These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Crime & Punishment

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Incursions: CCP is too slow - now we will act

First post
Author
Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#761 - 2012-01-26 00:27:51 UTC
Hans Jagerblitzen wrote:

I'm just a lowsec resident who finds the whole "inflation-gonna-ruin-everything" argument pretty hilarious. I've been playing for two years, and never seen significant price changes for the ships I fly on a regular basis, other than seasonal spikes or temporary market manipulations, but even those usually bounce back. The EvE market is far more resilient than most of us realize I think.


The fact that published numbers (over months) state that for the first time in years EvE turned from deflation to inflation proves that it's neither a seasonal spike nor a anything else.
You may go check prices over the last years on sites like EvEMarketeer.com and see items steadily rising across the months, even during the summer.


Hans Jagerblitzen wrote:

Those that front and pretend that this is about saving the economy are, as one poster called it, exuding "false altruism" to defend what is really just a tear collection drive, though I am amused that this time it actually doesn't even involve PvP.


I don't give a crap about false altruism. I have just tried a slew of other MMOs and they all suck hard balls. Only EvE is left that is a good game. I want EvE to go ahead for another 8 years and this involves keeping his economy healthy. Call this however you want.
Tian Nu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#762 - 2012-01-26 01:16:20 UTC
Vareah i don't know what price you guys debate but is about plex they always drop before summer (no one play the game ppl go out ) and start to rize again in september usualy if there is nice expension the price go up by few hundred millions.

you guys can search my posts as i usualy always buy GTC one year ahaid for the next year and trace the prices no need web site.

Father O'Malley about Darius III begging for whelp: “Hows that working out for ya ? I make it 02:21 and all I see is you begging Riverini to get numbers and trying to recruit from the incursion public channel.”

Agonis
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#763 - 2012-01-26 01:19:47 UTC
Krissada wrote:
Well this is exactly why we want them all to know we are coming and they can't do nothing about it.
Even if they try to do something it would just be so much more sweet when carebears have actually done a criminal act and lowered their security status.

For haven't we fulfilled one of the most epic goals in EVE? Turning carebears into aggressive and dangerous PVP'ers?
One way or another some would argue that suicide blackbird jamming is not real PvP. If we make carebears go against us it is one step closer to their salvation and them shedding their title as carebears.
Only then can I see myself as being victorious. This is why we are calling out public. We want you to fight us with everything you got, we want you to come out of your caves and roar at us. We want you to DO SOMETHING AND STOP CRYING.


You truly whine far to much.

Carebears aren't going to change anymore than ranting idiots such as yourself are going to change.

This whole thing had it's 15 minutes of fame and accomplishes nothing at the end of the day. Go do something productive like stopping the Russians from making a living off Eve since CCP refuses to put them on their own server so they aren't ISK selling for real cash.

Then you might actually be doing something... dare I says.. Productive.
Tian Nu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#764 - 2012-01-26 01:21:46 UTC
Blake Zacary wrote:
All this thread needs now is Darius to post saying,not only was this a way to troll the bears but a way to troll the pvper's into carebearing Big smile


seeng that they can't get fleets to shoot down mom sites any more he may just take you up on that one Blink

Father O'Malley about Darius III begging for whelp: “Hows that working out for ya ? I make it 02:21 and all I see is you begging Riverini to get numbers and trying to recruit from the incursion public channel.”

Callous Jade
Dockturnal Bromance
#765 - 2012-01-26 01:24:54 UTC
Hans Jagerblitzen wrote:
Tallian Saotome wrote:
drdxie wrote:
If everyone is so upset about risk vs reward.. .just let me add.. that if you are in an alliance in null.. there is almost zero risk in farming anoms and belt rats. You have intel channels and local to pre warn you of any danger. I have a toon in NULL and I can happily farm anoms all day in my PVE tengu without a care in the world. I worry more about being ganked in HS in a faction fitted ship than I do in the NULL pocket my alliance is in.

Sorry, those things all take alot of work to keep going. Do you know how hard it is to keep intel channels from becoming useless while people talk about how X hostiles avatar looks like their math teacher?

Those things in nullsec are not provided by CCP. We worked to make them a reality. How much work did you do for your safe isk making?


