These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Caldari State] Liberation of Nennamaila

Author
Arrendis
TK Corp
#81 - 2016-12-10 01:57:18 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:
Oh for Maker's sake, I am stupid, I am terribly sorry, I confused the threads!!


Quite alright, these things happen.

Quote:

The Caldari State gave us though the promise to invade the Federation and we believe it.

Besides that fighting in the warzone is not just for "winning the war". It is for protection of those who live there from the occupants. And even if we liberate all the system - we have still to fight to protect them from being occupied and oppressed again.


Yes, but see, that's rather the point, isn't it? The Caldari State is prohibited from invading the Federation wholesale by CONCORD, and the other Yulai signatories would all (including the Amarr Empire) be required to enforce that by defending the Federation. Wouldn't it simply make more sense to stop the fighting, so that the gains you've made can't be reversed by the Federation?
Skyweir Kinnison
Doomheim
#82 - 2016-12-10 09:07:53 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
Yes, but see, that's rather the point, isn't it? The Caldari State is prohibited from invading the Federation wholesale by CONCORD, and the other Yulai signatories would all (including the Amarr Empire) be required to enforce that by defending the Federation. Wouldn't it simply make more sense to stop the fighting, so that the gains you've made can't be reversed by the Federation?


You are of course, correct that it would make more sense to stop - though your earlier thesis about the economic benefits explains why there is also an imperative to continue.

However, one of the politically charged issues about stopping is deciding who has made 'gains'. The FDU has held most of the war zone for most of the last few years. Should the war have stopped then, with only a couple of systems in State hands? Much earlier, the Protectorate had made large gains - perhaps that was the moment? Inevitably, there are loud arguments on both sides. Commander Kim expects the war to be carried right into the Federation. I daresay there are vested interests (President Roden's armaments interests clearly notwithstanding in any way) which wanted the recent domination of the war zone to be pushed further into the State.

The wars of the null-sec powers often see clearly defined wins and losses in terms of territory, materiel, and prestige.They come to an end - sometimes swiftly, sometimes after years of varying intensity. Such an end is about to be played out in M-OE88 this very day.

The CONCORD sanctioned phony wars will have no such conclusion, I fear. There is - most unusually for a conflict - no obvious victory condition.


Humanity has won its battle. Liberty now has a country.

Arrendis
TK Corp
#83 - 2016-12-10 16:23:47 UTC
Skyweir Kinnison wrote:
You are of course, correct that it would make more sense to stop - though your earlier thesis about the economic benefits explains why there is also an imperative to continue.


Oh, totally. There's absolutely no reason for the governments involved to want anything but a continuation of the meaningless violence—they care more about the ISK being spent, the taxes being generated, and the sheer entertainment/propaganda value of the fighting than they do about the lives lost on and above those worlds.

Quote:

However, one of the politically charged issues about stopping is deciding who has made 'gains'. The FDU has held most of the war zone for most of the last few years. Should the war have stopped then, with only a couple of systems in State hands? Much earlier, the Protectorate had made large gains - perhaps that was the moment? Inevitably, there are loud arguments on both sides. Commander Kim expects the war to be carried right into the Federation. I daresay there are vested interests (President Roden's armaments interests clearly notwithstanding in any way) which wanted the recent domination of the war zone to be pushed further into the State.


The obvious answer, of course, is 'it would depend on when it happens'. Any war can have sudden reversals. If you know you can't hold onto your gains indefinitely, you offer peace when you're in a position of strength. If you know you can't retake your losses, you sue for peace while you can still make aggression costly.

Quote:

The wars of the null-sec powers often see clearly defined wins and losses in terms of territory, materiel, and prestige.They come to an end - sometimes swiftly, sometimes after years of varying intensity. Such an end is about to be played out in M-OE88 this very day.


Quite probably, yes—though some are already questioning whether this will mark an end to the war, or simply knock one of the parties out of it while the fighting shifts to the Vale of the Silent. The more interesting question for me, though, is where Circle-of-Two goes from here.

