These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

BREAKING NEWS: Amarr Empire Opens Their Arms to Outcast Clone Soldiers

Author
Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#21 - 2013-03-18 18:00:40 UTC
Astroyka wrote:


I'm no theologian of course.


You're no debater either.

The subject is clearly above your reading comprehension level, best run along.





Sabik now, Sabik forever

Astroyka
IXXAXAAR
#22 - 2013-03-18 18:03:46 UTC
Kares Shahzu wrote:
Astroyka wrote:
Kares Shahzu wrote:
Scripture states nothing of the sort regarding the Minmatar.


Really? You sure about that? The scriptures may not be explicit in saying "Thou shal't go reclaim the Minmatar", but scripture is used for the reason for enslaving the Matari.

I'm no theologian of course.


No, the Scriptures are not the justification for enslavement of the Minmatar. They are the justification for the Reclaiming. Enslavement is a process of the Reclamation chosen and instituted by the Amarr and the Empire, not the Scriptures.
There are passages that could be argued to be in support of slavery, but the actual institution of slavery is not outlined in the Scriptures.


Can you see the contradictions in your own statement? Do I really need to hold your hand through it?

Its a sad day indeed when I point an Amarrian to his own scriptures. Search IGS and you WILL find many stories and comments where scripture has been used as the basis for their arguments regarding slavery.

Good luck to any clone solider willing (or otherwise) to be reclaimed.

Astroyka

A New Eden pilot, fighting against slavery in New Eden

www.astroyka.net

@Astroyka

Astroyka
IXXAXAAR
#23 - 2013-03-18 18:07:27 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Astroyka wrote:


I'm no theologian of course.


You're no debater either.

The subject is clearly above your reading comprehension level, best run along.


Thank you for your wise words and insightful comments on the subject. No actual comment to make on the topic? Just inane statements?

Astroyka

A New Eden pilot, fighting against slavery in New Eden

www.astroyka.net

@Astroyka

Samira Kernher
Cail Avetatu
#24 - 2013-03-18 18:09:03 UTC
Astroyka wrote:
And there we have the hypocrisy ... It's fine, its the same old argument about what constitutes reclamation, Matari can't be automagically reclaimed because scripture states it, but anyone else can be reclaimed at a drop of a hat even if they don't believe.

Carry on. Lets see how the news story progresses.


The Matari that willingly embraced God were not enslaved. That is why the Mandate exists. That the rest of the Matari were enslaved, and for so long, was solely a result of their stubbornness and resistance.

Those clone soldiers who take up Her Imperial Majesty's offer will not be enslaved, but nor will they be made citizens "at the drop of a hat". All who live in the Empire must adhere to the faith, or be in the process of being taught the faith. There are many foreigners in the Empire came here of their own free will, who embraced the faith willingly, and were thus never enslaved. Those clone soldiers who accept the offer will, along with receiving care and support for their conditions, be also receiving spiritual education, and both of these will happen in the sanctuary colonies that Her Imperial Majesty will be establishing.

That is not enslavement, as it is voluntary. The Reclaiming includes slavery as one method of conversion, for those that are defiant and unwilling to give themselves to God, but it is not the only method.
Astroyka
IXXAXAAR
#25 - 2013-03-18 18:28:48 UTC
Samira Kernher wrote:
The Matari that willingly embraced God were not enslaved. That is why the Mandate exists. That the rest of the Matari were enslaved, and for so long, was solely a result of their stubbornness and resistance.

Those clone soldiers who take up Her Imperial Majesty's offer will not be enslaved, but nor will they be made citizens "at the drop of a hat". All who live in the Empire must adhere to the faith, or be in the process of being taught the faith. There are many foreigners in the Empire came here of their own free will, who embraced the faith willingly, and were thus never enslaved. Those clone soldiers who accept the offer will, along with receiving care and support for their conditions, be also receiving spiritual education, and both of these will happen in the sanctuary colonies that Her Imperial Majesty will be establishing.


Thank you, Samira, for your insight.

I'll leave this here for posterity:

Samira Kernher wrote:
The Reclaiming includes slavery as one method of conversion, for those that are defiant and unwilling to give themselves to God

Astroyka

A New Eden pilot, fighting against slavery in New Eden

www.astroyka.net

@Astroyka

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#26 - 2013-03-18 18:33:07 UTC
Astroyka wrote:


Thank you for your wise words and insightful comments on the subject.


You're welcome!


Astroyka wrote:

No actual comment to make on the topic?


Several Imperial faithful have clearly stated why you are incorrect, no need to add to that chorus. The Empress (bless her little heart) has the dubious honor of addressing billions of people with her public statements; hence she needs to be very. clear. in. her. wording.

That you refuse to comprehend, or I suspect rather lack the proper neurons to make the appropriate connections, is perhaps a deficiency you should look into before worming your way into an Amarr theology discussion.

But please, keep telling us why you know more about the Reclaiming than the Reclaimers.

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Milton Middleson
Rifterlings
#27 - 2013-03-18 18:44:12 UTC
Kane Spero wrote:

I'm still wary of this being a clever ruse, but I'll keep an eye on this situation as it develops. At least one nation doesn't see genocide as the answer to men and women who have served their nations.


Don't worry. It's not especially clever. Sarum is offering to sell you something you already own, for the mere cost of your freedom.

You'd be better off as outlaws.
Kallo Unarmored
Doomheim
#28 - 2013-03-18 18:48:14 UTC
They give vitoc to children then expect clone soldiers to 'trust' them. Heh, I'm staying the heck away from Amarr space and so should the rest of them.
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#29 - 2013-03-18 18:48:24 UTC
I would imagine that the Amarr Empire would see potential in slaves that can instantly be reborn as soon as they die. For one, you can have them do all kinds of dangerous work. Secondly and probably the most significant, you can have someone in servitude for all of eternity.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Samira Kernher
Cail Avetatu
#30 - 2013-03-18 18:50:50 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I would imagine that the Amarr Empire would see potential in slaves that can instantly be reborn as soon as they die. For one, you can have them do all kinds of dangerous work. Secondly and probably the most significant, you can have someone in servitude for all of eternity.


That is not the purpose of servitude.
Kallo Unarmored
Doomheim
#31 - 2013-03-18 18:58:49 UTC
Samira Kernher wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I would imagine that the Amarr Empire would see potential in slaves that can instantly be reborn as soon as they die. For one, you can have them do all kinds of dangerous work. Secondly and probably the most significant, you can have someone in servitude for all of eternity.


That is not the purpose of servitude.


Purpose or however they brainwash people into obedience . I don't wany any part in it, as the man said before; better off outlaws.
Astroyka
IXXAXAAR
#32 - 2013-03-18 19:01:20 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Several Imperial faithful have clearly stated why you are incorrect, no need to add to that chorus.


Incorrect about what? The assumption that the soldiers may be on the path to slavery? Sure, I'll concede that, I can't see into the future on how the soliders will be treated. Isn't that the debate?

Silas Vitalia wrote:
That you refuse to comprehend, or I suspect rather lack the proper neurons to make the appropriate connections, is perhaps a deficiency you should look into before worming your way into an Amarr theology discussion.

But please, keep telling us why you know more about the Reclaiming than the Reclaimers.


Ouch....

I can only recount using comments, statements and stories I've read and been privy to via GalNet, IGS and other public sources and relay that as understanding of your ways. If anything, you should berate your brothers and sisters for their lack of understanding and misleading the rest of New Eden and IGS on such matters so we would all be clear on your beliefs.

Oh, but wait, faith can be interpreted by each believer in so many ways, no wonder outsiders are confused.

Astroyka

A New Eden pilot, fighting against slavery in New Eden

www.astroyka.net

@Astroyka

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#33 - 2013-03-18 19:09:28 UTC
Astroyka wrote:


Oh, but wait, faith can be interpreted by each believer in so many ways, no wonder outsiders are confused.


Actually it can't. For True Believers there is but a single valid interpretation at any time; this view is disseminated in the Empire through the Theology Council. They... frown upon each believer trying to interpret the Faith in their own way. The message gets diluted that way, you see.

Better for their to be a single and correct fount of spiritual and theological knowledge.


I feel the same way of course, but different sources naturally.

If you actually -are- curious about the misguided Imperial faith you should contact one of the Imperials in this thread.

Or come over for a cocktail, I'll set you straight.









Sabik now, Sabik forever

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2013-03-18 19:10:24 UTC
Samira Kernher wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I would imagine that the Amarr Empire would see potential in slaves that can instantly be reborn as soon as they die. For one, you can have them do all kinds of dangerous work. Secondly and probably the most significant, you can have someone in servitude for all of eternity.


That is not the purpose of servitude.


Right, I forgot that your justification is "To bring savage people to the light of our God" or something along those lines.

The reason why your Empire was able to expand so rapidly was because of Slavery whether you want to acknowledge it or not. You can get things done a lot quicker when you can have thousands of people work for no pay in horrible conditions with nothing more than "God's Will" to justify it.

You can sugar coat it all you want, but at the end of the day, you hold slaves to provide a source of labor. Whether or not it's a bad thing to do is an entirely different debate (I think it is, but that's beside the point). Your Empire uses Slaves to handle labor and whatever your people don't want to do.

What you might claim the reason is, is a justification to your own people and the rest of New Eden.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#35 - 2013-03-18 19:18:16 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Statment


I love how the other races always feel they know what we're thinking and the 'real' reasons for all our actions. It's the Amarr! Always an ulterior motive behind -everything- they say and do.

For a culture that supposedly respects other races and values I find Gallente most amusing in their inability to take another race's ambitions and practices at face value without seeking supposed hidden meaning.

Amarr have never as a culture been shy about stating our ambitions, our goals, or our methods. Surely you should know us well enough by now to know we think highly enough of ourselves to not hide our intentions or methods.

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#36 - 2013-03-18 19:23:13 UTC
Kallo Unarmored wrote:
Purpose or however they brainwash people into obedience . I don't wany any part in it, as the man said before; better off outlaws.


Kettle. Pot. Black.

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

Astroyka
IXXAXAAR
#37 - 2013-03-18 19:24:24 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Actually it can't. For True Believers there is but a single valid interpretation at any time; this view is disseminated in the Empire through the Theology Council. They... frown upon each believer trying to interpret the Faith in their own way. The message gets diluted that way, you see.


I'm sure you can concede that there are many of your brothers and sisters commenting on IGS that have their own interpretation of your faith, which in-turn confuses those of us trying to understand the Matari question.

No offence, but there are less "True Believers" speaking clarity than there are "Interpreters".

Silas Vitalia wrote:
If you actually -are- curious about the misguided Imperial faith you should contact one of the Imperials in this thread.

Or come over for a cocktail, I'll set you straight.


While I thank you for your offer, and those that have made the same in the past, I will state the same reasons why I can't accept:

1) My militia status wouldn't go down too well with your navy.
2) My adverse reaction if a slave served me a cocktail.
3) My extremely busy diary.



Astroyka

A New Eden pilot, fighting against slavery in New Eden

www.astroyka.net

@Astroyka

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#38 - 2013-03-18 19:35:55 UTC
Vitalia why do you even care? You're a Sabik, a twisted heretical offshoot of the "true" Amarr religion (according to your own kind). Since you feel the faith the rest of the Empire practices is false why stand up for the government and people who believe in it?

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Samira Kernher
Cail Avetatu
#39 - 2013-03-18 19:38:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Samira Kernher
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Samira Kernher wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
I would imagine that the Amarr Empire would see potential in slaves that can instantly be reborn as soon as they die. For one, you can have them do all kinds of dangerous work. Secondly and probably the most significant, you can have someone in servitude for all of eternity.


That is not the purpose of servitude.


Right, I forgot that your justification is "To bring savage people to the light of our God" or something along those lines.

The reason why your Empire was able to expand so rapidly was because of Slavery whether you want to acknowledge it or not. You can get things done a lot quicker when you can have thousands of people work for no pay in horrible conditions with nothing more than "God's Will" to justify it.

You can sugar coat it all you want, but at the end of the day, you hold slaves to provide a source of labor. Whether or not it's a bad thing to do is an entirely different debate (I think it is, but that's beside the point). Your Empire uses Slaves to handle labor and whatever your people don't want to do.

What you might claim the reason is, is a justification to your own people and the rest of New Eden.


"Only through many hardships
Is a man stripped to his very foundations
And in such a state
Devoid of distractions
Is his soul free to soar
And in this
He is closest to God"

- The Scriptures, Book of Missions 42:5

"Chosen, you are first before God.
You are the True and the Faithful.
But in such a state must you hold yourselves high above all.
And constantly prove yourself worthy of Gods Love.
How can such a gift be repaid,
Other than to toil all our days,
In His glorious service,
According to His will,
Serving Him always,
Bearing Him first in our thoughts,
Always must we strive to show Him our worth,
For we are the Chosen, Blessed above all."

- The Scriptures, Anoyia's Exhortation to the Faithful


All in the Empire toil in the service of God. Slaves labor, but so do the Chosen. Many voluntarily work alongside slaves. Many practice the same forms of punishment upon themselves for their own sins. The only difference is that slaves, who are still at risk of succumbing to temptation, are given few freedoms so that they might be properly taught without falling back into sin. That is why slavery exists. It is to provide spiritual education in an environment where the individual will be unable to exercise the sins that will lead them away from God. It is harsh, but what is right is often difficult, and I for one am grateful that my Holder and my custodian cared enough about my soul to set me upon the road to salvation.

Once the slave has embraced God's light, they are freed. We who are freed will still toil, as all in the Empire toil in the name of God, but we have greater freedoms because we are no longer at risk of giving in to our temptations. Eternal slavery would be nothing but a sign that the Holder is refusing to teach his servants and thus he would be punished for it and his slave given to a Holder who will provide proper spiritual education. It is the same reason why TCMCs are banned in all properly devoted regions of the Empire, and the same reason why the Empire is opposed to "true slavery" organizations like Sansha's Nation and the Angel Cartel, whom care nothing for their slaves' spiritual salvation and only for what economic benefit they can provide.
Uraniae Fehrnah
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#40 - 2013-03-18 19:42:26 UTC
Bear in mind these are my personal opinions and I am in no way speaking for the Empire as a whole.

Kallo Unarmored wrote:
They give vitoc to children then expect clone soldiers to 'trust' them. Heh, I'm staying the heck away from Amarr space and so should the rest of them.



Would you rather slave overseers withhold Vitoc and allow those children to suffer and die from Vitoxin? Vitoc is a treatment method for managing Vitoxin. Now obviously it would be better to just not use Vitoxin at all, that I'll absolutely agree with. It's a horrible method, but try to remember the distinction between Vitoc and Vitoxin.

As for the rest of the conversation. Slavery is not the only path to a pious and righteous life within the Empire. The Reclaiming is not just about enslaving the rest of humanity. Slavery is (ideally) not about providing a workforce for Imperial efforts. Generational slavery is, at best, a negligent mockery of sacred responsibility to enlighten others. Children are born innocent of the sins of their forebears. To be perfectly honest I find the institution of generational slavery to be a precarious step down a similar path as the followers of Ocilanian interpretation of Scripture.

Now, the Empress has declared that any clone soldiers seeking refuge will be allowed to settle on a planet within the Empire. They will receive medical and psychiatric treatment, vocational training to become productive and potentially able to make their Safe Haven colony self sufficient. They will not be enslaved, they will however not be allowed to leave the colony, presumably until they demonstrate to be sufficiently rehabilitated and pose no real threat to the wider population. I don't see that restriction as anything too dissimilar to rehabilitation and probation of the mentally ill or the criminally convicted within other nations.