These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next pageLast page
 

Is it possible for the Empires to come to a truce?

Author
Avio Yaken
Stay Frosty.
A Band Apart.
#1 - 2015-08-26 15:40:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Avio Yaken
Hi..I'm not the best at this "serious discussion" stuff on the IGS but...I'm willing to try..

Ladies and gentlemen, the Drifters have proven themselves as a serious threat not to be taken lightly, currently the fight in Khanid space is going horribly for the Kingdom as control over the constellation has not budged...Well..they managed to claim 5% of the constellation before losing it to the drifters as of this morning...

As a mercenary its rather hypocritical of me to ask for some kind of cease fire between factions, but this threat is obviously nothing we have ever faced before.

I ask if it would be possible if the four empires would be willing to stop tossing more and more resources at theses pointless war-zones against each other and perhaps have a temporary truce to deal with this devastating force before it gets out of hand..THEN we can go back to killing each other

If the drifters manage to take out the largest nation in the entire cluster...Whats to say the State might last on its own..or the Republic..Or even the Federation...Alone we can lethal sure..But as a team we can dominate this foe quickly

Years ago the empires combined forces in order to fight off Sansha's nation. Why can't we do that again here and now against a more pressing enemy that can very well threaten the entirety of the cluster more than the Nation ever could..

And i don't think i need to remind you of the Empress....How she was obliterated in a matter of seconds in the HQ of the same Amarr Navy thats suppose to be fighting back theses damn things, they are not mindless drones, they are adaptive and resourceful and have tech that is far superior to our own.

We don't have to be friends forever..Just a temporary truce to deal with this cancer that we can quickly remove before it becomes fatal.

I fought at Sarum prime during that rally...I lost people close to me that day, i witnessed their power firsthand and I'm willing to not fight in this war as a mercenary, but a soldier to stop this madness

Besides...i can't even be a mercenary if the Drifters wipe everyone out...

(.___________________________________________.)/

Sinjin Mokk
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#2 - 2015-08-26 15:58:59 UTC
Having had a good, up-close tactical view of what we're facing, I think this is a subject worthy of discussion.

"Angels live, they never die, Apart from us, behind the sky. They're fading souls who've turned to ice, So ashen white in paradise."

Markus Error
Manfios
#3 - 2015-08-26 16:16:44 UTC
This does presume the Drifters simply haven't gotten to the other races yet... which is entirely reasonable.

Unfortunately, while the empires have made display of solidarity before in this manner - to wipe the floor with the original Sansha's Nation - they seem to be too busy fighting amongst themselves and arguing about things to agree on anything except the most trivial of matters.

No, I feel if anyone is going to actually fight the Drifters, it'll be the Amarr and any capsuleer who cares to throw their hat in that particular ring. I'm holding onto a faint hope the empires will clue the hell in, but seems they won't.

"If it cannot be shot the #### down, it can always be blown the #### up."

-Unknown

Avio Yaken
Stay Frosty.
A Band Apart.
#4 - 2015-08-26 16:28:09 UTC
Markus Error wrote:
This does presume the Drifters simply haven't gotten to the other races yet... which is entirely reasonable.

Unfortunately, while the empires have made display of solidarity before in this manner - to wipe the floor with the original Sansha's Nation - they seem to be too busy fighting amongst themselves and arguing about things to agree on anything except the most trivial of matters.

No, I feel if anyone is going to actually fight the Drifters, it'll be the Amarr and any capsuleer who cares to throw their hat in that particular ring. I'm holding onto a faint hope the empires will clue the hell in, but seems they won't.


i refuse to believe we can't just have one temporary truce..even if its just for a day..i know its possible...

Again we don't all have to have a long lasting truce...Just one so we can allocate resources on the same problem before it becomes a threat we cannot topple


Then we can go back to the fighting between ourselfs.Hell..i want that still! my job is to profit off that..As sicking as that sounds to some...But we risk to lose everything unless we work together...Currently we don't have the best odds..but there is nothing from stopping us in improving those odds..Yeah..maybe a fragile alliance is not the best thing..But it might be our only way to fight back the Drifters


My opinion....

