These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dear CCP where does one draw the line?

First post
Author
Drago Shouna
Doomheim
#81 - 2016-04-09 19:41:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Drago Shouna
Neuntausend wrote:
Drago Shouna wrote:
Look at the comments above..the fact that it's happened out of the game means lines have been crossed, or at the best blurred.

It seems to me that it's a dangerous road to tread.


By that logic, forums, Teamspeak/Mumble/Ventrilo, e-mails and instant messengers cross the line, as people use those to talk about and coordinate their actions in the game, outside of the game. In years past, players have been scammed on voice comms outside of the game, were made to sing on Teamspeak in order to save their ships, were alliances forged and destroyed outside of the game. It's what people tend to call the "Metagame" and it's what many people genuinely love about Eve.


And players were banned for it..

Singing logs, or publishing ip addresses, where's the difference?

Call it what you want, it doesn't change what I said.

Solecist Project...." They refuse to play by the rules and laws of the game and use it as excuse ..." " They don't care about how you play as long as they get to play how they want."

Welcome to EVE.

Shae Tadaruwa
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#82 - 2016-04-09 21:57:42 UTC
Drago Shouna wrote:
Neuntausend wrote:
Drago Shouna wrote:
Look at the comments above..the fact that it's happened out of the game means lines have been crossed, or at the best blurred.

It seems to me that it's a dangerous road to tread.


By that logic, forums, Teamspeak/Mumble/Ventrilo, e-mails and instant messengers cross the line, as people use those to talk about and coordinate their actions in the game, outside of the game. In years past, players have been scammed on voice comms outside of the game, were made to sing on Teamspeak in order to save their ships, were alliances forged and destroyed outside of the game. It's what people tend to call the "Metagame" and it's what many people genuinely love about Eve.


And players were banned for it..

Singing logs, or publishing ip addresses, where's the difference?

Call it what you want, it doesn't change what I said.

People were banned over the Bonus Room stupidity, but not because it was out of game but because it was ruled as harassment.

Just because it's out of game does not mean a line has been crossed (which is what you claimed).

Stuff happens outside the game all the time and it's perfectly fine.

CCP Gargant singing for his Legion for example:
http://youtu.be/UtItWL6GfSM

Dracvlad - "...Your intel is free intel, all you do is pay for it..." && "...If you warp on the same path as a cloaked ship, you'll make a bookmark at exactly the same spot as the cloaky camper..."

Imalia Bloodlines
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#83 - 2016-04-09 22:44:19 UTC
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:
OK So this from the Reddit thread is why I tell people "DON'T CLICK ON A DAMNED THING".

Quote:
This morning, with a cleverly crafted trap, we now have identified the spy. Lemba is the spy. It breaks my heart to say this, but the proof is overwhelming. We sent bait link to the leaker’s reddit account with a text file hosted from our side. When Lemba logged into the leaker account and clicked on the link’s text file and accessed the text file, we found the IP address to match that of Lemba’s. Here’s the proof.



It's more than doxxing/IP risks here. More than some spy being hunted either. In fact, lay that aside. This is something for super pilots and FCs.

Roughly 6 years ago I recall a story from another player who described doing some haunting of locals in some nullsec pocket. I don't recall the details except that his target was a Russian corp.


Anyway, they claimed they could get him, which he denied. But later during the usual cat and mouse fu that is Eve Online, the connection to the server got a bit funny.

Right before it happened the last thing to appear in local in the soon-to-be-frozen up client was "here goes" or something like that.

Now I'm no wizard of networks, but I know enough from my days protecting servers from Chinese hackers (seriously, real hackers. In China).

If someone gets your IP number, they can run a trace. This is not so much cop stuff. Unless you have Eve installed on a web server they won't get all the way to the end, but they don't need to.

They need only know what nodes you are using, which "big switch" you are getting to the Eve server to. It depends on your service. For example, I used to live at a place that had spotty cable internet as it was remote, and I could run a trace from there to my office VPN and see what nodes I was using (helpful to know if your connection is good for an online meeting with streaming video that you want to ensure is OK for it). But at times I used a 4G Wireless system connected to my computer and running the same trace revealed entirely different paths. The 4G account is from an entirely different company.

And then..... well there are "services" you can get anonymously which can run a DDOS on just about any address you give them. I don't know any personally, and I won't go beyond this point because IMO I'm on the verge of going from geeksplaining network 101 to game exploit.

Basically, the IP number can be used to shut down a connection, something that can be a really bad deal for an FC or super pilot.

Only a couple of times over the years I have heard of this happening in Eve.

If this "war" results in this kind of activity, not only should those engaging in it be permabanned from the game, but they should also face criminal charges in their home jurisdiction. But in the end, if internet spaceships so srs that people have to resort to these tactics, then suddenly I don't feel like playing this game any more if that's the kind of people who play it.

Hopefully CCP takes a good hard look into this matter and other matters like this because there are plenty of sore losers to go around.




