These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A report into the Sebiestor brain and its Implications for Society

Author
Doctor Valate
Delve Medical Services
#1 - 2013-12-18 17:23:41 UTC
As some of you will no doubt remember, myself and associates have been conducting some research into the properties of the Sebiestor brain.

We are happy to be able to publish the report into our research, here, on the IGS.

So, here it is:

The Structure of the Sebiestor Brain and its Implications for Society

By Dr. Valerie Valate, director of research, Kaztropolis Imperial Neurophysics Institute, and Empress Synthia 1, Queen of Kaztropol.

Abstract:

Sebiestor persons are commonly believed to be innovative thinkers. This project set out to investigate some of the reasons behind this, with a view to determining ways of improving the Sebiestor population, and indeed, the rest of the human population, in accordance with the Scriptures.
The project used brain imaging tools, aptitude testing and DNA sampling in an effort to determine the relationships between genetics, background, brain structure and problem-solving ability.
An association between brain structure and educational background was found, as was an association between brain structure and problem solving ability.
No relationship was observed between genetics and brain structure.

Introduction:

The Sebiestor have long had a reputation as being innovative thinkers, with an affinity for engineering and problem-solving. The reasons behind this are unclear, but understanding of the causes of this would be of benefit to all of humanity, as it would allow the opportunity of improving the whole population, which is of course part of the divine mission given to Man by God – to improve humanity as a whole.
The Empress Synthia, patron of the Kaztropolis Neurophysics Institute, initiated this project, after some other research on Minmatar brain structures found an anomaly – a Sebiestor subject had a brain structure that was highly interconnected, and a better than average problem-solving ability.
It was hypothesised that Sebiestor people have brains that are highly interconnected, and this is the reason behind the reputation that Sebiestor people have.

Methodology:

A total of 534 Sebiestor volunteers were recruited through advertising in space stations and communications channels.
A substantial number of volunteers were recruited from Pator Tech School, and another large group of volunteers were recruited from the Republic University school of Dance.
A number of Sebiestor capsuleers were also recruited as experimental volunteers.

The volunteers were questioned about their family and educational background, before being subjected to testing. The first test involved a scan of the brain to determine its structure. The second test involved the subject performing numerous spatial reasoning and problem solving activities, activities which are normal for aptitude testing for a variety of careers. The third test involved taking a genetic sample of the volunteer.

Results:

Results can be seen in figures 1 through 4.

Figure 1 shows a brain of one of the volunteers, a Sebiestor capsuleer named “Anabella Rella”. The image displays areas of the brain that light up during the problem-solving exercises, demonstrating a wide range of activity, indicating a higher than averagely connected brain.

Figure 2 examines the relationship between brain structures and the educational background of the volunteers. Chi-square testing finds that with a probability of 0.0103, then the null hypothesis of having no relationship between educational background and brain structure can be rejected, and that there is a relationship between the educational background of a Sebiestor and the structure of their brain.

Figure 3 examines the relationship between brain structures and the genetic markers associated with Sebiestor tribe members. Four genetic markers have been associated with Sebiestor tribe members in previous research by Republic University projects. These particular genetic sequences are only found in Minmatar individuals with Sebiestor heritage. This project labelled them BD1 through 4, for “brain development”. Chi-square testing finds that with a probability of 0.2561, that this is insufficient to reject the null hypothesis that there is no relationship between genetics and brain structures.

Figure 4 examines the relationship between test scores and brain structures. 30 individuals were randomly selected from the volunteers from each of the three categories of brain structure, and their spatial reasoning and aptitude test scores were compared. T-testing found that with low probabilities, the null hypotheses that there were no associations between brain structures and test scores could be rejected, and that the alternate hypothesis, that a higher brain interconnection was associated with a higher test score could be accepted.

Doctor Valerie Valate. Not to be confused with the other Valerie Valate.