Gigx is a proud man—something that has been fairly consistently used against him, really. He betrayed his former allies in order to hold onto his space. Now he's lost that, to the very people whom he loudly proclaimed would be new allies. Black Omega, evicted from Syndicate, was folded into CO2 with only their industrial/pirate-hunting interests remaining semi-independent for branding purposes.

The closest thing he has to friends now is TEST, who fought to defend CO2 at least in part because CO2's presence in Tribute provided them a buffer zone where PL supercapitals wouldn't be basing to hunt TEST capitals and supers being used to generate income. If TEST isn't evicted, will CO2 look to crash on their couch for a while? Will they even be allowed to? Unlike FCON and RZR, CO2's relationship with XIX and the Drone Regions is amazingly bad. Their relations with Stainwagon are possibly worse—and Stainwagon, Red Alliance, and similar groups in the southeast have... other reasons... to Bee less than welcoming to CO2.

And those reasons mean you can be reasonably sure CO2 won't come within ten LY of Delve. So where do they go? Outer Ring? Who will actually trust Gigx to honor his alliances now, and not turn on his 'friends' as soon as they're inconvenient/he thinks he can get a better deal/he stabbing them in the back will let him save his own butt?

I know I'm gonna be making popcorn for weeks as the aftermath of this one unfolds.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#84 - 2016-12-11 01:54:56 UTC
In YC115 the Federaton has violated the treaty they signed in YC110 and have invaded into Caldari Prime.

What did CONCORD? Nothing. They only marked all capsuleers as suspects.
Now it's our turn to repay the debt.

The Federation stepped the border already, and the war spilled into high security space. Now we have just one goal to achieve. The Federation must be destroyed.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Deitra Vess
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#85 - 2016-12-11 02:02:42 UTC
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....
Nevyn Auscent
Broke Sauce
#86 - 2016-12-11 03:29:58 UTC
Deitra Vess wrote:
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....

Just to correct history, Concord set everyone in system suspect when the Caldari destroyed the Concord Battleship that was there to resolve the situation. If Concord was to give someone more than a slap on the wrist, it would be the Caldari taking that, not the Gallente.
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.

We can argue over who was right and who was wrong, but lets at least recognise the real facts.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#87 - 2016-12-11 04:49:33 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Deitra Vess wrote:
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....

Just to correct history, Concord set everyone in system suspect when the Caldari destroyed the Concord Battleship that was there to resolve the situation. If Concord was to give someone more than a slap on the wrist, it would be the Caldari taking that, not the Gallente.
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.

We can argue over who was right and who was wrong, but lets at least recognise the real facts.

Well well, now ignorant asks to recognize his deliriums as "real facts".

Just look at these pearls. Especially this one.
Quote:
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.


Looks like little he knew that when these events happened (and actually why they did happen in first place) was a Gallente ground invasion on Caldari Prime. By doing so they have violated both Yulai convention and treaty of YC110. The fleet didn't get confirmation of the target and was moving in support position without actually bombarding. Though there were obviously hostile federal military units, not civilians.

And that fact could be verified by several footages that DUST mercenaries who fought for FDU side has provided.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Deitra Vess
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#88 - 2016-12-11 07:10:26 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Deitra Vess wrote:
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....

Just to correct history, Concord set everyone in system suspect when the Caldari destroyed the Concord Battleship that was there to resolve the situation. If Concord was to give someone more than a slap on the wrist, it would be the Caldari taking that, not the Gallente.
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.

We can argue over who was right and who was wrong, but lets at least recognise the real facts.

That I did not know, thanks!
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#89 - 2016-12-11 10:17:35 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Deitra Vess wrote:
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....

Just to correct history, Concord set everyone in system suspect when the Caldari destroyed the Concord Battleship that was there to resolve the situation. If Concord was to give someone more than a slap on the wrist, it would be the Caldari taking that, not the Gallente.
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.

We can argue over who was right and who was wrong, but lets at least recognise the real facts.


Concord was repeatedly warned to leave Sovreign Caldari State space and repeatedly refused. In the end Admiral Yanala removed a ship that was a material threat to the safe navigation of her command. I don't remember having a single problem with the destruction of that battleship, since it also finally silenced the unwarranted arrogance of the Concord lapdog piloting it.