Today I was watching stream on twitch by Zarvox Toral, great guy, very down to earth, helps newbies etc...He was running Interceptor fleet.

At one point, they were about to engage caracals and someone DDOS'd his speak service, nobody could hear his order, bunch of ceptors died. I really really can not believe that CCP would tolerate something like this. We are not talking about game any more, this can cause serious damage IRL!!!
March rabbit
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#84 - 2016-04-09 23:14:06 UTC  |  Edited by: March rabbit
Imalia Bloodlines wrote:
At one point, they were about to engage caracals and someone DDOS'd his speak service, nobody could hear his order, bunch of ceptors died. I really really can not believe that CCP would tolerate something like this. We are not talking about game any more, this can cause serious damage IRL!!!

TBH it does not look like anyone could really do DDoS against bunch of interceptors.... You sure it was not some 'natural' internet problem?

The Mittani: "the inappropriate drunked joke"

Yael Capra Nubiana
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#85 - 2016-04-09 23:51:39 UTC
That's why i love EVE.

Spies, spyhunters, traitors, lies, heroes ... and tears.

Forget Shakespeare, forget the Nibelungenlied, forgett the clash of civilizations, forget all that, just look at EVE.

A big War, a clash between two giant powers is going on, and we will got alot similary things during the next months.

Remember Churchill said on May 13. 1940: ".... I would say to the House as I said to those who have joined this government: I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat. We have before us an ordeal of the most grievous kind. We have before us many, many long months of struggle and of suffering. .... You ask, what is our aim? I can answer in one word: Victory. Victory at all costs—Victory in spite of all terror—Victory, however long and hard the road may be, for without victory there is no survival.

Who will win?

Plexing is pure self en-slavement.

Ralph King-Griffin
New Eden Tech Support
#86 - 2016-04-10 01:46:20 UTC
Yael Capra Nubiana wrote:

Who will win?

better question , who will give a **** if people are getting doxed over it.
d0cTeR9
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#87 - 2016-04-10 01:51:48 UTC
Mario Putzo wrote:
Is that what EVE Online is about? This isn't the first time certain members of this group have been involved in these tactics...but it should be their last.


Where is the limit? None apparently. Every time we go out, we have our TS server nuked, our forum attacked, the list goes on. Most third party services become unusable. It's like that every time when dealing with certain large entities in the game.

Been around since the beginning.

Shae Tadaruwa
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#88 - 2016-04-10 02:30:34 UTC
Ralph King-Griffin wrote:
Yael Capra Nubiana wrote:

Who will win?

better question , who will give a **** if people are getting doxed over it.

No one is getting doxxed.

Dracvlad - "...Your intel is free intel, all you do is pay for it..." && "...If you warp on the same path as a cloaked ship, you'll make a bookmark at exactly the same spot as the cloaky camper..."

Salah ad-Din al-Jawahiri
Dreamweb Industries
Novus Ordo.
#89 - 2016-04-10 08:52:03 UTC
Shae Tadaruwa wrote:
Ralph King-Griffin wrote:
Yael Capra Nubiana wrote:

Who will win?

better question , who will give a **** if people are getting doxed over it.

No one is getting doxxed.


Yet.

Agent of the New Order

Live by the Code - die by the Code.

The Voice of Highsec

Imalia Bloodlines
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#90 - 2016-04-10 09:08:07 UTC
March rabbit wrote:
Imalia Bloodlines wrote:
At one point, they were about to engage caracals and someone DDOS'd his speak service, nobody could hear his order, bunch of ceptors died. I really really can not believe that CCP would tolerate something like this. We are not talking about game any more, this can cause serious damage IRL!!!

TBH it does not look like anyone could really do DDoS against bunch of interceptors.... You sure it was not some 'natural' internet problem?


No everything was working fine except when he told them to jump the gate, suddenly nobody could hear him. Then he fleet warped a few player while the rest was 1 system behind. Then they started to jump 1 by 1 and die because nobody could hear him. Only at that one point, stream was running for 6 hours without any problems except for that instance.
Shae Tadaruwa
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#91 - 2016-04-10 09:15:56 UTC
Salah ad-Din al-Jawahiri wrote:
Shae Tadaruwa wrote:
Ralph King-Griffin wrote:
Yael Capra Nubiana wrote:

Who will win?

better question , who will give a **** if people are getting doxed over it.

No one is getting doxxed.


Yet.

Exactly. So nothing wrong.

If someone gets doxxed, then whoever does it should be banned as they breaks the EULA.

Dracvlad - "...Your intel is free intel, all you do is pay for it..." && "...If you warp on the same path as a cloaked ship, you'll make a bookmark at exactly the same spot as the cloaky camper..."