This is why I continue to argue that highsec residents deserve a better set of gameplay tools to take security into their own hands. The bounty system is outdated and lackluster, non-transferrable killrights do nothing to foster a player-driven security economy, and the result is that those that get crucified for being "carebears" have no resources at their disposal to actually make high-security space safe themselves.

Despite all the tears about how privileged high sec residents are, the bottom line is the mechanics still favor the prankster. Ganking in highsec is (literally) child's play, as any 12-year old with a Brutix, a few million skillpoints, and an hour lesson from a Goon instructor can engage in this freely for as long as he wants, paid for by isk he didn't even have to work for. I'm not exaggerating here, this is what The Mittani has gloated about continuously since stepping into the public spotlight.

This whole "carebears don't want to play in the sandbox" whine is really rooted in the narrow-minded assumption that risk = ship death. Miners, manufacturers, and especially market traders often take large risks to achieve a profit, even if that risk is of a financial nature instead of physical harm. Players that enjoy that half of the game are told by those that enjoy shooting that they must regularly bend over and suffer from regular ship loss or else they don't belong in the game. This is horseshit.

I have no interest in having a guns-off, flag-yourself-for-PvP zone in the game. However, select areas of space where ganks are *possible* but still present a significant challenge to the aggressor, should be allowed to protect gameplay diversity. The problem is that unsolicited highsec aggression is NOT any genuine challenge today, because empire citizens lack the ability to defend themselves against long-term shenanigans like the ice interdiction. Its not their fault that CCP hasn't looked more at developing player-centric bounties, wardecs, CONCORD, crimewatch, etc. Highsec space should be an area where players can enjoy activities with a reduced chance of ship loss. But they should be able to make it difficult for the pranksters instead of being forced to rely on this crappy substitute in the form of NPC police.

As a lowsec resident and FW pilot who enjoys nothing more in the game than to log on, get some kills, lose some ships, and have a laugh, I get sick of hearing suicide attacks called "PvP" and that "gankage is what makes EvE a sandbox". Thats not why most players play EvE. There is loss that is fun (I have no bad feelings when I've gone up against a good enemy and lost) and there is loss that is tear-your-hair-out-frustrating. If we're going to clean up things like POS mechanics, UI, and other features of the game to eliminate setbacks and frustration, reducing childish pranks is as justified as any other fix that makes gameplay more fluid and fun.


Some facts I have extrapolated from my observations.

1. Killrights are a perfectly viable means of retribution, particularly against "soft targets" like suicide gank tornados.

2. Carebears dont use them.
Hans Jagerblitzen
Ice Fire Warriors
#766 - 2012-01-26 01:53:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Hans Jagerblitzen
Callous Jade wrote:

Some facts I have extrapolated from my observations.

1. Killrights are a perfectly viable means of retribution, particularly against "soft targets" like suicide gank tornados.

2. Carebears dont use them.


Killrights aren't used much because they are extremely limited in scope. You can only kill the person who killed you, which depends, of course on factors such as:

a) Actually running into that same character again
b) Having the proper ship setup at that time to kill them
c) Even having the skill / skill points to actually defeat them in the first place.

I'm not a carebear, and I've never used my killrights, mostly because of (a).

The current setup favors the random ganker. He can travel to a new area, lay waste to a bunch of noobs, than move on, knowing he probably won't see those victims again before the killrights expire, or that if he does he'll still have the upper hand in a fight.

I believe in a free-market security economy, where you can pay another player to utilize your killrights. No different than contract killing, really, but even that system in this game is also completely broken.

Why? Because bounties are only awarded for pod kills. In high and lowsec, with no bubbles, being able to catch the pod of any pilot who knows what they are doing is extremely situational. Any talented PvP pilot not operating in nullsec can get his pod out of a fight 100% of the time barring a mistake, or lag.

The result is that one of the most classic science fiction professions (alongside smuggling and piracy) - becomes functionally useless in the EvE universe. Bounty hunters patrolling highsec or lowsec looking to avenge the weak (for a paycheck, of course) face the most impossible and masochistic of challenges.

Even a simple change like awarding bounties for ship loss instead of pod loss would be light years ahead of where we are now in terms of elevating bounty hunting as a fun, profitable venture.

Players would absolutely use locator agents, stalk victims, set traps, and make hay if they could do this by catching ships. But most pilots in their right minds are not going to make a profession out of pod-catching other professional PvP'ers in the heart of empire space.

