These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Wormholes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Please fix ninja harvesting

Author
Sushi Nardieu
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#21 - 2013-02-08 04:21:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Sushi Nardieu
I just want an opportunity to gank ships that clear ladar sites. Please gift this to w-space CCP.

Ninjaing is too EZ.

I wanna see TENG00S, CARRIERS and other expensive things out in space.

The Guns of Knowledge 

Nobutada Mishi
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#22 - 2013-02-08 05:00:32 UTC
Sushi Nardieu wrote:
I just want an opportunity to gank ships that clear ladar sites. Please gift this to w-space CCP.

Ninjaing is too EZ.

I wanna see TENG00S, CARRIERS and other expensive things out in space.

finally...someone who isn't mentally ********
Winthorp
#23 - 2013-02-08 05:57:12 UTC
Nobutada Mishi wrote:
Sushi Nardieu wrote:
I just want an opportunity to gank ships that clear ladar sites. Please gift this to w-space CCP.

Ninjaing is too EZ.

I wanna see TENG00S, CARRIERS and other expensive things out in space.

finally...someone who isn't mentally ********


I wouldn't be too convinced of that.
Marsan
#24 - 2013-02-08 08:12:26 UTC
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.

Former forum cheerleader CCP, now just a grumpy small portion of the community.

Borlag Crendraven
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#25 - 2013-02-08 08:20:26 UTC
Marsan wrote:
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.


The venture has a ton of advantages when compared to cruisers, starting from being harder to scan down due to smaller signature and the possibility of fitting ECCM to make it even harder, they are also much faster and as such you can orbit the clouds to make getting warpins directly to you much more difficult. On top of that the clouds themselves uncloak everything that tries to sneak up on you on grid and if that's not enough, you'll have a vastly improved alignment speed and as a frigate, getting a lock on you takes more time than it does to lock a cruiser.

And it's not just a little faster, it's the fastest gas harvester in the game when properly trained.
Bamsey Amraa
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#26 - 2013-02-08 08:51:26 UTC
Where is the problem? Gas is cheaper then T3 price is low and its mean i can do more pew pew in my Proteus... i feel good with that
Qvar Dar'Zanar
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#27 - 2013-02-08 10:39:19 UTC
Bamsey Amraa wrote:
Where is the problem? Gas is cheaper then T3 price is low and its mean i can do more pew pew in my Proteus... i feel good with that


WHAT?? You're not absurdly rich? Away with you, outcast!
Senn Denroth
Lazerhawks
L A Z E R H A W K S
#28 - 2013-02-08 10:49:43 UTC  |  Edited by: Senn Denroth
"PVP" corp... wanting to gank miners...

How do these people even manage to create accounts
QT McWhiskers
MultiPass Inc.
The 5th Seal
#29 - 2013-02-08 11:30:27 UTC  |  Edited by: QT McWhiskers
Derath Ellecon wrote:
And who cares about gas prices? I can make more in 20min running a site than an hour mining gas. Let them have it.


A year ago, gas prices were upwards of 150k per unit for 320 and about 70-90k per unit for the 540. I remember one night, using cruisers and old style can mining, with only 3 people online, we had a static that had 4 instrumentals in it, 3 vitals, and had a c2 static that had a high sec in sobaseki. (1 jump to jita) We gassed out all the instrumentals and the vitals ran the gas to jita. Using JUST the profits from the gas, I bought a replacement bhaalgorn and a redeemer fully fit. I still had about a bil left over from this.

Today, if I were to pull off the same feet, I would barely be able to buy the bhaalgorn.
Borlag Crendraven
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#30 - 2013-02-08 11:50:03 UTC
QT McWhiskers wrote:
Derath Ellecon wrote:
And who cares about gas prices? I can make more in 20min running a site than an hour mining gas. Let them have it.


A year ago, gas prices were upwards of 150k per unit for 320 and about 70-90k per unit for the 540. I remember one night, using cruisers and old style can mining, with only 3 people online, we had a static that had 4 instrumentals in it, 3 vitals, and had a c2 static that had a high sec in sobaseki. (1 jump to jita) We gassed out all the instrumentals and the vitals ran the gas to jita. Using JUST the profits from the gas, I bought a replacement bhaalgorn and a redeemer fully fit. I still had about a bil left over from this.

Today, if I were to pull off the same feet, I would barely be able to buy the bhaalgorn.


Depending on how you look at things, that may or may not be a bad thing at all... Isk is already way too easy to come by.
Rek Seven
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#31 - 2013-02-08 11:59:48 UTC
Borlag Crendraven wrote:
Marsan wrote:
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.


