These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

Fuel block confusion

Author
Dersk
Perkone
Caldari State
#21 - 2011-12-01 23:36:40 UTC
Cygnet Lythanea wrote:
I might point out that they decided not to increase POS fuel bay sizes. They're the same size as they were before.


140k m3 for a large tower, live
Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#22 - 2011-12-02 00:10:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Cygnet Lythanea wrote:
I might point out that they decided not to increase POS fuel bay sizes. They're the same size as they were before.

Large towers were 110k m^3 IIRC, now they're 140k m^3.

They could use up to 228.5 m^3/hour at full grid/CPU load (20 days 1 hour until refuel), now they always use 200 m^3/hour (29 days 4 hours until refuel).
That's large non-faction towers in area without sov fuel benefits.

Granted, you COULD have a large tower loaded with near-maxed CPU and moderate grid usage (say, a large caldari tower with 12 assorted labs, 3 equipment arrays and a corp hangar, so, about 99% CPU and 66% grid used, or 207.7 m^3/hour total - which is already more than you use now), in which case your tower would last 22+ days before a refill was needed, but that's still under the 29+ days you get now.
Garasu nosekai
Creodron.com
#23 - 2011-12-02 00:51:32 UTC
Dusty Meg wrote:
Akita T wrote:
Let me repeat that : numbers for a LARGE regular tower with no fuel consumption bonuses...

BEFORE fuel blocks:
108.5 m^3/hour for mandatory fuel
UP TO 60 m^3/hour for powergrid
UP TO 60 m^3/hour for CPU
= total of UP TO a maximum of 228.5 m^3/hour at full MW/tf load
Assuming 90% CPU load and 65% grid load, that's (108.5+54+39)m^3/hour = 201.5 m^3/hour

AFTER fuel blocks - always 200 m^3/hour, regardless of CPU/grid load.

P.S. Before the patch, assuming a 50% load on both CPU and grid (at which time you could have just as well just bloody switched to a medium tower) that's a 168.5 m^3/hour use, vs 200 m^3/hour use, or only 31.5 m^3/hour difference (+18.7% total fuel volume).

Forum eat my post.
That clears that up and nullifies your argument of them being 44% more volume. Just put some more modules on the pos and it justifies it. And the prices is A due to the PI price increases and B due to the fact that all the blocks currently on the market are wasting fuel. As soon as the server was back up I was on my way to my local Thukker Mix station to pick up the BPO's. Then got them straight in a pos to ME them to perfect (40), these dont come out for another 2 days, which means the prices will drop



I seriously don't think you are getting the point of what I'm saying... BEFORE we could take in !90! days of fuel with one freighter for all three of our towers. Never mind what our towers were running at that doesn't matter at all now, its a fact that that was our usage amount for fuel. Now we can take in basically one fill for each which as someone said is around 20 some odd days.. I'm over the cost thing i understand that, I understand the capacity and usage of the towers of themselves now. All I am saying at this point is the amount of time worth of fuel we can take in with one trip has been decreased substantially
Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#24 - 2011-12-02 01:27:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Garasu nosekai wrote:
BEFORE we could take in !90! days of fuel with one freighter for all three of our towers.

You say you had 3 large towers (2 regular caldari and 1 true sansha), with less than 960k m^3 of fuel used in 90 days.
You also say your towers used up nearly all of the power and about half of the CPU.

IF your statements are correct, your caldari towers (before any sov fuel benefits, if any) would have used up somewhere around 195 m^3 of fuel per hour, about as much as they are using now (200 m^3/hour). You needed to refill them every 564 hours or so (23 days and a half).
Your TS tower would have probably used a less fuel per hour, no idea exactly how much less, but let's guesstimate around 145 m^3/hour, give or take (refills every 758 hours or thereabouts, so a bit over 31 days and a half). TS is the second tier, it used to have a rough -25% fuel use, right ? Not so good with faction towers.

Before any sov fuel bonuses, 90 days of fuel (4+ refills) should have needed roughly 1,155,600 m^3 of fuel.
This means you were getting sov fuel benefits of AT LEAST -17%, so I can only assume the actual bonus was -20%.
That would put your actual fuel need for 90 days at around 924,480 m^3.

And your refill intervals at around 705 hours for the caldari towers (29+ days) and around 947 hours for the TS tower (39+ days).

