These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

You did it to yourselves - Yet Another Boost null/low, nerf hi thread, except not.

Author
CraftyCroc
Fraternity Alliance Please Ignore
#101 - 2012-12-30 17:45:50 UTC
All of these threads have 0.0 F1 monkeys complaining about null being all blue.

Why not drop roles and move onto something a little more exciting?
POKER ALICE
Moonshine Monks Gentlemans Club
#102 - 2012-12-30 17:51:45 UTC
Quote:
So, I've read a ton of back and forth on this, and here's my question. Is there actually, really, a lack of industrial ability in null, or is it nullseccers wanting industrialists in a place where they can get gudfites?



They just need more industrialist slaves to build their toys.

"If you're not willing to fight for what you have in ≡v≡ you don't deserve it, and you will lose it. And if you dont deserve what you have and we cant make you lose it, we will ask CCP to nerf it"

Qolde
Scrambled Eggs Inc.
#103 - 2012-12-30 17:53:47 UTC
My 0.0 corp has almost 0 blues, and there are 0 F1 monkeys in it. Secondly, I'm not complaining about the circlejerk status of null, I'm asking CFHBC and Solar to leverage it in favor of all of 0.0. Burn Jita II, The market edition.

If someone craps in your sandbox: 1. Light it on fire 2. Grab your shovel 3. Throw it back at them.

Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#104 - 2012-12-30 17:55:29 UTC
CraftyCroc wrote:
All of these threads have 0.0 F1 monkeys complaining about null being all blue.

Why not drop roles and move onto something a little more exciting?

Hilarious we just had some drama after people shooting one another. It's exciting !

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

Randolph Rothstein
whatever corp.
#105 - 2012-12-30 17:57:30 UTC
Qolde wrote:
It's not impossible. Especially if most of the people in the game hate going to Jita. The only people who really like Jita and don't want it to change are trade bots. Everyone else could give a ****, as long as they can get what they need. Nullsec and lowsec citizens collectively have trillions of isk. I admit, it is a part of the whole prisoner's dilemma that shapes the interactions of the game, but why can't we all see that, and fix it? We're smarter than game theory.


the problem is not in money or even time

the problem is people are a55holes,the second you start to sell stuff for lower price (lower price to attract people and create volume) in the new hub you are trying to create,you d have bunch of people buying the cheap stuff and reselling it at jita or anywhere else in high sec - even if you managed to get 50% of null sec folk (which is lets be honest unrealistic) to not sell stuff at jita the other 50% would trip you just to make quick isk off that - and remember once you stop selling at jita prices will go up and thats even more fuel to market speculation fire

building a fleet of titans is a childs play compared to making people trust your idea and actually act upon it,and its not like thousand people,you d need tens of thousands of players to make that commitment - thats such monumental task that if you managed to pull it off id vote for you becoming the jesus of new eden
Frostys Virpio
State War Academy
Caldari State
#106 - 2012-12-30 18:03:43 UTC
Qolde wrote:
It's not impossible. Especially if most of the people in the game hate going to Jita. The only people who really like Jita and don't want it to change are trade bots. Everyone else could give a ****, as long as they can get what they need. Nullsec and lowsec citizens collectively have trillions of isk. I admit, it is a part of the whole prisoner's dilemma that shapes the interactions of the game, but why can't we all see that, and fix it? We're smarter than game theory.


How do you prevent every single player in null from selling in Jita? Thats the core of the roblem every single time a group of player want to gouge the rest into a different market. Even if HBC and CFC said no one ever sell in high, do you really think not a single guy would go out of his way with alt to sell at the much higher price once the current supply would have melted? How about the rest of null not in CFC of HBC? Who block them from selling in high?

Your proposition sounds like when some miners said they should stop selling trit untill hulkageddon stopped effctively stopping the supply of ships to gank with. It never work because everybody has it's own price at wich he will say **** it I sell anyway.
Sergeant Acht Scultz
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#107 - 2012-12-30 18:13:48 UTC
Randolph Rothstein wrote:
Qolde wrote:
It's not impossible. Especially if most of the people in the game hate going to Jita. The only people who really like Jita and don't want it to change are trade bots. Everyone else could give a ****, as long as they can get what they need. Nullsec and lowsec citizens collectively have trillions of isk. I admit, it is a part of the whole prisoner's dilemma that shapes the interactions of the game, but why can't we all see that, and fix it? We're smarter than game theory.


