These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

CCP, when eve is getting real PvP?

First post First post
Author
Vordek Rei
Masters of Mass
#141 - 2013-05-22 23:46:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Vordek Rei
Arguing with Basil Pupkin is dumb, when we can test it.

AttentionI will pay for all the costs associated with such an event (duel) or Duels, rules are simple.Attention

Standard Frigates, Destroyers or Cruisers, with standard fittings.

No named/officer/etc or LP store mods. Just run of the mill items.

Make sure you don't have too many implants, max value of 25 mil in total.

Rules are simple - when you fight Basil Pupkin make sure you can prove with that you have fewer SP than him, or prove it in such a way that its very likely that you do.

I will pay all* expenses for this event. - I will only pay for destroyed items.

Just wasted +700 mil on a face plug, think I can spare a few millions of isk for the laughs.
Basil Pupkin
Republic Military School
#142 - 2013-05-22 23:47:51 UTC
Luna Q wrote:
you are stupid, & should feel bad. Quit now & give all your stuff to people that have learned to EvE.


I've invested too much to quit. I wish I could ruin EvE for everyone, but it seems Odyssey will do well enough.
Eve brings nothing but regret to anyone who lost the chance to register earlier.

Being teh freightergankbear automatically puts you below missionbear and minerbear in carebear hierarchy.

If you're about to make "this will make eve un-eve" argument, odds are you are defending some utterly horrible mechanics against a good change.

Invisusira
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#143 - 2013-05-22 23:49:25 UTC
ITT:

OP confuses "skill" with "skillpoints"
Basil Pupkin
Republic Military School
#144 - 2013-05-22 23:50:11 UTC
Vordek Rei wrote:
Arguing with Basil Pupkin is dumb, when we can test it.

AttentionI will pay for all the costs associated with such an event (duel) or Duels, rules are simple.Attention

Standard Frigates, Destroyers or Cruisers, with standard fittings.

No named/officer/etc or LP store mods. Just run of the mill items.

Make sure you don't have too many implants, max value of 25 mil in total.

Rules are simple - when you fight Basil Pupkin make sure you can prove with that you have fewer SP than him, or prove it in such a way that its very likely that you do.

I will pay all* expenses for this event. - I will only pay for destroyed items.

Just wasted +700 mil on a face plug, think I can spare a few millions of isk for the laughs.


This is indeed a situation where SP can make less of an impact. But it's so unreal and impractical, which destroys the value of experiment completely.

Invisusira wrote:
ITT:

OP confuses "skill" with "skillpoints"



Since you win with skillpoints, skillpoints are skill.

Being teh freightergankbear automatically puts you below missionbear and minerbear in carebear hierarchy.

If you're about to make "this will make eve un-eve" argument, odds are you are defending some utterly horrible mechanics against a good change.

Vordek Rei
Masters of Mass
#145 - 2013-05-22 23:51:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Vordek Rei
Well well then if you don't want to play my game I will force you, enjoy you new bounty. Evil
Rhivre
TarNec
Invisible Exchequer
#146 - 2013-05-22 23:51:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Rhivre
Basil Pupkin wrote:


I said better ships are better, not bigger. And better ships take months to simply get into, not to mention do something in them.


No, actually, at varying points in this thread you have made various claims.

Texas Sharpshooter

Or maybe

Special

Your claim was "Eve "PvP" formula is simple as wood - more SP wins. You have an account created later than 2007-2008? Automatic defeat at every attempt of pvping."

You then clarified to say "Oh, I meant 1v1, cos duelling is pro"


Then you claimed that given the same ship, a player with 100m SP would beat a specialized char with fewer SP.
"Numbers = more SP = win. Not an exception."
""You don't have that SP heap? Lol noob, automatic defeat forever."

Then you confused Skill in PvP with SP:
"Except piloting skills are skillpoints."
"Whoever has more SP wins.
Winner is said to have more piloting skills than the loser.

So either they're the same or very closely related."

Now you are claiming that the problem is that "better" ships require more SP.

So your current argument is "I should be able to get this seasons arena gear and skills at level 1"


finally:

"I said better ships are better, not bigger. And better ships take months to simply get into, not to mention do something in them."

I respectfully disagree. Sure, if you want to be in null, maybe you need some big huge scary ship that takes 6 months...but then, do you think it is unfair that a 1 day old player cannot fly in a L4 missionboat?

My PvP alts take 2-3 months to finish training usually, because for me, the "best" ship is the one I like flying...for a new char, those months taking training for a T2 frig/cruiser/whatever are time gained throwing cheap ships around.

As mentioned before, you are welcome to buy a high SP pvp pilot as a new player, hop into the ship, and see if your SP gets you very far against a player who has actually been shooting stuff, and losing ships and learning from their mistakes.