Doctor Valate
Delve Medical Services
#2 - 2013-12-18 17:24:03 UTC
Discussion:

Questions may be asked about how representative the sample population was. There is a high level of suspicion towards Amarrian scientists, because of political and historical concerns, which may have had an effect on how representative the sample is, compared to the wider Sebiestor population.
There are also questions regarding how accurate the scoring of the tests was, being administered to Sebiestor persons. The testing methods that are known to Amarr science, as laid out in the Scriptures may not necessarily provide accurate results when administered to non-Amarrian persons, because of cultural effects.
The lack of any clear genetic effect is interesting, as it has implications for the wider Sebiestor population, both inside and outside the Republic. No clear genetic link means that improving the Sebiestor population would not be a simple matter of selective mating. This may be a disappointment to some, such as those engaged in Sebiestor slave farming, while for others, such as Sebiestor freewomen, it means there is somewhat less pressure on them to find an appropriate mate – it seems as if any Sebiestor may be as good as any other, as regards being able to rear intelligent, ingenious Sebiestor children.
The apparent link between educational background and brain structure is important, as it shows that to reach a persons full potential, then a substantial investment in education is necessary. This means that authorities with the responsibility for a Sebiestor population should prioritise education of the Sebiestor children, and to provide a stimulating environment for an expecting Sebiestor mother. A developing child, before it is born, is sensitive to sounds from the outside – the Sebiestor mother should therefore be in an environment which stimulates the child. A highly educated Sebiestor mother is more likely to have a child with a highly interconnected brain, because she is more likely to be living in an environment that provides stimulation to the developing child. This has implications for the Republic, with respect to accommodating Sebiestor citizens from freed slave populations – they may face a poverty trap otherwise.

Conclusions:

The structure of the Sebiestor brain has a significant effect on that Sebiestor individuals ability to perform complex tasks.
The educational background of a Sebiestor family is important, as it has an effect on the brain structures of the future generations.
Educational investment should be one of the top priorities for any authority responsible for Sebiestor persons.

Acknowledgements:
The authors wish to express thanks to the many Sebiestor volunteers that contributed to this project, the city and people of Kaztropolis, the Republic University and Pator Tech School, and all others who assisted in this research.

Doctor Valerie Valate. Not to be confused with the other Valerie Valate.

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#3 - 2013-12-19 16:05:12 UTC
For SCIENCE!

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Telegram Sam
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#4 - 2013-12-19 16:34:57 UTC
An interesting article, with interesting conclusions. Questions:

a) Has it been determined whether Sebiestor tend to have more or less interconnectivity in brain activity compared to individuals of other Minmatar tribes? Or of other races?

b) The article suggests that interconnectivity of brain activity enhances the individual's capacity for innovative thinking and problem solving. Does this ability come at a price, i.e. a lessening in performance in other areas? It would seem (and this is a layman's assumption) that a brain or any other organic system has a finite number of resources. The way those resources are devoted should influence the system's strengths and weaknesses in various areas.

Does heightened interconnectivity (quickly utilizing many specialized areas of the brain) have the consequence of diminishing the individual's ability to utilize one particular specialized area at its full maximum potential? As a hypothetical example, does innovative thinking and talent at engineering come at the cost of diminished ability in the creative arts, athletics, or social/interpersonal adroitness?
Chinwe Rhei
Syn Interstellar
#5 - 2013-12-19 17:26:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Chinwe Rhei
Have you considered the fact that your sample of sebiestors may be non-representative because sebiestors with significantly interconnected brains may be clever enough to see through your ruse and would not risk their precious brains by participating in an Amarr-led study of questionable motives ?.
So your sample group could be self-selected towards gullibility, mental simplicity or suicide tendencies ?

Just curious about your methodology.
Slave A00073078
Northern Raven Reconnaissance Syndicate
#6 - 2013-12-19 17:47:18 UTC
Well thank god we got that figured out.
Doctor Valate
Delve Medical Services
#7 - 2013-12-19 20:23:12 UTC
Telegram Sam wrote:
Questions


A. The variability of people is such that it is difficult to say whether any group has a significantly different brain structure. There are a number of things that should be considered here though. Firstly, even groups with no real reputation for intellectual achievement, such as say Ealurians, have performed no better or worse than any other group when assigned intellectual tasks. Secondly, it is Written, in the Apocryphon, that all may become Chosen. If different groups had substantially different brains, then they would not have the same opportunity to be Chosen. Clearly then, despite what the Theology Council may claim, all people are created equal. God wills it.

