These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Fiction

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Quick Question - Is it possible?

First post First post
Author
Nayo Renyk
Armored Corps
#1 - 2012-11-17 02:04:34 UTC
So, I'v been wondering about this for weeks now and id like to know if their is anything non-compatible with EVE lore here;

Would it be possible for a capsuleer (If he/she so choices to opt for it) to have a triple clone setup using the new dust technology that would let one clone with the new dust implant command the bridge of a ship (As in how they did it before the empyrean age), while having the (likely modified) pod on board with a second clone inside, then finally a clone safely at a station.
The point being one could pilot a ship the good ol' fashion style, If said ship goes down then the consciousness of the caption would go directly to the pod. If the pod goes down then its the same old story.

So ignoring the obvious fall-backs of such a choice, would it theoretically be possible? Im certainly not the oldest player around and my knowledge of the lore is even more limited, especially with dust 514. But its still an idea kicking around in the back of my head that i would appreciate feed back on.
Qvar Dar'Zanar
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#2 - 2012-11-17 13:21:36 UTC  |  Edited by: Qvar Dar'Zanar
The point on capsuleers being on capsules is that:
1. You can command your ship way more fficiently thanks to being integrated with the hardware itself.
2. If you die, your consciousness is automatically sent to the new clone in a safe station.

While DUST soldiers would be (in theory) able to command a ship, they would not be neraly as good as a capsuleer pilot (we are talking about advancements in commanding capabilities that make 'mortal' captains shiver in fear).
Also, while a killed DUST captain would be able to transfer his consciousness to a new clone, there's a big problem in your scheme: Capsules are prepared to send the information upon destruction, not to recive it and implant it in the body they are holding. Only stations with enough infrastructure can do that.
Nayo Renyk
Armored Corps
#3 - 2012-11-17 22:51:17 UTC
Qvar Dar'Zanar wrote:
The point on capsuleers being on capsules is that:
1. You can command your ship way more fficiently thanks to being integrated with the hardware itself.
2. If you die, your consciousness is automatically sent to the new clone in a safe station.

While DUST soldiers would be (in theory) able to command a ship, they would not be neraly as good as a capsuleer pilot (we are talking about advancements in commanding capabilities that make 'mortal' captains shiver in fear).
Also, while a killed DUST captain would be able to transfer his consciousness to a new clone, there's a big problem in your scheme: Capsules are prepared to send the information upon destruction, not to recive it and implant it in the body they are holding. Only stations with enough infrastructure can do that.


Well again ignoring the obvious disadvantages, the whole idea is it would open up a brand new theater for fiction; A capsuleer can directly interact with his/her crew and ship while maintaining immortality and even maintaining a strong link to the ship. The possibility's simply gush out from my head at least..
And to your infrastrucure point, call me insanely retarted, but how much does one actually need? Enough to house a planet conquering military? Okay, sure you need a station.. at least a command center.. But for one clone? Thats essentially super-human and No more than a few hundred meters at most, ready to go.? I already said the pod would be modified, why not with the aid of the ship itself? In fact I know certain ships have or used to have the capability for clone bays so by your logic some ships could do it. The question then is, simply how big does it need to be?
Esna Pitoojee
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#4 - 2012-11-18 00:42:27 UTC
Devs have stated that DUST cloning implants are incompatible with capsule "flash cloning" technology. In theory a capsuleer might be able to abandon their capsuleer career and swap over entirely to DUST implants, but this would be a lengthy and difficult process, not something you could dynamically swap between in the midst of an ongoing fight.
Qvar Dar'Zanar
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#5 - 2012-11-18 02:23:47 UTC
Nayo Renyk wrote:
already said the pod would be modified, why not with the aid of the ship itself? In fact I know certain ships have or used to have the capability for clone bays so by your logic some ships could do it. The question then is, simply how big does it need to be?


Rigth. Didn't thought about that.
Nayo Renyk
Armored Corps
#6 - 2012-11-18 02:41:00 UTC
Esna Pitoojee wrote:
Devs have stated that DUST cloning implants are incompatible with capsule "flash cloning" technology.

Okay, incompatible how? Keep in mind only the bridge clone would have the implants. So in the case of consecutive death, it would be two completely different cloning techniques. This is all assuming of course the mind of the capsuleer could do this without turning into jelly..
Esna Pitoojee
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#7 - 2012-11-18 05:21:06 UTC
Incompatible as in they do not work together; trying to plug them in together might be likened to taking two computers operating in entirely different languages and networking them together. They would not communicate automatically.

