These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Amarr vs Minmatar Update

Author
Vordak Kallager
Descendance.
GoonSwarm.
#21 - 2012-11-22 21:59:58 UTC
The Amarr's problem (across all timezones) has always been cooperation and leadership. There have been a few people that were able to get everyone in the Amarr fleeted up and working together: Predator Elite, Xeno Nephilim, to some extent Eran Mintor. Currently there is no one left to fill that void of being the guy everyone trusts and will fly for. The Minmatar are blessed with multiple of these people who are all great friends, share intel, channels, etc. When a system falls for the Amarr, you here stuff like "Oh, it's because so-and-so-group didn't help." etc etc. I'm not saying everyone on the Amarr does this kind of blame-gaming, but in contrast, you never hear that **** from the Minmatar side. Instead, you hear stuff like "Okay guys, *we* lost the system, but here is *our* plan of attack to regain the upperhand." etc etc. The Minmatar alliances are basically one big love orgy. Our powers combined, and all that. vOv

Sa souvraya niende misain ye.

uredo
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#22 - 2012-11-22 23:18:36 UTC
What a load of rubbish.

There has been great corperation and leadership at times in EU Amarr FW. Maybe not now, but there certainly used to be.

When I started, the Fleet of Lurv was out *every* night without fail (EU TZ), and was open to the whole militia. And everyone joined it and had great fun.

Things only got political when W-BR came along, and then everyone got antsy about POCO rights.

Then there was that whole Battle of Tannakan fiasco and things were never quite the same again.

The final nail in the coffin for much of the old guard was getting years of assets locked up in stations.

We didn't care about occupancy, just getting some fun fights.
Taoist Dragon
Okata Syndicate
#23 - 2012-11-23 00:21:39 UTC
Yay \o/ we got a mention in FW thread!!

Anyways the idea of a 'unified' militia turns my blood cold!

We are a militia! By definition we are a rag tag bunch of miscreants who just happen to fight for the same boss (the Amarr empire)

We roam, fly & fight depending on how our individual corps/allainces like. This is not a null sec power bloc building here people!
No I'm not saying we shouldn't cooperate with other corps/alliances but just saying that if we don't all get together to do stuff we are failing?! c'mon we are all here for the fights Twisted

We get together with other corps/allainces/groups for bigger ops when needed and just do our own thing the rest of the time.

Fly dangerous! Have fun! And come shoot me! (the minnies that is!)






nah bugger it.......everyone come shoot me!

I like blowing up!

That is the Way, the Tao.

Balance is everything.

Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#24 - 2012-11-23 00:26:58 UTC
Vordak Kallager wrote:
.....

Funny how those two coincided, eh?

The hash-job pushed by CCP as presented at FanFest was the straw that broek the camels back for just about all the old-timers in Amarr and most left in dismay/disgust .. with the old-timers, Amarr lost (naturally) all established and FW savvy FCs after having dominated rather consistently despite lower 'official' numbers since the beginning.
The exact reverse happened on the "other side" as the hash-job and its implementation left Shakorites controlling a majority of space which became a no dock zone for Amarr, a staggering broken payout scheme and no real way for their enemies to make a come back as CCP accidentally forgot to balance the bloody thing ... suddenly Mims were paid through the nose for scratching their arses and people flooded the spacelanes for fun and profit, as with any large gathering a leadership emerged on its own volition as did cooperation.

What I mean is: Had CCP not botched so fiercely, you would have your 'allotted' space or however much the plexers could hold (as it had always been, probably 50/50), but you'd be run around in circles by far more experienced and 'drilled' Amarr fleets (as it had always been).

The only positive thing to be said is that the unlimited ISK available did not (as is often the case) fracture the infant leadership caste .. must have had some hardcore diplo's in those months to make it through that so hats off to them.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#25 - 2012-11-23 01:00:09 UTC
What a load of horsecrap.

Allegedly, Minmatar acts like a giant ball of velcro in a cotton wool factory, with FCs everyone trusts and everyone hops in fleets for, with a dozen fleets advertised for SFI's. Uh, nope. There are many corps and alliances in Minmatar who will only let you join their fleets when they know you, know you aren't a sack full of knuckles, and aren't a spy. This results in the general militia scrub population being excluded from most fleets (except Polska's welpfleets; you join knowing you're going to lose your ship to a drunk up-phuckery). It takes time, dedication and a modicum of social ability to get into what Vordak alleges is a well-oiled machine of war.

