These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Disciples of Ston

Author
Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#81 - 2011-10-14 14:14:41 UTC
RHETORICAL SKILL: BLESSING OR CURSE?


Recently, I have been monitoring, but not particularly active in both the IGS and The Summit communication forums/Channels. I wanted to pay close attention to the presence of communication skill among participants. What I found is a tribute to many in our cluster. There are skilled communicators among us, no doubt. There are masters of language, logic and rhetorical method. There are wizards of wit and repartee.

Is all this skill a blessing or a curse? I have watched positions defended with great skill and expertise. Arguments have been waged and won. Here is the problem, rhetorical skill can be exercised in the defense of falsehood just as easily as in the defense of truth. I have observed that many can be swayed simply by an argument won. “The man or woman who wins the argument, must be right.” Many have fallen for this.

I know a simple man; not a capsuleer, but a simple mortal. He has no rhetorical skills. He is a man of strong values and conviction. I have observed the way that he wears a stoic silence when acting upon his convictions. He has no ability to argue for his position, but many times I have been “won over” by “listening” to his life.

Forgive me for this generalization, but capsuleers take great satisfaction in the winning of arguments, less satisfaction in the defense of truth. I have observed that sometimes people take the contrary position for nothing more than to start an argument and win it. Recently, I have started several responses to statements I have seen on the IGS and then cancelled the post. Do I need to argue for arguments sake? Do I really want to change minds that are unlikely to change? Or, do I just want to play rhetoric?

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#82 - 2011-10-14 14:47:39 UTC
Ston, I believe many capsuleers, myself included, see words as weapons.

This is not an incorrect view. The issue comes in when the weapon is used, as is so often the case with capsuleers, for no other reason than to start a fight.

One of the goals of MAJTH is to promote the virtue of prudence amongst the capsuleer class as one of the highest virtues, behind only faith and mercy.
Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#83 - 2011-10-16 00:18:31 UTC
Dear Mr. Thessalonia,

I wish the very best and Divine blessing on your endeavor to promote civil religious discussion. WHile I understand your thoughts on "words as weapons," and believe also in the importance of persuading others of what we hold as truth, I prefer to refer to words as "tools," rather than weapons.

I hope that we may discover ourselves building on the same edifice with these powerful tools.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#84 - 2011-10-16 13:23:56 UTC
ALLIANCE OR NOT?

In our slave rescue work, we have found many partners and like minded people. It may surprise some, that these individuals come from a diversity of races, nationalities and political interests. SOme of these indivduals are even at war with each other. Given all their differences, mercy towards those who are left to die, binds people together for action.

When we began this organization, I told Edaine, that while he was not required to be a strict disciple in the sense that he had to embrace pacifism, all Disciples applicant would have to. Further, we would never "fleet up" or join and alliance with those who actively engage in combat. We knew at the time, that the future would pressure us to compromise that stand some day. For instance, joining an alliance has huge advantages when trying to survive in dangerous low. null, and sub null parts of space. So, when asked to join an alliance, it gives us pause. However, in the end, we respectfully decline.

Respectfully! Why? I have grown to appreciate many of the members of this alliance; their honor, restraint and self control, and the principles for which they stand. Even though we are not formally enjoining ourselves in alliance, I do hope that we will cooperate in the rescue of those left to die in space and in the working towards the freedom of all races and peoples.

The Disciples of Ston bod you peace

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#85 - 2011-10-17 13:34:20 UTC
TRUST

I just received some homeless individuals from a humanitarian pilot for our homeless shelter. The exchange was made through a simple jet can. He was mining and used the same can he used for mining. There was no need to abandon the can. I took the homeless people and left his minerals. He did not attack me even though he could have legally. Why do I share this? Because trust between pilots united for mercy, justice, and peace is possible in this Cluster. I want to thank Mr. Horn for upholding standards of integrity, nobility and mercy. Peace to you my friend.

Ston

BELIEVE IT OR NOT, IT IS QUIET HERE

I have rotated off of rescue ops and am back in Jita, looking for clone bodies. There is really only a few areas in Jita, that are loud and chaotic. Jita 4-4, around a few of the gates, and the local com channel are all chaotic and loud.

Most of my searching takes me to quiet areas of the system. If the Com is off, there is little to disturb the contemplative soul.

I am off to Korama to help get a few homeless ones settled in and established at our shelter there.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#86 - 2011-10-18 15:14:43 UTC
Why offer vocational training to former slaves if they cannot move about freely in so-called "free space?" We will offer what freedom we can and hope for more in the future. Why shouldn't these rescued former slaves be offered the opportunity for the education and training of their choice? The Mother, Father, and five children that made the journey to our vocational center represent the first group who have decided to make the step of furthering their training and "be free" in spite of the turpitude of the State, Federation, and Republic.

The Disciples of Ston will transport these brave people wherever they are willing to take the risk to go.