the problem is not in money or even time

the problem is people are a55holes,the second you start to sell stuff for lower price (lower price to attract people and create volume) in the new hub you are trying to create,you d have bunch of people buying the cheap stuff and reselling it at jita or anywhere else in high sec - even if you managed to get 50% of null sec folk (which is lets be honest unrealistic) to not sell stuff at jita the other 50% would trip you just to make quick isk off that - and remember once you stop selling at jita prices will go up and thats even more fuel to market speculation fire

building a fleet of titans is a childs play compared to making people trust your idea and actually act upon it,and its not like thousand people,you d need tens of thousands of players to make that commitment - thats such monumental task that if you managed to pull it off id vote for you becoming the jesus of new eden




One of the reasons why trading needs "regulation" or nerf hammer.

removed inappropriate ASCII art signature - CCP Eterne

Qolde
Scrambled Eggs Inc.
#108 - 2012-12-30 18:15:52 UTC
If you sell slightly below Jita prices, and people buy it to relist in Jita, you then raise prices. You're still selling it at the same rate, with less travel time. Time > the puny amount of Money you'd gain by risking 4 extra JF jumps to get to jita yourself. It benefits the producer, the trader, the speculator, the people on the fringe of empire. Even if a few entities continue to sell in Jita, they'd eventually be losing, because there'd be new trade hubs that have buy orders up for higher than Jita prices, looking for things they can't get locally. Say the north needs a bunch of vagabonds, and jita's selling fernite plates at 8k, and in akkio, which is next door to metropolis where the **** grows on trees, they're selling at 7.5k, and all the other things they need are there as well, for reasonable prices, why would you want to go to Jita, which is further away, and is now the victim of not being as supplied as it once was?

The CFHBC really is like 75% of null now. There's no reason for them to sell in Jita when the cons outweigh the pros. They've already done many things as a group that have affected markets for their own benefit. Did goons mine ice in empire during their ice interdiction? Did they sell tech to buy orders doing OTEC? Did they whine about ship losses during Burn Jita? This time the benefit wouldn't be isk, for them it would be something even better. Isk per effort. Adding on top of that the opportunity for kills in lowsec/npcnull (I know someone has to camp the lowsec trade hubsPirate). I really do believe this idea can take hold, because there are still other trade hubs. They just need t2 components from the producers in their respective regions. Even hisec will benefit from this, just not the ones around Jita.

If someone craps in your sandbox: 1. Light it on fire 2. Grab your shovel 3. Throw it back at them.

Ritsum
Perkone
Caldari State
#109 - 2012-12-30 18:34:13 UTC
Qolde wrote:
For us 0.0 residents who blame all things bad on carebears, we must realize that we do this to ourselves. Hisec in its current form could not exist without our blessings, and decisions to make their lives so convenient and fruitful. Most tech 2 manufacturing and even large ship manufacturing takes place in empire, yet the amount of megacyte, morphite and zydrine required to make this possible ALL must come from nullsec. Every single t2 material that exists must be harvested and processed outside of hisec. So why do we all ferry our goods straight to the carebear capital in Jita?

We know why we do. Because everyone else does, and that's where buyers go. Sensible, logical, and efficient. Now consider this proposal. All nullsec/lowsec organizations who have an interest in making null more active shall flat out refuse to sell anything in any hisec system for at least 3 months. Put it up in a lowsec npc nullsec system near your home for around Jita prices. If one or two small corps do this, it's almost meaningless. But if one of the supercoalitions could see the potential of this change in habits, the results would be awesome for us, and ****** for hisec players.

The outcomes I see would be all good:
Lowsec and NPCNull Trade hubs around the borders of 0.0 would spring to life, presenting trade opportunities to fill the eternal demand of t2 materials in jita.

Pirates notice these trade hubs, and do their thing, possibly decreasing the supply of materials even further, through item destruction. Even better isk for the producer of said goods.

Nullsec denizens save on jump fuel from trying to clear the whole universe just to get to jita and sell to a trade bots buy orders.

Smart cookies start interregional trading routes, balancing out these lowsec/null trade hubs with materials from each major part of space, making the availablity rival jita, and closer to the outer edges of empire, moving production away from The Forge slowly but surely.

0.0 industry fixed
lowsec populated
risk vs reward realized.
delicious tears from the true carebears.

only problem i can think of is getting the supercoalitions to agree on something.



And while everyone else is trying to sell at these other hubs you will be selling everything at Jita at premium prices, am I doing it right?

