These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Regarding the Battlecruiser and Destroyer skill changes

Author
FloppieTheBanjoClown
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#21 - 2012-03-28 17:08:48 UTC
BeanBagKing wrote:
ibt... oh wait, it's not one of those threads....

Judging from what they've said so far the plan seems to be if you have Battlecruiser 4 when the patch hits, then you'll get Gallente BC 4, Amarr BC 4, etc. If you have Battlecruiser 5, you'll get Gallente BC 5, Amarr BC 5... you get the idea.


So if Minmatar Cruiser is a prerequisite for Minmatar Battlecruiser, as was my impression, what happens if I don't have Min Cruiser trained? Would I lose the BC 5 skill for that race and have to train it, even though today I can train Min Cruiser and jump straight into a Hurricane?

I'm not against the skill change, but I do think they haven't thought through all the consequences of the transition. SOMEONE is going to get unfair treatment when the skills are converted. Personally, I bothered to train Destroyers 5 recently just to be sure I was covered if/when this happens.

Founding member of the Belligerent Undesirables movement.

Lugaedh
Bluestar Enterprises
The Craftsmen
#22 - 2012-03-28 17:09:21 UTC
Marduk Nibiru wrote:
Karl Hobb wrote:
THE L0CK wrote:
the message is that if you have BC 5 currently you will receive BC 5 across the board. If you have BC 4 then you will receive BC 4 across the board. Same goes for Destroyers.

It's actually a case of "If you could fly it before you can fly it after the change". So if you're missing a racial cruiser skill you wouldn't get the equivalent BC skill for that race, only the ones you are qualified for. Same goes for Destroyers.

Elsewhere, it's been said the best thing to do is train all frigates to IV, all cruisers to at least III (possibly IV, it's only a few days), and BC and Dessie to V.


Any idea when this is happening?

I'm training a cross-the-board PvP alt and I want to take as much advantage of this as possible. Currently got 3 of 4 cruiser to 4, and dessie/bc at 2. So I need like a month more.


May 22nd according to an article on golem.de the day before yesterday (inferno patch. i think destroyers will start first)
Karl Hobb
Imperial Margarine
#23 - 2012-03-28 17:11:46 UTC
FloppieTheBanjoClown wrote:
So if Minmatar Cruiser is a prerequisite for Minmatar Battlecruiser, as was my impression, what happens if I don't have Min Cruiser trained? Would I lose the BC 5 skill for that race and have to train it, even though today I can train Min Cruiser and jump straight into a Hurricane?

At this time, and given what has been said and what we know of how CCP will do this, that is exactly what will happen.

A professional astro-bastard was not available so they sent me.

Marduk Nibiru
Chaos Delivery Systems
#24 - 2012-03-28 17:14:44 UTC
THE L0CK wrote:
the message is that if you have BC 5 currently you will receive BC 5 across the board. If you have BC 4 then you will receive BC 4 across the board. Same goes for Destroyers.


Are they really basing it on skill level or on the ships you can fly? Technically speaking they could provide the latter by just making you BC3 across the board unless you can fly command ships, which also need cruiser 5 if I'm recalling correct (at work).

I hope they lower the SP required for these skills. If they're going to make you train 4 BC instead of just one then it shouldn't be a 5x or whatever it is. They should drop it an x or two. Of course, that would make brewing Drake alts a little on the fast side...
Danfen Fenix
#25 - 2012-03-28 17:17:56 UTC
How about something in the 'redeem' menu...

Option 1: Exchange BC (level) for Racial BC (level) across the board

OR (for the 'OCD skillsheet' people out there)

Option 2: Exchange BC (level) for selected Racial BCs (level)

first option allows the player to just get all 4. Second allows them to just pick what they want, i.e. Only Gallente & Amarr. The first obviously is a smarter one to pick if you do not want to train more skills, but the second will be available to keep any awkward people quiet.

Of course, once the option has been chosen, it is not reversible...so choose carefully and live with your actions P
BeanBagKing
The Order of Atlas
#26 - 2012-03-28 17:23:14 UTC
FloppieTheBanjoClown wrote:
BeanBagKing wrote:
ibt... oh wait, it's not one of those threads....

