These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Jita Park Speakers Corner

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

** HILMAR - Remove the CSM Now...**

First post First post
Author
Guy Grand
Doomheim
#101 - 2011-10-21 13:24:46 UTC
Eternum Praetorian wrote:
Guy Grand wrote:
Eternum Praetorian wrote:
I have said this before, I want my interests and the interests of my friends addressed.

This makes you different then the current CSM how?



They are elected to represent people like me.
I am not elected to represent myself am I?



[quote]CSM's must be fair, neutral and courteous in order to fulfill their intended roll.
Else they are useless to everyone.

Are you new to the world as well as this game?



Are you new to a real-life working business model for a Video game?


Oh good you know how to edit.

So, no I am not new to business.

If I was, I would think that some customer elected body, in a biased election, could somehow represent anyone's interests but the elected. I would then whine about how my interests aren't being represented, even though any individual's interests are never served in a democracy, universal suffrage democracy or not. Then, having removed my own moral high ground by stating that I am the moral equivalent of who I am whining about, I would then go on to alienate everyone I could, you know, just to make my position as unsympathetic as possible.
T-Jay Charante
Black Sun Industry and Research
#102 - 2011-10-21 13:24:47 UTC
Karadion wrote:
Eternum Praetorian wrote:
I have said this before, I want my interests and the interests of my friends addressed.
I want representatives who recognize my play style and the playing style of people like me.

The current CSM, and most of the CSM's before that, are not giving me that "feeling". They are elected representatives that should be representing all of EVE online, from mining in empire to null sec. Their primary concern should be game balancing in every aspect of the game...

If they can't do that then there is no point in having them. Ugh

At the very least we could use an Empire CSM, Low Sec CSM and Null Sec CSM (or something). What we have now can only steer CCP in the wrong direction, and I believe has. Purposefully or not, It doesn't really matter, because a null sec only CSM cannot fulfill the above requirements. These are important requirements.

No ones "idea" of how the game should be played should take precedence over anyone else's.
CSM's must be fair, neutral and courteous in order to fulfill their intended roll.
Else they are useless to everyone.
They don't give you that warm feeling inside because they're not fighting to buff your mission bots / isk return. You got Trebor and that other person what's his name? Whatever. The current CSM got voted because they presented their platforms they believe in and also gained the favor of their own alliances because they share similar feelings.

PS: Use enter's less. Makes you look like you are skilled in grammar.


And just like in the Middle East, it's revolution time Cool
Rico Minali
Sons Of 0din
Commonwealth Vanguard
#103 - 2011-10-21 13:25:06 UTC
For the first time since the CSM was created, finally, we have got CCP to actually listen and start to fix many of the broken things in Eve, and to actually focus on what Eve is rather than force it into a change that wasnt that popular, while still promising to actually sort out Incarna when Eve is ready for it.

So, what is it you actually want? Are you mad that the CSM has actually succeeded, or are you mad that the success was partly due to someone you arbitrarily hate, probably due to what you have been told by your peers?

I really am sick of hearing about how Goonswarm and Mittani are destroying Eve, in my four and a half years of playing I have spent the last eight or nine months allied to Goonswarm, guess what I found? That they are alot of fun to fly with and are really not that different to every other faction in Eve. They scam, cheat, lie and splde people, just like everyone else does, they are simply more honest about it.

Trust me, I almost know what I'm doing.

Karadion
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#104 - 2011-10-21 13:26:46 UTC
T-Jay Charante wrote:
And just like in the Middle East, it's revolution time Cool
Just how do you figure I'm from the Middle East? What if it's my choice to abstain?
Renan Ruivo
Forcas armadas
Brave Collective
#105 - 2011-10-21 13:29:28 UTC
Well its like i said when the current CSM got elected.. Mittens is a jerk.... but he is a jerk who is on our side (the players) so its a good thing.

Lawyers are jerks but everyone likes one when they're advocating our own cause.

The world is a community of idiots doing a series of things until it explodes and we all die.

Grath Telkin
Amok.
Goonswarm Federation
#106 - 2011-10-21 13:29:58 UTC
I don't like the Mittani, and I'm pretty sure from people copy pasting things to me that he doesn't like me either.


But he's worked pretty hard through every possible avenue (Media, direct contact, talking to players, radio speeches) to steer EVE back towards something that doesn't smell like a dying elk.

To deny that is pretty close minded and partial brain death may be responsible.


To help this thread, and my sworn overly-hair gelled-spitcatcher adorned nemesis, I reported all the pubbies in this thread that were so incapable of holding a normal human conversation that they had to result to swearing, insults, and name calling, like Mr.Randomspelledwithnumbers.


