These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Lieutenant Ouyano's Research into the appearance of the Drifters

Author
Azrial Bathana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#21 - 2015-02-19 18:13:45 UTC
Siddhar Gangari wrote:
Perhaps the Drifters do not like capsuleers because we ourselves utilize Jovian technology in our ships and brains. Perhaps this splinter group feels such technology should never have been gifted to humans in the first place.



That is a possibility. I think at the moment we just have to wait to see there next move.
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#22 - 2015-02-19 18:16:43 UTC
Siddhar Gangari wrote:
Perhaps the Drifters do not like capsuleers because we ourselves utilize Jovian technology in our ships and brains. Perhaps this splinter group feels such technology should never have been gifted to humans in the first place.

I have been considering this as a very real possibility.
Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#23 - 2015-02-19 18:24:42 UTC
An aggressive and powerful force is moving into territory, staging military assets and destroying things. Seems to me "just wait to see" is a very bad idea.
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#24 - 2015-02-19 18:31:16 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
An aggressive and powerful force is moving into territory, staging military assets and destroying things. Seems to me "just wait to see" is a very bad idea.

They could likely be staging for war. Whether they are siding with us or against us is very hard to determine at this point.
I feel we should do our utmost to be seen as friendly, and not enemy.
Azrial Bathana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#25 - 2015-02-19 21:45:42 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
An aggressive and powerful force is moving into territory, staging military assets and destroying things. Seems to me "just wait to see" is a very bad idea.


Well if they aren't at war with us then some form of preemptive strike would surely put us in conflict with them. Unfortunately most capsuleers have a mentality similar to yours.

Conflict with the drifters seems more and more inevitable everytime I read another post.
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#26 - 2015-02-19 22:22:05 UTC
Azrial Bathana wrote:
Conflict with the drifters seems more and more inevitable everytime I read another post.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#27 - 2015-02-19 22:35:43 UTC
If they didn't want a war, they shouldn't have sent Battleships.

That said, just because you lack the strategic vision to see any options other than "just wait" and "preemptive strike" does not mean the rest of us are so limited in our thinking.

Empire Navies should be mobilizing to observe Drifter facilities and monitor any force movements. We see now that the Drifters aren't hiding their activities, neither should the Empires hide that they are capable of a forceful response. Every one of these Drifter wormholes, structures, and any other activity should have an assigned Empire Naval task force observing at extreme distance and making every effort to avoid conflict, and warning Capsuleers not to interfere.

If or when the Drifters prove to be hostile, these are the kinds of forces that we will need in place to direct the full force of each Empire's counter attacks. In order for those attacks to be successful, we need our forces fully alert and ready to be deployed. Loyalist Capsuleer forces should be utilized within the bounds of operational security to support these operations.
Azrial Bathana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#28 - 2015-02-19 23:57:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Azrial Bathana
Rinai Vero wrote:
If they didn't want a war, they shouldn't have sent Battleships.

That said, just because you lack the strategic vision to see any options other than "just wait" and "preemptive strike" does not mean the rest of us are so limited in our thinking.

Empire Navies should be mobilizing to observe Drifter facilities and monitor any force movements. We see now that the Drifters aren't hiding their activities, neither should the Empires hide that they are capable of a forceful response. Every one of these Drifter wormholes, structures, and any other activity should have an assigned Empire Naval task force observing at extreme distance and making every effort to avoid conflict, and warning Capsuleers not to interfere.

If or when the Drifters prove to be hostile, these are the kinds of forces that we will need in place to direct the full force of each Empire's counter attacks. In order for those attacks to be successful, we need our forces fully alert and ready to be deployed. Loyalist Capsuleer forces should be utilized within the bounds of operational security to support these operations.



Its apparent you didn't really understand what I meant. I agree we do need to gather as much info on these drifters as possible, however we should not engage them or provoke them in anyway. As for the battleships, capsuleers tend to have a shoot first attitude which is something you've taken no effort to hide. If I were a drifter I would have brought a battleship too.

Also its probably best not to make snide remarks when you don't fully understand what someone means. It makes you look silly in the long run.
Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#29 - 2015-02-20 00:16:57 UTC
Azrial Bathana wrote:



Its apparent you didn't really understand what I meant. I agree we do need to gather as much info on these drifters as possible, however we should not engage them or provoke them in anyway. As for the battleships, capsuleers tend to have a shoot first attitude which is something you've taken no effort to hide. If I were a drifter I would have brought a battleship too.

Also its probably best not to make snide remarks when you don't fully understand what someone means. It makes you look silly in the long run.


Mince words as you like.

Azrial Bathana wrote:
I think at the moment we just have to wait to see there next move.


Azrial Bathana wrote:
Rinai Vero wrote:
An aggressive and powerful force is moving into territory, staging military assets and destroying things. Seems to me "just wait to see" is a very bad idea.


Well if they aren't at war with us then some form of preemptive strike would surely put us in conflict with them. Unfortunately most capsuleers have a mentality similar to yours.


I've characterized your positions appropriately.

This isn't me being snide. This is me pointing out naivety bluntly. They are provoking us and you are talking about "just" watching.