Carn Uta
In From The Cold
Pandemic Horde
#92 - 2016-04-10 09:15:57 UTC
Considering I spent an interesting hour or so a couple of weeks ago listening to Marconius Porkbutte explaining to us n00bs all about the meta game of Eve, and how much he enjoyed that side of the game - which of course included all the spying stuff - I find it amusing just how utterly paranoid Goons are about APIs and IPs and so on. I would imagine Porkbutte must be applauding Lemba at this time.
No?
xxxTRUSTxxx
Galactic Rangers
#93 - 2016-04-10 14:31:37 UTC
Hey OP do you really believe this is just confined to EVE?

because let me tell you, it's not, this type of meta gaming has existed since day 1 in every game i've played online.
the line is drawn where you ask,,, i'd have to say there is no line, farming intel on people on the web is kinda how the web works my pretty confused and innocent friend Big smile

but hey,, it's ok, the sky won't fall, the world will keep turning and all is just feckin dandy in the universe.

pro tip: if you spy, be good at it. if you don't, well you have nothing to worry about.Roll
Mario Putzo
#94 - 2016-04-10 17:27:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Mario Putzo
xxxTRUSTxxx wrote:
Hey OP do you really believe this is just confined to EVE?

because let me tell you, it's not, this type of meta gaming has existed since day 1 in every game i've played online.
the line is drawn where you ask,,, i'd have to say there is no line, farming intel on people on the web is kinda how the web works my pretty confused and innocent friend Big smile

but hey,, it's ok, the sky won't fall, the world will keep turning and all is just feckin dandy in the universe.

pro tip: if you spy, be good at it. if you don't, well you have nothing to worry about.Roll



Not talking about they spying, or the counter spying, im talking about sending an alliance wide mail, followed by a coalition wide ping, containing information that could be used to negatively impact the guy. I think spying/counter intel is great, I think sharing such info directly to 17K/40K (respectively) is out of line, and CCP does have the authority to do something about it because that sharing happened through an in game EVE mail.

I have nothing against someone running counter intel, its the stuff afterwards like what happened to Manfred Sidious for example. There needs to be a line, and some **** shouldn't be brought into the game or publicly broadcast. Had someone said "We know this is the guy because we tracked his IP through a bait link" instead of here is the guys full IP information see we have proof, I probably wouldn't give a ****.

Its like Bonus room, it was never a problem the 2 years it ran, until one guy spoke up about it then it became a problem. If no one raises the question, we may never know the answer. Frankly there is a huge difference between tracking an IP, and broadcasting said IP to essentially everyone in EVE. We already know there is at least one scumbag in this game (Digital Ebola) who would abuse such information to the furthest extent of his abilities.
000Hunter000
Missiles 'R' Us
#95 - 2016-04-10 19:58:54 UTC
Just one sentence...


GET... A... LIFE!!! Shocked
Mina Sebiestar
Minmatar Inner Space Conglomerate
#96 - 2016-04-10 21:46:59 UTC
pathetic even for goons

You choke behind a smile a fake behind the fear

Because >>I is too hard

d0cTeR9
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#97 - 2016-04-10 22:33:24 UTC  |  Edited by: d0cTeR9
Imalia Bloodlines wrote:
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:
OK So this from the Reddit thread is why I tell people "DON'T CLICK ON A DAMNED THING".



Today I was watching stream on twitch by Zarvox Toral, great guy, very down to earth, helps newbies etc...He was running Interceptor fleet.

At one point, they were about to engage caracals and someone DDOS'd his speak service, nobody could hear his order, bunch of ceptors died. I really really can not believe that CCP would tolerate something like this. We are not talking about game any more, this can cause serious damage IRL!!!


It's quite sad and frustrating, but guess what... PL has done it on a few occasions (by PL, meaning someone in the alliance, someone that likes you guys... someone did it for your guys benefit). I think most big alliances have done it/does it... its quite... pathetic but has become somewhat the 'norm' in this game... Wasn't like that when i played more years ago...

Been around since the beginning.

Tzar Sinak
Mythic Heights
#98 - 2016-04-11 15:32:59 UTC
What is the IP address for https://www.themittani.com/ ?

Hydrostatic Podcast First class listening of all things EVE

Check out the Eve-Prosper show for your market updates!

ISD Buldath
#99 - 2016-04-11 16:03:04 UTC  |  Edited by: ISD Buldath
Quote:
35. Posting of chat logs outside the Crime & Punishment forum channel is prohibited.

The posting of chat logs between player parties is prohibited on all forum channels of the EVE Online forums, with the exception of the Crime & Punishment Channel where they can be posted as part of stories in the Pirate Story Thread.

Specific rules regarding the omission of pilot names apply in this instance. Further details can be found in the rules stickies in the Crime & Punishment forum channel.


After careful consideration, I have decided to lock this thread, as removing the content of the above posted rule would completely lynch the post and make its point null and void. Topics like these also stir a whole load of other issues regarding doxxing, personal Information and so on. I urge that those who feel effected by this file a support ticket regarding it and allow a member of CCP Staff to take a closer look.

~ISD Buldath

Instructor King of the Forums! Knight of the General Discussion

Support, Training and Resources Division

Interstellar Services Department

I do not respond to EVE-Mails regarding forum moderation.