What happened after that was the Gallente breach of yet another peace treaty and their casual disregard of all the dangers that Operation Highlander represented to the population of the planet below. Had Admiral Yanala been insane enough to carry out the insane orders given her, the Highlander force would not have been able to prevent it from happening, meaning that their strike was neither precise nor surgical and that the only thing certain about it was the desecration of Home, the deaths of multiple innocent Gallente and Caldari citizens and, of course, yet another dead Caldari hero.

Fortunately Capsuleer forces on the field were able to ensure that for every tear issued by the Caldari people for the loss of Admiral Yanala, an equal amount of Federal Navy blood was shed during the shattering of that portion of the Highlander fleet that did not manage to successfully flee into warp.

I am devoted to the untangling of relations between Gallente Federation and Caldari State and I am more than willing to admit that there are sins aplenty on both sides of the line, but whilst we can argue over who was right and who was wrong, let's at least recognise the real facts.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Nomistrav
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#90 - 2016-12-11 10:56:51 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Deitra Vess wrote:
Since Concord gave those responsible a slap on the wrist, shouldn't your grievance be with Concord for not enforcing the treaties our empires have signed? Concord did allow it to happen, allowed countless caldari to die at the hands of what is basically your arch rival. A rival that it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize would do just what they did.... Food for thought.....

Just to correct history, Concord set everyone in system suspect when the Caldari destroyed the Concord Battleship that was there to resolve the situation. If Concord was to give someone more than a slap on the wrist, it would be the Caldari taking that, not the Gallente.
The Gallente did not engage the titan until after the Concord battleship was destroyed, which showed that the Caldari were prepared to ignore the Yulai convention regarding civilian bombardment also.

We can argue over who was right and who was wrong, but lets at least recognise the real facts.


Concord was repeatedly warned to leave Sovreign Caldari State space and repeatedly refused. In the end Admiral Yanala removed a ship that was a material threat to the safe navigation of her command. I don't remember having a single problem with the destruction of that battleship, since it also finally silenced the unwarranted arrogance of the Concord lapdog piloting it.

What happened after that was the Gallente breach of yet another peace treaty and their casual disregard of all the dangers that Operation Highlander represented to the population of the planet below. Had Admiral Yanala been insane enough to carry out the insane orders given her, the Highlander force would not have been able to prevent it from happening, meaning that their strike was neither precise nor surgical and that the only thing certain about it was the desecration of Home, the deaths of multiple innocent Gallente and Caldari citizens and, of course, yet another dead Caldari hero.

Fortunately Capsuleer forces on the field were able to ensure that for every tear issued by the Caldari people for the loss of Admiral Yanala, an equal amount of Federal Navy blood was shed during the shattering of that portion of the Highlander fleet that did not manage to successfully flee into warp.

I am devoted to the untangling of relations between Gallente Federation and Caldari State and I am more than willing to admit that there are sins aplenty on both sides of the line, but whilst we can argue over who was right and who was wrong, let's at least recognise the real facts.


Take heed, Sir Tuulinen, that if we are to appreciate the real facts that we must also acknowledge the origins of said oeace treaty that the Federation violated. I speak for myself, but I find few people in the world that honor peace treaties they are strong armed to sign.

"As long as space endures,

as long as sentient beings exist,

until then, may I too remain

and dispel the miseries of the world."

~ Vremaja Idama

Jev North
Doomheim
#91 - 2016-12-11 11:13:58 UTC
Nomistrav wrote:
Sir Tuulinen

I know we've done some work for the 24th, but I completely missed you being knighted, Pieter! Congratulations.

Even though our love is cruel; even though our stars are crossed.