Play EvE how you want to play it and do not let others dictate how you play. Evolve your playstyle to protect yourself from others! Even in "PVE", "PVP" is there, lurking in the shadows.

Skydell
Bad Girl Posse
#110 - 2012-12-30 18:34:16 UTC
Many of the Null establishments rely on the T2 income to pay their Sov bills. Even Goons would be forced to cherry pick their Sov if they couldn't sell Technetium for 3 or 4 months.

None of the Null toys are worth their salt. From faction ships to officer mods to T2.

If you know you are going to be sitting in a mission hub running missions, a meta 4 fit Raven with faction Ammo is all you need. Any scenario where you will lose that Meta 4 fit Raven, the same will happen with an Officer fit Golem. From the ISK to bonus perspective, Null doesn't compete.
Randolph Rothstein
whatever corp.
#111 - 2012-12-30 18:47:02 UTC
Qolde wrote:
If you sell slightly below Jita prices, and people buy it to relist in Jita, you then raise prices. You're still selling it at the same rate, with less travel time. Time > the puny amount of Money you'd gain by risking 4 extra JF jumps to get to jita yourself. It benefits the producer, the trader, the speculator, the people on the fringe of empire. Even if a few entities continue to sell in Jita, they'd eventually be losing, because there'd be new trade hubs that have buy orders up for higher than Jita prices, looking for things they can't get locally. Say the north needs a bunch of vagabonds, and jita's selling fernite plates at 8k, and in akkio, which is next door to metropolis where the **** grows on trees, they're selling at 7.5k, and all the other things they need are there as well, for reasonable prices, why would you want to go to Jita, which is further away, and is now the victim of not being as supplied as it once was?

The CFHBC really is like 75% of null now. There's no reason for them to sell in Jita when the cons outweigh the pros. They've already done many things as a group that have affected markets for their own benefit. Did goons mine ice in empire during their ice interdiction? Did they sell tech to buy orders doing OTEC? Did they whine about ship losses during Burn Jita? This time the benefit wouldn't be isk, for them it would be something even better. Isk per effort. Adding on top of that the opportunity for kills in lowsec/npcnull (I know someone has to camp the lowsec trade hubsPirate). I really do believe this idea can take hold, because there are still other trade hubs. They just need t2 components from the producers in their respective regions. Even hisec will benefit from this, just not the ones around Jita.


you are failing right there trying to create null sec hub in alliance space

meaning that high sec players and low sec players not in that one alliance would simply not trade there - which turns your hub to flea market

i might be pesimistic here but i really think that at least some of the alliance players would do the math and realized they could make more money on T2 stuff than ever before - on their alts ofc,if i was in that alliance the first thing id do would be figuring out how can i make the money out of it alliance be damned - it would actually spark my game,because all of a sudden id be traitor in disguisse,double agent - holy sjit that would be awesome Shocked
Piugattuk
Litla Sundlaugin
#112 - 2012-12-30 18:58:46 UTC
Qolde wrote:
For us 0.0 residents who blame all things bad on carebears, we must realize that we do this to ourselves. Hisec in its current form could not exist without our blessings, and decisions to make their lives so convenient and fruitful. Most tech 2 manufacturing and even large ship manufacturing takes place in empire, yet the amount of megacyte, morphite and zydrine required to make this possible ALL must come from nullsec. Every single t2 material that exists must be harvested and processed outside of hisec. So why do we all ferry our goods straight to the carebear capital in Jita?

We know why we do. Because everyone else does, and that's where buyers go. Sensible, logical, and efficient. Now consider this proposal. All nullsec/lowsec organizations who have an interest in making null more active shall flat out refuse to sell anything in any hisec system for at least 3 months. Put it up in a lowsec npc nullsec system near your home for around Jita prices. If one or two small corps do this, it's almost meaningless. But if one of the supercoalitions could see the potential of this change in habits, the results would be awesome for us, and ****** for hisec players.

The outcomes I see would be all good:
Lowsec and NPCNull Trade hubs around the borders of 0.0 would spring to life, presenting trade opportunities to fill the eternal demand of t2 materials in jita.

Pirates notice these trade hubs, and do their thing, possibly decreasing the supply of materials even further, through item destruction. Even better isk for the producer of said goods.

Nullsec denizens save on jump fuel from trying to clear the whole universe just to get to jita and sell to a trade bots buy orders.

