These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Battleship rebalence what happened - CCP care to comment?

Author
NightmareX
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#41 - 2015-04-05 21:42:33 UTC  |  Edited by: NightmareX
DHB WildCat wrote:
As a Battleship pilot myself, I can confirm that 5 harpies (rail fit) would own a vindi and t1 support. Vindi cannot catch them or track them. Now if they are blaster fit then thats another story. Either the harpies come into dual 90% web range and die to the vindi, or do not kill anything as hopefully the support stays with the vindi.

Nightmarex just cant imagine anything on a ship other than its short ranged weapons.

Sure, if you can keep distance 22+km all the time, then you might be in luck. However, the second any of those frigs goes inside my web range, they are going to die insanely fast.

Here is a list of my current EVE / PVP videos:

1: Asteroid Madness

2: Clash of the Empires

3: Suddenly Spaceships fighting in Tama

Mega Face
Absolute Order
Absolute Honor
#42 - 2015-04-05 21:47:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Mega Face
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
I would personally love to hear of your magical vindi that can track 4-5km/s harps, but not just track them, but pin them at the same time. So now you're suggesting that you're in a vindi that's wasting cap on an MWD, tanking, firing it's blasters and keeping any other active modules active while in the process. No, i probably wouldn't even believe you if every slot you had were filled with Tcomps and enhancers.

Do you know how slow even a 8 km/s Dramiel would go if it gets double webbed by a Vindicator?

It would go so slow that even a snail would laugh it's ass of by going faster. Sure, i wouldn't hit the frigs extremely hard though, but i would hit them hard enough to hurt them pretty well.

Loading Faction Antimatter + Dual 90% web (doesn't get 2x 90% when you applies that to a ship though as it will be penalized for using more than one webber) is the key to scare every frig pilots in a Vindicator (granted you are an experienced Vindicator pilot).



How in the devils hell are you going faster than a frigate, with enough agility to maintain your full velocity at all times while trying to keep up with our orbit? You aren't going to apply those webs under any circumstances at all. If we were orbiting you at 70km, sure, i can see your 1.5km/s vindi maintaing 99% of it's entire velocity, at 30km? No. The most you'll be turning with is like 600m/s. You'd be orbit locked for the entire encounter.
NightmareX
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#43 - 2015-04-05 22:13:47 UTC  |  Edited by: NightmareX
Mega Face wrote:
How in the devils hell are you going faster than a frigate, with enough agility to maintain your full velocity at all times while trying to keep up with our orbit? You aren't going to apply those webs under any circumstances at all. If we were orbiting you at 70km, sure, i can see your 1.5km/s vindi maintaing 99% of it's entire velocity, at 30km? No. The most you'll be turning with is like 600m/s. You'd be orbit locked for the entire encounter.

Let's say you are orbiting me at 24-25 km while i have around 22 km web range. I can do some maneuvering on my part that will kinda trick you inside my web range there as the difference in distance is so small here.

I wouldn't just sit still or just try to use the orbit / approact button on you. I would simply do tactical moves around to try and trick you closer. Again, we are talking about an experienced Vindicator pilot here that knows 100% what he's doing.

If you are using a Domination Disruptor with boosts to disruptor range in fleet, then you might do better as you have more room to move outside of the Vindicator's web rang while keeping me tackled.

EDIT: If the Vindicator have a LMJD fitted, then you wont kill the Vindicator if you are using a disruptor on him.

Here is a list of my current EVE / PVP videos:

1: Asteroid Madness

2: Clash of the Empires

3: Suddenly Spaceships fighting in Tama

Mega Face
Absolute Order
Absolute Honor
#44 - 2015-04-05 22:24:24 UTC
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
How in the devils hell are you going faster than a frigate, with enough agility to maintain your full velocity at all times while trying to keep up with our orbit? You aren't going to apply those webs under any circumstances at all. If we were orbiting you at 70km, sure, i can see your 1.5km/s vindi maintaing 99% of it's entire velocity, at 30km? No. The most you'll be turning with is like 600m/s. You'd be orbit locked for the entire encounter.

Let's say you are orbiting me at 24-25 km while i have around 22 km web range. I can do some maneuvering on my part that will kinda trick you inside my web range there as the difference in distance is so small here.