Woodrow Ormand
The Bosena Accords
Round Table Assembly
#92 - 2016-12-11 11:23:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Woodrow Ormand
According to the yulai convention, if I am not mistaken, Concord is placed as an intermediary and a multi national police force. So unless a nation leaves the treaties, which the state did not, they do not have the authority to order the Concord vessel out of the space above caldari prime. Now if the federation had sent a strike force to the planets surface before the state of emergency was declared, and if the advanced scanning capabilities of a leviathon class titan couldn't pick it up, then the far more advanced scanners of Concord would have picked it up and that day and the aftermath would have gone differently. Were there insurgents on the ground? Yes, that's what happens when you invade someone's home, but nothing sent or sanctioned by the federation, though we now know that they were preparing something anyway. If the leviathon hadn't moved into position with intentions to break a Concord sanctioned treaty and the federation had moved to enact operation highlander, then Concord would have sided with the state, but that is not how it played out.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#93 - 2016-12-11 15:12:08 UTC
Woodrow Ormand wrote:
According to the yulai convention, if I am not mistaken, Concord is placed as an intermediary and a multi national police force. So unless a nation leaves the treaties, which the state did not, they do not have the authority to order the Concord vessel out of the space above caldari prime.

Would they? And what would they do? Shake fist? We all know how their HQ was blapped in YC110 just by several crazy tribals. Do you really think they would have a chance against whole Federation fleet? Their ship has been destroyed by our Navy, and what did they do? Sent their fleet against ours? That didn't happen.

Or maybe they knew already that we were the defending side.


Woodrow Ormand wrote:
Now if the federation had sent a strike force to the planets surface before the state of emergency was declared, and if the advanced scanning capabilities of a leviathon class titan couldn't pick it up, then the far more advanced scanners of Concord would have picked it up and that day and the aftermath would have gone differently. Were there insurgents on the ground? Yes, that's what happens when you invade someone's home, but nothing sent or sanctioned by the federation, though we now know that they were preparing something anyway. If the leviathon hadn't moved into position with intentions to break a Concord sanctioned treaty and the federation had moved to enact operation highlander, then Concord would have sided with the state, but that is not how it played out.


Oh, right. A typical Blaque-ish propaganda. "Evil villains Caldari decided to fight themselves on the planet and made up a combat grounds for dust troopers for fun. To add to this entertainment, they moved the titan close to planet and decided to doomsday civilian districts on the ground so fighting dusties could see nice fireworks while they play with their guns. By there came Gallente President riding on a white nyx and killed all the baddies." That reminds some gallente crap holo-flicks I had misfortune to watch.

Luckily for us, the fact that there were exactly FDU insurgents was confirmed even by FDU. So, now, what Blaque will do? Will start assasinating their own troops? Would you assassinate some FDU ground troopers for saying what they saw, Mr. Ormand?

And who do you think can beleive your words, Mr. Ormand? I mean, besides some brainwashed gallente citizens who used to such sort of dumb scenarios from your holoreels.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Slayer Liberator
Fusion Enterprises Ltd
Pandemic Horde
#94 - 2016-12-12 02:26:59 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:
Woodrow Ormand wrote:
According to the yulai convention, if I am not mistaken, Concord is placed as an intermediary and a multi national police force. So unless a nation leaves the treaties, which the state did not, they do not have the authority to order the Concord vessel out of the space above caldari prime.

Would they? And what would they do? Shake fist? We all know how their HQ was blapped in YC110 just by several crazy tribals. Do you really think they would have a chance against whole Federation fleet? Their ship has been destroyed by our Navy, and what did they do? Sent their fleet against ours? That didn't happen.

Or maybe they knew already that we were the defending side.


Woodrow Ormand wrote:
Now if the federation had sent a strike force to the planets surface before the state of emergency was declared, and if the advanced scanning capabilities of a leviathon class titan couldn't pick it up, then the far more advanced scanners of Concord would have picked it up and that day and the aftermath would have gone differently. Were there insurgents on the ground? Yes, that's what happens when you invade someone's home, but nothing sent or sanctioned by the federation, though we now know that they were preparing something anyway. If the leviathon hadn't moved into position with intentions to break a Concord sanctioned treaty and the federation had moved to enact operation highlander, then Concord would have sided with the state, but that is not how it played out.


