These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

"You don't quote much Scripture..."

First post
Author
Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#81 - 2013-09-17 02:29:31 UTC
So much to get to! I should start with Confliktus, who asked about the Scriptures and their origins.

I think most people make the mistake of assuming the Scriptures are like other religious texts. That they are written or compiled at some time and then set in stone. That they are a sort of cypher by which to view everything in life. I think that has been almost universally true. The Scriptures are a bit more than that. It is, by definition, a living document made up of uncounted pieces.

Essentially, "The Scriptures" is the trademarked name for all the pieces of our history that pertain to God and his plan for the universe. That's quite a range of things, you might imagine. The Scriptures fill vast libraries and are not simply texts, but even more. The Scriptures include everything from stories of our origins, moral tales, early technical manuals, ancient pieces of pottery and architecture, early ship design, you name it. We've got it somewhere. Sometimes, a Theologian's library looks more like a museum or a junkyard.

These things are important, though. God very rarely interacts with the universe directly, and only slightly more commonly does He send members of His host. We were obviously blessed early on though, and chosen to carry His message through the cosmos. Very often, people wonder how, for such a "backwards" people we managed to get to most of the important space exploration and communication sciences first. The simple answer is that those are the most important ones. Those are the ones we needed to travel and spread the Word. So even early drafts of our first warp drives have tales that relate to the Scriptures. How our engine technology was derived from being able to harness the very essence of God's creation.

It can be anything from scrawlings on a engineer's napkin that reveals the nature of the universe or a carving on ancient architecture that tells a piece of a story about the reign of an emperor, but mostly, it is text. Billions, if not trillions of pages of text. Even digitized, it takes up multiple stories of server space. It is the complete work of our history over thousands of years, and every day we piece more of it together. It is a labor of love for our people. We look back on those first people who were not as blessed as we are with modern convenience and read about how the Lord gave them the answers to problems we still face today.

Really, that is the common thread throughout everything. Most cultures care only about their predecessors in a very narrow and disjointed way, but it is only by looking at the big picture that you can really see the works of God. The way He shaped our people and provided us with the answers to questions we would not need to ask for millenia. There are pieces of Scripture in the first Books that seem logical to us now, but that the ancients who were around at the time would have made no sense of. As we expand, everyone doing his part to read and understand his piece of the puzzle, we bring the bigger picture into focus.

That sounds brilliant, but in reality, it really is hard work for all involved. The truth is that the Scriptures are something one person could never learn. You can't see enough of the whole thing, from one person's perspective, to understand the nature of our Empire and the nature of God's wisdom. It's simply too big for anything but an entire Empire to understand. Some people read basic Scripture as part of their daily lessons, looking over them and re-reading them in their original context to see if there is something the millions who read it before missed. Some Amarrian theologians dedicate their entire lives to them and will do nothing but find and read Scripture their whole lives, knowing they will never understand the entire work alone.

In the end, that is the point. Everyone has their pieces of the puzzle that begin locking into place. We see Scriptures that refer to things in one place, and then will hunt for years to find where in that vast volume of works that its reference is. By making these connections, we learn more about the time and the place that these works were described in. We can piece together whole books by realizing that we have five overlapping copies of one book, none of which are complete alone. Some books are literally pieced together from hundreds of different pieces of text, art, and architecture assembled from fragments of our forgotten history.

It continues to this day, as well. The idea of what is "ancient" is creeping forward, and we are beginning to understand how God's work never ended. He still shapes the world and universe, guiding us towards a day when we will stand beside him looking down on his creation, having graduated, as a species, from the great test of life. He will call us brothers that day, and we will all walk beside him into the Kingdom of Heaven. Together, as one people, for all eternity.

That day may not come for millenia, but come it will. In the meantime, who is to say that our works now will not someday be called Scripture. Two thousand years from now, some work we may think is insignificant may come to bring understanding to some problem being worked on by our predecessors.

It is a humbling thought, that God is writing the Scriptures of two thousand years from now at this moment. His instruments are us, and his papyrus is the cosmos.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#82 - 2013-09-17 02:53:41 UTC  |  Edited by: Constantin Baracca
Anabella Rella wrote:
Once again Pilot Baracca you dismissed my comment with your supposition that billions would give up their freedom in exchange for guaranteed meals, shelter and education as a slave. When slavery is described in the manner which you did perhaps there would be hundreds of thousands of the most wretched and hopeless from all over the cluster who would accept it. Perhaps. I rather doubt that billions would do so because they have that option right now. Nothing prevents anyone from turning themselves over to the thousands of slave traders who operate in all sectors of space. I don't see any mass migration, even from the very worst areas of the major nations, to your imperial "utopia", however. I think that most people are intelligent enough to understand exactly what you're selling and want no parts of it.

I have no doubt that there are people who were liberated who, due to their conditioning as slaves, are unable to cope with having to think and act on their own as members of a free society. Those are the exception rather than the rule, in my experience at any rate.

As to Pilot Filth's credibility, it appears that I, a supposed "inferior", know more about the meaning of the Amarr imperial symbol than he does. His interpretation is incorrect. The correct orthodox interpretation can be found here.


Oh, I haven't dismissed your comment at all, Bella, and I apologize if you felt that way. I had intended to answer the question, but perhaps it was incomplete. In any case, as with everyone here, I would say to not worry about "Slaver Filth". One thing I think everyone likes about the Amarrian religion is that we preach that the world is full of distractions that divert us from real understanding. Whether or not we agree on what specifically those are, I'm fairly sure we can all agree that our interjecting friend is one of them.

I think you and I have different experiences in the Minmatar Republic. Perhaps it is a location problem, as I do tend to frequent the more, I suppose 'colorful', areas of the Republic. People who really are downtrodden and have nothing. I think you underestimate how desperate they are. The Minmatar Republic has sometimes forgotten that great structures are built on the backs of great infrastructure. With so much military spending in the Republic, domestic problems have yet to be addressed.

