These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Does WAR make players leave Eve?

First post First post First post
Author
Cyborg 497
State War Academy
Caldari State
#241 - 2013-11-07 18:20:16 UTC
J'Poll wrote:
Cyborg 497 wrote:
J'Poll wrote:


So. The aggressors dont log on. HOW is that affecting the defenders. They cant kill you when not logged in. I have mined and missioned in the past while under a wardec. Add them to your watchlist, be on your toes when one of them is online. If they are all offline, what is different then not wardecced.

YOU are exactly the kind that is wrong with EVE. Expecting a complete safe enviroment and CCPs help all the time.

Let me repeat it again: CCP themself stated that highsec is NOT completely safe, just a bit safer. They dont want WoW inspace like you want. The stuff is working as intended. EVE is Darwinism at its best, adapt or die... A 100 man indy corp can wreck havoc to any PvP corp that decs them. They have numbers, they can build their own supplies. They just need a big pair of balls and tactics, but.most only care about 1 thing, their own carebearing size of their wallets


You are the typical wardec numpty that CCP have already made changes to Eve because of. First off, to misquote or misrepresemt the other person's point: I clearly stated we (I) do NOT want WoW-type protection in Eve.

The changes being proposed are small; incremental increases to wardecs. What is wrong with that!?! QuestionAttention It will cut out many of the frivolous wardecs made by numerous bored psuedo-PVP corps.

The other point was it was a hypothetical example: the general rule is not to mine during war: you can get around that ofc but it does mean organizing protected fleets.

And didn't you know that many PVPers do not login while they play alts who spy on their chosen opponent for vulnerable quarry? You're the kind of mug who would get caught with your trousers down, merrily mining away oblivious that they had you under observation the whole time!!

A small correction to wardecs would be a good rebalancing IMO. Greater safeguards to new players are needed to increase the revenue CCP get for this brilliant game!


Same response to you as the other idiot that can't do any research:

I don't wardec...Hell, I hardly undock.

But you think that increasing the money amount will hurt the wardeccers....good luck, you have even less braincells then I expected.

You do know that trading can give you billions a month as PROFIT. So, wardeccers have to get their ships from some place, guess what, the wardecs are not an income, they have alts and side jobs to provide it.

The only way a war will be fixed, if you get yourself and your lazy bum out of that mining ship / mission blingy ship and fight people.


And you do know that lots of people have MULTIPLE accounts.

PvP guys can play on their PvP guy while having an alt online to spy on you.

Same counts for you, you can mine while having an alt next door on the gate watching for War targets.


In the end, EVERY and ALL of your post can be summed down to 1 single TL:DR


*I'm a F-ing Carebear, I want risk free PvE...CCP HELP ME*



And you do know, subscription numbers are still INCREASING...which means that current system is doing just fine for new players to keep coming to the game.



I like how you take my answer, and repeat it as if you said it first.

I think you're the one who needs help....
J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#242 - 2013-11-07 18:20:46 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:

And how is changing the war mechanics going to help NEW players (who start in a NPC corp, who can't be wardecced).


Because many of them join player corps early. They are encouraged to do so at every turn: In the forums, in the help channels, by CCP, by other players, etc.


I know...I'm a NCQA regular, and on that same forum there is a great guide on how to find a PROPER corp.

And a PROPER corp will help you during wardecs

They will have counter measures, tips and tricks, PvP players to defend you etc. etc.


That's fantastic. It's too bad so many new players don't automagically know where to find the best resources. If only we had a properly updated official wiki with everything you need to know as a new player. But we don't.


You do know you can help out by answering questions in NCQA or Help

You do know you can submit articles for the wiki...


Ooh wait, neither of those increas your wallet thus you are not interested in that as a carebear.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Princess Bride
SharkNado
#243 - 2013-11-07 18:21:02 UTC
Velicitia wrote:

hint: you (or any EVE subscriber) can edit it.


Thanks for the hint. So why haven't you added your suggested resource to it yet?

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

Velicitia
XS Tech
#244 - 2013-11-07 18:22:48 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
Velicitia wrote:

hint: you (or any EVE subscriber) can edit it.


Thanks for the hint. So why haven't you added your suggested resource to it yet?


what resource is that?

I think you're confusing me with someone else.

