These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Fiction

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

Sleepers and the Wormhole storyline

Author
Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#21 - 2013-07-21 23:05:19 UTC
Amann Karris wrote:


Quote:
It's like being given a jigsaw puzzle, when the solution is to put the box on your head and walk away.

That's exactly the solution that's intended. "Nothing to see here, move along." It's not the only solution. However, people want nice, tidy answers and the uncertainty of these kinds of puzzles tend to either drive people crazy, or drive them away.

Accept what you can see, make of it what you will, and have patience. When all else fails, bait the devs and hope they bite. ;)


This is how I feel exactly when it comes to this puzzle lol

I still think the Talocan are an offshoot of the Jove like the Sleepers. I think the Talocans were given the mandate of searching the galaxy and parts unknown for Terran tech that could have cured their degenerative disease or maybe they were searching for ancient Jove ruins on the off chance they would find an intact ancient Jove that could give them a template for their unaltered DNA.

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Cowgeneral
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#22 - 2013-07-22 06:09:33 UTC
Amann Karris wrote:
Synthetic Cultist wrote:
This connection between Sleepers and Jove, was never visible in any way ingame. Instead, it was revealed in one of the books. Came more or less right out of nowhere. Don't remember any mention of the Talocan at all in the book.

It didn't really come out of nowhere, but the biggest connecting pieces were in the books. There was enough to have a reasonable certainty without there being a smoking gun or huge neon sign.

Quote:
It's like being given a jigsaw puzzle, when the solution is to put the box on your head and walk away.

That's exactly the solution that's intended. "Nothing to see here, move along." It's not the only solution. However, people want nice, tidy answers and the uncertainty of these kinds of puzzles tend to either drive people crazy, or drive them away.

Accept what you can see, make of it what you will, and have patience. When all else fails, bait the devs and hope they bite. ;)


This is the same sort of ambiguity that this topic breeds, especially player-to-player conversations. "There's a grand design, don't worry!" or some typical vague implication of knowledge others are not privy to. Whether that's the price of doing business or simply a matter of discourse, who is to say.

My argument and that of Velarra's is that the generic response to critique of this method of storytelling or lack thereof, IE "If you're criticizing it you're buying into the pitfalls set into the intricate story to trip people up because by questioning it you've admitted defeat and/or are missing the point." Is incorrect because we have not been given any reason to think otherwise. Over four years have passed and still nothing, the best any of us can hope for is future content in another expansion once W-Space comes back full circle on the update board. My belief and contention now is that W-Space has effectively been put on the backlog for updating and that the promised content hasn't been delivered on. Maybe I'm presuming too much but then again that's what Dropbear more than hinted at in his post.

Your argument holds true that people do like clean and tidy answers but what has happened (or hasn't, rather) with the W-Space storyline seems to go beyond players wanting cookie cutter answers. The absence of a thread of critique like this in all that time, as far as I'm aware of, seems to show this.

So unless you can back up claims that CCP has been keeping up with Sleepers and you can define what the 'solution' and 'question' is without being extraordinarily vague, I'm not buying it. That's not to be rude, I'm just trying to combat the trend I've seen take hold of many threads concerning Wormholes and Sleepers.

Also if everyone could post links in your posts to whatever you're talking about or referencing, I'd greatly appreciate it.
Amann Karris
Doomheim
#23 - 2013-07-22 09:10:46 UTC
I considered sending the following via PM so as not to derail this thread, but it concerns more than the OP so I felt that leaving it here would be beneficial.

Big smile

Cowgeneral wrote:
So unless you can back up claims that CCP has been keeping up with Sleepers and you can define what the 'solution' and 'question' is without being extraordinarily vague, I'm not buying it.

Whether or not CCP has been keeping up with Sleepers is for them to answer.

I understand your concerns, and I don't blame you. The "question" has NEVER been defined aside from "What are the Sleepers?" which is pretty decisively answered in Templar One. Tony Gonzales and CCP have seemingly tried to make any further investigation moot. It's not just a question of game mechanics but one of "where do we go from here?" There's a LOT of answers out there, but the questions need to be defined. You've made a good start, but honestly at this point answering them requires a lot of time and effort (more than just a series of replies to a thread).

It is my belief that the answers have been given. Sleepers are Jovians. Talocan may or may not be the Architects. The wormholes are part of a natural transportation system that may or may not be complete. Some of this is knowable from in-game evidence, and that which is not really has no bearing on the game or how it's played. Anything "off screen" should, in my opinion, stay there. (Information on who the Sleepers are and what the Architects are is in Templar One) There are other pieces of the puzzle, but if you look at too big a picture everything just becomes a jumble of unconnected dots.