However, it is not as easy as turning themselves in to slavers. I wish it were. As it stands, the first problem is finding one. We sometimes forget the vastness of space, and Matari are very wary of re-entering the Amarr Empire with hostilities at the level they are at. Even if you find a slaver, you are not sure they are taking you to Amarr proper. Plenty are Sansha or Blood Raiders, and slavery there is quite a different beast than our version.

Most importantly, a point I think you are trying to get at but haven't spoken, is that there is no guarantee you would be in good care. One thing I think people conflate is that we almost assuredly failed as a society in your education if you are still Matari and have your own Republic. If we had used the bounties of the Empire properly, you would have been Amarrian by now, as many slaves of the House of Baracca have become. However, many Holders became lazy. I've previously mentioned this. If one does not look inward at their own failings, they are doomed to repeat their mistakes.

Therefore, what I have proposed is two-fold. There is the relations end, my end, where we need to get out and preach the Word ourselves. We can't just let the discussion on whether our system is good or not be defined by others and simply use our lasers to do our talking instead of the hard work of evangelizing. We have to go out and let people know that there is a better way for them, a way where we don't let you fall through the cracks. Where you don't have to look up at the top of a hole wondering how you will ever get out without it caving in on your head. They need to know us as more than just conquerors and boogie men, but as a people who are concerned with their value.

The other end, the internal end, is a much larger movement, spearheaded by the other clergy associated with me. They have two major problems. First, we are planning for millions and billions of refugees and converts, so there needs to be a system in place to make it as easy as you say. Show up, sign up, and we can get you to work! The second is more difficult. We need to identify good and bad Holders. Slavery is for education, as I've described. There are good families out there, who really do want to spread the Word and free people from the endless cycles of debt and despair they live in. We need to know where the newcomers are going and there needs to be a way we can monitor their spiritual health from the church. We, as a church, need to be involved in the process and divorce it from just a way to get cheap labor.

It will be a lot of work, but we've seen the cost we pay when we try to get something for nothing. We don't need to break slaves down with Vitoxin and pain. The Word is the salve of the universe! It energizes us and brings us together in a way people outside the Amarr Empire simply can't comprehend. Caldari do not love their state, Gallenteans their freedom, and Matari their tribe more than we come together to love our God.

We don't need better slaves, we need to be better Amarr. God chose us because He knew we could be the greatest people in the cluster.

It's time to rise up to the challenge and be the people He expects us to be.

The universe is watching.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#83 - 2013-09-17 03:16:33 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Father Constatin, bare in mind that the situation you are describing is a voluntary transfer. I would have to agree that if anyone went to the most downtrodden and impoverished folk in the cluster and made your offer the poor would take it. As someone who has seen refugees make futile attempts to grab onto the wings of aircraft in an attempt to escape their suffering I can safely say people will be willing to risk anything if it meant salvation, be it worldly or spiritually.

The problem here is that the Amarr didn't give people a choice, they forced it upon them. "Come with us or die" was the offer on the table. When the Gallente first met face to face with the Caldari we did so with an extended hand. When the Amarr first met face to face with he Minmatar your hands were on whips and guns.

Father Constantin, you are trying to spread your faith the way that your people should have done so in the first place. With an open understanding of all cultures and bringing to them your scriptures instead of slave collars. The problem with the Empire is that your ancestors did not take this approach. Instead of sending missionaries first, your Empire sent crusaders. While Empress Jamyl and balanced, open minded thinkers such as yourself are a sign that the Empire is starting to move away from this ideology, there are still a great many people running your government that think that the rest of the cluster should be enslaved, and that they should get on that job ASAP.


Thank you Fred, for essentially making the problem clear. I would say I disagree that the reason the Matari are angry with us is not because of how we met and conquered them. There are plenty of conquered people who are now Amarrians in the proper sense. Rather, I think our issues were based on how we handled the aftermath. Slave collars were not necessary for most slaves, so I've always only approved of their use in dire situations, when slaves are actually violent towards each other or potentially dangerous in other ways. I would not say that they would be necessary in the majority of cases. Plenty of people are willing to work daily if they know their basic needs will be fulfilled. As you mentioned above, this is a dream for many of the poor and downtrodden. You should not need a constant source of pain to teach if you yourself are an example of good teaching.

But really, the worst sin of ours, one that I strongly oppose and continue to oppose to this day, is Vitoc. That hideous method of control is wrong on every level. First of all, it inserts ANOTHER basic need you have to fulfill daily. It is horrific around the cluster to infect people with diseases regardless. But worst of all, Vitoc is a drug that dulls the mind and the senses. Dulled senses do not understand Scripture. Dulled senses do not learn. Dulled senses never come closer to being Amarr.

That this terrible failing is not gone yet is a matter of shame, and its banning should be a matter of time. It is antithetical to everything we are trying to teach, and those who are using it are teaching the worst trait of all. Addiction.

On the mention of our government, though, we revivalists who are truly looking to remake the Empire into a better leader in the cluster, the people the Scriptures mean us to be, is sitting in the top seat. Change is slow in Amarr, as I have previously recounted, but change is coming. Not change to something radically new, but simply to look back at the Scriptures and to realize their wisdom. Sometimes, we think we know better. That we can take it all as read that we know everything.

I think Jamyl is truly a religious empress, more than others. She has read the Scriptures and seen where we have abused our position of authority. She understands where we failed. The Emancipation is the first step in a New Reclaiming, a Reclaiming of ourselves and the entire cluster. It will be harder. We are working from below the ground to build a great temple to God; few trust us to build the Empire that spans the cosmos. But she understands that everything we work for will take centuries or millenia. The long, slow, hard way where growth is inevitable and assured is always preferable to the short, fast, easy way where growth is only dependent on the size of your fist.