Judging from what they've said so far the plan seems to be if you have Battlecruiser 4 when the patch hits, then you'll get Gallente BC 4, Amarr BC 4, etc. If you have Battlecruiser 5, you'll get Gallente BC 5, Amarr BC 5... you get the idea.


So if Minmatar Cruiser is a prerequisite for Minmatar Battlecruiser, as was my impression, what happens if I don't have Min Cruiser trained? Would I lose the BC 5 skill for that race and have to train it, even though today I can train Min Cruiser and jump straight into a Hurricane?

I'm not against the skill change, but I do think they haven't thought through all the consequences of the transition. SOMEONE is going to get unfair treatment when the skills are converted. Personally, I bothered to train Destroyers 5 recently just to be sure I was covered if/when this happens.


I -think- that you would get Min BC 5 even if you don't have Min Cruiser trained. Look at it this way, CCP's intention seems to be to disrupt your skill training as little as possible. Now I have command ships trained right now, but I can't fly Min command ships because I don't have Min Cruiser 5. If I decided I wanted to fly the Claymore though, I would train Min Cruiser 5, 20 days, and jump in it. Similarly if you don't have Min cruiser at all, but wanted to train it, you could jump in a hurricane, but if they don't give you the skills for that post patch, they are forcing you to add the extra Min BC training time, effectivly making you train something that you have at this moment, regardless of your ability to fly that specific ship.

Now if they don't give me Min BC 5, and I decide I want to fly the Claymore, I have to train Min Cruiser 5 THEN train Min BC 5 (40ish days). CCP has doubled the time it takes me to get into a ship post patch compared to pre patch. I'd certainly qualify that as disrupting my skill training. Again, I -think- that they are trying to disrupt things as little as possible, that seems to be the idea they have in mind. How exactly they implement it and where they draw the line I don't know.

Your right, I don't think they've completely thought through all the consequences (or if they have in meetings, they haven't shared). I don't think there's a way to do it though that won't have a negative effect on what you can fly now without reimbursing all 4 racial BC/destroyer skills even if you only fly 1 race. There's a lot of guesswork going into it on my part though :P

My advice to my corp mates is to train all the cruiser and frigs to 4 (or whatever) right now, it's not a long train, and then destroyer 5 and BC 5 (like a month and a half there). It's a little long, but at that point you should be able to fly everything available and you should be reimbursed with level 5 skills after.
Herping yourDerp
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#27 - 2012-03-28 17:31:04 UTC
maybe they will make BC a x3 skill or something to compensate.
BeanBagKing
The Order of Atlas
#28 - 2012-03-28 17:38:13 UTC
Herping yourDerp wrote:
maybe they will make BC a x3 skill or something to compensate.


Unless they change their mind, I don't think so, reference
CCP Ytterbium wrote:

  • New destroyer and battlecruiser skills would be same rank than existing ones

  • Also
    CCP Ytterbium wrote:

  • Destroyer and Battlecruiser reimbursement: it has been said before, but allow us to repeat again, that we do not want to cut ships you can already fly. Thus, having BC skill at 5 would mean you get all four variations at 5.

  • Nothing is mentioned about having cruiser (or any other pre-req) to any level, "having BC skill at 5 would mean you get all four variations at 5" seems pretty clear. However, as has been pointed out, there may be instances where you could have BC to 5, but not a racial cruiser, so you couldn't fly the ship, violating the "already fly" clause. I'm erring on the side of you'll get it though because...
    CCP Soundwave wrote:

    We'll find a suitable reimbursement that makes everyone happy. I'm not terribly fussed about giving away a little extra if it moves we move the ship progression system into a better place.

    Cindy Marco
    Sebiestor Tribe
    Minmatar Republic
    #29 - 2012-03-28 17:42:21 UTC
    It wouldn't really make sense to change the rank of BC. Cruisers are 5x and will be a prereq to BC under the new system. BC are already at 6x.

