These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Which race generally has the best advanced cruisers?

Author
Drennon Nas
The Omega Syndicate
#1 - 2011-10-13 08:25:04 UTC
I'm trying to decide what race I want to train advanced cruisers for.

Which is race best for pve? which race is best for pvp? Which race would be better to train for to be able to easily pvp/pve interchangeably?

I'm a newish player, and I've heard that the caldari's the best for pve due to the tengu and basilisk. I know amarr has the curse and guardian. Is the legion any good? Minmatar has the loki... and what else is worth using? I've heard the Ishtar was a great drone boat for galentte. Do they have anything else worth looking at?
Sven Hammerstorm
Royal Amarr Institute
Amarr Empire
#2 - 2011-10-13 08:56:32 UTC
PvE - Caldari for the tengu. Also works fine for pvp.
As for pure pvp, all the other races have good options. Virtually every recon ship is worth flying. Having recon V and all cruisers V offers some very good choices Smile
Salvia Olima
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#3 - 2011-10-13 09:09:12 UTC




I recommend Caldari/Minmatar.

Tengu simply rules above all other T3, capstable 100MN AB is awesome both for PvE and PvP, (in nullsec I mean) while Loki is one of the most versatile T3, from solo hunter to sniper or brawler, lots and lots of good setups available. Basilisks are used more often these days then in the past. Passive shield tanking skills come very useful in PvP, so whether you fly Drakes or Vagabond/Cynabal every sp you invested in it pays off. Huginns are welcome in most roaming gangs.

Gallente shines in the capital range, unknown how the hybrid unnerf will affect it.
Legion is not very good, Zealot/Guardian is king only in AHAC-gangs, Curse.. maybe in lowsec, not seen a single one in nullsec in the past few months. Also, it is nearly always called primary, which is bad on an empty stomach.
Shayla Sh'inlux
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#4 - 2011-10-13 09:11:34 UTC
Quote:

Which is race best for pve?


Caldari. Tengu.

Quote:

which race is best for pvp?


Winmatar

Quote:

Which race would be better to train for to be able to easily pvp/pve interchangeably?


Probably Amarr. Although Tengu/Drake are decent at PvP too. And Cane/Sleip are just fine for PvE as well.
Mocam
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#5 - 2011-10-13 09:15:04 UTC
Drennon Nas wrote:
I'm trying to decide what race I want to train advanced cruisers for.

Which is race best for pve? which race is best for pvp? Which race would be better to train for to be able to easily pvp/pve interchangeably?

I'm a newish player, and I've heard that the caldari's the best for pve due to the tengu and basilisk. I know amarr has the curse and guardian. Is the legion any good? Minmatar has the loki... and what else is worth using? I've heard the Ishtar was a great drone boat for galentte. Do they have anything else worth looking at?


Quite an open ended question with a hell of a lot of opinion involved in answering it.

I'll touch on them a bit but understand - everyone is going to think this or that ship "sucks" or "is good" or "is best". All of them tend to see a good deal of use.

Logistics -
Guardian (Amarr) - best for a group of logistics backing up armor tanked ships.
Basalisk (Caldari) - best for group of logistics backing up shield tanked ships.
Scimitar (Minmatar) - best for a single logistics to back up a small gang of shield tanked ships.
Oneiros (Gallente) - arguably the worst - best for a single logistics to back up a small gang of armor tanked ships.

The last 2 pretty much require logistics 5 training to use them well. They aren't that difficult to get cap stable which the first 2 don't do easily at all. They also do not get energy transfer bonuses vs the first 2 - so Amarr and Caldari ships, in teams, can exceed 'cap stable' and actually provide extra energy to others in a fleet. *IF* they have other logi there to share energy transfers with.

What type of support would you like to provide if you flew one?

HIC's -
All are decent - Onyx seems to be one of the most popular but they all can get the job done well.

Role is heavy tackler from hell. They tend to pack battleship level tank on a cruiser hull so can take a healthy beating - especially being as battleship class weapons don't hit them all that decently.

In highsec and lowsec, they use a script to turn their bubbles into beams that can tackle any ship in the game - from a titan to a deep space transport. The only way to break the tackle is to get outside their range or make them stop using the device - kill it or neut it.

In nullsec they are moving bubbles that only T3's can "ignore" by fitting a special sub-system. Nothing else can warp out of that bubble and it surrounds the ship which can fly around a bit - albeit slowly.

HAC's -
a lot of variances here. Mass opinions. These are the damage dealing cruiser class ships.

