These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Successful Income from Orca Boosting?

Author
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#1 - 2013-04-25 17:14:41 UTC
Has anyone ever had a successful marketing model for making income from boosting other miners in your system? I have tried to do this a few times, with little to now success - people either don't want to pay anything for a boost, or get it for free... this seems at odds with the capitalist model of the economy... *yes I have been reading Adam Smith of late"

Three must be a matrix that allow someone to charge a nominal fee with success for a win-win boosting/mining... it seems a valid career choose, to be a "mining foreman" in a command and control ship giving out valuable services to miners in barges and exhumers.

Any ideas or success stories? Models? theories? guess? insane-delusions?
Haulie Berry
#2 - 2013-04-25 17:25:58 UTC
Quote:
...this seems at odds with the capitalist model of the economy...


No, it really doesn't. If anything, it's the other way around: capitalism is precisely WHY this doesn't work.

Look, let's be clear about something:

You're basically asking people to pay you merely for ******* existing, and you're surprised that there aren't a lot of takers? And, while your existence could be a boon to some people, since the barrier to entry is minimal and, as we've already established, there's no particular additional effort required, you know what sounds like a better plan?

Bringing my *own* orca. When I'm done with it, I can almost certainly sell the pilot for as much or more than the plex cost I sunk into it, too.

That's how capitalism works.
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#3 - 2013-04-25 17:40:21 UTC
Haulie Berry wrote:
Quote:
...this seems at odds with the capitalist model of the economy...


No, it really doesn't. If anything, it's the other way around: capitalism is precisely WHY this doesn't work.

Look, let's be clear about something:

You're basically asking people to pay you merely for ******* existing, and you're surprised that there aren't a lot of takers? And, while your existence could be a boon to some people, since the barrier to entry is minimal and, as we've already established, there's no particular additional effort required, you know what sounds like a better plan?

Bringing my *own* orca. When I'm done with it, I can almost certainly sell the pilot for as much or more than the plex cost I sunk into it, too.

That's how capitalism works.


Not to argue a point, rather I would like to discuss it. But...

An Orca with max boost and implant is a major investment for any player (even if just an alt, that is alot of ISK and skill time)... so that has a fixed value that can be measured. Next, since the boost from this substantially increases the hourly of any miner in the system in the fleet, that also has a fixed increase in profit and value.

Now my orca sits almost all the time idea for the past year, as I can not mine in it and so am in my own, making my own, and if someone wants to fleet up I get the max mining boost for skills while in my mack and the adding in my HX implant.

So there seems to be something broken in either the practice or the impression of valuation of this as a service.

In strict terms, if these where real individuals, and each had to make a living by his own labor, the many miners would be making more than they could solo or in a group of themselves (all in barges or exhumers) then they can with the the added boost of the foreman who is boosting them (his labor) but not seeing any return on it personally, this is why I think it's a failure of the capitalist model...

If 10 people own cars, and 9 of them drive them around, and the 10th keeps them all supplied with gas, parts and services ad a discount off maket value (they are getting more value then the would normally) while not being paid for such while the then the last person is losing out while the others are taking advantage of him and so there is no incentive to keep doing it, he is better to simply stop doing it and keep to himself and let the others fair for themselves. But if each person pays him a percentage of the cost, so that 1/9th of the cost of each part,gas or serivice is covered, he breaks even, still no incentive but the other 9 get there's at 1/10th the cost of the whole, still a great deal... but if they pay him anything over that amount he then still discounts them (adding value) while he himself starts to see a profit also and so there is incentive to keep doing this for the benefit of all.
Haulie Berry
#4 - 2013-04-25 17:59:50 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:


An Orca with max boost and implant is a major investment for any player (even if just an alt, that is alot of ISK and skill time)...


Yeah, it's really not. If you've been here for like a minute, the 3-4 months to train a perfect Orca booster might seem like a long time, but that's nothing for a seasoned player.

Quote:
Now my orca sits almost all the time idea for the past year, as I can not mine in it and so am in my own, making my own, and if someone wants to fleet up I get the max mining boost for skills while in my mack and the adding in my HX implant.


This has no bearing on your value to other people.

Quote:
So there seems to be something broken in either the practice or the impression of valuation of this as a service.


YOUR impression of the value of the service is clearly broken, yes - probably because you think your Orca constitutes a "major investment".

