Discussion. I can give you a conclusive answer.

About 10% of buyers care about name/reputation. They are primarily newish players buying their first character. The other 90% want one thing. The cheapest price for the type of character they are looking for. They'll buy it, use it, and sell it again when they get tired of it.

One example. Most of the WTBs right now are for Capital sitters. Do you really think these people care that the name is stupid or that they have GS, CODE and Test in the corp history? Of course not.

Mr Epeen Cool
Colt Blackhawk
Doomheim
#877 - 2015-10-15 21:43:32 UTC
Lots of hysteria here without any reasons behind it.
Eve is already pay to win and some "pro" vets are now crying.
Just show me the difference between:
a) Buying plex with money, selling it on market and then buying a char for isk on the character market.
b) Buying plex with money, seling it on market and then buying skill points for isk from another character.

Yep there is none :P
Apart from the fact that the new idea is a lot more comfortable.
But hey we have a "vets cry thread" now. Sometimes I think the old players are killing this game.
Eve is already pay to win. All you need is isk or RL money to buy toons and multibox.

[09:04:53] Ashira Twilight > Plant the f****** amarr flag and s*** on their smoking wrecks.

Winter Archipelago
Autumn Industrial Enterprises
#878 - 2015-10-15 21:44:59 UTC
Another thought if this plan goes ahead: Create a second type of unallocated SP (different from the Skill reimbursement / refund / whathaveyou pool that we have now). This injectable SP can only go into this second Transneural Skillpoints pool.

This second pool can only be used to train skills that can be trained on Trial accounts. This would limit what all it can be used for, and would orient it more towards newer characters than old and rich ones.
Mara Rinn
Cosmic Goo Convertor
#879 - 2015-10-15 21:45:16 UTC
I am amused that the "solution" to the character bazaar being out-of-game is to destroy it entirely.

SP for money is a bad idea. The people most able to exploit this feature will be those setting up short-lived characters on new accounts.

The beauty of the character bazaar is that you are paying for the right skills, not just a number of SP. Bonus points for clean history and a good name.

Rather than SP for ISK, bring the character bazaar into the game. Allow ads on bulletin boards and CQ screens.
Fredou
Hidden Agenda
Deep Space Engineering
#880 - 2015-10-15 21:45:29 UTC
No please no

I'm not going to read the previous 44 pages

why on earth would you want to do this? really


i have started playing eve nearly 10 ½ years ago

i have over 230m sp

you can gain about ~ 24m per year

why would you want to kill this?