Apparently SFI's are so cheap in the LP store you'd have to be an idiot not to use them when in Militia, but somehow can't get ahold of them in Amarr militia. Apparently, no one ever sells the hulls outside of Militia and they are never on sale in Jita or Rens or Hek or Dodixie. I mean...what's the eyeroll emotion?

Then Veshta cries tears of solitude about water under the bridge. Which is a river of Amarr tears about how great it used to be, and a bridge made of idiocy cemented with depression-laced myths. Last time I looked at the FW map Amarr had flipped a bunch of metro systems and were doing OK. There certainly wasn't a whole swathe of Metro before the hotfix which was so deeply contested it was pointless decontesting it; great farms for the Caldari alts and Amarr, whereas Minmatar had to funnel their offensive plexing into a handful of systems, or plex Caldari space - which had no effect on keeping the Amarr restricted to a handful of systems.

The fact is, Amarr suffers from the same problem Minmatar does, with old hands and old corps stubbornly sticking to their own corners and own fleets, and not being happy-go-lucky sociable with every scrub and noob in Militia. The only difference is that you obviously lack numbers of old hands, which is an historic thing and won't change until you work on the social aspects. Given most Fweddit people are manchildren or mentally disabled, a third of your allegedly "decent PVPers" are douchenozzles hanging around Hek undock, and the rest of you have aspergers syndrme, you have bugger all chance of changing anything, let alone pushing territory.

Take some anti-aspergers meds, get over your inferiority complex (via Cialis or viagra), and deal with it.
subtle turtle
Doozer Mining Cartel
#26 - 2012-11-23 02:14:31 UTC
Trinkets friend wrote:


... get over your inferiority complex (via Cialis or viagra), and deal with it.


I took this advice, and now I've been "PVPing" (if you get my drift) for greater than 4 hours... Should I contact my doctor?
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#27 - 2012-11-23 03:56:51 UTC
subtle turtle wrote:
Trinkets friend wrote:


... get over your inferiority complex (via Cialis or viagra), and deal with it.


I took this advice, and now I've been "PVPing" (if you get my drift) for greater than 4 hours... Should I contact my doctor?


Hell no. Brag to all your friends instead.
Zen Guerrilla
CTRL-Q
Ushra'Khan
#28 - 2012-11-23 06:42:34 UTC
Sadly the amarr lack FCs these days and/or just general organization.

I feel that in the EU timezone we are usually outnumbered these days. But most Amarrios just seem to be sitting in Kamela station, waiting for someone to tell the what to do.

A few newer corps are very active and trying hard but on their own they often won't have the numbers and sometimes still lack the experience.

But props to those still giving us fights. Fiscal Fisting, Forced Penetration, Agony, Blackwatch guard and even that random french corp whose name i always forget.



Bring it on.
Twisted


/edit

Also, there's still people complaining about SFI blobs? It's going on for ages now and you guys still haven't figured out a counter? I also heard rumors about SFIs for sale on the market.

pew pew

AndromacheDarkstar
Integrated Insterstellar Holdings
#29 - 2012-11-23 07:56:57 UTC
Trinkets friend wrote:
What a load of horsecrap.



Apparently SFI's are so cheap in the LP store you'd have to be an idiot not to use them when in Militia, but somehow can't get ahold of them in Amarr militia. Apparently, no one ever sells the hulls outside of Militia and they are never on sale in Jita or Rens or Hek or Dodixie. I mean...what's the eyeroll emotion?



The fact is, Amarr suffers from the same problem Minmatar does, with old hands and old corps stubbornly sticking to their own corners and own fleets, and not being happy-go-lucky sociable with every scrub and noob in Militia. The only difference is that you obviously lack numbers of old hands, which is an historic thing and won't change until you work on the social aspects. Given most Fweddit people are manchildren or mentally disabled, a third of your allegedly "decent PVPers" are douchenozzles hanging around Hek undock, and the rest of you have aspergers syndrme, you have bugger all chance of changing anything, let alone pushing territory.