Keep in mind that both the capsule and the DUST implants were complete technologies either stolen or gifted in a complete state by other cultures than the ones they are used by ingame. Whether or not the various empires understand -exactly how- the DUST implants work at this point is debatable.
Nayo Renyk
Armored Corps
#8 - 2012-11-18 21:30:49 UTC
I completely understand why you wouldnt be able to put a dust merc in a pod, However this isnt like that. The only thing that the clones would have in common would be the consciousness of the pilot, which both should handle just fine. So, the only thing that could be "incompatible" would be the actual transfer from bridge to pod. But it seems to me like it isnt something that couldnt be worked around..

Maybe im just kicking a dead horse here, but essentially "No, Becuase you can't" wasnt really what i was going for.
Perhaps I should have gone with "under what possible circumstances would this work?" as my OP..
Marcion Cravik
Phoibe Enterprises
#9 - 2012-11-19 11:36:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Marcion Cravik
Nayo Renyk wrote:
Maybe im just kicking a dead horse here, but essentially "No, Becuase you can't" wasnt really what i was going for.
Perhaps I should have gone with "under what possible circumstances would this work?" as my OP..


The problem regarding transfer between different clone types is that the layout of their brain cells needs to be identical. This is something that gets transmitted on the moment of a capsuleer's death to recreate his brain to the smalles detail, thus preventing insanity or worse after reanimation.

Different Implants mean a different nervous layout, therefore the brain state information of a capsuleer and a DUST clone will never be the same or compatible.

But if you really want this to work under certain circumstances, why let you imagination get bothered?
Galaxy Pig
New Order Logistics
CODE.
#10 - 2012-11-19 17:00:12 UTC
Esna Pitoojee wrote:
Devs have stated that DUST cloning implants are incompatible with capsule "flash cloning" technology. In theory a capsuleer might be able to abandon their capsuleer career and swap over entirely to DUST implants, but this would be a lengthy and difficult process, not something you could dynamically swap between in the midst of an ongoing fight.


Really? Interesting, can I get links? I figured that's how they would solve the WiS mortality issue...

Highsec is owned by players now. Systems 0.5-1.0 are New Order Territory. All miners and other residents of Highsec must obey The Code. Mining without a permit is dangerous and harmful to the EVE community. See www.MinerBumping.com

Galaxy Pig
New Order Logistics
CODE.
#11 - 2012-11-19 17:11:28 UTC
Yeah and OP, it just begs the question "why???"

So many disadvantages, not one real advantage I can see. Capsuleers can communicate with their crew if they want to, but why would we? They're just organic mechanisms comprising a vast machine that we may or may not relate to more than we do them. They should know their jobs and what to do and if they don't we leave them in a jet can. If I'm feeling considerate, AND I think about it, I'll give em a heads up if we have to warp suddenly so they don't puke all over my ship.

Highsec is owned by players now. Systems 0.5-1.0 are New Order Territory. All miners and other residents of Highsec must obey The Code. Mining without a permit is dangerous and harmful to the EVE community. See www.MinerBumping.com

ISD Gallifreyan
ISD Community Communications Liaisons
ISD Alliance
#12 - 2012-11-19 17:45:32 UTC
I believe In the book Empyrian Age, one of the Character's was able to get out of his Pod while in space.
If my memory serves me, the ship had a modified Pod Gantry built into the ship so he could get out and perform experiments.

ISD Gallifreyan

Lt. Commander

Community Communication Liaisons (CCL)

Interstellar Services Department

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#13 - 2012-11-19 19:00:24 UTC
Nayo Renyk wrote:
Esna Pitoojee wrote:
Devs have stated that DUST cloning implants are incompatible with capsule "flash cloning" technology.

Okay, incompatible how? Keep in mind only the bridge clone would have the implants. So in the case of consecutive death, it would be two completely different cloning techniques. This is all assuming of course the mind of the capsuleer could do this without turning into jelly..


Having multiple copies of your informorph running around is strictly forbidden by CONCORD, hence why there aren't multiple copies of every capsuleer running around forming entire fleets by themselves.
Qvar Dar'Zanar
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#14 - 2012-11-19 20:47:16 UTC
ISD Gallifreyan wrote:
I believe In the book Empyrian Age, one of the Character's was able to get out of his Pod while in space.
If my memory serves me, the ship had a modified Pod Gantry built into the ship so he could get out and perform experiments.