CPM0 Chairman / CSM7 Vice Secretary

EnslaverOfMinmatar
You gonna get aped
#767 - 2012-01-26 07:15:14 UTC
Blake Zacary wrote:
All this thread needs now is Darius to post saying,not only was this a way to troll the bears but a way to troll the pvper's into carebearing Big smile


I don't mind 1 hour of carebearing if I get 20 killmails in the process.

Every EVE player must read this http://www.eveonline.com/background/potw/default.asp?cid=29-01-07

Tallian Saotome
Nuclear Arms Exchange Inc.
#768 - 2012-01-26 07:52:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Tallian Saotome
Hans Jagerblitzen wrote:

Why? Because bounties are only awarded for pod kills. In high and lowsec, with no bubbles, being able to catch the pod of any pilot who knows what they are doing is extremely situational. Any talented PvP pilot not operating in nullsec can get his pod out of a fight 100% of the time barring a mistake, or lag.

There is no talent. All you need to do is pay attention, and start spamming warp to a random celestial when you know the next hit is gonna kill ya. When your pod pops out of your wreck, you insta warp.

Lag and inattention are the only real threats to pods outside of null.

Edit: Or accidentally picking as your random warpout the celestial you are on, but that falls under inattention in my book Blink

Inappropriate signature removed, CCP Phantom.

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#769 - 2012-01-26 09:41:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Vaerah Vahrokha
Tian Nu wrote:
Vareah i don't know what price you guys debate but is about plex they always drop before summer (no one play the game ppl go out ) and start to rize again in september usualy if there is nice expension the price go up by few hundred millions.

you guys can search my posts as i usualy always buy GTC one year ahaid for the next year and trace the prices no need web site.


Yes prices drop before summer but the last year has not been a case of PLEX = X, drop to Y, then resume to X when demands picks up again. It's been PLEX = X, drop to Y + Z just below X, then resume to X + Z. Z is the inflation effect.


Hans Jagerblitzen wrote:

The current setup favors the random ganker. He can travel to a new area, lay waste to a bunch of noobs, than move on, knowing he probably won't see those victims again before the killrights expire, or that if he does he'll still have the upper hand in a fight.

I believe in a free-market security economy, where you can pay another player to utilize your killrights. No different than contract killing, really, but even that system in this game is also completely broken.

Why? Because bounties are only awarded for pod kills. In high and lowsec, with no bubbles, being able to catch the pod of any pilot who knows what they are doing is extremely situational. Any talented PvP pilot not operating in nullsec can get his pod out of a fight 100% of the time barring a mistake, or lag.

The result is that one of the most classic science fiction professions (alongside smuggling and piracy) - becomes functionally useless in the EvE universe. Bounty hunters patrolling highsec or lowsec looking to avenge the weak (for a paycheck, of course) face the most impossible and masochistic of challenges.

Even a simple change like awarding bounties for ship loss instead of pod loss would be light years ahead of where we are now in terms of elevating bounty hunting as a fun, profitable venture.

Players would absolutely use locator agents, stalk victims, set traps, and make hay if they could do this by catching ships. But most pilots in their right minds are not going to make a profession out of pod-catching other professional PvP'ers in the heart of empire space.


I see a couple of flaws in your reasonment (expecially talking about general ganking not incursions).

1) Gank pilots are usually expendable. You'll probably never meet the same guy again because he's biomassed.
Even for incursions, they don't need real incursion proof high SP pilots, just one that "fakes" it. Knowing the pilot is "burned" (banned) once discovered actually promotes this.

2) Gank boats are usually cheap throwaways. Good luck convincing a "professional" stalking something worth a couple millions.

Basically what you really miss is the link to their main, which barring drastic EvE changes, you'll never find and might never come to high sec or might never undock.
Darius III
Interstellar eXodus
The Initiative.
#770 - 2012-01-26 11:03:24 UTC
Blake Zacary wrote:
All this thread needs now is Darius to post saying,not only was this a way to troll the bears but a way to troll the pvper's into carebearing Big smile


Hey you-Get out of my head and stop reading my private mails!

Tian Nu wrote:


seeng that they can't get fleets to shoot down mom sites any more he may just take you up on that one Blink


You are a moron. Just a typical moron though, not a superstar moron like ENDEVOR.