Take some anti-aspergers meds, get over your inferiority complex (via Cialis or viagra), and deal with it.


Ill admit the minmattar get alot of **** pinned on them but you cant fail to agree there is a major differnece between buying SFI`s with LP and buying them outright. I dont think you can argue against the fact that the minmatar are generally richer (which i think is still half our fault for not trying to plex harder) so replacing the ships becomes easier.

I do object to the aspergers line though, some of us are still trying to put some emphasis on plexing and system control alongside the PVP, its just tough to get the numbers to compete.
Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#30 - 2012-11-23 07:57:06 UTC
Trinkets friend wrote:
...Apparently SFI's are so cheap in the LP store you'd have to be an idiot not to use them when in Militia, but somehow can't get ahold of them in Amarr militia. Apparently, no one ever sells the hulls outside of Militia and they are never on sale in Jita or Rens or Hek or Dodixie. I mean...what's the eyeroll emotion?

"Are" is present tense and thus not accurate as the infinit LP I refer to was removed recently, but yes SFI's were indeed selling at cost just as each and every navy item available to FW was .. I am not aware of a more than a few item that made it through The Great LP Devaluation unscathed.
Trinkets friend wrote:
...Last time I looked at the FW map Amarr had flipped a bunch of metro systems and were doing OK...

So you assume that all that rabid insanity and idiocy that everyone but you is afflicted with causes them to not be able to recall events more than a month back?
Or perhaps you were so invested in the FarmVille™ (read: no-risk seeking FW noob) that the hot-fix, which was the first step towards rolling it back, burned itself into your memory in such a way that it erased all memory of what went before?
(hint: the botch job I am referring to is the launch of FarmVille™ and the fact that Mims with oodles of forewarning took 95% of all systems by abusing the at the broken plex mechanics that had plagued FW since D1).

PS: Your post is tantamount to slander at best and libel at worst and more than likely a violation of the forum EULA's "personal attacks" clause. But I am as much a proponent of free thought/speech/will as you must be of free ISK so instead of reporting you as I normally would I shall merely add you to the ignore list as I do all other over-emotional ragers around here.
AndromacheDarkstar
Integrated Insterstellar Holdings
#31 - 2012-11-23 07:58:47 UTC  |  Edited by: AndromacheDarkstar
Zen Guerrilla wrote:
Sadly the amarr lack FCs these days and/or just general organization.

I feel that in the EU timezone we are usually outnumbered these days. But most Amarrios just seem to be sitting in Kamela station, waiting for someone to tell the what to do.

A few newer corps are very active and trying hard but on their own they often won't have the numbers and sometimes still lack the experience.

But props to those still giving us fights. Fiscal Fisting, Forced Penetration, Agony, Blackwatch guard and even that random french corp whose name i always forget.



Bring it on.
Twisted


/edit

Also, there's still people complaining about SFI blobs? It's going on for ages now and you guys still haven't figured out a counter? I also heard rumors about SFIs for sale on the market.


Thanks for the recognition, we do try and bring the fights. Hopefully one day soon once out experiance and SP have built up a little more we can start to make them even more interesting. Also i dont think people complain about SSFI`s so much now, just an accepted part of life.

EDIT - I probably should have mentioned the rest of the alliance rather than just sucking up all the credit myself, very rare our alliance dosent all fly together. we just have the best corp name of course
Bengal Bob
Slymsloot Enterprises
#32 - 2012-11-23 09:58:05 UTC
Veshta Yoshida wrote:
Trinkets friend wrote:
...Apparently SFI's are so cheap in the LP store you'd have to be an idiot not to use them when in Militia, but somehow can't get ahold of them in Amarr militia. Apparently, no one ever sells the hulls outside of Militia and they are never on sale in Jita or Rens or Hek or Dodixie. I mean...what's the eyeroll emotion?

"Are" is present tense and thus not accurate as the infinit LP I refer to was removed recently, but yes SFI's were indeed selling at cost just as each and every navy item available to FW was .. I am not aware of a more than a few item that made it through The Great LP Devaluation unscathed.
Trinkets friend wrote:
...Last time I looked at the FW map Amarr had flipped a bunch of metro systems and were doing OK...

