These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

By what right?

Author
Ssakaa
Animatar Foundation
#21 - 2012-12-10 11:18:33 UTC
Out of interest, Halete, why do you consider the Federation as, as you put it, a "dangerous, reprehensible beast"?

Would you care to share?

"Modern Life is Rubbish"

Astera Zandraki
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#22 - 2012-12-10 12:13:51 UTC
I am curious to know this as well, what is so evil about the Federation in your eyes Ms. Halete?
Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#23 - 2012-12-10 12:30:38 UTC
Out of respect; I wouldn't care to share. I've already answered with my take on the topic and don't wish to de-rail the subject any further.

Fragments of my stance on the Federation are littered about these boards if you feel so compelled to discover more. Alternatively, you can speak to me. But this isn't the place, especially with the likes of Inhonores present.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Anslo
Scope Works
#24 - 2012-12-10 13:54:12 UTC
Oh don't be shy Halete. Go ahead. Why do you hate us?

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]

Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#25 - 2012-12-10 15:00:27 UTC
Anslo wrote:
Oh don't be shy Halete. Go ahead. Why do you hate us?


Bite my ****, pretty-boy.

No means no. Something that your kind would have done well to learn from the Caldari.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Anslo
Scope Works
#26 - 2012-12-10 15:04:44 UTC
Halete wrote:
Anslo wrote:
Oh don't be shy Halete. Go ahead. Why do you hate us?


Bite my ****, pretty-boy.

No means no. Something that your kind would have done well to learn from the Caldari.


Hit a nerve? No need to be bitchy. You brought it up. If you didn't want to talk about it, you wouldn't have mentioned it. In that case, you're screaming for attention. So don't come at me when people ask.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]

Halete
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#27 - 2012-12-10 15:09:39 UTC
Anslo wrote:

Hit a nerve? No need to be bitchy. You brought it up. If you didn't want to talk about it, you wouldn't have mentioned it. In that case, you're screaming for attention. So don't come at me when people ask.


You're wrong. We brought it up because it was relevant and went into no more detail than sufficient to answer his question.

I don't want any more attention. I asked to be shown some respect or to be contacted privately and you did not show me that decency.

Now please, drop it. Your replies feel like some strange invasion of my person and I wish the sensation to cease.

"To know the true path, but yet, to never follow it. That is possibly the gravest sin" - The Scriptures, Book of Missions 13:21

Logan Fyreite
Grim Bit Interface
#28 - 2012-12-10 15:19:32 UTC
I find this very interesting.

I would say I have been, hmmm, shall we say, outside of the influence of the empires for years now. But not once have I ever heard someone call me "not Minmatar." Well at least not to my face. I have also never seen it happen in the Summit on on these channels in such frequency that it requires special Seri comment on.

The whole topic seems more like political speak to me. When asked where Seri had heard these things he gave a slight and fairly worthless response that reads more like "This is just something I came up with to talk about" than "This is something that happens all the time."

Now then I am not saying that surely if anyone would have experienced this it would be me, but coming from a Sebbie like myself, with no family or Vouval mark, nor any clan to speak of, short of my genetic heritage, I would think that I would be exposed to it at some point.

I suppose it reflects on the class of persons that time is spent with.
Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#29 - 2012-12-10 17:06:52 UTC
Speaking as one who was raised in the Federation I can say that I never experienced any of this "you're not a true Minmatar" nonsense that Pilot Inhonores spoke of. I've gotten plenty of racist crap from non-Matari, however.

As others have said there are idiots of all stripes living in all areas of space. To be ignorant, xenophobic or bigoted is not purely a Minmatar issue. I'd suggest that Pilot Inhonores spend less time inside the echo chamber of the Summit comm channel and more time speaking to regular people in the real world.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Jace Sarice
#30 - 2012-12-10 17:29:51 UTC
Anabella Rella wrote:
To be ignorant, xenophobic or bigoted is not purely a Minmatar issue.


How might it be xenophobic or bigoted to disavow members of your own kind? If you are detracting from those with a supposedly similar ancestry and identity of your own due to their disloyal actions, how is that bigoted?
Alizabeth Vea
Doomheim
#31 - 2012-12-10 18:32:05 UTC
Seriphyn Inhonores wrote:
By what right do Minmatar loyalist capsuleers get to claim that any Minmatar outside the Republic are "not Minmatar"?


How dare someone make a group and then define the rules of membership? By what right do the members of Goonwaffe get to claim that capsuleers outside of Goonwaffe, but still in CONDI, are not goons?

This is why people don't like the Gallente.

Retainer of Lady Newelle and House Sarum.

"Those who step into the light shall be redeemed, the sins of their past cleansed, so that they may know salvation." -Empress Jamyl Sarum I

Virtue. Valor. Victory.

Astera Zandraki
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#32 - 2012-12-10 19:43:03 UTC
'Minmatar' is not a group, it is an ethnicity, it is not a choice to be born Minmatar. The Minmatar Republic is a group, and people can be accepted or not into that as the Republic authorities wish.