I wouldn't just sit still or just try to use the orbit / approact button on you. I would simply do tactical moves around to try and trick you closer. Again, we are talking about an experienced Vindicator pilot here that knows 100% what he's doing.

If you are using a Domination Disruptor with boosts to disruptor range in fleet, then you might do better as you have more room to move outside of the Vindicator's web rang while keeping me tackled.


Where are you getting 22km webs is what i'm wondering? If you're suggesting that it takes a 3billion isk module ontop of a 1billion isk highly specialized faction battleship, mixed in with any other stupidly improbable pvp set-ups you're EFTing @ me right now. Just to have a chance to kill a group of bread and butter frigates, shouldn't that be testimony to the current state of battleship vs smaller hull warfare?

You're suggesting upwards to 5billion isk to kill a group of harpies. "tactical moves" entirely limited by your agility unfortunately, because the minute you burn a straight line in one direction, and the 13 seconds it's going to take you to get to your full velocity, we've already had ample amounts of time for the game to actually auto-correct our orbit automatically.
NightmareX
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#45 - 2015-04-05 22:31:50 UTC  |  Edited by: NightmareX
Mega Face wrote:
Where are you getting 22km webs is what i'm wondering? If you're suggesting that it takes a 3billion isk module ontop of a 1billion isk highly specialized faction battleship, mixed in with any other stupidly improbable pvp set-ups you're EFTing @ me right now. Just to have a chance to kill a group of bread and butter frigates, shouldn't that be testimony to the current state of battleship vs smaller hull warfare?

You're suggesting upwards to 5billion isk to kill a group of harpies. "tactical moves" entirely limited by your agility unfortunately, because the minute you burn a straight line in one direction, and the 13 seconds it's going to take you to get to your full velocity, we've already had ample amounts of time for the game to actually auto-correct our orbit automatically.

The Vindicator i had did cost 2.5 bill isk in total with 2x FN webbers when i sold it.

About the web range. If you use a FN webber and overloads it, you will have 18.4km web range. And if you add some fleet bonuses to web range on top of that, you can get to 22km or something like that in range i think (correct me if i'm wrong here).

EDIT: Here is the setup i used: http://eve.battleclinic.com/view_loadout.php?id=43960

Guess why it have such a huge amount of views and likes Big smile?

Here is a list of my current EVE / PVP videos:

1: Asteroid Madness

2: Clash of the Empires

3: Suddenly Spaceships fighting in Tama

Mega Face
Absolute Order
Absolute Honor
#46 - 2015-04-05 22:58:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Mega Face
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
Where are you getting 22km webs is what i'm wondering? If you're suggesting that it takes a 3billion isk module ontop of a 1billion isk highly specialized faction battleship, mixed in with any other stupidly improbable pvp set-ups you're EFTing @ me right now. Just to have a chance to kill a group of bread and butter frigates, shouldn't that be testimony to the current state of battleship vs smaller hull warfare?

You're suggesting upwards to 5billion isk to kill a group of harpies. "tactical moves" entirely limited by your agility unfortunately, because the minute you burn a straight line in one direction, and the 13 seconds it's going to take you to get to your full velocity, we've already had ample amounts of time for the game to actually auto-correct our orbit automatically.

The Vindicator i had did cost 2.5 bill isk in total with 2x FN webbers when i sold it.

About the web range. If you use a FN webber and overloads it, you will have 18.4km web range. And if you add some fleet bonuses to web range on top of that, you can get to 22km or something like that in range i think (correct me if i'm wrong here).

EDIT: Here is the setup i used: http://eve.battleclinic.com/view_loadout.php?id=43960

Guess why it have such a huge amount of views and likes Big smile?



So the narrative becomes even more comical when not only do you need a 1b faction battleship, but gang links with max skills on a secondary ship, while overheating your web - just to have a sliver of hope to kill some long ranged frigates. Yet you still don't see how grossly imbalanced frigates are vs battleships? You've pretty much added every thing to your advantage in this fight, and all they'd have to do is manually tackle you in their 2m frigates. You seem to forget that they can overheat as well, and they don't have to risk popping a 400m isk web in the process.

