These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Fiction

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next page
 

What happens when a capsuleer dies in station?

Author
Ghaustyl Kathix
Rising Thunder
#1 - 2014-05-13 19:48:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghaustyl Kathix
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?
Gabriel Dube
Outer Planets Alliance
#2 - 2014-05-14 07:16:10 UTC
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?


The cloning system is the only plot-device keeping capsuleers from being "mortal". So, yeah, if a capsuleer does get killed without having his brain instantly flash copied and 3D-Printed back into a valid clone, death suddenly becomes a serious matter. This actually does happen to a couple of npc pod pilots in mission chains.

It's also probably the reason why eggers rarely leave the captain's quarters. Blink

So we do know what is behind that darned door : potential mortality.

That being said, it would clearly be possible to have life-support augmentations or full-body prosthetics that would easily allow you to survive critical wounds, except brain damage.

Though you could always handwave it away with portable consciousness-transfer headwear or just Dust-like dropsuit tech.
Bagrat Skalski
Koinuun Kotei
#3 - 2014-05-14 09:20:01 UTC
Having implant in your head similar to what mercenaries on battlefield have and station receivers receiving your consciousness is the key to your survival.
Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#4 - 2014-05-14 13:50:43 UTC
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?


If you're not in your pod, you're dead. The end.
Willmahh
#5 - 2014-05-14 15:41:49 UTC
Owen Levanth wrote:
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?


If you're not in your pod, you're dead. The end.


Think of a clone as your hard copy last backup with the pod breach transmission being an incremental addition to the hard copy to gather the difference since the last "backup"


if you're not in your pod, you wake up with complete amnesia from the last time you updated your clone - essentially losing memories and experience..

Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#6 - 2014-05-14 16:57:27 UTC
Willmahh wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?


If you're not in your pod, you're dead. The end.


Think of a clone as your hard copy last backup with the pod breach transmission being an incremental addition to the hard copy to gather the difference since the last "backup"


if you're not in your pod, you wake up with complete amnesia from the last time you updated your clone - essentially losing memories and experience..



Funny you should mention that, this is how DUST-clones work. Sadly, your run-off-the-mill capsuleer-clones don't work like that. If you're not in your pod, your new clone will never receive the transmission with your mind, so your clone will never awake.
Willmahh
#7 - 2014-05-14 18:58:54 UTC
but your clone would have all the memories and skills up to the moment they were created/last updated, no?
Ghaustyl Kathix
Rising Thunder
#8 - 2014-05-14 19:07:08 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghaustyl Kathix
And then you have the very interesting Broker from Empyrean Age, and to a lesser extent Otro Gariushi, capsuleers who spend (or spent) most of their time outside of pods.

Owen Levanth wrote:
If you're not in your pod, your new clone will never receive the transmission with your mind, so your clone will never awake.
One of the capsuleer implants conceivably could tell if you're dead and send a signal to wake up your clone. Problem is, it probably doesn't image your brain at the moment of death for a seamless transition, so it might just be a regularly saved backup.
Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#9 - 2014-05-14 19:14:26 UTC
Willmahh wrote:
but your clone would have all the memories and skills up to the moment they were created/last updated, no?


No, that's DUST clones. (OK not really, it's more complicated. Your memories are in some sort of centralized database and get updated from your DUST-implants and on demand downloaded to a fresh clone.)

Capsuleer-clones are, like all clones when fresh and unused, empty shells. Only when the mind-scanner in your capsule scans your mind and sends the image back, does the clone receive your memories.

To contrast this with Dustbunnies, there's a nice little official lore story somewhere mentioning cases where DUST-soldiers were accidentally duplicated because of their implants: A DUST-mercenary abandoned and thought KIA is cloned again with the old memories still in the database, even if the "real" Dustbunny is still alive and well back on that old battlefield. As long as the old one isn't killed (in range of a receiver, that is), the new memories won't enter the central database.

Luckily those cases resolve themselves on account of DUST-clones having a life expectancy of around 5 years and the short range of their transmitters, so there is never any confusion of which one of you is real.

In short:
Capsuleer: Infinite transmitting range, memories can only be transmitted when you're inside your capsule. Your life expectancy is rather high, thanks to other upgrades. You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.