So you assume that all that rabid insanity and idiocy that everyone but you is afflicted with causes them to not be able to recall events more than a month back?
Or perhaps you were so invested in the FarmVille™ (read: no-risk seeking FW noob) that the hot-fix, which was the first step towards rolling it back, burned itself into your memory in such a way that it erased all memory of what went before?
(hint: the botch job I am referring to is the launch of FarmVille™ and the fact that Mims with oodles of forewarning took 95% of all systems by abusing the at the broken plex mechanics that had plagued FW since D1).

PS: Your post is tantamount to slander at best and libel at worst and more than likely a violation of the forum EULA's "personal attacks" clause. But I am as much a proponent of free thought/speech/will as you must be of free ISK so instead of reporting you as I normally would I shall merely add you to the ignore list as I do all other over-emotional ragers around here.


You were much more fun when you did PVP Veshta. Put away the bitterness and return, the Amarr need some help.

The same old claims are boring, the ONLY reason that the Amarr couldn't hold their systems pre patch is that they relied heavily on Wolfs Brigade for support and guidance - and then were sold out by Wolf Brigade who needed to keep Kamela and consequently agreed to non agression in all other systems. The Minmatar had no extra warning or advantage other than reading the patch notes.

If PIE had been there fighting, things might have been different. PIE has always been a plexing corp and the experience you guys could have brought might have made the difference to those that chose to stay and fight instead of leaving.

The pre-patch fights didn't only win us systems, it forged friendships. Those of us that fought and died over those couple weeks for every single minor plex gained trust and much space love for each other.

Maybe we are too insular, maybe we should reach out to more in General Militia, but we watched as the Amarr learnt a valuable lesson when Wolfs Brigade tore down the militia and left it fractured and fighting amongst itself. ISK and LP doesn't really mean anything unless there is trust. So we are taking things slowly and picking who we want to fight alongside.

Enough knocking of CCP - so many years we waited, and now look. FW revitalised, kills everywhere, regular changes and balancing, complete reworking of frigates, cruisers, bc. It looks very much like it is all being done so that plex fighting and skirmishing is massively boosted. FW is a major part of CCP's current plans, and if it is successful, could be an ongoing project. It certainly is delivering the drama and tears that get people interested in EVE and which have been so absent from 0.0

Are we there yet? Nope. But look where we were a few years ago.

Make some in game friends and come back to the fight.
Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#33 - 2012-11-23 10:45:50 UTC
December fourth.

That date will (hopefully) bring the end to five years of unbalanced core mechanics which means most of if not all of the old guard will return .. personally turned my back on FW before WBr came on the scene in earnest so have no idea what/why/who they did, prior to that I had tried pushing the damn boulder up the hill that never ends for 4 years, the chosen (by CCP, so no I will bash them in perpetuity) solution was to create the greatest farm in Eve history without addressing any of the actual issues is what urged me to withdraw.

As for PIE: The admiralty asked me, as I suspect they asked the handful of other in our ranks with extensive FW knowledge, for advice after the FF presentation, which I think is why the corporation chose to take the bench for the duration .. should be noted that had the corporation stayed I would have had to quit (corp, not Eve) as the FF changes had zero merit as far as I was concerned and represented a major setback for the "improve FW!" lobby.
Doubt the addition of a few more plexers that we might have supplied would have made much of a difference as we are talking pre-NPC change plexing (the boulder referenced above) .. and well, combat wise this year has seen very little of the fights I want and enjoy as it became a constant to-fro of alt farm hands after only a month or so with the "regular" big brawls once in a while.

PS: What fights worth mentioning were there pre-patch besides Kourmonen, if you are to be brutally honest and could they even hope to hold a candle to the blood/fun that came from Arzad, Sisieide, Lantorn, Ezzara back before FW was incentivized to hell and back?
PPS: I had a lot more fun when I was doing PvP so the opening observation is spot-on :)

In short (short is relative!): Thanks, but no thanks. I'll hold on to my bitterness until such time CCP proves to me that they know just what the hell they are doing .. so far 4/12/12 looks to be it .. four years of brokenass faggotry only to see change due to a completely unrelated incident (The Week of Jita Emoraging over NeX) and the resulting restructuring ... CCP did not choose to go back to FW (and Eve for that matter), they were forced to -- that is my main bitterness fuel and the fire it creates will need some serious dev sweat to put out.