You aren't going to win against frigates, ever, at all.
NightmareX
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#47 - 2015-04-05 23:09:14 UTC  |  Edited by: NightmareX
Mega Face wrote:
So the narrative becomes even more comical when not only do you need a 1b faction battleship, but gang links with max skills on a secondary ship, while overheating your web - just to have a sliver of hope to kill some long ranged frigates. Yet you still don't see how grossly imbalanced frigates are vs battleships? You've pretty much added every thing to your advantage in this fight, and all they'd have to do is manually tackle you in their 2m frigates. You seem to forget that they can overheat as well, and they don't have to risk popping a 400m isk web in the process.

You aren't going to win against frigates, ever, at all.

The thing here that you are forgetting, is that if you are going to have the disruptor on your frig overloaded, you can't do that for a very long time. You have to keep it overloaded for a long time if you want to keep more distance from the Vindicator as long you are killing it.

While i only need to overload the webbers at the right moment for maybe 2-3 cycles before it's game over for the frigs.

See the difference?

EDIT: The Federation Navy Webifier cost about 65-70 mill isk each, which is dirt cheap on a Vindicator.

Here is a list of my current EVE / PVP videos:

1: Asteroid Madness

2: Clash of the Empires

3: Suddenly Spaceships fighting in Tama

Tiddle Jr
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#48 - 2015-04-05 23:25:07 UTC
Mega Face wrote:
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
Where are you getting 22km webs is what i'm wondering? If you're suggesting that it takes a 3billion isk module ontop of a 1billion isk highly specialized faction battleship, mixed in with any other stupidly improbable pvp set-ups you're EFTing @ me right now. Just to have a chance to kill a group of bread and butter frigates, shouldn't that be testimony to the current state of battleship vs smaller hull warfare?

You're suggesting upwards to 5billion isk to kill a group of harpies. "tactical moves" entirely limited by your agility unfortunately, because the minute you burn a straight line in one direction, and the 13 seconds it's going to take you to get to your full velocity, we've already had ample amounts of time for the game to actually auto-correct our orbit automatically.

The Vindicator i had did cost 2.5 bill isk in total with 2x FN webbers when i sold it.

About the web range. If you use a FN webber and overloads it, you will have 18.4km web range. And if you add some fleet bonuses to web range on top of that, you can get to 22km or something like that in range i think (correct me if i'm wrong here).

EDIT: Here is the setup i used: http://eve.battleclinic.com/view_loadout.php?id=43960

Guess why it have such a huge amount of views and likes Big smile?



So the narrative becomes even more comical when not only do you need a 1b faction battleship, but gang links with max skills on a secondary ship, while overheating your web - just to have a sliver of hope to kill some long ranged frigates. Yet you still don't see how grossly imbalanced frigates are vs battleships? You've pretty much added every thing to your advantage in this fight, and all they'd have to do is manually tackle you in their 2m frigates. You seem to forget that they can overheat as well, and they don't have to risk popping a 400m isk web in the process.

You aren't going to win against frigates, ever, at all.


Cool story bro. The only one who made the whole thing comic is you.

The case was very clear - dual web vindi and drones vs 30m frig orbiting under vindi's guns.
But suddenly you start talkig about your friends who bring catalysts then there is Harpy gang etc etc.

"The message is that there are known knowns. There are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say there are things that we now know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know" - CCP

Mega Face
Absolute Order
Absolute Honor
#49 - 2015-04-05 23:33:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Mega Face
Tiddle Jr wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
Where are you getting 22km webs is what i'm wondering? If you're suggesting that it takes a 3billion isk module ontop of a 1billion isk highly specialized faction battleship, mixed in with any other stupidly improbable pvp set-ups you're EFTing @ me right now. Just to have a chance to kill a group of bread and butter frigates, shouldn't that be testimony to the current state of battleship vs smaller hull warfare?

You're suggesting upwards to 5billion isk to kill a group of harpies. "tactical moves" entirely limited by your agility unfortunately, because the minute you burn a straight line in one direction, and the 13 seconds it's going to take you to get to your full velocity, we've already had ample amounts of time for the game to actually auto-correct our orbit automatically.

The Vindicator i had did cost 2.5 bill isk in total with 2x FN webbers when i sold it.

