These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Missions & Complexes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The nerf to Drone Hordes

First post
Author
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#21 - 2011-11-30 16:10:45 UTC
Sub Prime wrote:


So you're saying that drones shouldn't drop alloys and also that drones shouldn't have bounties or any other means of ISK revenue?



Actually, I think drones should drop alloys. Minerals should come from ore only. Drones should drop tags like Sleepers do that need to be resold in empire (this is actually a buff IMO, as it means less trucking around alloys).

I also think all regular rats (non commander/officer) should only result in metal scraps for salvage. Salvage should solely come from mag sites (yay buff to mag sites).
Sub Prime
Perkone
Caldari State
#22 - 2011-11-30 16:11:15 UTC
Jenn aSide wrote:
Sub Prime wrote:


So you're saying that drones shouldn't drop alloys and also that drones shouldn't have bounties or any other means of ISK revenue? I just want to clarify exactly what you mean.


Did I say anything about bounties?

I have no problem with people shooting drones to somehow generate isk, although I personally prefer my NPCs be of the pirate persuasion (Death To Guristas and all that).

The problem was they WAY they generated isk (not for me, but for miners, and by extension, for the rest of the game). CCP seems to be trying to fix that, and that's fine with me.


I'm fine with that as well. Infact I prefer bounties to drone alloys. There are numerous reasons why this is more beneficial to individuals and corps within the drone regions.
Sephiroth CloneIIV
Brothers of Tyr
Goonswarm Federation
#23 - 2011-11-30 16:14:03 UTC
If something has been changed to make hoards worse then I would say the complaint is legit, though it has not been explained exactly what has changed.

For one, if the stuff comes in waves, is that a change? If the drones target everything in mission area, then hold back the noctois.

If you are multiboxing wait for the area to be cleared before puting in notis, while that char is salvaging the stuff in the thousands of M3 your other char can clear a new site

if not multiboxing, well you have to clear the area anyway before reshiping, no salvaging is not safe in industirals with any rats present.

If you are using a maurader does a all in one ship work, or do the presence of rats now prevent tractoring and cycling the salvager.


If whatever change is a problem, clearly state how it is a problem.
Sub Prime
Perkone
Caldari State
#24 - 2011-11-30 16:16:02 UTC
Emperor Salazar wrote:
Sub Prime wrote:


So you're saying that drones shouldn't drop alloys and also that drones shouldn't have bounties or any other means of ISK revenue?



Actually, I think drones should drop alloys. Minerals should come from ore only. Drones should drop tags like Sleepers do that need to be resold in empire (this is actually a buff IMO, as it means less trucking around alloys).

I also think all regular rats (non commander/officer) should only result in metal scraps for salvage. Salvage should solely come from mag sites (yay buff to mag sites).


What would drone alloys be used for?

Fair enough that sleeper tags have to be sold in empire, but I think the ability to sell drone tags should be in any station/outpost. Getting things in and out of nullsec (especially if you're a long way out) can be a royal pain in the arse.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#25 - 2011-11-30 16:20:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Emperor Salazar
Sub Prime wrote:


What would drone alloys be used for?

Fair enough that sleeper tags have to be sold in empire, but I think the ability to sell drone tags should be in any station/outpost. Getting things in and out of nullsec (especially if you're a long way out) can be a royal pain in the arse.


Uh....

I'm saying replace drone alloys entirely with tags.

And having to get things out of space is a good thing. Not having NPC buy orders in null means player buy orders can be placed in null from people who are willing to port it out to empire and make a profit. This is already done with OPEs.
Sub Prime
Perkone
Caldari State
#26 - 2011-11-30 16:33:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Sub Prime
Sephiroth CloneIIV wrote:
If something has been changed to make hoards worse then I would say the complaint is legit, though it has not been explained exactly what has changed.

For one, if the stuff comes in waves, is that a change? If the drones target everything in mission area, then hold back the noctois.

