These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Fiction

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The Enheduanni as History

Author
Min Chu-Ch'eng
Aideron Robotics
Aideron Robotics.
#1 - 2015-02-19 04:38:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Min Chu-Ch'eng
As my first foray into the tin foil hat arena I'd like to submit this premise; at least portions of The Prophecy of Macaper are based upon ancient texts by the first author/poet in history, Enheduanna. If this idea has already been raised, I apologize; I didn’t see any mention of it in my wanderings and readings of conjecture, but I am new so I may have missed something.

For reference I’d like to provide some links at the beginning of this post, the first is simply the Wikipedia entry regarding Enheduanna, and the second and third links are to translations of her hymns to the goddess Inana. I also included a link to the Prophecy of Macaper; but after all the excellent coverage lately by Rhavas, the Hydrostatic gang and many others, it’s probably unnecessary. I’ll also break this post into parts; the first will discuss a potential RL historical link for the Enheduanni, and the second will conjecture on potential implications. Regardless, I hope that this gets people thinking and imagining in some potentially new directions. After all, that’s the fun part, right? :)

1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enheduanna
2) http://etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/cgi-bin/etcsl.cgi?text=t.4.07.2&charenc=j# (Inana B)
3) http://etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/cgi-bin/etcsl.cgi?text=t.4.07.3&charenc=j# (Inana C)
4) https://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/TheProphecyofMacaper%28Chronicle%29
Min Chu-Ch'eng
Aideron Robotics
Aideron Robotics.
#2 - 2015-02-19 04:44:45 UTC
Part 1: Evidence for an Enheduanni-Enheduanna link

So, I’d like to confess something: when delving into EVE lore I flubbed the spelling of Enheduanni. I’m guessing I probably wasn’t the first, nor will I likely be the last, but when I mismashed my keyboard the search results returned, instead, the name Enheduanna. “Well, now that bears a striking resemblance to what I’m searching for but I clearly botched it. Wonder who/what/where Enheduanna is.” A similarity in spelling alone could be entirely coincidental, particularly if the names are using roots I’m unfamiliar with (anyone with expertise please feel free to chime in!). However, two things made me more than a bit curious: 1) authors and other artists are frequently known to take their inspiration from history and/or their environment and 2) Enheduanni seems like a moderate-to-difficult combination to stumble upon.

I also find it intriguing that the link is to an incredibly early author/poet, as to the EVE universe the Enheduanni are in a similar historical position. We know little of their culture, mythos, etc., except relices and temples we found throughout space; if you haven’t check the Wiki-link yet, Enheduanna was also a high princess and priestess in Sumeria, one of Earth’s earliest recorded civilizations. The combination made her a potent political and religious leader. Hrm. Continuing the potential life-story similarities, during the reign of her brother she becomes embroiled in political turmoil political turmoil and cast out, though eventually she is reinstated to her position and later becomes perceived as semi-divine. This matches some of the theories regarding what was thought to occur with the Enheduanni, namely, at one point they coexisted/were part of Jovian society, were exiled/cast out/ trapped (in Anoixis or otherwise?), and are seeking to come back/escape their prison, of whatever form that may take. I think we already knew we were in trouble, but if they’re also deific...ouch.

For me, however, it was the similarity between Inana B and C and the Prophecy of Macaper that made my skin goosebump. Quick reference time for the Seven Events of the Apolocalypse:
1) “cosmetic kiss of the comets”
2) rains lasting weeks, a great flood
3) “roaring stone that silences the world”
4) “appetite of nothing expands over the world”
5) “the little brother makes the final sorrowful steps home; he is not welcome”
6) “what was many now becomes one when one becomes four”
7) “return of the dark light from the heart of the mother”

On lines 99-108 of Inana C you’ll see that the goddess Inana in Enheduanna’s poem is described as riding on the back of “seven great beasts as she comes forth from heaven.” Let’s see how many of the actual events we can match between the two: While 60-72 of Inana C talk about pulverizing the divine plans of heaven and earth, this is the one I find hardest to match, likely in part due to the lack of knowledge about comets in ancient Sumeria ;) Still, if comets are celestial bodies (akin to gods/deities) there are some potential links. Inana B also talks about divine powers, as well as the destroyer of foreign lands (which technically comets are foreign bodies in our solar systems).

1-12 of Inana B, 18-28 and 29-38 of Inana C, all talk about Inana’s wrath as “a devastating flood which no one can withstand. A great watercourse, ......, she abases those whom she despises.” Lots of links with that one.

What’s interesting about the third is that Inana actually goes toe to toe with a mountain (I kid you not), when it refuses to acknowledge her supremacy (Inana and Ebih, I haven’t linked that one, but a short version is Inana C 109-114). But I would say Inana B, lines 20-33 are closer; “at your battle cry, my lady, the foreign lands lie low.” What’s even more intriguing is “When humanity comes before you in awed silence at the terrifying radiance and tempest, you grasp the most terrible of all the divine powers.”