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#245 - 2013-11-07 18:23:14 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
Velicitia wrote:

hint: you (or any EVE subscriber) can edit it.


Thanks for the hint. So why haven't you added your suggested resource to it yet?


Me personally, cause I'm too lazy to type everything out...

And don't backfire it....you brought up the outdated wiki...but YOU can also edit it.

You complained about it, not me or Velic

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Cyborg 497
State War Academy
Caldari State
#246 - 2013-11-07 18:26:18 UTC
Velicitia wrote:


Wardecs have already been made more expensive, and yet here people are whining that "hey CCP, make them more expensive and they'll go away".



I wish some of exponents of wardecs would represent the counter argument accurately rather than exaggerate to prove a point.
Princess Bride
SharkNado
#247 - 2013-11-07 18:27:28 UTC
J'Poll wrote:


1.) Sure there are ******** corps. Hence you do RESEARCH the corp before you join them. There is a great guide about that on the forums.

2.) UHM...ask...Help channel, rookie help, NCQA forums...not like there isn't a place where you can ask questions / verify the info you found etc.

3.) As I said, I know at least 8 or 9 guys that made their own corp as a new player. Of those 6 corps, 1 got wardecced, but only because he was after wardecs in the first place, as he wanted to PvP. The other 5 corps, up until now, never had a single wardec. Why, because they keep low profile.

Will they receive a wardec, sure they will, at one point. But you and the other whiners make it sound like you are wardecced the second you make a corp, which is NOT true.


--

Luckily you already showed that you are the idiot here...


1) You do realize that most new players don't read the forums right? Does this mean they are worthless players and should be excluded?
2) Help channel? LOL. More trolls there than in the forums. Is anyone who gets bad advice in the help channel a worthless player that should be excluded?
3) So the unlucky ones that get wardecced early, get frustrated, and quit are worthless players and should be excluded?

No, I am not a whiner. No, I do not make it sound like "you are wardecced the second you make a corp." And, more ad hominem please, you are just proving my point for me.

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

Pap Uhotih
Royal Amarr Institute
Amarr Empire
#248 - 2013-11-07 18:29:10 UTC
Cyborg 497 wrote:
Velicitia wrote:


Wardecs have already been made more expensive, and yet here people are whining that "hey CCP, make them more expensive and they'll go away".



I wish some of exponents of wardecs would represent the counter argument accurately rather than exaggerate to prove a point.


But then they would have to explain why declaring war on Goonswarm makes good economic sense when it really should be a pretty stupid thing to do.
Velicitia
XS Tech
#249 - 2013-11-07 18:29:27 UTC
Cyborg 497 wrote:
Velicitia wrote:


Wardecs have already been made more expensive, and yet here people are whining that "hey CCP, make them more expensive and they'll go away".



I wish some of exponents of wardecs would represent the counter argument accurately rather than exaggerate to prove a point.


I'm sorry, what?

I'm pretty sure I pointed out that 'decs have been made more expensive these days.

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#250 - 2013-11-07 18:32:18 UTC
Cyborg 497 wrote:
Velicitia wrote:


Wardecs have already been made more expensive, and yet here people are whining that "hey CCP, make them more expensive and they'll go away".



I wish some of exponents of wardecs would represent the counter argument accurately rather than exaggerate to prove a point.


I love how you cut the part out that proofs that Velic is right.

Wardecs are already MORE expensive then they were...please, quote that part too.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#251 - 2013-11-07 18:35:15 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:


1.) Sure there are ******** corps. Hence you do RESEARCH the corp before you join them. There is a great guide about that on the forums.

2.) UHM...ask...Help channel, rookie help, NCQA forums...not like there isn't a place where you can ask questions / verify the info you found etc.

3.) As I said, I know at least 8 or 9 guys that made their own corp as a new player. Of those 6 corps, 1 got wardecced, but only because he was after wardecs in the first place, as he wanted to PvP. The other 5 corps, up until now, never had a single wardec. Why, because they keep low profile.

Will they receive a wardec, sure they will, at one point. But you and the other whiners make it sound like you are wardecced the second you make a corp, which is NOT true.


--

Luckily you already showed that you are the idiot here...