Correct. He was the only crew of his ship, thou.
Nayo Renyk
Armored Corps
#15 - 2012-11-22 22:08:06 UTC
Galaxy Pig wrote:
Yeah and OP, it just begs the question "why???"

AGAIN, its the story element. For example, I like to think of my capsuleer as an observer. He doesnt really care much for isk and power so much as seeing what other people would do with such things. With immortality on the bridge he would use plenty of his free time just basicly testing his crew. He would get to know them, and either toy with them, help them become a better person.. Or which ever he felt like doing at the time. Satistic? Maybe. But like you said "they're just organic mechanisms comprising a vast machine". If he ever got bored he could just blow up the ship and start fresh.
In short, Its to have the option to live with "demi-god" status without having to be confined inside a jelly filled space egg.
The rest is up to imagination..

Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Having multiple copies of your informorph running around is strictly forbidden by CONCORD


Interesting.. But from the amount of threads iv seem to do with explaining the multiple characters issue and other topics that would collide with this it seems like its easy to believe CONCORD would suspend such a rule in certain cases such as 'a good read'n story'. Also keeping in mind under this set up its not like there are literally multiples of the same capsuleer running around, its just one mind.

Marcion Cravik wrote:
Different Implants mean a different nervous layout,.. But if you really want this to work under certain circumstances, why let you imagination get bothered?

The brain cell layout needs to be the EXACT same? Hmm seems kinda far fetch considering the sheer randomness of such things. However if one starts to pick apart those kind of explainations the whole cloning process in general starts to make less and less sense, so i wont, and just say i see your point. And dont worry, me imagination arnt get bothered =P just wanted to hear what other people had to say on the subject, and so far im finding this thread quite interesting.
CCP Falcon
#16 - 2012-11-23 10:06:22 UTC
To cut a long story short, this wouldn't be feasable.

If we break cloning down it basically fits into three separate, distinct categories :

Standard cloning :

Anyone with the money to afford it can do this, and have a replica grown and a neural backup of themselves stored. A lot of famous people, people with insane wealth, political figures and suchlike do this, effectively like life insurance. Some Capsuleers also do this as a fail safe in case of capsule hardware failure or death out of pod.

Regardless, this has the disadvantage of amnesia that reaches from the point of death back as far as the last memory imprint stores up to, so fairly regular neural scanning to keep the records up to date is required. The soft scanning process is also far more lengthy, lasting up to an hour and way more inefficient in terms of time commitment.

Capsuleer cloning :

The cloning we're all familiar with. Automated neural burning, then the injection of a nanotoxin to effectively euthanize the pilot on breach of the capsule's hull. The technology only went into full scale commercial use in 104-105YC after decades of testing and the final success of merging the capsule and the clone.

Before then, Capsuleers used to fly ships the same, via neural control with all the benefits of reaction time, but no neural burning equipment, effectively still leaving them "mortal".

The technique in use today involves basically the same process as standard cloning above in terms of mind scanning, but the scan takes a nanosecond and records the state of every neuron in the brain. The process is destructive, and causes damage to brain tissue, thus the nanotoxin is used to effectively kill the pilot.

From here the data is uploaded via burst transmission to the pilot's registered cloning facility, then parsed to the memory of the new clone where the pilot awake with his memory right up to the point of death, probably annoyed with himself, other people, and with a considerable dent in his bank balance.

DUST Cloning :

This uses a "Fifth lobe" cerebral implant that allows the instant transfer of consciousness at the moment of death, and is a vastly different technology to that used by capsuleers. The implant is not naturally grown, it's harvested from... other means... and is implanted into the subject to be cloned. In short, like becoming a capsuleer, the success margin for this is VERY small, and you have to be very lucky and genetically sound to be able to survive the process.

Right now, we can't talk much about the backstory as a lot of it is still under wraps.


In the same respect, there are CONCORD laws that are enforced very vigorously regarding the activation of more than one clone of an individual at the same time to prevent "Clonejacking". Only one person has ever been successful at this, The Broker, who subsequently developed all kinds of physical and mental issues due to it.

There are several chronicles that detail the cloning process, clonejacking, and the laws surrounding it. You should check them out on the EVE Wiki Smile

CCP Falcon || EVE Universe Community Manager || @CCP_Falcon

Happy Birthday To FAWLTY7! <3

MainDrain
Applied Anarchy
The Initiative.
#17 - 2012-11-23 11:09:16 UTC
CCP Falcon wrote:
To cut a long story short, this wouldn't be feasable.

