These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

DED escalations from Anoms - Not enough risk?

Author
Sean Parisi
Blackrise Vanguard
#21 - 2015-03-18 06:21:32 UTC
Reduce the drop rates or add more drops for Anon escalations. More frequency, less drops - Maintain the current tables for escalations from scanned sites.

Or add other tweaks to anon escalations, more travel, harder difficulty or whatever else. Just my biased opinion as a guy who scans sites as opposed to anons (FW space has none)
Juan Mileghere
The Corporate Raiders
Safety.
#22 - 2015-03-18 06:57:54 UTC
Kirkra wrote:
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Aran Hotchkiss wrote:
...

If you're saying that anything above a 4/10 can spawn as a cosmic signature in hisec, grrr because if that's the case that marginalises me running combat exploration in low-security space.
...
No.


It's very rare that the 5/10's show up in a hisec site so servers more as a taster for folks to see how losec sites would be. The loot payout is probably lower too as the hisec loot tables aren't as generous as losec/null/WH I thought?


Actually both Angel Refuge and Angel Den escalate to a DED5 in HS space. Those are HS anomalies are can be found in abundance (for other factions the spawn DED3 and DED4). This is probably a remnant from the days when Angels did not have a DED3 and DED4 for those anoms to escalate to. The result? Just doing anoms half-afk will net you an Angel DED5 in HS per 1, sometimes 2 hours. The payout is a LOT higher than any other site in HS. Around 60mil in guaranteed payout and tasty things like B-type invul field as bonus (empty drop is very rare).

Makes me wonder if any of the other formerly missing DED4 sites have their relevant anoms spawn a DED5, but I'm too lazy to check really.

lol I got 4 empty drops in a row over the past few weeks now that you state that regarding DED 5s
Characternumber210492
Job Center Plus
#23 - 2015-03-18 09:30:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Characternumber210492
Nasar Vyron wrote:
Just another lazy ganker crying for CCP to make it easier for him. Move along.


Never ganked anyone in high sec before. 5/10s and above have potentially great payouts and should have the same risk associated with them as there always has been (being in low/null)

Aran Hotchkiss wrote:
DED sites spawned from anoms in lowsec should always be in low or null sec - I think this was implemented recently.

If you're saying that anything above a 4/10 can spawn as a cosmic signature in hisec, grrr because if that's the case that marginalises me running combat exploration in low-security space.

I'll add some more to this post once I re-read the OP because I'm not 100% sure what you're asking for.


While it might be very hard to find a person running a high-end DED site from a hi-sec anomaly, the anomalies in question are available for anyone to warp to.


The only thing I semi-agree with would be preventing 5/10's from anomalies in lowsec spawning in hi-sec - and I think this is the case anyway, although it was implemented more so pirates living in lowsec (and unable to enter hisec) wouldn't get an unlucky escalation they couldn't access. [And if you suggest they should sell it they can't do that very easily - only way to sell escalations currently is to warp to the site yourself and then bookmark it]


Anyway.

No.


The change they made is that if you have a negative sec status your DED escalation will never spawn in high sec. If you have a postiive sec and run anoms in highsec you can get 5/10s and 6/10s in high sec, while the rest of us run risk by scanning and running them in low.

Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Aran Hotchkiss wrote:
...

If you're saying that anything above a 4/10 can spawn as a cosmic signature in hisec, grrr because if that's the case that marginalises me running combat exploration in low-security space.
...
No.


It's very rare that the 5/10's show up in a hisec site so servers more as a taster for folks to see how losec sites would be. The loot payout is probably lower too as the hisec loot tables aren't as generous as losec/null/WH I thought?


Loot table for a DED is the same regardless of where it is ran.
Ciba Lexlulu
Stay Frosty.
A Band Apart.
#24 - 2015-03-18 11:33:22 UTC  |  Edited by: Ciba Lexlulu
Nasar Vyron wrote:
Just another lazy ganker crying for CCP to make it easier for him. Move along.