The “appetite of nothing expands over the world” I believe is a reference to the dragon’s venom Inana deposits on foreign lands, that leaves all vegetation dead and unable to grow. In the hymn, it’s also tied back to Inana roaring, so there’s an additional tie, there. Between the dragon’s venom, “raining blazing fire down upon the land” and “Whoever eats ...... Inana's food and milk of death will not last” (Inana C) I think we have some appetite candidates. Again, I think we have some options on interpretation here.

Inana B has a section (42-59) that at the ends talks about a wife shuns her husband after Inana’s triumph. It could also refer to Enheduanna’s story as opposed to Inana’s; while she is a sister, not a brother, she was banished from her home. Ugh. By far the toughest passage to find anything to connect to, I couldn’t find anything directly related to this, unless you go off into Jungian psychology, which others have discussed in relation to the EVE universe already. There’s at least one scholar who relates Enheduanna to that philosophy (as a much earlier version) and thus the one becomes four could still apply Jungian style, but I’d still peg this as tenuous.

Beyond goddesses being referred to as mothers (and many references to divine wombs, etc.), we have 49-59 and 174-181 of Inana C: “On the wide and silent plain, darkening the bright daylight, she turns midday into darkness. People look upon each other in anger, they look for combat.” and “At your anger what is bright darkens; you turn midday into darkness. When the time had come you destroyed the place you had in your thoughts, you made the place tremble.”

I realize that I’ve based all of this off of some very very old poems and hymns, and that some of these interpretations and connections are hazy. Thanks for sticking with it so far; and hopefully part 2 will stir some thoughts as to how this all relates to EVE.
Min Chu-Ch'eng
Aideron Robotics
Aideron Robotics.
#3 - 2015-02-19 04:51:46 UTC
Part 2: What Enheduanna-Inana might mean for EVE

Everyone back? Cold beer or hot mug of coffee in hand? Awesome. Please bring your EVE Tin Foil Hat (™) with you, as I could definitely use some more insight and knowledge on some of the ideas I’ll be tossing out. Templar: One and Source are on their way to my house now, so if anything I say contradicts those I apologize in advance and feel free to ignore it.

If we assume for the moment that the Enheduanna/Enheduanni similarity is not a coincidence (thanks for giving me the benefit of the doubt!), then the first thing that strikes me is that Enheduanna is not, herself, a goddess. She reaches very high status approaching a god later in life, but she is constantly in service to Inana, who if Part 1 holds may be the “mother” referenced in Macaper. That would indicate that the Enheduanni are in fact servants of some higher power/being/race that are striving to do zer bidding (general-neutral, just in case). Yikes. The Enheduanni appear to be enough of a headache, but if their own exile/prison has to do with trying to assist something else? That sounds even worse, but also may provide good incentive to isolate them from the rest of the EVE universe. Their manipulation of events in New Eden would then center around their worship of this other power/being. At the time of the Theodicy Chronicle, the events of Seyllin and the opening of W-space had not yet occurred, which may explain the lack of more direct involvement from the Enheduanni. Side note; theodicy is an attempt to answer the question of why a good God permits the manifestation of evil. But no one said which “God” the EVE chronicle might be referring to; the Enheduanni might consider every other race in New Eden a manifestation of evil that needs to be purged. shivers And the follow-up to that is then what have they been up to since?

“Alright, Min, that’s all well and good, but there’s more right?” Why, yes, intrepid reader, there is! Another thing that stuck out to me reading Inana B and C is that when Inana grew angry she would incite humans to attack and fight amongst one another. This combined with the religious and political bent of Enheduanna also seems to correspond to how the Enheduanni seem to go about business. If that tracks, then even just inciting war between the Empires could be enough of an “end goal” for the Enheduanni, as acting in the service of their divine. They may also have passed along enough of their religion to one of the Empires such that their religion still has a presence in New Eden, but that could be my pro-Gallente anti-Amarr bent showing through ;) Thinking of the Amarr as puppets (on strings!) led by the Enheduanni is mighty scary, however, especially with access to super-weapons and the potential ability to go toe-to-toe (or beat outright) the Jove. “I’ve got no strings to hold me down.”

I’m sure I’ll have other tin-foiling ideas on this and more in the future, but this has already gone on more than long enough, so I’ll issue my apologies and get this out there. Beware the coming of our new goddess Inana, though; she really doesn’t seem like a particularly happy camper!
Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#4 - 2015-02-24 17:53:24 UTC
This is all interesting stuff! I was not familiar with this historical figure at all.

Thanks for writing it up.