That is why there needs to be a concerted effort to actually collect the ingame-available information and make it accessible. The dots need to be connected. Arek'jaalan was a good start, but much of the project stalled when it became a "give us answers oh wise and powerful Dropbear" situation. There really needs to be a central database where Sleeper sites and related information can be posted that is easily accessible in-game. It's something that players can do, but also something that CCP really needs to step up and facilitate. Again, Arek'jaalan would have been a wonderful opportunity to do this, but the lack of direction from Dropbear kind of defeated the purpose. It can't just be IC interaction, it must include OOC feedback.

I love the initiative you've taken. I'm willing to help any way I can. I'm just one player, however, and I really don't want to burn myself out trying to find the answers (I think anyone else interested in this would feel the same).

So, why don't we start our own project? Something similar to Arek'jaalan, with an emphasis on collecting data and facilitating further investigation?

The idea is simple. Start up a chat channel, find some moderators, get some folks to start organizing information on the EVE Wiki, make an announcement post in the appropriate subforums, that sort of thing. I've been thinking about doing just that for the past few days, and if others are interested let's get the ball rolling. Once we get some sort of a plan together, contact CCP and say, "Hey, we've got this thing going, you guys want to join in?"

As someone who both went crazy and walked away from this mystery in the past, I really don't want to invest all of my playtime into this, but I'm more than willing to do my part.

Thank you for posting this thread, and my apologies if my previous reply seemed flippant.
Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#24 - 2013-07-22 09:26:56 UTC
I really need to read this Templar One book. Amann I'd be more than willing to help Big smile

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Niko medes
Freeman Technologies
#25 - 2013-07-22 18:12:39 UTC
Amann Karris, I'd be more than happy to support this effort you've suggested above. EVEmail me with details or invite me to the chat channel once it is created.
Cowgeneral
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#26 - 2013-07-23 13:35:18 UTC
That does sound enticing, however there are a few things that I am considering before committing to such a project.

Of course we have the ability to do it, but that doesn't mean the Devs will play along and humor us with events if we try. If the W-Space story is done, I see no reason why they'd bother. Although I suppose them saying one way or another would give the game away.

Another thing is we should pick up where Arek'Jaalan left off, this seems rather intuitive however it's one thing to have our own project and another to be Arek'Jaalan 2.0. What with Dropbear aka Hilen Tukoss gone, I don't know the current state of affairs with Arek'Jaalan. The issue now would be integrating what we do know into the new project while still giving previous credit where it is due.

Furthermore, Arek'Jaalan was Developer headed and by extension gave players a real sense of purpose, a "This is real." feeling. I'm not sure how we can emulate that sort of enthusiasm which seems to have tapered off since 2011.

My RP alt, which I probably should've posted all of this on in the first place is Seylan Veers, for continuities sake in-game since I'm usually mining quite a bit on this character, is to consider this char ICly as Veers. But that's getting ahead of myself.

It is a great idea Amann and it'd be cool to see how many people are interested and what ideas they have.
Dobie Mercault
Special Admirer Philosophy Club
#27 - 2013-07-23 21:02:39 UTC
I missed this first time around so count me in.

If I can make a suggestion, don't use the eve wiki. It's too hard to filter the signal out from the noise. I'm halfway tempted to offer a better solution like setting up our own basic host (site/wiki/forum). Does that sound like a preferable idea to others, though? Whatever we do needs everyone on the same page, I'd think.
Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#28 - 2013-07-24 13:50:36 UTC
Dobie Mercault wrote:
I missed this first time around so count me in.

If I can make a suggestion, don't use the eve wiki. It's too hard to filter the signal out from the noise. I'm halfway tempted to offer a better solution like setting up our own basic host (site/wiki/forum). Does that sound like a preferable idea to others, though? Whatever we do needs everyone on the same page, I'd think.


I was thinking the same thing. I was planning on taking screen pics of the complexes that involve any missions with the sleepers and talocan. Text, ships, stations, etc. If what CCP Dropbear said in the old forums a few years ago is true then all the evidence is in the game so we could be missing something. It's very possible that there is a mission that some people have done but never reported. It's not uncommon since some people don't care about the history and only the money to be made.

Are there any missions that we know of that are in any of the nullsec areas?

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Myyona
Ataraxia Pharmacies
#29 - 2013-07-25 09:18:54 UTC
Ah, new lore seekers appear.