Quote:
Now we can take in basically one fill for each

The large caldari control towers before any sov benefits have a full load of 140k m^3 for 700 hours each, and need 432,000 m^3 of fuel cubes for 90 days.
The TS tower (again, second tier, right?) only uses 32 blocks (again, before sov bonuses, if any) instead of 40, so a full load of 140k will last 875 hours (36 days 11 hours), and need 345,600 m^3 of fuel cubes for 90 days.

Grand total BEFORE SOV FUEL BONUSES, IF ANY APPLY would be 1,209,000 m^3.
That's only 53,400 m^3 more than before (assuming towers in a no-sov-fuel-reduction area), or a measly +4.62% extra.

Assuming the same -20% fuel reduction for sov still applies after this patch, the fuel you need for 90 days should be 967,200 m^3.
That's only 42,720 m^3 more than before (assuming the sov-based fuel reduction still applies), for the same measly +4.62% extra fuel volume.

If the fuel bonus of -20% will still apply, then your fuel pellet usage will be only 160 (caldari) and either 125 or 130 (TS) m^3/hour, yielding a full refill time of functioning of 875 and either 1,076 or 1,120 hours, respectively (36+ days and almost 45 or 46+ days between refills).

OR are you telling us that sov fuel benefits no longer exist after this patch ?!?
If so, THAT is your problem, not the fuel pellets.
And it would still only be about 25% more fuel volume because of that, combined with the less than 5% from before, only about 30% extra volume total, not over 40% as you seem to fear.

So, do sov fuel benefits still exist after the patch or not ?
Maybe you just forgot to include them in manually, if they're not displayed properly but they still exist.
Velicitia
XS Tech
#25 - 2011-12-02 01:36:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Velicitia
edit ... nevermind ... Akita's maths are better.

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#26 - 2011-12-02 01:38:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Velicitia wrote:
wait, how were you cramming ninety days of fuel into a tower?

They're not cramming it into the tower itself all at the same time, they're just shipping it once every 3 months from (probably) highsec to wherever they live using a single regular freighter.

P.S. Again, the OP's issue is not REALLY with the transition to fuel blocks... it's about whether or not the sov fuel discount will still apply to fuel blocks too, and if yes, where can he see that discount displayed now.
The OP is assuming the sov fuel discount will no longer apply... or, at least, that's what he's basing his volume calculations on... apparently.
See post above for more details.
Scrapyard Bob
EVE University
Ivy League
#27 - 2011-12-02 02:07:17 UTC
The primary reason that the devs changed from 1/2/4 to 10/20/40 blocks per hour (and made the batch produce 10x more blocks from the ingredients) was so that they could put the faction tower and sov bonuses back in.

I don't have detailed numbers on that though - the 2nd dev blog covers some of it though.
Denidil
Cascades Mountain Operatives
#28 - 2011-12-02 02:21:59 UTC
sov and faction tower bonuses still exist, they reintroduced them as part of increasing fuel block counts by 10 and cutting size by 10

Tedium and difficulty are not the same thing, if you don't realize this then STFU about game design.

Garasu nosekai
Creodron.com
#29 - 2011-12-02 02:38:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Garasu nosekai
.... We get no SOV bonuses where we live I don't know where you got that idea. Like I said I don't do the fuel which is why I had to research the price stuff and why i was here asking in the first place. But I do help move the fuel in pretty much every time for the past 11 months. Like Iv said about 4 times now, It is a 100% fact that our corp could survive for 90 days on one trip of a freighter. Now we would need two. That is all I have been saying its a pain in the ******* ass to move even the one freighter worth two is just that much worse.

You guys have just been over thinking the crap out of the simple thing I have been saying. 3 large towers (I am not sure what the TS tower will use exactly, something like 37 per hour or something) will use 1296000 m3 in 90 days, no matter what. Which is more m3 then it took us for 90 days before. That's it, that's all I'm saying.
Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#30 - 2011-12-02 02:47:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Garasu nosekai wrote:
.... We get no SOV bonuses where we live I don't know where you got that idea.

In that case, you could not have moved ALL the fuel you needed for 90 days for all those towers in a single freighter, since you would have needed somewhere around 1,155,600 m^3 for that.

Unless you mean you had some locally-produced PI bits (which can account for a sizable portion of the total fuel volume) and you were only importing the ice products.
In which case, what the bloody hell is stopping you from manufacturing your own fuel cubes locally with imported ice products and locally produced PI goods ?