(.___________________________________________.)/

Nameira Vanis-Tor
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#5 - 2015-08-26 16:45:27 UTC
If the Amarr Empire wishes to survive the price for Tribal intervention should be as follows:

1) Independance for the Ammatar people's and territory from the Empire. If that tribe wishes to maintain an alliance with the Empire on their own terms then that is their rightful business.

2) Immediate emancipation of all Minmatar and their descendants.

3) An outlawing of enslavement of any member of a Minmatar Tribe. If they wish to spread their religion then let them use peaceful means only.

4) War reparations to be paid to each Tribe commensurate with the physical, emotional, mental, cultural and material damage done by the Empire to that Tribe. Diplomats and financial experts can figure out the fund involved and a long payback period would be tolerable.

5) The 24th IC to abandon sovereignty they hold in any traditional Minmatar Territory in the Metropolis/Heimatar regions. Also for the Empire to cease any further aggression in the warzone. In perpetuity.

6) The Empire will provide ships and equipment to the Tribes in order to assist against the Drifter Incursions. Each Tribe would also be paid to compensate for any Minmatar losses.

7) Following the next crowning of an Emperor/Empress each Royal House shall send its next Heir to the Republic as guests in order to provide surety for the agreed measures being met.

This is just a draft but tell me, does that sound reasonable for the aid of those The Empire has been trying to persecute and ahnilalate for centuries?
Yockerbow
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#6 - 2015-08-26 16:56:05 UTC
The Empires came together to fight Sansha because there was very good reason to believe that he was dangerous to them all. He was an equal opportunity enslaver and expanded on all fronts.Also, they had the Jove on their side as well. Today, it isn't clear whether the Jove tacitly approve of the Drifters or if the Directorate has in fact collapsed.

The Drifters so far have only attacked Amarr forces; outside scattered reports of police skirmishes they seem to have restricted themselves to scouting the other regions. Not only that, so far they seem to completely disregard planetary infrastructure, orbital colonies, etc.

As long as they restrict their aggression to capsuleer and Amarr Navy forces, it's unlikely the other 3 empires will unite to face them. The Republic won't assist the Empire unless either a) the Empire abolishes slavery unconditionally, or b) the Drifters begin enslaving baseline humans. The Republic will also do everything possible to keep the Federation from providing assistance. The Caldari may or may not assist, but the power vacuum left by the death of the Empress will make that less likely - no business likes to deal with you when they know you'll soon be Under New Management.

Unless the situation greatly changes (new weapon developments to close the technology gap, Jove showing up and helping, Amarr meeting Matari demands), the Amarr Empire is likely on its own for the forseeable future.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#7 - 2015-08-26 17:21:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Aria Jenneth
Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
If the Amarr Empire wishes to survive the price for Tribal intervention should be as follows:

1) Independance for the Ammatar people's and territory from the Empire. If that tribe wishes to maintain an alliance with the Empire on their own terms then that is their rightful business.

2) Immediate emancipation of all Minmatar and their descendants.

3) An outlawing of enslavement of any member of a Minmatar Tribe. If they wish to spread their religion then let them use peaceful means only.

4) War reparations to be paid to each Tribe commensurate with the physical, emotional, mental, cultural and material damage done by the Empire to that Tribe. Diplomats and financial experts can figure out the fund involved and a long payback period would be tolerable.

5) The 24th IC to abandon sovereignty they hold in any traditional Minmatar Territory in the Metropolis/Heimatar regions. Also for the Empire to cease any further aggression in the warzone. In perpetuity.

6) The Empire will provide ships and equipment to the Tribes in order to assist against the Drifter Incursions. Each Tribe would also be paid to compensate for any Minmatar losses.

7) Following the next crowning of an Emperor/Empress each Royal House shall send its next Heir to the Republic as guests in order to provide surety for the agreed measures being met.

This is just a draft but tell me, does that sound reasonable for the aid of those The Empire has been trying to persecute and ahnilalate for centuries?

No.

It doesn't.

Respectfully, pilot, we're likely fighting the Sleepers. If that's true, we're all aggressors, and the Drifters have cleverly picked the most easily-isolated first target.

They'll probably come after each of us in turn. If I were them, I'd go for the Gallente, next-- the Caldari will be asking questions similar to yours, and the Minmatar Republic will likely be busy trying to get to surviving formerly-enslaved Matari before the pirate factions do.

Then the State.