What she must do is strengthen the interior of the Empire, to leave no crack in our armor, and then to spread the Word throughout the cluster. As you've said, people will see the wisdom and come to us. I don't think it will be in ignorance, though. I think people will evaluate their lives where they are, weigh what they gain from what they have compared to what they gain with us.

In the end, I don't think democracy is living up to its promise. It is a fundamental difference between our people that you see free choice in all things as good, whereas we view it with suspicion. Where you see great decisions making great people, we see when bad decisions ruin lives. In your space, it is acceptable for someone to really fall into a pit of drugs and hopelessness as long as it was their choice and mistake. In our Empire, that simply shouldn't be acceptable. It may mean they do not have as many choices in life. But with us, they will learn that life is full of distractions. Sometimes, the best way to clear you mind is to learn to live simply, without your conveniences.

In a way, I think that is precisely what is happening to those Holders who abused their positions. They treated slaves as conveniences. The Empress will see they learn to do without.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Makkal Hanaya
Revenent Defence Corperation
#84 - 2013-09-17 04:53:52 UTC
I am beginning to think that you don't quote much Scripture because that would interrupt your detailed pontifications on whatever subject has caught your fancy.

Render unto Khanid the things which are Khanid's; and unto God the things that are God's.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#85 - 2013-09-17 07:32:10 UTC
I see much within the borders of the Empire that needs to be addressed. If you only paid attention to this and kept your noses out of the territory of others, perhaps you wouldn't have the image problem that now besets you.

It is not going to happen. The minute that you move on either the Federation or the Republic and look like you're halfway to winning, the rest of the cluster will turn on you and shred you. Self-preservation demands it.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#86 - 2013-09-17 12:37:41 UTC
Makkal Hanaya wrote:
I am beginning to think that you don't quote much Scripture because that would interrupt your detailed pontifications on whatever subject has caught your fancy.


I am simply answering questions and concerns people have about my Empire. None other has truly had to justify its existence, for reasons mentioned previously. Amarrian scholars tend to be somewhat absorbed in their work and our business community really doesn't have the time to explain our culture. Between the military and the clergy, I suppose this should be a task for the latter.

People deserve to know who we are and what we stand for. We've been made to be dragons in the eyes of the cluster because, for too long, we've allowed the discussion about us to happen outside of our borders.

So some of the explanations may be long, but we're making up for lost time. I have so much to say because there is so little known about us outside the cluster. People got the information they wanted to reinforce whatever views they had and then stopped learning.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#87 - 2013-09-17 12:55:40 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
I see much within the borders of the Empire that needs to be addressed. If you only paid attention to this and kept your noses out of the territory of others, perhaps you wouldn't have the image problem that now besets you.

It is not going to happen. The minute that you move on either the Federation or the Republic and look like you're halfway to winning, the rest of the cluster will turn on you and shred you. Self-preservation demands it.


To be fair, Pieter, it hasn't been us invading the territory of others for a while now. What I have said before is that it shouldn't even be necessary. I've seen the domestic state of the rest of the cluster. There are millions and billions of souls for whom the democratic experiment has descended into class warfare. We wouldn't have to preach hard to convert them.

Once the poor underclasses of other societies have overcome their prejudices and flocked to the relative security and regularity of the Empire, it isn't going to be a problem we need to solve with invasion. Invasion would be counterproductive. Once people see the success of the system, how it answers the problems they thought incurable in society, they will more than happily join the example of the Khanid.

Honestly, in the long run, I think evangelism and ministry will be faster than military means. The Word of God spreads like wildfire and has a range farther than any other tool God has given to us. It also doesn't take nearly as many resources. It is all there, right now, waiting for use.

All it will take is for us to show how great we truly are. To have discipline and to follow the doctrines of the Scriptures. It's simply a matter of time after that.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Slaver Filth
Council of Apostles
#88 - 2013-09-17 21:38:00 UTC
Constantin Baracca wrote:
The Word of God spreads like wildfire and has a range farther than any other tool God has given to us. It also doesn't take nearly as many resources. It is all there, right now, waiting for use.
The bold an underlining above was added by me.

So let me see if I got this right, ...... you purport that the best way to spread the Word of God is by not quoting scripture?

"Child of Amarr seek not warmth in our cold hearts, we are the old serpent of New Eden and you must do your part, revel in our viciousness, we rule by venom and our strike is merciless, "

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#89 - 2013-09-17 23:10:08 UTC
Slaver Filth wrote:
Constantin Baracca wrote:
The Word of God spreads like wildfire and has a range farther than any other tool God has given to us. It also doesn't take nearly as many resources. It is all there, right now, waiting for use.
The bold an underlining above was added by me.

So let me see if I got this right, ...... you purport that the best way to spread the Word of God is by not quoting scripture?


An actual question, it seems. In fact, yes.

I went over this a while ago, actually, in the very first post of the thread. Anyone who studies the Word does know that actually quoting the Scripture is a very poor way to teach its methods. Quotes from the Scripture are too divorced from their original meaning and context when spoken aloud. To explain why any passage means what it means might take all day, if you have the background knowledge in the subject to know. Anyone who knows our Scriptures to any degree will agree that it is like describing a planet with a handful of sand.

I enumerated this point before, so I would urge you to go back and re-read that.

More to, I think, the point of the question, you may be wondering why I say to teach the Word without really quoting the Scripture. Imagine if a child asks why he should not steal a pen from his friend. The first thing to do is not to break out the legal code and read aloud from the section about theft. Not only will the child probably not understand it, not only will it take too long and impart too little information, but the child will only learn that it is illegal to steal. He will not necessarily, from that text, know why it is wrong.

