These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123
 

Slaves or no

First post
Author
Ghoest
#41 - 2012-01-02 21:47:47 UTC
Blue Rook wrote:
Ghoest wrote:
[quote=Eyup Mi'duck]
My problem is that CCP tied a negative in game status to a real life group - and in a way parallels and magnifies some ugly history .
If the in game groupings had not been tied to real life races I would be content to let people role play slavers.


Well.. the uglyness of history should always be magnified - atleast in so much that ignoring history dooms all to repetition. (feel the platitude burn) That being said, New Eden is riddled with barbaric practices - slavery, being only a fraction of them.




You are doing a bit of semantic sleight of hand.

I said something in an obvious context and you are knowingly responding with reference to the word in a different context.

Magnify can simply mean "to make larger" and it was obvious that was my usage. You responded using it with reference to vision.

mag·ni·fy/ˈmagnəˌfī/
Verb:

1 -Make (something) appear larger than it is, esp. with a lens or microscope.
2 -Be capable of increasing the size or apparent size of something.

Wherever You Went - Here You Are

Ghoest
#42 - 2012-01-02 21:50:12 UTC
Rhinanna wrote:
Your argument only holds ANY truth if you regard there as been no difference between effective intelligence and potential intelligence. A person with a lesser education with have a lower effective intelligence than someone who has had a better education.
They how how to analyse information better because they have been taught to.

You are reading into it that CCP were saying that the minmatar race is genetically less intelligent than the others, instead of the simple fact that a race emerging from slavery is much much less likely to have the same education facilities. I'm fairly sure that educating their slaves wasn't a high piroity for the amarr.....




You lost - and now you are shaming yourself.

hush

Wherever You Went - Here You Are

Large Collidable Object
morons.
#43 - 2012-01-02 22:04:20 UTC
Rose Hips wrote:
Q: Would a Minmatar "Capsuleer" ever be a slave of an Amarr Capsuleer?



Actually, I am owned by an Amarr master - however, I'm well-fed and he provides me with beautiful makeup in barrels.

There's happiness in slavery.
You know... [morons.](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gjOx65yD5A)
Vyl Vit
#44 - 2012-01-02 22:10:35 UTC
Hmmm....when they were giving out brains you thought they said "trains" and passed it up.

Paradise is like where you are right now, only much, much better.

Pok Nibin
Doomheim
#45 - 2012-01-02 22:11:37 UTC
They may take some convincing, but I'm optimistic.

The right to free speech doesn't automatically carry with it the right to be taken seriously.

Blue Rook
Ghost Cabal
#46 - 2012-01-02 22:14:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Blue Rook
Ghoest wrote:


You are doing a bit of semantic sleight of hand.



You are correct and on the nose.
Though, I did/do understand the/your contextual usage of magnify.


Unfortunately I'm not overly impressed with with societies ability to maintain an accurate and consistent awareness of history. I'll take what I can get, as far as whatever it takes to ensure that the present and future retain a memory of certain blunders of humanity.

Ofcourse not all historical tragedies such as slavery, genocide, and similar depravity are exaggerated (magnified). Enough of them have been dragged into the present social recall as one-liners or tasteless humor I'm ashamed to say. But like I said, I'll take what I can get.
RubyPorto
RubysRhymes
#47 - 2012-01-02 22:43:12 UTC
Yeah, this thread isn't going anywhere good. I'm getting out of here. It's a pain I have to shiptoast to unfollow a thread, innit?

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths." -Abrazzar "the risk of having your day ruined by other people is the cornerstone with which EVE was built" -CCP Solomon

Rhinanna
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#48 - 2012-01-03 01:09:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Rhinanna
Ghoest wrote:
Rhinanna wrote:
Your argument only holds ANY truth if you regard there as been no difference between effective intelligence and potential intelligence. A person with a lesser education with have a lower effective intelligence than someone who has had a better education.
They how how to analyse information better because they have been taught to.

You are reading into it that CCP were saying that the minmatar race is genetically less intelligent than the others, instead of the simple fact that a race emerging from slavery is much much less likely to have the same education facilities. I'm fairly sure that educating their slaves wasn't a high piroity for the amarr.....




You lost - and now you are shaming yourself.

hush


Ah so basically you don't have a counter to my argument, that would mean you lose not the other way round.

You haven't answered any of my arguments, frankly if there is anyone making themselves look silly here its you.

There is NOTHING disrespectful about RPing a slaver at all, unless you ACTUALLY have a decent argument that:

1- Links in game Black people to IRL Black people
2- Can show that Intelligence in game is mean to be potential/genetic intelligence instead of applied/train intelligence.

Then you don't have an argument I'm afraid cos you are making massive assumptions and using them as facts.

Given point 2 is virtually proven to be false as better educated people score better on every IQ test available it seems that your argument is based mainly on your bum fluff.