I am talking about taking active steps to ready our peoples for the very real possibility that we are about to be attacked.
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#30 - 2015-02-20 02:09:20 UTC
I had an interesting notion after observing some activity today.

What if the Drifters are here to defend us from something . . .
Aedre Lafisques
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#31 - 2015-02-20 02:25:12 UTC
I will be forward with this; I'm concerned that we're being judged.

Being provoked is something that happens all the time between Capsuleers. It's up to the personality of the individual to accept losses in the face of honour and action, or to play the long game and still potentially face further losses.

Most scenarios in this instance to me as such indicate losses either way, as they are not overtly friendly, posturing about with their flashy guns as they do.

Bringing a battleship into sovereign spaces is a threat. Absolutely obliterating ships with a super weapon is a threat. Their killboard is stunningly green, and much of it in High Sec.

I'm concerned that this advanced set of people that are not forthcoming in speaking to us is waiting to see if fear overwhelms us. Maybe they are waiting for the fear to set in and divide us. Maybe they are waiting to see if we're organized enough to stay calm. Maybe they are waiting for us to do nothing while hedging our bets, and lose everything in a slow reaction to a sudden attack. What it is that they're doing is not the point, however: An enemy will find me and attack me. They will scan me down, hunt me, or opportunity attack at leisure. They won't even hesitate, sometimes even facing losses in the doing.

They aren't doing this, they are instead acting in a way that should unsettle us.

These ships are aggressive only when disturbed. I'm not saying that this, or that not attempting to communicate when we all presume that they can is acceptable. It's not; It's rude. Do you think I'm being factious? I suspect that they don't care about the details.

I'm not sure I can clearly describe my frustration with watching people disturb what could be creatures, a peoples we can't yet understand, or the half-awake, and then claiming that they are being shot at, aggressed.

Do we call an animal unacceptable if it wanders into our house and we jab at it? What does one do when that happens?
We have two options. We kill it for entering our sovereign space, or we carefully try not not anger it.
Not angering an animal requires a certain tact. We don't know what these things are. They look like people but are they? If they are people, and we decide they are not behaving appropriately, but they are actually more advanced, how exactly do we enforce our sense of right on them? Attrition war with the Caldari is tiring and awful enough, we cannot afford to fight the men with superweapons and hoping they run out of ISK or cap.

People might think that I'm asking for diplomacy or negotiation, or 'waiting'. What I am asking for, however, is for increased bravery on our parts and our crew, to continue to investigate the circumstances to which aggression occurs and document it, and share it, as is being done here.

I hope that no one sees being cautious as 'inaction'. No one is as prepared to handle this threat delicately as we are. We have continued consciousnesses and near infinite resources. Our concerns must be our crews and not hampering terribly our ability to redeploy and shift gears at a moment's notice. Our abilities in this regard far outstrip the Navies. I'm practically a volounteer in Black Rise and I have a more than dozen different shiptypes at the ready. This is not anywhere near what the regulars have lying in wait.

I won't be bullied into simplistic thinking by a secretive or downright impaired enemy. I will do what anyone faced with unknown odds would do, and that is draw a very slow and deliberate outline around the enemy's attitude and capabilities over time, rather than call down the wrath of a cyno and a hundred supers. Has fighting the Caldari for so long, with their self depreciating manner in conflict made us so eager to take a sword to a hornet's nest? You claim that you want action rather than inaction, but it sounds very much like you'd like this action to include warmongering with a wholly unknown force.

I don't know about you, but I have full confidence that the GMVA is capable of changing tacks quickly and efficiently. If this should go poorly for all of us, and it likely will, perhaps there was nothing we could do. But perhaps our actions were the cause, and perhaps we could have done more to have mitigated our troubles.

Those of you working to further our intel on this aggressive new entity in our midst are to be commended, in particular in ways that can be construed as curious rather than as the threat I worry we actually are. I am not worried that the wrath of Capsuleers are more than they are bargaining for. We are unfathomable in cunning and resourcefulness, and rage. I'm worried that the worst of it could have been avoided. We all have too much shooting first in our histories that only ruin chances for ourselves down the line. Can we honestly claim after all of this that first strike is really wiser in the long run? We are experts, and we should know better.
Azrial Bathana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#32 - 2015-02-20 04:13:41 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
Azrial Bathana wrote:



Its apparent you didn't really understand what I meant. I agree we do need to gather as much info on these drifters as possible, however we should not engage them or provoke them in anyway. As for the battleships, capsuleers tend to have a shoot first attitude which is something you've taken no effort to hide. If I were a drifter I would have brought a battleship too.

Also its probably best not to make snide remarks when you don't fully understand what someone means. It makes you look silly in the long run.


Mince words as you like.

Azrial Bathana wrote:
I think at the moment we just have to wait to see there next move.


Azrial Bathana wrote:
Rinai Vero wrote:
An aggressive and powerful force is moving into territory, staging military assets and destroying things. Seems to me "just wait to see" is a very bad idea.