If you are multiboxing wait for the area to be cleared before puting in notis, while that char is salvaging the stuff in the thousands of M3 your other char can clear a new site

if not multiboxing, well you have to clear the area anyway before reshiping, no salvaging is not safe in industirals with any rats present.

If you are using a maurader does a all in one ship work, or do the presence of rats now prevent tractoring and cycling the salvager.


If whatever change is a problem, clearly state how it is a problem.


Similar to Sanctums, there are 2 Drone Hordes. One operated on a spawn basis with a trigger ship spawning the next wave of drones. The other (and by far more popular if you had the right tank) consisted of a wave on warp in and 4 other waves triggered by shooting a bunker. Heavily/speed tanking ships could pop all the bunkers, get full aggro and then a noctis could warp in to salvage as the drones got popped. Now there spawns come in triggered waves which is a problem when you have a salvager.

While this isn't a problem with sanctums where the ISK is generated through bounties, it is with hordes as this means salvaging has to take place after the last spawn has been aggroed and therefore means it takes longer to get the alloys.

EDIT: Oh, the alloys from all the ships in a drone horde take up approx 2700-3000m3 so using a marauder isn't feasible.
Jenn aSide
Soul Machines
The Initiative.
#27 - 2011-11-30 16:45:03 UTC
Emperor Salazar wrote:
Sub Prime wrote:


So you're saying that drones shouldn't drop alloys and also that drones shouldn't have bounties or any other means of ISK revenue?



Actually, I think drones should drop alloys. Minerals should come from ore only. Drones should drop tags like Sleepers do that need to be resold in empire (this is actually a buff IMO, as it means less trucking around alloys).

I also think all regular rats (non commander/officer) should only result in metal scraps for salvage. Salvage should solely come from mag sites (yay buff to mag sites).


+1
TOTALHELLD3ATH
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#28 - 2011-11-30 17:12:28 UTC
Emperor Salazar wrote:
TOTALHELLD3ATH wrote:


That's not the point. Its about your space that you have worked hard building an outpost and upgrading getting nerf'd out from under you on the whim of the Devs. Yes, people will gravitate to the new better space, but it sucks for those on the receiving end of the nerf. And before anyone spouts off about Russian bots its not about that either. Its a nerf to at the keyboard players who run the sites.

Great expansion CCP, but this one thing sours the hole thing for those of us in drone. Especially as you give the other anoms a boost. Sad


So your argument is that you have a personal attachment to the space because of the time and effort you have invested in it? Should CCP intervene if someone decides to attempt to take your space from you in game?

If you want better space, go take it.


Hell no, CCP should not intervene if someone wants the space and attacks. That's kind of the point of the game. In this case CCP is coming in and devaluing the space. There are no reinforcement timers for that bullsh*t.
TOTALHELLD3ATH
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#29 - 2011-11-30 17:18:23 UTC
Oh, and someone was asking if CCP thought about it before implementing this. There was plenty of people say WTF are you doing to the hordes in the anom boost thread. And Greyscale pretty much said. Yeah we know this is a kick in the nuts. Tough cookies where doing it anyway.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#30 - 2011-11-30 17:37:56 UTC
TOTALHELLD3ATH wrote:


Hell no, CCP should not intervene if someone wants the space and attacks. That's kind of the point of the game. In this case CCP is coming in and devaluing the space. There are no reinforcement timers for that bullsh*t.


Well its good that you're smart enough to see it in that light.

Now, take it the next step and realize THIS IS A GOOD THING. Devalued space means other space is more valuable.

You want value? Leave the drone regions.
Evgeniy Taran
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#31 - 2011-11-30 18:24:36 UTC
Emperor Salazar wrote:
TOTALHELLD3ATH wrote:


Hell no, CCP should not intervene if someone wants the space and attacks. That's kind of the point of the game. In this case CCP is coming in and devaluing the space. There are no reinforcement timers for that bullsh*t.


Well its good that you're smart enough to see it in that light.