If you don't feel you got the representation you needed out of the CSM, there is literally nothing stopping you from creating a platform and running.

Its free.

Anybody can run, and the Nullsec population is dwarfed by the Empire population, if you get the word out, there is literally no way that any 0.0 group can stop you from becoming the CSM chair. Even if every Goon had 4 accounts and voted for their pick, if you got even 1/4 of the Empire population to vote for you, it would be a landslide.

Stop whining for CCP to do something for you, and go do it yourself. That's what EVE is all about, and always has been.

Malcanis - Without drone assign, the slowcat doctrine will wither and die.

Gilentajsa
Matari Combat Research and Manufacture Inc.
#107 - 2011-10-21 13:34:29 UTC
Jade Constantine wrote:
Gilentajsa wrote:
White Tree wrote:
The Mittani wrote:
As I relaxed in the aftermath of a time-dilated fight where supercaps didn't rule the day and lag didn't determine the outcome, I browsed a rack of podkills with implants, spun my recently rebalanced hybrid-gunned ship, and typed off a poorly-thought-out ragepost about how the CSM was irrelevant, because I'm literally a big babby who has no idea what he's talking about.

I then went off to enjoy a bunch of new spaceship-related content that CCP produced after they finally acknowledged that focusing on FiS instead of WiS was the right thing to do!


[quote=The Mittani]As I relaxed in the aftermath of a time-dilated fight where supercaps didn't rule the day and lag didn't determine the outcome, I browsed a rack of podkills with implants, spun my recently rebalanced hybrid-gunned ship, and typed off a poorly-thought-out ragepost about how the CSM was irrelevant, because I'm literally a big babby who has no idea what he's talking about.

I then went off to enjoy a bunch of new spaceship-related content that CCP produced after they finally acknowledged that focusing on FiS instead of WiS was the right thing to do!



What was that you said?

I couldn't hear you through the **** in your mouth.




While I wouldn't be quite so crass as the poster above me. This does actually illustrate a problem with this CSM. Mittani's personality is quite dominant in that group and it has become apparent its a case of mr Mittani organgrinder and his half dozen monkeys. It does damage the balance of the CSM when its quite obvious only one person is calling the shots and the rest are just acting like beta followers rather than presenting individual and independent viewpoints.




+1 for the mental picture

It does raise a very good point though, does a handful of narcissistic megalomaniacs (<--not even directed at the entire CSM) truly represent YOUR interests in Eve or just Toolswarm Federations?

s

Guy Grand
Doomheim
#108 - 2011-10-21 13:36:39 UTC  |  Edited by: Guy Grand
Eternum Praetorian wrote:
Guy Grand wrote:
Eternum Praetorian wrote:
Guy Grand wrote:
[quote=Eternum Praetorian]I have said this before, I want my interests and the interests of my friends addressed.

This makes you different then the current CSM how?



They are elected to represent people like me.
I am not elected to represent myself am I?


Your answer completely sidesteps my point. You fail completely to address the others. Try again.



No, it does it just fine.
I, like 99% of the player base, are meant to be represented by our elected representatives, the CSM. That is why they exist, and we should not have to "fly to Iceland" to have our interests communicated.


No it doesn't. Your presumption that all players are like you, or can be, underlines your social solipsism at its most basic. You also presume to have information you don't have, by stating that you know what 99% of the player base wants (not to suggest that you didn't just pull that percentage straight out of your ass). OWS lemming indeed Karadion.

"The purpose of the CSM is to represent society interests to CCP. This requires
active engagement with the player community to master EVE issue awareness,
understanding, and evaluation in the context of the “greatest good for the
greater player base”.
The scope of issues is restricted only to EVE, its ongoing
development, and limited meta (out-of-game) issues which have direct relevance
to the EVE universe."

Notice it doesn't say, greatest good of Eternum Preatorian and his friends. Also note that I'm still not buying your baseless accusation that the CSM is corrupt, just because you are unhappy with things as they are. This is the actual thesis of your whole position, that your personal interests are not being met, and that that means that the communities are not as well. Which does not follow, and never will.
Signal11th
#109 - 2011-10-21 13:37:14 UTC
Grath Telkin wrote:
I don't like the Mittani, and I'm pretty sure from people copy pasting things to me that he doesn't like me either.


But he's worked pretty hard through every possible avenue (Media, direct contact, talking to players, radio speeches) to steer EVE back towards something that doesn't smell like a dying elk.

To deny that is pretty close minded and partial brain death may be responsible.