I suppose you'd want to look at the "weakest" ones but all of them are decent.
Minmater - Munnin is less popular than the Vagabond
It's bonuses are to optimal range vs the vaga being falloff. Projectiles tend to "live in" falloff and the minmatar ships are about speed - the vaga also gets a speed bonus.

Gallente - Demios is less popular than the Ishtar
The Demios is a gun ship - primarily blaster fit. As such it needs to be up close and personal to do it's task and... "hybrids have issues". The Ishtar is a drone boat - solid drone skills and it shines like any drone boat can/will. It can also field a full flight of 5 sentry drones (battleship class weaponry).

Caldari - Eagle is less popular than the Cererbus.
Eagle is a hybrid gun ship. Hybrids have issues and Caldari tend to avoid guns over missile skills. Cererbus is a missile ship - Caldari? Yeah. Cererbus is more popular.

Amarr - no clue really. I hear good things and mutters about both.

T3's -
Expensive compared to the other options but - In order of popularity:
Caldari Tengu - top contender for "best PvE' ship in the game. Also used in PvP but less popular than other options.
Minmatar Loki - can do decently at PvE but PvP it does seem to shine better. Booster fits seem common but DPS use from them is also popular. Fast, agile and able to do the usual "flexibility" gig.

Almost a toss up on which is thought less of - Legion or Proteus. Armor tends to be less popular in these smaller mid-sized ship classes. They tend to be far less agile and lacking in the GTFO ability.

Amarr Legion - but the Legion is a nice ship for armor HAC gangs. It can do PvE well but tends to be a bit slow for most folks tastes in PvP.
Proteus - Hard to get solid tank and good DPS on it. Armor tanked makes it less agile but it can show some serious damage numbers *IF* it can get in blaster range.

Recon's -
All are thought well of by their pilots. The Curse and Pilgrim are held in fairly high esteme due to their abilities at soloing. If it's soloing you are into - they may be your best options but all of them work very nicely in the right types of gangs.



Again, a hell of a lot of opinion in how this stuff works out. "Best" is often more aligned to your style of play and which ship fits it. Trying to solo the world? Like "in your face" or "long range"? Into Support style stuff - command or repair? ...

Don't ignore one just because it's not as popular as another. Figure out your style and find the one (or ones) that fit(s).
Jill Antaris
Jill's Open Incursion Corp
#6 - 2011-10-13 09:24:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Jill Antaris
Amarr:

Zealot: Very good at bigger gangs, ok in some more tanky fits for small gang stuff. Can be used for med range armor HAC gangs.

Sacrilege: Outside of 1o1 not really good, even then it is a close range HAC, what makes it kind of limited in eve.

Curse\Pilgrim: Good for gangs/solo. Basically the most offensive recons out there, by the ability to shut down movement/dps/active tanks with neuts.

Legion: More tanky Zealot for PVE with Lasers, not to bad, noting really awesome. Works ok as heavy HAM brawler in solo/small gang pvp if you are into expensive fits and imps. Also works as super tanked curse to cap out capitals.

Guardian: Agreeable the best big gang logistic, by his armor rr focus and good stats. Gets quite expensive in proper big gang fittings by the need for T2 grid rigs.

Gallente:

Diemost: Terrible.

Ishtar: Like a cruiser sized domi, very flexible for PVE. Ok ship for small gang pvp.

Lachesis\Arazu: Long range scram with a heavy shield tank for gate camping under sentry agro or long range gang tackler. The arazu is basically a cloak with a long point, weak tank, the ability to stop a single slow target from shooting you and terrible cap and dps issues, making it more or less meh for solo.

Proteus: Cloaky long range point with ok dps or EHP brick with ok dps. Ok for small gang/solo not really useful for other stuff.

Oneiros: Not really this useful since there are hardly gang types that require self substantiating small gang armor RR ships. The tracking bonus can be used for PVE or stuff like boosting titans, but not really this common.

Caldari:

Cerberus: Extreme long range missile ship, works as support/anti support ship in big gangs(vs Falcons and stuff). For any thing else a drake is cheaper and more effective.

Eagle: Terrible.

Rook\Falcon: Because of Falcon, excellent small to med gang support ships.

Tengu: Excellent at PVE by combining the gank of a CM raven with a much better tank and the ability to deal more damage against small hulls and a massive range.
Can be used similar to the HAM Legion for PVP, but got a lot more range.

Basilisk: Heavy tanked shield RR logi for bigger gangs.

Minmatar

Vagabound: Pretty much the solo skirmish hac, high speed, range, ok DPS. A weak capacitor is his main drawback, beside nearly everybody in it is terrible at flying it.