Dustbunny: Very short transmitting range, your memories are stored savely away from the battlefield, only occasional memory-upgrades are needed. You can die anywhere and still survive, sometimes with memory-loss. Your life expectancy is 5 years, though. Also technically speaking, only that bunch of stored memories is really "you".

Most of this is from EVE: Source, other stuff I've simply read up in lore-stuff like the chronicles.
Precentor Saggitus
Planet Express Transport
#10 - 2014-05-14 19:22:56 UTC
Willmahh wrote:
but your clone would have all the memories and skills up to the moment they were created/last updated, no?


One would assume that clones are updated somewhat in a character's "off time" so that when a capsuleer gets podded the data transfer isn't all of the capsuleer's memory at once. This is sort of the process behind jump clones, where the old clone isn't terminated, but rather stored in stasis and then re updated when necessary.

I believe in Empyrean Age, part of the plot behind Falek Grange's clone is that they didn't have time to update it before being forced to transport it and were in the process of updating it when the assassin attacked. One would also assumed that Otro could have been clone activated if all his back ups weren't in station.

Few people understand the psycology of a highway traffic cop. Your average speeder will panic and immediately pull over to the side. This is wrong. It arouses contempt in the cop heart. Make the bastard chase you. He will follow.

Gabriel Dube
Outer Planets Alliance
#11 - 2014-05-14 19:32:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Gabriel Dube
Willmahh wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
I can't remember where I read it (I think Empyrean Age), but I remember reading about how the cloning system works, when a capsuleer is podded. When it detects a breach in the pod, it flashes an image of the capsuleer's brain and transmits it through the stargates (basically routers), eventually reaching the medical bay where your clone is, to update the clone up to the moment where he died.

Which raises an interesting question; Since you don't have a system detecting when you're dead, what happens, lore-wise, if a capsuleer dies in station?


If you're not in your pod, you're dead. The end.


Think of a clone as your hard copy last backup with the pod breach transmission being an incremental addition to the hard copy to gather the difference since the last "backup"


if you're not in your pod, you wake up with complete amnesia from the last time you updated your clone - essentially losing memories and experience..



Then it is debatable wether or not it would really be "you". From what I understood, he whole point of the consciousness transfer as a central part of the cloning process, either with the Dust-like implants or the capsule's brain-flash imaging, is that your "consciousness" is never at two places at the same time. Clones are supposedly blank slates until their brains are reconfigured on a neural level to match your deceased body's neural architecture. Otherwise, you could have all sorts of cliché stories with clones being woken up prematurely and meeting with their "real" self...

I may be wrong on this, but I always thought the clone SP limit was more of a bandwidth thing between the emitter and the reciever (with potentially having to send the image of your brain through the stargate network and all), not an actual memory limit in the clone itself.
Ghaustyl Kathix
Rising Thunder
#12 - 2014-05-14 19:46:08 UTC
Gabriel Dube wrote:
I may be wrong on this, but I always thought the clone SP limit was more of a bandwidth thing between the emitter and the reciever (with potentially having to send the image of your brain through the stargate network and all), not an actual memory limit in the clone itself.

Nope, http://www.eve-wiki.net/index.php?title=Clone read the part here about medical clone grades.
Lochiel
Native Freshfood
Minmatar Republic
#13 - 2014-05-14 19:59:55 UTC
Precentor Saggitus wrote:
Willmahh wrote:
but your clone would have all the memories and skills up to the moment they were created/last updated, no?


One would assume that clones are updated somewhat in a character's "off time" so that when a capsuleer gets podded the data transfer isn't all of the capsuleer's memory at once. This is sort of the process behind jump clones, where the old clone isn't terminated, but rather stored in stasis and then re updated when necessary.

I believe in Empyrean Age, part of the plot behind Falek Grange's clone is that they didn't have time to update it before being forced to transport it and were in the process of updating it when the assassin attacked. One would also assumed that Otro could have been clone activated if all his back ups weren't in station.


I believe that this is incorrect, but I'm trying to find lore on Jump Clones so if you have a link I'd appreciate it.

The issue with Falek Grange's clone was that the final stages where interrupted. The data had been burned out of his brain, transfered to the clone facility and was in the process of being inserted into his new clone when life got interesting.