Smart cookies start interregional trading routes, balancing out these lowsec/null trade hubs with materials from each major part of space, making the availablity rival jita, and closer to the outer edges of empire, moving production away from The Forge slowly but surely.

0.0 industry fixed
lowsec populated
risk vs reward realized.
delicious tears from the true carebears.

only problem i can think of is getting the supercoalitions to agree on something.


Finally one guy gets it, I'm a carebear I wish you luck in this endeavour and I'm not kidding.
Qolde
Scrambled Eggs Inc.
#113 - 2012-12-30 19:01:28 UTC
Skydell wrote:
Many of the Null establishments rely on the T2 income to pay their Sov bills. Even Goons would be forced to cherry pick their Sov if they couldn't sell Technetium for 3 or 4 months.

None of the Null toys are worth their salt. From faction ships to officer mods to T2.

If you know you are going to be sitting in a mission hub running missions, a meta 4 fit Raven with faction Ammo is all you need. Any scenario where you will lose that Meta 4 fit Raven, the same will happen with an Officer fit Golem. From the ISK to bonus perspective, Null doesn't compete.


Technetium is going to sell no matter where you place it, so is neodymium, dysprosium, and whatever else you can imagine. If C+H left their sell orders up in jita, and just placed their new stock in lowsec at Jita prices, it would start to sell before the old stock was gone. T2 would skyrocket either way. You're out of your head if you think that there is a single alliance in the game who would field t2 weapons during a fleet op. You're out of your head even more if you think a carebear would dare trade in his golem for a raven. A mach for a mael. That's called supply and demand. The machariel blueprint would be worth 400-500m if it followed the LP formula of other items. If it weren't worth its salt, it would not be used. I do agree that it's expensive, but it's not overpriced. Gate camping without a claymore? Sucks. Abaddon fleet without a damnation or loki? crazy talk. Blasters without null? Pffffft. What are you smoking?

Randolph, it definitely wouldn't be joe shmoe making these decisions. If they have a tech moon, then they probably arent joe shmoe, who would try to benefit in the wallet in most cases. But there's something nice about some Nullsec organizations. The concept of a team. BoB had it. Some of their corps were 100% communist. Goons have it, they get free ships and mods, and have no rules. They could say in a coalition mail,"We're going to starve Jita for t2 goods, everyone sell your moonshit in Maila(lowsec that is 10 hisec jumps from jita) for a while. Go camp there, watch the tears." The players with brains and balls would figure out how to win. (it's not hard in lowsec) The rest would take a pay cut. Tech sells either way. Price even goes up, with how much would be destroyed in transit during the learning process. T2 harvesters have less work, more profit, and traders have something fun to do.

C+H guys, see what your market and military overlords think of this idea. Point them to this thread. Someone get akita t to check it out too and do some magic market speculation.

If someone craps in your sandbox: 1. Light it on fire 2. Grab your shovel 3. Throw it back at them.

Randolph Rothstein
whatever corp.
#114 - 2012-12-30 19:14:09 UTC
well there is another problem

you said 75% on null are friendly or whatever

what if they fall apart? you spent a year trying to lure people out of jita when suddenly you are no longer friends with other and you will loose access to that hub

are you ready to risk it?

im not arguing that its impossible to do that at all,im saying that its a monumental goal that would require a lot of things not to go down to sjithouse - thats why lowsec peeps havent even try that (and if they tried it was so insignificant nobody noticed) and they keep whining on forums asking ccp to fix low sec

btw for me it would be obvious task,if i was a leader of a giant alliance id want to do that - seeing that not happening tells me that either they are incompetent or they dont trust each other or they dont trust members enough to pull it off or they are simply lazy and whining to ccp is easier to do
Seven Koskanaiken
Shadow Legions.
SONS of BANE
#115 - 2012-12-30 19:15:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Seven Koskanaiken
Dave stark wrote:
i'm actually quite eager to see hbc/cfc have control of null. something will have to give once everywhere is owned by one entity (give or take), and i think that'll bring about some interesting events.
i could, of course, be over optimistic and talking out of my ass. only time will tell.


if the winner of a competition is rewarded with the means to win even more competitions then the logical systemic result is the elimation of all other competitors
this is the point behind the game Monopoly, eventually one person ends up with everything and it becomes unplayable
in real life you get around this by using innovation
in eve there is no innovation, just min maxing
Qolde
Scrambled Eggs Inc.
#116 - 2012-12-30 19:20:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Qolde
Randolph Rothstein wrote:
well there is another problem

you said 75% on null are friendly or whatever

what if they fall apart? you spent a year trying to lure people out of jita when suddenly you are no longer friends with other and you will loose access to that hub

are you ready to risk it?