We also have a group of former slaves who wish to open an Academic Study Center for those who wish to pursue higher degrees. We will be working on that in the near future.

We put the call out to all freedom loving pilots who, themselves, have been caring for rescued former slaves to consider bringing them to one of our centers or allowing us to transport them. If the hypocrites in government won't give genuine freedom to the former slave, let us give what we can.

SANKOFA

Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#87 - 2011-10-20 14:03:35 UTC
When I first joined the Disciples of Ston, I found the life of non-violent confrontation to be simple and in many ways, worry free. Flying an unarmed rookie ship by myself, engaging other pilots in subjects pertaining to peace; it was a simple idealistic approach. We didn't worry about ISK because we needed so little of it. We didn't worry about harming anyone, because we were unarmed and our ships carried no crews. We were often attacked, destroyed, and sometimes podded, but that was just us. it didn't matter.

But... When you begin to focus on the ideals of peace, freedom, and generosity, you do not stay self-focused for long. We began to look hard not only at helping the capsuleer but humanity as a whole. To make the story short, that brings us to the present. The slave rescue mission has required ISK to fund. We depend more now on Edaine and what he makes and donates. We fly ships with crews to protect, albeit without weapons. We train skills (something we didn't originally need to do). We break the law by smuggling former slaves into free space so they can have a semblance of a life. We are preparing to enter dangerous parts of the Cluster to confront violence and greed in those places.

In all this, we bring living human crews with us. There are lives we are now responsible for beside our own. This has been a huge change and not what I originally saw in being a Disciples of Ston. No, I haven't changed my mind about what we are doing or my part in it. However, it is not carefree any longer.

SANKOFA

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#88 - 2011-10-20 14:19:12 UTC
Manwe Todako wrote:
When I first joined the Disciples of Ston, I found the life of non-violent confrontation to be simple and in many ways, worry free. Flying an unarmed rookie ship by myself, engaging other pilots in subjects pertaining to peace; it was a simple idealistic approach. We didn't worry about ISK because we needed so little of it. We didn't worry about harming anyone, because we were unarmed and our ships carried no crews. We were often attacked, destroyed, and sometimes podded, but that was just us. it didn't matter.

But... When you begin to focus on the ideals of peace, freedom, and generosity, you do not stay self-focused for long. We began to look hard not only at helping the capsuleer but humanity as a whole. To make the story short, that brings us to the present. The slave rescue mission has required ISK to fund. We depend more now on Edaine and what he makes and donates. We fly ships with crews to protect, albeit without weapons. We train skills (something we didn't originally need to do). We break the law by smuggling former slaves into free space so they can have a semblance of a life. We are preparing to enter dangerous parts of the Cluster to confront violence and greed in those places.

In all this, we bring living human crews with us. There are lives we are now responsible for beside our own. This has been a huge change and not what I originally saw in being a Disciples of Ston. No, I haven't changed my mind about what we are doing or my part in it. However, it is not carefree any longer.


This is very wise, and I wish more capsuleers would pay attention to the fact that they have a duty of care to the people on board their vessels.

Yes, they know what they were in for. This doesn't mean they should be treated like meat.

I quite like what the Disciples are doing, at least so far as your work to improve creation from the bottom up goes. Keep it up.
Kentt Em'asep
Clone Red Creations
#89 - 2011-10-21 04:45:30 UTC
Keep up the good work, same here, defiantly like what is being done by you guys. Been reading of your travels and encounters and they always give me a good feeling. I myself have not done a whole lot of low sec roaming like what you guys usually do, but if I am ever in the area I'll say hello. Maybe even offer my services or something if that option presented itself.

~"That's right. Today, tomorrow, the next day, and the day after that, and the day after that... from here on until forever, every time you look at my avatar - you'll see this scowl."~

~"Forever?"~

~"Yes - forever. It's what I do."~

Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#90 - 2011-10-22 00:38:32 UTC
The Minmatar industrial vessel called the "Hoarder" is not a real fancy deal, but it is a great rescue vessel. When outfitted with two Tech 2 shield extenders and two or three warp core stabilizers, it is a safe vessel for rescue work. No weapons are needed. The capsuleer pilot controls many things on board, but her crew are the first responders; they are the first ones to meet the real needs of those rescued when they are transported from their "death cans" onto the rescue ship.

This is where the capsuleer in our "self-important" power, fades and real humans take over doing what only flesh and blood can do. While I am floating in my vat of ecto-plasm, my crew is performing first aid and calming the hysterical. I cannot commend my crew enough for how they handled 425 rescued people this evening. What chaos! but they have gorwn in experience now not just as crew men and women, but as counselors and crisis managers.

At times like these, I am grateful that I can do my part in this mission, but I also feel removed. Yes, back at the station, I can mingle with the people and do my part, but when I am in the egg, there is no personal connection, at least not like my crew has. I am wired to the ship, enclosed in my pod.