Well if they aren't at war with us then some form of preemptive strike would surely put us in conflict with them. Unfortunately most capsuleers have a mentality similar to yours.


I've characterized your positions appropriately.

This isn't me being snide. This is me pointing out naivety bluntly. They are provoking us and you are talking about "just" watching.

I am talking about taking active steps to ready our peoples for the very real possibility that we are about to be attacked.


You haven't characterized them appropriately considering that not what I meant. They aren't provoking us, they've just come set up towers in space and are defending them the same way anyone else would. They just happen to have super tech while doing it.

I'm not saying don't defend yourselves, I'm just saying maybe its best not to go and poke our very strong, very advanced, new neighbors.


Observe them, give it time, and then formulate a plan based on that data. Or run in guns blazing and possibly start a war that we cannot win.
Kithrus
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#33 - 2015-02-20 04:20:22 UTC
Lisa Ouyano wrote:
I had an interesting notion after observing some activity today.

What if the Drifters are here to defend us from something . . .


I've wondered the same thing. We assume because the structures we encounter seemed to belong to the drifters they were the drifters. What if the structures were making ready to open somehow?

Darkness is more then absence of light, it is ignorance and corruption. I will be the Bulwark from such things that you may live in the light. Pray so my arms do not grow weary and my footing remain sure.

If you are brave, join me in the dark.

Jarrad Glynn Kirk
#34 - 2015-02-20 06:19:32 UTC
Lisa Ouyano wrote:
I had an interesting notion after observing some activity today.

What if the Drifters are here to defend us from something . . .

Did not even consider the possibility of that.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#35 - 2015-02-20 06:43:25 UTC
Azrial Bathana wrote:

You haven't characterized them appropriately considering that not what I meant. They aren't provoking us, they've just come set up towers in space and are defending them the same way anyone else would. They just happen to have super tech while doing it.

I'm not saying don't defend yourselves, I'm just saying maybe its best not to go and poke our very strong, very advanced, new neighbors.


Observe them, give it time, and then formulate a plan based on that data. Or run in guns blazing and possibly start a war that we cannot win.


...

Most of that statement is naive to a truly stunning degree. I don't know what universe you're living in, but here in reality what the Drifters are doing is a provocation of the most blatant sort.

Once again, it is you talking about "poking" and "guns blazing" when what I've said has nothing to do with either.

Believe me, if I thought this situation called for overheated blasters... I'd be saying overheat your blasters!
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#36 - 2015-02-20 06:47:35 UTC
Miss Vero and Mister Bathana,

I will ask you politely to please take your personal squabble to another venue.

Thank you,
Lt. Ouyano
Azrial Bathana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#37 - 2015-02-20 06:54:03 UTC
Lisa Ouyano wrote:
Miss Vero and Mister Bathana,

I will ask you politely to please take your personal squabble to another venue.

Thank you,
Lt. Ouyano


I was done anyway, I just remembered that she isn't in a position where anything she does could really effect anything on a large scale anyway.

That being said neither am I so we were both kind of wasting our time.


"If they didn't want a war, they shouldn't have sent Battleships."

(Peaceful words of someone claiming they aren't advocating a war between capsuleers and drifters)

Reko Blancwoodd
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#38 - 2015-02-20 07:06:45 UTC

Lt. Ouyano

When did you become a lieutenant?
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#39 - 2015-02-20 07:43:12 UTC
Reko Blancwoodd wrote:

Lt. Ouyano

When did you become a lieutenant?

Answered privately.
Lisa Ouyano
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#40 - 2015-02-20 14:57:39 UTC
117.02.19 Field Report

Investigated 4 locations, Outuni, Afivad, Ordize, (name forgotten will fix)

Outuni: No activity
Afivad: No activity
(Name): No activity
Ordize: Substantial activity.

In Ordize I attempted to use an armor rep on Apollo's craft, near the wormhole. He refused to let me.
Seconds later Apollo leaves system.
I head to their tower, no activity.
Minutes later Apollo returns and fires upon me.
I warp to the star Apollo warps to within 100km of me.
Artemetis appears in system and warpa within 20km of me.
At the star Apollo is unable to land hits, artemetis lands two solid hits.
I warp out to a more or less random moon. Then I warp to another moon.
Apollo warps to me, then Artemetis.
I suspect fleet warp was used, but they were not aligned.
I warp to another moon then jump system.

Shortly thereafter I am contacted by another team which had been destroying seeker drones in an effort to draw the Drifters.
Destroying seekers did not draw the Drifters.
I invite them to Ordize.
They arrive in system before I return.
Upon arrival in system they aggress the machinery outside of the wormhole.
Drifters appear quickly and open fire.

I arrive in Ordize and see the wreckage of the previous engagement. No drifter activity.
Aedre Lafisques joins the efforts, and I station him at the wormhole while I investigate the tower.

Within 3 minutes of me entering system Apollo warps in and immediately warpa to me from the wormhole.
He fires two shots and destroys my Exequor.
Thereafter he warpa back to the wormhole and destroys Lafisques's frigate.
Aggressive action by both Apollo and Artemetis continues in Ordize.

End of report.