1) You do realize that most new players don't read the forums right? Does this mean they are worthless players and should be excluded?
2) Help channel? LOL. More trolls there than in the forums. Is anyone who gets bad advice in the help channel a worthless player that should be excluded?
3) So the unlucky ones that get wardecced early, get frustrated, and quit are worthless players and should be excluded?

No, I am not a whiner. No, I do not make it sound like "you are wardecced the second you make a corp." And, more ad hominem please, you are just proving my point for me.



1.) I know and I have already adressed that part to CCP multiple times, they should add that to the NPE. Make people aware there is a special forum for new players.

2.) Help sucks, most of the time. Rookie help and NCQA, both specially made for NEW players (which your whole argument is about) are moderated quite strict. Hell, rookie help actually auto pops up every time you log in the first 30 days.

3.) Nope, but they can ASK for help. It's a MMO after all. Plenty of helpful people around besides the deucebags. And with the current and improved wardec mechanism you even HIRE assistance to help you defend.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Velicitia
XS Tech
#252 - 2013-11-07 18:36:53 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:

1) You do realize that most new players don't read the forums right? Does this mean they are worthless players and should be excluded?
2) Help channel? LOL. More trolls there than in the forums. Is anyone who gets bad advice in the help channel a worthless player that should be excluded?
3) So the unlucky ones that get wardecced early, get frustrated, and quit are worthless players and should be excluded?

No, I am not a whiner. No, I do not make it sound like "you are wardecced the second you make a corp." And, more ad hominem please, you are just proving my point for me.


1. That's unfortunate Sad. Perhaps they should.
2. Maybe I'm in a different help channel than you ... it's usually pretty much "correct" in the advice given to people. Yes, people will give snarky answers from time to time; but I have not seen where a blatantly wrong answer was not quickly corrected.
3. Don't see "worthless" player being thrown around by anyone by you. However, the "unlucky" people to have been on the receiving end of a wardec (and getting frustrated and quitting) should have known better -- generally when I see those "unlucky souls", they have assumed that EVE corporations are just as worthless as a guild in most other MMOs (i.e. just a group with a unique banner, nothing more).

EVE is very much like RL in the sense of "what you don't know can harm you" (laws are a good example -- not knowing that you're breaking a law does not exonerate you -- the judge pretty much tells you "too bad").

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

Princess Bride
SharkNado
#253 - 2013-11-07 18:41:11 UTC
J'Poll wrote:

And don't backfire it....you brought up the outdated wiki...but YOU can also edit it.

You complained about it, not me or Velic


So because I point out a problem means I am personally responsible for fixing it? And anyone who didn't bring it up is absolved from any responsibility? What a strange set of rules you adhere to. But either way, where the responsibility lies for the ****-poor outdated reference material isn't relative to the truth of its existence. New players have a helluva challenge before them in parsing, verifying, and learning what they need to know. They need time to undertake the task.

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#254 - 2013-11-07 18:47:58 UTC  |  Edited by: J'Poll
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:

And don't backfire it....you brought up the outdated wiki...but YOU can also edit it.

You complained about it, not me or Velic


So because I point out a problem means I am personally responsible for fixing it? And anyone who didn't bring it up is absolved from any responsibility? What a strange set of rules you adhere to. But either way, where the responsibility lies for the ****-poor outdated reference material isn't relative to the truth of its existence. New players have a helluva challenge before them in parsing, verifying, and learning what they need to know. They need time to undertake the task.


Nope, but the moment Velic said you can edit it, you jumped in the defence by saying why Velic didn't do it yet.

But why should Velic have done it already......

And new players already have a good source of information...It's called other older players.

I can name about 10 people from the top of my head who don't mind answering any question a newbie can have.
And there are actually multiple channels in EVE that if you did a little bit of research (and without research you won't get any where in EVE at all) will find that has helpful people in it.

So basically, if a new player shows a bit of interest in the game he is paying for and doesn't mind doing a little bit of reading about it, he WILL find a **** load of information and lots of helpful people.

If you are lazy and expect anything handed to you, sorry, that ain't EVE...And if you then quit, too bad, you won't be missed.

I rather have 500.000 subs of high quality then 5.000.000 and have a dressed down version of EVE where everything is handed to you on a silver platter and where 95% of the people are mindless teenagers (WoW can keep those people).

