These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

PIE and the 24th Imperial Crusade Threaten The Disciples of Ston

Author
Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#81 - 2012-01-04 18:14:55 UTC
Manwe Todako wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:


Let me put it this way - were all of the the slaves released by their legal owners?

Had any of the slaves at any time been subject to forcible release?

Had any of the slaves escaped contrary to the wishes of their owners?


Answers:
Question One: All the slaves we have rescued were illegally sold by their holders to lawless slavers or lawless pilots who sought to illegally transport them out of Amarrian space and sell them into slavery to other buyers. Thus; it is the holders you should be investigating whoever they may be.
Question Two: What is forcible release? I'm not sure what you are talking about. The case of Tobias might apply but you'll have to explain that one.
Question Three: None of the former slaves we have thus far rescued has escaped from their holders. But, the Disciples of Ston will offer sanctuary to any slave who has escaped and appeals for sanctuary so long as they are not guilty of crimes worthy of incarceration or death. If such is the case, they are welcome to be interred in our detention facility if they prefer that to whatever other punishment they might incur elsewhere. The Disciples of Ston oppose the death penalty and will protect even captured slavers from being returned to authorities to be put to death. No slaver we have rescued has requested to return to Amarr for "justice."


Can you back your claims up with documentary evidence?

Forcible release is when slaves are released by a third party against the wishes of their owner.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#82 - 2012-01-04 18:20:46 UTC
Mensha Khael Crow wrote:


Would you object to these being confirmed somehow? Perhaps an interview to confirm they are aware of the option and prefer not to apply to it?


Not at all, we have struggled with trying to make sure that the slavers we rescue aren't just saying what they think we want them to say. We have told them that we are willing to hand them over to the Amarrian authorities. Our only stipulation is that the death penalty, torture, and generational slavery are off the table. We have not received any reply from any governmental authorities nor from Concord, who we have asked numerous times to assist us in the final placement of these individuals. Find a neutral party that the Disciples trust and that the detainees trust, and we will get to it.

Right now, we are floating an idea both to our detainee population and to our Council of Elders about establishing a voluntary rehabilitation work program, whereby slavers could work in the M-Centers for their release. This would be strictly voluntary. Details have yet to be worked out.

SANKOFA

Thgil Goldcore
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#83 - 2012-01-04 18:57:34 UTC
In terms of legality, I believe that taking in the slaves abandoned in space would make them YOUR slaves... What you do with them in terms of release them or use them for hard labor is your completely your choice. Taking from the container is Concord's law, not Amarrian law.

I have little to no interest in that. I know and expect that you will have many slaves on your premises and will be freeing them. You have already made that fact quite public and if we had a problem with that activity we would already be at war with you.

My interest is if your using Amarrian space to conduct militia activities such as training or procurement of weapons for hostile forces. If you are found guilty of this, then Amarrian space should be barred from you by force.

I notice many of the detractors here who are arguing in your favor Manwe are the exact same people who you could be providing arms or personnel to. Obviously we care very little about people who we are already at war with what they think... and its not helping your case at all.

So, it comes down to this Manwe, since Ston made it rather apparent that you are the one whom will make all the decisions in this matter, you need to decide.

Will you subject yourself to investigation. Your irrational fears that we will swoop down once we find your facilities and take your slaves from you is entirely unfounded. Say what you like about PIE, we do follow Amarrian law... That would be a rather large violation of Amarrian law. Those are YOUR slaves, we have little interest in them.

Or will you subject yourself to war. It is a last resort I am not fond of. But hostile forces to the empire should be removed from empire space.

I don't really care what anyone else has to say on the matter. Manwe, your future is in your hands.

Thgil Goldcore
Divine Commodore of the 24th Imperial Crusade.
Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#84 - 2012-01-04 20:00:14 UTC
Thgil Goldcore wrote:
In terms of legality, I believe that taking in the slaves abandoned in space would make them YOUR slaves... Those are YOUR slaves, we have little interest in them...

Thgil Goldcore
Divine Commodore of the 24th Imperial Crusade.


This is the mindset the bring tears to our eyes and groans to our hearts. The mindset that these people that we rescue must be someone's property; that the law says either they belong to you or they belong to me; that they are your possession or my possession. NO! They are human beings created in the Divine image and they are not anyone's property; not mine, not yours. We consider these human souls to be endowed by their creator with the inalienable right to liberty. Let the law say what it says, this principle remains our underlying value.