Some capsuleers thrive in this sense of being aloof. I do not. It is the worst part about being who we are. I am going to do everything I can to stay connected to the "real humans" out there, lest I lose my "human" soul.

SANKOFA

Kentt Em'asep
Clone Red Creations
#91 - 2011-10-22 01:06:52 UTC
Manwe Todako wrote:
At times like these, I am grateful that I can do my part in this mission, but I also feel removed. Yes, back at the station, I can mingle with the people and do my part, but when I am in the egg, there is no personal connection, at least not like my crew has. I am wired to the ship, enclosed in my pod.

Some capsuleers thrive in this sense of being aloof. I do not. It is the worst part about being who we are. I am going to do everything I can to stay connected to the "real humans" out there, lest I lose my "human" soul.


Not sure of what type, but I remember there being some ships that the capsuleer can exit the egg while still in space. Or some that allow a hologram of the capsuleer to wander the ship. Not sure what type but they might just be high class vessels.

~"That's right. Today, tomorrow, the next day, and the day after that, and the day after that... from here on until forever, every time you look at my avatar - you'll see this scowl."~

~"Forever?"~

~"Yes - forever. It's what I do."~

Kithrus
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#92 - 2011-10-22 08:31:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Kithrus
I've had enough frankly...

For the last few months I tried to be nice and ignore this little.... propaganda **** pot but I had it up to here.

No capsulleer in their right or mind regardless of how amoral they are would leave anyone in space unless said party has incurred the capsulleers wrath in a way that could possibly in some semi rare cases warrant leaving someone in a can in space.

This is not to justify the action mind but to point out that no one could or would leave anyone in space in any realistic environment.

Even the must debase of souls would ransoms said persons or enslave them. So explain to me in the name of God why the hell is there over 20 pages both from the old IGS and the new one to which we are now using combined of people leaving anyone behind in cans?

Once a year? Sure. Twice? Maybe? More then three or more? Your kidding right?

This unrealistic projection done by the Disciples of Ston is nothing more then a very weak attempt to validate their existence on the IGS so they can feel like they are helping. All they have for proof of these assumed persons who would leave people behind is their word. Nothing more.

Because in this "UNIVERSE" and I stress that in ways I hope to God are abundantly clear no one would ever do that.

I shall be making it my concern to see this thread removed by Concord on the grounds of slander for the purpose of propaganda.

Darkness is more then absence of light, it is ignorance and corruption. I will be the Bulwark from such things that you may live in the light. Pray so my arms do not grow weary and my footing remain sure.

If you are brave, join me in the dark.

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#93 - 2011-10-22 15:16:34 UTC
I am sorry that you don't believe us, Mr. Kithrus, but we will keep doing this work and reporting it here and other places as well. I hope one day that people such as you will even join us in this work. I am glad that you have such an optimistic view of the capsuleer and think that they couldn't possibly do what we are describing. I only wish it were true.

We are doing only what our convictions dictate. I wish you wouldn't oppose it. But, I suppose there will always be opposition especially when such things are exposed.

If you would ever wish to take a break from what you are doing now and join us for a couple weeks, you could see for yourself that what we are doing is real.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#94 - 2011-10-22 16:25:46 UTC
BIOMASS

To some, that is what the clone body is. To others it is more. We have found a minority within New Eden that maintain enough human connection that the body is more than just a replaceable biomass to house the consciousness. To those to whom it matters, the body is an integrated presence with the infomorph of mind, emotion, and will that possesses it. The physical and non-physical shape and influence each other. The body become unique and continues to evelop in unique ways the instant it is joined with the infomorph.

This morning I contracted a body to one of those rare capsuleers who wanted it back. Something Manwe said recently has struck me again; something about how the capsuleer tends to be "aloof." It is yet a mystery whether or not the infomorph will ever have an independent consciousness. As it stands, we need the body for existence as we know it. The body still ties us to our humanity.

We intend to treat it with dignity.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#95 - 2011-10-23 00:44:02 UTC
FOR BETTER UNDERSTANDING

Partly because of recent criticism lodged against our organization. Actually, we have been accused of lying about what we do. Also, in order to help the community understand the kind of greed and avarice that we are up against in our cluster, I set to this explanation.

Edaine was kind enough to send me a copy of a still he took during his most recent rescue. It can be found right here.

Niarja is on one of the busiest traded routes between the Amarr home systems and Caldari space, more specifically, Jita. It is a border system. It also has no stations. When one attempts to activate the jump gate between Niarja and Kaaputenen, a warning will display if you are carrying contraband, including slaves. One cannot activate the gate unless first seeing the warning. Busy traders, rather than back tracking to sell their slaves, will dump them there at the border. They do not want to risk Caldari customs reprisals and loss of standing. This system is non-stop busy with traders, and some are carrying slaves. Those who consider their time more important than the lives they carry, will dump them rather than back track a system to find a station where they could be sold or left.