B. If there was some lessening of performance in other areas, it was not something that was observed in the course of this study. However, a brain is an energy intensive organ. Possibly the increased energy requirements of a Sebiestor brain are behind the generally thinner build of most Sebiestor. Difficult to say without a proper study. I am sure the Republic University would have detailed anatomical data about Sebiestor people.

Chinwe Rhei wrote:
Have you considered...


Yes. It is one of the points in the Discussion. It is undetermined if there was an effect, and if that effect, if it does exist, influence the results to a significant degree.

I will let Anabella Rella respond to the implication that she is a gullible suicidal simpleton. Since she was part of the study and all.


Slave A00073078 wrote:
Well thank god.


Indeed.

Doctor Valerie Valate. Not to be confused with the other Valerie Valate.

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#8 - 2013-12-19 22:00:01 UTC
Chinwe Rhei wrote:
Have you considered the fact that your sample of sebiestors may be non-representative because sebiestors with significantly interconnected brains may be clever enough to see through your ruse and would not risk their precious brains by participating in an Amarr-led study of questionable motives ?.
So your sample group could be self-selected towards gullibility, mental simplicity or suicide tendencies ?

Just curious about your methodology.


I participated out of a sense of wanting to do something that could possibly advance our knowledge of the brain and also wanting to help bridge the gap between the Minmatar and Amarr nations. I consider myself neither gullible nor mentally ill. I approached the testing with a healthy amount of skepticism and took part only after certain conditions were satisfied. I was also well armed and had a coterie of secirity personnel standing by should anything untoward be attempted.

Trust but verify as the old saying goes.

Others may have participated for other reasons but I can speak only for myself, of course.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Leopold Caine
Stillwater Corporation
#9 - 2013-12-19 22:10:18 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
Chinwe Rhei wrote:
Have you considered the fact that your sample of sebiestors may be non-representative because sebiestors with significantly interconnected brains may be clever enough to see through your ruse and would not risk their precious brains by participating in an Amarr-led study of questionable motives ?.
So your sample group could be self-selected towards gullibility, mental simplicity or suicide tendencies ?

Just curious about your methodology.


I participated out of a sense ...



See, that's exactly what a sebiestor ms. Rhei described would say.
  • Leopold Caine, Domination Malakim

Angels are never far...

Stillwater Corporation Recruitment Open - Angel Cartel Bloc

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#10 - 2013-12-21 03:23:44 UTC
Leopold Caine wrote:



See, that's exactly what a sebiestor ms. Rhei described would say.


Nice try. I reject your lame attempt.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Synthetic Cultist
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#11 - 2013-12-22 11:18:14 UTC
The Purpose of Science is to seek Answers that raise Questions.

There are new Questions to be Answered in the Field of Brain Research.

I, Synthia 1, Queen of Kaztropol, am Pleased to have Furthered the Knowledge of Humanity through this Project.

Synthia 1, Empress of Kaztropol.

It is Written.

Karynn Denton
Astrometrica
#12 - 2013-12-23 10:54:20 UTC
Doctor Valate, in your initial appeal for volunteers you mentioned that part-Sebiestors would also be tested.

Were there any significant differences between those of part and whole Sebiestor descent?

I'd be grateful if you could word your reply in layman's terms, I'm not very good at science. Seriously, those white coats don't suit me.

Karynn Denton

Caravan Master

Doctor Valate
Delve Medical Services
#13 - 2014-01-08 00:58:50 UTC
Karynn Denton wrote:
Doctor Valate, in your initial appeal for volunteers you mentioned that part-Sebiestors would also be tested.

Were there any significant differences between those of part and whole Sebiestor descent?

I'd be grateful if you could word your reply in layman's terms, I'm not very good at science. Seriously, those white coats don't suit me.


Oh, terribly sorry for the delay.

The part-Sebiestor test subjects displayed a range of capabilities, scores were between the upper and lower scores recorded for pure-Sebiestor subjects, but we are unable to say if the results were significant or not, because of the small numbers that identified as only part-Sebiestor.

In laymans terms, We didn't have enough test subjects to say for sure, but we didn't notice any huge difference.

My recommendation, though, would be to seek a pure Sebiestor mate, if that was your concern. Oh, and try and be in a stimulating environment while your child develops, it's not as if that would do any harm.

Doctor Valerie Valate. Not to be confused with the other Valerie Valate.

