Ships & Modules

Frigates:

Wolf: Limited by two mids, but has decent falloff/DPS and can be a good brawler or fleet ship. 6/10
Jaguar: Fast, versatile, can be great as either solo or heavy tackle. A bit overshadowed by the Dram. 7/10
Claw: Most Claws roll with a close-range AB fit. Anything else and you'll be overshadowed a bit by the Stiletto. Meh. 5/10
Stiletto: Fast, nice point range, high scanres. Trying to use it for anything other than fleet tackle is silly, though. 7/10
Hyena: Suffers from the same fate as most other EAFs: Squishy and overshadowed by recons. Meeeeehh. 3/10
Firetail: Less tank than a Jaguar, less speed/DPS than a Dramiel. It can work, but I just don't see why. 4/10

Ishkur: Nice dronebay, nice dps, nice versatility. Not really much else to say. 8/10
Enyo: Two mids with blasters. Meh. I guess it can work for wolfpacks. 5/10
Taranis: Awesome little blaster brawler. Melts face up close, or chews you down from a distance with rails. 8/10
Ares: Fly it like a stiletto with a slightly different slot layout. Not really much difference. 7/10
Keres: Even more pointless than the Hyena, since interceptors get almost as much point range anyway. Might be viable for damps, but... Get a celestis? 2/10
Comet: Decently sturdy brawler with a nice mix of tank and DPS. No glaring flaws. 8/10

Retribution: One mid. LOL. Absolutely useless for anything beyond fleet DPS, but who uses a frigate for fleet DPS? 2/10
Vengeance: Can be flown like a mini-sac, with rockets and a decent active tank, making for either a nice heavy tackler or solo frig. 7/10.
Malediction: OK all around. Rockets are nice for drone killing. 6/10
Crusader: Can be a nice range-controller with an AB. A little overshadowed by the Slicer for MWD-kiting. 6/10
Sentinel: Perhaps the only useful EAF. It will eat other frigates alive with TD/neuts, like a mini-curse. It's paper thin though. 7/10
Slicer: With a MWD and scorch, it can pack quite a punch while keeping distance. Good for GTFO-situations. 7/10

Harpy: Can be fitted for rail kiting or blaster brawling. Doesn't really excel at either, but doesn't suck either. 5/10
Hawk: Can take on just about any frigate 1v1 by out-tanking them with a shield booster. Not bad after the rocket buff. 7/10
Crow: See Stiletto and Ares, but with missiles. 7/10
Raptor: 0/10
Kitsune: It has some practical application due to its small sig and fast scanres, but for almost anything, a blackbird is cheaper and better. 3/10
Hookbill: Five mids makes for great range control, rockets are nice for consistent DPS. Not a bad ship. 7/10

Dramiel: Fastest ship in the game, most agile ship in the game, has good DPS and tank for a frigate. Overpowered currently, but getting nerfed. 10/10
Daredevil: 90% web makes it lethal against other frigates. Very squishy, but very painful. 9/10
Cruor: Has the 90% webs of the Daredevil combined with a semi-useful bonus to nos/neuts. Lacking in DPS/mobility, but good against active tanked frigates. (See: Hawk, Vengeance.) 7/10
Worm: Bleh. Everything it can do is done better by other frigates. 4/10
Succubus: Bleh. It has utility highs, but no bonus for anything that can be fit there. It could be flown like a laser Jaguar with one less lowslot, but... Why? 5/10

Maybe I'll move on to other stuff later, but those are my opinions on the frigs.

Edit: Oh my god... I thought you wanted me to rate them from 1-10. FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF-

He asked for a top 10, not marks out of 10 for everything.

To be fair your scores seem pretty good. Retribution is good for murdering dictors and inties, raptor doesn't trully deserve 0/10 as it can still do its primary job (tackling) passibly well. Malediction needs to get suicidally close to actually use its rockets.

Alright, since everyone seems to want it...

Vagabond: Has nice speed, falloff, DPS, and a moderate tank, allowing for a combination of killing power and escape ability. Stay at a range and chip them down. Sadly, it's been overshadowed by the Cynabal a bit since Dominion, but is still very viable. 8/10

Muninn: Hmm. A bit of a neglected ship. It's slower than the Vaga, and has an optimal range bonus, leading one to think that it should be fitted with arties... But then to get respectable arty DPS, you pretty much sacrifice all your tank, or to get respectable tank, sacrifice all your DPS. Needs better fitting reqs/slot layout to be competitive. 5/10

Rapier: With the popularity of nanoships, this definitely has its place for cloaky ambushes with 50km+ webs in a fleet. Can also be used with a nanofleet to help keep range. Lacking a bit for solo due to low tank/DPS, but still viable. 7/10

Huginn: You basically sacrifice the covert ops cloak of the Rapier for more high slots... Except that you're very unlikely to actually get a fit in which you can use all your weapon slots. Split weapon system is also annoying. Needs more fitting space. 4/10

Broadsword: Probably the best HIC, due to nice AC DPS, speed, and a good shield tank on top. Useful for any 0.0 fleet. 9/10