Once you realize it isn't, in fact, a major investment, it becomes pretty obvious why you have trouble selling the service. All of the serious or even semi-serious miners have already gone ahead and made this minor investment because it's a blindingly obvious thing for them to do. This leaves the stupidest/laziest dilettante miners as your target market, and your sales pitch is, "Hey, how about you guys pay me for being even lazier than you!"
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#5 - 2013-04-25 18:04:45 UTC
my orca pilot (JC) has a Foreman Implant, not an HX the HX is on the active miner... a Foreman Mindlink has a significant cost... so that is something that affect others boost and so is part of the "Prefect/Max boost Orca", w/o it it's not a max boost.
Haulie Berry
#6 - 2013-04-25 18:05:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Haulie Berry
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
my orca pilot (JC) has a Foreman Implant, not an HX the HX is on the active miner... a Foreman Mindlink has a significant cost... so that is something that affect others boost and so is part of the "Prefect/Max boost Orca", w/o it it's not a max boost.


1 billion is not a significant cost. This is what I mean - you're basing your belief that this is a service people should want to pay for on a whole lot of erroneous assumptions which, in the aggregate, make it seem like this service is more valuable to people than it actually is.

Trust me, it's not the entire rest of the game getting this one wrong.
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#7 - 2013-04-25 18:10:15 UTC
Haulie Berry wrote:


YOUR impression of the value of the service is clearly broken, yes - probably because you think your Orca constitutes a "major investment".

Once you realize it isn't, in fact, a major investment, it becomes pretty obvious why you have trouble selling the service. All of the serious or even semi-serious miners have already gone ahead and made this minor investment because it's a blindingly obvious thing for them to do. This leaves the stupidest/laziest dilettante miners as your target market, and your sales pitch is, "Hey, how about you guys pay me for being even lazier than you!"


Well what must someone do to have a Orca Alt?

1. you seen a second account, in PLEX terms.. that is 520M per 30 days approx.
2. you need an orca, about 750M last I checked.
3. you need the skills and modules, and then the time spent training (some might not count time).

How much hourly mining profits must one do to hit break even on that, before one seems one ISK of return on investment? - at least a bit in my estimation.

This is much like a person rather than simply using a service, say a hair cut shop, decided to cut his own, and so enrolls himself in school, purchases a cutting business and then sits himself down to cut his hair each month, when it would be much cheaper just to pay the fee for someone already doing this labor for others and keep the costs minimal to the need.
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#8 - 2013-04-25 18:12:41 UTC
Haulie Berry wrote:
1 billion is not a significant cost.


You must not be a solo or single man corp with alts HS miner.. which is who I am talking about... Null bunnies and big corp holders aren't in need of this and have massive subsidized benefits that no single person could manage... walmart v. mom and pop shop...
Haulie Berry
#9 - 2013-04-25 18:23:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Haulie Berry
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Haulie Berry wrote:


YOUR impression of the value of the service is clearly broken, yes - probably because you think your Orca constitutes a "major investment".

Once you realize it isn't, in fact, a major investment, it becomes pretty obvious why you have trouble selling the service. All of the serious or even semi-serious miners have already gone ahead and made this minor investment because it's a blindingly obvious thing for them to do. This leaves the stupidest/laziest dilettante miners as your target market, and your sales pitch is, "Hey, how about you guys pay me for being even lazier than you!"


Well what must someone do to have a Orca Alt?

1. you seen a second account, in PLEX terms.. that is 520M per 30 days approx.
2. you need an orca, about 750M last I checked.
3. you need the skills and modules, and then the time spent training (some might not count time).

How much hourly mining profits must one do to hit break even on that, before one seems one ISK of return on investment? - at least a bit in my estimation.

This is much like a person rather than simply using a service, say a hair cut shop, decided to cut his own, and so enrolls himself in school, purchases a cutting business and then sits himself down to cut his hair each month, when it would be much cheaper just to pay the fee for someone already doing this labor for others and keep the costs minimal to the need.



You're ignoring a whole lot of inconvenient factors in an effort to maintain your belief that this is a solid business plan, and that everyone else is wrong for not seeing it as such.

-The orca pilot has resale value. Those PLEX you sink into him aren't a straight cost. They're an investment. Even as a marginally lossy investment (and I've seen plenty of characters sell for more than the time and skillbook cost of their training, so you may even see additional profit from this), this will almost certainly be more cost effective than paying someone else.