Muninn: Like a Zealot, but more flexible and with more alpha as a trade off for DPS as long range HAC.

Huginn/Rapier: Solid support ships, mostly used for long range webs and quite effective against most nano setups. Have not seen so much rapiers since the nano age. The EW got some use for Incrusion PVE.

Loki: Super tanked huginn for fleet pvp or super rupture for solo/small gang. It is ok for PVE, similar to the legion, however it is a pain to get a tanked arti setup working with the ac subs(that give you a lot more dps because of her extra drones) and you need tons of ammo for the ac setups.

Scimitar: Quick and nimble Logi for nano gangs, in expense of raw repping power compared to the Basilisk.

The Hics are pretty much the same, Gallente\Mini is a bit better for focus pointing and fitting sensor boosters for smaller stuff, Amarr\Caldari got the better staying power for bigger fights.
Drennon Nas
The Omega Syndicate
#7 - 2011-10-13 10:56:12 UTC
I just want to say thank you for the educated in depth responses. You've been very helpful.
Captain Nares
O3 Corporation
#8 - 2011-10-13 14:21:11 UTC
Best PvE SC - Tengu.
Best PvP SC - Tengu.

The only problem is that it is going to be nerfed over some time (next 10 years probably) Roll

I have all lvl5 Loki and what can I say about it:

PvE - much worse than Tengu.
PvP - much less interesting to fly than Cynabal and much more xpencive than Huginn/Rapier.
Goose99
#9 - 2011-10-13 15:26:14 UTC
Captain Nares wrote:
Best PvE SC - Tengu.
Best PvP SC - Tengu.

The only problem is that it is going to be nerfed over some time (next 10 years probably) Roll

I have all lvl5 Loki and what can I say about it:

PvE - much worse than Tengu.
PvP - much less interesting to fly than Cynabal and much more xpencive than Huginn/Rapier.


Check your kb stats.

Most numerous t3: Tengu
Least numerous t3: Proteus
T3 most killed: Tengu
T3 that get most kills: Proteus

Pve and pvp are different, undock moarBear
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#10 - 2011-10-13 19:35:13 UTC
Drennon Nas wrote:
I'm trying to decide what race I want to train advanced cruisers for.



Winmatar yesterday, winmatar today, winmatar tomorrow and the days after.
Mfume Apocal
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#11 - 2011-10-13 20:17:59 UTC
Goose99 wrote:
Check your kb stats.

Most numerous t3: Tengu
Least numerous t3: Proteus
T3 most killed: Tengu
T3 that get most kills: Proteus

Pve and pvp are different, undock moarBear


Quote:
Top 20 Kills by Shiptype
1 Drake 76819
2 Hurricane 50394
3 Abaddon 23947
...
11 Tengu 6728
Captain Nares
O3 Corporation
#12 - 2011-10-13 23:04:39 UTC  |  Edited by: Captain Nares
Goose99 wrote:

Check your kb stats.


1) Stats differ from KB to KB. Stats depend on KB owner.
2) After getting KB stats, you must interprete them properly.

Seems like you've failed at both points.

Btw, here are monthly top20 killers according to eve-kill:

Rank Ships Kills
1 Drake 79626
2 Hurricane 51451
3 Abaddon 26180
4 Maelstrom 20024
5 Armageddon 14584
6 Tempest 13030
7 Scimitar 10041
8 Dramiel 8337
9 Zealot 7843
10 Hound 6978
11 Tengu 6951
12 Sabre 6930
13 Cynabal 6694
14 Rifter 6391
15 Rapier 6259
16 Vagabond 6136
17 Harbinger 5618
18 Manticore 5581
19 Capsule 4822
20 Loki 4643
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#13 - 2011-10-14 16:47:47 UTC
Captain Nares wrote:
Goose99 wrote:

Check your kb stats.


1) Stats differ from KB to KB. Stats depend on KB owner.
2) After getting KB stats, you must interprete them properly.

Seems like you've failed at both points.

Btw, here are monthly top20 killers according to eve-kill:

Rank Ships Kills
1 Drake 79626
2 Hurricane 51451
3 Abaddon 26180
4 Maelstrom 20024
5 Armageddon 14584
6 Tempest 13030
7 Scimitar 10041
8 Dramiel 8337
9 Zealot 7843
10 Hound 6978
11 Tengu 6951
12 Sabre 6930
13 Cynabal 6694
14 Rifter 6391
15 Rapier 6259
16 Vagabond 6136
17 Harbinger 5618
18 Manticore 5581
19 Capsule 4822
20 Loki 4643


I'm looking for some Gallente ship but I can't see it, do you think I have some bug??
JackStraw56
Run Like an Antelope
#14 - 2011-10-14 16:53:57 UTC
Tanya Powers wrote:
I'm looking for some Gallente ship but I can't see it, do you think I have some bug??