SANKOFA

Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#85 - 2012-01-04 20:32:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Lyn Farel
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Caellach Marellus wrote:
the Disciples called her bluff. .


..and yet they still complied with the demands to be granted a tour?

If PIE is indeed given a tour then it would appear to me that the direct, "bullying" approach was in fact successful in the end?


Even with a good result, it may still remain a prejudice to PIE Inc reputation considering the PR blunder it actually is. I am not sure that the outcome is still a positive one.
Thgil Goldcore
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#86 - 2012-01-04 22:31:15 UTC
I think alot of people dont understand how an inspection works. You cant ask to see if they comply, you must demand it.

What am I going to do, say 'will you let me inspect your facilities' and if they say no I just go 'ok... i'll take your word that your being honest.' No... If there is no threat for someone committing illegal acts, does the investigation matter? No...

This is cut and dry. There is plenty of reason to warrant investigation. From being very outspoken against the empire to receiving funding and support from hostile military forces, this investigation is clearly a worthwhile endeavor.

Just so there is a level playing field of expectations, I will break down things down so you know what to expect. I will be as straightforward as I can and plan no deception. Whatever you have to say about PIE, you cannot fault us for being anything less than honest and strait-forward.

Things I will consider crimes or hostile actions.

-Sending money, weapons, or trained personal to hostile militia forces.
-preforming as a recon platform for hostile militia forces.
-Any other action that can be considered aggressive to the empire.
-Hiding any aspect from the inspection. The inspection will be complete, you can't say 'sorry, not our military training room.'

Things that I expect, and don't consider a crime against the empire

-Holding slaves.
-Non-Amarrian ideals. While offensive, not illegal or military in nature... I would make such things public knowledge though.
-Blockade running. You are running the other nations blockades, not Amarrian ones. I don't care.
-Training for civil jobs. I understand you operate, in part, as a school. which can include training personal in star-ship operation. Provided that its not military in nature, this is not a crime.
-receiving funds from military organizations. As long as these funds are used strictly for humanitarian uses, as you say you are, this is not a crime in itself. You have already made this fact public. If I did have a problem with it, we would be at war right now.

My investigation team will come with specialists including weapons and logistical experts. Their job is to simply look for signs of the crimes I have listed out. They will be granted moderator level access to your systems, you are permitted to have your own specialists shadow them to be sure they are doing exactly what they say they are.

I give you my word that I will not
- I will not be searching for a record of slave names to look for escaped slaves.
-Share the location of your centers with anyone (under the condition that you're found innocent).
- Bring weapons onto your premises or surveillance gear. Once my inspection is over, you need not fear nanite cameras.

Now, Our demands are very clear... I will not play any more games and see you jump around in circles trying to prolong this any more. I am willing to negotiate a few points, however such negotiations should be private, as this entire issue should have been.

I will ask once more and no more after.

Do you submit to inspection?
Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#87 - 2012-01-04 22:37:34 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Caellach Marellus wrote:
the Disciples called her bluff. .


..and yet they still complied with the demands to be granted a tour?

If PIE is indeed given a tour then it would appear to me that the direct, "bullying" approach was in fact successful in the end?


Even with a good result, it may still remain a prejudice to PIE Inc reputation considering the PR blunder it actually is. I am not sure that the outcome is still a positive one.


So a few more people or organizations that already hate PIE and everything they stand for might now not like them or their methods?

Say it ain't so!

The only opinions fiathful Amarrians need lose any sleep over are the opinions of other faithful Amarrians.

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Annara Shardani
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#88 - 2012-01-04 23:03:40 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
The only opinions fiathful Amarrians need lose any sleep over are the opinions of other faithful Amarrians.
That is a valid statement.
So allow me to state that the manner in which ms Goldcore comported herself was highly inelegant and disappointing.
I would expect better of my fellow Amarrians.
Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#89 - 2012-01-05 00:19:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Caellach Marellus
Silas Vitalia wrote:
So a few more people or organizations that already hate PIE and everything they stand for might now not like them or their methods?

Say it ain't so!


It takes blind eyes and ignorance to think that only PIE's detractors would frown on their conduct here.


Quote:
The only opinions faithful Amarrians need lose any sleep over are the opinions of other faithful Amarrians.


And it's that backward thinking that means you will forever find yourself struggling when dealing with matters beyond Imperial control. There is a who universe out there that isn't Amarrian, you do yourself no favours with segregation and disillusioned notions of superiority.