    With the other ships (except destroyers) the bigger the ship, the higher rank it is.
    Rivur'Tam
    the united
    #30 - 2012-03-28 17:44:43 UTC
    i really don't thiunk they will give you all bc lv5 if you only have the 1 trained

    i think it will be based on your cruiser skill

    ie if you have bc 5

    gall cruiser 4

    amarr cruiser 3

    caldari cruiser 5

    mini cruiser 4

    you will get

    gall bc 4

    amarr bc 3

    caldari bc 5

    mini bc 4

    that would be a fair way to do it but giving us all 5 for bc 5 would be great but that would defeat the point of changing in the first place

    [b]Inappropriate signature removed. Spitfire

    ^^ my sig was awesome that naugty spitfire stole it for himself true story

    United Recruitment Director.[/b]

    adopt
    Brutor Tribe
    Minmatar Republic
    #31 - 2012-03-28 17:53:04 UTC
    Rivur'Tam wrote:
    i really don't thiunk they will give you all bc lv5 if you only have the 1 trained

    i think it will be based on your cruiser skill

    ie if you have bc 5

    gall cruiser 4

    amarr cruiser 3

    caldari cruiser 5

    mini cruiser 4

    you will get

    gall bc 4

    amarr bc 3

    caldari bc 5

    mini bc 4

    that would be a fair way to do it but giving us all 5 for bc 5 would be great but that would defeat the point of changing in the first place


    How on earth would that be fair? If I spent 36 days training it from level 1 to 5 I think I should be compensated.
    Cindy Marco
    Sebiestor Tribe
    Minmatar Republic
    #32 - 2012-03-28 17:58:06 UTC
    Rivur'Tam wrote:
    i really don't thiunk they will give you all bc lv5 if you only have the 1 trained

    i think it will be based on your cruiser skill

    ie if you have bc 5

    gall cruiser 4
    amarr cruiser 3
    caldari cruiser 5
    mini cruiser 4

    you will get

    gall bc 4
    amarr bc 3
    caldari bc 5
    mini bc 4

    that would be a fair way to do it but giving us all 5 for bc 5 would be great but that would defeat the point of changing in the first place

    If they did it that way they would be removing bonuses people already trained for.
    Maria Yumeno
    Venomous Cloud
    #33 - 2012-03-28 17:59:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Maria Yumeno
    Are they only changing the BC and Destroyer skills?

    Or will there be upcoming racial command ship skill books and such?

    I have read the Dev blog and it does not state any intention to change the t2 skill tree, but it would be logical to do that, no?
    Cindy Marco
    Sebiestor Tribe
    Minmatar Republic
    #34 - 2012-03-28 18:08:45 UTC
    Maria Yumeno wrote:
    Are they only changing the BC and Destroyer skills?

    Or will there be upcoming racial command ship skill books and such?

    They haven't said anything, but god, that would suck. If they broke down all the T2 ships into racials it would likely knock me up into the next clone bracket.
    Ajita al Tchar
    Doomheim
    #35 - 2012-03-28 18:46:24 UTC
    Rivur'Tam wrote:
    i really don't thiunk they will give you all bc lv5 if you only have the 1 trained

    i think it will be based on your cruiser skill

    ie if you have bc 5

    gall cruiser 4

    amarr cruiser 3

    caldari cruiser 5

    mini cruiser 4

    you will get

    gall bc 4

    amarr bc 3

    caldari bc 5

    mini bc 4

    that would be a fair way to do it but giving us all 5 for bc 5 would be great but that would defeat the point of changing in the first place


    No, it wouldn't be any more fair, nor would it defeat the point of changing stuff. On that last point, seriously, wtf are you talking about? What do you think the point is (because apparently it's something strange)?

    This is a situation where you can't have a solution that will make everyone happy. However you spin it, someone loses out on something except perhaps those who have all cruisers to 5 and BC 5 (you might argue they lose out because they might have to upgrade their clone to a more expensive one). Some will hurt more than others, it's unavoidable. I think that the way that does the least damage involves giving Racial BC V to those who have BC V right now and the Racial Cruiser III or higher. Same for Destroyers and Frigate skills.

    AFAIK there are no ships* that directly require BC V so technically you wouldn't suddenly not be able to fly some ship that you could fly before even if BC V isn't given based on BC and Cruiser skills, but then folks would have to spend literally months training up to use their BC's as well as they could before which kind of sucks. Losing Destroyer V would however matter to dictor pilots as you have to have that skill to get into a T2 destroyer.