Not sure what you mean by lazy ganker. PvP is always come with risk of losing your ship; unlike missioning or running DED site in highsec. Increased risk means higher payout for explorer as DED mods supply drops. Any players that have the courage to run the site under spawn mechanic I suggest (and flying pvp-fit ship instead of min maxing) will be rewarded.
Corraidhin Farsaidh
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#25 - 2015-03-18 11:48:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Corraidhin Farsaidh
Characternumber210492 wrote:
...5/10s and above have potentially great payouts and should have the same risk associated with them as there always has been... (being in low/null)


The 5/10 in hisec has exactly the same risk associated as the 5/10 in losec null, but you have the additional risks then associated with being in losec/null. This is balanced out by the increased frequency of the escalations in lower security space

Characternumber210492 wrote:

The change they made is that if you have a negative sec status your DED escalation will never spawn in high sec. If you have a postiive sec and run anoms in highsec you can get 5/10s and 6/10s in high sec, while the rest of us run risk by scanning and running them in low.

Those in losec/null also get greater rewards by virtue of the greater frequency of available escalations (even if it is because you are willing to run all of the lower sec escalations rather than the 1 in 5-6 that show up in hisec)

Characternumber210492 wrote:

Loot table for a DED is the same regardless of where it is ran.


Thanks for clarifying, I thought it also scaled with sec rating of the system.

I have no problem with the odd 5/10 popping up in hisec as it gives a nice reward to the persistent explorer and also may well entice those who receive them into more losec forays in future.

As for the original post a player who is hunting other players to gank in sites should not receive an easy mode access to the escalation site. The player running the site had to (possibly) scan down and run a combat anom to receive the escalation. Any other player can do the same if they also want the escalations or can use combat probes and check the ships in a system. If they aren't willing to make this effort then they don't deserve to crash the escalation site.
Characternumber210492
Job Center Plus
#26 - 2015-03-18 13:33:42 UTC
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:


The 5/10 in hisec has exactly the same risk associated as the 5/10 in losec null, but you have the additional risks then associated with being in losec/null. This is balanced out by the increased frequency of the escalations in lower security space


A DED escalation in high sec has virtually no risk compared to one in low and null.
1. If the ship leaves it can't be probed, its yours exclusively unless you get combat probed. Again much less likely in high sec.
2. You can't be legally shot by other players

Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:

Those in losec/null also get greater rewards by virtue of the greater frequency of available escalations (even if it is because you are willing to run all of the lower sec escalations rather than the 1 in 5-6 that show up in hisec)


I don't know the figures on the rate at which they spawn in low and high from anom escalations, and somehow doubt you do either. All I know is that they can and do spawn in high sec now, see above for my issues with this.

Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:

I have no problem with the odd 5/10 popping up in hisec as it gives a nice reward to the persistent explorer and also may well entice those who receive them into more losec forays in future.


Me neither but it's not the explorer who will get the site, its the person who can run an extremely easy anomoly (only frigates and sentries most the time) who will get these very safe and potentially very profitable sites which used to only spawn in a risk heavy environment.
Kirkra
The Versa-Ex Corp
#27 - 2015-03-18 14:21:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Kirkra
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:

The 5/10 in hisec has exactly the same risk associated as the 5/10 in losec null, but you have the additional risks then associated with being in losec/null. This is balanced out by the increased frequency of the escalations in lower security space


Hisec exploration is pretty much risk-free. There's Concord, remember? The only real risk is that someone will scan you, come in and steal your loot at the last moment. But there's an entire host of things you can do about that, specially in the sites with 6 stasis towers in the last room and a loot structure with 300k EHP. Not to mention you can add some ECCM to your ship, making it close to impossible to probe down.

Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:

Those in losec/null also get greater rewards by virtue of the greater frequency of available escalations (even if it is because you are willing to run all of the lower sec escalations rather than the 1 in 5-6 that show up in hisec)


As stated above many times - an anom in LS accidentally escalating to a DED5 in HS once in a while is not the problem. The problem is HS anoms escalating to DED sites in HS almost every time. You don't get 1 in 5-6 showing up in HS, you get 1 in 5-6 showing up in LS, and the rest in HS. Out of dozens of DED5 I got, only a couple were in lowsec.

Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:

I have no problem with the odd 5/10 popping up in hisec as it gives a nice reward to the persistent explorer and also may well entice those who receive them into more losec forays in future.


Persistent would be OK. No really, if someone's been scanning in lowsec for a week, evading camps and what not, I'm perfectly fine with them enjoying a safe escalation in HS.