im not arguing that its impossible to do that at all,im saying that its a monumental goal that would require a lot of things not to go down to sjithouse - thats why lowsec peeps havent even try that (and if they tried it was so insignificant nobody noticed) and they keep whining on forums asking ccp to fix low sec

btw for me it would be obvious task,if i was a leader of a giant alliance id want to do that - seeing that not happening tells me that either they are incompetent or they dont trust each other or they dont trust members enough to pull it off or they are simply lazy and whining to ccp is easier to do

lowsec. lowsec. lowsec. you cannot lose access to lowsec. you can be camped in a station pretty hard, but you can ALWAYS escape(if youre not a tard), especially if it's a trade hub. You have undock bookmarks, interceptors, covert ops, black ops, jump freighters, and all manner of tools at your disposal to never be trapped in a station. An NPC null station can be bubblecamped, this is quite different. You might need a covops alt to scout for bubbles. Roll

Even if your assets are locked in a player owned station, you can still sell them and you can deliver completed S&I projects. Science & Market skills, ftw.

If someone craps in your sandbox: 1. Light it on fire 2. Grab your shovel 3. Throw it back at them.

Randolph Rothstein
whatever corp.
#117 - 2012-12-30 19:27:34 UTC
Qolde wrote:
Randolph Rothstein wrote:
well there is another problem

you said 75% on null are friendly or whatever

what if they fall apart? you spent a year trying to lure people out of jita when suddenly you are no longer friends with other and you will loose access to that hub

are you ready to risk it?

im not arguing that its impossible to do that at all,im saying that its a monumental goal that would require a lot of things not to go down to sjithouse - thats why lowsec peeps havent even try that (and if they tried it was so insignificant nobody noticed) and they keep whining on forums asking ccp to fix low sec

btw for me it would be obvious task,if i was a leader of a giant alliance id want to do that - seeing that not happening tells me that either they are incompetent or they dont trust each other or they dont trust members enough to pull it off or they are simply lazy and whining to ccp is easier to do

lowsec. lowsec. lowsec. you cannot lose access to lowsec. you can be camped in a station pretty hard, but you can ALWAYS escape(if youre not a tard), especially if it's a trade hub. You have undock bookmarks, interceptors, covert ops, black ops, jump freighters, and all manner of tools at your disposal to never be trapped in a station. An NPC null station can be bubblecamped, this is quite different. You might need a covops alt to scout for bubbles. Roll


you just described a lot of stuff im not willing to deal with,id just pay a 1M more in jita than fooling around with that
Nicolo da'Vicenza
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#118 - 2012-12-30 19:29:02 UTC
POKER ALICE wrote:
Quote:
So, I've read a ton of back and forth on this, and here's my question. Is there actually, really, a lack of industrial ability in null, or is it nullseccers wanting industrialists in a place where they can get gudfites?



They just need more industrialist slaves to build their toys.

we already have those (you)
Qolde
Scrambled Eggs Inc.
#119 - 2012-12-30 19:30:09 UTC
Nicolo da'Vicenza wrote:
POKER ALICE wrote:
Quote:
So, I've read a ton of back and forth on this, and here's my question. Is there actually, really, a lack of industrial ability in null, or is it nullseccers wanting industrialists in a place where they can get gudfites?



They just need more industrialist slaves to build their toys.

we already have those (you)

Just want them closer to null.

If someone craps in your sandbox: 1. Light it on fire 2. Grab your shovel 3. Throw it back at them.

Malcanis
Vanishing Point.
The Initiative.
#120 - 2012-12-30 19:30:53 UTC
Randolph Rothstein wrote:
so heres idea for you lowsec people

stop selling all your stuff at jita,right now

dont wait untill ccp does something,be proactive - maybe if you start actually doing something,ccp will notice you

you talk way too much and act way to little

and im not saying this because i have large quantities of low sec ore stored or low sec alts Roll



Please do inform us how this will add extra manufacturing and research lines to nullsec stations, or allow more than one per system or pay Sov bills or pay for stations.

I'm fascinated to learn.

"Just remember later that I warned against any change to jump ranges or fatigue. You earned whats coming."

Grath Telkin, 11.10.2016