About the web range. If you use a FN webber and overloads it, you will have 18.4km web range. And if you add some fleet bonuses to web range on top of that, you can get to 22km or something like that in range i think (correct me if i'm wrong here).

EDIT: Here is the setup i used: http://eve.battleclinic.com/view_loadout.php?id=43960

Guess why it have such a huge amount of views and likes Big smile?



So the narrative becomes even more comical when not only do you need a 1b faction battleship, but gang links with max skills on a secondary ship, while overheating your web - just to have a sliver of hope to kill some long ranged frigates. Yet you still don't see how grossly imbalanced frigates are vs battleships? You've pretty much added every thing to your advantage in this fight, and all they'd have to do is manually tackle you in their 2m frigates. You seem to forget that they can overheat as well, and they don't have to risk popping a 400m isk web in the process.

You aren't going to win against frigates, ever, at all.


Cool story bro. The only one who made the whole thing comic is you.

The case was very clear - dual web vindi and drones vs 30m frig orbiting under vindi's guns.
But suddenly you start talkig about your friends who bring catalysts then there is Harpy gang etc etc.


What's more improbable to happen. Me having a 12 man frig fleet, or you ever undocking in a PVP vindi? No frigate (or ship for that matter) is going to allow a slow ass vindi to apply any sort of web on it, it's never going to happen - you don't have the speed, the agility or the luck for any of your webs to do nothing more than being wasted modules on a battleship that just got it's ass handed to it by frigates.

I'm technically allowed to bring over 500 T1 or 300 T2 small ship hulls of any size or variation, if you're allowed to field 1 vindi if we're doing this for a cost per cost basis. But i'm not, all i need is 5 harpies - it's overkill enough.
Tiddle Jr
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#50 - 2015-04-05 23:52:28 UTC
Glad to hear that we finally agree on the case your 30m frig won't own my +2b (dual web) Vindi.

Cheers

"The message is that there are known knowns. There are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say there are things that we now know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know" - CCP

NightmareX
Pandemic Horde Inc.
Pandemic Horde
#51 - 2015-04-05 23:52:58 UTC  |  Edited by: NightmareX
Mega Face wrote:
No frigate (or ship for that matter) is going to allow a slow ass vindi to apply any sort of web on it, it's never going to happen - you don't have the speed, the agility or the luck for any of your webs to do nothing more than being wasted modules on a battleship that just got it's ass handed to it by frigates.

How many good fitted Vindicators piloted by really experienced Vindicator pilots have you been fighting with frigs?

And how much experience do you have in flying a Vindicator?

If we had been talking about a normal Megathron here, or even a Navy Mega, then you would have much more chance to kill them. But we aren't as we are talking about the Vindicator which is a monster / beast in what it's meant to do.

Here is a list of my current EVE / PVP videos:

1: Asteroid Madness

2: Clash of the Empires

3: Suddenly Spaceships fighting in Tama

baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#52 - 2015-04-06 03:45:16 UTC
NightmareX wrote:
Mega Face wrote:
No frigate (or ship for that matter) is going to allow a slow ass vindi to apply any sort of web on it, it's never going to happen - you don't have the speed, the agility or the luck for any of your webs to do nothing more than being wasted modules on a battleship that just got it's ass handed to it by frigates.

How many good fitted Vindicators piloted by really experienced Vindicator pilots have you been fighting with frigs?

And how much experience do you have in flying a Vindicator?

If we had been talking about a normal Megathron here, or even a Navy Mega, then you would have much more chance to kill them. But we aren't as we are talking about the Vindicator which is a monster / beast in what it's meant to do.


Oh there are ways for a normal mega to happyslap 30 mil frigates.

But if you want an easier time of things just grab a RLML rattlesnake or even a RHML raven.
baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#53 - 2015-04-06 03:55:12 UTC
Amanda Guido wrote:


And your plan when even a couple frigates warp in on you and get under your guns? How do you plan to get yourself out of that one big guy?

Let me tell you, your billion dollar BS will go down in flames as a 30 million isk frigate pilot laughs and oogles at the killmail without a scratch.


Come at me bro
Valkin Mordirc
#54 - 2015-04-06 04:19:20 UTC
Mega Face wrote:
No frigate (or ship for that matter) is going to allow a slow ass vindi to apply any sort of web on it, it's never going to happen - you don't have the speed, the agility or the luck for any of your webs to do nothing more than being wasted modules on a battleship that just got it's ass handed to it by frigates.