You'll burn last. With all your kin. And there'll be no one left to help you.
Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#8 - 2015-08-26 17:23:24 UTC
Yockerbow wrote:
He was an equal opportunity enslaver and expanded on all fronts.


Handily ignoring the fact that the Amarr have always had Nation beat in both enslavement and aggressive and militaristic expansion. Also that the majority of the slaves that Nation had were legally purchased from the Amarrian Empire in exchange for currency and technology. But wahey, whatever to make your point I suppose.

As far as the main thread here, I doubt it. The Amarr either have to have something worth offering, which they don't seem to. Or the Drifters have to pose a direct threat to the other big three, which they don't currently. Sure they are a general threat, but not to the point where the others are worried enough to really do something about it.

The Drifters seem to have a real, strong vendetta against the former Empress and her actions. They also seem to react strongly against that which they perceive as aggression. To both ends, they eliminated the former Empress and have responded to the Amarrian Declaration of War by funneling forces in to Amarrian space. There has been nothing shown to the Federation, State, and Republic that it's in their best interests to intervene. And even far less in the interest of empires outside of the Big Four.

Until you can offer up a reason why others should pitch in beyond speculation of "Maybe the Drifters will come after you next!", the Empire stands alone.

Come along, Avio. Come away from the Amarrians. Let them burn.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#9 - 2015-08-26 17:34:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Aria Jenneth
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Until you can offer up a reason why others should pitch in beyond speculation of "Maybe the Drifters will come after you next!", the Empire stands alone.

Come along, Avio. Come away from the Amarrians. Let them burn.


Sure, it's speculation, Evi, but not without basis. We've been seeing Sleeper-type facilities and devices associated with Drifter activity. This has actually been the case for a while, but the pattern's continuing enough to make me kind of doubt it's coincidence.

If it's the Sleepers we're fighting ... any empire that produces capsuleers is quite likely their enemy.

Also, respectfully, Evi ... you're my corpmate and therefore comrade and all, but you're in this to help empire capsuleers kill each other.

Right?

Is there a reason we should believe you have any empire's best interests at heart?

Don't you want to see us all burn?
Deitra Vess
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#10 - 2015-08-26 17:41:26 UTC
Avio, it seems unlikely I'm afraid.
Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#11 - 2015-08-26 17:47:31 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Is there a reason we should believe you have any empire's best interests at heart?

Don't you want to see us all burn?


I despise the governments. I have sympathy for the civilians caught under them. I consider myself aligned to the interests of an entity that has been at war with the empires for eight decades now.

Humanity will survive the Drfters. But if there is a god I shall pray to him that the empires do not.
Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#12 - 2015-08-26 17:56:31 UTC
Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
The price for Tribal intervention should be as follows:

1) Independance for the Ammatar people's and territory from the Empire. If that tribe wishes to maintain an alliance with the Empire on their own terms then that is their rightful business.

2) Immediate emancipation of all Minmatar and their descendants.

3) An outlawing of enslavement of any member of a Minmatar Tribe. If they wish to spread their religion then let them use peaceful means only.

4) War reparations to be paid to each Tribe commensurate with the physical, emotional, mental, cultural and material damage done by the Empire to that Tribe. Diplomats and financial experts can figure out the fund involved and a long payback period would be tolerable.

5) The 24th IC to abandon sovereignty they hold in any traditional Minmatar Territory in the Metropolis/Heimatar regions. Also for the Empire to cease any further aggression in the warzone. In perpetuity.

6) The Empire will provide ships and equipment to the Tribes in order to assist against the Drifter Incursions. Each Tribe would also be paid to compensate for any Minmatar losses.

7) Following the next crowning of an Emperor/Empress each Royal House shall send its next Heir to the Republic as guests in order to provide surety for the agreed measures being met.


This is a price peace could be bought at. The Republic would reciprocate on point five and point six should be removed entirely.

This could end in a decade a war that has lasted for a thousand years with no bloodshed.
It also seems too good to be true. God willing the next emperor will see the wisdom in peace as Empress Jayml did

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Rook Moray
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2015-08-26 18:20:42 UTC
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Is there a reason we should believe you have any empire's best interests at heart?

Don't you want to see us all burn?


I despise the governments. I have sympathy for the civilians caught under them. I consider myself aligned to the interests of an entity that has been at war with the empires for eight decades now.