Either that or you've simply failed to understand what I'm saying.

-The sword is only as sharp as the one who wields it! Other names: Drenzul (WoT, WoW, Lineage 2, WarH, BloodBowl, BSG, SC2 and lots more) 

CausticS0da
Shrubbery Acquisitions
Blohm and Voss Shipyards Alliance
#49 - 2012-01-04 09:32:12 UTC
Valei Khurelem wrote:
CCP Navigator wrote:
Guys and Girls,

if you wish to discuss the backstory of EVE in regards to the Amarr and Minmatar then please do so. If I believe that your posts are racist in nature, or point to real world events, you will be off these forums permanently.

Here is a rule of thumb before you have to ask, 'What is allowed?', consider for a moment if I will like it. If not, don't post it.

Simple.


I'm sorry, but this is why having a 12+ rating for EVE and having slavery/sex in the lore you have is a stupid idea.

What this says to people is "Yes, we have sex and violence in our games, but no we don't talk about it and we won't allow anyone else to talk about it" this some of the most nonsensical case of political correctness I've ever read and I regularly get news from the BBC, please stop being a bunch of pussies and just give this game an 18+ rating already. Your sales won't fall because children who want to play the game will either lie about their age or get their parents to buy it for them, the only people who care about this thing are people who either don't have children or are parents who are completely incompetent and incapable of raising them.

People need to stop running around and pretending they're for freedom of speech and expression and then immediately going back on what they say the moment anyone decides to bring up real issues.

Oh and stop censoring swear words you stupid assholes, I know of kids as young as 13 who know exactly what it all means so it just proves it does nothing anyway.


*searches for dislike button.
Errubus
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#50 - 2012-01-25 17:38:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Errubus
First of all I have to admit I have not read all the chronicles, so I'm basing my views on the Novels and the character description from the game.
Well to answer the original question I would say the answer is yes, though it's a complex issue.
I was going to start off with discussing Ni-Kunni Capsuleers, but the Ni-Kunni are, for the most part, not considered slaves anymore. As such I'll have to be a bit more theoretical.
Since the question is would a Capsuleer be a slave to another Capsuleer I think you can cut that into two separate questions. Would someone willingly remain/become a slave if they were a Capsuleer and can a Capsuleer be forced into slavery?
Quote:
As a culture Amarr adheres to the basic tenet that what others call slavery is in fact one step on an indentured person’s spiritual path to fully embracing their faith

To the Amarr faith slavery is not an ends, it is a means. Many former slaves have been released and are now influential free member of society. It is used on those that do not embrace the Amarr faith right away. And ofc the children of slaves are born as slaves. If a slave shows the proper faith he or she can be freed. Now a freed slave is ofc no longer a slave and would not count towards the answer if a slave can be a Capsuleer. Still, someone who is on the verge of being freed could be made a Capsuleer. Prime fiction shows most slaves as being either ignorant, drug addict or people desperately holding on waiting for the moment they are free. Ofc other pieces of fiction are just as 'guilty' of raising similar views of slaves. Not all slaves were noble sufferers however. Many were well treated and mostly content. Some quite indoctrinated to believe that they were in fact 'inferior' and deferential to their masters. So in this setting of fiction I am sure there are countless millions of slaves quite content to be slaves or even quite willing to be freed only to serve the Empire as a free person. Now a normal Holder would not quickly make such a willing servant a Capsuleer. After all they could easily outlive them and who knows what could happen in the future. But if said Holder were a Capsuleer then it is conceivable the slave could be made a Capsuleer to be on hand forevermore. Now what eternity might hold in store is another matter entirely. And if a free Minmatar Capsuleer would want to join the Empire he or she may be made a slave at first to test his or her conviction.

Now the other question is a bit more difficult; can a Capsuleer be forced into slavery. Others have said the Capsuleer can simply bolt and run. There are ways to prevent even a Capsuleer ship from performing certain acts. Though this does require foresight I'm sure a ships navigation computer can be set to disable the warp engines and jumps to certain gates. The same may be applied to ships guns, so they can't fire on ships with a certain transponder signal. Now that won’t get someone to act in a way you'd want, it can make them not act in the way you don’t want. As for just killing yourself to be transferred into a clone that does imply that there is a clone to get back to. It's clearly stated in fiction that if you don't have a pre-prepared clone to jump to when your body dies you will die for real. So if there is no clone there is also no escape. Aside from this, the urge to live is quite strong in every being. To actually commit suicide takes quite a lot and even that can be prevented if you know the other might try this. Now that still doesn't make someone act the way you want them to. Vitoc or similar drugs won't work, since it dulls the mind, the one thing that's so powerful in a Capsuleer. So you'd need to force them in some other way. Threat of force may work if the Capsuleer has no clone to go to and can be made to fear the beatings more then whatever you want them to do. Equally you can hold people dear to the Capsuleer hostage. This would also limit the threat of a Capsuleer jumping clones since doing so would endanger the ones he or she is trying to protect. And there are ways of brainwashing a Capsuleer if Templar One is any proof. Ofc this all takes rather a lot of effort and one can wonder if it's even worth it.
But with the proper leverage I'm sure a Capsuleer can be made to do things they would not do of their own volition. So yes a Capsuleer can become a slave to another in my opinion.
Weiland Taur
The Icarus Expedition
Solyaris Chtonium
#51 - 2012-01-28 16:17:59 UTC
Per the idea of a capsuleer being enslaved, several of the chronicles deal with this idea. One in particular, I would link but that would take away the opportunity for the reader to find their way through some very good fiction, deals with a Minmatar clone tech who deposits Amarr Capsuleers into Slavers, (the hounds). A particularly chilling story.