To say that speaking out against a, limited, xenophobia is why some people dislike the Federation is.. somewhat baseless.
Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Doomheim
#33 - 2012-12-11 02:31:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Well it's a lot like breeding dogs. Sometimes a degree of force and pressure is required in order to ensure that specific traits and strengths are passed on from generation to generation and that the breeds survives against the invasion of foreign mongrels.

It is a choice though, some peoples are like the wolves who seek to roam in freedom without masters and find their strength in the unity of the pack and others are like Caillean poodles who await eagerly for the next meal to come from their owners and yap eagerly in anticipation to be fed, groomed and put on display.

Some Matari must no doubt remember that they are wolves first and foremost and that identity as a people, culture, and nation is all that matters - irrespective of what the barking of their poodle brethren might say of it in order to please the masters whose hands feed them in the Federation.

Besides, Gallentean liberals and libertarians have always had difficulty understanding the importance of a unified society, national identity, culture and tradition to fulfilling the true needs of an individual citizen in much the same way as a prostitute has difficulty understanding the importance of dignity, pride and self-worth.

Kurilaivonen|Concern

Alizabeth Vea
Doomheim
#34 - 2012-12-11 03:57:21 UTC
Astera Zandraki wrote:
'Minmatar' is not a group, it is an ethnicity, it is not a choice to be born Minmatar. The Minmatar Republic is a group, and people can be accepted or not into that as the Republic authorities wish.

To say that speaking out against a, limited, xenophobia is why some people dislike the Federation is.. somewhat baseless.


I might be ethnically Caldari. But, I really wouldn't count myself as culturally Caldari, not anymore. The closest that I've gotten to the State since I moved to Fade was a midpoint in Black Rise while I was jumping my carrier. Minmatar living in the Republic have a shared experience. And they, rightfully so, are upset that others that do not share that experience are trying to claim it. Minmatar in the Republic have been constantly beat down by the Amarr, but the plucky SOBs keep getting back up. The ethnic Minmatar in the Federation have not been subjected to that level of hardship.

For example: In the Tribute/Vale campaign, I flew a Scimitar. I lost four of them in combat. Each time, I was able to give a decent warning for evac, but there were some inevitable losses. I had to bring in new crewmen to replace the ones that I had lost. None of the new crewmembers could ever match the level of camaraderie of the original ones. (Side note, the original crew have all been discharged and they are set for life.)

And, I was more referring to the holier than thou attitude of the Gallente. They're at the same level as the Amarrians.

Retainer of Lady Newelle and House Sarum.

"Those who step into the light shall be redeemed, the sins of their past cleansed, so that they may know salvation." -Empress Jamyl Sarum I

Virtue. Valor. Victory.

Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#35 - 2012-12-11 04:37:55 UTC
Alizabeth Vea wrote:
Minmatar living in the Republic have a shared experience. And they, rightfully so, are upset that others that do not share that experience are trying to claim it. Minmatar in the Republic have been constantly beat down by the Amarr, but the plucky SOBs keep getting back up. The ethnic Minmatar in the Federation have not been subjected to that level of hardship.



I find that entire argument wishy-washy. In Tribalism, two Matari may not have a shared experience at all! The Vherokior have a completely different experience than, say, the Brutor. Or the Sebiestor to the Krusual. Or the Thukker to the Starkmanir. They're all different groups with different shared experiences. And let's not forget different clan cultures!

A simple counter-argument: The Thukker tribe do not live in the Republic, and some of the Caravans even disagree on many points with the Republic. Having taken to a nomadic lifestyle, much of the "original" Thukker culture was preserved because of our ability to evade enslavement. So what, because we had a different experience and arguably easier time we're not Minmatar?

Sod off, and stay out of this. As Ava said in a different thread, I find it funny that non-Matari are even weighing in on this when they have no clue. And by the Spirits, stop using poor analogies from your personal combat experience. They are irrelevant here.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#36 - 2012-12-11 05:04:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Anabella Rella
Pilot Gesakaarin I understand that you have a personal axe to grind with the Federation but, please stop trying to pass off your opinions as fact. The Republic is an independent nation of equal stature to the State, Empire or Federation. This is the second screed of yours in which you've attempted to paint Matari as somehow backwards, second-class people who only manage to exist thanks to the handouts of our "Federal masters". As a Matari who's lived in both the Federation and the Republic I find this notion quite frankly offensive. I also find your proposition is far from the truth.

While it's a matter of historical record that the Gallente helped us break away from the Empire by providing arms, training, funds and logistics the fact of the matter is that we, the Minmatar people, were the ones who fought and died to secure our freedom and do so to this very day. We freed ourselves. We bore the burden of fighting off the imperials. We are not puppets of the Gallente. As a matter of fact there is strong sentiment within the Republic to move farther away from the Federation as evidenced by the fact that we dissolved our Federal styled government and are moving back to a more traditional council of all the Tribes.