If we break cloning down it basically fits into three separate, distinct categories :

Standard cloning :

Anyone with the money to afford it can do this, and have a replica grown and a neural backup of themselves stored. A lot of famous people, people with insane wealth, political figures and suchlike do this, effectively like life insurance. Some Capsuleers also do this as a fail safe in case of capsule hardware failure or death out of pod.

Regardless, this has the disadvantage of amnesia that reaches from the point of death back as far as the last memory imprint stores up to, so fairly regular neural scanning to keep the records up to date is required. The soft scanning process is also far more lengthy, lasting up to an hour and way more inefficient in terms of time commitment.

Capsuleer cloning :

The cloning we're all familiar with. Automated neural burning, then the injection of a nanotoxin to effectively euthanize the pilot on breach of the capsule's hull. The technology only went into full scale commercial use in 104-105YC after decades of testing and the final success of merging the capsule and the clone.

Before then, Capsuleers used to fly ships the same, via neural control with all the benefits of reaction time, but no neural burning equipment, effectively still leaving them "mortal".

The technique in use today involves basically the same process as standard cloning above in terms of mind scanning, but the scan takes a nanosecond and records the state of every neuron in the brain. The process is destructive, and causes damage to brain tissue, thus the nanotoxin is used to effectively kill the pilot.

From here the data is uploaded via burst transmission to the pilot's registered cloning facility, then parsed to the memory of the new clone where the pilot awake with his memory right up to the point of death, probably annoyed with himself, other people, and with a considerable dent in his bank balance.

DUST Cloning :

This uses a "Fifth lobe" cerebral implant that allows the instant transfer of consciousness at the moment of death, and is a vastly different technology to that used by capsuleers. The implant is not naturally grown, it's harvested from... other means... and is implanted into the subject to be cloned. In short, like becoming a capsuleer, the success margin for this is VERY small, and you have to be very lucky and genetically sound to be able to survive the process.

Right now, we can't talk much about the backstory as a lot of it is still under wraps.


In the same respect, there are CONCORD laws that are enforced very vigorously regarding the activation of more than one clone of an individual at the same time to prevent "Clonejacking". Only one person has ever been successful at this, The Broker, who subsequently developed all kinds of physical and mental issues due to it.

There are several chronicles that detail the cloning process, clonejacking, and the laws surrounding it. You should check them out on the EVE Wiki Smile


Awesome response, really getting into more of the fiction of eve. any chance of a link to these articles?
CCP Eterne
C C P
C C P Alliance
#18 - 2012-11-23 13:43:53 UTC
CCP Falcon wrote:

Standard cloning :

Anyone with the money to afford it can do this, and have a replica grown and a neural backup of themselves stored. A lot of famous people, people with insane wealth, political figures and suchlike do this, effectively like life insurance. Some Capsuleers also do this as a fail safe in case of capsule hardware failure or death out of pod.

Regardless, this has the disadvantage of amnesia that reaches from the point of death back as far as the last memory imprint stores up to, so fairly regular neural scanning to keep the records up to date is required. The soft scanning process is also far more lengthy, lasting up to an hour and way more inefficient in terms of time commitment.


If you want to get technical we retconned out the official references to that on the wiki articles.

EVE Online/DUST 514 Community Representative ※ EVE Illuminati ※ Fiction Adept

@CCP_Eterne ※ @EVE_LiveEvents

CCP Falcon
#19 - 2012-11-23 15:32:17 UTC
CCP Eterne wrote:
CCP Falcon wrote:

Standard cloning :

Anyone with the money to afford it can do this, and have a replica grown and a neural backup of themselves stored. A lot of famous people, people with insane wealth, political figures and suchlike do this, effectively like life insurance. Some Capsuleers also do this as a fail safe in case of capsule hardware failure or death out of pod.

Regardless, this has the disadvantage of amnesia that reaches from the point of death back as far as the last memory imprint stores up to, so fairly regular neural scanning to keep the records up to date is required. The soft scanning process is also far more lengthy, lasting up to an hour and way more inefficient in terms of time commitment.


If you want to get technical we retconned out the official references to that on the wiki articles.


In the same respect, it's still used by most RPers in game. Blink

CCP Falcon || EVE Universe Community Manager || @CCP_Falcon

Happy Birthday To FAWLTY7! <3

Esna Pitoojee
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#20 - 2012-11-23 17:39:14 UTC
It was also used (or at least, the use of such was very heavily implied) by Hilen Tukoss during the Arek'jalaan arc.
12Next page