Oh, right. A typical Blaque-ish propaganda. "Evil villains Caldari decided to fight themselves on the planet and made up a combat grounds for dust troopers for fun. To add to this entertainment, they moved the titan close to planet and decided to doomsday civilian districts on the ground so fighting dusties could see nice fireworks while they play with their guns. By there came Gallente President riding on a white nyx and killed all the baddies." That reminds some gallente crap holo-flicks I had misfortune to watch.

Luckily for us, the fact that there were exactly FDU insurgents was confirmed even by FDU. So, now, what Blaque will do? Will start assasinating their own troops? Would you assassinate some FDU ground troopers for saying what they saw, Mr. Ormand?

And who do you think can beleive your words, Mr. Ormand? I mean, besides some brainwashed gallente citizens who used to such sort of dumb scenarios from your holoreels.

That imitation of Federal propaganda was quite accurate
Woodrow Ormand
The Bosena Accords
Round Table Assembly
#95 - 2016-12-12 04:37:27 UTC
These are the facts to my knowledge. And based off of concords response they seem all the more likely, but don't confuse that with a fanatical support of a government like Ms. Kim. I support the gallente ideals, not the government. I only support the government to a certain extent because if they fall then gallente ideals, too, will fall. I support freedom, Ms. Kim, which though I know you say you don't support freedom, but your actions of using your own freedom to support a government who will turn their back on you at a moments notice, says otherwise.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#96 - 2016-12-12 05:34:00 UTC
Woodrow Ormand wrote:
I support freedom, Ms. Kim, which though I know you say you don't support freedom, but your actions of using your own freedom to support a government who will turn their back on you at a moments notice, says otherwise.


Due to linguistic peculiarities, Diana considers 'freedom' and 'chaos' to be the same thing. I suggest if you want to try to make a case about self-determination and the right to choose your own course in life, you couch it in those terms, instead.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#97 - 2016-12-12 06:14:31 UTC
Arrendis wrote:
Woodrow Ormand wrote:
I support freedom, Ms. Kim, which though I know you say you don't support freedom, but your actions of using your own freedom to support a government who will turn their back on you at a moments notice, says otherwise.


Due to linguistic peculiarities, Diana considers 'freedom' and 'chaos' to be the same thing. I suggest if you want to try to make a case about self-determination and the right to choose your own course in life, you couch it in those terms, instead.

It's an oddity of the Napaani tongue. Diana is one of those Caldari who views that tongue as her native language, rather than the Caldari Standard that many of us grow up with. It certainly makes her Napaani very fluent, which can be a serious advantage.

Napanii doesn't have a word for freedom that is linguistically distinct from Chaos. It does contain a number of loan words, but nothing harking from the purer Raata core of the language.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#98 - 2016-12-12 06:18:27 UTC
Woodrow Ormand wrote:
These are the facts to my knowledge. And based off of concords response they seem all the more likely, but don't confuse that with a fanatical support of a government like Ms. Kim. I support the gallente ideals, not the government. I only support the government to a certain extent because if they fall then gallente ideals, too, will fall. I support freedom, Ms. Kim, which though I know you say you don't support freedom, but your actions of using your own freedom to support a government who will turn their back on you at a moments notice, says otherwise.


Any government will do that. There are even many circumstances where they would be in breach of their oaths if they did not. Governments must rule with compassion, but that compassion must be applied globally across the body politic.

Don't think for an instant that your Federation isn't the same.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#99 - 2016-12-12 06:23:51 UTC
I despise freedom cultists. It is very hard to speak with such fanatics who operate with their brainwashed destructive ideals instead of facts.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Woodrow Ormand
The Bosena Accords
Round Table Assembly
#100 - 2016-12-12 06:30:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Woodrow Ormand
Oh, I wouldn't be surprised of the federation did it. But if it's done to me I wouldn't be affected in the slightest, my business is in nullsec, but if gallente ideals are in jeopardy, I will defend them. And Ms. Kim, when I say freedom I refer to the personal choice to be whatever and do whatever you want. Everyone should have the option to choose their own path, as you, and all capsuleers have, Ms. Kim.