Please stop attempting to interpret our actions and our society through your biased Caldari eyes. Go ahead and hate the Gallente all you like but, please leave us out of it.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Doomheim
#37 - 2012-12-11 06:28:47 UTC
Mademoiselle Rella,

I hold the utmost respect for the Matari who hold fast and true to their cultural life, tribal traditions, and ethnic identity for they are men and women who understand to divorce oneself from the purity of national identity is to also live a life without value or worth. The fact that Sanmatar Shakor has realized the failings and fallacies of parliamentary and democratic party politics to properly express the true will of the people is also to be commended, for the will of a nation is often best expressed through loyalty to a single leader.

What I have far less respect for is those Matari who prostitute themselves like cheap whores to the foreign and invasive concepts of multiculturalism, liberalism, and democratic party politics in the Federation, that like a cancer eats away at the fundamental concepts of national and cultural unity that is instrumental in preserving the unique identity of a people as a race and identity. Is this not the heart of the matter then?

Do not get me wrong, this is not an attempt on my part to paint all Matari as Liberals devoid of any and all respect for honour, history, tradition, patriotism, and the sacrifices of their ancestors for there are no doubt just as many Caldari Liberals who would gladly lay on their backs, spread their legs, and sell-out the State for the clink of a coin purse from the Federation. Then again, it's not like a Liberal whatever their origins can truly appreciate just how devoid of worth they are for the entire philosophy demands the mindset of utter selfishness, delusion, and the belief that the individual should not be constrained by society.

Does it mean I hate all Gallenteans? No. I just happen to despise liberalism and democracy as ideologies and hold that its proponents whether they are Gallentean, Caldari, Amarr or Matari need to be defeated in order to preserve the cultural and national identities of all races in New Eden and ensure the order and stability upon which a lasting peace between all can at last be forged in the spirit of mutual respect, trust, and fraternity.

Even I as a Caldari can to a degree respect Roden or Blaque for the work they are doing in the Federation in that regard.

Kurilaivonen|Concern

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#38 - 2012-12-11 10:14:52 UTC
This discussion is about the Minmatar and their self-determination and not the struggle between the Gallente and the Caldari. To try and bend the topic back towards the original subject I'll offer the only piece of advice I feel qualified to give.

All this talk about ethnicity is interesting, but culture is the real key. Share genes with someone and you have some commonalities, but share a culture with them and you have a real bond that you can count on. The Minmatar already instinctively know this, their Tribes share common culture after all, the only step they really need to take is to decide what being Minmatar really means. Is this the Republic? It doesn't sound like the Minmatar are convinced of that to me, but essentially we need to stop trying to tell them what being Minmatar is and leave them to work it out.

Why in the name of the Winds should we even care? How does their decision really affect us? I don't expect Sebiestor or Vherokior to tell me what it means to be Civire. Or Wiyrkomi. Or Caldari. I'm damned if I care to tell them what it means to be Sebiestor or Minmatar. I might be interested enough to listen to them tell ME what those things mean, if the stories are interesting or it helps me learn more about an ally or enemy or potential trading partner.

I feel no kinship with a Civire who isn't culturally Caldari. I am the true brother of any Deteis who embraces The Way.

That's the one lesson the tribes of Minmatar can learn from the Caldari. Just that the answer to this question must be found and that it probably doesn't lie in genetics. Oh, and that they should remember that the only answer worth a damn is the one they come up with themselves. Anyone telling them different is either trying to buy them or trying to sell them something.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Astera Zandraki
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#39 - 2012-12-11 11:04:07 UTC
Ms. Gesakarrin, I was wondering if you've ever been to any of the culturally Caldari nations in the Federation? Some of those are closer to the original Raata culture than even the State. So, before you talk about monolithic blocs and amalgamation, do some basic research.

On another note, quit it with the clumsy prostitution analogies. I don't think if you've ever met one you'd be making such brutal and uneducated statements.

As you you Pieter -she grins- You're correct, cultural similarities are more about feelings than genetics, but do you feel a bond with the Caldari nations living in the Federation at all? on a side note.
Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Doomheim
#40 - 2012-12-11 11:35:18 UTC
Astera Zandraki wrote:
Ms. Gesakarrin, I was wondering if you've ever been to any of the culturally Caldari nations in the Federation? Some of those are closer to the original Raata culture than even the State. So, before you talk about monolithic blocs and amalgamation, do some basic research.


The Caldari State is the only bastion of true Caldari culture and the only legitimate heir to the legacy and destiny of the Caldari people. I could care less whatever themeparks or Raata zoos those who call themselves Caldari construct in the Federation for they are nothing more than the descendents of collaborators and traitors to their people during the secession. If they choose to embrace their true heritage however, nothing prevents them from returning to their brothers and sisters in the State where they would be welcomed with open arms.

Kurilaivonen|Concern