Hence the point of ministry. Essentially, it is the function of a theologian to parse and research Scripture, to decipher and understand its meanings given the context of time, place, and events in which they were written. It is the function of a priest to absorb the raw data and be able to translate it into something that anyone, including a non-believer who has never heard of the Scripture in his life, will understand. No one knows what snakes refer to in any line of Scripture, especially since the meaning changed for a period of a few hundred years in which snakes were seen as animals to be admired and emulated. You don't want to spend two weeks discussing finance in the twelfth century of the Empire to explain that wealth in body is not worth the wealth of the soul. If you read the stories that speak to that though, you would need to. Otherwise, you wouldn't know why God would need a footstool, why we couldn't build one anyway, and what the Amarr needed limestone for.

In essence, quoting Scripture can confuse plenty of Amarr who don't know that particular part of historical context. It will especially seem bizarre if you are not raised learning it. For us Amarr who started reading Scripture the moment we were learning to read, it sometimes eludes us that people outside the Empire don't know the Riddle of the Bridge, so they have no idea what exactly is with all these people stopping at bridges and asking the Lord for guidance. It's too much information, not enough information, and none of the information they really need to understand us, God, and the faith all at the same time.

It's important to break the stories down into moralistic tales. If you ask a Gallente what is important about democracy, you can be sure they will not begin quoting their legal statutes on political taxation. They give you a synopsis and tell you what is good about the system. If they are responsible, they also tell you what is bad about it. Ministry and evangelism is precisely the same thing. You need to tell people what God wants, what God provides, and what God requires we give up. You need to boil Scripture down to the simple truths that God needs us to know.

In the end, when we have begun taking on students, they can learn Scripture. They will understand the basic metaphors and similes. Then, I think, quoting Scripture has quite a bit more meaning.

Until then, most of traveling ministry is about learning other cultures. Learning how to talk to them and describe our system in a way they will understand it. If everyone out there can simply say we are slavers and to live under us is to live under the whip, they have completely misrepresented what it means to be part of the laboring class of our Empire. But they are speaking the language of their people.

Simply, the Word is not literally words. The Word is a compendium of wisdom that has been given to us. Timeless wisdom of God that resounds as true throughout the ages. When we stumble, we look back and see where we have deviated. We recognize that we have been wrong and we react accordingly. We return to the rock of the Word. It isn't a set of bombastic slogans the way democratic political parties chant. It is a long, complex set of ideas that are meant to show us the path to becoming the greatest people in the universe. It also tells us how to spread those ideas to other people.

Once you translate everything into a language people understand, you would be amazed how many people love and understand it. Even better, it helps you to understand it as well.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Slaver Filth
Council of Apostles
#90 - 2013-09-18 20:42:03 UTC
Young pilot Constantin I pray in your zealous enthusiasm you don't equate your current efforts with the majesty of our sacred scriptures. You tread upon a dangerous path that meanders blindly into the realm of self delusional heresy.
Quote:
"The word of the Lord is pure,
It is a shield for the faithful,
Brought unto men by the Angels,
As a guiding light in the darkness "
- The Scriptures, Prophet Anoyia 8:15

You are a learned man who should well recognize the path you choose is replete with moral hazard.
Quote:
But those who turn away from his light,
And reject his true word
Shall be struck down by his wrath
For we are his retribution incarnate
His Angels of Vengeance"
- The Scriptures, Book of Reclaiming 4:45

I implore you to reconsider your decision to function as a self appointed expert of the interpertations of our scriptures, for the penalty for being wrong is severe.
Quote:
"The Wrath of God is Immense. His Justice is Swift and Decisive. His Tolerance is Limited."
- The Scriptures, Book I, The Code of Demeanor
Young pilot Constantin have you completely considered the peril you risk on your path of pontification?

"Child of Amarr seek not warmth in our cold hearts, we are the old serpent of New Eden and you must do your part, revel in our viciousness, we rule by venom and our strike is merciless, "

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#91 - 2013-09-19 01:09:11 UTC
Slaver Filth wrote:
Young pilot Constantin have you completely considered the peril you risk on your path of pontification?


I have, indeed. Actually, more to the point, the Theology Council has. I was appointed as a spiritual ambassador by a bloc of accardinated bishops as prescribed by the Council's decrees. I would not be out here doing what I do without permission. It was agreed that I be one of the spiritual representatives as an exploratory gesture. My ministry beyond the borders of the Empire has recorded incredible results. We are converting, for the first time in recent history, deep in non-Amarrian space. The Word is being preached in colonies of ours that cannot be destroyed.

One of the reasons I was accorded this great position was because I have a great deal of experience in ministry. The methods I use are not only approved, it is the way we all preach the Word. There have been quite a few Amarrians beyond our space, military and researchers alike. However, the discipline of ministry is somewhat arcane to those of us who have forgotten what it was like to learn the Word.

I could, if I wanted, teach parts of Scripture every single day on this board as if it were lessons. It would, however, be counterproductive in most cases. One thing you quickly learn in my profession is that even if you could memorize the whole of the Scriptures back to front, that does not necessarily mean you would understand them. Of the two, memorization and understanding, the latter is by far the most important. Rampant quoting of certain pieces of Scripture have led to people completely misunderstanding the entire point of our culture.

Even the EVE University organization only has a handful of passages. Maybe 50 quotes, mostly taken from our ships invocations. It is by those words that most people in the cluster know us.

That is what I was sent to rectify. I was sent to minister to the stars the same way I ministered to my diocese on Amarr Prime. It is important that we have our say in the conversation, so that others who dislike us cannot paint us with the same brushstroke as their hate.

My results are beginning to show. Not only do we have dozens of small, stable colonies in other empires' space, we are preparing a new trial program. An education program that is voluntary. With my growing cadre of priests, we have fanned out to seek out those that other empires left behind. People who are aimless and wandering, seeking purpose and direction in life. People who want to escape their life of cyclical sin.

Imagine a voluntary conversion program. Something no other empire has the moral authority to stop. Imagine our Empire swelling with believers who will finally escape the torment of their misdirected lives and learn discipline through work. More people who will come to read Scripture and finally understand these bits we are all quoting.