And I'm still puzzled how the whole wardec mechanism has ANYTHING to do with new player retention. yes, they can join a corp that sucks when being wardecced, does this mean the wardec mechanism is wrong, or that the corp they joined is wrong.

IMO, CCP should not change the wardec mechanism, but change the NPE in that it will include more about what a corp is, what is involved in being in a corp (little bit of info about roles, corp hangars, POS, wardecs, alliances, good and bad points about being in a corp vs NPC corp). As with the current NPE, that is something that is hardly explained. THAT would help NEW players...

Changing wars doesn't help new players, it helps risk adverse people that want high-sec to be totally risk free.

As you can say the same about scams. I often see new players leave because they got scammed and lost all their ISK.
Or ganking. Because new players leave because they didn't follow rule 1: Don't fly what you can't afford to lose.

Both of those things are also fundamental things that make EVE a different MMO, and for 10 years people have dealt with them. And for 10 years EVE has grown, so they all work.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Velicitia
XS Tech
#255 - 2013-11-07 18:58:05 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:

And don't backfire it....you brought up the outdated wiki...but YOU can also edit it.

You complained about it, not me or Velic


So because I point out a problem means I am personally responsible for fixing it? And anyone who didn't bring it up is absolved from any responsibility?



I believe the point J is making is that "since you saw it, how about you fix it instead of waiting for someone else to do it for you". He's already said his reasons for not updating it (i.e. "Lazy").

I barely look at the wiki, because I'm familiar enough with Eve to get myself killed without help Blink ... though there have been times where I've seen things wrong (broken links, poorly worded explanations) and have corrected it.

Quote:
They need time to undertake the task.


Exactly -- which is why rushing off and creating "3 man rookie corp 12,000" after a week and then bitching that CCP needs to change (list of things) to make EVE better garners so much negativity from the older players. They haven't been in game long enough to understand what it is they're doing.

Hell, a rookie in one of the public channels I'm part of did this ... myself and one of the other vets were like "WTF are you thinking!" (to which the rookie was like "meh, just a tax corp, if I get dec'd i move on, no biggie")

As far as getting in a ****** corp vs. a good corp goes, people make mistakes ... I could follow that "guide to joining a corp" to the letter and still **** it up and end up in a corp I don't fit in with that well.

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

Princess Bride
SharkNado
#256 - 2013-11-07 19:15:54 UTC  |  Edited by: Princess Bride
J'Poll wrote:

And new players already have a good source of information...It's called other older players.

I can name about 10 people from the top of my head who don't mind answering any question a newbie can have.
And there are actually multiple channels in EVE that if you did a little bit of research (and without research you won't get any where in EVE at all) will find that has helpful people in it.


I can name about 40,000 people by pointing you to the list of players in Jita local who would be happy to slit a newbie's throat to make a million ISK, or just for the lols. Eve is a PVP game. You can't have both the harsh, cold reality of Eve, full of sharks and scammers, and at the same time point to the player base as a primary source for valid information.

Quote:

So basically, if a new player shows a bit of interest in the game he is paying for and doesn't mind doing a little bit of reading about it, he WILL find a **** load of information and lots of helpful people.


A bit of interest? A little bit of reading? I think you misplaced the **** in your sentence.

Quote:

I rather have 500.000 subs of high quality then 5.000.000 and have a dressed down version of EVE where everything is handed to you on a silver platter and where 95% of the people are mindless teenagers (WoW can keep those people).


Sure, because you're a member of an "exclusive club" and you want to keep it exclusive.

Quote:

And I'm still puzzled how the whole wardec mechanism has ANYTHING to do with new player retention. yes, they can join a corp that sucks when being wardecced, does this mean the wardec mechanism is wrong, or that the corp they joined is wrong.


It has been suggested that wardecs deprive a new player of the opportunity to learn the basics of the game before they are expected to fight competitively against those who wardec their corp. This may cause some of them to become frustrated and quit before they get a chance to become knowledgeable players.

Quote:

IMO, CCP should not change the wardec mechanism, but change the NPE in that it will include more about what a corp is, what is involved in being in a corp (little bit of info about roles, corp hangars, POS, wardecs, alliances, good and bad points about being in a corp vs NPC corp). As with the current NPE, that is something that is hardly explained. THAT would help NEW players...