Though, this thread seem oddly familiar for those of us that has been through the loop a couple of time.

Anyhow, Velarra is spot on regarding the completeness of the Eve lore. It is refreshing to see somebody realize that the missing parts are indeed just that; missing parts, and not obscure references to some little known philosopher or writer. The missing parts purpose are indeed to give the sense of mystery, which is also the reason why they will continue to be missing.

Even when Arek'Jaalan was more active (not saying it is dead), there was a general misconception that there were an already written storyline and plot to uncover, this being "finding the truth". Others thought they could "write the truth" by stating things with certainty and then get the CCP Seal of Approval, turning their fiction into prime. Of course, they only one who could do that was Tony G, and even he had a bad habit of ignoring or rewriting old prime fiction sources to make them fit into his interpretation of "the truth".

Though, science (even fictional science) is not about definite truths; it is about possible explanations for how things relate based on evidence, and then believe in the explanation with the most supporting evidence and highest likelihood. For that, A'J was actually an invitation to players to come up with their own free interpretation of various questions regarding the ancient races and rogue drones, but as there was/is no firmly written key (no definite truth due to the missing parts) to these questions, this exercise in interpretation could continue on and on forever.

My own attempt at interpretation is found here: The Sleeper - Jovian Connection and again I must stress, that this is just the most plausible explanation I can see with the evidence provided, without using information that is regarded to be unknown to our characters. Note that I wrote this article before Templar One was released, but I do not find anything in the book that strongly contradicts my hypothesis.

Also, for collecting info pieces from locations in w-space, I did that years ago: Jowen Went to Whiskey Space

Lastly, the Evelopedia has been rather dysfunctional for a longer period of time. That is why I have not updated some references that has become broken. It is also why I have not considered for real to expand on A'J related projects, though, if the wiki get fixed, I will likely be interested to be working on it again.

CEO - Ataraxia Pharmacies Personal Biography

Myyona
Ataraxia Pharmacies
#30 - 2013-07-25 09:28:28 UTC
Nakami Saans wrote:
If what CCP Dropbear said in the old forums a few years ago is true then all the evidence is in the game so we could be missing something.

I do not believe he said that. And by "interactive storytelling" it appears he meant something like "I give you three words of a sentence and you fill out the blanks" without there being any key to compare with.

CEO - Ataraxia Pharmacies Personal Biography

Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#31 - 2013-07-25 11:30:59 UTC
Myyona wrote:
Nakami Saans wrote:
If what CCP Dropbear said in the old forums a few years ago is true then all the evidence is in the game so we could be missing something.

I do not believe he said that. And by "interactive storytelling" it appears he meant something like "I give you three words of a sentence and you fill out the blanks" without there being any key to compare with.


The old forum thread is here. The actual part of the paragraph I'm referring to is:

Quote:
All of this - all of it - is unfolding in real time, and it will take either a genius or a collective effort to make sense of the whole from the fragments that remain. We are watching and waiting for the day to come when the capsuleers will move this particular storyline forward. We are still waiting.


Quote:
Let me tell you now that if you look closely at all things Sleeper, you will be rewarded for it. Nothing was put anywhere by mistake, and very, very, little of it is what you could describe as "filler". When it comes to the Sleepers, each stroke on the canvas was meant to be there and each part serves a purpose, whether little or...big. There are depths to this storyline that nobody has explored, complexities that have not yet been understood, mysteries that are still waiting to be unraveled, and this is a year and half after the discovery of Anoik...wormhole space.


But for all we know it could have been a elaborate deception. We don't know and the fact that it's several year old info. CCP Dropbear is apparently still in CCP's employ he is either on an extended holiday since he got married or he is working on another project. Here is the thread I found that bit of info in and the quote by CCP Goliath is:

Quote:
Just a quick note - neither Headfirst nor Dropbear have left CCP.


While the realist in my is saying I'm probably not going to find anything new, the hopeful explorer part of me wants to experience these missions for myself. The CCP team is trying to find a way to do live events in W-space but the logistics of it is proving to be...difficult to pull off. It's the same thread that i linked about Dropbear still apart of CCP. Those are my thoughts anyway.

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Myyona
Ataraxia Pharmacies
#32 - 2013-07-25 11:45:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Myyona
Dropbear did leave CCP for a period, but apparently returned to the fold again rather quick (see references here). Apparently he is currently working in Atlanta (ref), and I believe that means he is in no longer working with the Eve Content/Storyline team in any capacity (they work out of Reykjavik) and has not done for quite a while.