All without firing a single shot or losing a single life from our Navy. It isn't just a possibility. It's becoming a reality. We are beginning to prepare a list of names, people who are ready, right now, to emigrate and begin the program. All that is required is for the Theology Council to examine our request and green-light a trial program. We need the infrastructure to handle these people, because the lack of infrastructure and stability is precisely why they are coming.

How many millions are living in cycles of drugs, debt, and poverty that we can forge into contented, educated, productive citizens? We must be prepared to teach when they come. Not if. When.

Even if you do not understand or disapprove of my ministry, I am a professional. This is what I have been trained to do, nearly from birth, and I am very good at it. I was performing sacraments at six years old. I wrote my first theological thesis at ten. I performed my first sermon at twelve. I was hearing confessions at fourteen. I was leading a diocese as a bishop at twenty-six. I even taught a private lesson to the Royal Congregation, at the Imperial Adviser's request.

Even if you don't trust me or my credentials, trust the Theology Council has evaluated me. They agreed to fund this ministry of mine for a reason.

I know what I am doing.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#92 - 2013-09-19 15:30:45 UTC
This voluntary approach of yours sounds all well and good but, I'm still not sold. The way you "recruit" the down and out is very similar to the way terrorist organizations do; finding the most wretched and hopeless and offering them the chance to be a part of something. These newly converted recruits then become fervently devoted to you and your cause and can be used as tools/weapons against the societies that they feel abandoned them.

At any rate I have a couple more questions:

What happens with those who, after joining you discover that they're now slaves and want out or, for whatever reason wish to leave? Are they allowed to?

What happens to those of us who, in spite of all your ministry, still refuse to convert to your religion and culture? Will we be locked in a forever war against your hordes of newly minted zombie zealots in addition to the 24IC and Imperial Navy?

I honestly wouldn't have a problem with your peaceful missionary work if it weren't for the fact that you continue to insist on the "reclaiming" of the rest of the universe. It also strikes me as being hypocritical. If your deity created us all and imbued us with free will wouldn't it be logical to accept the fact that some of us would use said will to reject the creator? Why not accept that fact, respect that we're using the gift of free will as was intended by this creator and leave us alone?

As another pilot pointed out, you are sowing the seeds of your own destruction by continuing your "reclaiming". When the other nations finally wake up to the realization that the Empire is a real threat to their survival they will band together to destroy you as they did with Kuvakei. Only this time they'll have learned from their mistakes of dealing with him and will make certain that nothing remains of Amarr to ever threaten them again.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#93 - 2013-09-19 16:45:32 UTC
I'll answer those questions largely in order, Bella, but I feel I may need to move around a bit. If anything isn't made clear, do let me know and I will try to clarify.

I think your first point about recruitment somewhat answers a question you made later. Think about those two points together. What happens if you don't convert? Why are we recruiting the down-and-out who feel that their societies abandoned them? Essentially, the point is that your society isn't any more fair or humane than ours, the government tends to use words like "choices" to absolve themselves of responsibility. You have the choice to go to whatever school you want. Even if that were true, what it actually means is that the government does not need to provide you your education. You have the choice to work wherever you want. That means the government is not responsible for your employment or your income. You have the choice to live wherever you please. That also means the government is not responsible for keeping you out of the rain in a shipping crate. People will be informed of what they are giving up, the right to live, work, and learn whatever it is they want. In fact, I have vigorously questioned whether they are truly prepared for doing so. In return, I am saying that we will take responsibility. We will house, employ, and teach them.

I think you perhaps value choice a bit more than the man the station employs to recharge your capacitor. In fact, I am willing to bet that he is largely worried about money more than he values it. He wonders how his children will get an education if he can't afford it. How does he get them out of the cycle of gang warfare if he can't limit their choices of what they are doing? It is those people who look up at people who could afford the tools they needed to make it far in your society and resents it. It is to him we come and say that there is another way. That free choice in all aspects of your life isn't always worth what you pay for it. Would you like to be trained to do something, go out every day and do it, and come back to a place of shelter that you never have to worry about affording? Those promises can't be made by free societies, who can't even save their people from rampant domestic drug and crime problems. Yet these are the people all societies depend on, at their core. Even yours.

If your working class disappears for our space, you will self-regulate. People who used to do more attractive labor will become the new bottom of society. They will look for simpler and more sure ways to live. They will look for purpose.

I might be wrong, but I highly doubt it. I've seen some sorry states of slavery, but I've never seen anything as bad as a Gallente halfway-house or a Minmatar ghetto slum. It's obvious that nobody is thinking about them and nobody wants them.

We do. We tell them point-blank they will have their choices stripped away. They will not be able to pick what we train them to do or what they do. They will need to trust in us. I thought it would take decades to build the trust in our Empire outside of our borders to make it work. I've found there are a few million people who already dislike their home empires more than they fear us. They already are slaves. They just aren't often very well-paid or well-maintained slaves where they are.

In the end, you seem to want to raise the specter of our Navy or your traditional enemies. I think, in the end, I am a soldier in the New Reclaiming. While you spend your time and assets fighting our soldiers, you've neglected your own people. I will take them away from their poverty and reclaim them for the Empire. Better than that, I will do it without ever firing a shot. Best of all, if they come with me willingly, there isn't a single thing anyone can do about it. If you could band together to save a people you don't value, I wouldn't be able to sign a few hundred names at every homeless community. You would have taken care of it already.

The only way you would be able to stop me is if you turned inward and created a better life for all of your people. I highly doubt you can do that. You're too afraid of our Navy to spend anything less than exorbitant amounts of money trying to fight us.

In the end, your own worst enemy is you. To give every single person access to the basic necessities we can promise slaves, you would need to become us.

In the end, I think you will.