EITHER WAY, the total amount of fuel volume your towers will use up given your stated current grid and CPU loads will only be LESS THAN 5% HIGHER than it already is.
NOT 40% higher.

Quote:
3 large towers (I am not sure what the TS tower will use exactly, something like 37 per hour or something) will use 1296000 m3 in 90 days, no matter what.

32 per hour without sov bonuses.
Again, RIGHT NOW, before fuel pellets, your towers ALREADY consume SOMEWHERE AROUND 1,155,600 m^3 of assorted fuels in a 90-day period.
With after the switchover, your towers will consume 1,209,000 m^3 of fuel pellets in the same 90-day period.
Garasu nosekai
Creodron.com
#31 - 2011-12-02 02:53:12 UTC
Akita T wrote:
Garasu nosekai wrote:
.... We get no SOV bonuses where we live I don't know where you got that idea.

In that case, you could not have moved ALL the fuel you needed for 90 days for all those towers, since you would have needed somewhere around 1,155,600 m^3 for that.

Unless you mean you had some locally-produced PI bits (which can account for a sizable portion of the total fuel volume) and you were only importing the ice products.
In which case, what the bloody hell is stopping you from manufacturing your own fuel cubes locally ?

EITHER WAY, the total amount of fuel volume your towers will use up given your stated current grid and CPU loads will only be LESS THAN 5% HIGHER than it already is.
NOT 40% higher.



Omfg... you can obviously read so wtf is stopping you from understanding i'm not talking about the volume CONSUMED BY THE GOD DAMN TOWERS!!! I'm talking about the amount we can fit in a freaking freighter. A freighter CAN NOT HOLD 1296000 m3 that should be the end of the discussion. Anyways I have all the info that I was asking for about this topic so I'm done. Thanks to the people that actually helped and just pointed to me the articles and info that was relevant.
Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#32 - 2011-12-02 02:56:54 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Garasu nosekai wrote:
[rage removed] A freighter CAN NOT HOLD 1296000 [rage removed]


First off, you will not need 1,296,000. You will only need 1,209,000.
And a freighter can not hold 1,155,600 either, and that's roughly how much you ACTUALLY NEED RIGHT NOW TO FEED THOSE EXACT TOWERS YOU MENTIONED YOU HAVE AT THOSE USAGE LEVEL YOU CLAIMED FOR EXACTLY 90 DAYS if you get no sov fuel benefits.

You were
-either- NOT importing ALL the fuel bits the towers were using
-or- you were not importing enough fuel for 90 days.



IF you were NOT importing ALL of the fuel bits needed but only some (while producing others locally via PI or mining ice or whatnot else), why can't you keep importing what's missing and manufacturing the fuel blocks locally ? The volume difference will be minimal.

IF you were importing everything, you
-either- might want to recalculate how long your fuel was lasting in reality (probably around 75 days, not 90)
-or- you need to look again at how much grid/CPU your towers were really using (a lot less than you claimed they do)

Either way, your calculations were incorrect.
The only question is which mistake did you make ?
Garasu nosekai
Creodron.com
#33 - 2011-12-02 03:11:52 UTC
Akita T wrote:
Garasu nosekai wrote:
[rage removed] A freighter CAN NOT HOLD 1296000 [rage removed]


First off, you don't need 1,296,000. You only need 1,209,000.
And a freighter can not hold 1,155,600 either, and that's roughly how much you ACTUALLY NEED RIGHT NOW TO FEED THOSE EXACT TOWERS FOR EXACTLY 90 DAYS if you get no sov benefits.

You were
-either- NOT importing ALL the fuel bits the towers were using
-or- you were not importing enough fuel for 90 days.



IF you were NOT importing ALL of the fuel bits needed but only some (while producing others locally via PI or mining ice or whatnot else), why can't you keep importing what's missing and manufacturing the fuel blocks locally ? The volume difference will be minimal.

IF you were importing everything, you
-either- might want to recalculate how long your fuel was lasting in reality
-or- you need to look again at how much grid/CPU your towers were really using (since they probably use a lot less than you claimed)

Either way, your calculations were incorrect.
The only question is which mistake did you make ?