Again, you're taking this off topic with your archaic mindset.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#90 - 2012-01-05 00:39:17 UTC
Thgil Goldcore wrote:
I think alot of people dont understand how an inspection works. You cant ask to see if they comply, you must demand it.


Actually you can ask, quite politely as a first line of diplomacy, especially when dealing with non hostile entities. Just because you don't consider it to be a valid approach doesn't mean it's doomed to fail. Perhaps you should learn a bit about tact.


Quote:
What am I going to do, say 'will you let me inspect your facilities' and if they say no I just go 'ok... i'll take your word that your being honest.'


No, you further explain your position, while assuring any concerns they have that do not cross with your reasons for being there. You engage in a (not always, but potentially) lengthy discussion, advancing through negotiation (yes, negotiation. You're making a huge request here with little benefit to them for your compliance).

Should you find yourself at a situation where you have allayed their concerns, and yet are still being held back by either stubborn nature and/or unreasonable demands (Note: Demands in general through negotiation aren't unreasonable by default. Don't just say "You shouldn't get to ask anything of me, this is unreasonable!") At this point your words should become more forceful and enforce consequences (at least ones you can actually deliver, don't try calling their bluff if you're new to this stuff)

Should this all fail, make plans for whatever action you deem necessary, at least you've tried.

Sounds boring, complicated, unnecessary and frustrating right? Well that's diplomacy for you, it requires patience, tact and skill. However it has an advantage over simply bullrushing in, good diplomacy forges bridges for further contact in future. It's also more likely to get you what you want, without a bitter taste left in the mouth.

Charging in and threatening to declare war is no better than to simply kick someone's door down and threaten to set fire to their sitting room if they don't let you use their bathroom. No, that analogy isn't flawed as you have as much right to enter someone's property as your little gold badge actually gives you the right to demand this investigation.

You should find yourself fortunate that the Disciples don't consider this act of aggression on your behalf as a threat, and consider starting the very actions you're demanding this inspection to search for, in retaliation.

Quote:
This is cut and dry. There is plenty of reason to warrant investigation. From being very outspoken against the empire to receiving funding and support from hostile military forces, this investigation is clearly a worthwhile endeavor.


You might have reasons for wishing to investigate, that isn't in question. It's just your approach has less tact than myself after a few bottles of Tequila.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Half Cocked Jack
Un4seen Development
Goonswarm Federation
#91 - 2012-01-05 02:32:49 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Rodj, are you saying that PIE Inc. now has the authority to uphold Amarrian Law on non-Amarrian organizations now? I would like to see where in your charter you claim that ability, and the official documentation from the MIO which allows you to do so.


We have the same authority as every other capsuleer organisation.


So what you are saying is that you have the authority to stomp your feet and vehemently and tell these Disciples--these Stoners--to submit to your will...resorting if necessary to the physical violence that inevitable leads to a short-lived pissing match between aligned parties? Congratulations, dear sir.
Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#92 - 2012-01-05 08:08:14 UTC
Unless Goldcore and her merry bunch of docksuleers have suddenly been relocated to Yulai and been placed in charge of the DED, SCC or another of CONCORD's high level enforcement branches, they have absolutely no standing to demand a damned thing from another sovereign capsuleer organization. Their choices are to declare war or shut the hell up. End of story.

Well done Disciples for exposing this ill-considered, heavy-handed amateur bullying attempt.

By the way, sorry that I'm late to this party. Put me down as interested in participating as a volunteer observer representing EM should this "investigatory tour" proceed. I promise I won't laugh in Goldcore's face...much. Blink

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Half Cocked Jack
Un4seen Development
Goonswarm Federation
#93 - 2012-01-05 10:02:38 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
By the way, sorry that I'm late to this party. Put me down as interested in participating as a volunteer observer representing EM should this "investigatory tour" proceed. I promise I won't laugh in Goldcore's face...much. Blink


I'd also volunteer to watch, but I don't go into the Empire's territories unless armed to the teeth for a number of reasons. Least of which being these very sorts of legal spats over former slaves. I quite forcefully liberated myself, back in the day.

Also, apologies for referencing a comment from so far back in the conversation that had already been hashed out. The arrangement of these new interfaces put me under the false impression that I was viewing the last page. Also, wine.
Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#94 - 2012-01-05 10:26:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Caellach Marellus
I would hope any representative from whichever groups attend any potential investigation conduct themselves with a sense of responsibility and maturity. And respect, if not for each other then at least for your hosts.