My, I suppose I will need another post to answer the doctrinal question.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#94 - 2013-09-19 17:04:16 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
This voluntary approach of yours sounds all well and good but, I'm still not sold. The way you "recruit" the down and out is very similar to the way terrorist organizations do; finding the most wretched and hopeless and offering them the chance to be a part of something. These newly converted recruits then become fervently devoted to you and your cause and can be used as tools/weapons against the societies that they feel abandoned them.

At any rate I have a couple more questions:

What happens with those who, after joining you discover that they're now slaves and want out or, for whatever reason wish to leave? Are they allowed to?

What happens to those of us who, in spite of all your ministry, still refuse to convert to your religion and culture? Will we be locked in a forever war against your hordes of newly minted zombie zealots in addition to the 24IC and Imperial Navy?

I honestly wouldn't have a problem with your peaceful missionary work if it weren't for the fact that you continue to insist on the "reclaiming" of the rest of the universe. It also strikes me as being hypocritical. If your deity created us all and imbued us with free will wouldn't it be logical to accept the fact that some of us would use said will to reject the creator? Why not accept that fact, respect that we're using the gift of free will as was intended by this creator and leave us alone?

As another pilot pointed out, you are sowing the seeds of your own destruction by continuing your "reclaiming". When the other nations finally wake up to the realization that the Empire is a real threat to their survival they will band together to destroy you as they did with Kuvakei. Only this time they'll have learned from their mistakes of dealing with him and will make certain that nothing remains of Amarr to ever threaten them again.


If God intended there to be no free will, why do we have it? Not an uncommon question, honestly. I think it comes from a natural misunderstanding of what free will is.

To be what we are, to develop and learn, we require a few things. Drive, curiosity, intelligence. These basic elements are what makes up the combination that we call free will. In essence, free will is an incomplete version of discipline. Free will would indicate that we are our own masters and that the world works however we feel like it should. The simple fact is, it doesn't. Temperance is meant to be added to free will to create rationality.

For example, let's say you decided you wanted to inject boosters to "free your mind" into your veins. Free will certainly allows you to do that. You have the choice to do it. It isn't a very good idea, but the concept of free will isn't concerned with whether things are good or bad ideas. In fact, if you find a good idea and demand everyone follows it, it becomes a law. Laws are inherently what free will should lead to, to order and regularity. If something is a good idea, why shouldn't everyone do it?

In the Amarrian Empire, this is taught as a matter of course. You may have to make rapid decisions in combat or during a shopping trip, but in any moment where you have any time? You ask others. You see whether your way of thinking has merit. We aren't a capricious people because we really do value the opinions of experts. When I thought up the idea for this ministry, I didn't hop into a ship to do it. I took the idea to the Theology Council and my superiors. I let them examine my proposals. In the end, they wanted a trial with just a few of us to see our results, so that damage would be limited if I was wrong. When my results were confirmed to be positive, I was given more funds and personnel to effect a larger study.

With free will, I would have traipsed off into Matari space and been probably killed in a few minutes. With my people and the law behind me? I know this way is righteous, and I can safely say that it's not just me thinking this. It's us. We think this is the way forward.

So why do we have free will? Because it is made from a few ingredients you need to make good decisions, but with a few key ingredients missing. You can't make good decisions if you can't make decisions at all. That is why we are provided with it by God. You can choose to make bad decisions on whims, but that involves a fundamental lack of discipline. Most people who reject God do so because temperance isn't always easy, pleasant, or self-gratifying. Sometimes, you need to work when you don't feel like it, to do things you don't want to do because someone needs it to be done. Sometimes, you don't get to do something you want to do on vacation because you need to study to better yourself. Sometimes, you don't get to buy yourself a cool ship on credit because you'll not be able to pay it back.

To lose that gratification, to not make your own success or happiness the meaning of your life, is the true test of us humans.

I'm perfectly happy to leave any individual alone who doesn't want to learn that lesson. I will as long as I know I won't suffer the consequences of their poor decision making.

I think if you wanted to be left alone, though, you should largely reciprocate. The last massive invasion between us wasn't ours. I may not be violent or retributive, but conservative factions of my government certainly don't need much more evidence that the Minmatar Republic are not necessarily or universally benign neighbors.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Slaver Filth
Council of Apostles
#95 - 2013-09-19 18:41:30 UTC  |  Edited by: Slaver Filth
Anabella Rella wrote:
This voluntary approach of yours sounds all well and good but, I'm still not sold. The way you "recruit" the down and out is very similar to the way terrorist organizations do; finding the most wretched and hopeless and offering them the chance to be a part of something. These newly converted recruits then become fervently devoted to you and your cause and can be used as tools/weapons against the societies that they feel abandoned them.

At any rate I have a couple more questions:

What happens with those who, after joining you discover that they're now slaves and want out or, for whatever reason wish to leave? Are they allowed to?

What happens to those of us who, in spite of all your ministry, still refuse to convert to your religion and culture? Will we be locked in a forever war against your hordes of newly minted zombie zealots in addition to the 24IC and Imperial Navy?

I honestly wouldn't have a problem with your peaceful missionary work if it weren't for the fact that you continue to insist on the "reclaiming" of the rest of the universe. It also strikes me as being hypocritical. If your deity created us all and imbued us with free will wouldn't it be logical to accept the fact that some of us would use said will to reject the creator? Why not accept that fact, respect that we're using the gift of free will as was intended by this creator and leave us alone?

As another pilot pointed out, you are sowing the seeds of your own destruction by continuing your "reclaiming". When the other nations finally wake up to the realization that the Empire is a real threat to their survival they will band together to destroy you as they did with Kuvakei. Only this time they'll have learned from their mistakes of dealing with him and will make certain that nothing remains of Amarr to ever threaten them again.
"The Amarr people came into the world and the world came into being.
Our illustrious ancestors freed their souls from the evils of the old.
world and created a new one.
The great Amarr Empire was founded to cultivate the spirit of man.
To do so the enemies of the outside had to be defeated and the enemies of the inside controlled."
- The Scriptures, Book I 1:14


The free will of Man does not get to overpower the Will of God. The efforts against Kuvakei would not have been possible without the accord of the Amarr Empire, the Gallente, the Minmatar, and the Caldari shall never stop distrusting each other enough to stand united against us, and everyday we gather our strength.