-The orca pilot doesn't necessarily need to exist on its very own account. Many people run multiple accounts anyway. If you don't have a pressing need to train another character on an account you're holding anyway , the PLEX is a sunk cost. For instance, I opened a second account to make an invention/RE character. When I finished training the skills for that, I didn't really have any need to train that character any further. It does everything I want and never needs another SP sunk into it. I'm not going to close the account, and I don't need to train the "main" on it. If I want an Orca pilot on it, there is no significant additional cost to me to train one (and, incidentally, this is exactly what I did - though in my case, it was for use as a hauler, not a booster).

You're mistaking investments with costs.

The Orca hull is not a cost. If you lose it, it's a cost. If you sell it, what you paid minus what you received for it is its cost. It may even appreciate with mineral prices. Same goes for the mindlink - if you sell the character, you will factor that into its value.


Quote:
You must not be a solo or single man corp with alts HS miner.. which is who I am talking about... Null bunnies and big corp holders aren't in need of this and have massive subsidized benefits that no single person could manage... walmart v. mom and pop shop...


Er... I run a one-man corp (with two accounts). You're correct that I do not mine, though (it's peasant work).

Seriously. This is a classic case of starting with a conclusion ("This should be a valued service!"), and then trying to beat the facts into shape to fit with that conclusion.
Dave Stark
#10 - 2013-04-25 18:52:02 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Well what must someone do to have a Orca Alt?

1. you seen a second account, in PLEX terms.. that is 520M per 30 days approx.
2. you need an orca, about 750M last I checked.
3. you need the skills and modules, and then the time spent training (some might not count time).


power of 2 account. 3 plex (~1.5bn)
implant, and ship(~1.8bn)
total ~3.5bn if we're being generous.

then like, 6 months to wait for skills to train.

i think mine took 7 months to train because i took info/siege/skirmish/armoured warfare all to V, along with the skill for siege links to have the t2 shield link.

all of that for around 4bn isk was relatively cheap.
Dave Stark
#11 - 2013-04-25 18:54:45 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Haulie Berry wrote:
1 billion is not a significant cost.


You must not be a solo or single man corp with alts HS miner.. which is who I am talking about... Null bunnies and big corp holders aren't in need of this and have massive subsidized benefits that no single person could manage... walmart v. mom and pop shop...


i've 3 accounts (including an orca)
confirming 1bn isk is easily obtained.

you're either poor, terrible at making isk, or both, to think that 1bn isk is a lot of money.
Styth spiting
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#12 - 2013-04-25 19:12:38 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Has anyone ever had a successful marketing model for making income from boosting other miners in your system? I have tried to do this a few times, with little to now success - people either don't want to pay anything for a boost, or get it for free... this seems at odds with the capitalist model of the economy... *yes I have been reading Adam Smith of late"

Three must be a matrix that allow someone to charge a nominal fee with success for a win-win boosting/mining... it seems a valid career choose, to be a "mining foreman" in a command and control ship giving out valuable services to miners in barges and exhumers.

Any ideas or success stories? Models? theories? guess? insane-delusions?


Orca boosts are a great thing, but unless you're also hauling for the person the value gained from the boosting is pretty minimal. Since most solo players will be (in most cases) mining in a retriever or mackinaw and mining to station the gains per hour will be marginal when you consider time spent warping to station, dropping off, warping back. Also most likely these people are AFK / Idle mining so the increase boosts actually means more work (more frequently having to haul to station).

But the other problem is that if you are offering hauling services as well there is no guarantee that you will auctually contract the ore/minerals after they are done. Why should they trust you? Once they give you their ore there is no reason why they should expect you to give it back. There is also the problem with sharing fleets with people you don't know. A player could join your fleet and then start fleet warping to miners to gank them.

So overall simply offering boosts is a minimial service many players don't need, will not trust you, or have boosts from someone else.

You wold be better off joining a mining corp, or contacting several mining corps and offer your services to their mining ops. Basically when they plan a mining op they contact you, and you join them, boost and haul, and you get a share of what is mined. With this setup you are offering a much better service that has much more value, and you'll actually make more isk/hour.