I understand that because we form up on weekends and kill all the moms in empire people like to think that we will always do it every time. I like that theres some guy who was telling BTL / TDF that his "blackbird fleet is the only reason we didnt come" yesterday.

You arent even good Bears, if you were good Bears, and had some guts and any brains-you would be out hunting for the new 4 Billion ISK Invuls that drop from plexes that take 20 minutes to finish. Brick members got 2 A-type and and some B,C types over the last days.

As it is, this is only a very minor side job for Bricks. We don't have to form to kill every Mom every time, and we wont. We'll come when we want, if we want. The coalition doesnt need me, doesnt need Brick, doesnt need Krissada. All the interdiction fleets need is some guys to make it happen.

Believe it or not carebears, it really isnt about you/your incursions etc. It doesnt mean that mean that much to me to mean that much to you. A single day goes by without us killng your farmville NPC's and suddenly you are on top of the world telling people "they cant get a fleet together" LOLS.

Hmmm

Tian Nu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#771 - 2012-01-26 11:26:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Tian Nu
Darius III wrote:
Blake Zacary wrote:
All this thread needs now is Darius to post saying,not only was this a way to troll the bears but a way to troll the pvper's into carebearing Big smile


Hey you-Get out of my head and stop reading my private mails!

Tian Nu wrote:


seeng that they can't get fleets to shoot down mom sites any more he may just take you up on that one Blink


You are a moron. Just a typical moron though, not a superstar moron like ENDEVOR.

I understand that because we form up on weekends and kill all the moms in empire people like to think that we will always do it every time. I like that theres some guy who was telling BTL / TDF that his "blackbird fleet is the only reason we didnt come" yesterday.

You arent even good Bears, if you were good Bears, and had some guts and any brains-you would be out hunting for the new 4 Billion ISK Invuls that drop from plexes that take 20 minutes to finish. Brick members got 2 A-type and and some B,C types over the last days.

As it is, this is only a very minor side job for Bricks. We don't have to form to kill every Mom every time, and we wont. We'll come when we want, if we want. The coalition doesnt need me, doesnt need Brick, doesnt need Krissada. All the interdiction fleets need is some guys to make it happen.

Believe it or not carebears, it really isnt about you/your incursions etc. It doesnt mean that mean that much to me to mean that much to you. A single day goes by without us killng your farmville NPC's and suddenly you are on top of the world telling people "they cant get a fleet together" LOLS.



I agree youre tears are the best, ty for those. Keep begging for fleet on coms and i cast you my CSM vote.Blink

Let me clarify some things about ISK for you:

http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/831/tianeve.jpg/

we are not all poor like you are so keep scanning for those inv do the dirty work for me (be my slave) and i will gladly take them at 2bill pop from you Blink

Father O'Malley about Darius III begging for whelp: “Hows that working out for ya ? I make it 02:21 and all I see is you begging Riverini to get numbers and trying to recruit from the incursion public channel.”

Aren Dar
EVE University
Ivy League
#772 - 2012-01-26 12:09:14 UTC
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:

The fact that published numbers (over months) state that for the first time in years EvE turned from deflation to inflation proves that it's neither a seasonal spike nor a anything else.


CCP state that the economy has experienced 'steady' inflation of about 1% a month for the last year and a half. That predates the incursion expansion.

Taken on it's own all that indicates is that at some point in the past the economy shifted from deflation to inflation, and incursions were unrelated to that change.
Amarr Citizen 532532632
Hedion University
Amarr Empire
#773 - 2012-01-26 12:12:58 UTC
Darius III wrote:


As it is, this is only a very minor side job for Bricks......



See also: Lies.

Darius III wrote:


Believe it or not carebears, it really isnt about you/your incursions etc. It doesnt mean that mean that much to me to mean that much to you. A single day goes by without us killng your farmville NPC's and suddenly you are on top of the world telling people "they cant get a fleet together" LOLS.



QQ?

CSM tears. Best tears.
Endeavour Starfleet
#774 - 2012-01-26 12:56:10 UTC
It is Endeavour the U is there for a reason. Such as the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Endeavour Or the Space shuttle.
Tian Nu
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#775 - 2012-01-26 13:07:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Tian Nu
Darius III wrote:
Soon you will not be able to count on having an incursion available to you 23/7. We will be killing the rest of the MS all at one time in a few days if negotiations with the BLT and TDF leaders fall apart.