This is a sad fact. I wish with all my heart that those who say we are lying were right. They are not. This is not a once a year occurrence. It happens frequently. That is why we began the rescue work.

The picture shows the gate, the can, the pilot information contained in the can registry and anything else you may find useful. In any given rescue we see anywhere from 1 to hundreds of lives left to die. We rescue as many as we can.

Some may not accept this as evidence. That is your prerogative if you like. However, for the capsuleer community to remain in denial in unconscionable.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#96 - 2011-10-24 20:33:24 UTC
I just picked up chatter in Niarja local. There are other pilots picking up slaves at the Kaap gate. Likely to be sold back into slavery.

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.

Joenes Regyri
Doomheim
#97 - 2011-10-24 20:40:30 UTC
Kithrus wrote:
I've had enough frankly...

For the last few months I tried to be nice and ignore this little.... propaganda **** pot but I had it up to here.

No capsulleer in their right or mind regardless of how amoral they are would leave anyone in space
Because in this "UNIVERSE" and I stress that in ways I hope to God are abundantly clear no one would ever do that.


Clearly you do not live in the same cluster as I.
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#98 - 2011-10-24 20:51:33 UTC
Joenes Regyri wrote:
Kithrus wrote:
I've had enough frankly...

For the last few months I tried to be nice and ignore this little.... propaganda **** pot but I had it up to here.

No capsulleer in their right or mind regardless of how amoral they are would leave anyone in space
Because in this "UNIVERSE" and I stress that in ways I hope to God are abundantly clear no one would ever do that.


Clearly you do not live in the same cluster as I.


I have to agree with this. Kithrus, spend a little time flying around the empires proper. Spend some time talking with some of the monsters who call themselves capsuleers.

You'll see that creation needs a lot of work to be put right.
Ran'shad
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#99 - 2011-10-25 13:50:22 UTC
I feel sorry for you and your so-called disciples. You boast of rescuing slaves, liberating them and releasing them....you do not know what damage you are doing. Most slaves are not capable to interact with the galactic society at large, many cannot even make decisions for themselves apart form the very basics - bordering more on the animal survival instinct. To let these people loose into society is tantamount to releasing zoo animals back into the wild, ensuring that they wil be slaughtered by their new environment shortly after the post your self-gratifying congratulations message.

I will admit that some of my brethren have not always treated their slaves as human beings, and some worse than I would treat mindless animals... Do not assume you know all of us Amarrians.

High Lord Ran'Shad CEO Imperial Manufacturing and Engineering Regiment Elemental Tide Alliance

Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#100 - 2011-10-25 14:25:49 UTC
Ran'shad wrote:
I feel sorry for you and your so-called disciples. You boast of rescuing slaves, liberating them and releasing them....you do not know what damage you are doing. Most slaves are not capable to interact with the galactic society at large, many cannot even make decisions for themselves apart form the very basics - bordering more on the animal survival instinct. To let these people loose into society is tantamount to releasing zoo animals back into the wild, ensuring that they wil be slaughtered by their new environment shortly after the post your self-gratifying congratulations message.

I will admit that some of my brethren have not always treated their slaves as human beings, and some worse than I would treat mindless animals... Do not assume you know all of us Amarrians.



It is the Disciple kind of thing to forgive others, even for what appears to be willful ignorance. You obviously haven't looked at the whole of what the Disciples are doing. Can you say "Ma-tric-u-la-tion?" How many times do we have to explain our Matriculation program before you understand what we are doing for those we rescue from death in a jet can in space.

Would you have us just leave these people to die? Ran'shad? Read our Matriculation thread and you will see that we are not doing anything like what you are saying, neither are we boasting. We are reporting what we see and what we are doing.

Now, you reflect very poorly on yourself by describing former slaves as not capable of interaction with society at large or able to make decisions for themselves...animal instinct. Is that how you treat your slaves? Ranshad? We have spoken with many Amarrian holders who say the opposite. They say that their slaves are educated, trained, socially well adjusted, professional in conduct, and equipped not only to relate, but also to lead. Are you saying that these holders are lying, Ranshad? Are you saying that most holders treat their slaves in such a way that they are, in your own words, " not capable to interact with the galactic society at large, many cannot even make decisions for themselves apart form the very basics - bordering more on the animal survival instinct?" You condemn yourself, Ranshad. You should pay more attention to what you are saying before you write it down.

We rescue slaves that are jettisoned into space because slave traders don't want to bother with them. We rescue those left to die and you accuse us of doing damage. We take them in to our Matriculation Centers, Vocational training Centers, Academic Learning Centers, and you accuse us of doing damage.

I think we need to make room on our wall of shame for you.

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.