Remember, remember the fourth of December.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#34 - 2012-11-23 10:59:20 UTC
AndromacheDarkstar wrote:


Ill admit the minmattar get alot of **** pinned on them but you cant fail to agree there is a major differnece between buying SFI`s with LP and buying them outright. I dont think you can argue against the fact that the minmatar are generally richer (which i think is still half our fault for not trying to plex harder) so replacing the ships becomes easier.

I do object to the aspergers line though, some of us are still trying to put some emphasis on plexing and system control alongside the PVP, its just tough to get the numbers to compete.


Actually, I had Kraiklyn Asatru complain to me, along with Thinnish and most of the TRIAD guys, that their wallets were less than the cost of the ship I was flying at the time (my Eos of luls, may it RIP and gf to the Agony guys we reverse-welped in Hek, by the by). Coming from a wormhole life, I also got this in nullsec. So, what is rich? 80M ISK? 1B ISK? I can assure you that only hardcore plexing alts would top my wallet, and would struggle to top my list of pimp, yet hardly any of the Minmatr I regularly blather drunkenly on comms to admit a 9 digit or 10 digit wallet.

Secondly, there's no difference I would say between LP cost and ISK cost. You are implying that somehow it is cheaper to fly an SFI and blob the bejeesus out of the Amarr than to take the exact same number of LP's and a Stabber, convert a bunch of hulls in Amo or Hek, contract to a freighter alt and hoof them to Amarr for sale. The only difference in ISK is that you burn the SFI you actually lose yourself, versus exchanging it for ISK and buy something else. LP and all things bought with LP are fungible. Hence, there is a cost to PVP associated with taking your LP and blowing it on your own SFI.

Veshta Yoshida wrote:
zomg Dec 5th I frot it


Indeed, a number of BUGRY guys who've been idle will resart their EVE accounts on Dec 8th (after the first post-Retribution bug-fix patch ahaha) and join FW. Because things look cool.

I honestly hope that Amarr sorts its shizzle out. For my own selfish sakes, because I want to teabag a whoile bunch of people who haven't played for 2 years and think an Omen sucks, or who look at d-scan and see a horde of Breachers and Bursts and think "lol, noobs". It will be epic as the cognitive dissonance of the vets kicks in and thier heads automagically assplode.

But then, MJD, and I lose my viagra cialis hardon and realise there's going to be some pretty crap stuff too.
Bengal Bob
Slymsloot Enterprises
#35 - 2012-11-23 11:39:16 UTC
Veshta Yoshida wrote:
December fourth.

That date will (hopefully) bring the end to five years of unbalanced core mechanics which means most of if not all of the old guard will return .. personally turned my back on FW before WBr came on the scene in earnest so have no idea what/why/who they did, prior to that I had tried pushing the damn boulder up the hill that never ends for 4 years, the chosen (by CCP, so no I will bash them in perpetuity) solution was to create the greatest farm in Eve history without addressing any of the actual issues is what urged me to withdraw.

As for PIE: The admiralty asked me, as I suspect they asked the handful of other in our ranks with extensive FW knowledge, for advice after the FF presentation, which I think is why the corporation chose to take the bench for the duration .. should be noted that had the corporation stayed I would have had to quit (corp, not Eve) as the FF changes had zero merit as far as I was concerned and represented a major setback for the "improve FW!" lobby.
Doubt the addition of a few more plexers that we might have supplied would have made much of a difference as we are talking pre-NPC change plexing (the boulder referenced above) .. and well, combat wise this year has seen very little of the fights I want and enjoy as it became a constant to-fro of alt farm hands after only a month or so with the "regular" big brawls once in a while.