To help this thread, and my sworn overly-hair gelled-spitcatcher adorned nemesis, I reported all the pubbies in this thread that were so incapable of holding a normal human conversation that they had to result to swearing, insults, and name calling, like Mr.Randomspelledwithnumbers.


If you don't feel you got the representation you needed out of the CSM, there is literally nothing stopping you from creating a platform and running.

Its free.

Anybody can run, and the Nullsec population is dwarfed by the Empire population, if you get the word out, there is literally no way that any 0.0 group can stop you from becoming the CSM chair. Even if every Goon had 4 accounts and voted for their pick, if you got even 1/4 of the Empire population to vote for you, it would be a landslide.

Stop whining for CCP to do something for you, and go do it yourself. That's what EVE is all about, and always has been.



Good post totally agree, You do realise the term "pubbie" is an insult as well though?

God Said "Come Forth and receive eternal life!" I came fifth and won a toaster!

baltec1
Bat Country
Pandemic Horde
#110 - 2011-10-21 13:37:51 UTC
I'm betting this thread would not even be here if it wasn't for the war agaist the ice giants.

Nothing but tears and attempts to get back at people doing pvp in a pvp game.
Renan Ruivo
Forcas armadas
Brave Collective
#111 - 2011-10-21 13:42:35 UTC
Gilentajsa wrote:
While I wouldn't be quite so crass as the poster above me. This does actually illustrate a problem with this CSM. Mittani's personality is quite dominant in that group and it has become apparent its a case of mr Mittani organgrinder and his half dozen monkeys. It does damage the balance of the CSM when its quite obvious only one person is calling the shots and the rest are just acting like beta followers rather than presenting individual and independent viewpoints.


Erm.... what?

How can you state something like this, you have access to their Skype meetings or something?

The world is a community of idiots doing a series of things until it explodes and we all die.

Scatim Helicon
State War Academy
Caldari State
#112 - 2011-10-21 13:44:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Scatim Helicon
Jade Constantine wrote:
While I wouldn't be quite so crass as the poster above me. This does actually illustrate a problem with this CSM. Mittani's personality is quite dominant in that group and it has become apparent its a case of mr Mittani organgrinder and his half dozen monkeys. It does damage the balance of the CSM when its quite obvious only one person is calling the shots and the rest are just acting like beta followers rather than presenting individual and independent viewpoints.


Some people with strong personalities are able to dominate those around them.

Even if what you say is true, what you describe is not a 'problem with the CSM', its a basic feature of human interaction.

Every time you post a WiS thread, Hilmar strangles a kitten.

Garia666
CyberShield Inc
HYDRA RELOADED
#113 - 2011-10-21 13:46:19 UTC  |  Edited by: CCP Phantom
what CCP should understand is that just like CCP the CSM sits there with there own agenda.
If you have large alliances with allot of members voting for there guy. They will want what is best for them.
This has nothing to do with what is best for eve in general or its players..
Cailais
The Red Pill Taker Group
#114 - 2011-10-21 13:52:18 UTC
I love goons - they're just so passionate! Big smile

C.

Phunnestyle
Doomheim
#115 - 2011-10-21 13:53:30 UTC  |  Edited by: Phunnestyle
Scatim Helicon wrote:
Jada Maroo wrote:
I don't disagree. But it was hardly a selfless act and in the end will just allow Goons to expand territory.

Why would we want to expand territory?

"Oh boy more sov bills to pay for space that nobody uses! Hell yeah!"



LOL Goons are almost always on the defencive. While PL,NCDOT,Raiden where on break even IRC where powning Goons arses. Skill is very loosely used when implying it with a Goon. Goons are what they are, a swarm of bad/average players with exceptions ofc, reliant upon corruption, self gaining influences, lagg & having mass odds on fights. But where else would they go, as quality alliances will only recruit skilled players/experienced Vets.

If Goons where any good with Supers/Titans, new how & when to use them & hadn't sold alot of there Super capital fleet off the current insult of a winter patch wouldn't be looming. The current patch can't viably go ahead anyway, so much wrong with it,does very little to benifit EVE community, but does benifit a insignificant few entities. It brakes a broken game even more.
Refine Supers/Titans down, do something positive & benificial for the game, this is what every1 including Goons/DC should strive for regardless,not bl00dy minded self gain.
Reislier
#116 - 2011-10-21 13:54:25 UTC
Back in the summer, I marked October on my calendar.
Was anyone surprised to see staffing changes this month?
I remember thinking.. if this is true.. then October.. and here we are.
A reorganization is a wise move on CCP’s part.. it’s better than the alternatives.