Scythe Fleet Issue: It can kill t1 frigs. That's about it. 1/10

Stabber Fleet Issue: The Minmatar's close-range sigtanker. Orbit, afterburn, and pray that you don't get hit. Good for taking out larger, dumber targets; dies to some webs and accurate shooting, though. Best for killing unsuspecting targets. 7/10

--

Sacrilege: Two main ways of being fitted - dual active reppers to get a half-decent active tank, like a big Vengeance, or a brick fit to get a big passive tank, like a Drake. The repper fit is similar to an active Myrm in terms of tank/DPS, while the buffer fit is a bit lackluster comparing to the cheaper, more versatile Drake, sadly. 6/10

Zealot: Armor HACS! Armor HACs! ARMOR HACS! Low sig combined with nice pulse laser range makes this very nice for a cruiser gang. Can soak up decent damage while putting out quite a bit of its own. Not much to it other than tank + gank, but it does it well. 8/10

Curse: Ah, one of my personal favorites. Neuts, TDs, missiles, drones, and good range control make for an utterly deadly combination against turret ships. Sadly, they are weak against the ever-common passive Drake (dratted little things.) Still, they are deadly in the right circumstances. 9/10

Pilgrim: Somewhat more of a niché role than the Curse, due to reduced neut range. Rather than kiting like the Curse, the Pilgrim orbits close to mitigate enemy damage. Of course, this severely limits your "GTFO" capabilities in comparison to the Curse, meaning it's best for short fights which you should easily be able to win. You also have the Covops cloak, which is nice for sneaking around in hostile territory. 8/10

Devoter: Same purpose as the Broadsword: Bubble, pray. It's slower, though, and has less gank options... It's still able to interdict just fine, though. 7/10

Augoror Navy Issue: It can bait with 200,000+ HP, but everybody knows that, so it's not as good as it once was. :(. 3/10

Omen Navy Issue: Sort of like a Zealot, but more solo-oriented, with a dronebay. Not sure if it's worth having less DPS/tank/range than a Zealot, but meh. 6/10

--

Cerberus: Meh. It has awesome heavy missile range, but less DPS and tank than a Drake. Only useful role I see is sniping... But in larger engagements, the target will be dead before your missiles hit. Might be able to dish out some pain in a smaller battle, but that's about it. 5/10

Eagle: Sort of like a Cerb... Only with hybrids. If you fight close, you melt in seconds, and if you fight from far, you do very little rail dps. 2/10

Falcon: Fit appropriate racial jammers, warp at 70, uncloak, laugh... One of the best subcaps you could surprise someone with. If you use it correctly, it's downright awesome. I honestly don't see any major flaws with it, unless your enemies wisen up to start flying multiple races or counter-jam with a scorp. 9/10

Rook: Very much like Falcon, trades cloak for missiles. This makes it a bit more useful for large engagements if you want to squeeze in extra dps, but less useful for small ones where a cloak gives you better engagement options. Still very nice. 8/10

Onyx: Missiles and shields compared to the Broad's guns and shields. This means that when you're sitting still and bubbling, you can actually deal some dps, since you don't need to move around much to do missile damage - this is nice. However, it's slower and less versatile than the 'Broad in exchange. 7/10

Navy Osprey: It's fast, but very squishy. Apart from a nano LOLfit, not much point. 2/10

Navy Caracal: Slower but tankier and gankier than the Nosprey. Can actually field a nice nanofit with missiles, allowing for good damage projection at 20km. Alternatively, fly it like a supercaracal and SLAY frigates. 7/10

--

Ishtar: Can field five heavy drones, giving it very decent dps for a cruiser, which can also become a moderate tank when combined with your low sig. No glaring flaws, really. 7/10

Deimos: Suffers from lack of fitting options due to slots/space, and uses hybrids. 2/10

Lachesis: imo, it's a bit underrated - 50km point, 20km scram, and damps can turn the tide in a small-scale engagement. That said, it's lacking in DPS, and speed compared to the other recons. 7/10

Arazu: Sort of like a Lach, but cloaky, and with even less dps. Commonly used for hotdrops due to cloak + epic point range, and I can't say it's bad at that. 7/10

Phobos: Same as the other HICs, except with hybrids you're doing even less damage when stationary and bubbling. Meeeh... It can still bubble well - that's about it. 5/10

Oh wow, out of space... Will finish tomorrow, need some sleep.

Give this man a cookie. There are a couple ships I feel slightly differently about, but overall this is a great overview of the ships and their relative usefulness in PvP (the valuations are different for PvE, but this is still a good reference for PvP).

Frigates

1)Slicer
2)Daredevil
3)Taranis
4)Crusader
5)Rifter
6)Hookbill
7)Malediction
8)Comet
9)Incursus
10)Crow

Cruisers
1)Ishtar
2)Sac
3)Cyna
4)Vaga
5)Curse
6)Muninn
7)Zealot
8)Navy omen
9)Rapier
10)Arazu

Those are beyond terrible assessments.

Some pretty good info in this thread on ships. If anyone wants a deeper assessment of ships, check out this blog, which has a series of "know your enemy" entries on different ship classes:

ship assessments

Rooster is spot on, nice job +1

I'm just quoting this to show how ridiculous the paragraphing is............. AHhhhhhhhhhhhh it hurts my eyes.