If I was doing this I would research what mining corps/groups are in my area (region, 10+/- jumps away) and contact them. I would explain what my mining boosts skills were, and how much on average a miner would make per hour and basically explain to them why they need my services. Any mining group who does not have a maxed Orca would jump at the offer, you simply need to build trust. If you can temp join their corp (and dump ore into a corp hangar) then even better.
Dave Stark
#13 - 2013-04-25 19:26:56 UTC
Styth spiting wrote:
If you can temp join their corp (and dump ore into a corp hangar) then even better.


having considered this statement.

dear OP i have a 3 man corp and i'd be very interested in purchasing your service, if you'd like to join my corp and dump ore directly in to my corporate hanger i'd be very happy to reward you handsomely.
Haulie Berry
#14 - 2013-04-25 19:28:31 UTC
Dave Stark wrote:
Styth spiting wrote:
If you can temp join their corp (and dump ore into a corp hangar) then even better.


having considered this statement.

dear OP i have a 3 man corp and i'd be very interested in purchasing your service, if you'd like to join my corp and dump ore directly in to my corporate hanger i'd be very happy to reward you handsomely.


Ohhh, yeah. That DOES change everything, doesn't it?

Dave Stark
#15 - 2013-04-25 19:29:22 UTC
Haulie Berry wrote:
Dave Stark wrote:
Styth spiting wrote:
If you can temp join their corp (and dump ore into a corp hangar) then even better.


having considered this statement.

dear OP i have a 3 man corp and i'd be very interested in purchasing your service, if you'd like to join my corp and dump ore directly in to my corporate hanger i'd be very happy to reward you handsomely.


Ohhh, yeah. That DOES change everything, doesn't it?



well, it means i can use my orca pilot as a third miner. i can't see how this could possibly go wrong.
Mari Hata
Main Street Crafts and Goods
#16 - 2013-04-25 20:43:00 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Any ideas or success stories? Models? theories? guess? insane-delusions?


A year ago, joined an "open mining op" from an orca pilot, offering on the spot a fixed price per jetcan.
Did that a few times, made friends.
Eventually banded together, set up a wormhole op.
Had fun, profit for a couple months.

♫ ♪ ♪

Dave Stark
#17 - 2013-04-25 21:02:52 UTC
Mari Hata wrote:
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
Any ideas or success stories? Models? theories? guess? insane-delusions?


A year ago, joined an "open mining op" from an orca pilot, offering on the spot a fixed price per jetcan.
Did that a few times, made friends.
Eventually banded together, set up a wormhole op.
Had fun, profit for a couple months.


i did the same. minus the wormhole thing.
they even sold me a hulk at a reduced price in comparison to jita value.
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#18 - 2013-04-25 21:40:00 UTC
So then the answer to my original question is that an orca isn't worth bothering with and my initial statement that I "dry-docked" it about 8 months ago and haven't used it since is the best use of it for the time being - as a logitical ship for moving and not for boosting.

This also seems to be the case for fleet command and fleet boosting in general in HS, since there is little cause for anyone to join a fleet in mining that doesn't consist of his alts due to lost profit to someone that isn't one of his accounts.

So basically all mining is only a solo player with multiple accounts and alts that then make do anything that is co-operative actually is counter to profit and so the profit margin drives people to solo play and multipe accounts, hence mining and production/industry is by it's nature a single player game mode of play.
Aurelius Valentius
Valentius Corporation
Valentius Corporation Alliance
#19 - 2013-04-25 21:50:17 UTC
Styth spiting wrote:
[You wold be better off joining a mining corp, or contacting several mining corps and offer your services to their mining ops. Basically when they plan a mining op they contact you, and you join them, boost and haul, and you get a share of what is mined. With this setup you are offering a much better service that has much more value, and you'll actually make more isk/hour.


This would be a business model, but we have established that they can simply make an alt and have the profit all there own so they would never contract an outside booster as the 1B+ is and time and skills and all aren't that hard to come by, and being easily obtained, they would never need to do this.
Mari Hata
Main Street Crafts and Goods
#20 - 2013-04-25 22:11:48 UTC
Aurelius Valentius wrote:
there is little cause for anyone to join a fleet in mining that doesn't consist of his alts due to lost profit


Still, I'd give it a try before making assumptions, if I were you. Not every miner is a spreadsheet-monkey, you see. In fact, most of them aren't, because if they were, they wouldn't be mining in the first place.

♫ ♪ ♪

12Next page