The problem is that the anoms that escalate to DED5 in HS are easy and safe. As in T1 frigate with 5mil SP easy. They don't even need to be scanned - they just appear in your damn scanner without probes.

In this perspective, persistent gains an entire different meaning. It becomes "Open 3-5 clients with 2-3 week old chars, warp them out to different anoms, launch drones, wait 5 minutes, collect Highsec DED5 sites to do on your main farming alt". No brainpower involved. No skills. No risk. Not even controlling your ship beyond starting local tank when you warp in.
Corraidhin Farsaidh
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#28 - 2015-03-18 14:37:27 UTC
Kirkra wrote:
...
Persistent would be OK. No really, if someone's been scanning in lowsec for a week, evading camps and what not, I'm perfectly fine with them enjoying a safe escalation in HS.

The problem is that the anoms that escalate to DED5 in HS are easy and safe. As in T1 frigate with 5mil SP easy. They don't even need to be scanned - they just appear in your damn scanner without probes.

In this perspective, persistent gains an entire different meaning. It becomes "Open 3-5 clients with 2-3 week old chars, warp them out to different anoms, launch drones, wait 5 minutes, collect Highsec DED5 sites to do on your main farming alt". No brainpower involved. No skills. No risk. Not even controlling your ship beyond starting local tank when you warp in.


Ahh when I said the threat level of the DED is the same I meant the site itself, being in losec has it's own risk whether you are running a site or not. I do agree that it seems odd for these sites to come from the simpler combat sites though, they should certainly spawn from the higher DED rated sites.

The ones I've ever had in hisec have been few and far between and I explore a fair bit, must just be the space I'm in. The rarity of a hisec Serpentis Hydroponics plant is fine in my opinion but if the other regions DED 5/10 escalations are more often than that I would suggest they be balanced to be similar to the above.
Kirkra
The Versa-Ex Corp
#29 - 2015-03-18 14:50:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Kirkra
Corraidhin Farsaidh wrote:
Kirkra wrote:
...
Persistent would be OK. No really, if someone's been scanning in lowsec for a week, evading camps and what not, I'm perfectly fine with them enjoying a safe escalation in HS.

The problem is that the anoms that escalate to DED5 in HS are easy and safe. As in T1 frigate with 5mil SP easy. They don't even need to be scanned - they just appear in your damn scanner without probes.

In this perspective, persistent gains an entire different meaning. It becomes "Open 3-5 clients with 2-3 week old chars, warp them out to different anoms, launch drones, wait 5 minutes, collect Highsec DED5 sites to do on your main farming alt". No brainpower involved. No skills. No risk. Not even controlling your ship beyond starting local tank when you warp in.


Ahh when I said the threat level of the DED is the same I meant the site itself, being in losec has it's own risk whether you are running a site or not. I do agree that it seems odd for these sites to come from the simpler combat sites though, they should certainly spawn from the higher DED rated sites.

The ones I've ever had in hisec have been few and far between and I explore a fair bit, must just be the space I'm in. The rarity of a hisec Serpentis Hydroponics plant is fine in my opinion but if the other regions DED 5/10 escalations are more often than that I would suggest they be balanced to be similar to the above.


I'm not sure this is what the OP meant in the first place, but I agree with you here.

There is an occasional lowsec site escalating to HS. That's fine. There is an occasional DED5 site in HS. I've seen one or two in my years exploring. That's fine. I've seen dozens of highsec anomalies escalate to DED5 in highsec just this year alone. That's not fine and seems like a bug with Angel anomalies specifically, that was missed when the extra DED sites were introduced some time ago. Serpentis certainly do NOT have this behaviour and I would need to check what Sansha Den escalates to (Sansha were the other faction that did not have a DED4 at the time, but they did have a DED3).

EDIT:
Judging by the Wiki, Sansha Den (Highsec anomaly) also escalates to DED5. Same story - Sansha did not have a DED4, so the escalation was to DED5. Nobody cared since they were VERY rare. Now they are common and Sansha do have a DED4, yet the site it escalates to is unchanged.

This isn't as big a problem as the Angel sites, since Dens are a lot rarer in HS than Refuges, but still should be fixed.
Previous page12