Darius III wrote:
Soon you will not be able to count on having an incursion available to you on weekends. We will be killing the rest of the MS all at one time in a few days if negotiations with the BLT and TDF leaders fall apart.


I fixed it for you Blink

Father O'Malley about Darius III begging for whelp: “Hows that working out for ya ? I make it 02:21 and all I see is you begging Riverini to get numbers and trying to recruit from the incursion public channel.”

Herzog Wolfhammer
Sigma Special Tactics Group
#776 - 2012-01-26 15:58:47 UTC
Tian Nu wrote:
Darius III wrote:
Soon you will not be able to count on having an incursion available to you 23/7. We will be killing the rest of the MS all at one time in a few days if negotiations with the BLT and TDF leaders fall apart.


Darius III wrote:
Soon you will not be able to count on having an incursion available to you on weekends. We will be killing the rest of the MS all at one time in a few days if negotiations with the BLT and TDF leaders fall apart.


I fixed it for you Blink




Are you proud of not having a job?

Bring back DEEEEP Space!

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#777 - 2012-01-26 18:18:26 UTC
Aren Dar wrote:
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:

The fact that published numbers (over months) state that for the first time in years EvE turned from deflation to inflation proves that it's neither a seasonal spike nor a anything else.


CCP state that the economy has experienced 'steady' inflation of about 1% a month for the last year and a half. That predates the incursion expansion.

Taken on it's own all that indicates is that at some point in the past the economy shifted from deflation to inflation, and incursions were unrelated to that change.


It indicates that the nerfs done on other features (i.e. insurance, missions) were not enough to counter the ISK faucets of that time, and then a new massive ISK faucet has been planted on top of the already excessive ones. It might not be the starting cause but it is related with the issue as it makes it much worse.
Zubrette
R3d Fire
#778 - 2012-01-26 20:09:30 UTC
Zubrette wrote:
Today, my fellow griefer brother and sisters we struck a decisive blow to the Sansha Menace. No longer shall their looming shadows linger over our worlds. We defended our homes and loved ones from the greatest evil, devouring everything that does not concede to SANSHA KUVAKEI.

Those heroes who stood alone when no other capsuleers had the courage to stand up and fight for what they believed in shall forever be immortalized in history as greatest warriors of freedom and justice. Do not listen to the nay sayers who would try to twist you into villains for they, themselves work for the evil oppressor SANSHA KUVAKEI.

Gentlemen, you deserve a medal for completing the mission with overwhelming success. We were out numbered, out gunned, jammed, and had lovely comedians come onto our teamspeak to cheer us on and encourage us to finish our goals. Thank you BTL for helping us in our time of need by giving us the lifting of our spirits to press on. The laughs you gave us really pushed us to excellence, making us feel calm and pristine after the hardened battle against the Sansha invasion. Without your love and support, this would have not been possible.

In closing I would like to thank our loved ones who supported and cared for us during this long war, for if it had been you caring for us we would have withered away to dust in the pages of history. This proves that with the right leadership, structure, support and love for your other players - truly anything is possible.

HAIL, BRICKSQUAD/SKUNWORKS & COMPANY, VANQUISHERS OF THE SANSHA MENACE!
FloppieTheBanjoClown
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#779 - 2012-01-26 22:12:51 UTC
Don't forget Lead Farmers man! They were awesome through the whole thing.

Founding member of the Belligerent Undesirables movement.

Aren Dar
EVE University
Ivy League
#780 - 2012-01-27 11:35:09 UTC
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
Aren Dar wrote:

CCP state that the economy has experienced 'steady' inflation of about 1% a month for the last year and a half. That predates the incursion expansion.

Taken on it's own all that indicates is that at some point in the past the economy shifted from deflation to inflation, and incursions were unrelated to that change.


It indicates that the nerfs done on other features (i.e. insurance, missions) were not enough to counter the ISK faucets of that time, and then a new massive ISK faucet has been planted on top of the already excessive ones. It might not be the starting cause but it is related with the issue as it makes it much worse.


If inflation was 1% both BEFORE and AFTER incursions, how does that show that incursions made things "much worse"? Incursions were only released in November 2010, they are making a claim that goes back to mid-2010.

FWIW I suspect that CCP decided that mild inflation was preferable to deflation - because of the risks of deflationary spirals - and re-balanced the various ISK sources in that direction through 2010.