The venture has a ton of advantages when compared to cruisers, starting from being harder to scan down due to smaller signature and the possibility of fitting ECCM to make it even harder, they are also much faster and as such you can orbit the clouds to make getting warpins directly to you much more difficult. On top of that the clouds themselves uncloak everything that tries to sneak up on you on grid and if that's not enough, you'll have a vastly improved alignment speed and as a frigate, getting a lock on you takes more time than it does to lock a cruiser.

And it's not just a little faster, it's the fastest gas harvester in the game when properly trained.


Add to all that the massive ore bay means that the venture doesn't need to make regular drop offs or call for collection. This reduces a hunters opportunity to catch a miner unawares.

You have 2 options now - while the pilot is in system scan the wormhole he came from or scan the ship and pray he is afk.
Winthorp
#32 - 2013-02-08 13:08:06 UTC
QT McWhiskers wrote:
Derath Ellecon wrote:
And who cares about gas prices? I can make more in 20min running a site than an hour mining gas. Let them have it.


A year ago, gas prices were upwards of 150k per unit for 320 and about 70-90k per unit for the 540. I remember one night, using cruisers and old style can mining, with only 3 people online, we had a static that had 4 instrumentals in it, 3 vitals, and had a c2 static that had a high sec in sobaseki. (1 jump to jita) We gassed out all the instrumentals and the vitals ran the gas to jita. Using JUST the profits from the gas, I bought a replacement bhaalgorn and a redeemer fully fit. I still had about a bil left over from this.

Today, if I were to pull off the same feet, I would barely be able to buy the bhaalgorn.


Bhaalgorns are ****, you should be thankful you can now not afford them. Lol
Derath Ellecon
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#33 - 2013-02-08 13:45:59 UTC
QT McWhiskers wrote:
Derath Ellecon wrote:
And who cares about gas prices? I can make more in 20min running a site than an hour mining gas. Let them have it.


A year ago, gas prices were upwards of 150k per unit for 320 and about 70-90k per unit for the 540. I remember one night, using cruisers and old style can mining, with only 3 people online, we had a static that had 4 instrumentals in it, 3 vitals, and had a c2 static that had a high sec in sobaseki. (1 jump to jita) We gassed out all the instrumentals and the vitals ran the gas to jita. Using JUST the profits from the gas, I bought a replacement bhaalgorn and a redeemer fully fit. I still had about a bil left over from this.

Today, if I were to pull off the same feet, I would barely be able to buy the bhaalgorn.


Kind of misses the point but ok.

A couple things to note.

First, in terms of prices. If you look at C540, the price has fluctuated wildly in the last year. If you did do this about a year ago, you got a luckly spike. 540 gas was down almost as low as it is now last July. So while the venture may be a contributing factor right now in the gas price fall, historically gas goes up and down a ton to begin with.

Which flows into the second point. Gas is a commodity like many other items in EVE. When it is overproduced, prices fall. When prices fall enough, some people will decide its not worth the effort to harvest, which will bring down supply yada yada.

And the last point, which was my main one is still who really cares? So according to your numbers above, at 90,000 isk for C540, a Venture (if it had existed then) would harvest at a rate of about 86 million an hour. While that's nothing to scoff at, it is important to note this is C5 income (as I have never seen a C540 cloud below C5). So to compare that, what kind of per person isk/hr are those cap escalated sleeper sites? I know it has to be good, cause I can easily beat 86 mil/hr running C4 sites alone. Not to mention that after an hour of C4 sties I will probably have maybe 200m3 of loot to haul to market, while an hour of venture harvesting C540 will yield more gas than can fit in a blockade runner.


Dino Boff
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2013-02-08 17:18:22 UTC
The C320 prices went down with the demand for tengu, either because of the nerf or because NS tengu blobs are gone.

It's probably a good time to fix sleeper aggro.
Borlag Crendraven
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#35 - 2013-02-08 18:03:17 UTC
Rek Seven wrote:

Add to all that the massive ore bay means that the venture doesn't need to make regular drop offs or call for collection. This reduces a hunters opportunity to catch a miner unawares.

You have 2 options now - while the pilot is in system scan the wormhole he came from or scan the ship and pray he is afk.


Yup, though I concentrated on pointing out the things that make the Venture extremely safe to use, even in hostile situations. Unless you can trap it in a bubble, you're pretty much out of lucky catching it entirely. That said, I don't consider this that big of an issue, thanks to the ventures themselves not posing any risk to you either.
Marsan
#36 - 2013-02-08 23:59:56 UTC
Borlag Crendraven wrote:
Marsan wrote:
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.