Young pilot Constantin underestimates the power of the living Word of God and places all of his form of "faith" in the power of his own words to seduce the lost and the losers of New Eden into voluntary conversion, for the tiny amount of people that this approach has even the slightest possibility of success with perhaps the results will yield a few more loyal but confused hunting animals like Eran. For the time being, he is being tolerated, as long as he keeps such words far from the borders of the Amarr Empire. Nonetheless he has been officially notified herein the path he treads may well lead him to excommunication and his name being struck from the "Book Of Records", and as such I urge him to repent and avoid this calamity.

But heed my words the True Amarr and the Amarr Empire will not abandon scripture to seduce those God gave us dominion over.

"I give to you the destiny of Faith,
And you will bring its message to every planet of every star in the heavens:
Go forth, conquer in my Name, and reclaim that which I have given."
- The Scriptures, Book of Reclaiming 22:13


God's will shall always propel the Amarr Empire to secure what is meant to be, and the Word of God as given to us in "Scripture" shall always guide and compel the Amarr Empire to continue as God meant for us, his chosen to be. I am supremely confident the sweet sonnets of young pilot Constantin will not persuade the Amarr Empire to abandon God's will and word to follow him and the band of dregs he enlists in his fools errand.

We are the chosen, Amarr shall never abandon it's true faith and destiny.

"Child of Amarr seek not warmth in our cold hearts, we are the old serpent of New Eden and you must do your part, revel in our viciousness, we rule by venom and our strike is merciless, "

Gabriel Darkefyre
Gradient
Electus Matari
#96 - 2013-09-20 12:04:02 UTC
Constantin Baracca wrote:

In the end, you seem to want to raise the specter of our Navy or your traditional enemies. I think, in the end, I am a soldier in the New Reclaiming. While you spend your time and assets fighting our soldiers, you've neglected your own people. I will take them away from their poverty and reclaim them for the Empire.


Where they can live away their lives in a different kind of Poverty. Don't get me wrong, I'm not belittling your beliefs in this, however the idea that the Empire is some magical place where everyone has enough to eat and a roof over their head doesn't match up with the reality for many of the people in your Empire.

To Quote from Official Sources on the subject of your Commoner Class.

"However, a fairly large portion of the Empire would fall under the classification of working poor and struggle along in poverty. This portion is not as large as in the pre-tribal Republic, but is significantly larger than found in the Gallente Federation. These commoners often struggle to make ends meet and may bounce between low-paying jobs and unemployment. There is little social welfare in the Empire to care for those who meet hard times, thus many wind up homeless or reliant on family, putting additional financial strain on otherwise adequately compensated commoners.

For the most abject poor commoners in the Empire, including the homeless and those suffering from mental illness or physical deformity, living conditions can often be worse than slaves."

May I suggest that your time may be better spent getting your own house into order before complaining about the state of the houses of your Neighbours?
Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#97 - 2013-09-20 12:35:03 UTC
Gabriel Darkefyre wrote:
Constantin Baracca wrote:

In the end, you seem to want to raise the specter of our Navy or your traditional enemies. I think, in the end, I am a soldier in the New Reclaiming. While you spend your time and assets fighting our soldiers, you've neglected your own people. I will take them away from their poverty and reclaim them for the Empire.


Where they can live away their lives in a different kind of Poverty. Don't get me wrong, I'm not belittling your beliefs in this, however the idea that the Empire is some magical place where everyone has enough to eat and a roof over their head doesn't match up with the reality for many of the people in your Empire.

To Quote from Official Sources on the subject of your Commoner Class.

"However, a fairly large portion of the Empire would fall under the classification of working poor and struggle along in poverty. This portion is not as large as in the pre-tribal Republic, but is significantly larger than found in the Gallente Federation. These commoners often struggle to make ends meet and may bounce between low-paying jobs and unemployment. There is little social welfare in the Empire to care for those who meet hard times, thus many wind up homeless or reliant on family, putting additional financial strain on otherwise adequately compensated commoners.

For the most abject poor commoners in the Empire, including the homeless and those suffering from mental illness or physical deformity, living conditions can often be worse than slaves."

May I suggest that your time may be better spent getting your own house into order before complaining about the state of the houses of your Neighbours?


As a matter of fact, we have. Or at least, I've proven the method works on the Amarr themselves.

You see, I am the evangelistic wing of this experiment, but a much larger portion operates in our own space. This whole process started some years ago, when my archbishop (and grandmother) decided to look into the policies we had developed and how they had affected the Empire. Some called her a radical at the time, but inevitably they saw the wisdom of the endeavor.

Our travels into the space of others has netted some interesting information, but none more so than a Caldari theorist who called for wiping out wages and introducing a very rigid work/study/leisure schedule. Most Caldari thought that was a little high-minded and theoretical, that they would never be able to phase out the wage system. However, we did not have that problem. We intended to use that schedule: ten hours of work, four hours of study, two hours leisure, to sort of standardize servants' lives and get them used to regularity. We included a day with eight hours of study and no work in order to give people a chance to process the Scriptures.

However, we could not try this first on foreigners. They have no concept of God or often how work can improve their outlook on life, at least the sorts of people who would be interested in our rehabilitation program. We also had a problem that our list of interested parties during the ministry was expanding. In full swing, this program could easily draw thousands of people a day. We needed to make sure it worked first. So we tried it a few years ago on the impoverished from our own Empire. We offered to forgive all of their debts and enrolled them into the program. We gave them everything they needed as far as medicine and mental health, then sent them into the fields (this project was a wheat field).