Otherwise you're about as much use as non stick duct tape.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Arkady Sadik
Gradient
Electus Matari
#95 - 2012-01-05 11:05:20 UTC
Nation states are tied by multinational treaties and legislation. Especially in space, hands are often tied by necessity and realpolitik. Loyalist capsuleer organizations have always tried to fill in the gaps and enforce those rules and policies that the nations themselves can not, for whatever reason. The loyalist organizations assume that the nations they are loyal to would like those to be enacted that way, but of course this can never be proven. I took this "investigation" as such an approach: An attempt to enact the intent of the Empire without official Empire sanction.

This also means that requesting "proper papers" is difficult. Either they can easily be faked, or they are pretty much impossible to come by even for a genuine organization.

But in the end, the situation is simple: PIE wishes to investigate a group of capsuleers operating in the nation they are loyal to, to figure out how they should use their capsuleer powers in regards to them. That's nothing unusual. What is unusual is the rather hostile tone and open, direct threats, which turned a normal diplomatic contact into an aggressive attack.
Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#96 - 2012-01-05 13:36:59 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
Unless Goldcore and her merry bunch of docksuleers have suddenly been relocated to Yulai and been placed in charge of the DED, SCC or another of CONCORD's high level enforcement branches, they have absolutely no standing to demand a damned thing from another sovereign capsuleer organization. Their choices are to declare war or shut the hell up. End of story.

Well done Disciples for exposing this ill-considered, heavy-handed amateur bullying attempt.

By the way, sorry that I'm late to this party. Put me down as interested in participating as a volunteer observer representing EM should this "investigatory tour" proceed. I promise I won't laugh in Goldcore's face...much. Blink



It may be EM's policy to declare war on people without substantiating allegations, but we prefer to check the facts before taking action.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Arkady Sadik
Gradient
Electus Matari
#97 - 2012-01-05 13:42:27 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:
It may be EM's policy to declare war on people without substantiating allegations
If you have actual evidence of such, please provide it to us so we can act on it (in a different thread, or in private, up to you). Repeated slander in public to try and detract from your own case is not particularly professional, Admiral.

Arkady Sadik
Head Diplomat
Electus Matari
Manwe Todako
Disciples of Ston
#98 - 2012-01-05 15:44:27 UTC
Among our over 13,000 residents are a good number of former slaves who slaved aboard the war vessels of PIE and the 24th Imperial Crusade. These former slaves were compelled to assist their captors in killing their own kin, brothers, sisters, tribesmen in wars fought to defend their own continued captivity. These former slaves watched dear friends die in these battles and watched more of their kin being taken captive into slavery. Now these former slaves are no longer cannon fodder for Amarrian Slave Lords. They are now free; free as they can be under the continued oppressive policies of our governments. Having full access to these discussions on our public information system, the populations of our Matriculation Centers know full well the stakes.

Could we look them in the eye and tell them that a team of PIE and 24th IC specialists will sweep through their new homes, schools, places of worship, places of work and places of gathering? Could we say that we would simply let their former captors do this on their own terms with full, unfettered access? This would be treason against humanity as far as we are concerned. The conditions of any tour have been set forth by our Elder Council, but the continued aggressive, accusatory edge to PIE’s demands makes trust a fading commodity.

We cannot betray the trust that has been placed upon us by the Residents, Elder Leaders, and Corporate sponsors of our work. We simply cannot. NO, WE WILL NOT SUBMIT TO INSPECTION ON YOUR TERMS, PIE and 24th IC.

To those who have offered kind assistance, we are very grateful. If you would assist us, do so by helping us continue rescuing former slaves at border crossings and in battlefields and wherever they may need rescue. Do not take up arms for us or kill on our behalf for this is not our way. If we are hindered in our work, the best assistance will be to help us continue it.

SANKOFA

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#99 - 2012-01-05 15:48:34 UTC
Arkady Sadik wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
It may be EM's policy to declare war on people without substantiating allegations
If you have actual evidence of such, please provide it to us so we can act on it (in a different thread, or in private, up to you). Repeated slander in public to try and detract from your own case is not particularly professional, Admiral.

Arkady Sadik
Head Diplomat
Electus Matari



You're the one who claimed that the only options in these situations are war and shutting up.

And since your alliance has been known to declare war...

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#100 - 2012-01-05 15:53:34 UTC
Manwe Todako wrote:
Among our over 13,000 residents are a good number of former slaves who slaved aboard the war vessels of PIE and the 24th Imperial Crusade.


And how exactly did you acquire these slaves?

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori