These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A disturbing trend

Author
Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#61 - 2013-03-05 03:13:25 UTC
You're being a bit pedantic Sepherim. You know exactly what I meant. The fact remains that your people invaded both the Minmatar Empire and Jovian Directorate, sovereign entities that had functioning governments and infrastructure to provide for the well being of their respective populations.

Your attempt at obfuscating the facts by making a point to jump on my imprecise use of language does not invalidate the facts and thus, fails.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#62 - 2013-03-05 03:46:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Sepherim
I won't deny we invaded both the Minmatarr and the Jove Directorate. It's undeniable. What I'm claiming is that those slaves were, and still are, citizens of the Empire, as dictated by our laws which the Republic accepted when they signed the Yulai Treaty. You may not like it, and I understand it, but you are breaking the laws your Republic agreed to respect when they signed... not that they've been too succesfull in that either, given the invasion of our sovereign space, but that's a different point.

So, while respecting your Nation, you're violating your State.

To sum it up. We indeed invaded a State but that State no longer exists, and what you see now is a new State which occupies part of the same space the old one did, and shares some traditions and laws with it. And while we did attack a Nation that does continue today, none of the members of that Nation attacked survive to here. They have all died, and long ago all the members of that Nation are lawfully part of the citizenry of the Empire. Until your emancipation and secession, which created a new citizenship along with a new State, which we have not violated as much as you may like to claim so.

Thus, as you can see, I don't attempt to obfuscate any point. You are simply wrong. There's nothing bad with accepting that, sometimes, even us amarrians can be right.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Andreus Ixiris
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#63 - 2013-03-05 04:54:51 UTC
Scherezad wrote:
I think that all of us Capsuleers would be well-served by a few daily moments of contemplation on the wisdom our enemies expound.

When Louvaki begins expounding even the merest sliver of wisdom, you have my honest word that I will take a moment to contemplate it.

Given that this is Louvaki we're talking about, though, I won't exactly be holding my breath.

Andreus Ixiris > A Civire without a chin is barely a Civire at all.

Pieter Tuulinen > He'd be Civirely disadvantaged, Andreus.

Andreus Ixiris > ...

Andreus Ixiris > This is why we're at war.

Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#64 - 2013-03-05 05:04:04 UTC
Andreus Ixiris wrote:
When Louvaki begins expounding even the merest sliver of wisdom, you have my honest word that I will take a moment to contemplate it.

Given that this is Louvaki we're talking about, though, I won't exactly be holding my breath.


I will consider your wisdom.
Nick Shale
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#65 - 2013-03-05 05:21:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Nick Shale
Ensign Sepherim;
Since you seem to like technicalities, the Yulai Convention and the Yoiul Accords are different things. The Yoiul Accords is the treaty that established peace between the Four Empires, recognized the Minmatar Republic as a sovereign state, created CONCORD, established the uniform time keeping system, created the ISK, and a whole lot other things. The Yulai Convention is a subsection of the Yoiul Accords, that governs the rules of interstellar warfare.

Your suggestion of dishonesty from the Republic is classic rhetoric. The Minmatar people have ALWAYS repelled the yoke in one way or another no matter what title you give them. The only reason Amarr haven’t violated this accord it’s simply because it can’t, doing so will dig its own grave. The real insincerity is that Amarr by following men’s law is forfeiting Gods holy command of the Reclaiming eroding its fundamental moral values, lazily choosing hypocrisy over responsibility.

Or perhaps you share my conclusion that the current interpretations of the scriptures have been manipulated for only one purpose, which is the projection of power disguised as the Lord's word.
Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#66 - 2013-03-05 10:20:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Sepherim
Nick Shale wrote:
Ensign Sepherim;
Since you seem to like technicalities, the Yulai Convention and the Yoiul Accords are different things. The Yoiul Accords is the treaty that established peace between the Four Empires, recognized the Minmatar Republic as a sovereign state, created CONCORD, established the uniform time keeping system, created the ISK, and a whole lot other things. The Yulai Convention is a subsection of the Yoiul Accords, that governs the rules of interstellar warfare.


I stand corrected, thank you for the clarification, captain Shale. And have no problem admitting you're right.

But I do have a small point to make in this regard, I'm not a friend of technicalities, but sometimes they are important. This was a reply to captain Rella when she said I was wrong in my previous post, which claimed Minmatarr were amarrian citizens (or slaves) back a few centuries, and thus it was an internal political/demographical management issue. She claimed I was wrong because the sovereign nation had existed forever, and so I had to go and dismantle the argument that the nation was sovereign vs the nation had existed forever vs citizenry. To use a less controverted example, the Intaki nation exists, but politically they're part of the Gallente state. And such was also the case for the Minmatarr during centuries, even though it is no longer such.

I hope this clears up why technicalities were used in this specific case. As you can check in my other posts elsewhere, I rarely use my studies to prove a point. You could say it's... pedantic, as captain Rella put it.

Quote:
Your suggestion of dishonesty from the Republic is classic rhetoric. The Minmatar people have ALWAYS repelled the yoke in one way or another no matter what title you give them. The only reason Amarr haven’t violated this accord it’s simply because it can’t, doing so will dig its own grave. The real insincerity is that Amarr by following men’s law is forfeiting Gods holy command of the Reclaiming eroding its fundamental moral values, lazily choosing hypocrisy over responsibility.

Or perhaps you share my conclusion that the current interpretations of the scriptures have been manipulated for only one purpose, which is the projection of power disguised as the Lord's word.


No suggestion of dishonesty, it's a fact. You can check the history books and see who attacked the CONCORD main station and invaded another empire. It wasn't us. As much as pilots like to talk about our Reclaiming, and how we invade everything, we actually don't. And haven't invaded anyone in a long time. We have a powerful Navy, we could have attacked the station since its formation, and yet have respected the international accords we are signataries of.

And we don't invade other state's sovereign space to "free its citizens" as you are doing, and which was the original point of this topic. We don't raid, we don't make slaves anymore, we have even freed a good number of them. Holding us accountable for the mistakes of the past can only go so far.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#67 - 2013-03-05 11:18:34 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
To sum it up. We indeed invaded a State but that State no longer exists, and what you see now is a new State which occupies part of the same space the old one did, and shares some traditions and laws with it.


To clarify, the Amarr Empire conquered the Minmatar Empire, which composed of a whooping three solar systems. We have never invaded the Minmater Republic, which includes those same three solar systems and more than a few Amarrian ones as well. And there was also a gap of several centuries between the fall of the former and the rise of the latter.

If you want to know more about the Republic's history you can look it up in the databases at the CONCORD station in Yulai.

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

Nick Shale
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#68 - 2013-03-05 15:45:51 UTC
Sepherim wrote:

No suggestion of dishonesty, it's a fact. You can check the history books and see who attacked the CONCORD main station and invaded another empire. It wasn't us. As much as pilots like to talk about our Reclaiming, and how we invade everything, we actually don't. And haven't invaded anyone in a long time. We have a powerful Navy, we could have attacked the station since its formation, and yet have respected the international accords we are signataries of.

And we don't invade other state's sovereign space to "free its citizens" as you are doing, and which was the original point of this topic. We don't raid, we don't make slaves anymore, we have even freed a good number of them. Holding us accountable for the mistakes of the past can only go so far.


Ensign Sepherim

You may call them dishonest for following their cause above any rules or accord, I call Amarr hypocrite for not following theirs.

Your Reclaiming failed, and it did so horribly after 9 generations the only seed you sowed was that of hate which inevitably grew into the Republic. You blame them for your failure and brand them untamed savages. God gave you this people to be stewarded into the light, it gave you time which you wasted, it showed you the path with St. Arzad but you condemned it. It gave you an emperor that showed you temperance but you call him weak and killed him. Now you see the fruit of your labor and call it wicked and dishonest, NO sir... I call Amarr dishonest for its lust of power, for its willingness to twist the word of God to accommodate that of men.

Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#69 - 2013-03-05 21:24:26 UTC
Nick Shale wrote:
You may call them dishonest for following their cause above any rules or accord, I call Amarr hypocrite for not following theirs.


We follow our rules and accords. We haven't broken Yulai, and we obey what our Empress says. That's all the rules we need.

Quote:
Your Reclaiming failed, and it did so horribly after 9 generations the only seed you sowed was that of hate which inevitably grew into the Republic. You blame them for your failure and brand them untamed savages. God gave you this people to be stewarded into the light, it gave you time which you wasted, it showed you the path with St. Arzad but you condemned it. It gave you an emperor that showed you temperance but you call him weak and killed him. Now you see the fruit of your labor and call it wicked and dishonest, NO sir... I call Amarr dishonest for its lust of power, for its willingness to twist the word of God to accommodate that of men.


I would suggest you check my posts, in this topic and elsewhere, looking for one time I have called your people savages. I believe you won't find it, because that's not how I feel about the Minmatarr. I'm sure that, if we were not on opposing lines of war, we could perfectly be friends and have a few drinks together in a bar confortably. Politics has cast us in two differnet sides of the battlelines, you honor your duty, we honor our own.

I disagree with your people being killed unnecessarily, and that was the whole point of this topic since the begining, even if it has evolved in other directions. I believe all lives are precious and valuable, those of the Amarr and those of the other sides of the border, and abhor the unneeded killing, specially of civilians. Am I dishonest? Am I lusting for power?

The Empire is very big, there are all sorts of people here. Some ninth generation slaves fled the Empire to the Republic. Many also stayed. We reap what we sow, but we haven't planted only fire and storm, we have planted good things among the bad ones as well. And we're human, we have human faults, and weaknesses. Of that, we all are equally guilty, no matter how transhumans some would wish themselves... maybe with the exception of the Sansha, I'm not sure of those.

So then, am I the monster you want me to be? Are they the millions like me in the Empire?

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Gabriel Darkefyre
Gradient
Electus Matari
#70 - 2013-03-05 23:56:14 UTC
Sepherim wrote:

No suggestion of dishonesty, it's a fact. You can check the history books and see who attacked the CONCORD main station and invaded another empire. It wasn't us. As much as pilots like to talk about our Reclaiming, and how we invade everything, we actually don't. And haven't invaded anyone in a long time. We have a powerful Navy, we could have attacked the station since its formation, and yet have respected the international accords we are signataries of.

And we don't invade other state's sovereign space to "free its citizens" as you are doing, and which was the original point of this topic. We don't raid, we don't make slaves anymore, we have even freed a good number of them. Holding us accountable for the mistakes of the past can only go so far.


http://www.eveonline.com/news.asp?a=single&nid=2530&tid=4

I'm guessing that someone forgot to advise Uriam Kador 5 Years ago that Invading another Sovereign Nation was no longer acceptable.
Nick Shale
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#71 - 2013-03-06 00:21:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Nick Shale
Ensign Sepherim
I must apologize for when I say “you” I refer to you as “the Amarrian people” and I don’t presume to know you personally, I merely pointed out my opinion of the ideal you adhere to.

What I find hypocrite Ensign Sepherim is that you say the killing of slaves by freedom fighters is unnecessary, when you jump in your warship and murder anyone that gets in the way of disenfranchising others. Both of the ideals justify murder for its cause and you denouncing the practice of your enemy when you yourself do it its insincere.

As for your commentary about faults and human weakness we all share, perhaps you should remember it when your pulling that trigger to impose your ideals into others.

About those drink, we can have them anytime and talk about this as I’m not your enemy however you might want to consult your superiors as I understand you’re not allowed to fraternize with people like me.
Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#72 - 2013-03-06 01:36:26 UTC
Gabriel Darkefyre wrote:
http://www.eveonline.com/news.asp?a=single&nid=2530&tid=4

I'm guessing that someone forgot to advise Uriam Kador 5 Years ago that Invading another Sovereign Nation was no longer acceptable.


Last time I checked, Uriam Kador is not Emperor. And he got punished and lost control of the Kador family fleet for this action.

I could point to your Defiants as an example of the same thing in the Republic.

Nick Shale wrote:
I must apologize for when I say “you” I refer to you as “the Amarrian people” and I don’t presume to know you personally, I merely pointed out my opinion of the ideal you adhere to.

What I find hypocrite Ensign Sepherim is that you say the killing of slaves by freedom fighters is unnecessary, when you jump in your warship and murder anyone that gets in the way of disenfranchising others. Both of the ideals justify murder for its cause and you denouncing the practice of your enemy when you yourself do it its insincere.


I believe this refers quite directly to me, but I'll take your previous words and imagine you referr to a generic amarrian. I'll reply as such.

Disenfranchising others requires the invasion of our sovereign space as the amarrian state. It also requires the violation of our laws and traditions. In Amarr, those things are a crime, and crimes must be punished. I believe, and hope, I'd get the same treatment if I took a free Minmatarr from Pator as my slave. And yet, you use a double standard in which one is bad and the other isn't. I think that's quite insincere.

Quote:
As for your commentary about faults and human weakness we all share, perhaps you should remember it when your pulling that trigger to impose your ideals into others.


I believe this is a personal comment. As such, believe me, I take it into account every time I pull the trigger. And it weighs heavily on me, but that is something I won't get into details here.

But I don't impose my ideals to others, though. I just follow orders. Orders that came after the Republic invaded Amarrian space, and still continues to try to grasp control of the amarrian Bleak Lands. My kills are not on me, on this occasion, but on your people.

Quote:
About those drink, we can have them anytime and talk about this as I’m not your enemy however you might want to consult your superiors as I understand you’re not allowed to fraternize with people like me.


I'll check it out. But I'm not sure it would be good, for either of us. At least until the dust is settled and we're no longer in war.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Sylux Raynes
Doomheim
#73 - 2013-03-06 01:55:18 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
We follow our rules and accords. We haven't broken Yulai, and we obey what our Empress says. That's all the rules we need.


You are a member of the Praetorian? I wonder if this is what they teach because it is certainly not in line with Amarrian tradition and heritage. The Scriptures are a massive part of our culture and history, play an integral part in our laws and society and have been a source of guidance for generations. While the Empress is indeed our Divinely appointed leader, her word is but one part of what guides us. Placing something as temporal as Yulai above the Scriptures is tantamount to heresy.

Pilot Shale has a valid point in that we have squandered our blessings and favor in the past, you needn't an outsider to make that plain if you are a student of history with an objective mind.

Sepherim wrote:
I disagree with your people being killed unnecessarily, and that was the whole point of this topic since the begining, even if it has evolved in other directions. I believe all lives are precious and valuable, those of the Amarr and those of the other sides of the border, and abhor the unneeded killing, specially of civilians.


This speaks highly of you.
Sylux Raynes
Doomheim
#74 - 2013-03-06 02:00:09 UTC
Sepherim wrote:

But I don't impose my ideals to others, though. I just follow orders. Orders that came after the Republic invaded Amarrian space, and still continues to try to grasp control of the amarrian Bleak Lands. My kills are not on me, on this occasion, but on your people.


Unfortunately, here I must disagree with your assessment. Regardless of your reasoning and your justifications, you are the one taking lives. I am not faulting you for this, merely pointing out the truth of the situation.

There is no sin in taking a life, yet we must examine ourselves constantly to ensure that the lives we take are not in vain, nor out of malice and selfishness. Blood is on the hands of every soldier as readily is it is on the hands of every murderer, where the distinction exists is the purpose behind that blood and the temperament of the one spilling it.
Nicoletta Mithra
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#75 - 2013-03-06 02:44:15 UTC
Sylux Raynes wrote:
Sepherim wrote:
We follow our rules and accords. We haven't broken Yulai, and we obey what our Empress says. That's all the rules we need.


You are a member of the Praetorian? I wonder if this is what they teach because it is certainly not in line with Amarrian tradition and heritage. The Scriptures are a massive part of our culture and history, play an integral part in our laws and society and have been a source of guidance for generations. While the Empress is indeed our Divinely appointed leader, her word is but one part of what guides us. Placing something as temporal as Yulai above the Scriptures is tantamount to heresy.


Cpt. Raynes, if you read carefully you will see that my fellow Praetorian referred to the Scriptures first, even if not bluntly so.

Faithfully,
N. Mithra
Sylux Raynes
Doomheim
#76 - 2013-03-06 03:30:37 UTC
Nicoletta Mithra wrote:


Cpt. Raynes, if you read carefully you will see that my fellow Praetorian referred to the Scriptures first, even if not bluntly so.

Faithfully,
N. Mithra


As you say, Ensign Mithra. I find it is prudent to be careful about such things, my questioning of the ensign was not borne from ill-will.
Nick Shale
Arcana Imperii Ltd.
#77 - 2013-03-06 04:06:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Nick Shale
Sepherim wrote:

Disenfranchising others requires the invasion of our sovereign space as the amarrian state. It also requires the violation of our laws and traditions. In Amarr, those things are a crime, and crimes must be punished. I believe, and hope, I'd get the same treatment if I took a free Minmatarr from Pator as my slave. And yet, you use a double standard in which one is bad and the other isn't. I think that's quite insincere.

But I don't impose my ideals to others, though. I just follow orders. Orders that came after the Republic invaded Amarrian space, and still continues to try to grasp control of the amarrian Bleak Lands. My kills are not on me, on this occasion, but on your people.


The Republic is a devil of amarrian making, with the Reclaiming boundaries were erased spreading the Minmatar across the Empire .When the seed of hate finally sprouted the Republic formed and claimed their kin revoking Amarr's claim over them. The excuse of sovereignty in this case is as absurd as saying the caldarians that remained in Caldari Prime after the breakout from the Federation were Gallente citizens.

You choose to follow the Empire's command, your honour binds you to follow orders but if those orders aren't examined with reason what is the difference between you and a Citizen from the Nation... only the targets you lock?

PS: I don't subscribe to any government yet, as my recent status as capsuleer have revealed different perspectives, while you assumed I was Minmatar by the color of my skin and the content of my arguments its but half true as my other half is Khanid and follows God's teachings, So Ensign Sepherim we are not enemies and we are not at war.
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#78 - 2013-03-06 04:10:44 UTC
If certain groups of Minmatar are so thirsty for blood and revenge, to do unto the Amarrians as they have done to them, then they are no better than their slavers were.

I support the liberation of slaves, however that should be up to the choice of the individual slave. Taking thousands of people away in a sudden raid and killing those that refuse and/or resist coming with you must be pretty similar to how the Amarr enslaved your people in the first place.

The Minmatar that see that this bloodshed has carried on far too long are the Minmatar that will bring their Republic to true glory in the future.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#79 - 2013-03-06 04:56:56 UTC
Sylux Raynes wrote:
While the Empress is indeed our Divinely appointed leader, her word is but one part of what guides us. Placing something as temporal as Yulai above the Scriptures is tantamount to heresy.


If the Divinely appointed Empress says to obey a treaty, how is it heresy? The Scriptures were not written in one day, nor have the stopped being written even now. The Universe evolves, the Empire evolves, we evolve and the Scriptures evolve with them.

Between the Age of Fire and the Age of Fusion there are many steps, many of them dirty and unclean - power generation through burning of fossil fuels, for example. Toxic wastes and other such hazards that harm the environment. Yet without going through those intermediate stages we never would be able to reach the point of being able to produce clean, efficient power sources. The same can be said of most technologies. The most primitive spaceships were once powered by chemical fuel sources, if you can imagine such a thing. Yet without those steps on the ladder we would not have warp drives or stargates today.

The point? All in God's will, and through God the Empress. We have suffered and we have made mistakes, which make many wonder doubt how infallible God's will really is. My answer is that these mistakes had to be made; that they are all steps on the ladder of progress. If we don't go through all the steps we will never reach our true destiny.

So as far as the Scriptures go... I do not consider it heresy if today the Empress makes a decree that goes against something that was written a thousand years ago. I believe that God put her Her Imperial Majesty here to guide us into the future, not to hold us in the past. Yes, the Scriptures are the foundation of our society, but foundations are there to be built upon.

There was a time when we conquered system after system in the name of the Reclaiming, and it worked. It worked until we encountered the Jove and then it stopped working. Why could we not conquer them as well? It was God's will, as with everything else. Because of the Jove all the warring nations were dragged to the table to start a new era of peace. Why did this happen? Because the age of conquest had ended, we had carved out enough space to be secure and stand strong. To grow any further might have stretched us beyond our limits, resulting in eventual anarchy and collapse.

It was clear that a new direction was needed and we went that way. We signed the treaties, we've kept our word, and put the age of conquest behind us. The Reclaiming of today is not done with fleets or lasers but with missionaries and priests. It is a peaceful reclaiming that doesn't expand our borders but instead creates new nations that are bound by a shared Faith. The Ammatar Mandate and the Khanid Kingdom are not part of the Amarr Empire, yet they are allies and always shall be so long as we all embrace the Faith. As the Faith spreads across borders opened by peace we will gain more allies. I do not see nor even want to see a future where the Gallente or the Caldari become part of the Empire. But I do see a future when the Word of God has spread through both and we can all stand united beneath His eyes.

So no, I see no heresy here.

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

Gabriel Darkefyre
Gradient
Electus Matari
#80 - 2013-03-06 10:27:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Gabriel Darkefyre
Sepherim wrote:
Gabriel Darkefyre wrote:
http://www.eveonline.com/news.asp?a=single&nid=2530&tid=4

I'm guessing that someone forgot to advise Uriam Kador 5 Years ago that Invading another Sovereign Nation was no longer acceptable.


Last time I checked, Uriam Kador is not Emperor. And he got punished and lost control of the Kador family fleet for this action.

I could point to your Defiants as an example of the same thing in the Republic.


Indeed you could. And likewise the Assault of the Elder Fleet.

I do find myself wondering at times if the punishment handed down to the Kador Family was for their Actions, or for their Failure? If Kador had succeeded in taking Solitude, would he still have had the fleet confiscated, or lauded in the Empire as a Conquering Hero?

Likewise, I'm not naive enough to believe that the Elder Fleet would not have been hung out to dry by the Republic Parliament as Unsanctioned Renegades if they'd completely failed in their objectives. After all, the success that they did achieve was sufficient to cause the Collapse of the Midular Administration at the time.

I guess we'll never know.