Working as intended.
Neo Rainhart
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#15 - 2011-10-14 17:17:54 UTC  |  Edited by: Neo Rainhart
Tanya Powers wrote:
I'm looking for some Gallente ship but I can't see it, do you think I have some bug??


I'm sure you had too much PUDDI
Cipher Jones
The Thomas Edwards Taco Tuesday All Stars
#16 - 2011-10-15 14:40:18 UTC
Captain Nares wrote:
Goose99 wrote:

Check your kb stats.


1) Stats differ from KB to KB. Stats depend on KB owner.
2) After getting KB stats, you must interprete them properly.

Seems like you've failed at both points.

Btw, here are monthly top20 killers according to eve-kill:

Rank Ships Kills
1 Drake 79626
2 Hurricane 51451
3 Abaddon 26180
4 Maelstrom 20024
5 Armageddon 14584
6 Tempest 13030
7 Scimitar 10041
8 Dramiel 8337
9 Zealot 7843
10 Hound 6978
11 Tengu 6951
12 Sabre 6930
13 Cynabal 6694
14 Rifter 6391
15 Rapier 6259
16 Vagabond 6136
17 Harbinger 5618
18 Manticore 5581
19 Capsule 4822
20 Loki 4643


Hmm, so capsules kill more ships than loki's according to your information.

You have clearly done your research and are infallible.

internet spaceships

are serious business sir.

and don't forget it

Mocam
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#17 - 2011-10-16 00:39:20 UTC
Captain Nares wrote:
Goose99 wrote:

Check your kb stats.


1) Stats differ from KB to KB. Stats depend on KB owner.
2) After getting KB stats, you must interprete them properly.

Seems like you've failed at both points.

Btw, here are monthly top20 killers according to eve-kill:

Rank Ships Kills
1 Drake 79626
2 Hurricane 51451
3 Abaddon 26180
4 Maelstrom 20024
5 Armageddon 14584
6 Tempest 13030
7 Scimitar 10041
8 Dramiel 8337
9 Zealot 7843
10 Hound 6978
11 Tengu 6951
12 Sabre 6930
13 Cynabal 6694
14 Rifter 6391
15 Rapier 6259
16 Vagabond 6136
17 Harbinger 5618
18 Manticore 5581
19 Capsule 4822
20 Loki 4643


I monitored that list for about 8 months - it changes around quite a bit.

Examples:
- Tengu wasn't on it for a chunk of time then suddenly rose up very high as, I believe it was PL, stated to use gangs of them.
- Melstrom was on their big many months back as the "alpha mael" was very popular.
- Gallente ships show at times and other times don't.

FOTM style uses.

Another thing to look at is the WEAPONS used in kills - that gives a slightly different picture being as you'll often find hybrids in that list but few hybrid packing ships in the ships listing.

If a bit more looking is done, you'll get a better feel for the actual usage versus just hulls but that hulls list does help folks see what is currently popular for use.
Songbird
#18 - 2011-10-16 01:11:37 UTC
What do you mean you don't see gallente ships, all these capsules are all of gallente pilots !!!
Mfume Apocal
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#19 - 2011-10-16 06:04:52 UTC
Cipher Jones wrote:
Hmm, so capsules kill more ships than loki's according to your information.

You have clearly done your research and are infallible.


You are at any point free to show us anything indicating that the Proteus has more kills than the Tengu.
Zillam Reynardine
Stargazer Holdings
#20 - 2011-10-16 06:35:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Zillam Reynardine
Ishtar is awesome for zzzz PVE. Jump into a pocket, turn on your tank, get all of the aggro, drop sentries, orbit, come back in half an hour. Everything dead all around you.

I hear tell the Proteus makes for a good cloaked gankboat... since by the time someone is close enough to disrupt your cloak, they're close enough for you to facemelt with blasters. Plus, scrams out to ~15km.

Also, it's possible to 300k EHP buffertank a Proteus, if you just want to bore you foe into conceding the fight.

I PVE'd for a few months in both an Ishtar and a Blasteus. Both are pretty boring, but at least the Ishtar I could leave alone and it'd still explode things. Blasteus melts the hell out of cruisers and battleships, but can't hit frigates for anything (this is why you keep a bay full of hobs and hammers), and 7km shooting range means scooting around at 1.5km/s to get into range.
12Next page