Oh, and you want to explore something in zero sec? Try to see what the COSMOS missions there can tell. I have not gotten around to do those myself. Chances are low that the will have Sleeper or Talocan related info, though.

ADD: The Live Event team at the time of A'J tried to do two events in w-space. Both ended up as a farce, so hopefully we will not have anything like that again.

CEO - Ataraxia Pharmacies Personal Biography

Myyona
Ataraxia Pharmacies
#33 - 2013-07-25 12:03:23 UTC
And this:
Quote:
All of this - all of it - is unfolding in real time, and it will take either a genius or a collective effort to make sense of the whole from the fragments that remain. We are watching and waiting for the day to come when the capsuleers will move this particular storyline forward. We are still waiting.

Quote:
Let me tell you now that if you look closely at all things Sleeper, you will be rewarded for it. Nothing was put anywhere by mistake, and very, very, little of it is what you could describe as "filler". When it comes to the Sleepers, each stroke on the canvas was meant to be there and each part serves a purpose, whether little or...big. There are depths to this storyline that nobody has explored, complexities that have not yet been understood, mysteries that are still waiting to be unraveled, and this is a year and half after the discovery of Anoik...wormhole space.

Yeah, I know what it initially looks like. But after having been through the mill a couple of times, I no longer believe my initial interpretation.

CEO - Ataraxia Pharmacies Personal Biography

Cowgeneral
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2013-07-25 13:08:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Cowgeneral
Here is a theory I sent to Amann Karris and convinced me it was worth sharing due to the dated nature of this story and by extension, lack of people to care (About defending Arek'Jaalan or Hilen Tukoss that is).

---

I was reading through the Anoikis and Vitrauze Project chronicles as well as the Arek'Jaalan files just now and a few thoughts occurred to me after reading through them.

It appears Arek'Jaalan is a ruse or some sort of ploy to divert attention from certain items or objects of interest by hiding them in plain sight. Its 'perceived benevolence' as stated in the Anoikis Chronicle is its greatest deception, mostly because it's true. Arek'Jaalan is open and plain about what has been released to the public concerning W-Space, key phrase being 'released to the public.' In the Anoikis Chronicle it is rather explicitly stated that Hilen Tukoss is a primary move behind the Sleeper Component monopolization.

"That will turn the empires toward research.

Not if we intervene and provide for them what convincingly appears to be the most promising final applications of any potential studies. This hints at precisely the point we must illuminate. When framed as a concern for the balance of power between the empires and the capsuleers, our interests will appear far more congruent with theirs, and our actions will remain understandable. The empires can be made to quickly appreciate how little control over these new areas they will have, and from there, it will be simple to assist each of them in coordinating access to components we identify as key. They will recognize it as the only opportunity any of them have for strategic equality. None will refuse."

This ties in with the opening quote:

Imagine if the bars to your prison were all you had ever known.

Then one day, someone appears and unlocks the door.

If they have the power to do this, then are they really the liberator?

You never remembered who it was that closed you in.


(Thanks to Amann, I now know this is a almost verbatim reference to Plato's Allegory of the Cave.)

So my analysis is that either the Sleeper Components are either far more valuable than the empires, Concord and Tukoss have made them out to be or they are in fact not that important but used as a cover-up for something that is.

This leads me to my next point. The ending of Anoikis ends with a large sum of figures listed as the amount of Sleeper Components turned in that October (2010?). The numbers at that time are extraordinary and would certainly be able to provide plenty of data for whatever 'secret project' Tukoss or the mysterious ambassador at the end of Anoikis may have been working on.

"Our research?

>Had she not realized yet? In the early months, we can make a great deal of ground.

Early months?

She had not. The ambassador swallowed. Emotion was rippling inside each cell, bursting throughout the bloodstream as it tried to break free."

My conclusion is that the 'ambassador' at the end of Anoikis is either a member of Sansha's Nation or Sansha Kuvakei himself (possessing a True Slave). While that is an extraordinary claim here are a few salient pieces of information I want to try and tie together.

1. The 'previous experience' of Ishukone as mentioned by the director to Tukoss is their contact with the Jove.

2. Lianda Burreau was chosen because of her extensive background in . This seems to imply her clone or consciousness was intercepted somehow after she was killed in Anoikis.

3. All four of the Sleeper Components seem to integrate locations, time stamps, monitoring, and AI respectively. The funneling of these items to Sansha's Nation would account for their apparent mastery of Wormhole technology and access to Jove space.