EVE: Source clearly states that the "burning scanner" technology that is used to read the brain state destroyes the brain in the process, takes a full and accurate snapshot, and thus allows the subject to maintain the stream of consiousness between bodies. The "Full and accurate" would not imply that only part of the memory is transfered.

I have no lore knowledge of how jump clones work, but I would guess that the tech is fundamentally different than a burn scanner... perhaps one that only works with more time and in a more controlled environment than even a Pod can supply.
Gabriel Dube
Outer Planets Alliance
#14 - 2014-05-14 20:01:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Gabriel Dube
Ghaustyl Kathix wrote:
Gabriel Dube wrote:
I may be wrong on this, but I always thought the clone SP limit was more of a bandwidth thing between the emitter and the reciever (with potentially having to send the image of your brain through the stargate network and all), not an actual memory limit in the clone itself.

Nope, http://www.eve-wiki.net/index.php?title=Clone read the part here about medical clone grades.


Then, there is a major problem. If your clone's SP limit is a hard memory limit, then your cloned body litterally cannot learn anything after reaching that limit and you would be incapable of remembering anything you experience past that point. As in, you would no longer be able to form any additional long-term memories. And then, regardless of wether you die or not, you would have to upload your "consciousness" to a new and upgraded body every time you reach the memory cap if you want to be able to do anything, since your original non-cloned body would be the only one able to have relatively unlimited memory. A hard memory limit on clones makes no sense, especially since being able to instantly make an entirely perfect map of your brain is necessary to know which fraction of your mind has to be sent to update the most recent backup in your clone. If you need to be able to do it all just to do part of it, why not do it all anyway?

Besides:
Quote:
It consists of two main technologies, one that allows an exact physical copy of an individuals body to be grown, faster than the original and then held dormant until it's needed, together with the technology that can download a person's memories into a blank brain.


From the same article. I think that this option makes a lot more sense.
CETA Elitist
The Prometheus Society
#15 - 2014-05-14 20:29:39 UTC  |  Edited by: CETA Elitist
Owen Levanth wrote:
[quote=Willmahh]You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.


each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.
Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#16 - 2014-05-14 20:52:57 UTC
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
[quote=Willmahh]You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.


each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.


No, this isn't how it works. See also the post right above yours. The clones' brains are blank until needed.
CETA Elitist
The Prometheus Society
#17 - 2014-05-14 20:54:06 UTC  |  Edited by: CETA Elitist
Owen Levanth wrote:
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
[quote=Willmahh]You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.


each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.


No, this isn't how it works. See also the post right above yours. The clones' brains are blank until needed.

My post and point are not affected by that fact.....well, fiction......
I'd also like to hear how it works in your opinion.
Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#18 - 2014-05-14 20:58:59 UTC
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
[quote=Willmahh]You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.


each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.


No, this isn't how it works. See also the post right above yours. The clones' brains are blank until needed.

My post and point are not affected by that fact.....well, fiction......


I'm sorry I have to tell you, but what CCP wants to be the lore in their game trumps your own weird ideas.
CETA Elitist
The Prometheus Society
#19 - 2014-05-14 21:00:32 UTC
Owen Levanth wrote:
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
CETA Elitist wrote:
[quote=Owen Levanth]

each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.


No, this isn't how it works. See also the post right above yours. The clones' brains are blank until needed.

My post and point are not affected by that fact.....well, fiction......


I'm sorry I have to tell you, but what CCP wants to be the lore in their game trumps your own weird ideas.

regarding the state of unused clones? I never said anything about them, and my post is completely compatible with them being blank when unused anyway. I don't think I understand what you're saying.
Willmahh
#20 - 2014-05-15 02:55:19 UTC
CETA Elitist wrote:
Owen Levanth wrote:
[quote=Willmahh]You are still you, even though some smartass philosophers could point out this is only because none of your other selves can be around to disagree with you.


each clone is a seperate instance of consciousness with modified memories. The new clone is now you, and the previous you is dead, with "you" being your unique psyche.

So it doesnt matter how many of "you" there are, since that does not infringe on one's ability to be you.



somehow you quoted something i didn't say.... :)
123Next page