Humanity will survive the Drfters. But if there is a god I shall pray to him that the empires do not.




Yeah. This.

Maybe we evolved past the need for "governments."

Someone mentioned the Jove? Notice how in the news when the Amarr Empress got aced, all the other "governments" sent words of support but there was no mention on the Jove. I think they got aced first.

“When you want to know how things really work, study them when they're coming apart.” -Guristas Proverb.

ValentinaDLM
SoE Roughriders
Electus Matari
#14 - 2015-08-26 18:23:26 UTC
Perhaps we should cut our losses on the Empire and look towards unity between the Caldari, Minmatar, and Gallente. Once that has happened then maybe the Empire would come along with peace.
Skyweir Kinnison
Doomheim
#15 - 2015-08-26 18:26:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Skyweir Kinnison
Anything is possible.

However, there are some impediments.

1. Amarr has not formally asked for aid. Until they do, I am unwilling to 'invade' their space.

2. Amarr already has a declared ally in the Caldari State. Why aren't they helping, since the mechanisms are already in place? It appears that they haven't been asked.

3. Looney demands such as those advanced by Ms Vanis-Tor making it very politically difficult for Amarrian leaders to issue requests for aid, since without an Emperor, many of their people might suspect collusion and compromise.

Only if it becomes clear that Amarr is losing the battle, will any of the above have any traction.

The other empires would do well to prepare themselves to defend their territory, research the Drifters further, and stand ready to help if the call ever comes. It's widely claimed that we are all in danger, but with no evidence at all that this is the case.

We should not be complacent, but neither should we be precipitate.

Humanity has won its battle. Liberty now has a country.

Tyrel Toov
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#16 - 2015-08-26 18:26:57 UTC
To be blunt, the Republic would have to request for us to assist the Amarr (getting that to happen is out of the hands of any capsuleer) before we do more then get a cup of coffee and watch the empire burn.

I want to paint my ship Periwinkle.

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#17 - 2015-08-26 18:34:02 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Peace between the empires existed for over a century. And that peace would still be surviving until today had it not been for the insane actions of Shakor and his self-styled Elders.

Even after they attacked Amarr, Empress Jamyl took the brave step of releasing an unprecedented number of slaves. Many of us hoped that this peace overture would have some effect on the Minmatars. But did the Shakorites even consider making overtures of their own? They did not.

Is a truce possible?

We Amarrians are a peace-loving people, but unfortunately the Republic is run by a bunch of psychopaths who revel in death and destruction.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Arrendis
TK Corp
#18 - 2015-08-26 18:37:09 UTC
Rook Moray wrote:
Maybe we evolved past the need for "governments."


Sure. We kill one another for fun, sacrificing millions of baseliners a day across New Eden. We've clearly 'evolved' past the need for large organizations to control resources, protect the weakest members of society, and focus our collective efforts and will...

About as well as we've 'evolved' past the need for cellular respiration.
Yockerbow
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#19 - 2015-08-26 18:41:21 UTC
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Yockerbow wrote:
He was an equal opportunity enslaver and expanded on all fronts.


Handily ignoring the fact that the Amarr have always had Nation beat in both enslavement and aggressive and militaristic expansion. Also that the majority of the slaves that Nation had were legally purchased from the Amarrian Empire in exchange for currency and technology. But wahey, whatever to make your point I suppose.


Don't mistake my comments on Sansha for approval of the Amarr. I actually have a certain respect for Sansha and his stated goals, at least in the original incarnation of his Nation. I was simply trying to contrast the first war against the Nation with the current Drifter situation.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#20 - 2015-08-26 18:47:10 UTC
Skyweir Kinnison wrote:
Anything is possible.

2. Amarr already has a declared ally in the Caldari State. Why aren't they helping, since the mechanisms are already in place? It appears that they haven't been asked.


The Alliance between the State and Empire refers to the state of affairs between the Empire, Federation, Republic and The State. It did not give the Empress carte blanche to drag us into any war she felt like starting without consulting us first. Any decision by The State to get involved at this point would follow the steps below:

1. Formal request by the Empire
2. CEP weighs up the costs and benefits of involvement
3. Decision to get involved or not announced
4. Outcome

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

123Next pageLast page