Improving the CSM process would also be wise.. especially now. CSM election is only as good as attendance at the website. That’s not a big percentage when you think about it.

If CCP wants a thorough sampling of players for elections.. and it would seem a sound tactic to firm up communication with their customers. Tie the voting process to the game login screen.

You want a good spread on player input, that is where you get it because it is needed now.
It will not happen in the forums.. hasn’t yet..
If players don’t vote then, it won’t be because they didn’t know about it.

If a broader player representation is desired, change the process to reach them.
It certainly wouldn’t hurt.

Be nice. If nice not work, be civil. If civil not work, beat with iron pipe till bloody and still.

Killer Gandry
The Concilium Enterprises
#117 - 2011-10-21 13:56:39 UTC
Karadion wrote:
"Goons this, goons that, goons everything, goons are ruining my "Walking in Station" experience! Give me my incarna, wah wah wah." Go play Second Life or in traffic.

At least the CSM had some influence in getting CCP to dump their stupid Vampire MMO and scale down Dust that both of would have never worked.


A few sidenotes to this:

NeXgate was an uproar from playerbase and not something the CSM set up. It was the playerbase which got CCP's attention.
Any CSM adoring himself with feathers over this is nothing more than a smug crow walking around with a peacocks feathers.

The CSM has no influence. They are nothing more than an overglorified sounding board to see what CCP can get away with. Or think they can get away with since this CSM works only for a part of the playerbase.
The fact WoD and Dust got scaled down is merely due to the fact that the only cashcow CCP has atm is EVE. the other 2 only cost money for the time being.
Since CCP has to keep it's shareholders and other parties whom they owe money happy they firt have to make sure the cashcow doesn't die of starvation.

WoD and Dust development do continue and when they hit the market eventually and start bringing in money, THAT is the time to see what the value of EVE still is for them.

Mr R4nd0m
Doomheim
#118 - 2011-10-21 13:57:07 UTC
baltec1 wrote:
I'm betting this thread would not even be here if it wasn't for the war agaist the ice giants.

Nothing but tears and attempts to get back at people doing pvp in a pvp game.


Wow you really believe that?
Vile rat
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#119 - 2011-10-21 13:58:29 UTC
Awesome! Another one of these threads, all made by the same group of people.

I'm not sure if the thread actually has a point or is just another in a long string of "I hate goons so I'm going to post how angry I am that they are on the CSM" thread but this will be my contribution.

I think we've done a pretty good job. We all ran on platforms, I think I've helped move the narrative along in a way that has improved the status of the issues I've outlined in my platform. Mittens had his platform, he's done a fantastic job putting attention where it's been needed. The rest of the CSM get's along mostly great and our working relationship with the rank and file CCP devs has been nothing short of astounding so everything as far as I can see is going swimmingly.

I think some of the haters out there are mad because we're blowing up your empire miners.

Some others are upset because they don't like how some of us carry ourselves in public.

A few are just upset because they hated that they got scammed by a goon once and this is their venue to rant about it.

A few had vested interests in maintaining a broken status quo and our push to bring supercaps down to earth pissed them off (I'm especially smug about this one).

There have even been some people who were mad that I didn't take a silly rant thread seriously! I continue to be under no obligation to act as you want me to. You ain't my momma.



None of the above has any impact on our ability to do a KICKEN RAD job representing the players and doing what we can to help make this game great again.

So peace out thread, you've been fun. Can't wait to post in tomorrow's version!

hugs and kisses,

the guy who won the election by getting more votes by people who think we're doing exactly what they sent us here to do.
Vastek Non
State War Academy
Caldari State
#120 - 2011-10-21 14:08:35 UTC
Signal11th wrote:
Bascially thats just a warning shot saying "certain 0.0 dwellers who will remain nameless, it's time to shut the **** up" but I would like the CSM to continue because apart from some disruptive elements to it it actually does a good job.

I think he has just figured out that some people are getting a little to big for their boots and it's a polite way of telling them to calm down a bit.


^ This.

For what its worth, in my opinion the CSM has largely done a pretty good job of presenting 'many' different views. I'm thinking of Trebor, Seleene here in particular.

Mittani i'm not too fond of and suspect his ego needs taking down several notches. Its difficult to tell if his seeming contempt for any not Goons is genuine or just over the top roleplay, however I suspect somewhere inbetween. Either way not necessarily good for EVE as a whole. It appears Hilmar may agree with that viewpoint.

I find Vile Rats sudden interest in High Sec life a bit surprising, however am trying to be optimistic rather than my initial cynicism.

The rest of the CSM I can't really comment on.