I have wondered if the Incarna expansion would deal with the kidnapping, ransoming and or enslavement of fellow capsuleers? It would be an interesting game play mechanic until it hit the real world news that Eve online was promoting slavery, not the type of press you want especially given the resurgence of slavery in the real life. Not to mention the mass desubs that would follow players waking up in small cells surrounded by sign posts reading, "u mad bro?"

Oh, and the Minmatar where not enslaved since the dawn of time. It was only after the Amarr had enslaved their neighbors on their homeworlds that they stumbled onto the Matari society during one of their Reclaimings. The Matari was an advanced society except crippled by two key differences from their attackers, they had failed to reinvent stargate technology and like their real world equivalents their tribal system most likely would have created issues in dealing with a coordinated attack from an autocratic and single minded adversary.

We can of course see this advanced nature in the Elder beat down of Amarr before the sudden Dues ex Machina intervention of Empress Samur.

Honnete Du Decimer
#52 - 2012-01-28 16:41:30 UTC
Rose Hips wrote:
Q: Would a Minmatar "Capsuleer" ever be a slave of an Amarr Capsuleer?


I am feel that OP is talk about fetish thing. Need go look Second Life. They have it there with space ship even.

Also if want make it for the game, then they can give full API. You watch all thing. They live one station for you and must trade one ship for other ship with you for do anything. Twisted

PMS [:p]

Elessa Enaka
Doomheim
#53 - 2012-01-28 20:50:53 UTC
I have always thought that it was odd that the Brutor were the only "black" people in Eve. There is a similar situation with the Ni-Kunni (which if you ask me are obviously supposed to be Egyptians). Every faction has asians, just as every faction has "white" people. There is no need to add new bloodlines or factions, but I do think it would be a good idea to allow a little more variety in complexion among all bloodlines.


Rhinanna wrote:
Oh and if you think ANY of this is sick, wait till you see World of Darkness. All I have to say there is read about the Sabbat, that make ANYTHING the Amarr have done tame in comparison.


When the WOD MMO is released, I will have absolutely no interest in it whatsoever if the Sabbat is not a playable faction. Also, if it is based off of that fail Requiem ****, I will pass entirely.

Devour to survive, so it is, so it's always been Eve is a great game if you can get past all of the asshats....

Weiland Taur
The Icarus Expedition
Solyaris Chtonium
#54 - 2012-01-28 22:10:07 UTC
Elessa Enaka wrote:
I have always thought that it was odd that the Brutor were the only "black" people in Eve. There is a similar situation with the Ni-Kunni (which if you ask me are obviously supposed to be Egyptians). Every faction has asians, just as every faction has "white" people. There is no need to add new bloodlines or factions, but I do think it would be a good idea to allow a little more variety in complexion among all bloodlines.


Sadly CCP follows the same paradigm that so many science fiction universes do with the "black" peoples being the more robust physically intimidating sort but lacking in the high technology of their tan deficient brethren.

Their is a wonderful moment in Clear Skies 2 (I believe) at the end where the one of the guys points out the Maelstrom and comments something along the line of it being what the Matari can make when not running for their lives. It's a nicely worded tribute to the fact that their enslavement was not their destiny or in fact what forged them but a moment that they escaped from. It makes me wonder when CCP will roll out new Matari ships that reflect their post enslavement industrial capabilities.
Roll Sizzle Beef
Space Mutiny
#55 - 2012-01-28 22:46:52 UTC
Any capsuleer could be at risk of enslavement in many scenarios. when away from scanning equipment (pod or otherwise) that could scan and fry the current bodies brain to be received at a designated medical station. The risk of permanent death could make them compliant.
On the other hand, a hacked or weaponized scanner could fry a capsuleer brain and implant them into a host body of choice, So death would be rewarded with a new body to torture if disloyal. An expensive option. but as a political prisoner, worth it.
Previous page123