Ok. Please let me make this simple for you... Idk how much PG CPU we always use, idk how much of every fuel piece we use and how much we may make. This is what i know, we fueled our system of three towers with around 960 km3 for 90 days.... this is not possible any more... ok? ok.
Akita T
Caldari Navy Volunteer Task Force
#34 - 2011-12-02 03:18:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Akita T
Garasu nosekai wrote:
Please let me make this simple for you... Idk how much PG CPU we always use, idk how much of every fuel piece we use and how much we may make. This is what i know, we fueled our system of three towers with around 960 km3 for 90 days.... this is not possible any more... ok? ok.

Please let me make this even simpler for you.
You already admitted you are NOT "the fuel guy", so you're most likely missing a crucial piece of the puzzle.
I am only trying to help you reach the correct answer but you're being needlessly aggravating by repeating inaccurate conclusions.

You almost certainly were NOT fueling your system with JUST 960k m^3 of fuels for 90 days.
It was never possible given the info you gave us. So it can't cease being possible.
You WERE making some stuff locally. At least 195k m^3 of it every 90 days, in fact.

If you import what you're missing and manufacture your fuel blocks locally (by including the stuff you used to make there already), you WILL still be able to fuel your system with roughly 960k m^3 of imports for roughly 90 days.
How much less (OR MORE) than 90 days depends on WHAT you were making locally, PI stuff or ice products, and which ones.
Tau Cabalander
Retirement Retreat
Working Stiffs
#35 - 2011-12-02 03:58:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Tau Cabalander
Nevermind. Missed a post above.
Cygnet Lythanea
World Welfare Works Association
#36 - 2011-12-02 04:01:49 UTC
None, bays are staying the same, but faction POS get to keep their bonus.
Tohan Remai
Kraken Exploration and Janitorial Services
The Initiative.
#37 - 2011-12-02 10:46:57 UTC
Quote:
You almost certainly were NOT fueling your system with JUST 960k m^3 of fuels for 90 days.
It was never possible given the info you gave us. So it can't cease being possible.
You WERE making some stuff locally. At least 195k m^3 of it every 90 days, in fact.


Or the Pos Fueler's skimming off a little profit as he goes... Lol...
Velicitia
XS Tech
#38 - 2011-12-02 14:30:37 UTC
Tohan Remai wrote:
Quote:
You almost certainly were NOT fueling your system with JUST 960k m^3 of fuels for 90 days.
It was never possible given the info you gave us. So it can't cease being possible.
You WERE making some stuff locally. At least 195k m^3 of it every 90 days, in fact.


Or the Pos Fueler's skimming off a little profit as he goes... Lol...


what's the comment you guys usually use for situations like this ...

"I like the cut of your jib."? or something like that...

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

AdZc
Legio Prima Victrix
#39 - 2011-12-02 15:00:26 UTC
I like trains.
Traska Gannel
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#40 - 2011-12-02 17:02:19 UTC
Garasu nosekai wrote:
Akita T wrote:
Garasu nosekai wrote:
[rage removed] A freighter CAN NOT HOLD 1296000 [rage removed]


First off, you don't need 1,296,000. You only need 1,209,000.
And a freighter can not hold 1,155,600 either, and that's roughly how much you ACTUALLY NEED RIGHT NOW TO FEED THOSE EXACT TOWERS FOR EXACTLY 90 DAYS if you get no sov benefits.

You were
-either- NOT importing ALL the fuel bits the towers were using
-or- you were not importing enough fuel for 90 days.



IF you were NOT importing ALL of the fuel bits needed but only some (while producing others locally via PI or mining ice or whatnot else), why can't you keep importing what's missing and manufacturing the fuel blocks locally ? The volume difference will be minimal.

IF you were importing everything, you
-either- might want to recalculate how long your fuel was lasting in reality
-or- you need to look again at how much grid/CPU your towers were really using (since they probably use a lot less than you claimed)

Either way, your calculations were incorrect.
The only question is which mistake did you make ?




Ok. Please let me make this simple for you... Idk how much PG CPU we always use, idk how much of every fuel piece we use and how much we may make. This is what i know, we fueled our system of three towers with around 960 km3 for 90 days.... this is not possible any more... ok? ok.



Tell me ... were you previously shipping in all the ICE you needed for the tower? How about anything else you may have mined locally? Each fuel block now has ALL the components used in fueling the tower, isotopes, heavy water ... if I had to guess you were probably obtaining some of this locally and only shipping in the parts you did not produce locally ... if you want to get back to where you were ... manufacture the fuel blocks on site and only ship in the bits that you don't produce locally.

Previous page123Next page