Changing wars doesn't help new players, it helps risk adverse people that want high-sec to be totally risk free.

As you can say the same about scams. I often see new players leave because they got scammed and lost all their ISK.
Or ganking. Because new players leave because they didn't follow rule 1: Don't fly what you can't afford to lose.

Both of those things are also fundamental things that make EVE a different MMO, and for 10 years people have dealt with them. And for 10 years EVE has grown, so they all work.


And for 10 years, people have dealt with a steady increase in policies and changes that help new players become grounded before they are thrown into the shark tank. And for 10 years EVE has grown, so they all work.

As for scams, in case you haven't noticed, CCP has tightened up a bit on what kinds of scams are allowed. But we're not talking about scams atm, we're talking about wardecs.

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#257 - 2013-11-07 19:20:41 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
J'Poll wrote:

And new players already have a good source of information...It's called other older players.

I can name about 10 people from the top of my head who don't mind answering any question a newbie can have.
And there are actually multiple channels in EVE that if you did a little bit of research (and without research you won't get any where in EVE at all) will find that has helpful people in it.


I can name about 40,000 people people by pointing you to the list of players in Jita local who would be happy to slit a newbie's throat to make a million ISK, or just for the lols. Eve is a PVP game. You can't have both the harsh, cold reality of Eve, full of sharks and scammers, and at the same time point to the player base as a primary source for valid information.


So, thanks for proving you are a ******

Cause of the **** people in Jita local, that means ALL others are the same.

You are the most stupid and ******** person in Jita I guess.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#258 - 2013-11-07 19:23:12 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:


It has been suggested that wardecs deprive a new player of the opportunity to learn the basics of the game before they are expected to fight competitively against those who wardec their corp. This may cause some of them to become frustrated and quit before they get a chance to become knowledgeable players.



Guess why they start in a NPC corp.

Guess...

Come one, even you with an IQ of a peanut should be able to figure this out.

If they choose to join a corp before completing the tutorials and NPE, that's THEIR choice, the game doesn't force them to join a corp at ANY point.

Take Oraac Ensor, he has been in the game for years, and never left the NCP starter corp.

If you join a corp, that is your decision...you can't blame game mechanics for that.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Princess Bride
SharkNado
#259 - 2013-11-07 19:26:08 UTC
Velicitia wrote:

Exactly -- which is why rushing off and creating "3 man rookie corp 12,000" after a week and then bitching that CCP needs to change (list of things) to make EVE better garners so much negativity from the older players. They haven't been in game long enough to understand what it is they're doing.

Hell, a rookie in one of the public channels I'm part of did this ... myself and one of the other vets were like "WTF are you thinking!" (to which the rookie was like "meh, just a tax corp, if I get dec'd i move on, no biggie")

As far as getting in a ****** corp vs. a good corp goes, people make mistakes ... I could follow that "guide to joining a corp" to the letter and still **** it up and end up in a corp I don't fit in with that well.


Why do people in this thread continually insist that their story about "this one time at band camp" has persuasive power? For the 5th time or so, your "cool story" about "this one noob I saw one time" is not a large enough sample to support any kind of persuasive argument. It is a logical fallacy. It has a name. That name is Hasty Generalization. In other words, no one cares about your story, fictional or fact, because I can just as easily cite another story, fact or fiction, to counter it because it reads exactly the opposite.

/rant

As for your first point about noobs who start corps too early... Are you suggesting that maybe it shouldn't be so easy to start a new corp? That's actually not a bad idea. Maybe instead of upping the cost of wardecs, they should up the cost of starting a corp.

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#260 - 2013-11-07 19:27:00 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:


As for scams, in case you haven't noticed, CCP has tightened up a bit on what kinds of scams are allowed. But we're not talking about scams atm, we're talking about wardecs.



Enlighten me what CCP changed about scams and what isn't allowed anymore...

Again, this whole thing was started by a carebear who wants riskfree bearing, under the false intention of "I want to help new players".

And talking about changes by CCP.

You, mr Peanut-head, should read up on the changes they made regarding new players:

Any action specifically targeting new players can be seen as a violation of the NPE rules.

So if a new player after 2 days start a corp and gets wardecced by some PvP group, he can petition them. As the PvP has nothing to gain from the wardec other then grief kills of new player frigates..

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club