The bit you miss that takes the time is the experience gained when you make a mistake. THAT is the part you want to skip.

If we all had equal SP and equal ships, we would still not all be equal at PvP and this is what is bothering you.
Invisusira
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#147 - 2013-05-22 23:52:30 UTC
ITT:

OP learns to use a dictionary
Shao Huang
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#148 - 2013-05-22 23:54:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Shao Huang
Basil Pupkin wrote:


I've invested too much to quit. I wish I could ruin EvE for everyone, but it seems Odyssey will do well enough.
Eve brings nothing but regret to anyone who lost the chance to register earlier.

And there is the actuality behind the attempted rhetoric. Based on this OP would have a very different view had they somehow not 'lost the chance to register earlier'.

Sometimes this emotional response is called envy. Historically speaking, it usually doesn't work out too well. Perhaps this thread will have provided something therapeutic or cathartic for the OP such that they do not have to live with the fairly well documented effects of contextualizing ones actions based on envy.

Private sig. Do not read.

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#149 - 2013-05-22 23:54:37 UTC
Basil Pupkin wrote:
Eve brings nothing but regret to anyone who lost the chance to register earlier.
Prove it.
Basil Pupkin
Republic Military School
#150 - 2013-05-22 23:56:36 UTC
Shao Huang wrote:
Basil Pupkin wrote:


I've invested too much to quit. I wish I could ruin EvE for everyone, but it seems Odyssey will do well enough.
Eve brings nothing but regret to anyone who lost the chance to register earlier.

And there is the actuality behind the attempted rhetoric. Based on this OP would have a very different view had they somehow not 'lost the chance to register earlier'.

Sometimes this emotional response is called envy. Historically speaking, it usually doesn't work out too well. Perhaps this thread will have provided something therapeutic or cathartic for the OP such that they do not have to live with the fairly well documented effects of contextualizing ones actions based on envy.


What can I do, envy aside, if I'll never have enough skillpoints to be "good"? Nothing.

Being teh freightergankbear automatically puts you below missionbear and minerbear in carebear hierarchy.

If you're about to make "this will make eve un-eve" argument, odds are you are defending some utterly horrible mechanics against a good change.

Anubis Joringer
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#151 - 2013-05-22 23:58:00 UTC
Basil Pupkin wrote:

Since you win with skillpoints, skillpoints are skill.


If you'd added a smiley or a "QED" at the end of this it would have looked indistinguishable from a spot-on parody of your posting. Satire is dead and you have killed it. Monster. Sad
Slutvana Khorkina
Bad Touches
#152 - 2013-05-22 23:59:05 UTC
This entire thread is everyone making statements of fact and OP saying "nuh uh". I feel like I'm watching the Eve version of the Argument Clinic sketch.

"Imagine the kind of stories people would read about EVE if the carebears got their wish. 'In EVE Online, some people mined. They arranged their mining lasers, and then they did something else for several minutes. Sign up for your free 14 day trial now!'" -- James 315

Basil Pupkin
Republic Military School
#153 - 2013-05-23 00:00:03 UTC
Anubis Joringer wrote:
Basil Pupkin wrote:

Since you win with skillpoints, skillpoints are skill.


If you'd added a smiley or a "QED" at the end of this it would have looked indistinguishable from a spot-on parody of your posting. Satire is dead and you have killed it. Monster. Sad


I'd kill a lot more things if I could, but I don't have enough SP to.

Being teh freightergankbear automatically puts you below missionbear and minerbear in carebear hierarchy.

If you're about to make "this will make eve un-eve" argument, odds are you are defending some utterly horrible mechanics against a good change.

Invisusira
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#154 - 2013-05-23 00:01:03 UTC
ITT: OP tries to invest SP into forum posting
WhiteGhostBear
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#155 - 2013-05-23 00:02:05 UTC  |  Edited by: WhiteGhostBear
Back in 2009, T'Amber ran a "Sisters of Eve" contest. It was kind of a Red vs. Blue kind of deal, except your character could be no older than a day or two when the contest started. This put everyone on even ground SP-wise.

Well, during the competition things were really quiet, so I decided to fly up to Rens with my week-old character in an Incursus of all things and look for trouble. There was some guy in a rifter looking for fights near one of the undocks and I decided "what the hell, it's a cheap Incursus with junk modules."

So I took the can, started the right, blew the other guy up. Note that this was back in 2009 when the Rifter was generally regarded as the champion of frigate combat, and the Incursus, eh, not so much. Not only was the other character quite a lot older than me, but he was fit with T2 gear on top of it all.

His fit was bad, his piloting was worse, and I ended up carrying the loot home.