Now, take it the next step and realize THIS IS A GOOD THING. Devalued space means other space is more valuable.

You want value? Leave the drone regions.

Try to guess what will happen if everyone will leave drone regiones Smile

Anyway I absolutely sure that CCP have the reason about nerf. But can't get what is a reason...
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#32 - 2011-11-30 18:38:37 UTC
Evgeniy Taran wrote:

Try to guess what will happen if everyone will leave drone regiones Smile



Other people who are willing to settle for the fat chick of space regions will move in.
WuMaTih
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#33 - 2011-11-30 18:42:05 UTC  |  Edited by: WuMaTih
The nerf to Drone hordes is to harsh.

And lets not post anymore BS about DRF Botters ect.. you think the only bots are in drone regions? your stupidly mistaken. There are thousands/tens of thousands of players who dont bot in this regions.
The arguement go find different space? So you want 1/3 of eve space to be ****? Where do you think they will go? Your space

Can a dev please explain to me how they are balanced with bounty space for the individual player?

We now cannot salvage while we do the horde which we NEED to do in order to get any money. This increases the time it takes to do a horde significantly. Which reduced ISK income.

Oh not to mention in order to be efficient in drone lands you need...

A) A second account with a noctis pilot

B) After you complete your horde you have to goto a station (if there is one in system) and get into a noctis (which you need the skills to fly one) Then you have to go tractor everything and loot everything (salvage is optional but youd be dumb not to) then you have to go back to station (agian if there is 1 in system).

Then after A or B you have to then haul (so you need skills to fly a hauler or a second hauler account) your alloys to a station with a refinery and refine the alloys into minerals.(which you need skills to refine well) You then have to sell these minerals all before you see a single isk for your work.

Please tell me agian.. how is this balanced with bounty space? Cause it gives you minerals instead of isk? Please just give us bounties and end it, leave minerals to the poor miners getting ravaged by the alloys.


BTW everything else looks sweet i just think drone regions require much more work and skills/accounts to acheive the same ammount of isk.Quote
Deathwing Reborn
#34 - 2011-11-30 18:48:50 UTC
Sephiroth CloneIIV wrote:
If something has been changed to make hoards worse then I would say the complaint is legit, though it has not been explained exactly what has changed.

For one, if the stuff comes in waves, is that a change? If the drones target everything in mission area, then hold back the noctois.

If you are multiboxing wait for the area to be cleared before puting in notis, while that char is salvaging the stuff in the thousands of M3 your other char can clear a new site

if not multiboxing, well you have to clear the area anyway before reshiping, no salvaging is not safe in industirals with any rats present.

If you are using a maurader does a all in one ship work, or do the presence of rats now prevent tractoring and cycling the salvager.


If whatever change is a problem, clearly state how it is a problem.



They basically took the horde site that is most common (in 0.1-0.4 this is almost always the only one available.) and made it take nearly twice as long to complete using drones (waves means your drones /fighters have to travel from one side of the site to the other many more times to kill all enemies) as well as decreasing the drop of alloys from ~3k to from what I have had so far ~2.2k m3. With both of these changes the total isk/hour has probably been cut in nearly half.

Oh and by the way this still does not account for the added time of logistics and drawbacks of not getting instant income from the site because you HAVE to salvage and loot EVERYTHING as well as get it refined and sold to make ANY isk on it.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#35 - 2011-11-30 19:01:23 UTC
WuMaTih wrote:

Can a dev please explain to me how they are balanced with bounty space for the individual player?


Can you explain to us why they need to be balanced?
Deathwing Reborn
#36 - 2011-11-30 19:15:42 UTC
Emperor Salazar wrote:
WuMaTih wrote:

Can a dev please explain to me how they are balanced with bounty space for the individual player?


Can you explain to us why they need to be balanced?


Can you explain to us why you think we needed a nerf to be balnaced if being balanced does not matter?