Actually, a Vindi does fairly well against AF's if it has link support, And what Nightmare is talking about, unless your manually orbiting the Vindicator it's actually fairly easy to make the auto-orbit in pop with in Fed Navy's Web Range so dual 90% webs with drones a harpy isn't going to last very long. So unless your harpy gang is using faction points with links, it's quite possible that the Vindi will wreak it.

As Baltec said Vindi isn't optimal for taking on Frig gangs. But it does do the job reasonably well. Nightmare has experience with that the Vindicator as it was one of his old corps major doctrine ship. So I'm sure he's a good idea what he's talking about.
#DeleteTheWeak
Iroquoiss Pliskin
9B30FF Labs
#55 - 2015-04-06 05:07:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Iroquoiss Pliskin
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a a specific Pirate faction battleship with 1bil in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png
Valkin Mordirc
#56 - 2015-04-06 05:42:09 UTC
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png



That graph is nice, but not very informative. It doesn't detail about what kind of damage is being applied and what its being applied to. *shrugs*


Most Battleships don't really need a true re balance. They do need tweaking imo, but not a complete work over.

The only one I would say needs to real resemblance is the Scorpion, as it doesn't really do a ECM role to well due to it's size, the Blackbird, Rook and Falcon far outclass it in jam strength (atleast the Rook/Falcon) and it's ability to survive. The Burst ECM role isn't that great of a bonus.

#DeleteTheWeak
Tiddle Jr
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#57 - 2015-04-06 05:42:40 UTC
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a a specific Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png


Don't mix up the things. It was a statement not a question to answer. And statement was that BS are terrible that bad that even a lonely frig could kill a bs in 1 vs. 1 engagement.

"The message is that there are known knowns. There are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say there are things that we now know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don't know" - CCP

Valkin Mordirc
#58 - 2015-04-06 05:47:18 UTC
Tiddle Jr wrote:
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a a specific Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png


Don't mix up the things. It was a statement not a question to answer. And statement was that BS are terrible that bad that even a lonely frig could kill a bs in 1 vs. 1 engagement.



Yeah that only really happens with mission BS'es for the most part. Battleships have a lot of options for tackling smaller ships, Like Heavy Neuts, Light and Medium drones, the ability to have dual webs, and an active tank that could easily hold a frig off indefinitely.
#DeleteTheWeak
Iroquoiss Pliskin
9B30FF Labs
#59 - 2015-04-06 07:07:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Iroquoiss Pliskin
Valkin Mordirc wrote:
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png



That graph is nice, but not very informative. It doesn't detail about what kind of damage is being applied and what its being applied to. *shrugs*


Damage done, including structures, in PvP segmented by weapon type.

Blue - drones
Orange - Lasers
Dark blue - Hybrids
Light blue - Missiles
Yellow - Projectiles

Tiddle Jr wrote:
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a a specific Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png


Don't mix up the things. It was a statement not a question to answer. And statement was that BS are terrible that bad that even a lonely frig could kill a bs in 1 vs. 1 engagement.


Don't worry, no one here is going to threaten the cancer meta no matter what we say or do. Smile
baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#60 - 2015-04-06 07:37:38 UTC
Valkin Mordirc wrote:
Iroquoiss Pliskin wrote:
I think OP has gotten his asnwer: You need a Pirate faction battleship with 1b in mods and a links alt to kill frigates in a BS nowadays. Smile

Tongue in cheek, of course. Smile

Maybe not. Blink

http://i.imgur.com/z4ynWV9.png



That graph is nice, but not very informative. It doesn't detail about what kind of damage is being applied and what its being applied to. *shrugs*


Most Battleships don't really need a true re balance. They do need tweaking imo, but not a complete work over.

The only one I would say needs to real resemblance is the Scorpion, as it doesn't really do a ECM role to well due to it's size, the Blackbird, Rook and Falcon far outclass it in jam strength (atleast the Rook/Falcon) and it's ability to survive. The Burst ECM role isn't that great of a bonus.



Scorp is great for those times when you need jams with a tank. They also make great bricks for throwing at people.