Skill Points do matter to an extent - you can track a little better, do a little damage, turn a little better - but everything else is vastly more important. Positioning, the fit of your ship, situational awareness, manual piloting, etc., etc. High skill points only allow you to better make use of your piloting abilities.

And, really, any character that has trained up combat skills for 3-4 months already has 80% of the mechanical effectiveness of someone who has been around longer. That extra 20% is easily compensated for by simply being smarter than the other guy.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure the OP is just trolling the forums, but just in case he is not:

I will be happy to buy for you 10 T1 frigates of your choice, complete with PvP fittings and ammo, if you promise to join Faction Warfare or RvB for a week. I suggest the Merlin these days - it's a beast and easy to fly.
Vordek Rei
Masters of Mass
#156 - 2013-05-23 00:03:47 UTC
WhiteGhostBear wrote:
Back in 2009, T'Amber ran a "Sisters of Eve" contest. It was kind of a Red vs. Blue kind of deal, except your character could be no older than a day or two when the contest started. This put everyone on even ground SP-wise.

Well, during the competition things were really quiet, so I decided to fly up to Rens with my week-old character in an Incursus of all things and look for trouble. There was some guy in a rifter looking for fights near one of the undocks and I decided "what the hell, it's a cheap Incursus with junk modules."

So I took the can, started the right, blew the other guy up. Note that this was back in 2009 when the Rifter was generally regarded as the champion of frigate combat, and the Incursus, eh, not so much. Not only was the other character quite a lot older than me, but he was fit with T2 gear on top of it all.

His fit was bad, his piloting was worse, and I ended up carrying the loot home.

Skill Points do matter to an extent - you can track a little better, do a little damage, turn a little better - but everything else is vastly more important. Positioning, the fit of your ship, situational awareness, manual piloting, etc., etc. High skill points only allow you to better make use of your piloting abilities.

And, really, any character that has trained up combat skills for 3-4 months already has 80% of the mechanical effectiveness of someone who has been around longer. That extra 20% is easily compensated for by simply being smarter than the other guy.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure the OP is just trolling the forums, but just in case he is not:

I will by happy to buy for you 10 T1 frigates of your choice, complete with PvP fittings and ammo, if you promise to join Faction Warfare or RvB for a week. I suggest the Merlin these days - it's a beast and easy to fly.


I gifted him a 50 mil bounty - that way we know he will get some experience, perhaps some skills.
Jack Miton
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#157 - 2013-05-23 00:07:02 UTC
This thread is all sorts of special. Do go on.

There is no Bob.

Stuck In Here With Me:  http://sihwm.blogspot.com.au/

Down the Pipe:  http://feeds.feedburner.com/CloakyScout

Rhivre
TarNec
Invisible Exchequer
#158 - 2013-05-23 00:09:29 UTC
Basil Pupkin wrote:


What can I do, envy aside, if I'll never have enough skillpoints to be "good"? Nothing.



Bored now.

This is just a variation of your 1.5 month old post on griefing, only then it was flying a bestower which got violenced.

Personally I think it is unfair that I cannot fly an orca, because well.....Mining Director V...involves training some mining related stuff.
Also, I would like a nightmare, but I need more SP for it, this is not fair, because I could be wtfpwning stuff in L4s instead of doing L3 drake missions.

Finally, I would like Tycoon V, and standing 10 with both faction and corp for my market orders. This is clearly an advantage to people who like doing missions, as it takes time to get these standings, and I can never hope to get there, especially with my aversion to missions.

I suspect it is not skillpoints which are stopping you from being good Roll
Orravan
Anomalie
#159 - 2013-05-23 00:10:06 UTC
Why exactly does people keep responding to a troll clearly feigning to be unable to understand :

> that higher skillpoints only mean a wider choice of ships ;
> that there's no "best" ships in Eve, as it all depend on your fitting strategy, your adaptiveness, and your knowledge of your opponent ;
> that in 10 years there's been enough examples (read : thousands each day) of "low" SP characters beating old vets, thanks to an appropriate and well thought response to the threat, nullifying the claims of the OP ;

?

So far, over 50 people sucessfully trolled. Let it die.

Finicky diplomat. Suicidal explorer. Faithful ally.

Tippia
Sunshine and Lollipops
#160 - 2013-05-23 00:10:57 UTC
Basil Pupkin wrote:
What can I do, envy aside, if I'll never have enough skillpoints to be "good"?.
Anything you like. “Enough” skillpoints is something you've chosen to define and limit yourself by — it's not something the game does. In fact, the game does the exact opposite: it ensures that it is inevitable that you will get the SP you think you need.

…the problem is that by deciding the be defeated at every turn, you never manage to learn the player skills that will actually keep you alive.

Quote:
I'd kill a lot more things if I could, but I don't have enough SP to.
Is it more than 1M? Then you can.