PS: What fights worth mentioning were there pre-patch besides Kourmonen, if you are to be brutally honest and could they even hope to hold a candle to the blood/fun that came from Arzad, Sisieide, Lantorn, Ezzara back before FW was incentivized to hell and back?
PPS: I had a lot more fun when I was doing PvP so the opening observation is spot-on :)

In short (short is relative!): Thanks, but no thanks. I'll hold on to my bitterness until such time CCP proves to me that they know just what the hell they are doing .. so far 4/12/12 looks to be it .. four years of brokenass faggotry only to see change due to a completely unrelated incident (The Week of Jita Emoraging over NeX) and the resulting restructuring ... CCP did not choose to go back to FW (and Eve for that matter), they were forced to -- that is my main bitterness fuel and the fire it creates will need some serious dev sweat to put out.

Remember, remember the fourth of December.


I was just as bitter as you, and raging on the forums. Indeed, I refused to participate in the madness of CQ and avatar upgrades and instead chose a close up of of my freshly shaved left bollock as my avatar to express my rage at CCP.

I very nearly quit, but regardless of the reasons, it appears that CCP is moving forward in a generally favourable direction for most FW pvpers. Overlooking distractions FW is a lot better than previously.

You underestimate the impact PIE could have had. I know you didn't have huge numbers, but your guys could have led, advised and trained the general militia that were trying to plex. I know the NPC issue has made the Amarr bitter, but it has never prevented Amarr players from solo plexing so it hasn't absolutely hindered you. In the two weeks before the patch though the NPC imbalance was irrelevant as the plexes all had gangs in them fighting.

Regardless of RP reasons and loss of faith in CCP, PIE's biggest mistake was in leaving Amarr during their greatest hour of need in FW. All those years of work plexing and fighting to hold the line were thrown away when PIE turned from the fight when even the greenest Amarr noob was out and fighting.

You guys need to get back in the game and try to rebuild the Amarr because they need it. And you know you like killing the Minnies :)
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#36 - 2012-11-23 12:23:04 UTC  |  Edited by: Zarnak Wulf
Amarr militia needed to lose a lot of the old guard and start over from scratch. You really can't accomplish anything when people refuse to plex or refuse to get into this or that ship. The new pilots coming on generally have a positive attitude and are willing to work. There is a lot more cooperation and team work. The whole 'Amarr just infight' line of thought is a few months past the expiration date. We just need to continue to build our numbers.

Also - LOL at the Minmatar claiming they're outnumbered in any time zone. No. Just no.
uredo
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#37 - 2012-11-23 14:02:02 UTC
With a saw, a hammer, a chisel, a gun, a change of clothes, a Swiss passport, and a huge false moustache, we might just stand a chance.
.
.
.
Let's see, what have we here?
.
.
.
A small painted wooden duck.
Tiberius Murderhorne
CONTRATTO
#38 - 2012-11-23 14:52:52 UTC
Amarr is going to come back.... we are all coming back! you'll see! muhhahahhhhahahahhahahaahhahahaahahaha

plus the new omen is full of win, The Amarr will be charging over the hill in a fleet of Omens supported by Augoror's you'll see.... you'll all see......

Disclaimer : My posting does not always reflect my Corps views or my allience views.... Infact sometimes it does not even reflect my views!

Braitai
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#39 - 2012-11-23 15:27:50 UTC
[quote=Veshta Yoshidapersonally turned my back on FW before WBr came on the scene in earnest so have no idea what/why/who they did,[/quote]

So basically you don't know anything. Keep being all bitter-vet though, it's quite amusing. I'm sure it's comforting to dream up imaginary scenarios of how inferno panned out when you have no first hand experience, considering your delusions of Amarr fleet superiority are so attached to your character's persona.

It's weird (telling?) that your RP character's superiority complex is bled through (grown out of?) your real opinions.
Almity
In Exile.
#40 - 2012-11-23 15:56:40 UTC
I have no clue where all this "Amarr are losing" crap comes from. Since the week before inferno we have been getting awesome fights and we win many of them. I.Law, Fweddit, tmfed, ect in the US TZ have been kicking some ass.

I.Law broke 1k kills in each of the last two months and we have a chance of doing it again this month. We fight the SFI "blob" and do pretty damn well against it most fights. I can't speak for the EU TZ but in the US TZ Amarr is strong.