Karynn Denton
Astrometrica
#14 - 2014-01-08 11:08:09 UTC
Thanks for the clarification Doctor Valate.

My interest was purely out of personal curiosity as I have a Sebiestor mother and Thukker father.

As for my choice of "mate" - a free spirit and the ability to make me laugh will get a man much further than bloodline will!
But thanks for your recommendation, all the same Smile

Karynn Denton

Caravan Master

Felsusguy
Panopticon Engineering
#15 - 2014-01-10 16:15:47 UTC
I must question the validity of this research. If these results can be replicated by multiple independent third-party research organizations using a variety of random group selection methods, I might be able to accept the claims. Until then, however, these results are not convincing.

The Caldari put business before pleasure. The Gallente put business in pleasure.

Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#16 - 2014-01-14 18:17:05 UTC
Dr Valate,

Thank you for your excellent article! I look forward to seeing it in my next issue of Kaztropol Neurophysics Review, and hope to see it at the top of the headlines.

Your work in this article touches on some of the work being done in our labs here at Lai Dai Research Biomedical and Cybernetic. I would like to ask if you are planning on expanding on the study to examine markers outside of BD1-4, specifically if you will be examining CREST, CREB, AJ2V/synpat, or Hedber? The question you are investigating seems heavily involved in dendritic branching patterns, and even though these genes are not unique to the Sebiestor, they may represent a high proportion of the population, leading to the popular stereotype.

Best of luck in your next project.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#17 - 2014-01-14 18:24:35 UTC
Felsusguy wrote:
I must question the validity of this research. If these results can be replicated by multiple independent third-party research organizations using a variety of random group selection methods, I might be able to accept the claims. Until then, however, these results are not convincing.

I'm a little confused, sir. Which conclusion do you not accept - that there is no apparent link between genes BD1-4 and neural interconnectivity, that there is an apparent link between education levels and neural interconnectivity, or that there is an apparent link between neural interconnectivity and test scores? Of all three, only the first might be considered contentious, but even then not enough to reject the results as unconvincing.

If you would like, we at Lai Dai Research Biomedical and Cybernetic would be happy to replicate the test with another random selection method and then publish the data. We will even offer a 50% discount to our standard lab fees, in the interest of fostering good relations with the KINI.
Doctor Valate
Delve Medical Services
#18 - 2014-01-27 23:30:33 UTC
Scherezad wrote:
Dr Valate,

Thank you for your excellent article! I look forward to seeing it in my next issue of Kaztropol Neurophysics Review, and hope to see it at the top of the headlines.

Your work in this article touches on some of the work being done in our labs here at Lai Dai Research Biomedical and Cybernetic. I would like to ask if you are planning on expanding on the study to examine markers outside of BD1-4, specifically if you will be examining CREST, CREB, AJ2V/synpat, or Hedber? The question you are investigating seems heavily involved in dendritic branching patterns, and even though these genes are not unique to the Sebiestor, they may represent a high proportion of the population, leading to the popular stereotype.

Best of luck in your next project.


Excellent, thank you.

There are as yet, no plans to expand the study to look at other genetic markers, though that is a very interesting suggestion, and perhaps a future project shall look at this.

As it is at the moment, I feel that, if there is no link between the uniquely Sebiestor genes and the brain performance, then it means that the other findings of our research gain importance for social policy for all populations, not just Sebiestor.

More projects are rarely a bad thing.

I am sure the latest research from your own organisation will prove interesting reading.

Onwards and upwards.

Doctor Valerie Valate. Not to be confused with the other Valerie Valate.

Gosakumori Noh
Coven of One
#19 - 2014-01-28 01:56:14 UTC
Doctor Valate wrote:
More projects are rarely a bad thing.


It's positively as if someone bred the Sebiestor to be a project. One question I often have, however, is why so many of those that made it up into space are so difficult to distinguish from Gallidoodles in more or less all behavioral respects.

Perhaps it was the Gallidoodles who bred them to be projects. Hmmm.
Makkal Hanaya
Revenent Defence Corperation
#20 - 2014-01-28 10:13:19 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
For SCIENCE!


You are science famous! Your brain is so awesome people write papers about it.

Render unto Khanid the things which are Khanid's; and unto God the things that are God's.