We can go round and round about this. The simple fact is that CCP just hit drone regions with the nerf bat again because the rest of the players cant handle the fact that we make a living in the worst space in the game and make it look easy.
Vipieris
Fraternal Order of Raddei
#37 - 2011-11-30 19:24:41 UTC
I love how people who DON'T live in these areas are so quick to argue about something they obviously know nothing about...


I also love the snarky comments they make like, "Well maybe it shouldn't be balanced," and "go find somewhere else to live" when I know without any doubt whatsoever that they'd be screaming bloody murder if THEIR gameplay was affected...


So I'll respond to all of them with this comment:

"I didn't ask you for your opinion, so STFU...."

That work for you? Good.


Personally I thought the Hordes were just fine as they were, and I've only been running them now for about a month, busting my a$$ to get the right skills, the right ship, the right fittings, buying BPO's for the drones/fighters, etc... Now it's becoming pretty obvious that carriers - already being useless for PvP - are useless for PvE as well.

So I challenge CCP to address these concerns, as they've now made the "hardest" drone site one of the least valuable. And for those of you who aren't affected by this issue, I invite you to mind your own damned business.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#38 - 2011-11-30 19:31:36 UTC
Vipieris wrote:
I love how people who DON'T live in these areas are so quick to argue about something they obviously know nothing about...


I also love the snarky comments they make like, "Well maybe it shouldn't be balanced," and "go find somewhere else to live" when I know without any doubt whatsoever that they'd be screaming bloody murder if THEIR gameplay was affected...


So I'll respond to all of them with this comment:

"I didn't ask you for your opinion, so STFU...."

That work for you? Good.


Personally I thought the Hordes were just fine as they were, and I've only been running them now for about a month, busting my a$$ to get the right skills, the right ship, the right fittings, buying BPO's for the drones/fighters, etc... Now it's becoming pretty obvious that carriers - already being useless for PvP - are useless for PvE as well.

So I challenge CCP to address these concerns, as they've now made the "hardest" drone site one of the least valuable. And for those of you who aren't affected by this issue, I invite you to mind your own damned business.


Looks like a renter is rather butthurt. Maybe you could negotiate with your land lord for lower monthly payments since your farming anomalies were nerfed?

Nah, just complain here instead so we can all laugh at you.

also lol carriers useless for PvP; renters not so bright are they?
Herrington Vance
Doomheim
#39 - 2011-11-30 19:40:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Herrington Vance
I think it is fairly obvious that, regardless of how much anyone agrees or disagrees with the concept of certain space being of dramatically lower value (or higher opportunity cost), CCP is trying to push drone-residents to get mobile and start hassling other regions for "better," space.

Ultimately, it makes little difference what we think about equitable anom equivalents. CCP has made it's agenda clear ages ago and they clearly think that this is their best bet to get sov. wars going again. Since the NC was evicted, I'll be they even think their plan has been a success thus far.

Personally, I don't think anything short of tech moons will ever be worth structure grinding over, but perhaps i'm under-estimating the boredom super pilots will experience without being able to smack subcaps around.
Emperor Salazar
Remote Soviet Industries
Insidious Empire
#40 - 2011-11-30 19:54:14 UTC
Herrington Vance wrote:
I think it is fairly obvious that, regardless of how much anyone agrees or disagrees with the concept of certain space being of dramatically lower value (or higher opportunity cost), CCP is trying to push drone-residents to get mobile and start hassling other regions for "better," space.

Ultimately, it makes little difference what we think about equitable anom equivalents. CCP has made it's agenda clear ages ago and they clearly think that this is their best bet to get sov. wars going again. Since the NC was evicted, I'll be they even think their plan has been a success thus far.

Personally, I don't think anything short of tech moons will ever be worth structure grinding over, but perhaps i'm under-estimating the boredom super pilots will experience without being able to smack subcaps around.


Look at this guy being all logical in a thread of whine, tears and entitlement.

Props to you for being the hero we need.