4. Even though the ambassador is at first glance supposed to be recognized of the Empires, his female associate consistently refers to "The Empires" not "The other Empires." While flimsy, I believe it implies either the ambassador hailing from CONCORD or some other entity.

5. The 'most promising final applications of any potential studies' appears to be the Tech III cruisers. This implies that there is a further possibility with Sleeper technology and our current exploits have only scratched the surface.

Also,

-Arek'Jaalan as said by Tukoss himself is to be taken as "To get revenge." That seems to fall into line with Sansha Kuvakei's driving theme.

-Arek'Jaalan actively avoids investigation into Sleeper Components. (As far as I know.) All I've seen so far is a few cursory mentions.

-Arek'Jaalan fits within the quote about the prison bars and the liberator at the beginning of Anoikis, if the Project sets the standard, how will we ever know anything beyond it?

-Talocan technology vaguely resembles Nation technology, particularly the spines on certain structures. This one is a stretch I know, but it could fit.

Other possibilities is that CONCORD is behind this, which begs the question as to why and whether or not their security is compromised by foreign agents (Sansha) or worse they're doing it of their own internal accord.

My theory is that Sansha's Nation has been using the Sleeper Components and a captured Lianda Burreau for their recent breakthroughs in Wormhole technology. Additionally, we have been duped by CONCORD and Hilen Tukoss into buying into their prescribed definitions of the potential of Sleeper technology. This leads to further perception that their reason for this is direct manipulation by Sansha's Nation.

To me these pieces of information fall together fairly well and would account for several aspects of the current plot. However, this does take several assertions, such as knowledge of the CreoDron meeting, Hilen Tukoss' conversations, the ambassador's monologue, etc...
Myyona
Ataraxia Pharmacies
#35 - 2013-07-25 13:37:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Myyona
Great theory crafting, lack of references. Regardless, an interesting hypothesis you got there.

If some new folks have not seen it; The Haakkainen Musings is probably still the best attempt at deriving plausible explanations based on all evidence presented. Sadly, Mr. Haakkainen decided to leave Eve and stop theory crafting after/because of Templar One.

CEO - Ataraxia Pharmacies Personal Biography

Cowgeneral
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#36 - 2013-07-25 14:18:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Cowgeneral
My mistake, seems like I violated my own rules there. Although the majority of the points are speculation, most everything can be found in the Chronicles or the EVElopedia.

Anoikis Chronicle.
The Vitrauze Project Chronicle.
Sleeper Components.
Arek'Jaalan Project. ("To get revenge" quote at very bottom.)
Also for images where I compared Talocan and Nation technology: Arek'Jaalan Library.
Ishukone Corporation.

Also thank you so very much for that link, I'm going through the PDF file now and this is incredible. Also that is the first post-Old Forums thread I've seen where Dropbear made an appearance, thank you.

EDIT: Also hadn't thought that the ambassador was Jovian in the Anoikis Chronicle, that's an interesting take on it and certainly plausible.
Job Valador
Professional Amateurs
#37 - 2013-07-26 03:40:21 UTC
I read every wall of text on here and my brain just dripped out of my ears.

@_@

I think we all have been living in wormholes for too long

"The stone exhibited a profound lack of movement."

Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#38 - 2013-07-26 11:21:08 UTC
Job Valador wrote:
I read every wall of text on here and my brain just dripped out of my ears.

@_@

I think we all have been living in wormholes for too long


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAA

I know how you feel. I've been trying to catch up while in the process of moving and registering for classes.

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Nakami Saans
Conclave of Independent Pilots
#39 - 2013-07-26 11:23:09 UTC
Myyona, you've given me alot to read and since my life has been crazy the past few days it might take me a while to sift through it all. Same to you Cow. Thanks! ^.^

People: "You shouldn't burn bridges." Me: "I don't, I bomb them from orbit."

Cowgeneral
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#40 - 2013-07-28 05:47:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Cowgeneral
An interesting find concerning the shift between lore focus on Wormhole Space in the Dropbear Era (2009-2011 from my estimations) to the current focus on Empires in the Illuminati Team Era (2011-present) by Rhavas, a long time player and Arek'Jaalan contributor.

http://interstellarprivateer.wordpress.com/2013/05/10/the-humans-are-the-real-monsters/

It'd be interesting to find out just how much of that is true and how much is speculation but from what has happened so far it seems like Rhavas is mostly correct. I wonder if W-Space will ever be pickd up in the future but the article speaks for itself.
Previous page123Next page