It's amazing how antisocial behavior and mental illness can be mended simply by giving people a sense of purpose in life. The results were astounding, and the project has expanded since then.

It was this that has given us the backing we needed to put together the first work program for foreigners. I just received word that we have the green light for the foreign recruitment project, this one a production facility for fittings. As soon as the facilities and manufacturing centers are built, probably within a few months to a year, we will pick up our first batch of volunteers.

We're very excited to see how this works. If God's love can penetrate even these hearts, how much could it do for the rest of the cluster? We've especially been receiving word from former slaves who will enter the program so long as we can institute some kind of standards of behavior on the part of the Holders they may end up serving.

Honestly, I couldn't agree more. That could take more wrangling. In the meantime, at least I know the family that will be hosting the foreign project has an excellent reputation in re-education and assimilation, with a low rate of recidivism.

These are just the early stages, but it barely needs funding right now. The wheat field is now paying for itself AND our next domestic re-education project.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Gabriel Darkefyre
Gradient
Electus Matari
#98 - 2013-09-20 13:49:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Gabriel Darkefyre
Perhaps I didn't make my point clear. While I can understand if you have successfully trialled this program on your own people the fact is it remains exactly that: a Trial. To be frank, there's a lot of Empire out there, around 40% of the current inhabited worlds by all accounts. That's a lot of room for a lot of Dispossessed Amarrian Citizens.

What I am suggesting is that until your Program is in place to cover the Entire Empire, you should not be looking towards expanding it into the space of your Neighbours.

I wish you luck in assisting your own Citizens through this. Forgive me for not wishing you the same in your interference in the internal workings of other Territories.
Constantin Baracca
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#99 - 2013-09-20 14:58:26 UTC
Gabriel Darkefyre wrote:
Perhaps I didn't make my point clear. While I can understand if you have successfully trialled this program on your own people the fact is it remains exactly that: a Trial. To be frank, there's a lot of Empire out there, around 40% of the current inhabited worlds by all accounts. That's a lot of room for a lot of Dispossessed Amarrian Citizens.

What I am suggesting is that until your Program is in place to cover the Entire Empire, you should not be looking towards expanding it into the space of your Neighbours.

I wish you luck in assisting your own Citizens through this. Forgive me for not wishing you the same in your interference in the internal workings of other Territories.


I suppose this is something of a dissonance between us and the rest of the empires. If I see people languishing in poverty and suffering, I don't think it is suddenly not my business to help simply because they do not share my parentage. There are parts of our society, in fact much larger factions, who are handling the domestic issues. My job is to travel and minister to the rest of the cluster (hence why you see and hear from me).

Our programs cannot simply be made to fix our problems and then ignore the problem in the rest of the cluster. Essentially, the process in other areas is to allow people to manage their own lives even if they do not have the tools or skills to do so. Instead of enforcing education of the skills and providing the basic tools, it seems the easiest thing to do is to keep them locked in a cycle of debt until they cannot pay, then repossess everything they have. If someone tries to go outside of the system and breaks the law, they are sent to prison.

We Amarrians are not factionalist. I know how this almost universally is received as some sort of hostile invasion every time we do something outside of our systems, but I do not think of people as "your poor" as distinct from "my poor". There is only a system of poverty which I believe we have a cure for. There is no reason why we should only provide this opportunity to our citizens alone. While I do understand that being distinct from us is very important to others at present and that hostile invasions are not going to help that matter, I certainly cannot abide, as a God-believing man, that the impoverished and drug-addicted people who are pleading to me for some kind of help are someone else's problem.

Nobody else seems to be doing anything seriously to help them. They are only being lumped together in places where they can be out of sight and not do any harm. This is my new diocese, and I will not leave them in the cold to die if I can get them into our program.

"What good will it be for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul? Or what can anyone give in exchange for their soul?"

-Matthew 16:26

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#100 - 2013-09-21 08:11:44 UTC
Now I've heard everything. Pilot are you actually attempting to sell slavery as the panacea for everything wrong with modern society including poverty, mental illness, substance addiction, illiteracy, laziness, irresponsible spending and more? Seriously? You twist the language to make freedom sound like slavery and slavery to sound like freedom. I've heard some doublespeak in my life but, oh my gods...

I'm thoroughly astounded at how your system of generational slavery, cultural imperialism, racial supremacy, territorial conquest, genocide and forced assimilation has suddenly morphed into a "voluntary work program". Every work program that I know of (excluding those where the participant is incarcerated) is indeed voluntary. Participants are free to leave the program whenever they wish and their descendants for the next 9 generations aren't forced to take part. They're typically paid a wage while they learn a trade or skill. They're free to live where they wish. They're not murdered, drugged or beaten by their employers. They're not held and treated as property to be sold or given away to another. You sure as hell can't make that claim about slavery. At the end of the day, each person in bondage lives (or dies) solely at the whim of their master.

As for your assertion that the Republic spends more for military preparedness than on social programs, you're likely correct. However, remember that the reason our government has had to do so was because of your ancestors invading and subjugating us in the first place. The Amarr are still a clear and present danger to the Republic so long as they pursue the "reclaiming". Your people haven't invaded another nation in quite some time, true. However, there's nothing stopping you from doing so whenever you'd like.

I appreciate that you fervently believe that you're doing some noble deed for humanity by stripping people, in this case those poor souls who are least able to defend themselves, of their individuality, their freedom of choice, their dignity. Just because you believe it does not make it so, however. There are huge numbers of slave owners who abuse, torture, and murder those they hold. You can't control them nor can your government or your deity for that matter.

In closing I'd recommend that you focus on the issue of holding abusive slave owners accountable for their inhumane acts, As my colleague said, clean your own house before you attack your neighbor's for being filthy.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.