The venture has a ton of advantages when compared to cruisers, starting from being harder to scan down due to smaller signature and the possibility of fitting ECCM to make it even harder, they are also much faster and as such you can orbit the clouds to make getting warpins directly to you much more difficult. On top of that the clouds themselves uncloak everything that tries to sneak up on you on grid and if that's not enough, you'll have a vastly improved alignment speed and as a frigate, getting a lock on you takes more time than it does to lock a cruiser.

And it's not just a little faster, it's the fastest gas harvester in the game when properly trained.


- I can fit ECCM on my cruiser too. Not to mention you are an idiot if you use combat to scan down gas miners. Use dscan to narrow things down and scan down the bloody site with core probes in a single quick scan.
- If clouds are uncloaking you need to reconsider how you hunt gassers.
- A smart miner is either orbiting or aligned with an AB or MW

It sounds like you just miss idiots jet can mining at a dead stop.

Former forum cheerleader CCP, now just a grumpy small portion of the community.

Phaderift
Girls Lie But Zkill Doesn't
Pandemic Legion
#37 - 2013-02-09 00:29:02 UTC
Marsan wrote:
Borlag Crendraven wrote:
Marsan wrote:
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.


The venture has a ton of advantages when compared to cruisers, starting from being harder to scan down due to smaller signature and the possibility of fitting ECCM to make it even harder, they are also much faster and as such you can orbit the clouds to make getting warpins directly to you much more difficult. On top of that the clouds themselves uncloak everything that tries to sneak up on you on grid and if that's not enough, you'll have a vastly improved alignment speed and as a frigate, getting a lock on you takes more time than it does to lock a cruiser.

And it's not just a little faster, it's the fastest gas harvester in the game when properly trained.


- I can fit ECCM on my cruiser too. Not to mention you are an idiot if you use combat to scan down gas miners. Use dscan to narrow things down and scan down the bloody site with core probes in a single quick scan.
- If clouds are uncloaking you need to reconsider how you hunt gassers.
- A smart miner is either orbiting or aligned with an AB or MW

It sounds like you just miss idiots jet can mining at a dead stop.



not true

with the way you ninja mine you are almost always standing still on the cloud and the rats are at the warp in. so either need to combat them or spend probably 20 minutes avoiding clouds and the sleepers to get close enough to them for tackle if you just scan down the site .. at which point if you don't have 3 points of tackle they just align and warp out :p heck if you are in anything but a bomber they will probably be warped out before you get the cloak no lock timer to wear off :p The ventures are a very purpose built ship, and they do what they were designed to do very well .. best bet ... bubble their return hole then spook them .. gets most gas suckers .... 90% of the time
Borlag Crendraven
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#38 - 2013-02-09 00:38:03 UTC
Marsan wrote:
Borlag Crendraven wrote:
Marsan wrote:
How exact is the venture worse than a cruiser with a few warp stabs? It mines a little faster to be sure, but by that logic we'd be all still be mining in cruisers.


The venture has a ton of advantages when compared to cruisers, starting from being harder to scan down due to smaller signature and the possibility of fitting ECCM to make it even harder, they are also much faster and as such you can orbit the clouds to make getting warpins directly to you much more difficult. On top of that the clouds themselves uncloak everything that tries to sneak up on you on grid and if that's not enough, you'll have a vastly improved alignment speed and as a frigate, getting a lock on you takes more time than it does to lock a cruiser.

And it's not just a little faster, it's the fastest gas harvester in the game when properly trained.


- I can fit ECCM on my cruiser too. Not to mention you are an idiot if you use combat to scan down gas miners. Use dscan to narrow things down and scan down the bloody site with core probes in a single quick scan.
- If clouds are uncloaking you need to reconsider how you hunt gassers.
- A smart miner is either orbiting or aligned with an AB or MW

It sounds like you just miss idiots jet can mining at a dead stop.


Heh...

I have no issues popping ventures myself, because I know how to do it properly, your way leads into nothing but lost kills. I merely stated the numerous advantages the Venture has over cruisers. It appears you also don't know how the signature radius and sensor strength affect the difficulty or probing down stuff, yet are trying to lecture me about it?

Simply put, if you try to catch Ventures in the sites themselves, you are doing it wrong. They have literally every single advantage possible for the numerous reasons I stated above.
Piugattuk
Litla Sundlaugin
#39 - 2013-02-09 02:15:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Piugattuk
You should have done as that other poster siad, just wait till the novelty wore out and save any gas you mine yourself, gank the ninjas then when prices rose profit.

But since CCP is now aware you killed a good thing for isk for yourself with reduce risk, not being a smack talker but that wasn't smart.

Funny though, since it will get harder then the easier soft novelty players that you can kill will leave and prices will climb but the risk taker is gonna become more greedy to mine even more, putting isk in their pockets. Big smile
Jess Tanner
Bangworks Systems Inc.
#40 - 2013-02-10 06:56:08 UTC