    * DO NOT say "Command Ships require BC V to fly, I won't be able to fly my CS if I lose BC V" because it's not true. The skill Command Ships requires BC V, the ships themselves do not (nested skills). If you already have that skill injected (let alone trained up) it won't suddenly uninject if you lose BC V, thus rendering you unable to fly your CS. Losing BC V will have an effect on bonuses for command ships since one of them is a "Battlecruisers Skill Bonus", but technically you'd still be able to fly it, just not as effectively. For comparison, you *would* lose your ability to fly dictors if you lose Dessy V since that skill is a direct prereq for the ship.
    Markus Reese
    Deep Core Mining Inc.
    Caldari State
    #36 - 2012-03-28 19:39:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Markus Reese
    I thought about this before, posted in one of the early threads.

    With the launcher, an in game skill check prior to patch would be excellent

    I viewed it as follows, first patch day. This will set up a mirror point for a skillcheck. Any skill training after it would only reimburse sp. (so no 1 month ghost training of BC5 past patch day). Ergo, if a destroyer/battlecruiser skill is partially trained or completes training after a set point, you just get sp

    second, a check for battlecruiser or destroyer skill, for whichever first applies, it will look at your cruiser/frigate skills. You would get equivelant battlecruiser/destroyer skill for any faction you have the cruiser/frigate level high enough

    last, any prereq skill that changed to higher for a ship (Ie cruiser 4, frig 4 from 3) would get buffed

    This would allow anybody to log in to not even notice any changes, aside from your sp would increase accordingly in listing.

    After log in, a msg would pop up saying any sp reimbursed as well as to inform to check your clone.

    To quote Lfod Shi

    The ratting itself is PvE. Getting away with it is PvP.

    Tyberius Franklin
    Federal Navy Academy
    Gallente Federation
    #37 - 2012-03-28 20:01:07 UTC
    [quote=Markus Reese]I thought about this before, posted in one of the early threads.

    With the launcher, an in game skill check prior to patch would be excellen

    I viewed it as follows, first patch day. This will set up a mirror point for a skillcheck. Any skill training after it would only reimburse sp. (so no 1 month ghost training of BC5 past patch day). Ergo, if a destroyer/battlecruiser skill is partially trained or completes training after a set point, you just get s

    second, a check for battlecruiser or destroyer skill, for whichever first applies, it will look at your cruiser/frigate skills. You would get equivelant battlecruiser/destroyer skill for any faction you have the cruiser/frigate level high enoug

    last, any prereq skill that changed to higher for a ship (Ie cruiser 4, frig 4 from 3) would get buffe

    This would allow anybody to log in to not even notice any changes, aside from your sp would increase accordingly in listing.

    After log in, a msg would pop up saying any sp reimbursed as well as to inform to check your clone.[/quote
    The blog stated that due to the way prerequisites work we wouldn't loose skills already trained even if prereqs were changed to things we do not have if i recall correctly, thus bumping untrained skills to meet the new prerequisites would be unnecessary. It also means one can't game the system by training up a new character to BS lvl 1 in all races now to get all4 BC and Destroyers skills to lvl 4 for free.
    Spy 21
    Doomheim
    #38 - 2012-03-28 20:14:19 UTC
    Hmmm....

    So what happens if you have all 4 crusier skills trained to III or higher...
    Battlecruisers IV...

    And Battlecruisers V half trained?

    Spy

    Obfuscation for the WIN on page 3...

    Sirinda
    Ekchuah's Shrine Comporium
    #39 - 2012-03-28 20:16:14 UTC
    So just throwing this in here, but what would speak against enough free SP so you can get all four racial BC skills to the level your old BC skill was trained to?
    Tippia
    Sunshine and Lollipops
    #40 - 2012-03-28 20:22:32 UTC
    Maria Yumeno wrote:
    Are they only changing the BC and Destroyer skills?

    Or will there be upcoming racial command ship skill books and such?
    No racial T2 skills.

    They're separating the skills into two distinct categories: racial T1 skills that give you access to hulls, and general T2 skills that give you access to roles (and the variants of the hulls the T1 skills give you).

    Sirinda wrote:
    So just throwing this in here, but what would speak against enough free SP so you can get all four racial BC skills to the level your old BC skill was trained to?
    The fact that you don't necessarily need to spend them on the BC skills, and thus can suddenly make a huge jump in your ability to do something completely unrelated.